(1 day, 22 hours ago)
Written Corrections… Can the Minister be clear about how we are planning to migrate away from US-based systems and invest a lot more in British-based systems, so that we can have more data sovereignty?
… First, let me go through again what this incident involved. We are working very closely with Microsoft, and it has confirmed that this was not an attack on its systems. One of its servers went down due to a defect that had been found; there was a surge in load that brought that bug—that defect—to the fore. There was another completely unrelated issue, which was that a server that accounts for 14% of capacity was also down for maintenance at the time.
[Official Report, 16 November 2026; Vol. 793, c. 575.]
Written correction submitted by the Minister for Creative Industries, Media and Online Safety, the right hon. Member for Edinburgh South (Ian Murray):
…There was another completely unrelated issue, which was that 14% of server capacity was also down.
Chris Vince (Harlow) (Lab/Co-op)
…The Microsoft outage had a huge impact on residents and businesses in my constituency of Harlow, and I was reassured to hear when I contacted my local hospital that it had not been hugely impacted, but will the Minister reassure the House that he will do everything he can to hold Microsoft to account and ensure that there is no spectre of future outages?
I am glad that my hon. Friend managed to talk to his NHS trust and resolve that issue over the weekend. Only two NHS trusts stood up an incident response unit, but it was no longer required so they stood it back down relatively quickly.
[Official Report, 16 November 2026; Vol. 793, c. 578.]
Written correction submitted by the Minister for Creative Industries, Media and Online Safety:
… Only two NHS trusts declared critical incidents, but they called them off relatively quickly.
(2 days, 22 hours ago)
Written StatementsChildren and families have a right to be safe online. Online spaces are as much a part of public life as any high street, and people should be able to communicate, learn and participate without being exposed to serious and preventable harm. That is why the Government are committed to ensuring that online services take effective responsibility for making their platforms safer.
Today, I am laying before Parliament amendments to four of Ofcom’s codes of practice and a new code of practice—“Illegal Content Code of Practice for User-to-User Services: Proactive Technologies”—under the Online Safety Act 2023. These measures mark a further important step in cracking down on illegal content online, strengthening protections for children and families against child sexual abuse and exploitation, grooming, terrorism and other serious illegal harms.
The Online Safety Act places duties on regulated user-to-user and search services. Providers must assess the risks arising on their services and put proportionate systems and processes in place to protect their users. Ofcom, as the independent regulator, sets out measures in statutory codes of practice that providers can take to meet those duties. The amendments and the new draft code being laid today will strengthen the codes in several important respects.
The updates to the codes will strengthen protections for children and families by helping services seek out child sexual abuse material and stop it from spreading. Ofcom recommends that relevant service providers use proactive technology to detect image-based child sexual abuse material that has not previously been identified, and deploy hash matching to detect known material, including on regulated user-to-user pornographic services. Hash matching compares online content against a database of known illegal material, helping services to identify and remove it before it spreads. The updates also recommend that providers ban users who generate, share or upload child sexual exploitation and abuse content from their platforms, and take action to remove illegal content from children’s recommender feeds.
Children will also benefit from stronger protections against grooming. Service providers are already required to take steps to prevent strangers from contacting children. Where providers choose not to apply these steps to all users, the updates make it clear that they should use highly effective age assurance to identify the accounts that need these protections.
The updates will strengthen online protections for all users. Ofcom recommends that services use hash matching technology to help tackle illegal terrorist material. It has also recommended that services have proportionate and effective policies for sanctioning users who share or upload illegal content, and content that is harmful to children.
Ofcom has now submitted the amendments for parliamentary scrutiny. If neither House objects to the amendments during this 40-day scrutiny period, Ofcom may issue the amended codes, and the updated measures will come into force 21 days after they are issued.
Once in force, these measures will help services to seek out child sexual abuse material and terrorist content, keep those responsible for child sexual exploitation and abuse content off their platforms, and protect child users from suspected illegal content in recommender feeds while it is assessed. They mark another important step in implementing the Online Safety Act and ensuring that protections keep pace with new technology.
Ofcom will keep its codes under review to address emerging harms, with plans to consult in spring 2027 on extending proactive technology to a wider range of harms.
The Government welcome these amendments and the further protections they will bring for all users online, particularly children. We are clear, however, that there is more to do. These measures build on the important foundations of the Online Safety Act and form part of our wider commitment to going further to make the online world safer for children, including through our work to raise the age of social media for under-16s.
[HCWS477]
(2 days, 22 hours ago)
Commons ChamberWith permission, I will make a statement on the Microsoft 365 outage. On Thursday 12 and Friday 13 November, an outage affecting Microsoft IT systems caused impacts around the world. Users of Microsoft products were unable to send and receive emails or to use a range of other Microsoft products and services. This was a serious incident that caused disruption for a lot of people and businesses.
Microsoft initially explained that the incident was caused by an elevated load on its infrastructure and later provided further details of the three main issues that led to the outage. The company said there is no indication that the incident was caused by malicious activity. In the UK, the incident affected individuals, businesses and the public sector. There were impacts on the health sector and other public services, but key services such as 999 remained operational. There were no major critical service impacts, and public sector resilience plans were in place.
The incident could have been more serious if it had lasted longer or affected wider parts of Microsoft’s infrastructure. It reinforces the importance of promoting and improving our digital resilience—something that the Government have already taken significant steps on. There was some organisational disruption in local government, where many organisations rely on Microsoft products. Multiple local resilience forums were stood up to provide support and co-ordination among local services.
The incident also caused disruption across businesses of all sizes. Staff were unable to carry out their normal duties, and firms were unable to complete their usual transactions. Members and staff in this place were also affected. We recognise the disruption that it caused to people and organisations, and we are still working to understand the full impact.
However, critical and important services remained available and operational across the country. Accident and emergency departments remained open. Transport services were unaffected by this outage. Borders remained operational. There were no known issues with UK mobile, broadband or landline connectivity. Major telecoms providers confirmed that their services were working as normal. We currently have no evidence of wider impacts on UK data centre infrastructure or other cloud operators, and no such impacts have been reported to us by industry at this stage. There were no reported impacts on water or waste water treatment processes. Businesses, including shops and services, remained open right across the United Kingdom. By Friday afternoon, Microsoft systems were back online, and services were returning to normal.
The Government take this issue seriously. Public sector organisations and Government Departments have plans in place to mitigate potential impacts and ensure the continuation of their operations in exactly these situations. The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport is the lead Department for national digital resilience issues. As soon as we became aware of the problem on Thursday evening, we contacted Microsoft to start discussions on the issue, to assess the impact and to request details of how the problem was to be resolved. The Minister with responsibility for cyber security, who is in the other place, spoke to the chief executive officer of Microsoft UK on Friday. My officials in DCMS led the co-ordination of the response across Departments in collaboration with the Cabinet Office. We expect Microsoft to share the lessons learned from the incident. We will be engaging further on how it will prevent such incidents from happening in the future, and plan for swifter remediation of incidents to limit service disruption.
Digital services, such as the cloud computing services that Microsoft provides, are already regulated under the UK’s Network and Information Systems Regulations 2018, which require providers to manage security and resilience risks, prevent and minimise the impact of incidents, and report significant incidents, including non-malicious system failures. Our Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill will strengthen that framework further. It strengthens and clarifies the duties applying to cloud providers, brings data centres and managed service providers into scope, and enables security and resilience requirements to be updated as risks evolve.
The UK has adopted and benefited from new technology faster than many other nations. That has powered our economy and enabled growth and innovation. However, in an environment where we are so dependent on this technology, we need to ensure that our systems are resilient and that we have plans in place for when there is disruption. That will ensure that where there are problems, we can recover faster, and that is true for both Government and industry.
In parallel, we are also working to diversify Government’s supply arrangements, including backing small and medium-sized British suppliers. By using Government’s collective buying power, we can encourage a more competitive and resilient technology market—for example, through the national cloud infrastructure programme, which will improve resilience by diversifying supply options and enabling the Government to contract for cloud services at a whole-of-system level.
The first duty of any Government is to protect their citizens. That is why we have been taking significant action to improve resilience across the nation. The Government cyber action plan, published in January, sets out how we will improve cyber-security and digital resilience across Government and the public sector. I have already mentioned the Cyber Security and Resilience Bill, which is currently in this House. The Bill will boost UK cyber-defences and improve the resilience of our essential and digital services. In the recent Budget, we committed £500 million to build the secure foundations for an AI-enabled economy, including measures to strengthen the public sector technology estate.
A cross-Whitehall technology risk group for the UK Government is now established. It is actively reviewing and overseeing the response to other major strategic risks. We have recently established a chief IT operations function for the UK Government, which has been key to our work on the recent incident. Its critical role will be to systematically review post-incident reports, service outages and performance, and to work with IT operational, commercial and financial leads to develop future interventions that strengthen public sector resilience.
The future technology plan will set out operational standards and practices for firmer foundations across the UK Government, alongside accelerating an intensive baselining of the public sector technology stack, technical health and dependencies. We take these actions as any responsible Government would do in order to protect our citizens, our businesses and our economy.
This outage, like the CrowdStrike incident in 2024, shows how dependent our economy is on interconnected IT systems and why resilience planning matters. We have also seen in the US how outdated technology can have an impact on services the public relies on. My Department will now be working with partners across Government and industry to fully understand the impacts of this incident and gather any further lessons learned. We will use this work to strengthen our resilience. In that spirit, I commend this statement to the House.
On her birthday, I call the shadow Secretary of State.
Rebecca Paul (Reigate) (Con)
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. I do not think I have ever been wished happy birthday like that—an important first for me.
I thank the Minister for advance sight of his statement, and all those who worked tirelessly to keep our essential public services running during what was an extremely challenging incident. Last week’s outage should serve as a wake-up call about the resilience of our national digital infrastructure. A technical fault at a single company caused widespread disruption across our NHS, police forces, schools, businesses and Departments. At least 47 NHS trusts reported difficulties, with some NHS services resorting to pen and paper to keep the basics going.
The Minister tells us that there were no major impacts on critical services, but acknowledges that the Government are still working to understand the full extent of the disruption. How can he therefore be confident in that assessment? Can the Minister tell the House how many appointments, treatments and operations were delayed? Do we know of any incidents in which patient safety was compromised? Can he provide assurances that no critical communications have been permanently lost?
While I welcome the Minister’s assurances regarding the UK’s telecommunications networks, that is a separate issue from the resilience of internet-based telephone systems that depend on the affected platforms. Many public bodies advised people to contact them by telephone instead, but increasingly our telephone systems are integrated with the very same digital platforms that failed last week. What assessment has the Minister made of the impact caused by affected telephone systems, particularly within the NHS?
No one disputes that there are immense benefits to digitisation and even standardisation across our public services, but those benefits must be balanced against the risks of over-reliance on individual providers. Indeed, the Government’s own cloud procurement guidance explicitly recognises these risks. Have the Government undertaken a comprehensive audit of our dependence on individual technology suppliers across our critical national infrastructure?
The Minister speaks of diversifying the Government’s supply arrangements, yet only last month the Government declined to introduce the supplier diversification targets recommended by the Science and Technology Committee. In light of last week’s events, does he expect to reconsider that decision? When did the Government last conduct a cross-departmental exercise simulating the prolonged failure of a major technology provider? What assessment has been made of the impact of the outage on the functioning of central Government? The Minister assures us that Departments have contingency plans in place for precisely such circumstances. Which Departments activated those plans last week, and how effective did they prove to be? Without asking him to disclose sensitive information, can he confirm that independent back-up systems are in place to ensure that the machinery of government can continue to function in the event of a more prolonged outage?
Thankfully, there is no indication that the incident was the result of a cyber-attack, but that makes the scale of disruption all the more alarming. If a technical fault can wreak such havoc, what might be achieved through a sophisticated and co-ordinated attack by a hostile state, backed by artificial intelligence? What if the outage had lasted a week, rather than a day? What if it had coincided with a national emergency? In January, the Government announced their £210 million cyber action plan. Will the Minister say more about the lessons that will be drawn from the incident, and will he consider whether further provisions are needed in the Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill to address supplier concentration?
The Minister says that he will engage further with Microsoft. Given the £1.9 billion spent on Microsoft licences across the public sector in 2024-25, will the Government seek contractual remedies, and what specific improvements in resilience will they demand? We have a duty to ensure that services can continue to operate, regardless of the fortunes of any single technology company. Will the Minister commit to a comprehensive review of our exposure to those risks, and report back to this House on the practical steps that the Government can take to address them? Digital transformation is vital, but must never come at the expense of national resilience.
A very happy birthday to the shadow Minister, and I am sorry that she has had to spend it in the Chamber with me, dealing with these serious issues. She asked a number of questions, and I am grateful for the way that she approached them. The questions she raised are those that the Government have been asking for some time, including through the Government resilience action plan in 2025; the cyber action plan came from the £210 million that we invested in that.
I can only re-emphasise that it is very early in the situation, and that there was no real impact on the public sector. When I said that we do not yet fully understand the disruption across the whole economy, that was more about the private sector. Understanding the impact and disruption that the outage had on the economy as a whole will take more time. We are not aware of any delays in the NHS, or of NHS patients who were put in danger, and 999 services remained as they have always been.
The hon. Lady asked about the assessment of different telephone systems, and diversification across Government. The cyber action plan is there to ensure exactly that; it looks at legacy systems and diversification. The national cloud infrastructure procurement process is about diversification of cloud services; the Government can use that big procurement to diversify our tech stack, ensure that we are seeding British companies, and ensure that we have some sovereignty here. There are only a few suppliers in the marketplace—the big ones that we all know. More than 90% of the civil service uses some kind of Microsoft product, so diversification must be part of the assessment. A comprehensive audit has been done of our resilience in Government. The hon. Lady asks what might have happened if there was a hostile state involved, or if the outage happened during a national emergency. All our plans are in place for that. The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport, along with the National Cyber Security Centre, stands up the co-ordination group. It ensures that there is only one point of contact, and ensures co-ordination not just across Government, but between companies.
As I understand, this was not a cyber-attack. If we think about the incident as being a five-lane motorway, one of the lanes was already down because Microsoft was working on it. There was a bug in the fourth lane of the motorway, if I can stretch the analogy. That overloaded the capacity; pretty much all the traffic was pushed into one or two lanes, and that caused the system to fall over. It was an incident after an incident. Three things happened that meant that we ended up in this situation. Microsoft resolved this relatively quickly, working in co-ordination with DCMS and the NCSC, and we are not aware at this stage that there is any legacy from that. It seems that the backlog is through, and everyone who sent or was to receive something should have got it. We are pleased that the backlog is now gone, and I encourage Members to determine whether they and their constituents have received the email traffic that they should have got by Friday afternoon; by 2 pm on Friday, the incident had passed.
I call the Chair of the Science and Technology Committee.
I am grateful to the Chair of the Select Committee for raising those issues, which we have discussed many times in the Committee. She asks about the shape of large and medium-sized managed service providers, like Microsoft. They account for about 97.6% of the total managed service provider marketplace in this country, which is worth about £47 billion, and about 321 large providers account for 86% of that total. We know that 98% to 99% of civil servants use Microsoft as their platform for communications, which is incredibly high. There is not much in the way of diversification in the marketplace for that, but some Departments use Google and some use Microsoft, so there is that sort of diversification.
The Government cyber action plan will look at where Government sits within the supply chain and logistics sector, and lay out our vulnerabilities and our vendor lock-in. It is incredibly important that we see that through as quickly as possible, but that is not easy. The sovereign AI fund, brought forward by the former Secretary of State for Science, Innovation and Technology, my right hon. Friend the Member for Leicester West (Liz Kendall), before the summer, provides half a billion pounds to seed our own sovereign AI for the tech stack. As my hon. Friend the Chair of the Select Committee knows, we cannot compete in all parts of the tech stack —it would be wrong for us to try to do so—but we can compete in the parts that we are good at, and the sovereign AI fund is there to invest in those kinds of organisations and areas. In the Budget, we committed half a billion pounds to building the secure foundations for an AI-enabled economy. That is different from the sovereign AI fund that I mentioned.
At questions to the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport last Thursday, we talked about ensuring that cyber-security is on the agenda in every single boardroom, so that business people are aware that the NCSC has free cyber-security tools that all businesses should be using. I encourage them to use them, so that our economy, as well as the Government, becomes more resilient.
I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson.
Victoria Collins (Harpenden and Berkhamsted) (LD)
Microsoft’s failure last week is a wake-up call for the UK. Our public services and economy need to stop relying on a few US firms and back more British tech. The outage knocked out services used by over a million UK businesses and public bodies, with 20 million users. Eleanor in the UK could not send urgent cancer referrals. Hugo could not pay his staff, who live pay cheque to pay cheque. Mohamed, a pharmacist, could not dispense prescriptions. Online police reporting went down. Even this House lost its main communication channel.
This is not a surprise. The Institute for Public Policy Research found that the US receives almost twice as much UK public sector tech spend as every other foreign country combined. It found that only £1 in every £6 of Government spending goes to British firms. We found that more than half of central Government keep most of their data with two US companies, and Palantir is still embedded in public services. In July, digital resilience failure was added to the national risk register, so the Government know the risk, but they lack a strategic plan.
The Liberal Democrats have spent months calling for a digital sovereign strategy, which has received cross-party support. It would allow us to stay open globally, while building resilience and competition, and would stop that lock-in. We even tabled an amendment to the Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill, but unfortunately the Government rejected it. They might like to consider that the IPPR suggests practical steps. It says that we should build at home, in those areas where Britain can genuinely compete; use the Government’s power as a buyer, regulator and standard setter to shape the market; and partner with other middle powers, including the EU, so that no single country holds the off switch.
The Tories attacked our idea, but industry and experts agree with the Lib Dems. TechUK talks about a confident sovereign strategy for supporting growth, security and resilience. UK Research and Innovation calls for a sovereign AI strategy, and the Open Rights Group warns that over-reliance on foreign firms is an urgent national security issue. We do not have digital resilience; we still have digital dependence. Will the Minister back our calls and commit to publishing a digital sovereign strategy to support growth, security and resilience?
I am grateful to the hon. Lady for those comments. It is really important to lay out that this is an isolated incident for Microsoft. It was not a cyber-attack as such; its systems were overloaded, due to a combination of three factors that compounded the problem. The incident affected 74 countries across the world, so it was widespread, not just in the United Kingdom.
The hon. Lady asks about investment in sovereign technology. We have put £500 million in the sovereign AI fund, £1 billion into the AI hardware plan and £2 billion into quantum investment, so that the Government can be a first customer for some of these technologies, giving them routes to market. That is a really big commitment, in terms of AI and tech sovereignty of this country’s tech stack.
Departments are responsible for contracting services. We recognise that relying on a small number of suppliers can create risks to resilience, competition and value for money. Our aim is resilience through choice; we are not trying to swap one dependency for another. Large global providers bring scale, security and capability, and benefit public services. The Government mean to keep access to the best technology, while building greater choice and stronger UK capability; I think everyone in the House would agree with that. We are moving away from each organisation buying separately, and towards a joined-up approach from Government, to give economies of scale. Procurement decisions are based on value for money for the taxpayer, security, and the effective delivery of services. That is why we are very keen to take forward the Government cyber action plan.
We are very keen to ensure that the NCSC and DCMS continue to work together on these issues. We are looking at the national cloud infrastructure project to try to seed and develop those sovereign capabilities here. Until we get to the end of that process, we will not really know where we are in providing competition to the big suppliers, but everyone is aware that it is a problem that we have little choice in this marketplace other than to use some of these global providers, and the Government are actively working to resolve that.
Many of my constituents rely on terrestrial TV and radio, and Friday’s outage showed us what happens when digital goes down. In the light of this morning’s recommendation by the Lords National Resilience Committee, will the Minister rule out switching off terrestrial television—the back-up that keeps working when digital goes down? I am very concerned that not ruling that out would present a very real threat to our national security.
I am very grateful to my hon. Friend for raising the issue of the future of TV distribution, which was raised in our media Green Paper; the consultation on that has finished, and the White Paper will be produced shortly. We took the decision in the Green Paper to turn off digital terrestrial television, but the issue is what date we use. That is examined in the Green Paper; it will be either 2034 or 2044. We have not made a decision as a Government on that date. We have made a decision on what we will do, but not on when we will do it.
I call the Chair of the Culture, Media and Sport Committee.
We are the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee.
The Minister has set out very clearly, as have others, the entrenched position of Microsoft in the UK’s digital ecosystem. Considering the great over-reliance of domestic businesses, consumers, Government and local authorities on its software, can the Minister set out how urgent the diversification and resilience building that he mentioned is? Has that urgency changed in the light of what happened on Friday? In addition, the Competition and Markets Authority is currently looking at whether it should designate Microsoft as having strategic market status, and is due to conclude that work in February. Has the Minister’s readiness to respond to that report also changed in the light of Friday’s events?
I am grateful to the Chair of the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee for her questions. It is still DCMS—we need to get that into our minds.
The hon. Lady raises two important points. The first, which is about over-reliance on certain suppliers, is well made; that is why the Government have been putting a lot of money into sovereign AI and tech sovereignty in terms of the tech stack. We have the Government cyber action plan that examines the readiness and resilience of individual Government Departments, looking at legacy technology and co-ordination across the piece. We also have the national cloud infrastructure programme, which is about making sure that big, Government-wide procurement can seed UK businesses, looking at cloud sovereignty and making sure that we have a choice of suppliers. We are such a big customer; we need to make sure that we have those suppliers on our shores. We introduced the Government cyber charter to ensure that any strategic suppliers, including Microsoft, are early adopters of Government cyber policy and best practice. That charter sets clear expectations for suppliers, strengthening resilience across Government supply chains and encouraging them to drive the same standards throughout their wider supplier networks.
The hon. Lady’s point about Microsoft is well made. The Government contract with Microsoft in a way that is very deep and broad. That gives us an economy of scale with one of the world’s best suppliers in this area and access to new technology, but it also probably gives us vendor lock-in and a lack of choice in what other vendors we might be able to use. However, this was not a cyber-security incident; it was just a technology failure in one of Microsoft’s operations. This problem was caused by a backlog of data going through a very narrow lane, as opposed to the service that Microsoft is normally able to provide.
I thank the Minister for his statement. I am not 100% convinced that we know exactly what happened, but I am pleased that he feels that Microsoft is telling the truth.
The Minister said that the first job of Government is to protect their citizens. I completely agree, and my Bill—the Artificial Intelligence (Consent and Misuse) Bill—would go a long way towards ensuring that we protect our citizens as AI advances. As has been mentioned, EU countries are migrating away from Microsoft systems; that was mainly driven by the President of the US claiming that he was going to activate the kill switch for Microsoft, which worried a lot of countries. Can the Minister be clear about how we are planning to migrate away from US-based systems and invest a lot more in British-based systems, so that we can have more data sovereignty?
There are a number of answers to that question, and I am grateful to my hon. Friend for raising it. First, let me go through again what this incident involved. We are working very closely with Microsoft, and it has confirmed that this was not an attack on its systems. One of its servers went down due to a defect that had been found; there was a surge in load that brought that bug—that defect—to the fore. There was another completely unrelated issue, which was that a server that accounts for 14% of capacity was also down for maintenance at the time. This outage was caused by the volume of traffic choking the servers that were left, which produced a backlog and brought the servers down. Microsoft resolved the problem relatively quickly. By 2 pm on Friday, services were coming back online.
My hon. Friend asked what we are doing to diversify away from US suppliers and the big international suppliers. I have already mentioned the £500 million sovereign AI fund, which is there to back British businesses and promote that sovereignty; the £1.1 billion AI hardware plan; and the £500 million to try to resolve some of these issues that was in this year’s Budget. We have a tech stack that is dominated by US tech companies. We want more AI sovereignty in the United Kingdom; we are willing to fund that, and we are funding it. That is how we will make sure we have the most resilient services, but also the most technologically advanced services, in the UK.
I am grateful to the Minister for making this important statement. Those of us with rural constituencies represent many people who are very worried about the copper switch-off that is coming as we move to fibre. Fibre is an energy-intensive system, unlike the copper system, and it seems to be coming without a delay being considered. Donald Rumsfeld once talked about the known unknowns. We know that an attack will happen somewhere. The Minister has outlined that this outage was a specific issue, but it shows how reliant we are on these systems. The hon. Member for Rotherham (Sarah Champion) talked about the switching off of terrestrial television. These things are of great concern. I urge the Minister to take away what happened on Friday and look at the broader picture. When the known unknown happens and everything gets closed down, the proven and tried systems of copper connections and terrestrial radio and television should be there as a back-up system on which people can rely.
This is an issue for all of us in this Chamber, because we rely on that technology. Similar discussions about whether we are over-reliant on technology probably happened, if we check Hansard, with the invention of the personal computer and the internet. Technology makes us a better economy and makes it easier for businesses to operate. It makes it easier for us all to stay connected and informed. Resilience is a key part of what we are trying to do in government, whether through our cyber action plan or all the other initiatives that I have mentioned from this Dispatch Box. That cyber action plan has £210 million in funding to better utilise cyber-skills and to deliver once and for all, at scale, a co-ordinated approach across Government to tackle all those critical risks that the right hon. Gentleman mentions.
The right hon. Gentleman talks about power and national power outages. We know that telecoms networks have substantial power back-ups at core network sites. We have a resilient electricity system, but we cannot plan for every eventuality. It would be wrong for a Minister of any colour to stand at this Dispatch Box and say that we will not have any other cyber-attacks or any other outages such as this. What we need to do is minimise them, minimise the risk and make sure that the Government are in the best place, including in terms of the wider economy.
I declare an interest, as I have a close relative who is working on the regulation of Microsoft. I thank the Minister for his statement. Will he update the House more broadly on how the UK is planning to be more resilient in this field, particularly given that a relatively small number of suppliers have such a critical role in the economy?
As I have said, we recognise that relying on a small number of suppliers can create risks for resilience, competition and value for money. Those suppliers provide us with the very best technology, and we are not trying to swap one dependency for another, but alongside the large global providers, which bring skills, security and capability, we must ensure that we have our own sovereignty in this country in the areas of the tech stack that we are good at. We have put taxpayers’ money where our mouth is to develop that tech stack and that sovereignty, so that we have resilience.
Graham Leadbitter (Moray West, Nairn and Strathspey) (SNP)
The statement raises the issues of resilience and preparedness in the public and private sectors. Can the Minister and his team do more to support businesses, both small and large—including through the known communication channels, such as the Federation of Small Businesses, Prosper and others—by more widely distributing advice and messages about digital preparedness tools? This has been a significant enough incident to warrant a ministerial statement, but there are rural and remote businesses and public services that tackle digital challenges every single day of the week due to lack of fibre broadband and other issues. Can more be done to roll out fibre broadband even faster?
There was a lot in that question, and I will try to run through it in order. Building Digital UK has Project Gigabit, which is trying to get to 99% of all premises by 2032. Many of those who are most affected and are the hardest to reach will be in the hon. Gentleman’s constituency in the highlands of Scotland. For that 1%, there will be additional technologies—they are evolving all the time—to make sure that everyone is connected. As I have said at the Dispatch Box many times, we cannot have growth in every postcode without connectivity, and the more rural somewhere is, the more difficult it is to have that connection.
From the point view of the wider economy and business, the only thing that I can continue to emphasise from this Dispatch Box is that people should use the National Cyber Security Centre’s free tools on cyber-security. That should be on the lips of every board member sitting around the boardroom table. We will have a much more resilient economy with much more resilient businesses only if everybody plays their part.
Deirdre Costigan (Ealing Southall) (Lab)
West London is part of a cluster of data centres where, if there is a problem with one centre, data can be backed up in another. In my constituency, two data centres have recently been agreed by Ealing council, which has taken the position that only data centres with the highest environmental standards will be allowed. Does the Minister agree that clustering data centres in this way is the right approach to digital resilience, along with the Government’s new data centre covenant, which will ensure that we meet our climate commitments?
I could not have put it better myself. We do need data centres for this. If we are talking about AI sovereignty and tech sovereignty, it is best for them to be onshore here in the United Kingdom. That is a big challenge, but we must ensure that it is done correctly, and I pay tribute to Ealing council for the way in which it has done it in its area.
Alison Griffiths (Bognor Regis and Littlehampton) (Con)
The Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill is in its final stages of parliamentary scrutiny, and in this context I particularly note the role of resilience in ensuring our national economic security. What assessment have the Government made of the potential impact in future outages on critical national infrastructure—including communications and supply chains—on which essential services depend, and what further amendments to the Bill might be needed?
The Bill will return to this House relatively soon. It updates the Network and Information Systems Regulations 2018 to bring some of these companies into scope, including data centres, and contains a provision to extend the scope, if necessary, to include more organisations and more sectors of the economy. It will be back in this House before the end of the year, and we will be able to debate these matters in more detail then, but its purpose is to ensure that we have greater resilience and to update the regulations.
Chris Vince (Harlow) (Lab/Co-op)
I thank the Minister for coming to the House in such a timely fashion. I know he will have been disappointed to learn today that the new James Bond is not a Scotsman. The Microsoft outage had a huge impact on residents and businesses in my constituency of Harlow, and I was reassured to hear when I contacted my local hospital that it had not been hugely impacted, but will the Minister reassure the House that he will do everything he can to hold Microsoft to account and ensure that there is no spectre of future outages?
I am glad that my hon. Friend managed to talk to his NHS trust and resolve that issue over the weekend. Only two NHS trusts stood up an incident response unit, but it was no longer required so they stood it back down relatively quickly. That shows that the system does work. The co-ordination of the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport and the National Cyber Security Centre to bring together the Government Cyber Co-ordination Centre meant that the information was filtered from Microsoft through the Government to trusts and local government so that they could stand up incident responses if they needed to do so, but they did not need to do so in this particular case.
Martin Wrigley (Newton Abbot) (LD)
I thank the Minister for his statement, and for his welcome comments about backing more British suppliers that are small and medium-sized enterprises. May I ask him to extend that review and look into not only alternative suppliers of the solutions, but the decision to have software as a service as the default choice every time, so that we can improve the resilience of the services here and possibly even copy the French by developing our own open-source solution?
I can only re-emphasise what I have said already. The Government are backing our work on the tech stack with taxpayers’ money to see how we can seed good businesses in this country that wish to grow and enter these marketplaces. It is difficult for the Government to do that, because the big suppliers are there for us to secure value for money for the taxpayer. However, the current procurement process through the national cloud infrastructure programme is about ensuring that we not only secure the best value for money but have some tech sovereignty on British soil by seeding those companies to make them grow.
Sorcha Eastwood (Lagan Valley) (Alliance)
Given the Microsoft 365 outage, the Vodafone outage last year and Storm Éowyn, which prevented my constituents from receiving communications, does the Minister agree that sometimes the older ways are the best? In my constituency, we have a 90-year-old transmitter that still transmits analogue. I worry that if the Government go ahead with their plan to switch off analogue, it will cut off people in a way that we know will happen again. What can the Minister tell my constituents to assure them that old technologies will still be considered critical national infrastructure?
The media Green Paper lays out that the Government have already made the choice that we will switch off digital terrestrial television and move to internet protocol television at some point in the future, but the date has not yet been determined—it could be 2034 or 2044. We are examining the consultation to work out the best way forward. The hon. Lady’s constituents can be assured that no decision has been made, and we will take into account the issues that she raises when making that decision.
Richard Tice (Boston and Skegness) (Reform)
The Microsoft outage was, of course, a shock—indeed, it was a wake-up call to us all—but it may be that we got away lightly. Imagine if it lasted for a week or a fortnight, enhanced by bad actors. The Minister and other Members have referred to the need for open-source alternatives. Will he commit to coming back within three to six months on plans and progress for such alternatives?
The rhetoric from the hon. Gentleman is not necessarily helpful, because it was an isolated incident at Microsoft. There have been incidents in the past, which he referred to, and there will be incidents in the future. Our job is to make the Government as resilient as possible, and to put in place the tools and legislation to make sure that the economy is as resilient as possible, so that the UK can stand when these kinds of incidents happen.
Ayoub Khan (Birmingham Perry Barr) (Ind)
I am pleased that the Minister has spoken about the steps that this Government will take in relation to digital resilience, because for weeks I have been pointing out a fault in the General Register Office’s new electronic register for births, deaths and stillbirths in England and Wales, which went live earlier this month. Over 70 senior council officials from around 50 local authorities wrote to the Home Office and told it that when the system fails, it is impossible to issue the death certificates needed for the deceased to be repatriated and buried overseas—something that is very important for many religious communities. In response, the Home Office has simply ignored warnings and continued regardless. Does the Minister agree that the lessons of the Microsoft outage should be learned by the Government as well as corporations, and will he agree to raise this matter with his counterparts in the Home Office so that we can prevent a disaster from happening?
I am not aware of that incident, but I will raise it with Ministers in the Home Office to find out what has happened. The hon. Gentleman asks us to learn the lessons from the Microsoft outage, which we and Microsoft will learn, but we were learning lessons before the Microsoft incident, because this Government want to be much more resilient. The Government’s cyber action plan, which was published at the start of this year, is part of that project, and is backed by £210 million of taxpayers’ money. That is about central direction, co-ordination, pace, consistency and clarity when it comes to the resilience of Government, and it is also about making sure that the wider economy has resilience.
I thank the Minister for his very comprehensive answers and for his interest in this matter. When Microsoft goes down, the country grinds to a halt—“IP meltdown” is how we refer to it. In my constituency last week, problems were not only financial. We saw NHS staff forced to use pen and paper, courts forced to adjourn, and councils and schools left scrambling to function. The IT system in my office, and in Government offices, was down until 1.40 pm on Friday, and my constituents and others were disadvantaged as a result. It raises serious questions about our over-reliance on a single system. What steps are being taken to ensure that every Government Department has proper contingency plans and offline back-ups, so that a technical failure never again paralyses our public services?
The hon. Gentleman talks about people reverting to pen and paper and other systems kicking in. The whole point of having a resilience plan is that when things happen across the tech stack or any of the systems, other systems kick in. That is why we did not see widespread disruption across the whole public sector. Yes, it was an inconvenience. My own emails went down until about 2 o’clock on Friday. I know that because the test email I sent myself on Thursday night arrived at about 2 pm on Friday, and the acknowledgment that it had arrived bounced back. The backlog has been cleared, and Microsoft resolved the problem as quickly as it could, but the whole point of the Government’s cyber action plan is to make sure that all Government Departments, local government and our public sector have resilience, and that the private sector also has resilience.
On a point of order, Madam Deputy Speaker. There are about 300,000 jobs in tech and telecoms in Berkshire—Reading lies in that county and is the county town—and there are many more thousands of those jobs across the country, yet we only occasionally discuss issues related to this very important area of employment. Could there be a debate in the House on the contribution of tech and telecoms to the British economy?
(5 days, 22 hours ago)
Written CorrectionsI can commit to meeting my hon. Friend to talk about these specific issues. We do a regular telecoms drop-in for MPs, and I encourage all MPs to ensure they come to that so they can meet the mobile network operators and Building Digital UK on the broadband side to ensure that we are covering all these issues. It is not an exact science, so when there are examples like that which my hon. Friend brings forward, I would like to hear about them, so I am happy to meet her.
[Official Report, 12 November 2026; Vol. 793, c. 309.]
Written correction submitted by the Minister for Creative Industries, Media and Online Safety, the right hon. Member for Edinburgh South (Ian Murray):
I can commit to meeting my hon. Friend to talk about these specific issues. We do a regular telecoms drop-in for MPs, and I encourage all MPs to ensure they come to that so they can meet myself, and officials from the Department’s digital infrastructure and Building Digital UK teams, to ensure that we are covering all these issues. It is not an exact science, so when there are examples like that which my hon. Friend brings forward, I would like to hear about them, so I am happy to meet her.
(6 days, 22 hours ago)
Written StatementsRadio continues to be a strong and highly valued medium in the UK, with 87% of the population tuning in every week. However, the means by which listeners tune into radio has undergone a significant shift in recent years. In particular, there has been sustained growth in listeners’ use of voice-activated devices, such as smart speakers, to access online streams of live broadcast radio. The use of these kinds of devices by radio listeners has grown strongly: according to the most recent figures from RAJAR, 18% of total radio listening is now via a voice-assisted device.
In response to these changes, the Media Act 2024 amended the Communications Act 2003 to introduce new powers to protect the availability and carriage of online streams of UK broadcast radio on such voice-activated platforms, defined in legislation as radio selection services. These protections were put in place to ensure that listeners using services designated by the Secretary of State are able to continue to easily access live radio.
Before making any such designation, the Secretary of State is required to receive and consider a report from Ofcom, which was provided on 19 March 2026, and to consult with persons who appear to represent providers of radio selection services, providers of internet radio services, and other appropriate stakeholders.
The Secretary of State agreed with Ofcom’s conclusion that 700,000 UK users is the appropriate threshold for designation. Consequently, between 15 July and 9 September 2026, the Government consulted on a “minded to” decision that Amazon’s Alexa, Google Assistant, and Apple’s Siri, along with AI-enabled versions of these services, should all be designated as RSS.
Today, we have published our response to this consultation. This confirms that Amazon’s Alexa (including Alexa+), Google Assistant (including Gemini), and Apple’s Siri are all designated as radio selection services. Regulations which give effect to these designations are being made today.
[HCWS469]
(6 days, 22 hours ago)
Commons Chamber
Gregory Stafford (Farnham and Bordon) (Con)
Lifting the full potential of our city regions and clusters across the UK is a core objective not just of our modern industrial strategy, but of our plan for growth in every postcode. Place-based funding is helping to ensure that our city regions and high-potential clusters are able to unlock more growth, create more good jobs and continue producing world-class creative content. London is a global creative industries super-cluster, and we are committed to supporting its continued success as one of the 12 priority super-clusters identified in the creative industries sector plan.
Gregory Stafford
My constituent Simon has built a media company in the heart of our creative sector in London, but at a recent surgery he told me that the Culture Secretary’s regional funding drive is destroying the creative industry in London and the south-east. Simon and his business partner employ 25 people, and they pay rent, business rates and service charges on top of their wage bill. We should be supporting this industry, not stripping it. What is the Minister doing to support the creative industries in the south of England?
I congratulate Simon on setting up his business. It is true that 67% of all creative industries activity happens in London alone, and an extra 18% in the south-east. The region is a super-cluster, and this Government are doing all we can to ensure that we support the industry right across the United Kingdom. The BBC has built hubs across the country, including in Cardiff, Bristol, Manchester, Newcastle and Glasgow, and they provide the ecosystem that allows companies to thrive. London will remain one of our super-clusters, and the funding that we are putting into the creative industries goes right across the country.
To get growth in every postcode, surely we must junk the Tories’ crude anti-London formula that saw the whole of the capital disadvantaged, including Ealing Studios—the home of comedy—and Acton’s Versa Studios, where “Big Brother” is made. Can Ministers start the rebalancing by introducing an unscripted tax credit? It has worked wonders in Ireland, where it is at 20%.
I do not know whether that was a question to me or a challenge to the hon. Member for Farnham and Bordon (Gregory Stafford), who asked the original question. The Government are fully committed to funding the creative industries wherever they are across the country. The Prime Minister has challenged all of us in the Government to create growth in every postcode, but in order to do so we need creativity in every postcode, because we know that there is talent everywhere, but not opportunity.
Aphra Brandreth (Chester South and Eddisbury) (Con)
Will Stone (Swindon North) (Lab)
I was delighted to see £20 million allocated for a new cultural venue in Swindon via the growth mission fund, thanks to the tenacity of my hon. Friend and my right hon. Friend the Member for Swindon South (Heidi Alexander). Officials will continue to work on plans for the theatre with the new Conservative council, which I believe is assessing whether it should take this forward. The investment remains subject to a final business case demonstrating the project’s viability and affordability. I welcome this investment in the arts and communities in Swindon, and I thank my hon. Friend for his question.
Will Stone
I thank the Minister for his response. I am actively encouraging the Conservative administration in Swindon to proceed with the plans for a new theatre, following the funding successfully secured by my right hon. Friend the Member for Swindon South (Heidi Alexander) and me. In the interim, we have to think about our beloved Wyvern theatre. Is there any additional support to retrofit existing theatres in the interim?
There is. We are investing up to £425 million via the creative foundations fund for urgent capital works for not-for-profit cultural venues in England. The funding is already supporting older theatres, such as Scarborough Theatre Trust and Northampton Theatres Trust. I understand that Wyvern theatre’s activities involve Swindon borough council, a commercial operator and a charitable programme via Reach Inclusive Arts. I encourage local partners to discuss capital pressures with Arts Council England and my hon. Friend. I am sure that the Arts Minister would be delighted to meet him and his colleague, my right hon. Friend the Member for Swindon South (Heidi Alexander), to discuss that further.
Sarah Bool (South Northamptonshire) (Con)
Josh Babarinde (Eastbourne) (LD)
Before I answer the question, I say to the hon. Gentleman that we stand fully with him after recent incidents online, with him having received tens of thousands of disgusting messages and death threats. This Government and everyone else in this House—maybe with the exception of a few Members of Parliament —take a zero-tolerance approach to racism and those kinds of threats. We stand with the hon. Gentleman.
Local journalism is vital to society and democracy, including titles such as the Eastbourne Herald and the Eastbourne Reporter in the hon. Gentleman’s constituency. We published the local media action plan to help the sector adjust and thrive in the digital age. Our actions include a local news fund with up to £12 million, a campaign to inspire the next generation of journalists and readers, and an updated plan for journalists’ safety, both here and abroad.
Josh Babarinde
I thank the Minister for his comments. It should not be controversial to say that you do not have to be white to be English. [Hon. Members: “Hear, hear.”] Much of social media has become a cesspit of abuse and disinformation, but local journalism can be an antidote to such poison. Local journalism in Eastbourne is thriving, with the likes of Adam and Ivana recently joining the Eastbourne Herald and Paul Gibson’s Eastbourne News expanding, too. Will the Minister tell us a little more about what he can do to support local journalism in the fight against disinformation and misinformation?
We have the local news fund and the local news strategy. This is an issue right across the country, and we need to ensure that we have a thriving local journalistic community so that we can get those stories to people and so that the news is trusted and trustworthy. The BBC obviously plays a key role in that, and the BBC charter process is investigating how it can support that infrastructure and ecosystem across the country. I would be very happy to work with the hon. Gentleman in sharing his experience to see what we can do to help his local area and areas across all regions across the country. I want to emphasise from the Dispatch Box, too, that you do not have to be white to be English—the hon. Gentleman is right to say that—although you do have to be tight to be Scottish. [Laughter.]
Chris Vince (Harlow) (Lab/Co-op)
From Scotland to Harlow, Mr Speaker. Online news sites like Your Harlow, which has provided thousands of news articles to Harlow residents across the years, rely on people visiting their site for advertising revenue, but there is a danger posed by AI summaries, particularly when some of those summaries are wrong. What thought has the Minister given to the impact of AI summaries on local news sources like Your Harlow?
The Government are actively looking at this issue, because we know from experience—we always use the Southport example—that when there are incidents or crisis moments across the country, people turn to their local news outlets and the BBC to find the truth because they are sceptical of what they are reading. In the meantime, anyone who is reading these AI summaries online should double-check with their local newspapers and the sources they are given to ensure that that information is true. What happens, of course, is the old adage: a lie is halfway around the world before the truth has got its boots on. That happens much faster now with social media. I am delighted that my hon. Friend has broken his habit in the House by at least mentioning Harlow in his question.
Vibrant local news is essential to our democracy, but plans for the Government or a state quango to pick what is a source of trustworthy news content and is prioritised over other publishers risk undermining that sector. Does the Minister agree that the approach of picking winners, with the state deciding what can be trusted, is a dangerous course and should be abandoned?
I disagree with the hon. Gentleman on this basis: the media Green Paper to which I think he is referring is trying to deal with the issue of misinformation and disinformation and to answer the exam question posed by the hon. Member for Eastbourne (Josh Babarinde) about how we promote the local trustworthy news that the public are crying out for and have a massive thirst for. It is an ecosystem that we have to try to support. The Green Paper is rightly posing these questions, and we will have the answers for the White Paper shortly.
The Minister has not given an answer and has declined to rule out going ahead with the proposals in the Green Paper for the state or a quango to decide what is trustworthy news. Will he at least rule out that only news publishers that sign up to an approved regulator under the press recognition system could qualify?
These are questions that have been asked in the Green Paper. The White Paper will be published soon, and I am not going to pre-empt it at this Dispatch Box. The hon. Gentleman will just have to contain himself until then. The big, fundamental issue here is how we deal with the misinformation and disinformation in this country that is undermining our democracy and society and doing the kinds of things that have been experienced by the hon. Member for Eastbourne. Those are the kinds of questions the Green Paper is trying to address. It is in all our interests—the interests of every Member in this House—to get misinformation and disinformation out of our ecosystem so that we can have a thriving democracy and thriving communities.
Tom Collins (Worcester) (Lab)
Keeping children safe online is a top priority for this Department and the Government. That is why we are taking urgent steps to clean up our online spaces, including by raising the age limit for social media to 16, dealing with the risks of children livestreaming themselves, stopping unknown adults from communicating with children through online services, including gaming, and switching off harmful features for 16-year-olds and 17-year-olds. We will also prevent under-18s from accessing chatbots that offer sexualised content. I look forward to working with my hon. Friend to continue these discussions.
Tom Collins
I am grateful to the Minister for his Department’s open initial response to the product approach, which would see digital products required to meet safety standards, just like every other product marketed in the UK. The Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade has asked the Law Commission to look at this approach from a product liability perspective, and they are consulting on that now. Will the Minister and the Secretary of State work with their counterparts in that Department to explore treating digital products as products under the law?
I could not agree more with my hon. Friend. He has recently launched a white paper on digital product safety, arguing that platforms, AI and social media should be subject to the same rigorous product safety frameworks as physical goods to protect the public without stifling innovation, and it looks at this from a hazards perspective rather than a harms perspective. It is an incredibly interesting piece of work. It is something that we are actively looking at, and platforms and social media companies should be looking at it to ensure that their products are safe by design for children.
Monica Harding (Esher and Walton) (LD)
Last week, analysis carried out by 17 expert organisations found that platforms are failing to protect women and girls online. This comes three years after the Online Safety Act and one year after Ofcom published its guidance. Does the Minister agree that this lack of action is unacceptable, and will the Government move quickly to strengthen the Act to better protect women and girls?
I agree with the hon. Lady. Tackling violence against women and girls is a top priority for the Government. We wish to halve violence against women and girls by the end of this Parliament. Platforms are not doing their duty in making sure that these harms are removed. We are talking about and majoring on tackling harms for children at the moment, but we are trying to create a better online experience for everyone in society, whether they are children or not.
Anna Sabine (Frome and East Somerset) (LD)
The Government are rightly trying to protect children’s safety online, but AI smart glasses risk undermining some of those protections. Children and adults, particularly women, are being filmed without their consent and the footage is being posted online and used to train AI. In the Westminster Hall debate I secured last week, the Minister for Safeguarding said that the Government are looking at options to restrict the use of smart glasses. Will the Minister for Online Safety confirm what measures are being explored and when they will be laid before this House?
Through the course of the consultation with Members, society and the industry on the under-16 social media ban, a lot of issues have arisen across the age ranges regarding smart glasses and some of the harms of new technologies. We are actively looking at what needs to be done in that area, particularly with smart glasses. It is a security issue and a safety issue; indeed, it is a consent issue. Smart glasses should not be any different from any other issues regarding people’s consent for using their images online and what is being done with those images.
Rebecca Smith (South West Devon) (Con)
The right hon. Gentleman is really showing his experience in the Chamber there. [Laughter.] Mobile connectivity is not a “nice to have”; it is an everyday necessity which connects people and communities and drives growth in every postcode. Of course, we cannot have growth in every postcode without connectivity in every postcode. The Government’s ambition is for all populated areas to have access to high-quality stand-alone 5G by 2030.
I will try again. Mobile notspots are a big challenge in parts of North Yorkshire and other rural parts of the UK. The shared rural network has been effective at meeting its targets, but now that those targets have been met, what plans do Ministers have for the remaining notspots to be sorted out?
The right hon. Gentleman is absolutely right to talk about the success of the shared rural network, but notspots still remain. Direct-to-device technology is one way of resolving those. It is a pragmatic solution for remote areas where terrestrial infrastructure is not viable. Lessons learned from the shared rural network programme demonstrate where this might offer a better solution, including for deployment costs, topography and local opposition to new infrastructure in some areas. We will continue to monitor this closely with the industry and ensure that all the tech is being made available to ensure these notspots disappear.
Perran Moon (Camborne and Redruth) (Ind)
Meur ras ha myttin da, Mr Speaker. With Cornish constituencies ranking on average 628th out of 650 for good-quality mobile coverage, the paucity of our digital connectivity affects businesses, residents and visitors alike. It is an exemplar of market failure. What are Ministers actually doing to correct this Cornish imbalance?
The shared rural network programme has been a huge success, but as I said in answer to the initial question of the right hon. Member for Skipton and Ripon (Sir Julian Smith), there are still notspots and still some infrastructure problems across the country. We are working closely with the mobile networks to ensure that we can resolve those issues. New technology is coming forward all the time, including that direct-to-device satellite technology. I would be happy to meet my hon. Friend to go through the specific issues in his constituency and region to ensure that we have everything covered.
Dr Ellie Chowns (North Herefordshire) (Green)
A constituent of mine in her 80s living in a village with no mobile signal has contacted me to share her anxieties about the impending digital switchover. She has done everything asked of her to prepare and has a battery back-up, but she has been told that no fall alarm will work outside her house. She is worried that if there is a power cut that lasts longer than an hour, she will have no way of calling for help. As she put it to me, would it not be sensible to ensure that there was adequate mobile reception everywhere before the digital switchover? Does the Minister recognise these concerns and what will he do to address them?
We have received correspondence on the kind of issues that the hon. Lady raises, and I am happy to meet her directly to go through her constituent’s particular concerns. We have to ensure that nobody is left behind when we are doing any kind of switchover from older to new technologies. We need to ensure in particular that vulnerable customers are looked after. We are working closely with the mobile networks to ensure that that happens and with the broadband providers to ensure that they can get to every part of the country as well.
Amanda Hack (North West Leicestershire) (Lab)
Mobile reception is patchy at best in my semi-rural constituency. However, what is clear is when industrial sheds are built close to residential areas, mobile reception deteriorates, like in Ellistown in my constituency. Would the Minister agree to meet me to discuss how we can manage situations like this and prevent them in the future?
I can commit to meeting my hon. Friend to talk about these specific issues. We do a regular telecoms drop-in for MPs, and I encourage all MPs to ensure they come to that so they can meet the mobile network operators and Building Digital UK on the broadband side to ensure that we are covering all these issues. It is not an exact science, so when there are examples like that which my hon. Friend brings forward, I would like to hear about them, so I am happy to meet her.
Mrs Elsie Blundell (Heywood and Middleton North) (Lab)
Richard Quigley (Isle of Wight West) (Lab)
I congratulate Neil and everyone in the team at Medina Studios on putting together a fantastic proposal. We are supportive of areas that want to grow their film industry and the work that has gone into Medina Studios is very impressive indeed. The Government are committed to maximising the potential of the film industry and ensuring that growth benefits the whole of the UK. The Department funds the British Film Commission to support UK infrastructure, including studio space. The BFC promotes the entire UK, including the Isle of Wight, working hand in glove with Creative England on production support, where appropriate. I am pleased to note that the BFC has assisted Medina Studios. Funding from the growth mission fund is a matter for the Treasury. I would be happy to meet my hon. Friend and I thank him for the way in which he champions the Isle of Wight through that project.
That is an issue for the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, and we have been working closely with that Department about its planning proposals. I am sure that the right hon. Lady will be not be disappointed when they come forward.
David Williams (Stoke-on-Trent North) (Lab)
It has been 18 months since my Committee published its report on misinformation, with detailed recommendations on how to address the way in which digital advertising drives scandalous, sensationalist and addictive content, yet our inquiry into digital childhood is raising exactly the same issues. What has been done to address them? To be clear, neither Ofcom’s online information advisory committee nor the online advertising taskforce has taken any steps.
I am delighted that my hon. Friend asked that question, which concerns a vital issue that the Government are trying to deal with. The online advertising taskforce has workstreams that have been looking at the issue very closely. I chair that taskforce, and am keen to push it further forward. The issue is not just the way in which advertising is delivered, but the monetisation of illegal and harmful content; if we want to deal with any of the issues relating to the online world, we must follow the money.
Salisbury Playhouse is one of three producing theatres in the south-west, and this week it launched a campaign to raise £22 million. The Arts Council, Wiltshire council and Salisbury city council have already made a £10 million contribution. Are the ministerial team having conversations with the Treasury to create incentives for private philanthropy and giving, so that we can maximise the opportunity to fill this gap and make Salisbury Playhouse the brilliant place it needs to be for the future?
The right hon. Gentleman asks a great question. The Hodge review into Arts Council England examined what we need to do to bring more philanthropic funding into the sector so that it has more money, not less. I encourage him to engage with Arts Council England on taking those proposals forward. Of course, these questions are always a matter for His Majesty’s Treasury, but we are working very closely with Treasury colleagues on how we can implement the Hodge review in full.
I am proud to represent Liverpool, a city that has produced some very talented footballers, musicians and actors, including Stephen Graham, Jodie Comer and James Nelson-Joyce. However, far too many of our young working-class kids in Liverpool fail to get into the creative sector. Can the Secretary of State commit to doing everything she can to remove the barriers so that more working-class young people in Liverpool can break into the sector based on talent, not on privilege and class?
I was pleased to hear the Minister acknowledge that the Government will not achieve growth in every postcode unless we have adequate mobile connectivity. Unfortunately, in my constituency, many postcodes have inadequate mobile connectivity. Indeed, we have some of the worst connectivity in the whole United Kingdom. Will the Minister meet me to ensure that we can get some urgency into finally resolving this important issue for my constituents?
The right hon. Gentleman is exactly right: we cannot have growth in every postcode without connectivity in every postcode. I would be happy to meet him, but I gently remind him that when we do, it is his turn to buy the wine.
Chris Webb (Blackpool South) (Lab)
In response to Blackpool being shortlisted to be city of culture, Lynn Williams, the leader of Blackpool council, rightly said:
“We have a proud working-class culture and a wonderful history of entertainment, music and performance.”
Our bid to become the next city of culture for the UK is the right and only choice for the panel. It will allow us to celebrate our iconic history and shape our future, because Blackpool never settles for anything small. Will the Secretary of State support our ambition by supporting our much-loved heritage venues and my campaign for a new arena to create a year-round resort, showing Blackpool in a new light?
We need to go faster to get everybody in.
Charlie Dewhirst (Bridlington and The Wolds) (Con)
In his Budget speech, the Chancellor pledged to protect seaside arcades, but the increase in the machine games duty from 20% to 25% threatens businesses in my constituency, such as Leisureland on Bridlington seafront, which I had the pleasure of visiting last week. Will the Minister make representations to the Treasury to ensure that we protect those brilliant local businesses?
John Slinger (Rugby) (Lab)
As someone who played in rock bands and wrote songs, I was delighted to read in the Canadian budget about the Canada creative credit: 48,000 Canadian dollars-worth of tax credit to provide creative artists with income, tax-free, on the creative output that they engage in. Will the Minister update the House on the excellent work we are doing and on what more we can do to help creative artists across this land?
I am delighted that the old rocker has asked that question. We have a 10-point plan for music, which is there to support the music industry from a grassroots level all the way through to our top talent and artists. The Arts Council England review, led by Baroness Hodge in the other place, looked at whether we should support individual artists, and the Arts Council is now looking at that to see how it can best support individual artists. We are backers of music, and we want to continue to be the best in the world.
Sir Ashley Fox (Bridgwater) (Con)
Highbridge Social Club is a not-for-profit club led entirely by volunteers, and it has served our community since it was founded in 1913. Club treasurer Rachel Marsh has written to me to say that the rise in machine games duty announced in the Budget will cost the club £1,500 a year. Coming on top of the employer national insurance charges, this Government’s tax increases threaten the viability of the club. What help and advice can the Minister offer to Rachel as she struggles to balance the club’s books?
What assessment has the Minister made of the cyber-security risks posed by DeepSeek in light of the US’s decision to block it from public procurement?
We will bring forward additional legislation to this House shortly to protect our undersea cables and infrastructure from threats, whether they be state or non-state threats. I hope everyone will support those proposals, including the hon. Gentleman.
Sean Woodcock (Banbury) (Lab)
In 2002, Radio 1 DJ Chris Moyles said on air that he wanted to help Charlotte Church lose her virginity. She was 15 at the time. He stayed in post for another decade. Does the Secretary of State agree that Brand and Walliams were not aberrations, but reflect a culture across entertainment that needs to be consigned to history?
(2 weeks ago)
Commons ChamberI beg to move,
That the period on the expiry of which proceedings on the Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill shall lapse in pursuance of paragraph (13) of Standing Order No. 80A shall be extended, so that the period expires at the end of 29 April 2027 rather than at the end of 11 November 2026.
The UK is subject to daily and unrelenting cyber-attacks, as cyber-criminals and state-linked actors blackmail businesses, steal data and threaten our very way of life. As our lives become increasingly digital, the threat comes not only from hostile actors, but from weaknesses in the resilience of our systems. We must defend against both and focus our attention where it matters most.
Although all businesses should secure themselves against cyber-attack using the National Cyber Security Centre’s free toolkits, it is right that we do not over-regulate every business. That is why the Bill is targeted at our most essential and critical services, relating to drinking water, health, transport, energy and the digital services that keep our economy running. If these services were disrupted, we would have nowhere else to turn. The Bill safeguards those services and, in turn, protects the individuals and businesses that rely on them. That is the priority of this Government.
We will not hesitate to take action when hostile actors seek to do us harm. The Bill delivers a step change in national security and equips the Government with the powers to act decisively on threat intelligence. This Government have gone further still; we have tabled amendments to introduce a new vendor risk management framework, which will assist businesses in reviewing their supply chains and working with the Government to mitigate those risks, and it will, if necessary, enable Government to step in and instruct organisations to take action.
This week, the Bill re-entered the House after completing Third Reading in the other place on Monday 2 November. I pay tribute to the Minister, the noble Baroness Lloyd, as well as Members of this House and the other place for engaging so constructively throughout the Bill’s passage. In many instances, the contributions have refined the Bill and made it more robust. I know that hon. Members will continue this constructive dialogue in their consideration of Lords amendments, and will pass a Bill that is fit to deal with the cyber-threats that we face now and in future.
I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson.
I welcome the comments made by the Liberal Democrat spokesperson on this incredibly serious issue and look forward to her bringing them back when we actually have the debate, beyond this carry-over motion. I hope she will support the carry-over motion so she can make her speech again.
My hon. Friend the Member for Halesowen (Alex Ballinger) mentioned JLR and other high profile issues of a serious nature. That allows me to briefly give a big message to all businesses in the country that cyber-security is also their responsibility—it should be in every boardroom, at the top of every agenda, to ensure we are not having those incidents. As my hon. Friend, said prevention is better than cure. The National Cyber Security Centre has all the free tools available, so I encourage every single business—micro, small, medium and large—to use those tools to ensure they are as secure as they possibly can be. Of course, we cannot stop all cyber-attacks being successful, but we can minimise the risk as much as possible and make sure that it is everyone’s responsibility.
David Chadwick (Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe) (LD)
During the evidence collection process, lots of experts from the cyber-security sector called for board accountability to be reintroduced into the Bill, as it is in similar legislation in the European Union. Will he give us his thoughts on why that has not been included?
The Liberal Democrat spokesperson mentioned the same European Union regulations. We need to do what is in the best interests of businesses in the United Kingdom. The message is pretty clear that all businesses must have cyber-security at the top of their agenda—it should be in every boardroom and we keep encouraging them to do so.
Chris Vince (Harlow) (Lab/Co-op)
Madam Deputy Speaker, you missed out on me making a very long speech, so you are very lucky. Will the Minister briefly touch on what liability there will be for frontier model providers, such as OpenAI, who breach their duties, for example I am thinking of the Hugging Face incident in July 2026?
My hon. Friend from Harlow—I am surprised he did not mention Harlow in his contribution, so I thought I had better put it on the record or otherwise he will be struck out—makes a good point. However, we can also see that AI provides a good solution to this problem. Because of the PHP incidents in the past few weeks, we have identified that there were holes in that particular system and then those holes were patched and plugged, so while AI is a big cyber-security problem, it is also a big part of the solution. This Bill is here to give us better cyber-security and better resilience across all our economy.
Question put and agreed to.
(2 weeks, 2 days ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
It is a great pleasure to serve with you in the Chair, Mrs Hobhouse. It has been a superb debate. I congratulate my hon. and learned Friend the Member for Folkestone and Hythe (Tony Vaughan) on introducing this e-petition debate. It has been a very thoughtful debate, and rightly so, because questions about children, social media and online safety go right to the heart of family life in this country.
I have two young girls aged six and one. Although they are not yet at the stage of social media and telephones, the daily fight to get them off screens at that age requires the diplomatic skills of the UN, because screens are everywhere. As parents we probably set the worst examples. Our whole lives are on our phones now, whether we are at work or trying to do family admin. We all live in a digital age where we are more connected than ever before. Being online can bring huge benefits, from making new connections to learning new skills. I pay great tribute to Leo and his colleagues for setting up this petition and getting the issues brought into the public domain, while we highlight the trade-offs that the Government have to make to keep children safe.
I want to be absolutely clear from the start that children are at risk of real harm online. Those risks have been present for some time, and successive Governments have failed to regulate to keep children safe online. As the Secretary of State has made clear, our ambition is not simply to make the online world safer, but to enable and empower children and young people to use it safely. That requires an active Government who are prepared to step in when children are being harmed, but also to step in to give children alternative uses for both the online and offline world. We are not starting from scratch. The Online Safety Act introduces one of the most robust systems globally for protecting children from harm online. It is important to state that the Act is not perfect, but everything that we do beyond this builds on the Act. It is one of the most robust pieces of legislation globally to try to protect children from harm.
I take on board the criticisms and points made by the hon. Member for North West Norfolk (James Wild) and other Members about the Ofcom analysis, which showed that over the first nine months it had not seen a major reduction in online harms among children. None the less, we can prove the counterfactual that there has not been a massive increase, so perhaps the Online Safety Act is working to the extent of not increasing the harms. However, we want to get the harms to the lowest possible level.
We have to be honest: we will never deal with 100% of harms. What we are trying to do with the Online Safety Act and all the regulations on top of that—the under-16 social media ban, features and functionalities bans, and AI chatbot restrictions—is layer on as much as we possibly can to increase the number of harms we can take out of the system. We will never get to 100%, though, and we have to be honest about that.
The Online Safety Act’s child safety duties came into effect in July 2025, requiring platforms to prevent children from encountering pornography, self-harm material and suicide and eating disorders content. Providers must also protect children from other types of harmful content such as violent content and bullying and abusive content. But we always knew we had to do much more. That is why earlier this year we launched the “Growing up in the online world” consultation to hear directly from parents, experts, stakeholders and, more important, young people themselves. The wider public also had to be involved in deciding how we can make the online world safer and more enriching for our young people.
The consultation received more than 116,000 responses. Nine in 10 parents who responded told us they support a ban on social media for their children. The analysis showed they were screaming out for help, to go to the point made by my hon. Friend the Member for Aylesbury (Laura Kyrke-Smith). Although what we heard from young people themselves was more nuanced, two thirds of children who responded to the consultation told us that they would support age restrictions for under-16s on at least some social media. Ofcom’s latest research found that almost three quarters of children aged 11 to 17 had seen or heard potentially harmful content online in a four-week period, including six in 10 who encountered bullying and five in 10 who encountered hate content directly.
We believe that social media services create unique risks for children, and while many of them have made welcome changes, they have not gone far or fast enough to keep our children safe. We think that the responsible thing to do is ban social media companies from offering services to children under 16, but it does not stop there. This is not about stopping children from going online altogether; it is about making sure that the services they use are safe and suitable. To make these changes work, companies will be required to use highly effective age assurance that is backed by Ofcom’s robust enforcement powers.
Sam Carling
I appreciate the Minister’s tone and the different considerations he is bringing in, but does he agree that it is very difficult to define social media? We have a definition in the traditional sense, but there are social platforms now that operate primarily on an anonymous basis instead of having identities behind them, and there are online gaming platforms and so on. How do the Government propose to deal with the fact that social media is a very loose term now?
That goes to the heart of the problem, because social media is indeed a very loose term. Platforms that might have been out of scope are perhaps being brought into scope by having new functionalities that we might think are different from the social media platforms we are seeking to regulate. For example, Spotify has introduced stranger conversation functionality to its platform. Does that mean that it comes within scope? It depends how social media is defined and whether platforms are morphing into something different. For example, when Facebook was first introduced, it was a service for bringing university students together and letting them communicate with each other. It is now a worldwide content platform where anyone in the world—billions of people—can sign up for an account, interact with each other and upload their own content, which can be served through algorithms; of course, every bit of it is monetised. My hon. Friend is right that technology is moving very quickly, as is the definition of social media, and that is why the regulations have to be flexible enough to deal with some of those harms. I will return to the question of scope shortly.
To answer the question asked by the hon. Member for North West Norfolk, the first regulations will be laid before Parliament before the start of the Christmas recess, with restrictions coming into effect in spring next year. While social media services pose a unique risk, there are, as my hon. Friend the Member for North West Cambridgeshire (Sam Carling) said, other services that children can access that have many of the same harmful functions. That is why we are also preventing under-16s from accessing some of the riskier features. They will not be able to livestream themselves or communicate with strangers on a wide range of services, including gaming. We call this the Australia-plus model because we are bringing in gaming, which is not included in the restrictions there. 16 and 17-year-olds will have those protections applied by default. There will be no cliff edge on the adult social media experience: when they hit 16, restrictions will be applied by default when they enter an account until they are 18.
We will introduce default protections for 16 and 17-year-olds on persuasive features on social media such as autoplay and personalised feeds to support young people to manage their time online. We will also apply default overnight curfews, including muting push notifications. Many Members have mentioned the other features and functions on social media that are addictive but may not be as harmful as the really extreme harms, such as child sexual exploitation or some of the other stories we hear. There is a spectrum of harms, including the addictive nature of social media, the lack of sleep from using it and the neurological difficulties it is causing in the adolescent brain—that is why social media companies design them that way. In fact, there is a Science and Technology Committee hearing tomorrow morning on the neuroscience of childhood and how social media is affecting children. It is worth looking into these big issues, and that is why we are applying overnight curfews to try to combat the impact on sleep and attention as part of the social media defaults, including muting push notifications.
These protections will sit alongside a wider package of measures including stronger safeguards around AI chatbots and measures to promote a more positive and educational experience both online and offline. We want children to enjoy the benefits of the online world but give parents the confidence that they can do that safely. We know that regulation alone is not enough. We must also help children and young people to build media literacy and critical thinking skills to navigate the online world safely and prepare them for an increasingly digital future.
I have spent a lot of time in schools in my constituency talking to 11 to 15-year-olds about the social media ban. I think hon. Members are absolutely right to suggest that we do not give young people enough credit for their understanding of dangers online. They understand when there are things online that they should not be seeing. They are very much aware of bullying and of those addictive features, and we do not give them enough credit for being able to navigate this themselves.
We are therefore strengthening digital resilience and media literacy through changes in the curriculum and practical support for parents and carers, while helping children and families to access high-quality online content. This is about building on the protections that we already have and going further where children need us to. The Government cannot and will not look the other way. We must move more quickly and decisively to keep people safe online, and nowhere is that responsibility more important than in protecting children from harm.
Since I took on my online safety role in the reshuffle, I have spent a lot of time with grieving families. I encourage all Members of this House—Ministers, Cabinet members, Back Benchers and those who are just interested in this issue—to spend some time with the grieving families to hear directly from them how social media has impacted their family life. They have some incredibly difficult stories that are harrowing to hear, but I think all Members should hear them. The test for the Secretary of State and me is that if we get to the end of this process and find that all these regulations would not have saved their children from the harms that led to their deaths, we will have failed their children and failed to protect the children of the future from harm. That is a very high bar, but it is a bar we have to meet, because the social media companies have not. Over years, if not decades, they have consistently turned the other way, and they are starting to take action only because they realise that legislation is coming to restrict accounts for under-16s.
Our job as a Government is to build an online world that is safer and more responsible, where platforms take responsibility. If we ask more of the online world, we should also offer more in the real world: stronger communities, better youth provision and more trusted adults around young people. Safety is not just about what we block; it is also about what we build, and we are determined to do that.
I will run through some of the interesting and important questions that hon. Members have raised. My hon. and learned Friend the Member for Folkestone and Hythe, who introduced the debate with a tremendous speech, talked about age-gating and the Australian example. What Australia has not done—we have been learning this from Australia—is have highly effective age verification. That is the gateway to making sure that the ban works. Many hon. Members have rightly challenged me, as the Minister responsible, on what that will look like. We are looking at this at the moment. Should it be at the app store level, as the shadow Minister said? Should it be at the device level? Should it be at the level of each individual social media platform? We are working through those issues to see what the most effective option is, but the principle for us is to ask, “What is the most effective system of age verification to ensure that under-16s are protected from social media platforms?”
My hon. and learned Friend talked rightly about the risky parts of gaming. We are bringing gaming into our approach, through features and functions. We will pass the under-16s social media ban this side of the new year, and it will come into effect in the spring of next year; we will then bring forward a host of regulations on features and functions, including stranger communications, which is the biggest problem with Roblox and some of the other issues that hon. Members have raised. That will allow gamers to continue to have the functionality of stranger pairing, but without the ability to talk to strangers in a gaming context. That should resolve some of these issues. A lot of the harms are where vulnerable people are taken from the gaming environment to other platforms, in order for grooming and exploitation to continue. That is a commitment of the features and functions part of this, which overlays the social media ban.
I will talk a little about isolating young people, because that is always on my mind; I know the Secretary of State thinks about it a lot as well. I pay tribute to my hon. Friend the Member for North West Cambridgeshire, who is the baby of the House—I was hoping to be the baby of this debate, but I have been beaten by probably everybody else in the Chamber—for telling his personal story, which is a very brave thing to do. Isolation is a concern, particularly for vulnerable communities, but from the data and information that we have, we are seeing that the most vulnerable young people are the most susceptible to being involved in these harms.
The balance here is about whether we have these spaces where young, vulnerable people can seek that advice or the communities that they wish to be part of and where they can have that enrichment, or whether we protect them. On balance, protecting people is probably the best place to be, while enriching the offer that we can give young people so that they are confident that they can go to safe spaces with safe people they can talk to about their experiences. This is not an easy thing to resolve. If anyone said it was, they would not be telling the truth.
Let us talk a little about the way back. Essentially, it all comes down to the scope of the social media ban. What we want to do with the ban, which we announced in June, is capture user-to-user platforms whose purpose is to enable online interaction and which allow users to post material, alongside having an algorithm. The Australian regime includes platforms such as Snapchat, TikTok, YouTube, Instagram and Facebook. We will not be naming platforms directly in the regulations. Ofcom will subsequently apply the regulations to the social media companies and then determine whether it will produce a list of the companies that are in scope. I will explain what Ofcom will do in the regulations and what the thought processes are. Social media companies that think that they are in scope and that have more than a certain number of users will have to self-notify to Ofcom as being in scope of the legislation, and then conform to the regulations. We are working through the detail of how we translate the Australian scope into the UK context, and it is really important to get this right within that.
Several hon. Members talked about the regulations, about meeting the criteria and about what the off-ramp is. Essentially, the off-ramp or the way back is for platforms to prove, through their design, that they meet the regulations. It is just a case of reversing the situation. If stranger communication is banned and your online platform is subsequently not to be available to under-16s but you have that functionality, it is quite clear that you do not comply with the regulations, so the way back is to comply with the regulations and fall out of scope. That is an easy thing to say but not an easy thing to deliver, but that is the principle with which we will go forward on this.
If there are services like Lego Play or—YouTube has been mentioned—YouTube Kids, are there ways in which you can stop the harms being created by the algorithms, the recommender systems, the commenting systems or the conversations that can be had with strangers? If you have created a service that complies with all the regulations, is it then available to under-16s? I would say that currently the Government’s position is that, yes, there has to be an off-ramp, and the Canada model is something that we are looking at quite closely in terms of its regulations.
Tony Vaughan
Can I just clarify something? Is the off-ramp part of the features and functions piece, which is post spring, or will that be part of the ban in the regulations that will be put before Parliament before December?
Mine too, Mrs Hobhouse. It was such an engaging conversation that we were trying to have with each other, so I do apologise.
I suppose the simple answer to the question is, “We don’t quite know yet, but probably not.” And this is the answer to the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, the hon. Member for Frome and East Somerset (Anna Sabine), in terms of time. When we announced we were going forward with the ban, we had to have a legislative vehicle to put this through. The difficulty with that is this: we took the powers, in the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026, to put the regulations through. That means that we can do it quickly, and that is why we can make the commitment to do it this side of the end of the year. That then means that we have to make a whole body of potential legislation, in statutory instruments, in one go in December, which is not an easy feat if we want to get this right. I think the discussion about what the way back looks like will have to be a future discussion, probably alongside the features and functions part of the debate later on, after spring next year, when this is being implemented. That is not entirely settled yet, but given what we have to try to achieve by December, it is probably the only way to be able to put that in place.
Dr Arthur
I am just trying to get the sequencing right in my head. The Government are going to put regulations before Parliament before the end of the year. We all welcome that. Will it include Ofcom’s thinking about individual platforms, or do we have to wait for that? If we have to wait, when will we hear from Ofcom on that point?
Let me go through the timeline, because it is really important. The Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act gives us the power to make the regulations. We will make the regulations in December this year. These will come into effect in late spring, and by the time they come into effect, Ofcom will have to have done the work in terms of implementing the regulations, bringing the platforms that are in scope into scope and then starting to enforce what needs to be done. But there will have to be an implementation period after Ofcom has developed the guidance and what must be done on enforcement, so the day from which under-16s will no longer be able to access social media will be in late spring. Between December and late spring, Ofcom will develop the guidance required to implement the regulations. Throughout that process, we will be working on the features and functions, which relate to things like the stranger communications that I have already laid out.
My hon. Friend the Member for Aylesbury spoke about her own daughter and about a phone being on her Christmas list. I think the 116,000 responses to the consultation were just parents crying out for the necessary tools. The Labour party conference had many panels on online safety, and the example that was always used was alcohol licensing. Many of us will have a bottle of alcohol in the house; we know that under-18s are not allowed to drink it, but that does not stop some of them doing so. The tools cannot be foolproof, but they give parents the ability to say, “That is harmful to your health. It is harmful to children, and there are laws in place to say you can access that only when you are over the age of 18.” That gives parents the ability to draw a line in the sand, and I think a lot of them are crying out for the tools to help make those decisions.
The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport has put a lot of thought into what is happening on offline activities at the same time. We cannot have a situation in which the online world is restricted for under-16s but there is nothing for the offline world. We have put over £500 million into the Youth Matters fund to refurbish or build 250 new facilities, as well as a £22.5 million investment over three years to support up to 400 schools to provide youth-tailored enrichment schemes. We have made a major investment in the Youth Matters national youth strategy, a 10-year plan to ensure that every young person has somewhere to go, something to do and someone who cares. I think part of having someone who cares is about the ability to open up to someone who is not a parent, which allows a young person to have some of the difficult conversations that they may have sought to have online.
We heard about the nine-point plan of my hon. Friend the Member for Milton Keynes Central (Emily Darlington), who is no longer in her place. She has been right at the forefront in trying to see what a way back looks like and what it needs to be effective. I encourage Members to look at that nine-point plan and see the neuroscience event tomorrow that my hon. Friend will be part of as a member of the Science, Innovation and Technology Committee.
My constituency neighbour, my hon. Friend the Member for Edinburgh South West (Dr Arthur), demonstrated what is in his own inbox, which is probably a demonstration of what all our inboxes looked like around the country following the consultation. He highlighted a number of civil society organisations that have very strong views on this issue, one way or the other: they either support or do not support the ban, or they may reluctantly support a ban because something needs to be done. The challenge that the Government face in developing these regulations can be seen not only from this afternoon’s debate, but from what has been said by all the civil society organisations out there. I pay tribute to them all; many of them, such as the Molly Rose Foundation, have been set up on the back of tragedy and in horrendous circumstances. There is no one solution that they are proposing, and it is therefore the Government’s responsibility to find the best way forward that keeps children safe online and has the maximum benefit.
I will finish by mentioning a few more of my hon. Friends who raised some really good questions. We heard about international comparisons and the EU KIDS Act from my hon. Friend the Member for Stourbridge (Cat Eccles). We are basing all our evidence on international comparisons. Of course, we have the Australia model, which we talk about a lot, but the Canada model is currently being developed, and there is also the EU KIDS Act, which I was in Brussels talking about just last month. Those international comparisons will certainly affect what we think about, and the Council of Europe is right on this issue. I sat on the Council of Europe many years ago, and it will do a lot of great work in developing both the right of the child and the human right of access and protection from harm, including the protection of children from harm.
I pay tribute to my hon. Friend the Member for Plymouth Moor View (Fred Thomas), who is a fantastic resource on this issue, and I thank him for how he has been able to help us develop some of these regulations. Being online has huge benefits for young people, such as the ability to learn the guitar, like my hon. Friend—perhaps he should have given us a little song this afternoon to see whether his YouTube tutorials actually worked.
We often get questions like that—what will people do if they want to try to learn to play the guitar? Again, I emphasise that we are not banning people from being online, and we are not banning children from being online. Logged-out features can be used. If online platforms such as YouTube want to come forward with a new or redesigned platform that complies with the regulations, and wish to test whether they could be removed from scope, it is up to them to do so. In fact, we have been crying out for platforms to do that for many years. We have ended up in this position because they have not complied or had any intent to comply. They must comply with the regulations that are put in place.
I will finish with why we are doing this. I talked about the grieving families. I have a whole folder of their stories in front of me, and the harm is there for all to see. There are extreme cases of child sexual exploitation, children who have had to be taken into safeguarding because of their online experiences, or children who have died. Some of the stories are unpalatable, if we think about our own children; the Government have a responsibility to act.
As the Secretary of State said in the House on introducing the under-16 ban, social media companies have not done enough to keep children safe online. The Ofcom analysis shows that they are still not doing enough. The Government have to step in. We do not want to ban people from doing things. We do not want to ban under-16s from being on social media, but that is the only way in which we can protect children from its harms. We are determined to ensure that children have an enriched experience online, and that media literacy and the education system allow them that experience, but also that they have an enriched experience offline. I think the Secretary of State describes it as giving children their childhood back, which is a really good way of putting it.
Let the message today to Leo and all the petitioners be a really positive one: we hear their concerns, but we back parents, we believe in young people and we are determined to make the online world work better for them. That is the task we have to do between now and December, and it is the responsibility of not just the Government, but all Members. I re-emphasise what the Secretary of State has set as the benchmark: we have to be able to look those grieving families in the eye and say that we have done all we possibly can to make the online world a safer place, so that other people’s children do not end up like their children did. If we can achieve that, we will have achieved something not just for this generation, but for future generations as well.
(3 weeks, 6 days ago)
Written StatementsI would like to provide the House with an update on the Government work to strengthen the security and resilience of undersea infrastructure that is critical to the United Kingdom.
Today, the Government are publishing a White Paper on “Critical Undersea Infrastructure Security and Resilience: Proposals for modernising the UK’s legislation”. At the same time, we are launching a 12-week public consultation on these proposals.
Critical undersea infrastructure underpins services essential to the UK’s security, economy and daily life. Subsea telecommunications cables carry approximately 99% of the UK’s international data traffic, while subsea pipelines, interconnectors and other offshore energy infrastructure play a vital role in supporting the UK’s energy needs. As reliance on this infrastructure grows, so too does the importance of ensuring it remains secure and resilient.
In April, the then Defence Secretary revealed that the UK’s armed forces, working with allies, tracked Russian submarines tasked with surveying subsea cables. Incidents of this kind underline the global risks to CUI and the need for modern legal frameworks to protect it.
The Joint Committee on the National Security Strategy has made clear that UK legislation has not kept pace with the growing importance of CUI or the risks it now faces. The Government agree. The principal offence for damaging subsea cables dates back to 1885, refers to “telegraphic” communications, and makes limited provision for energy infrastructure. It no longer provides an adequate deterrent.
To address such deficiencies, the White Paper sets out detailed proposals for:
A new criminal penalties regime to strengthen deterrence against harmful conduct affecting CUI;
New security and resilience duties for providers of subsea telecoms cable systems and services;
A new national security power to enable the Government to require industry to take specified action where necessary and proportionate to ensure the security and resilience of subsea telecoms cable infrastructure and services; and
A new regulatory framework to help ensure the secure deployment and operation of subsea sensing technologies.
Through our consultation, the Government welcome views from anyone with an interest in these proposals, including individuals, industry, academia and civil society organisations. The responses will inform the development of future legislation. The White Paper contains 72 consultation questions covering the proposed framework.
The proposals are based principally on the reserved competences of telecommunications, national security and defence. The Government recognise that some proposals will interact with devolved responsibilities, including environmental and marine management functions.
The White Paper has been presented to Parliament as a Command Paper and will be placed in the Library in both Houses. It is also published on the gov.uk website.
[HCWS404]
(1 month ago)
Written StatementsI am repeating the following written ministerial statement made today in the other place by my noble Friend, the Minister for Arts and Museums, Baroness Mackenzie of Sherwood CBE:
Museums and galleries tell the story of who we are as a country and foster pride in the places we come from. They educate, inspire and entertain people and drive growth in our towns and cities. This Government are committed to ensuring that everyone, no matter their background or geographic location, can enjoy our national and regional museums.
DCMS has worked with the museums sector to explore options for charging overseas visitors admission to the national museums, to support financial resilience and underpin our commitment to ensuring art and culture is accessible to all. A full list of national museum sites with free admission can be seen in annex A.
I wish to update the House on this work.
First, I would like to thank everyone involved in this work for giving their expertise and time.
To introduce charging for overseas visitors would be a complex decision with far-reaching implications. The national museums are among our most treasured national assets, and visitors from all over the world cite our museums and galleries as a reason for their visit. National museums also add more than £1 billion a year to the economy. Seven of the UK’s 10 most visited museums are national museums. In 2025, 7.1 million people visited the Natural History Museum and 6.4 million visited the British Museum.
There is a long-standing principle of universal free admission to our world-class museums, which sets us apart from other countries around the world. No matter who you are, or where you are from, you can come to learn and be entertained and inspired.
We will not be pursuing a change in policy to universal free entry, but our findings more broadly will help inform the upcoming museums plan. As the Government confirmed earlier this year, a 10-year plan for museums in England will support a thriving and sustainable sector that supports growth in every postcode and opportunity for all. This work will be led by the museums sector and will cover museums across the country, including the DCMS sponsored museums. Further details will be announced later this autumn.
Annex A: National Museum Sites with Free Admission
British Museum—London
Horniman Museum—London
Imperial War Museum
Imperial War Museum (London)
Imperial War Museum North (Manchester)
Museum of the Home—London
National Gallery—London
National Museums Liverpool
World Museum
Museum of Liverpool
Walker Art Gallery
International Slavery Museum and Maritime Museum
Lady Lever Art Gallery
Sudley House
National Portrait Gallery—London
Natural History Museum
Natural History Museum (London)
Natural History Museum at Tring
Royal Armouries
Royal Armouries Leeds
Fort Nelson (Portsmouth)
Royal Museums Greenwich
National Maritime Museum (London)
Queen’s House (London)
Sir John Soane’s Museum—London
Science Museum Group
Science Museum (London)
Science and Industry Museum (Manchester)
National Science and Media Museum (Bradford)
National Railway Museum (York)
Locomotion (Shildon)
Tate
Tate Britain (London)
Tate Modern (London)
Tate Liverpool
Victoria and Albert Museum
Victoria and Albert Museum (London)
Young V&A (London)
V&A East (London)
V&A Wedgwood Collection (Stoke-on-Trent)
Wallace Collection—London
[HCWS359]