House of Commons (26) - Commons Chamber (12) / Westminster Hall (6) / Written Statements (5) / Written Corrections (3)
(1 day, 7 hours ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
(1 day, 7 hours ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
David Chadwick (Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe) (LD)
I beg to move,
That this House has considered community hospitals and step-down care.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I have secured this debate to raise the alarm about community hospitals across Powys and across Wales, which are in grave danger.
Community hospitals are a legacy left to us by previous generations. They are a reminder of how communities once came together to solve their own problems and of what concentrated local power can achieve, yet their fates are now being decided by Welsh health boards, while the Minister for Health and Care in Wales does nothing. The plans to take services away from community hospitals across Wales have been inching forward for the past few years, first under the Welsh Labour Government and now under Plaid Cymru. I raised these concerns at Prime Minister’s questions with the former Prime Minister, who is no longer in this place. He told me that he would write to me, but he never did. Community hospitals are a vital part of the NHS, especially in rural areas.
Brian Mathew (Melksham and Devizes) (LD)
Does my hon. Friend agree that many community hospitals, including Melksham community hospital in my constituency, are significantly under-utilised? That historic hospital should be a beacon of community healthcare. If the Government are serious about shifting care away from acute hospitals, such community sites must receive investment to bring the space back into use to support clinical services, including step-down care and treatment of minor injuries.
Order. May I ask Members to make short interventions, not speeches?
David Chadwick
I thank my hon. Friend for that contribution. The statistics in my constituency and across Powys are certainly different. The average utilisation rate of beds in community hospitals across Powys is 91%, which shows that these community hospitals are already full—the services are already being fully used. We have an ageing population. One of the oldest council wards in Wales is next to Llandrindod community hospital, which is why these services are so desperately needed.
On the point about the ageing population and Powys being an attractive area for people to retire to, does the hon. Member agree that the Barnett formula does not recognise need specifically on those issues for Wales?
David Chadwick
The right hon. Lady knows full well that I fully agree that the Barnett formula does not serve Wales as well as it should, and that we are disadvantaged in that sense.
Community hospitals care for people who need nursing overnight or a few more days of support before they can go home safely.
I thank the hon. Gentleman for securing this debate. He is right to underline the fact that the population is ageing and the proportion of those of pensionable age has continued to grow, particularly in rural areas. The Department of Health in Northern Ireland has recognised the need for change and has published a neighbourhood model of health and wellbeing. If we recognise the problems in Northern Ireland, Wales, Scotland and England, is it not time that all four nations got together to share their ideas and a way forward?
David Chadwick
What really matters in Wales is that the potential cut to community hospital services will have a knock-on impact in other areas of the Union, most obviously England. Lots of people from Powys rely on hospitals in Herefordshire and Shropshire because we do not have a general hospital of our own.
Many people who rely on their community hospital do not stay overnight; they go there for blood tests, X-rays or to use the attached minor injuries unit. The ability to access those services in the community is a lifeline for many, particularly those who need regular blood tests and rely on an infrequent bus or a lift from a neighbour to get to the nearest general hospital, which for many people in Powys is in Herefordshire or Shropshire. The removal of these services on the Welsh side of the border will lead to greater demand on the English side.
Alex Easton (North Down) (Ind)
My community hospital in Bangor has been stripped of its minor injuries unit and GP ward. Does the hon. Member agree that community hospitals across the UK deserve more investment? We could make better use of NHS resources while enabling people to receive care closer to home.
David Chadwick
Quite. I have two boys aged four and two, and we have frequently had to go to minor injury units because of what small children tend to do. Residents across my constituency are concerned that if the local unit closes, the next time they have to take their child to a minor injuries unit it might be a 30-mile drive away instead of just around the corner.
Community hospitals provide another service that we have not mentioned so far: in-patient mental health care. When it is provided locally, close to family and with a team to support someone after discharge, that is obviously better for mental health. They can also provide palliative and end-of-life care when symptoms are difficult to manage at home. For families spending those last days together, having a bed nearby means that they can visit their loved ones every day.
Local beds are especially important for my constituents, because we do not have a general hospital in Powys. People in Powys who rely on a general hospital will have to leave their own neighbourhood and either cross the border into England or go down to Swansea for an operation. They come back to community hospitals to recover. In its own evaluation of local step-down and rehabilitation units, the health board heard that most families had less far to travel to visit, and that patients valued the support they received from physiotherapists. Yet, under Powys teaching health board’s “Better Together” proposals, the number of physical health in-patient beds could be cut from 148—with a utilisation rate of 91% on average—to just 60. Both options would remove those beds from Ystradgynlais, Welshpool, Llanidloes, Machynlleth and Bronllys. Under the 60-bed option, Llandrindod Wells would lose its beds too. In Knighton, the mothballed beds would remain closed. The proposals would also concentrate mental health care on only one site in Bronllys, which is by far the worst for public transport options, and would shut two minor injuries units in the county and remove X-ray services from several sites.
Since the plans were announced, more than 10,000 people have signed my petition opposing the cuts. Every GP practice in Powys has signed a letter to the health board, raising their concerns about the cuts. Doctors have said to me privately that their biggest concern is the impact on palliative care and what it would mean for local residents in the last days of their life. Thousands of people have attended the public meetings that we have organised across the constituency. In Ystradgynlais, so many people came that they spilled out into the street and stood outside to listen, because we could not accommodate everybody inside. They pointed out some ludicrous stats that had been put forward in the pre-consultations, including the claim that they could get from Ystradgynlais to Brecon in 29 minutes, which is impossible.
Local doctors, nurses and residents all oppose these plans. In the past fortnight, I have spoken at rallies at Llandrindod Wells and Ystradgynlais. On Saturday, hundreds of people gathered once more outside Ystradgynlais community hospital, while hundreds poured into the streets of Welshpool for a hospital bed push through the town centre organised by Richard Church, Carol Robinson and Glyn Preston. People across Powys are desperate not to lose these services.
Welsh Liberal Democrat campaigners have raised similar concerns elsewhere in Wales. Maesteg community hospital was built in 1914 to care for injured servicemen. Miners from the Llynfi valley—
It behoves me to point out the obvious, which is that these are all matters to be answered by a Health Minister in Wales, and that the Health Minister here cannot answer them. I also need to point out that an extra £500 million was allocated to health in Wales in yesterday’s Welsh budget. It includes a national clinical plan in the spring and a community shift of expenditure directed to health boards of 0.5% of their budgets towards community services.
David Chadwick
The right hon. Lady is quite right to point out that healthcare is devolved to Wales, so these are predominantly Welsh issues, but everybody in this place should be concerned about the state of devolution. One of the big challenges in Wales is that we have a Welsh Health Minister—part of a new Government who have inherited a legislative framework from the previous Government—who is saying that he has no powers to do anything. That is not what devolution should look like, and it will drive people across Wales mad if it continues. We have a Welsh Health Minister who says he has no power to do anything about the health boards that are reportedly under his control. That is not a style of devolution that will keep people happy.
I understand that the Health Minister for Wales has written to the hon. Gentleman to explain the legislative framework as it stands. That includes the legislation on nursing staff levels, on which I think we agree, which was introduced by a predecessor of the hon. Gentleman’s as Liberal leader in Wales and which is affecting recruiting across rural areas.
Order. I remind Members that interventions must be short. They are not speeches.
David Chadwick
Staffing levels are obviously of critical importance, and that is one of the issues that confuses people. Powys teaching health board says that it needs to make these changes so it can hold on to the staff it has, but the staff I have spoken to are fed up. Who would put forward for a nursing job that they think might disappear in the next few months? That is having a damaging impact on morale across Powys and across Wales. Nurses have a choice of where to work, and my great fear is that this will drive our good, well-trained, professional nurses out of Wales.
In the Llynfi valley, the community hospital is under threat and people are wondering where their loved ones will end up; Dean Ronan is leading the campaign to keep it open. In north Wales, Betsi Cadwaladr same-day urgent primary care at Ysbyty Alltwen in Tremadog, Ysbyty Gwynedd in Bangor and Ysbyty Penrhos Stanley in Holyhead are all under threat of closure. In Swansea, 30 step-down beds have been moved out of Gorseinon hospital to Singleton, further reducing capacity and pushing more people into Morriston hospital or general hospitals further afield. Sam Bennett has been expressing his concerns about the situation there.
I think we all agree that over the past 40 years too many community and cottage hospitals have been closed, including in Builth Wells. Earlier this month, England’s chief medical officer, Professor Sir Chris Whitty, published his annual report on health in rural areas and small towns. It identified community hospitals as an important way to provide care in areas where larger hospitals are hard to reach. It also sets out why rural health services have to be planned around long distances, limited public transport and the available workforce. Those are precisely the conditions that people have to deal with in Powys.
Taking beds and services further away runs against what the evidence tells us about access to rural healthcare. With that in mind, is it any wonder that A&E departments are backed up? Take away a minor injuries unit, and some of the people who would have used it will turn up at an A&E in a general hospital further away. Take away step-down beds, and patients who could have moved to a community ward may have to stay in an acute bed. That will further clog up our hospitals across Wales and England and will add to ambulance delays.
Some health boards are using the promise of more care at home to justify removing beds, without explaining how they will deliver that care at the scale they are counting on. In Powys, the board says that it wants to expand care at home, district nursing and rehabilitation, but has not said how many staff it will need to do so; where it will recruit them from, particularly when it is struggling to fill its current vacancies; how many visits those staff will be able to deliver across a county the size of Powys; how much extra work will fall to the council; or who will have to pay for it.
There is also the practical question of delivering frequent care across rural Powys. Several visits a day can mean several long journeys a day. A care worker covering scattered villages can spend a substantial part of a shift on the road, and that extra time and fuel has to be paid for. When several patients need frequent nursing and therapy, a local ward allows staff to provide that care in one place. That can be a better use of limited staff and budgets, and it gives patients more time with the people helping them to recover. I want more people to be able to recover at home, but even if the board delivers everything it proposes, patients will still need community hospital beds.
People in Powys want answers. Where will their parents and loved ones recover after an operation? Where will they go for an X-ray after a fall? If someone they love needs end-of-life care, will they be close enough to visit every day? They deserve answers while there is still time to change the plans, yet the Welsh Health Minister keeps pointing back at the health board. The Welsh Government hold the purse strings and have a responsibility for the choices that the health board is being asked to make. The chairs of health boards in Wales are responsible for setting the strategic direction of health boards and are directly accountable to the Welsh Health Minister. The buck passing needs to stop. People in Powys deserve to hear directly from their Health Minister about what care they can expect and how it will be paid for.
I want to know, here today, whether this Minister agrees with Sir Chris Whitty about the value of community hospitals. Do this Government want to see them stay open across the United Kingdom? Are they concerned about the impact of what is happening in Powys? Is the Minister concerned about the cross-border impact that it will have?
I thank the thousands of residents across Powys who have spoken up and have stood in the cold and rain to show their concerns. The Welsh Health Minister should listen to them and think again before beds and crucial services are lost.
Dr Roz Savage (South Cotswolds) (LD)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe (David Chadwick) for securing this important debate.
Community hospitals are especially important in rural communities such as mine, where distances are greater, public transport is extremely limited and getting to hospital can depend on whether someone has a car or a friend or family member able to drive them. However, their value goes beyond convenience. Community hospitals provide a vital bridge between acute hospital care and returning home. For older people recovering from surgery, a stroke or serious illness, they can provide the rehabilitation and support those patients need in order to regain their independence.
Across England, about 13,000 patients a day are medically ready to leave acute hospitals but are stuck there. Getting people into the right care is better for patients—better for their chances of recovery and for their morale—and better for their families, who are able to visit them. Vitally, that also frees up beds for those who really need them.
I welcome the NHS ambition to provide more care at or close to home, but “care closer to home” must not become a euphemism for care without a bed. Some patients need the additional support that a community hospital provides. We could be still more ambitious in the way we use our community hospitals. They could become hubs for proactive healthcare, helping people to stay well, rather than simply treating them after they have become ill. That would save money as well as countless productive years.
In east Surrey, for example, the Growing Health Together initiative brings GPs, community organisations and residents together to improve health outcomes through activities that tackle loneliness, encourage exercise and build community connections. What’s not to love about that? Community hospitals could be natural anchors for that kind of preventive and life-enhancing approach.
That brings me to the issue of Cirencester hospital—a much-loved and cherished institution in my constituency. When its operating theatre was temporarily closed last year, local people were understandably concerned. I cannot tell you, Mr Turner, how many people have come up to me to tell me a personal family story about a fun night they spent in the minor injuries unit, or where they went to give birth. Working with Councillor Paul Hodgkinson, we organised a petition calling for services to be restored. In just a few days, we got more than 3,000 signatures. We delivered it to Downing Street in June 2026, but are still awaiting a response. I realise that a few other things were going on in Downing Street in June, but even so we would appreciate a response. I would be grateful if the Minister could help to secure one.
A response was sent in July 2026 from the ministerial correspondence and public enquiries unit at the Department of Health and Social Care. If the hon. Member has not got that letter, I have a copy here that I am happy to give her today.
Dr Savage
I thank the Minister and am very grateful to hear that. I will co-ordinate with her afterwards to receive that copy.
Since delivering the petition, I have met the ICB and been reassured that the future of Cirencester hospital is absolutely safe as part of the ICB’s ongoing re-engineering and rearrangement of facilities across Gloucestershire. That could have been better communicated to residents, which would have saved an awful lot of misunderstanding and unnecessary apprehension, but I am somewhat reassured that the future of the hospital is safe.
I welcome the NHS’s commitment to Cirencester hospital’s long-term future and recognise that services need to evolve in response to the changing needs of our country, but those decisions must reflect local needs. There is substantial planned housing growth—many thousands of new homes—in the villages around Cirencester over the next few years, which needs to be factored into the capacity of local health services. Local people must have a genuine say in shaping the hospital’s future: it is not just that the one-way communication needs to be improved; there needs to be two-way communication and genuine consultation.
I ask the Minister to ensure that healthcare planning reflects the needs of our growing rural communities, like those in South Cotswolds, and that community hospitals are seen not simply as facilities to be preserved, but as opportunities to develop. We should make the fullest possible use of these valuable local assets, which provide care close to home and help people to stay healthy in the first place. That is the future I would like to see for Cirencester hospital.
Monica Harding (Esher and Walton) (LD)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe (David Chadwick) on securing a debate on this important topic. My hon. Friends have spoken powerfully about rural provision and community hospitals, but I want to speak for a suburban constituency. The problem my hon. Friends describe—people stuck in acute beds with nowhere safe to go—is also serious in Surrey.
I want to talk particularly about Molesey community hospital in my constituency, which serves people across my constituency and beyond, providing rehabilitation beds, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, speech and language therapy, community nursing, out-patient clinics and end-of-life care. Its aim is to help patients return to living independently or with care or other support. In short, it is exactly the kind of care closer to home that the Government say they want more of. It is also a place that my constituents care about deeply. However, the building has been neglected for more than 30 years. An estate left to age does not save money; it costs more to maintain every year, and it makes modern equipment and new ways of working harder to bring in. Without investment, the care inside will eventually fall short, however dedicated the staff are.
The pressure on step-down care in my area is severe. My constituency sits within the Surrey and Sussex ICB, which NHS England’s discharge-ready date figures in September put joint last out of all 36 ICBs in England on discharge delays. Across England, the average patient leaves hospital just under a day after they are ready to go; in Surrey and Sussex, it is 1.6 days. For 85% of patients, discharge happens on the same day they are ready; the problem is those who face delays, often because they are waiting for further care to be available, including in community hospitals like Molesey and in the care system.
For patients who are delayed at all, the average wait in Surrey and Sussex is more than 11 days, compared to under seven nationally. In September, 345 people in Surrey and Sussex waited three weeks or more after they were ready to leave. That is 2.4% of all discharges, well over double the national rate. In a single month, the ICB lost 23,695 bed days due to delayed discharge. That is the equivalent of nearly 790 hospital beds occupied every day of September by people who no longer needed to be there.
Does the hon. Lady agree that the Government not doing what she advocates actually costs us money? We need to support community hospitals as patients are moved into greater care in the community.
Monica Harding
I agree 100%. It costs more money in the long run, and there is also the human cost. Elderly patients can lose mobility in the time they are in hospital, which makes the problem worse, and they end up in hospital for the longer term.
To compound the problem of delays in NHS services, those who need acute hospital beds cannot get them, because patients cannot be discharged. Even where performance is better, there is no room for complacency. Kingston and Richmond NHS foundation trust runs Kingston hospital, which many of my constituents use. It discharged 88% of patients with no delay in September, which is better than the national average and a credit to the management and staff there. However, even there, 787 bed days were lost in a single month. Our NHS—I know the Minister is aware of this—is fighting with one arm tied behind its back because we cannot sort out step-down care and adult social care.
The Government’s own 10-year health plan talks about getting the most out of the existing NHS estate and bringing care closer to where people live. Molesey is that estate, and Molesey is that care. Letting it decline will be at odds with the Government’s own strategy.
There is one more striking point. The data on the number of patients discharged into individual community hospitals is not published in a disaggregated format. How can we hold the Government to account and scrutinise NHS performance if the full data is not shared as a matter of course?
We Liberal Democrats have called for thousands of extra step-down and social care packages every week, including in community hospitals, and for a national care agency to end the postcode lottery in care. We want to fix social care and invest in community hospitals, and then free up hospitals, including A&Es and acute care, to do their work, rather than covering for failures in the broader system.
I ask the Minister several questions. First, will she look at the discharge-ready date figures in my ICB in Surrey and Sussex and push for improvement? Secondly, will she assure my constituents that Molesey’s essential services will be protected and the estate bettered, and agree that more step-down capacity there could cut discharge delays? Thirdly, what specific support will be given to Surrey and Sussex ICB this winter to improve its performance and cut discharge delays?
Princess Alice hospice in Esher announced this week that it will have to make cuts to its services—both in-patient beds and home visits—because of a funding shortfall of £3.5 million. It receives just 20% of its funding from the Government. The rest comes through selling woolly jumpers, essentially, and from donations on the high street, which is not only unsustainable, but wrong. Those cuts and the Princess Alice hospice’s inability to expand its provision put more stress on A&E. I wrote to the Minister about that this week. Will she agree to look into an urgent solution for the Princess Alice hospice, alongside a more long-term sustainable solution for hospice care?
As winter approaches, the urgency increases. The people of Molesey and my constituency of Esher and Walton, and the hundreds of people waiting on wards across Surrey and Sussex today, deserve nothing less than step-down care at capacity when it is needed.
Helen Maguire (Epsom and Ewell) (LD)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe (David Chadwick) for securing this important and timely debate on community hospitals and step-down care.
Community hospitals are small local hospitals or units providing a range of clinical services to their local population. They have been part of our healthcare system for over 150 years, and there are over 500 operating throughout the UK. They originally developed out of cottage hospitals and sit on a strong tradition of localised care that their communities have known and benefited from for generations. Those cottage hospitals were simply converted cottages with spaces for beds and operations. They were established to prevent patients having to take long journeys to the general hospitals in towns and cities, and to provide local doctor surgeons with a clean space to work.
Community hospitals have since developed into hubs of services meeting a range of needs, and they vary considerably as they have adapted to the needs of their local populations. Services may include community beds, clinics, minor injury services, diagnostic facilities, day care, mental health services and maternity care. That strong local tradition remains within community hospitals today, and they continue to be closely connected to their local area. They are therefore perfectly placed to understand local needs and act as an anchor in supporting prevention and the management of long-term conditions. They play an important role in reducing the pressure on larger acute hospitals by supporting early discharge and step-down care, freeing up beds, and reducing A&E demands. By reimagining what we can do with community hospitals, based around the needs of an ageing population and rising complexity, we can make a significant difference to patients.
When thousands of people a day are stuck in hospitals, unable to go home because the care they need is not available, it makes no sense to close down community hospitals. Under our A&E plan, the Liberal Democrats would invest in thousands of extra step-down and social care packages every week, including in community hospitals.
Community hospitals are particularly important in rural areas, where access to acute hospitals is often limited, as we have heard today. Rural populations frequently face great barriers to access, high delivery costs and persistent workforce shortages. In 2021, the chief medical officer’s annual report on health in coastal communities provided official recognition that rural places are not homogenous. Those living furthest from healthcare services in rural and coastal areas are most at risk of experiencing inequalities, particularly where there are poor and unaffordable transport connections.
Since September 2024, the number of delayed patients in community trusts has been notably flat, holding consistently at about 2,150 to 2,300 with little to no variation. Yet we have seen an escalating process of service reductions at many of those hospitals. My hon. Friend the Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe mentioned the devastating impact that cutting services in community hospitals across Wales will have, including for those in Powys, Gorseinon and Maesteg. Often the changes are introduced under a façade of trials, yet they almost always become permanent.
We understand that pragmatic changes to services are sometime necessary as a result of shifting demand, but they are often done without proper consultation with or explanations for the affected communities. We wholeheartedly agree with the ambition to shift more care into the community—that is important—but reducing services in local community hospitals is at odds with that goal. In fact, the hubs have a vital role to play alongside neighbourhood health centres. It is in the name: community hospitals.
I have seen the benefits of community hospitals at first hand. Leatherhead community hospital in my Epsom and Ewell constituency provides more than 33 specific consultation and out-patient services, including a stoma clinic, physiotherapy rehab, and speech and language therapy, for the diverse population that it serves. It is highly valued by the local community and shows the importance of maintaining strong accessibility, continuity of care and patient flows across community health infrastructure. Community hospitals are vital in the provision of those services and we must continue to support them.
Whether it is GPs, pharmacies, ambulance services or social care, rural health services have too often been an afterthought, and the same is true for community hospitals. They attract less funding and attention compared with the larger acute hospitals, resulting in workforce shortages and dilapidated estates.
Community hospitals also play a vital role in facilitating step-down care. They support early discharge and step-down care for patients who are medically fit to leave acute hospitals but still need further support to gain independence prior to being fully discharged. Step-down care is vital because it bridges the gap between high-intensity hospital treatment and supporting people to return to living independently in their communities, which in itself prevents readmissions.
Ineffective or missing step-down care is too frequent and the costs are too high. That results in delayed discharges, readmissions or improper placements, and it has major financial and human costs. When step-down care fails, patients experience significantly higher rates of emergency readmission. For already vulnerable groups, that is exacerbated. For example, homeless patients who are discharged without proper support face 2.5 times the rate of emergency readmission. At St Helier hospital, 13 out of 18 beds in the reablement unit had to close following the significant deterioration of the 90-year-old building. Structural cracks meant the building literally broke in two.
Analysis of NHS England’s October 2024 data shows that the number of bed days lost to delayed discharge has an average monthly cost of about £210 million. Over a whole year, that adds up to a staggering £2 billion in costs to the NHS. NHS England cautions that that calculation is likely to be lower than the true cost, as it does not account for the wider costs associated with the inability to admit new patients.
The Liberal Democrats represent those rural communities, and we know all too well the pressure that the system is under there and the important role that community hospitals play. That is why we have long called for a rescue plan for rural health services, in which rural community hospitals are an essential pillar. As part of that, alongside investment in community hospitals and step-down care, we have called for a strategic small surgeries fund to sustain services in rural and remote areas; and a strategy to close the gap in access to primary healthcare between urban and rural areas.
We have also called for an emergency fund to reverse closures of community ambulance stations and cancel planned closures where needed, which would particularly benefit rural communities; an end, through a national care agency, to the postcode lottery of care provision, which disproportionately affects rural communities; and a national drive for rural community first responders to protect air ambulances, integrating them into the emergency care system and ensuring that they receive NHS funding in addition to charitable donations.
In rural areas, it takes twice as long for people to reach their nearest GP by public transport as in urban areas, and around a third longer by driving, according to the Rural Services Network. Those findings were confirmed by Lord Darzi’s report on the NHS, which found that across much of rural England—including nearly the whole south-west, as well as much of the east of England—there are fewer than 46 dentists per 100,000 people. That is unacceptable, and we must change it. Access to vital community healthcare cannot be dictated by a postcode lottery. Community hospitals receive less funding and attention than larger acute hospitals, resulting in workforce shortages and run-down estates.
The bottom line is that community hospitals and step-down care are a service to us all. They bring multidisciplinary services closer to the community. They bridge the gap between hospitals and GPs. They relieve strain on hospital beds and A&E departments. They support faster discharge and rehabilitation, and help patients to regain that vital independence. They improve healthcare access for elderly and vulnerable patients by reducing the travel burden on patients and their families. I urge the Minister to reflect on all the calls from my colleagues and me during this important debate, because we must ensure that community hospitals and providers of step-down care receive the support they deserve.
Gregory Stafford (Farnham and Bordon) (Con)
It is once again a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I congratulate the hon. Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe (David Chadwick) on securing this debate, and I thank the hon. Members who have described the hospitals that their communities love, and their concerns about their future.
There are about 500 community hospitals in the UK. For many patients, they are where recovery begins: somewhere to regain strength and independence after an acute ward, before going home. That is step-down care, and I pay tribute to the staff, the leagues of friends and the volunteers who sustain those hospitals, and to the Community Hospitals Association.
The case is simple. A patient who is medically fit but still in an acute bed is in the wrong place. They are not getting the best care for their recovery, and they are taking a bed that someone else needs—perhaps someone in A&E or on a trolley in a corridor. In August, an average of 13,704 patients a day who were medically fit to leave were stuck in acute beds. Those are NHS England’s figures, analysed by the Nuffield Trust, which calls discharge delays:
“One of the biggest challenges facing the NHS”.
The King’s Fund puts last year’s cost at around £2.7 billion, up 7.5%, with almost one hospital bed in 10 taken by someone who does not need to be there. Behind each of those numbers is somebody’s mother, father, grandfather, grandmother or sibling, getting weaker by the day.
The situation is getting worse. The Health Service Journal reported this week that the cost of delayed discharges is running above the Government’s projections, and that NHS England has told Ministers that it cannot afford the beds it needs this winter. What is the plan to get a grip on this, and where are the beds going to come from?
At Health questions on 20 October, I put that question to the Minister for Secondary Care. I asked why delayed discharges are at an all-time high under this Government, and why the Government are failing so badly at getting people out of hospital and into care, either step-down or at home. The reply was the usual obfuscation and whataboutery. This Government have now been in office for over two years. The Minister did accept that patients being in the wrong place is
“not good for their health or their outcomes”—[Official Report, 20 October 2026; Vol. 791, c. 951.]
but she gave me no numbers, no date and no plan. She gave me the three shifts, which I welcome because I support care closer to home, but support for the destination is no substitute for a route, and every day without one means somebody lying in the wrong bed.
Care cannot be moved into the community without the people to deliver it. In June, the Minister for Secondary Care said that the workforce plan would be published “imminently”. Funnily enough, it was not. Two weeks ago, the Secretary of State told me that it would be in the new year. Patients are waiting, and the Government are clearly not moving with enough alacrity to get this sorted.
I see this in my constituency of Farnham and Bordon. When services at in-patient wards in Haslemere hospital were paused in 2025, patients who needed a community bed were offered places elsewhere in the Royal Surrey county hospital’s footprint, including at Milford hospital. I pay tribute to the staff who keep Haslemere going and to the League of Friends of the Haslemere and District Hospital.
As other hon. Members have mentioned, access is needed as much as beds. For an older person, someone without a car or someone whose family live far away, getting to care is half the battle. In Farnham, I launched the Hoppa, an accessible door-to-door community transport service that takes residents to Frimley Park, GP surgeries and the Royal Surrey. The town council, the borough council, a local charitable trust and community groups made it happen. I have supported the same service in Haslemere, and I am working with the Hampshire and Isle of Wight ICB to extend it across the Hampshire side of my constituency.
The Government’s answer is neighbourhood health. They will deliver 250 neighbourhood health centres—the first 120 by 2030, apparently—with £426 million over four years for the primary care estate. As I have said, I have absolutely no quarrel with care closer to home, and I have asked the Health Secretary to make Haslemere, Farnham, and Whitehill and Bordon neighbourhood health centres. However, the Nuffield Trust has questioned whether the framework can be delivered alongside the biggest restructuring of the NHS in a decade.
Indeed, GPs voted overwhelmingly against this year’s contract. In June, my hon. Friend the Member for Hinckley and Bosworth (Dr Evans) asked how community hospitals fit into this plan. He was told that they should be seen alongside neighbourhood teams, primary care and social care. That describes a system; it does not say where the beds are. The strategy has no funding line for the community hospitals doing this job today.
Ministers say that these are decisions for ICBs, yet the Health Bill removes the duty on commissioners to notify the Secretary of State of a proposed reconfiguration while keeping the power to call them in. The Government cannot say that it is all local and then remove the notification that tells them what the local decisions are. In March, the Department said that it had been notified of just nine notable changes, one of them affecting a community hospital’s beds. How does the Department know what is actually happening to community bed capacity across England?
The last Conservative Government expanded community diagnostic centres, with 170 now operating. We built 125 surgical hubs and grew urgent treatment centres and same-day emergency care, all to treat people nearer to home. We want to build on that with a proper intermediate tier that counts community hospitals as part of the answer. Denmark and Norway place intermediate care with a municipality, and Sweden uses small rural facilities for step-down.
The money matters too. Every day of delay that is avoided saves about £345 per bed. Even a modest reduction would therefore be worth hundreds of millions of pounds a year to the Exchequer and could be reinvested in the services that we so badly need. On behalf of the Conservatives, I will outline our plans on that in greater detail soon.
Today, I ask the Minister six things. First, when will the workforce plan be published? I have raised it on six separate occasions, with three different Health Secretaries, and I hope that the Minister can give me a more concrete answer today than the Secretary of State could two weeks ago. Secondly, what is the plan for step-down capacity this winter? Thirdly, will the Department publish national data on community hospital bed numbers and closures, and keep the duty to notify on reconfigurations in the Health Bill? Fourthly, what role will existing community hospitals play in the 250 neighbourhood health centres, and will any of the £426 million be used to support community hospitals specifically? Fifthly, when will the Government respond to the Carr-Hill review, and how will neighbourhood health reach rural communities? Finally, will the Government recognise community transport as part of the care pathway and package to support community hospitals?
Community hospitals earn their place. With beds, staff and a way for people to reach them, they offer some of the best value in the NHS. I look forward to the Minister’s response to those questions and her support for our community hospitals.
It is a great pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I congratulate the hon. Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe (David Chadwick) on securing this important debate, and I thank all Members who have contributed.
As the hon. Gentleman knows, health is a devolved matter, and decisions on NHS Wales services, including in Powys, are for the Welsh Government and the relevant health board. I note that there was a rather lengthy exchange between the hon. Gentleman and the right hon. Member for Dwyfor Meirionnydd (Liz Saville Roberts), who leads Plaid Cymru in Westminster. I do not want to intrude too much on the private grief in that corner of the Chamber, but I would expect Members’ concerns about access to healthcare in their constituencies to be taken very seriously. As an English Health Minister, I will always meet Members to discuss their concerns.
I recognise that communities along the border use services on both sides of it, and that obviously matters to the hon. Gentleman’s constituents. Arrangements are in place between England and Wales to ensure that patients who live near the border can access timely and appropriate care regardless of the administrative boundaries. Responsibility for that sits with the ICBs in England and with the local health boards in Wales.
The UK Government continue to work closely with the Welsh Government on areas of shared interest, including improving health outcomes and addressing common challenges across our health systems. While recognising the cross-border connections, I will focus my remarks on healthcare provision in England, as Members would expect. The debate has been a really good opportunity to discuss how we can deliver more care closer to home, as we have set out in the 10-year health plan, and the important role that community hospitals can play in delivering that vision.
As we have heard, community hospitals have a long and proud history. For more than 150 years they have provided local, accessible care that is adapted for the communities they serve. Hon. Members have spoken this morning about their local community hospitals in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, and I was pleased that we also heard reference to the chief medical officer’s excellent annual report, “Health in Rural Areas and Small Towns”, in which he specifically mentioned the important role of community hospitals in ensuring access to health services in rural areas and small towns.
Community hospitals play a key role in delivering step-down and intermediate care, thereby ensuring that patients receive care in the right place for them. While this is hugely beneficial to patients, there are also benefits to the wider health and care system when community and intermediate care work as they should. If we can move patients safely out of an acute bed when they no longer need that level of care, that bed will be available for those who need it, thereby improving the flow in the hospital and relieving the pressures in emergency departments and ambulance handovers. I am happy to look into the concerns raised by the hon. Member for Esher and Walton (Monica Harding) about discharge delays and step-down care in her constituency.
David Chadwick
The health trusts on the English side of the border in Herefordshire and Shropshire have expressed their concern multiple times, including to the Welsh Affairs Committee, about the impact of decisions by the Powys teaching health board on them and their ability to provide services to patients. Will the Minister tell us in more concrete detail the plans to fix the problems with cross-border healthcare, including in respect of medical record sharing?
Discussions are being held among the relevant authorities. I do not have a detailed read-out of the results of those discussions, but it is important that the Welsh Government, the ICBs and the UK Government have those conversations. Making sure that patients can access healthcare as close to home as possible should be at the heart of this. We would all want those discussions to focus on that.
It is important to recognise what these hospitals mean to the communities they serve, which rely on them. It is right to recognise that they are staffed by dedicated nurses, therapists, doctors and care staff, supported in many cases by volunteers and local charities. Many have been woven into local life for generations, and I want to put on the record my thanks to everyone who works in or supports a community hospital.
Monica Harding
Will the Minister congratulate community groups such as the League of Friends of Molesey Hospital that keep those hospitals front and centre of the community and fight for them?
I absolutely agree with the hon. Lady and pay tribute to those groups.
As we are talking about the workforce, I want to respond to the shadow Minister, the hon. Member for Farnham and Bordon (Gregory Stafford), who raised the issue of the long-awaited workforce plan. We need to get the plan right, which is why it is taking some time, but I gently point out to him that in the 14 years his party was in power, it failed to ever produce a workforce plan for the NHS.
I am very happy to give way, but I was in Parliament for those 14 years, so I know jolly well what happened.
Gregory Stafford
The Minister may have missed this, but we did produce a workforce plan. The whole point of the new Government’s workforce plan is to update the Conservative one, so I think she needs to check the record.
I will go away and check that, but for many, many years the Labour Opposition were arguing that we needed a proper workforce plan. I will check whether one was produced, but it took many years of badgering the Conservative Government to take what most of us think is a sensible approach to workforce planning. On the shadow Minister’s point about the Carr-Hill formula review, work is ongoing to look at the best distribution of funding for GP practices.
Let me turn to neighbourhood health, which has been talked about a lot. It is very clear that our ambition is to move out of hospitals and into local communities, and neighbourhood health is at the heart of that ambition. It is about bringing together teams from across the NHS, local government and the voluntary sector to improve the health and care of the people living in the area. We published the neighbourhood health framework in March this year to help local leaders to develop and scale neighbourhood health services. Through the medium-term planning framework, systems are required to set out how they will shift activity from hospital to community.
That ambition is why we will deliver 250 neighbourhood health centres, with 120 of those opening by 2030. We want to make it easier for people to access care closer to where they live up and down the country. The centres will provide easier, more convenient access to a wide range of health and care services on people’s doorsteps, with a neighbourhood health centre in every community.
Community hospitals play an important part in the wider community health service landscape. We know that we need strong community health services to support our ambitions for the NHS, which is why we have set clear guidance through the medium-term planning framework specifically on community health services. For the first time, we have set a target to reduce long waits for community health services. By 2028-29, at least 80% of community health service activity should take place within 18 weeks, bringing community health services in line with targets for elective care.
To help to reduce variation and improve access to community health services, we have set out a clear expectation of the community health services that ICBs should be commissioning. “Standardising community health services”, published in 2025, with further details added in 2026, provides an overview of the community health services that ICBs should be commissioning. That is hugely important.
We want to increase community health service capacity to meet growth in demand. Members have raised issues such as the development of housing estates and how important it is to have provision for the additional families who will reside there. We expect that the growth in demand will be around 3% nationally per year, and we need to address that. We are also taking action to reduce unwarranted variation, to cut waits and to improve access to high-quality community services, as the hon. Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) asked the Government to do.
On step-down and intermediate care, timely discharge into the right setting matters enormously for patients, and for the NHS to function properly and efficiently. I recognise that capacity is not evenly distributed across the country. Some areas have strong intermediate care offers and others have gaps. The pressure is felt most acutely in places where rural geography makes alternatives harder to arrange. We will address that by ensuring that intermediate care is planned properly at a local level, as part of the neighbourhood health plans, and by being clear that ICBs are accountable for commissioning to meet the needs of their populations. Decisions on how services are configured must be made locally, and they must be accompanied by appropriate engagement with patients, staff and local communities.
We all know about the pressures on the NHS across much of the country, including an ageing population, the increasing prevalence of long-term conditions, growing demand for rehabilitation and recovery services and, in some areas, significant population growth driven by new housing development.
Helen Maguire
One of the paths that we have been developing is to ensure that there are sufficient GPs when houses are at the planning stage. Does the Minister agree that it is important that new housing developments of 1,000 homes or whatever are not proposed unless there are the GP services to support them?
Recognising the needs of growing communities should be part of the planning that ICBs are involved in. I absolutely accept that that needs to be taken into account.
The pressures on the NHS make local community-based services more important, not less. Meeting the challenges will require strong joined-up community services, including community nursing, therapies, rehabilitation, urgent community response, virtual wards, primary care and social care, all working together around the needs of patients.
Ultimately, the future of community hospitals should not be considered in isolation; they form part of the broader community health infrastructure, which includes neighbourhood health teams, community providers, primary care, mental health services, social care and the voluntary sector. The question is not simply how many community hospitals we have, but how we use community assets and services to provide high-quality care closer to home.
I am grateful to the hon. Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe for bringing this issue to the House. Community hospitals and step-down care matter to patients, families and the wider NHS system. They have an important role in the neighbourhood-based model we are building. As we continue our work to strengthen neighbourhood health services and shift care closer to home, the experiences and concerns raised by Members today will make an important contribution to the discussion. I again thank all Members who participated in the debate.
David Chadwick
This debate has been a timely and urgent opportunity to raise the frustrations and concerns of communities across Powys that fear for the future of their community hospitals, which were built by communities for communities, often before the NHS existed. People took the initiative to address their own concerns, and now groups such as the League of Friends of the Llandrindod Wells Hospital, the Knighton Hospital and Community League of Friends and groups for other community hospitals across Powys fear that the fundraising they have generated over the years and decades and poured into their local community hospitals might all have been for nothing if those services are taken away by Health Ministers or health boards that are further away. That is why we have to restore local transparency and accountability over healthcare services across the United Kingdom, and definitely in Wales.
I thank the Minister for her remarks. I urge her to look at the cross-border impacts of the decision. If the Powys community hospitals disappear, the beds will end up on the English side of the border. There is a lot to be done to improve public transport options for people and to share medical records between England and Wales. If people are discharged from a hospital in Hereford to receive palliative care in Wales, they and their families desperately need their records to follow them.
Question put and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this House has considered community hospitals and step-down care.
(1 day, 7 hours ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
I will call Henry Tufnell to move the motion; I will then call the Minister to respond. I remind other Members that they may make a speech only with prior permission from the Member in charge of the debate and from the Minister. As I understand it, only one other Member has that consent. As is the convention for 30-minute debates, there will not be an opportunity for the Member in charge to wind up. I remind Members that interventions must be short.
Henry Tufnell (Mid and South Pembrokeshire) (Lab)
I beg to move,
That this House has considered telecommunications connectivity in rural areas.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner.
Reliable broadband and mobile signal are not luxuries; they are essential for work, education, public services and everyday life. Yet in many rural communities, such as those in my constituency, such connectivity is still lacking. Analysis of Ofcom data reveals that mine ranks 444th out of 650 constituencies in the UK for mobile service quality. Just 1% of premises in my constituency have high-quality 5G stand-alone signal, compared with 86% nationally. Those numbers are staggering and the consequences of such poor connectivity are felt every day by my constituents.
Poor connectivity is not only a problem in the hon. Gentleman’s constituency—it is the same in mine. However, we are fortunate to have a company called Fibrus, which does tremendous work across Northern Ireland. Does he agree that the Government must back proven providers such as Fibrus with sustained and targeted funding, and thereby address the very issues to which he is referring?
Henry Tufnell
I agree that the Government must do more; I will come on to that point later in my speech. I thank the hon. Gentleman for his intervention.
Tenby is one of Pembrokeshire’s largest towns and is a world-renowned tourist destination, yet it continues to suffer from persistent mobile notspots, particularly during the busy spring and summer months. Visitors struggle to use parking apps, businesses lose sales when card payment systems fail and residents are unable to access essential online services. I will say that today we have had positive news: O2 has announced that there will be eight outdoor small cells in place before the busy summer season next year, which will be some small consolation to the 5,000 people who live in Tenby and to the 70,000 people who regularly visit it. As I say, that is positive news—perhaps it reflects the timing of this Westminster Hall debate.
Essential services are also impacted by poor connectivity. Community nurses can struggle to make calls while carrying out visits, transport apps become unusable, schools face barriers in accessing online learning resources and businesses are unable to take full advantage of digital opportunities. Across the county, poor broadband and mobile coverage are limiting economic growth and preventing people from taking up jobs that depend on reliable remote working. I have spent many months pressing mobile operators, infrastructure providers, the local authority and Ministers for action.
Rachel Gilmour (Tiverton and Minehead) (LD)
In my constituency, St George’s church in Dunster could host a mast without harming the historical fabric of the building, providing coverage for around 1,000 residents and visitors. Does the hon. Gentleman agree that often the real obstacle in rural areas is not the availability of signal, but securing the commitment of mobile network operators in those areas?
Henry Tufnell
I agree with the hon. Member that the pace of progress is too often far too slow. I recognise the issues that she has raised regarding her own constituency; I have made repeated representations to VodafoneThree about the severity of the problem in Tenby in particular, and there is a planned upgrade to a key mast that serves the town, but it will not be completed until 2028. For residents and businesspeople who continue to struggle with inadequate coverage every day, that is simply not good enough.
Alison Bennett (Mid Sussex) (LD)
The hon. Member is setting out challenges in his constituency that are replicated in mine. Does he agree that it is outrageous that rural connectivity in France and Spain is better than the connectivity here in central London?
Henry Tufnell
The hon. Member is right. We too often face that rural premium, where rural areas get left behind and forgotten about while those upgrades happen in urban areas. That is not acceptable for her constituents or mine. I look forward to the publication later this year of the Government’s mobile market review, which will assess whether the current market structure is delivering the investment needed to improve mobile connectivity. For communities such as mine in Pembrokeshire, where coverage remains among the worst in the country, the test of that review must be whether it leads to faster investment, better coverage and an end to rural areas being left behind.
Perran Moon (Camborne and Redruth) (Ind)
In Cornwall, we are 638th out of 650 constituencies for mobile coverage. On average nationally, 38% of premises choose between all four networks for a high-quality 5G non-stand-alone signal. In Camborne, Redruth and Hale that figure is zero. If consumers have nowhere to switch to, operators have next to no competitive impetus to improve quality. Does my right hon. Friend agree that one of the remedies for this absence of competition—and one way to incentivise proper investment in Cornwall—would be for Ofcom to make full spectrum licences conditional on robust performance standards?
Henry Tufnell
I thank my hon. Friend for promoting me—I am not a right hon. Member—but I agree that we are too often in the situation of comparing how bad our constituencies are, and that we need organisations such as Ofcom to really grasp the nettle to make sure that this is not a race to the bottom in that sense. On that point, I urge the Minister to make sure that communities such as ours in Cornwall and west Wales are placed at the forefront of the Government’s efforts to improve telecommunications connectivity.
The stakes are only becoming higher. From next year, the UK’s landline network will be switched from analogue copper lines to digital services that rely on broadband.
Chris Kane (Stirling and Strathallan) (Lab)
I have recently been surveying villages across my constituency about this issue, and I was struck by what I heard from one constituent, Margaret. She informed me that she was unable to use her mobile emergency care button due to poor signal. Does my hon. Friend agree that the elderly are put at real risk by failings in this area?
Henry Tufnell
I agree. The actions taken will leave vulnerable constituents at greater risk, and leave rural areas with poor rural connectivity particularly exposed. During Storm Darragh, which affected my constituency in 2024, some homes in Pembrokeshire were left without power for nearly a week, yet the recommended minimum battery back-up for digital landline services is just one hour.
We were given categoric assurance that there would be back-up power sources at the mobile phone masts when those copper landlines were withdrawn. That has manifestly not happened. Does the hon. Member agree that it is for the regulator to ensure that its promises are kept?
Henry Tufnell
The right hon. Member’s point is well made. Prolonged outages leave both his constituents and mine completely cut off and unable to contact family members or emergency services—something that is particularly important when we are dealing with severe weather events.
That lack of connectivity is compounded by digital exclusion. More than a quarter of my constituents are aged 65 or older and nearly half are over the age of 50. AbilityNet is a fantastic organisation offering free advice and support for older people and those living with disability to help them access and use technology. As more and more of our essential services move online, such organisations are crucial to ensuring that no one is left behind.
Lee Pitcher (Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme) (Lab)
I have a disabled constituent who lives in a rural community and has been trying to connect to the Openreach network for months. They had brain surgery, and they asked Openreach not to come during that time—yet they still do not have connectivity. Does my hon. Friend agree that we need to ensure that, when people are in such situations, providers support them to get set up?
Henry Tufnell
I completely agree with my hon. Friend; he makes a really important point, and I am sorry to hear about the situation facing his constituent.
AbilityNet has funding from BT, but unfortunately that is due to end next summer, which means that constituents such as my hon. Friend’s and mine will face the huge issue of digital exclusion—and all at the same time as BT stands to make up to £2 billion in windfall profits from selling off the old copper cabling.
Dave Robertson (Lichfield) (Lab)
My hon. Friend is making a great speech about the importance of connectivity to rural areas like the ones in our constituencies. Does he share my concern about the number of landowners who are issuing notices to quit and having masts removed from their land? The Government need to take that seriously and protect what we have, while also rolling out more.
Henry Tufnell
I thank my hon. Friend for making that point. The Government need to use every avenue they can to boost connectivity, and working with farmers and landowners is essential to make that happen.
May I conclude by asking the Minister what steps his Department is taking to ensure that this money is being reinvested in supporting constituencies like mine, so that no rural community is left behind?
Torcuil Crichton (Na h-Eileanan an Iar) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Mid and South Pembrokeshire (Henry Tufnell) for securing this important debate, and I thank him and the Minister for allowing me to be part of the discussion.
Resilience is the definition of island living, but in Na h-Eileanan an Iar recently we have encountered major problems with connectivity thanks to the move from copper line to digital. It means that when the power goes out, as it did in Harris recently, so do the telephone lines, the mobile phones and the internet connection. The digital back-up provided to vulnerable customers—a hybrid battery pack—simply is not adequate. Provision is patchy, to say the least, understanding of the system is limited and in any case a four-hour or one-hour battery pack is no good in a 48-hour storm, particularly when the mobile phone mast has no battery or diesel back-up either.
To find answers to this connectivity problem, along with Donald MacKinnon, the MSP for Na h-Eileanan an Iar, and the South Harris community council, I convened a resilience meeting last Friday—irony of ironies, it was the day of the Microsoft outage, but the telephone companies and digital service providers were none the less able to attend. It was very useful and a good template for community resilience. Solutions are being found. The community is rising to the challenge, dusting off old preparedness documents and finding first responders who will go out when the digital signal goes down. It is a work in progress. It requires commitment from communities, but it also requires commitment and obligations from the telecoms providers.
Under the Civil Contingencies Act 2004, telecoms providers are category 2 responders. They are required by the Government and Ofcom, as the right hon. Member for Orkney and Shetland (Mr Carmichael) pointed out, to ensure network security, maintain uninterrupted access to 999 emergency services and provide emergency power back-ups to vulnerable users.
There are two things the Minister could commit to today. One is to ensure proper enforcement of those requirements, so that mobile masts have generator or battery back-up themselves and the battery pack that goes to consumers is not simply a box in a black plastic wrapper that is left unopened in a vulnerable consumer’s house. Phone companies should be obliged to give one-to-one instructions and reassurance, to ensure that vulnerable customers—who often rely on an emergency care button, as my hon. Friend the Member for Stirling and Strathallan (Chris Kane) pointed out—know how to operate those battery packs.
Secondly, and most importantly, it is vital that phone companies and mobile phone mast providers are forced to come to the table and to be part of the response in an emergency or an outage. I would like to see the Civil Contingencies Act changed so that phone companies become category 1 responders and are required to attend local and national resilience meetings and be embedded in civil contingency responses. That way, the mobile phone mast companies will be there with everyone else in the room ahead of the storm, maybe in the same Land Rover as the power companies going out and fixing the masts after the storm, to ensure that our rural and island communities stay connected in the worst that the weather can throw at us, because, as everyone knows, the weather we have now is the best weather we are going to see in our lifetime.
It is great to have you in the Chair for this debate, Mr Turner. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Mid and South Pembrokeshire (Henry Tufnell) on securing it: the tenacity with which he has continued to push the issue in his constituency has been of great benefit to every rural constituency across the country. I hope that the news from Virgin Media O2 that broke just as we walked into this Chamber, about what is happening in Tenby, is a direct result of this debate being on the agenda, and that the company has moved quickly because of it. Hopefully, those 10 mobile sites will help the 5,000 people in Tenby, as well as all the visitors who go there.
My hon. Friend is right to say that access to high-quality, reliable and secure digital connectivity is not a luxury, but part of the internal fabric of everything that we do. It is as important as energy and water, as interventions from hon. Members representing constituencies across the country have shown. It is how people stay in touch, how businesses grow and how the opportunities of the modern economy spread to every part of the country. If an area does not have connectivity as good as we would expect anywhere in the country, it could be hampered in economic growth. The Prime Minister has challenged us all to deliver good growth in every postcode. For that, we need good connectivity in every postcode, because it underpins what we need to do on our economy.
The impact on communities of poor mobile connectivity, which my hon. Friend laid out, should not be underestimated. For most of us, staying connected to modern life starts with the phone in our pocket—although the phone signal in my flat in central Edinburgh is dreadful, so maybe my hon. Friend the Member for Edinburgh South West (Dr Arthur) needs to stop campaigning against phone masts. What matters to people is whether they can make calls for work, use data reliably, access services, stay connected to others and have that security blanket that we have heard about in relation to the emergency services and the emergency call buttons that elderly people use.
I understand that my hon. Friend the Member for Mid and South Pembrokeshire has experienced very poor coverage in his constituency, but there is positive work going on. Perhaps I could share some of it with him, because it is recent and is not yet reflected in the Ofcom coverage statistics, which are about six or seven months behind. BT has eight mast upgrades planned in his constituency, two of which will be completed this year and the remaining six next year. I do not know whether he was aware of that. We have already spoken about what Virgin Media O2 is doing in Tenby centre. He was right to say that only 1% of his constituency has stand-alone 5G, but the figures from Vodafone tell us that 50% should now have it through the Vodafone network, and Vodafone plans to take that to over 90% within the next 18 months. It would be interesting to get feedback from my hon. Friend on that after this debate.
We fully understand that the experience on the ground does not necessarily reflect the figures that Ofcom uses and that there is a lag in those figures, but it seems to me that there is significant progress, and that is down to the tenacity of my hon. Friend.
Much progress has also been made in my constituency. With that in mind, the Minister will be aware of concerns about the digital switchover of the old copper landlines. I appreciate that the January 2027 deadline is an industry one, but is there a way of extending it for mobile notspots so that the landline is decommissioned only when the mobile signal has arrived?
I will come back to that point later, if I may, because a number of hon. Members have raised the switchover, particularly in relation to 2G connectivity, but the hon. Gentleman is right to raise it. We have big ambitions on connectivity and are having to work very closely with the industry to make sure that they are delivered. I think everyone in this debate, including the Government, is of the same view: we need to get this sorted, and as quickly as possible.
By 2030, we want people across the UK to see tangible improvements in connectivity in their everyday life, and we want economic growth and opportunity to be more widely shared. As part of that, we have ambitions for high-quality stand-alone 5G connectivity everywhere by 2030—in villages and rural communities, as well as towns and cities—and that must be delivered commercially, without Government subsidy. All three mobile network operators have committed to significant investment plans that align with those ambitions. Hearing local constituents’ experiences through their representatives in this place is how we can determine whether it is being rolled out, and rolled out quickly enough. We fully share the ambitions to push on as quickly as possible and to see those deadlines not as a target but as the backstop, with everything done much more quickly.
Although stand-alone 5G is already available outside 93% of premises across the UK, we understand that we need to go much further, particularly in constituencies such as Mid and South Pembrokeshire, and we continue to work with operators to support that.
Chris Kane
In Cowie in my constituency, there is one street that does not get any signal, while the rest of the village does. When people get a taxi home, the taxi driver will not drop them off at their door, because they cannot get the mobile payment to operate. Delivery drivers also get lost. Even within villages, there can be single streets that do not get connectivity, so we need to look at this at a granular level as well.
That is really important for the economy and businesses. It is not just about the streets in my hon. Friend’s constituency; if a cab parks in a car park and there is no connectivity, they cannot take payment, which is great for the passenger but not necessarily for the driver. That is why it is so important for the economy and for everything to be connected in a way that feeds into everything, from businesses and taxis to emergency responses.
Should we not recognise broadband providers like those to whom I referred in my earlier intervention, who do good work and deliver on all the tasks that they are purposed with, compared with those who are perhaps not as assiduous or as careful when it comes to replying to complaints?
I agree. We see this almost through a rural, topographical or digital inclusion lens, but it is everywhere in the country. Whether we are in central Stirling, in central Edinburgh, which I represent, or in rural Wales or Northern Ireland, there will be notspots, so we have to make sure that there is coverage everywhere. It is about quality coverage and about having resilience in that coverage.
Despite all that, the Government acknowledge that there are still areas with no access to mobile connectivity at all. Technological developments such as direct-to-device satellite technology are a potential solution; some platforms already offer that. In fact, I saw an O2 advert on Channel 4 last night that was advertising its new contracts for direct-to-device satellite technology. Lessons have been learned from the delivery of the shared network programme, which is hugely successful and has demonstrated where there are better solutions that can be used, including in high deployment areas. Developments in the market are very positive, but I fully understand the pressure to make sure that we can get it done.
I will touch on the PSTN switch-off and the issues raised by my hon. Friend the Member for Stirling and Strathallan (Chris Kane) and others. The digital switchover was a major undertaking that started almost a decade ago. It is already improving resilience and reliability. Over 96% of the original 35 million landlines have already been migrated from analogue to digital. In November 2024, the Government secured additional measures to protect customers. The safeguards include prioritising the identification of vulnerable multiple communication customers, free engineer visits and free battery back-up devices. In the event of a power outage, digital service providers of fibre are much more resilient than traditional copper landlines.
Alison Bennett
About six months ago, I received a letter from Baroness Lloyd saying that the gigabit broadband project, which was providing a Government subsidy to get broadband connected to rural areas, was being re-scoped. Can the Minister provide an update on that?
Although the Building Digital UK project should cover 99% of the country by 2032, that is still the ambition. We are now turning our attention to the last 1%. There are the same challenges with mobile connectivity. How do we get that last 1%? Are there technological solutions today? Will there be technological solutions by 2032 that allow us to close that gap? What do we need to do? These will be the very hardest geographical places to reach. As technology is moving all the time, there are ways in which we can resolve that last 1%, but the Government’s target is 99% coverage through Project Gigabit by 2032, and we are on track to deliver that.
On emergency calling, it is essential that everyone, particularly those who are most vulnerable, can connect to the emergency services when they need to. There are protections in place to make sure that they can. Ofcom rules require communications providers to ensure customers can access emergency services in a power cut, as we have heard, including providing a solution such as battery back-up free of charge to customers who rely solely on a landline.
Torcuil Crichton
I thank the Minister for highlighting what I said earlier. The hard evidence from consumers in my constituency is that when the power is off the battery packs do not last long enough, and the battery packs are in the houses. The digital phone mast has no battery to keep it going. They are pointless. Ofgem has to regulate the phone companies and make sure there are digital back-ups.
I am grateful for that example and for the other practical examples that we have heard from around the country. If my hon. Friend writes to me on that issue, we will take it away. I am also keen to look at the change from category 2 to category 1 for emergencies, because he is right that if the connectivity goes down, the phone companies should be part of that process, along with energy and other service responders. Of course, there is never any bad weather in his constituency, so he may not need to call upon them as much as others.
Several hon. Members raised mobile site resilience. In June, Ofcom strengthened its guidance for mobile operators to protect against the risk of severe loss during power cuts. Although mobile phone networks are generally resilient, they can be disrupted by events such as severe weather—we have heard about that happening on a number of occasions—and the loss of power to mast sites, which my hon. Friend spoke about. Communications providers have a statutory obligation to ensure that their networks and services remain available. If that is not happening, I ask Members to please let me know as the Minister and to report that to the regulator. Communications providers are required to report significant incidents directly to Ofcom, which has the power to investigate, rectify and penalise communications providers for any infringement of their duties. Those practical examples are really useful for the regulator and the Government.
Island communities have a further level of resilience threat, as the cable to the island can break. When will we hear detail on what the Government will do to increase protection for undersea cables?
Legislation on undersea cables is on its way, and it will be part of that process. We have announced that that will be coming forward relatively shortly, and I hope to engage with the right hon. Gentleman, who is from the furthest-away island community, to determine what that should look like.
Let me answer some of the questions from my hon. Friend the Member for Mid and South Pembrokeshire. He asked about money being reinvested from BT back into the network. In the telecoms access review, Ofcom asked BT to clearly identify the income associated with copper recovery in its accounting system. That will ensure that those profits are taken into account when the regulator sets the level of charge controls on certain wholesale products. However, the regulator and the Government do not directly intervene in the ways in which BT spends those profits, but at least there will be transparency about how it is done. Ofcom will take that into account when it looks at BT’s spending. BT and the two other big suppliers have massive investment plans and we need to ensure they are delivering them as quickly as possible.
I do not know whether I have any other questions to answer. I want to take up the challenge from my hon. Friend about the completion date of 2028 for the new mast. Perhaps we can have a further discussion about that to see whether there is anything we can do to push for the infrastructure to be built more quickly.
Dave Robertson
I will be very brief. I am really concerned about notices to quit and access to those sites in the long term. Will the Minister look at whatever the evidence says needs to be looked at, including the electronic communications code, if that is where the data points?
We are certainly examining that at the moment. The mobile market review is looking at all aspects of connectivity across the country. When we have these debates and issues are raised, we will take them back examine them very closely.
I am grateful to my hon. Friend the Member for Mid and South Pembrokeshire for securing this debate. We will continue to debate these issues, because Members want to represent their constituents and inform the Government of where the notspots and resilience issues are. We will take those issues away because we want to resolve them. Connectivity is an issue for all of us. The Government’s ambition is clear: we want the whole country to be connected. The Prime Minister has told Ministers and the Government that he wants growth in every postcode, and that can be delivered only through connectivity in every postcode. That is the Government’s ambition.
Question put and agreed to.
(1 day, 7 hours ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
Andy MacNae (Rossendale and Darwen) (Lab)
I beg to move,
That this House has considered Government support for reindustrialisation.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Efford. I thank the Minister for being here today and for all his work in this vital area. I also thank colleagues across the House who have come to contribute to this debate.
I warmly welcome the vision for reindustrialisation laid out by the Prime Minister: a Britain that once again makes more things in more places. That hugely popular ambition has strong support across the parliamentary Labour party. Today, Members across the House have the opportunity to colour in that vision by explaining what reindustrialisation means for our communities and how we can translate that into action.
For me, that begins in Rossendale and Darwen. Our towns helped to develop and power the industrial revolution. Our mills, factories and workshops supplied goods to Britain and the world. They provided skilled employment, prosperity and a sense of community. Great manufacturing businesses still exist in Rossendale and Darwen, yet far more have been lost, and with them we have lost a sense of opportunity and purpose. Sadly, that story is repeated across the country. Since 2006, we have lost more than 1 million jobs in our production industries—good jobs, in the places that needed them most. We see the consequences in our divisive politics, our rising health and welfare costs and our vulnerability to international turbulence.
We need to be clear that the deindustrialisation experienced over those years was not an inevitable result of global competition, so much as a deliberate shift towards a city-centric, service sector-led, trickle-down economic model that, to all intents and purposes, gave up on our towns. It deindustrialised places as economic engines and treated them simply as problems to be managed and as reliant on handouts.
Reindustrialisation offers the possibility of a different future: one that values every place and every person and recognises that good growth is about far more than national GDP. To explore that future, I will organise my remarks around three questions: why we need reindustrialisation, what it should mean and how we deliver it.
On the first two questions—the why and what—making more things in more places means secure, well-paid work, stronger communities and a more resilient country. That is a deeply Labour vision. It resonates powerfully in my constituency and is hugely popular across the country, with 80% of people supporting increased manufacturing and production nationally. That is why we established ReRG, the Reindustrialisation Research Group, which brings together about 100 MPs to support the Prime Minister’s vision and help to translate it into action.
People recognise intuitively that jobs in manufacturing are better paid and more secure than those in many other sectors. That is ever more true as we move into a world with artificial intelligence. Technology may enhance but will not replace skilled manufacturing jobs. With those jobs comes a sense of community and purpose. In places like Rossendale and Darwen, we have real pride in the things we make. When we are given a level playing field and make the most of our great strengths, technology and innovation, British businesses can compete with anyone.
There remains huge potential in British manufacturing, enhanced by our world-leading universities, yet for too long we have followed a laissez-faire orthodoxy that has given up on too many places and has simply accepted deindustrialisation as a price that we must pay. We now see the real cost: the billions spent on subsidising low pay, tackling youth worklessness, responding to poor health and repairing neglected infrastructure. The Milburn report, which was published this week, brings all those issues into stark focus. Reindustrialisation clearly has a key role to play in addressing the NEET crisis and delivering jobs where we need them the most.
The rationale for reindustrialisation goes wider. Our dogged and persistent inflation level is ultimately a production challenge. Our current account deficit, which reached £94 billion in 2025, means that our currency is weaker than if our economy was in balance. Given our dependence on food, energy and manufacturing imports, that depreciation has pushed up the cost of everyday living. Reindustrialisation can play a role in rebalancing our economy.
Another major prize is national resilience. A country cannot be truly resilient if it has little control over the things on which it fundamentally depends, such as energy, steel, fuels, chemicals, critical minerals and food. Recent global shocks have exposed the danger of assuming that Britain will always be able to purchase everything it needs from somewhere else. Reindustrialisation offers us the opportunity to rebuild our foundational industries and, with them, our economic security. A resilient economy, in which we make more of the things that we need to be secure while creating the conditions for good businesses to start, compete and grow in every part of the country, seems a pretty attractive destination.
This is absolutely not a return to the ’70s. Reindustrialisation is about taking pride in what we do well, leveraging the power of technology and innovation, and delivering a level playing field on which our businesses can compete, no matter where they are.
I congratulate my hon. Friend on securing this important debate. He is talking not only about traditional industries, but about the opportunity to innovate. New technologies could complement those industries, as well as standing firmly on their own two feet, and could contribute to reindustrialisation or new industrialisation in areas like Great Grimsby and Cleethorpes. For example, not only is the Viking CCS project a good thing in and of itself, but it will assist with jobs in refining and gas production, enabling them to decarbonise and to continue for many years to come.
Andy MacNae
Absolutely. My hon. Friend makes an important point: our carbon agenda is a massive reindustrialisation opportunity. Making the things that we need to power that transition is hugely important. The transition already supports hundreds of thousands of jobs in our economy. We have to grasp that opportunity with both hands, not see it as a threat.
Fundamentally, reindustrialisation is about the great British companies of the future. It is about a rebalanced economy that makes the things that we need to be secure. How do we go about delivering it? Let me start by welcoming the modern industrial strategy. It is a key element, supporting our high-growth sectors and successful clusters, recognising the importance of foundation industries, but it cannot and must not be the whole answer. If we are to deliver jobs and growth in every postcode, we need to consider our production economy—manufacturing, food production and mining—as a whole. In doing so, we must recognise that right now our businesses are under intense pressure from high energy costs and state-backed international competition.
Jobs and investment are at risk. We have lost 95,000 manufacturing jobs since 2024 alone, and too many communities have lost those jobs when they could least afford it. We need to address the reality with urgency. The first step towards reindustrialisation must be to halt deindustrialisation. That means further action on industrial energy costs. The Government’s British industrial competitiveness scheme covers 10,000 businesses, taking 25% off their energy bills. That is welcome, but it is a fraction of our production base, and the scheme does not help many of the businesses that need it most. Extending the scheme to all manufacturing would show that we really are on the side of our makers.
Procurement is another area in which swift action is needed. The Government spend £400 billion a year with private businesses. We need to ensure that more of that spending strengthens domestic supply chains, supports good employment and builds productive capacity in Britain while continuing to secure good value for taxpayers. Again, the Government have made very welcome steps in that direction, with action on social value and specific measures on steel, but we could do more. For example, we could bring forward Government spending through procurement accelerator programmes and the co-production of procurement programmes with business.
We could also move more quickly to ensure that businesses can access the finance that they need to grow. The British Business Bank and the National Wealth Fund are powerful institutions welcomed by industry, but we need to address gaps in pre-revenue and early-stage funding, as well as regional cold spots. Alongside all that, we need a clear destination; we need to know where we are going. The Reindustrialisation Research Group has proposed a target of creating 1 million additional jobs in manufacturing, mining and agriculture by 2036. That target would give the Government, industry, trade unions and local leaders a shared objective. It makes clear both the prize and the scale of the task. Such a jobs target might not sit alone; we may need other measures to ensure that they are good jobs in the places that really need them. None the less, an overarching target is needed to turn a broad ambition into a measurable national mission.
Setting a target is not enough. We need to build the state capacity to deliver it. Reindustrialisation cannot sit within one Department while energy, skills, transport, procurement, trade and finance operate in separate silos, nor can it be designed entirely in Whitehall. Local employers, colleges, trade unions and civic leaders understand the opportunities within their economies and understand the barriers preventing them from succeeding. They should be part of figuring out the solution.
The Reindustrialisation Research Group’s paper “Planning for Reindustrialisation” argues that the state needs four capabilities: knowledge of what is happening within firms and supply chains, expertise to turn that intelligence into policy, co-ordination between Departments and across national and local Government, and decisiveness to remove barriers quickly. That could mean a reindustrialisation intelligence centre to identify risks and opportunities before they become crises, supported by an industrial planning directorate and local industrial planning units. It could be backed by a ministerially led delivery board with the authority to break down departmental silos and resolve blockages.
If we are serious about reindustrialisation, we must not simply write a plan; we must build a state capable of delivering it. Having stabilised and set a foundation, we need a long-term policy that matches that ambition. It will not be easy or without up-front cost. Such a policy must address the underlying barriers to reindustrialisation. For instance, it must tackle the causes of high energy costs. We have the highest industrial energy prices in the western world. Reindustrialisation will go nowhere if we cannot address that in the long term, for instance by moving transition and infrastructure costs off bills and restructuring our energy market to address inefficiencies and rent seeking.
We need to go further on procurement to include arm’s length bodies, harnessing the full power of state spending, while also being prepared to address trade barriers and to invest directly in developing the capacity that we need to ensure national resilience.
We need to address skills constraints. Some 34% of manufacturing vacancies are due to a lack of applicants with the right skills. We need to align our skills training and careers system with the needs of business.
We need to deliver a step change in the availability of capital. A production sector creating a million more jobs will need to access very significant amounts of capital— hundreds of billions of pounds—so mobilising the power of our pension funds and incentivising investment in our great British businesses will be vital.
Alongside those national policies and others, we need to harness the power of devolution to address local constraints and deliver place-based support and investment co-designed with industry.
I have three questions for the Minister. First, how can the Government ensure that reindustrialisation reaches towns such as Rossendale and Darwen, rather than becoming another strategy dominated by already successful hotspots? Secondly, what further action can the Government take on industrial energy costs, business finance and public procurement to halt deindustrialisation now? Thirdly, will the Government adopt a clear objective for reindustrialisation? In that regard, what is the Minister’s view on ReRG’s suggestion of a target of 1 million additional jobs in manufacturing, mining and agriculture by 2036? How can such a reindustrialisation target support the creation of the 440,000 jobs identified in the Milburn report as vital to young people’s chances?
Reindustrialisation is about restoring possibility—the possibility that young people can build a good life in the communities where they grew up, that towns written off for decades can again become centres for enterprise and innovation, and that Britain can become more productive, more resilient and more confident about what it contributes to the world. That is the prize before us, and we look forward to working with the Minister to pursue it with urgency and ambition.
Several hon. Members rose—
Order. I remind Members that they should bob if they want to catch my eye. I am imposing a four-minute limit, to try to get everybody in. I call Perran Moon.
Perran Moon (Camborne and Redruth) (Ind)
Meur ras, Mr Efford; it is an honour to serve under your chairship again. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen (Andy MacNae), the chair of the Reindustrialisation Research Group, for securing this important debate.
Despite our proud mining history, Cornwall deindustrialised long before the rest of the country. The result was generational deprivation, seasonal and insecure employment, and weekly wages about £100 below the national average. Today, however, Cornwall stands on the precipice of reindustrialisation at scale, led by our critical minerals industry.
The opportunity for our nascent critical minerals industry is twofold. It offers the chance for Britain not only to reassert its sovereign capability over the green transition and de-risk overly concentrated supply chains, but to create good, productive jobs for Cornish men and women, who have endured years of austerity and under-investment in their life chances.
Reindustrialisation could contribute billions in gross value added to the Cornish economy. In my constituency of Camborne and Redruth, which includes Hayle, the number of young people on unemployment benefit rose by 34% in the last year, which is the 16th highest rise in the country—reindustrialisation could reinvigorate the badly damaged social contract for young people. Imagine Cornish lithium being extracted and processed in Cornwall, used in British electric vehicle batteries made in Bridgwater or on Teesside, and ultimately installed in electric vehicles manufactured in the west midlands. Alternatively, imagine similar domestic supply chains built around Cornish tin or tungsten.
The immediate obstacle is midstream processing, which the Minister has heard about today. At present, Cornish tin, for instance, would need to be exported to east Asia for processing, which would put at risk not only our sovereign resilience but Cornwall’s best chances of generating economic value from our own resources. I will continue to support the work of the Reindustrialisation Research Group. What steps are the Government taking to build domestic processing capacity, to ensure that Cornish communities secure the jobs, skills and lasting prosperity promised by reindustrialisation?
I now turn to my experience of 30 years in the automotive sector, particularly in relation to the proposals from some to dilute the zero emissions vehicle mandate, which would have a serious impact on reindustrialisation. Most Members of Parliament were elected on a manifesto to ban pure petrol and diesel vehicles by 2030. Fewer than one in 10 new vehicles registered in the UK are built in the UK and subject to the ZEV mandate. Diluting the ZEV mandate to 50% could lead to an increase in demand for petrol equivalent to more than double the Rosebank annual output.
Between July 2025 and July 2026, manufacturers spent £3.1 billion on discounting electric vehicles, but £7.6 billion on discounting petrol, diesel and hybrid vehicles. Today, average discounts are higher on petrol and hybrids than on electric vehicles. EV demand is up 27% year on year. Even based on the current growth rates, sales would hit 70% by 2030.
Weakening the ZEV mandate does not address the fundamental automotive sector issues: growing global competition, trade barriers and the influx of subsidised Chinese products. Reindustrialisation means focusing on supporting an industry in the process of massive transition, not burying our heads in the sand and hoping that consumers will continue to buy the volumes of petrol and diesel vehicles that they have historically. They simply will not.
Brian Leishman (Alloa and Grangemouth) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mr Efford. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen (Andy MacNae) for securing the debate.
The Prime Minister’s diagnosis is absolutely correct: four decades of bad political decisions have failed communities like mine. But having the correct diagnosis is the easy bit, as is his promising me that he will come to Grangemouth and hear the scale of the issues facing my community. When he does come, he must be ready to deliver the actions that will positively transform communities like mine.
With past industrial issues at Grangemouth, the Prime Minister has inherited a debt to the people of my constituency. In Keir Starmer’s speech to the Scottish Labour conference in February 2025, he committed £200 million to building a new industrial future in Grangemouth. Twenty-one months on, not a penny of that has been spent. The easy narrative is that that is all down to politicians, but there is the political will to deliver new industry and jobs in Grangemouth, and I know that the Minister will agree. I thank the Minister for replying to a letter of mine earlier this week, saying that the National Wealth Fund’s criteria that projects must reach have not been met. That, plus preparatory groundworks, is what is required to unlock the £200 million. Will the Government therefore revise the National Wealth Fund’s criteria and reassess the requirements to release funding, so we can get new industry and jobs into Grangemouth? Does the Minister have an update on those preparatory works?
What is stopping us from using our funds to rebuild Grangemouth and create a new industrial revolution under Government ownership? Grangemouth people are sick to the back teeth of private capital and foreign Governments closing sites, making hundreds of workers redundant and weakening Scotland’s manufacturing base, economy and national security. The Minister knows that any Government, of any party, carry tremendous social responsibility. As the Prime Minister rightly said, four decades of deindustrialisation, deregulation and privatisation have led to enormous geographical, economic and societal inequalities.
People like me—socialists—have always considered nationalisation to be an essential method of transforming society for the better. We have seen private companies own vital industry and act as if they have no responsibility to workers—as if citizens are mere consumers. Private capital often feels no accountability. Will the Minister detail what the Government are doing to challenge Syngenta’s departure from Grangemouth? It is my understanding that the consultation is in name only. The only proposal put forward by Syngenta is closure and 377 redundancies. What are the Government doing to save those jobs?
For decades, we have been in the grip of an industrial depression controlled by private capital and multinational corporations. The Prime Minister needs a fresh industrial strategy that puts the need of working-class people first. Part of that should include public—Government—ownership.
Antonia Bance (Tipton and Wednesbury) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Efford. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen (Andy MacNae) on securing this important debate.
In 1712, Thomas Newcomen built the world’s first steam pump at Conygre colliery, and that was it—the industrial revolution, and it started in Tipton. Chainworks, foundries and tube mills gave generations a decent living, until they didn’t. Manufacturing still accounts for a quarter of employment in Sandwell, with 1,000 firms employing 21,000 people. Today I want to pay particular tribute to my friend Mike Warner, who has just celebrated 60 years at J. H. Lavender, which casts aluminium components for automotive and other supply chains. Congratulations, Mike!
I am here today to argue for the towns that sent me here. I am here to argue for a hard stop to deindustrialisation, for reindustrialisation to be understood as production and for the Government to build on the industrial strategy and get Britain making again. The argument for reindustrialisation is not nostalgic. No one thinks we should reopen the mines—except perhaps the mines in Cornwall—or return to mass production; it is about making sure that Britain builds the products and technologies of the future.
Recent shocks have shown the importance of domestic capability in strategic industries and if we want the jobs and growth that come from the net zero transition, we must build things here. That is why reindustrialisation matters—because towns like mine want to create wealth, not watch it created somewhere else, and because once skills, supply chains and investment leave a place, rebuilding them is hard.
I want to focus on a few areas where I hope Ministers can go a little further. This Government deserve credit for putting industry back at the heart of economic policy through the modern industrial strategy, but I believe Ministers need to be more interventionist. To be fair, this Government have shown more willingness to intervene than any Government in years, which is particularly important to us, given that Speciality Steel is based in Wednesbury, but now we need more.
We should champion new investment and direct public finances into industrial towns, not simply where the spreadsheet says the return is highest. We should work with unions and employers to keep productive capacity in the UK however we can. The industrial strategy is not just for the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade; it should be the economic strategy of the whole Government. Too often one Department tries to grow British industry, while another makes decisions that undermine it. This is the whole Government’s job.
The No. 1 issue that manufacturers raise with me is energy costs. Ours are double those in Europe, and more than anything else they are why firms do not grow here and companies do not invest here. The British industrial competitiveness scheme will be a lifeline, but it is only for 10,000 manufacturers, and we should urgently expand it to all manufacturing.
Automotive is an £18 billion industry, a huge source of jobs and an anchor for the supply chain, but it is too difficult to make cars profitably in the UK. No one disputes the 2035 target, but it will be a hollow victory if we hit the ZEV targets through imports while UK plants close. We need to reduce the ZEV mandate target to 50%, place tariffs on state-sponsored Chinese EVs, and ensure that rules of origin and “made in Europe” requirements do not hit UK car making.
Tipton was there at the start of the industrial revolution. The challenge for this Government is to ensure that places like mine help to lead the next one.
Jodie Gosling (Nuneaton) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Efford. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen (Andy MacNae) for securing this important debate.
Nuneaton has a rich industrial history, in common with the rest of the west midlands, from brickworks and textiles to the mining communities that helped power our country for decades. That legacy has left us with an innovative, talented workforce with a strong work ethic and an enduring sense of pride. The foundations for success remain, but the infrastructure and investment required have been severely lacking.
There have been too many missed opportunities that have left communities like mine behind. The impact of the post-industrial legacy is felt across my town in all aspects: high streets, council finances, crime statistics, educational attainment, roads, housing and connectivity. The low skills base and low incomes are cited as driving factors in all my areas of high deprivation. Effective reindustrialisation in my town will end the decline caused for so long by under-investment. It will unlock the potential that exists in towns like Nuneaton across the country.
It is so hopeful to hear the Prime Minister and the Chancellor of the Exchequer laying out this agenda, backing cutting-edge reindustrialisation for the future, recognising the enormous potential of backing British business and skilled labour markets, and leading world innovation. This is key to the task of delivering on the modern industrial strategy, the 10-year plan, and bringing back hope to our communities.
In communities such as mine, there are companies leading the innovation. The chemicals production firm Univar in my constituency produces coolants and antifreeze products for the aerospace industry, yet it is locked out of schemes like BICS, which could help to secure the jobs and value added in our supply chains to support the innovations that we need in these critical industries. The supply chains and the critical raw materials that they produce are essential to driving wider industrial investment. The chemicals industry has lost £4.7 billion in economic value since 2021. The companies look elsewhere for their procurement; they go where there are advantages abroad.
Alongside colleagues from the Reindustrialisation Research Group, I wrote to Ministers to ask that BICS be extended to cover all areas, including research and development and other companies associated with these strong industries. I ask this Minister to update us today on what economic assessments have been done of potential growth that has been missed in those areas that we could be supporting with a wider BICS. I also ask the Minister to update us in his summing up on how this priority will be delivered across all Government areas and embedded in all policy. Who will be responsible for delivering, and how will we know when it has been a success?
Several hon. Members rose—
Order. After Sureena Brackenridge, the time limit on speeches will have to go down to three and a half minutes.
Sureena Brackenridge (Wolverhampton North East) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Efford. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen (Andy MacNae) for securing this important debate. Reindustrialisation matters enormously to places such as Wolverhampton and Willenhall, where manufacturing and engineering are part of our proud heritage and, importantly, are part of securing our industries of the future, too. We are known across the Black Country for having a skilled workforce who are not afraid of graft, and for established manufacturers and growing businesses. But we want them to grow further, and I have identified three practical challenges and barriers.
The first is energy costs. British manufacturers are paying far more for electricity than many of their international competitors. Research presented to the Reindustrialisation Research Group suggests that matching French electricity prices could save British manufacturers £5 billion to £6 billion a year. I welcome the British industrial competitiveness scheme, but too many manufacturers are still excluded. Extending eligibility from 10,000 to another 60,000 to 70,000 engineering firms would be a significant step forward. I ask the Minister to look at how we can widen BICS so that smaller engineering firms and manufacturers in places such as mine get the support they need.
The second is skills. The 2024 employer skills survey found that 34% of manufacturing vacancies were due to a lack of applicants with the right skills. However, engineering and manufacturing apprenticeships have at best stumbled over the last decade. We need to support the work of our mayor, Richard Parker, with a place-based strategy to connect our schools, colleges and employers much more closely and make better use of apprenticeship funding. Our young people need to see that there are good careers and real opportunities right on their doorstep.
The third is how we spend public money through British procurement. The Government spend about £394 billion with the private sector, yet research suggests that about £56 billion of procurement contracts by value go to foreign suppliers. When we invest in infrastructure, defence and major projects, we should be doing more to create opportunities for British manufacturers.
Adam Dance (Yeovil) (LD)
Yeovil has also been reindustrialising. Leonardo and other cutting-edge defence firms are doing amazing work, and Yeovil College has become a national centre of excellence for defence. Does the hon. Member agree the Government need to build on that by supporting small defence start-ups to come to Yeovil to take advantage of our manufacturing base and talent? That would be a win for our communities, the economy and national defence.
Sureena Brackenridge
I certainly agree with the hon. Gentleman, because place-based strategies will unlock the potential that is on the ground and the doorstep.
I want to bring this back to Wolverhampton North East. As the Minister introduces the industrial strategy and the 10-year plan, I urge him to look at what is happening in our area. The green innovation corridor offers real opportunities to bring investment, innovation and skilled jobs right into our region, but we need to make sure that my major employers and local small and medium-sized enterprises in our aerospace, defence and engineering supply chains benefit, that training meets the needs of employers on the factory floor and that apprenticeship funding is accessible.
Wolverhampton North East has always played a critical part in delivering Britain’s industrial renewal, but I want to see more of my local businesses confident to invest and grow and for young people to be equipped with the skills they need for the industries not just of today but of the future.
Alison Hume (Scarborough and Whitby) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Efford. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen (Andy MacNae) for securing this important debate. When we talk about reindustrialising Britain, we are talking about places like Scarborough and Whitby. Yes, mine is a beautiful constituency with a wonderful tourist offer, but we are also full of talent, ambition and potential. We have a proud industrial heritage, and today we are helping to build Britain’s future.
We are home to William Hare, a world-class steel fabricator that supplied steelwork for the turbine halls and control rooms at Hinkley Point C. Its contract at Sizewell C involves 550 tonnes of steel fabricated in Scarborough. We also have Alexander Dennis, one of the country’s leading electric bus manufacturers. It supplies buses to some of the country’s largest operators and combined authorities, and it employs more than 700 people in my constituency.
Last year, Schneider Electric opened a new manufacturing site in Scarborough. Its £42 million investment has created more than 200 jobs manufacturing low-voltage switchgear, and only recently, I was proud to welcome my hon. Friend the Minister on a visit to Woodsmith mine, operated by Anglo American near Whitby. This remarkable project has the potential to make Britain a major global polyhalite fertiliser producer and has already contributed nearly £2 billion to the regional economy.
The message is clear: businesses are backing Scarborough, and that is why reindustrialisation matters so much. I echo the comments made by hon. Members about energy costs. Can we urgently review the sector’s product rules? Our steel fabricators need the Government on their side. We charge a 50% tariff on covered steel imports once the tariff-free quota is exhausted, yet imported finished steelwork falls outside those restrictions. That creates a real risk that we could end up making it cheaper to do the work overseas and simply import the finished structure, exporting skilled jobs in the process.
I support action to protect British steelmaking, but where British steel suppliers cannot supply the grades or quantities our manufacturers need, will the Government consider adjusting import quotas so that businesses can buy essential inputs without facing the additional tariff? Will the Government bring forward the steel review and address the gap that could make it cheaper to fabricate overseas and import the finished structure, taking skilled work out of Britain? Who, and which Department, is leading on the vision in Government? If we get this right, we can create good jobs, stronger local economies and lasting growth in every postcode.
Josh Newbury (Cannock Chase) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mr Efford. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen (Andy MacNae) not only for securing this debate, but for convening and leading the Reindustrialisation Research Group, which is spearheading work in this vital area.
Cannock Chase knows better than most the consequences of industrial decline and the devastating impact it can have on people and the places they call home. For generations coalmining was at the heart of the local economy in my towns and villages, providing skilled, well-paid employment and supporting entire communities, but under Margaret Thatcher a whole industry was dismantled. Communities like ours paid the price, losing not just jobs but skills, investment, supply chains, a proud identity and economic security.
Reindustrialisation must be about building the industries, skills and opportunities of the future, which I have seen at first hand in businesses across my constituency, including Wilbar Components and Key Precision, which both work primarily with steel and are excellent examples of manufacturing expertise. Wilbar has been producing precision components in metals and plastics with expertise in computer numerical control turning and milling since 1981. It supplies industries including oil and gas, hydraulics and motorsport. Its main business is in the fixings used for headstones, and it supplies funeral directors right across Britain. Key Precision specialises in precision engineering, including five-axis CNC machining, and it supplies industries ranging from automotive to defence, medical and telecommunications.
Those are businesses with specialist machinery, a highly experienced workforce and technical expertise. They are keen to expand and are exactly the sort of businesses that we should be backing, but they face some hefty challenges, one being the cost and availability of raw materials, particularly steel. I welcome the action the Government have taken to support British steelmaking, such as the new steel strategy, investment through the National Wealth Fund and the introduction of a 50% tariff on steel imports above the new quotas, which will help to protect domestic production from unfair international competition.
British manufacturers such as Wilbar and Key Precision need the right materials of the right quality at a price that allows them to compete. There is an issue of specialist grades, sizes or types of steel not being available in Britain. If tariffs increase the cost of those materials, businesses are left to absorb extra cost, pass it on to customers or risk losing contracts to overseas competitors. The kicker is that completed components are not subject to the tariffs announced, so very low-cost products could come in from places such as south-east Asia. We must protect British steel production, but also make sure that the action we take does not inadvertently disadvantage British manufacturers.
As we have heard, there are other barriers to growth, including skill shortages. Around 34% of manufacturing vacancies have been reported as difficult to fill because applicants lack the necessary skills or qualifications. Businesses such as Wilbar and Key Precision need engineers and machinists who understand increasingly sophisticated manufacturing processes, so we need to make sure that young people see a route into those careers and that colleges are working closely with employers. I welcome the youth guarantee. Following the Milburn report, the Government will invest in a new settlement for young people. We must connect them with real opportunities in their own communities, including the skilled jobs being created by manufacturers.
Ultimately, reindustrialisation requires investment, a skilled workforce, competitive energy costs, access to markets and an understanding of the realities facing businesses. I know the level of expertise and specialist work taking place in my constituency. We should be rightly proud of that and do everything we can to back it.
Mr Jonathan Brash (Hartlepool) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Efford. For more than a century, towns like Hartlepool were the beating heart of British industry. We built the ships that sailed the world, forged the steel that built our cities, bridges and railways, and manufactured the products that powered our economy. Generations of working people took enormous pride in knowing that their skills, industries and communities were fundamental to the success of this country.
Then, over the course of a single generation, that industrial inheritance was squandered, sold off and sold out. A globalist mindset driven by a narrow neoliberal agenda decided that it was cheaper to make things elsewhere than to make them here. Our industries were sacrificed, our factories closed, our skilled jobs disappeared and communities that helped build Britain’s wealth were left to pick up the pieces. We lost more than jobs; we lost apprenticeships, opportunities and the confidence that our children could enjoy a better future than their parents. We lost the sense that we mattered.
However, that does not have to be our future, because something extraordinary is happening in Hartlepool. We have an opportunity to reindustrialise our town, rebuild our manufacturing base and create the skilled, well-paid jobs that generations of our community have been crying out for. And it is not a distant ambition—it is happening right now. We have Strabag investing in our industrial future with one of the most advanced tunnelling manufacturing factories in the world, JDR Cables manufacturing the infrastructure needed to support our energy industry, and Tata Steel and Corinth Pipeworks continuing the proud tradition of steel and pipe manufacturing that has defined Hartlepool for generations. We also have the extraordinary investment in new nuclear in Hartlepool led by Centrica and X-energy.
Together, these investments represent an enormous opportunity: billions of pounds in investment, thousands of new jobs, new supply chains and the chance to put Hartlepool at the forefront of Britain’s industrial and energy future. However, reindustrialisation does not simply mean building a power station or opening a factory; it means rebuilding the entire industrial ecosystem around those investments, and it means making sure the jobs, contracts, skills and economic benefits flow into the communities that host them.
I have always argued that the last Conservative Government’s levelling-up agenda was the right diagnosis with the wrong prescription. Asking left-behind communities to compete against each other for pots of money to fund superficial improvements was never going to reverse decades of economic decline. We cannot just improve the places we have left behind; we need to restore their economic power. We need to give towns like Hartlepool the opportunity to produce, manufacture, innovate and drive the British economy again. That means backing not just the businesses of the future, but the businesses we already have.
Finally, in the debate on Rosebank last week, I mentioned the “British worker test” that any reindustrialisation in this country must pass. Does it create good jobs for our communities? Does it strengthen our domestic supply chain? Does it develop the skills and capabilities we need as a country? Are British businesses and British workers actually getting a fair share of the opportunities they create? That is the test I set for this Government for reindustrialisation. It is what Hartlepool demands.
Gurinder Singh Josan (Smethwick) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Efford. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen (Andy MacNae) for securing the debate. I welcome the Government’s commitment to reindustrialisation, particularly when it comes to prioritising sovereign capability in key sectors.
I recently met the Mineral Products Association to talk about cement, which is crucial to reindustrialisation. It underpins the Government’s ambitions for the infrastructure, energy projects, transport links and housing that are needed to deliver growth in every postcode, and the sector supports well-paid jobs. It is strategically vital that cement remains a sovereign capability and not something we come to depend on other nations for.
However, we are becoming increasingly reliant on cement imports. UK cement production has fallen to its lowest level since 1950, while cement imports have tripled over the last 20 years, meaning we are offshoring jobs, investment and emissions. The UK’s cement producers face some of the highest energy costs in the world—around £30 million a year, which importers can avoid. Cement should be included in the energy-intensive industries compensation scheme. Our firms are paying about 50% more for energy than firms in Germany and France, four times as much as firms in the US and three times as much as firms in India and China. The EU’s carbon border adjustment mechanism has created further disparity, incentivising the diversion of more cement imports to the UK, undermining our domestic producers.
Furthermore, cement has been identified by the UK’s emissions trading schemes as the industry most vulnerable to carbon leakage. There is no point disadvantaging our cement producers only to pass on the carbon emissions to a second country, while their producers and workers reap the benefit. The UK carbon border adjustment mechanism is an opportunity to ensure that cement importers pay the same, if not more, for their emissions as our domestic producers.
The UK carbon border adjustment mechanism will also have a significant impact on downstream steel producers. The steel trade measure introduced earlier this year has had a particular impact on downstream companies that import raw materials. Companies such as Pargat Housewares, a large cookware and bakeware manufacturer, has to pay additional carbon-related charges on raw materials imported into the UK, and also has to compete with suppliers who avoid paying those same carbon charges. Our companies can compete, but only on a level playing field. I ask the Minister to carefully consider the impact of the UK’s carbon adjustment mechanism on our manufacturers.
On the ZEV mandate, this morning I met a representative of Toyota, which has 3,000 direct jobs in the UK and 11,000 total jobs. The 80% target for 2030 is not realistic for them; actual demand is around 45%. What are the company’s options? It can reduce sales volumes, further increase EV discounts, purchase credits or make compliance payments. None of those things is in the interest of car manufacturers in the UK or of UK workers. I ask the Minister to reduce the ZEV mandate to 50% by 2030 and give UK car manufacturers the chance to compete on a level playing field.
Finally, I back the TUC’s call to establish a reindustrialisation unit in No. 10 North. I hope that will put reindustrialisation at the forefront of all efforts to deliver a rebalanced economy that will work for all nations and regions.
Lorraine Beavers (Blackpool North and Fleetwood) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Efford. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen (Andy MacNae) on securing this debate.
Deindustrialisation is still an ongoing process across Britain, especially in places such as Blackpool North and Fleetwood. At the end of next month, AGC Chemicals will stop manufacturing at the Hillhouse enterprise zone in my constituency. About 200 skilled people will lose their jobs, some this winter and more through next year. Those are good, well-paid, unionised jobs that will be lost in a place that desperately cannot afford to keep losing them. I am therefore glad that last week the Prime Minister told the House that the 10-year plan will set out a compelling vision for reindustrialisation.
I have three questions for the Minister about how to turn that vision into reality. First, will the Government set a clear jobs target? The Reindustrialisation Research Group has suggested a target of a million more production jobs by 2036. A specific target would generate the necessary co-ordination across Government and tell investors that this Government mean business. Secondly, will the Government make reindustrialisation a clear and central priority? The Prime Minister has said No. 10 North would drive this agenda, but industrial policy involves energy, skills, trade and procurement, and is relevant to almost every aspect of Government.
Thirdly, what more will the Government do to help businesses with energy costs? Our manufacturers pay the highest industrial electricity prices in the western world, yet the British industrial competitive scheme helps only a small minority of them. The Minister knows that many of my Labour colleagues have asked the Chancellor to consider opening the scheme to all manufacturing firms. I ask the Minister to ensure that the Government continue to give that policy the attention it deserves.
Hon. Members know about the ongoing discussions around the Skynet satellite contract. I urge the Government to prioritise existing jobs, skills and supply chains, and to use procurement to strengthen the manufacturing base we already have. The Budget will help families to get through the winter; the 10-year plan has to give them something to work towards: decent jobs close to home through reindustrialising every part of Britain.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Efford. In debates such as this, it is easy to look back at the past. There is no future in our past. In Wales, we often talk about the coalfields and the mines. They are long gone. In their place is a quiet revolution: BAE Systems in Glascoed and General Dynamics in Oakdale and Merthyr are providing high-quality jobs. That is why the defence industry must be part of the modern industrial strategy and I welcome the Government’s plans for that.
The Government have said that they will plug a £4.7 billion gap in defence funding, and have committed to reaching a 3.5% of GDP target by 2035. That is an opportunity for this Government and for communities such as mine that can build a new industrial revolution in the places that have been left behind by Government.
Anna Dixon (Shipley) (Lab)
I recently attended Space Hub Yorkshire, where there were businesses at the forefront of advanced manufacturing and radio frequency. They could be world leaders in the defence and space sector. Does my hon. Friend agree that the Government need to back such businesses and ensure that our young people get the skills they need to access those new opportunities?
My hon. Friend has made my speech for me, so perhaps I should sit down. I absolutely agree that it is cutting-edge technologies in communities famous for their industrial past that are the way forward for our future. That is why I welcome the Chancellor’s announcement that £5 billion will be invested in defence through the British Business Bank and the National Wealth Fund. The Government are making defence an engine for growth in every postcode.
Last year, 24,000 new apprenticeships were created. Those are jobs for young people in the communities where they grew up, providing them with skills, training and employment. Jobs in the defence sector also pay £8,500 more than the average UK salary. If we are to continue to create these opportunities and encourage defence companies to set up all over the UK, we need to ensure that the MOD, which is known for wasting money, spends its money well and delivers projects on time. At the moment, every project is at red. I know that the Minister is not an MOD Minister, but I hope he speaks to the Minister for Defence Readiness and Industry about this issue. We have already seen what happens when it goes wrong—I think of my former constituency of Islwyn, where Ajax was headquartered and where the problems are still ongoing.
We must remember that every pound spent by Government comes out of hard-working taxpayers’ wages, so the caveat must be that Departments do not have carte blanche to spend what they will, and that includes the MOD. How does the Minister plan to ensure that money is spent well in future projects in defence and other sectors, as the Government implement their modern industrial policy.
Big companies play a vital role in reindustrialisation. I have spoken about BAE Systems, and we could talk about Lockheed Martin or even Leonardo, which was mentioned by the hon. Member for Yeovil (Adam Dance), who is no longer in his place, but we cannot overlook small companies in this country. They, too, play a vital role in industrialisation. Currently, less than 4% of MOD spending goes directly to small and medium-sized businesses, yet their expertise is vital. What I find frustrating—I hope the Minister will also take this up—is that so many small businesses come to me and say that they are working with large companies but are not being paid on time. It is all very well if a company has the profits to cushion late payment, but it can mean a four or five-person company going to the wall, and their expertise going with it—I promise I will wind up in a second, Mr Efford.
We have such a valuable opportunity. There are so many companies in Wales, such as Space Forge in Cardiff, ICOMAT in Gloucester and Tekever in Aberporth. Companies such as these and their innovative ideas need to be supported. How does the Minister plan to support small defence companies to succeed within the wider strategy, and what conversations is he having with the Welsh Government about making defence a priority, including through defence apprenticeships and opportunities in schools? I will finish with this message: we need good jobs, good growth and good companies all across the UK, but especially in constituencies such as mine, which for too long have been left behind. Their voices need to be heard.
Manufacturing directly contributes some £6 billion in output to the Northern Ireland economy, accounting for 13.4% of our total economic output, well above the UK average of 9.8%. Invest NI says that the sector makes a total contribution of over £16 billion, with 97,000 direct jobs. That is the hard-working ethic of Ulstermen and women.
Thales sustains over 1,100 direct jobs in defence and hundreds more in the supply chain, with £100 million pounds of investment and £1.6 billion pounds in contracts, through which the workforce of Northern Ireland contribute by supplying lightweight multi-role missiles to Ukraine. Our workers are directly defending freedom in Europe and securing our sovereign defence capability. Aerospace makes a significant contribution, alongside Harland & Wolff in shipbuilding. All those things show me that Northern Ireland has an incredibly important part to play in this United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. I always say that we are better together, and there is the proof.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Efford. I thank the hon. Member for Rossendale and Darwen (Andy MacNae) for securing this important debate.
Manufacturing is central to economic growth, regional prosperity and investment. It holds a vital place in the UK economy. It is a major driver of innovation and a significant contributor to high-quality job creation. It employs 2.6 million people nationwide and its wages are 8% above the average for the rest of the economy. In June 2025, the Liberal Democrats welcomed the reintroduction of the 10-year industrial strategy, following the reckless abandonment of the key framework by the last Conservative Government. That Government’s decision to scrap the industrial strategy in 2021 was a hugely damaging step. It weakened our economy and added to the chaos and uncertainty of the last Parliament.
We welcome this Government listening to British businesses and reinstating the industrial strategy. It focuses on many of the sectors that the Liberal Democrat strategy prioritised: life sciences, clean energy, professional and business services, and advanced manufacturing such as aerospace and automotive. However, not enough attention has been given to our agrifood industry and rural economy. Agricultural technology was one of the 11 priority sectors in the industrial strategy introduced by the Liberal Democrats when we were in government, and it has now been relegated to a handful of mentions.
We would boost the industrial strategy and pay particular attention to British firms in the critical sectors of the future. That means being more specific about growth opportunities in each region, particularly through clean energy technology and manufacturing, including regenerating ports and supply chains by harnessing the UK’s global leadership in floating offshore wind.
If the Government are serious about backing British business, they must show more ambition on trade with Europe. This week, there is a real opportunity for a reset with Europe. Our proposed growth and defence partnership with the EU includes joining the single market and customs union, which would make the UK richer, safer and stronger.
Make UK has found that nearly 60% of manufacturers welcome the Government’s renewed focus on reindustrialisation. However, its analysis also highlights that nearly two thirds of manufacturers identified employment costs as the main risks to business in 2026, and that 86% expected that those costs would rise over the following 12 months. The Government must scrap their damaging national insurance increase, which hurts jobs and growth, and look instead at the fairer ways of raising revenue that we have set out. We would issue defence bonds worth up to £20 billion over two years for defence capital spending and research and development. That would supercharge our defence industry and create jobs across the nations and regions.
It is very important that R&D is sponsored, supported and driven right across the United Kingdom—not just here in England but in Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales. If we can have the research and development that we hope for in Northern Ireland, we can push for even more jobs and do even better for the economy.
The hon. Gentleman is absolutely right. We need to focus on getting jobs and investment right across the UK, in every region and nation.
The Liberal Democrats would expand the British Business Bank so that viable small and medium-sized businesses have access to capital, and use it to crowd in private investment, particularly in zero-carbon products and technologies.
Measures to bring down some of the highest industrial energy prices in the world, including cutting electricity costs by up to 25% for over 7,000 electricity-intensive firms from 2027, are welcome news for our manufacturers. But business across the whole economy are struggling with high energy prices: 90% of manufacturers surveyed by Make UK reported that their energy bills had risen since 2022. The Liberal Democrats would urgently lower energy costs for households and businesses by decoupling wholesale gas prices from electricity costs, moving policy levies off energy bills, bringing forward backdated payments for the British industrial competitiveness scheme for internationally exposed energy-intensive manufacturers, and, critically, upgrading grid capacity.
While it is all well and good setting out goals and frameworks to boost industrialisation and our domestic manufacturing capabilities, it is vital that we have the people with the right skills to do the jobs. The industrial strategy came with a welcome funding boost, but stops well short of the reform that we need. The Government must accelerate apprenticeship reform and empower Skills England to act as a properly independent body with employers at its heart. The amount that businesses have paid into the apprenticeship levy has increased exponentially over the past decade, yet any business we speak to will tell us that it is a broken system. With 1 million young people out of work and training, we must address this urgently and act upon the findings of the Milburn review. We would implement the Liberal Democrat skills strategy, including skills tax credits, apprenticeship levy reform and a lifelong training grant. We would also establish skills co-operatives so that SMEs can pool training resources and rotate apprentices locally.
For many businesses, reindustrialisation relates to the cost, accessibility and reliability of the steel industry. Steel is a nationally strategic sector: it provides vital materials for our national infrastructure, from defence to renewable energy, and creates thousands of jobs across the UK. We believe in a thriving, privately run steel industry that is supported and empowered by the Government through an effective steel strategy. We need more ambition and clarity in delivering the steel strategy, including through boosting domestic production to meet 50% of domestic steel demand, up from roughly 30% today, and doing much more to incentivise the use of British-made steel in the private sector.
The Liberal Democrats support action to strengthen British steelmaking, but tariffs on specialist steel not produced at scale in the UK will not increase domestic production; they will only increase costs for UK manufacturers. Downstream steel-using industries employ about 300,000 people, compared with around 30,000 in primary steelmaking. A blanket approach risks weakening the far larger manufacturing jobs base while doing little to protect British steel.
Peter Fortune (Bromley and Biggin Hill) (Con)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Efford. I congratulate the hon. Member for Rossendale and Darwen (Andy MacNae) on securing the debate. I thank hon. Members from both sides of the House for their contributions—and for dragging themselves away from the Opposition day debate, which I know must have been very challenging.
There are just under 2.5 million jobs in UK manufacturing—6.7% of all jobs in the UK. Manufacturing generated £59.6 billion in gross value added in the quarter ending June 2026, accounting for 8.3% of the UK’s total GVA. Manufacturing and industry are a key part of our economy, but they are in a perilous position. We have seen the recent news of 4,000 job losses at Britain’s biggest car manufacturer, which underlines that the risk of losing our industrial base could not be clearer. Once these industries are gone, it will be near impossible to get them back. Factories and plants from all sorts of industries are shutting down because of crippling energy policies, £66 billion in tax rises and burdensome red tape such as the Employment Rights Act 2025. There are 176,000 fewer jobs available now than when the Government took office. Our industries need to be supported, but many feel that they are not.
The Government have correctly identified high energy costs as a major obstacle to British manufacturing. We have the highest industrial energy costs in the OECD, which cripple our manufacturing industry and cause it to rapidly deindustrialise, making us depend on imports. The British industrial competitiveness scheme is a central part of the Government’s action to counter this problem and allow for reindustrialisation, but with gas prices 12 times higher than the US NOLA benchmark, and title transfer facility gas—on which ammonia and all other raw materials are produced—at €90 per megawatt-hour, help is needed now. However, the British industrial competitiveness scheme does not even start until next year, and when it finally comes in 2027, it will be a complicated system of exemptions that will help selected businesses.
Antonia Bance
I think the hon. Member has misunderstood the nature of the British industrial competitiveness scheme. The first payments will indeed start next year, but they will be backdated to April this year—a point that he could usefully have made in his speech.
Peter Fortune
I thank the hon. Lady very much: I always accept a helpful intervention. Some might argue that that is too little, too late.
The fact that the scheme will only be available to eligible businesses that use at least 33 MWh of grid-supplied electricity a year raises further concerns. Small businesses —firms with fewer than 50 employees—use up to 25 MWh annually. For microbusinesses, that number is only 15 MWh. That will leave a huge number of businesses still facing uncompetitive costs. We need cheaper electricity for all British industry and manufacturing. Instead, we are leaving the underlying problem unresolved. The Opposition have a plan to deliver cheap power for every business, removing carbon taxes and subsidies that add costs for industry and reduce competitiveness.
The Government’s strategic sites accelerator scheme is intended to assist and accelerate the development of strategic investment sites across the UK. It was announced as part of the UK’s modern industrial strategy in August 2025. Since then, the scheme has met with nothing but deceleration. The scheme was launched in earnest only on 2 November this year. Taking well over a year to launch a pilot scheme to invest in six to 10 sites over this Parliament is simply not good enough. Will the Minister outline how quickly after the January deadline for applications a decision will be made on which sites will be invested in? How will the Department ensure that timelines do not slip again?
Let me turn to whether the education system can meet future skills needs. A Make UK report from March 2026 highlighted that 39% of manufacturers believed the education system could not provide enough workers with the required skills over the next decade. On top of that, half of manufacturers said that skills shortages were their biggest barrier to growth in 2026. Skills England’s 2026 assessment of advanced manufacturing identified 25 priority occupations, 71% of which were classified as being in elevated or critical demand, compared with 51% of all occupations assessed in 2025. Skills England estimates that around 148,000 workers will be needed in those priority occupations by 2035. Will the Minister outline what work is being done to ensure those skills shortages are being met? How will we get more people into the priority occupations, and how will the Government help businesses to retain those skilled employees?
The Government say that they are reindustrialising the UK, but there is little evidence of that. Unless they deal with the underlying issue of crippling industrial energy costs, and bring those costs down, we will continue to deindustrialise. I look forward to the Minister’s response.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade (Blair McDougall)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Efford. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen (Andy MacNae) on securing this important debate. He has become a central figure in the House in such debates, bringing together nearly 90 colleagues in the Reindustrialisation Research Group, which is a term that now strikes fear into the hearts of Ministers across Government. My hon. Friend has built a coalition around a simple ambition: that we become again a country that invents things, makes things and exports things to the world, and through that increased production and the good jobs that are created will come a sense of individual purpose.
It has been a pleasure in this debate to revisit some of the industrial sites that I have visited as a Minister over the last couple of months. I think of the extraordinary research and development work being done to produce the autonomous vehicles that I saw being tested at Horiba in Nuneaton. I also think of the amazing, buccaneering spirit of people in the critical minerals businesses out in Cornwall, who seem to be reinventing something that has a deep heritage. However, the thing I have been boring everyone about is my visit to Woodsmith mine, an extraordinary project with more than 30 km of underground conveyor belt going to the coast to enable the export of fertiliser. It is proof that when we as a country put our shoulders to the wheel, we can still create these incredible industrial projects.
I thank the Minister for those comments. Another one of those projects is T.G. Eakin, on Ballystockart Road in Comber. It is a pharmaceutical company that was started by a local man, Tom Eakin. It is a family-rooted company that manufactures wound care medical devices. Its products go out from Comber to 60 countries, and the company has an annual turnover of £40 million. That is ingenuity, that is invention, and that is the sort of people we have in Northern Ireland.
Blair McDougall
Absolutely. I was about to say that behind every one of these industrial sites are extraordinary workers and extraordinary entrepreneurs. The hon. Gentleman will also be pleased to hear that just recently I addressed market access for wound-treatment technologies in a meeting with an international partner.
The constituency of my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen tells really well the story that we are considering today. Darwen’s wallpaper and Rossendale valley’s footwear were made by people who exported their talent and creativity to the world. They created jobs that people were proud of, and that gave them a sense of purpose and identity. However, as such industries declined, towns lost the economic foundation that had sustained them.
As my hon. Friends the Members for Alloa and Grangemouth (Brian Leishman) and for Hartlepool (Mr Brash) have both said, this story is generational and it was repeated across the country. Between the mid-1960s and the 2010s, tradeable goods fell as a share of our economy by a quarter. Yes, tradeable knowledge-intensive services grew, but typically not in the places going through deindustrialisation. Indeed, of the places that were hardest hit by deindustrialisation in the 1970s and 1980s, research shows that fewer than 10% of them had recovered by 2011.
Under-investment made that situation worse. The UK has had the lowest investment in the G7 for 22 of the last 30 years. In addition, UK investment was geographically imbalanced, with investment per capita in London about twice that in Wales. The result has been weaker productivity and lower living standards, with real weekly earnings just £22 higher than they were at the start of the global financial crisis.
Moreover, as my hon. Friend the Member for Blackpool North and Fleetwood (Lorraine Beavers) pointed out, this story is not just about the past; these challenges continue today. Steel, chemicals, ceramics and our automotive supply chain face global overcapacity and intense competition, and behind every single closure and every job lost are families and communities in stress.
My hon. Friend the Member for Alloa and Grangemouth asked some specific questions. I can go into detail with him in person about those. This morning, I met representatives of Falkirk council to talk precisely about site preparation at Grangemouth. We are talking about revamping the investment taskforces that we have running. I have also repeatedly met representatives of Syngenta to attempt to secure increased production, and I will continue to work on that. At such sites, high energy costs, fragile supply chains, global competition and technologies such as AI compound the pressures.
As my hon. Friends the Members for Tipton and Wednesbury (Antonia Bance) and for Caerphilly (Chris Evans) and others said, reindustrialisation cannot be—and we do not want it to be—about turning the clock back. It has to be about a leap forward, creating more well-paid, good jobs across the country in competitive industries that sell to the world, alongside the critical foundational inputs that underpin them.
Anna Dixon
I thank the Minister for his concluding remarks. I would like to jolt his memory: he met some of the innovative space and defence SMEs in my constituency—Radio Design and Slipstream Engineering Design—when he visited Yorkshire. Will he address the question from my hon. Friend the Member for Caerphilly (Chris Evans) about defence procurement? I have spoken to the Minister before about making sure that some of our defence investment reaches those businesses.
Blair McDougall
I was deeply impressed with the expertise in my hon. Friend’s constituency, particularly in communication and space. I will come to issues around defence and procurement in a moment.
I want first to address a couple of the questions asked by my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen. On the prospect of a target, we fundamentally agree with him and his group about the need for high ambition, for a scale of ambition and for that to be set out clearly through the numbers that we want to achieve. We have some difference of opinion on exactly how to measure some of those productive jobs, but we have tasked the Industrial Strategy Advisory Council to work on that and we will continue to work with my hon. Friend’s group as well.
On the question about reaching everybody, as we move through the industrial strategy under the umbrella of reindustrialisation, my hon. Friend will see greater intentionality in ensuring that we have more of a sense of place running through it. His part of the world will shortly be getting a mayor, which will bring in a lot of the local growth plans and the other delivery models. We are working across the Government and with No. 10 North to improve the delivery model so that it has a more intentional understanding of place.
Andy MacNae
I am glad that the Minister has focused on the fact that Lancashire, like many other places in the country, will be getting a mayor, but we do not have one right now—that is two years away. Given the immediacy of some of the issues that our businesses and places are facing, does he recognise that we need to have capacity, capability, support and intentionality now, before we get a mayor?
Blair McDougall
Absolutely. I was about to refer to the 10-year plan by saying that that is not to say that we have to wait for support. We need that sense of urgency now.
I want to talk about where we are going. The industrial strategy remains the core of our industrial policy, but it is not the full extent of it. I hear loud and clear the comments from Members across the House about increasing support for energy costs, particularly for manufacturers. We are pushing hard to make sure that manufacturers take full advantage of the British industrial competitiveness scheme. On cement, we will be reviewing the energy intensive industry support and we are working with that sector and others as we review it. We also need to have in our heads that there is an opportunity cost; for every pound we spend on subsidising energy costs, we have less to spend on other interventions.
I notice that I am running out of time, but I could go on to say that we have expanded our public finance tools and, on defence procurement, that we are trying to make every pound of public spending work harder for British jobs and skills. We can see a down payment on that through the Royal Navy’s new floating docks, which are being built in the UK. My hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen is absolutely right; we need to go further, particularly in opening up innovative smaller companies to MOD procurement.
I thank the Government and the Minister for their commitment to the defence sector in Northern Ireland, which has clearly been beneficial. However, in proportion to population, Northern Ireland does not receive the number of contracts that other parts of the United Kingdom do. In the past, Ministers have committed to changing that balance. Could the Minister perhaps give us some encouragement on that?
Blair McDougall
Absolutely. A key part of making sure that industrialisation touches every part of the country is ensuring that the levers that we have, such as defence, are spread equitably around it. Northern Ireland has huge strengths in shipbuilding and aerospace, which can be taken into account.
The Government’s approach is clear: we will back the industries where Britain can win, stand behind the industries on which our economy depends and work hard to make sure that the benefits are spread across every part of the country. We expect to be judged on whether that delivers good jobs, investment and opportunity in those places. We will continue to work with hon. Members and with the group founded by my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale and Darwen. As hon. Members have said, it is my job as Minister for Reindustrialisation to ensure that the work is an entire-Government effort, as it has to be a national priority.
Andy MacNae
I thank the Minister for his welcome response: it was comprehensive, positive and constructive, which is exactly what we need to see. I also thank all colleagues for their contributions. The agenda, passion and imperative for reindustrialisation is shared, dare I say it, across all parties and the whole House. We all recognise the differences it could make to our places, so I would like to think that our sense of urgency is not only shared but justified.
We want to be as constructive as possible in supporting the agenda. To quickly reflect on the BICS scheme, the Minister rightly said that there is a cost to everything that we do, but we brought forward a cost-offset idea to pay for that. That is an intensely practical approach that we want to take to find the solutions that we know are out there and support our great British businesses.
We still need to ask ourselves some fundamental questions on the delivery process for the agenda. In the end, we need to have the institutional infrastructure to do the work. That is the No. 1 question: who is doing the work? To be blunt, work on reindustrialisation should not be capacity-constrained. It is vital that we work across Government and draw together capacity to deliver with the urgency and focus that is needed. We also need clarity on targets and objective, so that we know where we are trying to get to. The opportunity is absolutely massive. I thank the Minister for his support and for all the work he is doing with us, and I look forward to working with him going forward.
Question put and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this House has considered Government support for reindustrialisation.
(1 day, 7 hours ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
I will call Peter Lamb to move the motion; I will then call the Minister to respond. I remind other Members that they may make a speech only with prior permission from the Member in charge of the debate and from the Minister. As is the convention for 30-minute debates, there will not be an opportunity for the Member in charge to wind up.
Peter Lamb (Crawley) (Lab)
I beg to move,
That this House has considered Government support for the Croydon Area Remodelling Scheme on the Brighton Main Line.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Efford. The Brighton main line has been a significant area of focus of mine for about a decade. I am grateful for the support offered by my hon. Friend the Member for Croydon East (Natasha Irons)—in whose patch the remodelling works are supposed to take place—during the two and a half years for which we have been in this place together.
The Brighton main line is one of the most significant stretches of rail in the entire country. Roughly a fifth of all journeys in the UK take place along the line each day, and it acts as, essentially, the only direct rail link running the whole way through the north and south of London. The line plays a vital role for the many commuter towns along the route, enabling people to get to work each day. It provides the main public transport connectivity for two of the UK’s major airports, and without it much of the south would lack any direct rail connection with the city, and vice versa.
Unfortunately, the very success of the line puts its future at risk. Despite covid and the shift to greater home working, the use of capacity on the line during peak hours has now reached pre-pandemic levels. In a little over three years’ time, the line will run out of capacity completely. People will be simply unable to get on trains. This will have an enormous impact on the economy of the sub-region, which is one of the strongest in the country, and on the quality of life of all those who rely on the line as a means of transportation.
This issue has not crept up on us; I and others have been raising it for roughly a decade. We have known for years that capacity on the line was running out. Although longer trains with additional carriages and a few other minor improvements can buy us some time, the only way to resolve the capacity issue is for large-scale remodelling works to be undertaken to resolve the current pinch point at East Croydon.
Despite initial setbacks, we successfully secured, through the work of the Brighton Mainline Alliance, a commitment from the Department for Transport to undertake the improvements, and the land assembly and planning works began. Yet it was not to last and, alongside High Speed 2, the works became another victim of the Sunak Government’s railway cuts—a fact many of us remained unaware of for a very long time.
That decision was enormously short-sighted. The works may need to take place in London, but the scheme benefits services that run from Brighton all the way to Cambridge, Bedford and Peterborough, with connecting services covering much of the south-east and east of England. The project is about the full length of the Greater Thameslink growth corridor and the economic risk to the United Kingdom.
The Government have announced, with great fanfare, the expansion of Gatwick and Luton airports, the securing of Universal Studios UK, and the construction of new towns such as Tempsford, all of which fall within the Greater Thameslink growth corridor, and all of which depend on an increase in rail capacity along the Brighton main line.
I am here to support the hon. Gentleman; I always try to be helpful in my interventions. In Northern Ireland, we really needed the major development of Grand Central station, because the capacity need was at an all-time high, just as in the situation to which the hon. Gentleman refers. Does he agree that, while recognising the need for essential upgrades, we must consider carefully ways to keep disruption on railways to an absolute minimum, to reduce the impact on passengers? The hon. Gentleman talks about the way forward; I think the impact on passengers will be great.
Peter Lamb
I agree with the hon. Gentleman. In fact, the later we leave it, the more challenging it becomes, because we have less capacity and ability to put in place measures to limit the impact. We already experience that on a regular basis. At one point, I was due to meet representatives of the Department of Transport to discuss the rail link, and I arrived late because I was stuck outside East Croydon station. That happens to me regularly, as I commute to Parliament daily—I often find myself spending a fair amount of time on one side of East Croydon station or the other. We should do the maximum amount to minimise disruption.
The line is crucial, and not just for people from the UK; it serves two international airports, so it is many people’s first experience of the UK. Significant delegations of investors looking to invest in the UK have been held on the line for prolonged periods, and have subsequently decided not to invest in the United Kingdom because of that experience.
Alison Bennett (Mid Sussex) (LD)
The hon. Gentleman is making important points about a line that affects my constituency. Last month, 45% of trains from Haywards Heath ran late, and that is costing our economy money. When people need to make connections at, say Clapham Junction, they get delayed. Does the hon. Gentleman agree that time is money for those running businesses, and that the delays to improving East Croydon are unacceptable?
Peter Lamb
Absolutely. One reason for the introduction of the Gatwick Express service was to provide reliable connectivity between the city and the airport, and it is often used by business passengers. The reductions in the efficiency of that service over time have diminished an awful lot of that impact.
The reality is that businesspeople who have a lot of work to be transacting find themselves increasingly unable to use the line efficiently at all. It is not simply a case of delays; the level of congestion makes it hard for anyone to use their time on the train usefully. They cannot sit down and deal with emails; they are absolutely packed in like cattle at peak hours. There is no way of moving, so the journey is entirely dead time for that person and their business.
The cost attached of the improvements is significant—I do not doubt that—but the current estimate is a one-off cost in the realm of £2.9 billion. Gatwick’s expansion alone is set to increase the gross value added to the UK economy by £2 billion per annum. That is just one of the projects that is relying on the works taking place.
I fully support the Government’s ambition to deliver growth in every postcode, which is likely to involve investing in regions that have not seen investment for quite some time. As I have said since long before I got into my current role, the economic regeneration of the north of England is essential for London and the south-east, where we have to deal with the constant issue of younger working-age people moving to the south because it is the only place where there is sufficient employment. That has created an utterly unsustainably high pressure on housing and infrastructure.
Money can help to deal with some of the pressures, but the reality is that problems such as the water capacity in the south cannot easily be resolved. We physically cannot deal with the population size in the south of England. It is to the benefit of everyone currently living in the area to enable people to succeed and prosper in other parts of the United Kingdom. The problem is that that will not happen if we kill the goose that lays the golden eggs. London and the south-east are the only regions that are net contributors to the UK. They fund the rest of the UK, and if we fail to deliver the infrastructure that makes it possible for those areas to continue to function and to grow, every part of the country will suffer.
It is worth noting that even without enabling the projects that I have already mentioned, the Croydon scheme is one of the few major projects that will ultimately pay for itself. The Brighton main line is the only line in the Greater Thameslink railway network—which I believe is the largest network in the country—that makes a profit. It subsidises all other routes and, unusually, the problem is not attracting people to go by rail; it is too many people travelling by rail. We therefore have guaranteed additional ticket sales when the extra capacity is introduced, and sales will only grow over time. Combined with the development work around East Croydon station that the works will enable, this will cover the scheme’s costs several times over.
The works are essential for the quality of life of my local residents and all those who live along the lines that cover much of the south of England.
Jess Brown-Fuller (Chichester) (LD)
The hon. Gentleman talks about the impact on the entirety of the south-east. It is difficult for me to explain to my constituents in Chichester that their trains are often delayed because of an issue in Croydon, but that is the reality of the situation. The bottleneck causes a ripple effect of delays down the entirety of the line, and the hon. Gentleman is right to point out the economic damage caused. Does he agree that if the Government invest in the Croydon area remodelling scheme, they will unlock untold economic benefits for the south-east, so that it can continue to be a net contributor?
Peter Lamb
I absolutely agree. As a member of West Sussex county council I regularly utilised the line between Three Bridges and Chichester, and I often found myself late to meetings because of exactly that congestion. We are talking about an enormous area where this is one of the most significant pieces of infrastructure. The sheer scale of the economic and population impact, without reasonable alternatives in the area, needs to be taken into account in prioritising investment in this scheme compared with other investments.
The works would deliver huge economic growth opportunities for the UK and, in the process, deliver new revenue for the Treasury and unlock the prized projects that the Government have secured or announced. Ultimately, the works would pay for themselves. In reality, given the capacity constraints along the Greater Thameslink growth corridor, we only have three years left before we hit a crisis, but it is a problem that I know we can solve. We know very well the solution—it has been scoped already—but the clock is ticking. I offer my thanks to the Minister for being here, and to all those who have attended to participate in this important debate.
Natasha Irons (Croydon East) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Efford. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Crawley (Peter Lamb) for securing the debate and for his continued support in the campaign to unblock the Croydon bottleneck. As the Minister knows, I have raised this issue repeatedly in the House. It has implications not just for my constituents but for passengers, businesses and communities right across London, the south-east and beyond.
Last week, alongside the Good Growth Foundation, I launched a new report, “A Gateway to Gatwick and Beyond”, which sets out the enormous economic potential of the Croydon area remodelling scheme. The report found that in 2024, 67% of trains at East Croydon station were delayed or cancelled, and those delays were felt by passengers from Brighton to Bedford and everywhere in between. By addressing the Croydon bottleneck we could unlock more than £5 billion in economic benefits over the next 20 years—including more than 10,000 permanent jobs and over 14,000 new homes on brownfield land—and save commuters over 200,000 hours in commuting time.
The Labour Government have rightly backed the expansion of Gatwick and Luton airports, and the development of the Universal Studios site in Bedford. Those major investments will drive economic growth and create jobs, but what connects two of our fastest-growing airports and some of our most significant new developments is a stretch of Victorian railway infrastructure that struggles to cope with the demands already placed on it. If we are serious about realising the full economic potential of those developments, we must also invest in the infrastructure that connects them.
I appreciate the financial challenges that face the Government, so our report looks at how we could fund this vital scheme. We propose a mutual investment model to bring together central Government, local authorities and the private sector to share the cost of developing the improvements. The scheme would have a number of significant beneficiaries, from Gatwick airport to major landowners and developers in Croydon. If investment in our railway is to unlock billions of pounds in development and increase the value of commercial and residential land, there is a case for capturing some of that value to help to pay for the infrastructure that makes it possible. The full cost of the scheme need not fall at the feet of the Treasury, and I would welcome the Minister’s thoughts on how we might explore alternative funding models to get the scheme moving again.
But, as I have previously stated, my main motivation for backing this billion-pound scheme that could unlock billions in economic growth and opportunity across the south-east is simply to get a lift at Norwood Junction station. Network Rail will not progress plans for a lift on the off-chance that any scheme may include remodelling options for the station, yet for now the Department of Transport says that the scheme remains cancelled. That leaves my constituents stuck in a frustrating cycle of lift limbo. For disabled passengers, elderly residents and parents with pushchairs, the lack of step-free access is not simply an inconvenience, but a barrier to using their local railway station.
Alison Bennett
The hon. Member makes an important point about the lack of step-free access at Norwood station. People wanting to travel from there to Wivelsfield station in my constituency would face the same problem, as it has step-free access on only one side. Step-free access was granted under Access for All and then found to be not funded. Does she agree that it is essential that everybody, regardless of their accessibility needs, can travel on our rail network?
Natasha Irons
I completely agree. Step-free access is not just a nice-to-have; it is essential to ensure that we have an inclusive public transport system to which everyone has equal access.
There is an opportunity for us to break the cycle. I recently met colleagues from Network Rail and GTR who are working closely with the Department for Transport on the case for the Thameslink growth corridor. I understand that Network Rail plans to undertake essential renewals in the Norwood area in the early 2030s, which presents a window of opportunity to deliver improvements, making better use of public money and minimising disruption to passengers. I would be grateful if the Minister considered what steps his Department could take to capitalise on that opportunity and, crucially, how we can ensure that step-free access at Norwood Junction station is finally secured.
We have an opportunity to unblock billions of pounds in economic growth, build thousands of homes, create thousands of jobs and make a tangible difference to the lives of commuters using Norwood Junction station. The Labour Government are committed to breaking down barriers to opportunity. At Norwood Junction, that barrier is quite literally a flight of stairs. I hope the Minister will help us to finally get out of our lift limbo.
It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mr Efford. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Crawley (Peter Lamb) on securing this important debate and on his continued advocacy for his constituents and the millions of other passengers using the Brighton main line every year. My hon. Friend the Member for Croydon East (Natasha Irons) is an equally passionate and persistent advocate for improvements on the rail system in her constituency and beyond.
As we have heard, the Brighton main line is far more than a railway; it is an economic lifeline. It connects the south coast with London, opening up access to Gatwick airport and carrying millions of passengers to jobs, businesses and opportunities every year. A railway of this importance demands sustained investment. The Brighton main line underpins billions of pounds of economic activity, helps businesses to prosper, supports communities and connects people with opportunities across the south-east and beyond.
Since it was completed in 2020, the £7 billion Thameslink programme has delivered a once in a generation transformation of north-south rail through London. New class 700 trains brought substantially greater capacity and customer experience to the Brighton main line, while modern technology has helped to deliver a more reliable and resilient railway for passengers.
That transformation extended to many stations along the line. London Bridge and London Blackfriars were comprehensively redeveloped, while Farringdon has become a major strategic interchange that brings Thameslink and the Elizabeth line together. The result is a stronger, better-connected railway that continues to play a fundamental role in the economic success of London, the south-east and the communities it serves. Planning within the railway now increasingly recognises the importance of the Thameslink growth corridor as a whole, stretching from Brighton in the south all the way through to Cambridgeshire, Peterborough and Bedford.
We heard reference to the international visitors to the country through Gatwick airport. Over £250 million was spent upgrading Gatwick Airport station, delivering a more accessible concourse, doubling the space for passengers and improving the reliability of trains calling at the station. For too many years, Gatwick station had impacted service across the Brighton main line due to the extended time that passengers needed to board and alight trains. Following platform widening and the creation of an entirely new passenger concourse, passengers can board more quickly.
[Paula Barker in the Chair]
In addition, recent upgrades to the track and signalling infrastructure in the Gatwick area reduced delays and cut the journey time between Brighton and London by up to five minutes, while improving overall performance and reliability. The significant suite of works at Gatwick has also reduced knock-on delays further up and down the line. We have heard extensively in this debate about the importance of connectivity with other elements of the network.
I hope that my hon. Friend the Member for Crawley has seen some improvements in the line, but he is right to look ahead. He knows that there are challenges that have not gone away—challenges that were identified a considerable time ago. Plans to bring Gatwick’s northern runway into routine use represents an exciting investment in Crawley and the wider south-east. We know that this has the potential to create more jobs, strengthen the local economy and support the airport’s long-term resilience, but we are clear that additional airport capacity must be matched by sustainable and reliable surface access. The Brighton main line, Gatwick Airport station and the wider Thameslink growth corridor will therefore have an important role in supporting air passenger growth.
As we have heard, before the pandemic the Croydon area remodelling scheme—I will refer to it as CARS, which seems a little ironic, given that this is a rail debate—was developed as a way to address overcrowding, increase capacity and improve reliability on the Brighton main line. The complex junction at Selhurst, often referred to as the Croydon bottleneck, alongside the challenging operation of East Croydon and Norwood Junction stations, place significant constraint on the capacity and smooth operation of the network. CARS was developed to address those challenges by extensive remodelling of the tracks and rail junctions north of East Croydon station.
The programme also included plans for the redevelopment of East Croydon and Norwood Junction stations. At the time, Network Rail estimated that the scheme would take more than 10 years to deliver, costing about £2.9 billion. Delivery would also require substantial disruption to passengers travelling along the Brighton main line. But as we know, the covid-19 pandemic changed travel patterns, created uncertainty about future demand and placed considerable pressure on public finances. As my hon. Friend the Member for Crawley mentioned, the previous Government took the decision to cancel the scheme at the 2021 spending review, although, as he noted, that was probably not communicated as swiftly as people would have wanted.
Sadly, on 8 July last year the Secretary of State updated Parliament on rail infrastructure schemes progressing following the 2025 spending review, and as my hon. Friend the Member for Crawley is aware, CARS was not allocated any funding at that time. However, the Government are committed to delivering infrastructure that offers the greatest benefit to passengers and the wider economy as quickly as possible within a fully funded and deliverable programme.
Given the limited funding available for rail enhancement projects and significant recent investment already made on the line, including for the Thameslink programme and the Gatwick area upgrades, the difficult decision was taken at the spending review 2025 not to prioritise the scheme for that particular period. That is not to say we will not look at it closely moving forward. I am very interested to read the Good Growth Foundation report that my hon. Friend the Member for Croydon East mentioned. It will be an opportunity for the Department and probably the Treasury, given that there are interesting suggestions in there about funding options, but we will consider that in the round and whether there is anything on which we can move forward.
I reassure Members that work is going on right now to find innovative and affordable measures that can improve services on such a crucial area of the network. That includes considering whether elements of CARS could be delivered in phases alongside planned upcoming renewals, as has been referred to. Of course, we acknowledge that this approach would not deliver immediately the full benefits of CARS, but it would still deliver key passenger-facing benefits, including improved reliability across the BML and wider Thameslink growth corridor, and also, hopefully, deliver step-free access at Norwood Junction station, which my hon. Friend the Member for Croydon East has been campaigning for so persistently.
I should make it clear that if we can take those steps, that does not rule out delivery of the full CARS in future, but we are looking towards more pragmatically delivering passenger benefits in a staged way that is likely to be within the funding envelopes that will come in due course. As Members would expect, next year’s spending review will be an important opportunity to make the case for future investment. I look forward to working with my hon. Friend the Member for Crawley and all hon. Members, alongside the Rail Minister, to develop that case.
I thank my hon. Friend for securing today’s debate and for the commitment that he continues to show in championing improvements for rail passengers. I understand the disappointment caused by the original decision in 2021 and the decision last year. Although we recognise that that has not led to us being able to tackle the immediate challenges and impacts of the Croydon bottleneck, we are committed to working constructively with partners in the coming months and years to find what we can do within the funding envelopes that might be available to us. I can assure hon. Members that the Rail Minister is more than happy to engage with them and all stakeholders to find any interim solutions that might be of assistance to passengers on that part of the network.
Question put and agreed to.
(1 day, 7 hours ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
Jess Brown-Fuller (Chichester) (LD)
I beg to move,
That this House has considered the impact of water companies not being statutory consultees on planning applications.
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mrs Barker. I thank hon. Members—they are mainly hon. Friends—for attending this important debate. My constituency of Chichester is home to some of England’s rarest and most precious chalk streams, such as the Lavant and the Ems. Chichester harbour is a national landscape and a site of special scientific interest, as well as the largest recreational harbour in the whole of Europe. My constituency is also on a low-lying coastal plain, and it is on the frontline of climate change. Significant swathes of it are prone to flooding, which has increased in recent years.
Water matters to my constituents, whether that is because of the coastal erosion and flood risk faced by those along the coast or because of an appreciation of the biodiversity and unique environments created by our rivers and harbour. So when storm overflows across the constituency discharge raw sewage into those environments, which happens for hundreds if not thousands of hours a year, my inbox is filled by concerned residents saying, “Can’t we stop this happening? Why are they allowed to get away with this? Surely this should be illegal?”
I am not shy when it comes to criticising Southern Water’s failure to adequately invest in water infrastructure as a result of decades of inaction and a prioritisation of shareholders over the natural environment. However, it is absolutely baffling that waste water treatment capacity is not a material consideration for new build developments, because water companies are not statutory consultees on planning applications.
Like me, my hon. Friend will have many constituents who are concerned about new developments coming onstream in places where sewerage capacity is already a worry. Does she agree that it is utterly senseless that the one organisation that knows whether the network has capacity—the water company—is not required to comment and cannot refuse access to the network once a development is approved?
Jess Brown-Fuller
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. Water companies cannot refuse because they are bound by a statutory duty to connect as part of the Water Industry Act 1991.
I commend the hon. Lady for raising these matters. Over the last two years and beyond, the Liberal Democrat party has been very much to the fore in highlighting these issues, and it deserves credit for doing that. In Northern Ireland, the water companies are statutory consultees, and if there is not capacity in the waste water system for a new development, that development does not go ahead. Does the hon. Lady want to see that kind of legislation here?
Jess Brown-Fuller
I always appreciate the hon. Gentleman bringing a Northern Ireland perspective to these debates. I chatted to him before the debate, and it was interesting to hear him explain that Northern Ireland Water is always consulted on planning applications, and that if it does not have capacity, that can be taken into account.
The Chichester and Arun districts, which my constituency sits in, have been set huge house building targets by this Government. Chichester district saw a 59% increase on the previous target, from more than 700 homes a year to more than 1,200 a year. Arun district’s target is even higher, with 1,400 homes expected to be delivered per annum. It is neither unreasonable nor outlandish for existing residents of those communities to expect that, when those new houses are built, they come with the necessary infrastructure to manage the additional pressures.
We have numerous waste water treatment facilities in Chichester, and I have visited most of them, including ones that are operating at the limits of their licence. That is before the system becomes overwhelmed, at which point they enter “storm mode”, which permits them to release untreated water into the environment. Constraints at some of these sites—such as not owning land around them on to which they could expand—mean that upgrades to increase capacity are complicated and lengthy. I would like to provide an example of where that has happened in my constituency in recent months.
The Highgrove development is 300 homes in the village of Bosham, and increases the size of Bosham by 27%. When the site was originally proposed, a group of concerned residents pointed out that the waste water treatment site would struggle to accommodate the additional sewage. On that occasion, the Planning Inspectorate added a planning condition that capacity was to be dealt with at the waste water facility before any of the houses could be occupied. The houses started to be built, but capacity upgrades were not forthcoming. The residents sounded the alarm, but the build progressed.
Surprise, surprise, earlier this year the first tranche of houses was built and advertised, but no magic capacity had been created at the waste water treatment works. The developers then applied for a variation in the planning conditions to allow the waste water to be tankered off site as an interim measure, so that the houses might be occupied. To be honest, I do not remember the image of sewage tankers lined up along the road of the new estate in the glossy brochures provided to prospective buyers.
To get round the planning condition, the developers’ solution is now to introduce a holding tank on site. It is estimated that that will hold three days’ worth of sewage, before the sewage is then released to the waste water treatment works when capacity is available. One assumes that that capacity would become available in the middle of the night, if at all, because capacity may never magically appear, especially in periods of heavy rainfall.
In 2023, Bosham waste water treatment works discharged into Chichester harbour—an SSSI and national landscape—for 1,762 hours. That is 73 days that discharge went straight into our natural environment. Who knows what happens to the held sewage at Highgrove at points of high rainfall, when capacity does not exist? Well, I know what will happen: they will have to release it to the waste water treatment works, and it will end up in our precious environment.
We had similar challenges at the Clappers Lane development in Earnley. Yet again, the issues of water capacity were not addressed before developers started advertising their new properties to prospective buyers.
Adrian Ramsay (Waveney Valley) (Green)
I thank the hon. Lady for bringing this important debate to the House. I have an example from the market town of Harleston in my constituency that reinforces the point she makes. The Greater Norwich local plan identifies that existing sewerage constraints and the need for additional water supply are critical factors in the planned housing growth of 700 homes, which is a lot in a market town of 2,500 households. The local plan explicitly requires infrastructure capacity to be addressed to the satisfaction of Anglian Water. Does that not show that water companies must be statutory consultees so that that requirement is established before a development is given permission?
Jess Brown-Fuller
The hon. Gentleman takes me on nicely to my next point, which is about local plans. In response to the debate, I imagine that the Minister will say it is best practice to consult water companies when setting local plans, and he is right. Local plans inform water companies’ long-term infrastructure investment decisions, but developments can and do come forward outside of those plans or earlier than anticipated.
Tom Gordon (Harrogate and Knaresborough) (LD)
My hon. Friend might be surprised to hear that we have ended up in an awful situation across North Yorkshire, where we have seen the quadrupling of housing targets at the same time as the Conservative-run council has failed to put in place a local plan, which has exacerbated that problem. Thousands of houses are going through the planning system, with Yorkshire Water objecting on development grounds that there might be pollution and flood and public health risks. Does my hon. Friend agree that that is a damning indictment of Conservative-run North Yorkshire council and the Labour Government?
Jess Brown-Fuller
My hon. Friend is right to highlight that areas with no local plan are at risk of speculative development. Between 2011 and 2025, 80% of the homes built in my constituency were speculative development on windfall sites. That is in part down to the failure of the Conservative-run district council to put a local plan in place. Developers also love a square, flat field because it is much easier to develop than many of the sites identified in local plans.
Under the Liberal Democrats, Chichester district council now has a robust local plan, and work is beginning on the next one. However, for areas such as Pagham and Bersted, which sit in the Arun district council area, all development is speculative. The top-down house building target means that they cannot demonstrate a five-year housing land supply without consenting to development on greenfield land and flood plains.
Giving water companies an earlier and more meaningful voice in planning decisions, especially for major developments relying on infrastructure already nearing capacity, would help to identify potential challenges before they arise. That is not an extraordinary request. I am simply asking for better alignment between planning decisions and funded infrastructure investment, because that would better protect our precious natural environment and existing customers.
I put the following questions to the Minister. Should the Planning Inspectorate take waste water capacity into account on speculative developments, knowing that no assessment exists because the site was not identified in the local plan? Does the Minister recognise that the Government’s ambition to build 1.5 million homes will be severely hampered if there is nowhere to treat all the additional sewage caused by those extra homes, or is he comfortable with that ending up in key environmental areas such as Chichester harbour?
Do the Government have any plans to implement schedule 3 to the Flood and Water Management Act 2010 to mandate sustainable urban drainage on new development, so that less rainwater ends up in the sewer system? Will the Minister’s default yes position on development around train stations and transport hubs take water infrastructure into account at all? Finally, considering that water and waste water infrastructure can take years to assess, design, fund and develop, but housing developments can be delivered far more quickly, will he look again at making water companies statutory consultees on planning applications, so that they can have a seat at the table when it matters most—when the decisions are being made?
Chris Murray (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mrs Barker. I congratulate the hon. Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) on securing this important debate on water companies not being statutory consultees on planning applications.
We are approaching Christmas, and I am going to be something of a ghost of Christmas yet to come. I am from Scotland, where water companies are statutory consultees on planning applications, and I am afraid to say that that has not worked in Scotland. Our water is still full of sewage, despite Scottish Water being a publicly owned water company. There is a much more important argument to be made, which I think the Government are making, about involving developers at the plan-making stage.
Edinburgh has seen 10% population growth over the past 10 years. My constituency includes part of East Lothian, which has seen 16% population growth, and we are right beside Mid Lothian, which has seen 20% population growth over the past 10 years. We have found that incorporating water companies as statutory consultees has been a paper exercise that has not led to enforcement, has not held the water company—a publicly owned water company—accountable and has led to what our constituents do not want to see: sewage washing up on the shore.
Water policy in England has been beset by the mistakes of the Conservatives for the past 14 years. My argument to my friends in England is that they should make different mistakes from those of the SNP and learn from what has happened to us. This measure is not a panacea and it has not worked. Evidence of that came just yesterday, when Portobello beach in my constituency was rated poor by the Scottish water regulator. Fisherrow Sands, in Musselburgh, has been poor for three years running. Those are Scotland’s most visited beaches, on the shores of our nation’s capital, yet they are awash with wet wipes and sewage.
The situation is actually worse than I thought. Today, I met the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, the water regulator. Representatives told me that they monitor water only when they do not expect to find sewage. If they expect sewage, because it has been raining heavily, they do not even monitor. There were 109 days of unreported sewage spills in Scotland. Inexplicably, the agency sometimes tries to blame the spills on seagulls, but having personally picked up hundreds of wet wipes and sanitary products—which seagulls do not use—on those beaches, I can tell hon. Members that they are due to poor water regulation. This has been going on for years and, dismayingly, nothing has been done about it.
Even more shockingly, despite my constituents having to deal with human sewage on the beach, the bosses of Scottish Water collected more than £250,000 in bonuses last year. In England, the Government are stepping in to cap the bonuses of water companies, but when I wrote to the First Minister of Scotland about this, he refused to intervene. That is why I have set up a petition to deal with it.
Jess Brown-Fuller
I really appreciate the hon. Gentleman’s passion about fixing this. I just want to highlight that I do not believe that making water companies statutory consultees on planning applications will fix the entire system; there are a lot more things that we need to do for the entire water industry. I would also caution him that despite the Labour Government’s move to ban bonuses for water company execs, water companies are already finding workarounds; they are increasing their standard salaries rather than having those bonuses. Water companies are quite clever when it comes to getting around the measures introduced to hold them to account.
Chris Murray
The hon. Lady is quite right; we need to pursue water companies when they try to find workarounds. But I would still much rather have a Government willing to try than an SNP Government who do not even lift a finger. I understand that the hon. Lady is not arguing that this is a panacea solution, but the experience from the Edinburgh and East Lothian area, which is in a housing crisis, is that adding water companies to the planning system has just delayed the planning and lengthened the time it takes to get houses built, and has not had an impact on sewage.
What does make a difference is monitoring—we have 100% monitoring in England but only 30% monitoring in Scotland—and investment in infrastructure. I am desperate for a Government to step up and grip the sewage crisis in Scotland. I am just jealous of my friends in England and Wales for having Governments willing to do that.
Alison Bennett (Mid Sussex) (LD)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship this afternoon, Mrs Barker. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) for securing this debate. She has focused her remarks mostly on waste water companies; my remarks do apply to sewerage, but the main issue for Mid Sussex, as I think the Minister is already aware, is with freshwater companies, specifically South East Water.
Water companies should be statutory consultees on planning applications, and the fact that they are not is having severe impacts on my constituents. At its heart, this debate is about whether we are giving sufficient weight to the availability of water infrastructure before deciding where, and how many, homes should be built. I believe that the current arrangements fall short of what is needed.
Mid Sussex has seen substantial development over recent years. Our communities have accommodated new housing and made a significant contribution towards meeting the country’s housing needs, but there is a growing disconnect between the pace of development and the ability of essential services to keep up. Nowhere is that more apparent than with water. Pressure on water resources in Mid Sussex is exceptionally high; restrictions on water use have become an increasingly familiar experience. Drought conditions have placed further pressure on an already stretched system, while the possibility of much more severe restrictions has become a very real concern.
The difficulties are not confined to the availability of water itself; the infrastructure responsible for delivering that water to people’s homes is also proving increasingly unreliable. In October, a major burst water main disrupted supplies to approximately 5,000 properties across Hurstpierpoint, Burgess Hill and Hassocks. More than 1,000 properties remained without water into the following day. Residents were forced to seek alternative supplies, while businesses and other local services faced considerable disruption. Sadly, that was not a one-off event. Communities in Haywards Heath, Cuckfield, Staplefield and Albourne—in fact, pretty much every community in Mid Sussex—have all experienced interruptions to their water supply this year alone.
Alongside that, there are mounting concerns about the capacity of the sewerage network. A burst main south of Burgess Hill was spotted by a resident; it had been leaking raw sewage into a woodland for days. It took weeks to fix and involved the waste being tankered and then pumped into a different part of the network.
Against that backdrop, we must consider the role of water companies in the planning process. At present, water companies do not have the same statutory consultee status on planning applications as a number of other infrastructure and public bodies, yet local planning authorities are expected to make complex judgments about whether proposed developments are sustainable. Not only is there clear evidence that that is leading to problems, as I have set out, but it is entirely illogical. How can we properly assess whether a development is suitable if we do not ensure that the body responsible for providing one of its key inputs can confirm it has the ability to do so?
Statutory consultee status would address that problem. It would give water companies a defined responsibility to highlight shortages in supply, identify limitations in sewerage capacity and explain what improvements would be necessary to support successful development. I appreciate that this change would not resolve every difficulty facing the water industry, and I am not suggesting that water companies should be handed the power to block developments simply because they have concerns, but their technical knowledge and evidence must be properly incorporated into planning decisions.
A formal consultation process would make it much harder for fundamental infrastructure constraints to be overlooked. That is particularly important in Mid Sussex, where the emerging local plan proposes provision for more than 24,000 homes. That is a considerable increase in the demands being placed on our communities. Before further development is approved, there must be a genuine understanding of how the additional demand will be met without compromising the supply available to existing households and businesses.
Quite simply, we cannot keep approving developments on the assumption that infrastructure will somehow materialise afterwards. The Government are rightly focused on increasing the supply of housing, but the success of that ambition cannot be measured simply by the number of houses built. The houses have to be liveable. A home must have a dependable water supply and it must be connected to a sewerage system with sufficient capacity. The people who move in must be able to rely on the essential services that make somewhere a viable place to live.
Therefore, I ask the Minister to consider how statutory consultee status could be introduced, with clear expectations around response times, meaningful technical assessments and transparency about the infrastructure investment required. We need a planning system that anticipates problems rather than one that waits for them to materialise. In Mid Sussex, we have already experienced what happens when population growth, inadequate infrastructure and pressure on water resources collide.
We can and should build more homes, but we must do so responsibly. To do that, water companies have to be statutory consultees. I hope the Government recognise that that is not an unnecessary additional hurdle for development; it is a vital change that needs to be made if we are to have sustainable and functioning communities for a growing population.
Charlie Maynard (Witney) (LD)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mrs Barker. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) for securing this important debate.
The question we are debating sits at the intersection between two of the biggest challenges facing my Witney constituency: planning and pollution. We see a huge number of illegal sewage spills. Windrush Against Sewage Pollution’s analysis of Thames Water’s illegal discharges between 2021 and 2025 found 1,231 were within Witney, making it the single worst impacted constituency in the country by quite some margin. Of those discharges, 271 alone came from Faringdon sewage treatment works and another 249 came from Appleton.
Under the national planning policy framework, we are required by the Government to build 18,000 new homes in West Oxfordshire and 14,000 in Vale of White Horse. We absolutely should not have to take on that scale of development without the infrastructure in place to support it, whether that is transport, sewerage or any other infrastructure required. The capacity in our water and sewerage systems must be considered in full, otherwise we risk increasing sewage discharges into our local waterways and doing more damage.
Let us take, for example, the recent application to build 200 new homes on Shrivenham’s community golf course in my constituency, while the nearby Shrivenham sewage treatment works persistently dumps raw sewage into the Tuckmill brook. One incident last year continued non-stop for more than 1,000 hours, or 41 days straight. No asset management period 8 scheme—the current cycle for water companies from 2025 to 2030—has been announced to upgrade that works, and given Thames Water’s poor financial status, it is hard to envision that it will fast-track any work to that sewage treatment works whatever its contractual obligations state. That goes on and on across my constituency.
We therefore have a sewage works that is already failing on a large scale with no realistic prospect of improvement; a proposal for another 200 homes, which will increase the pressure on its capacity; and no solution proposed. That is one of countless examples of where we desperately need planning processes to take full account of the water and sewerage system capacity.
Councils have some tools available to them. Since November 2022, West Oxfordshire district council, of which I was formerly a member, has attached Grampian conditions to new developments that prohibit homes from being occupied until water and sewerage infrastructure is operational; I believe that we were one of the first planning authorities to introduce such conditions.
The council’s new draft local plan will go further, requiring any development that increases waste water discharges to have the infrastructure that is needed to manage such discharges without harming our rivers and ecosystems already in place. Crucially, the new plan commits the council to impose Grampian-style conditions wherever there is evidence of insufficient water supply or foul water capacity, so that infrastructure is delivered in step with new homes. [Interruption.] Would the Minister like to intervene? No. Okay.
Grampian conditions are only as strong as the information behind them, however, and in my experience Thames Water has a track record of failing to provide information to the council. In addition, Grampian conditions offer no protection where developments rely on private package treatment plants, such as the one that has just been approved in Brize Norton, because those plants are not monitored inside the national system. Councils do what they can but they depend on water companies to be honest about capacity, and there are further problems about where the sludge goes and the obligations around the sludge produced by private package treatment plants.
Crucially, however, we not only need a statutory duty for water companies to be consulted but—as per an amendment that my hon. Friend the Member for Westmorland and Lonsdale (Tim Farron) tabled during the passage of the Water (Special Measures) Act 2025—a statutory duty to compel them to give full and accurate information on that process, including an honest assessment of their ability to fulfil their duties, with appropriate penalties when that is found not to have been the case. My hon. Friend’s amendment was not accepted by the Government, but if they are serious about meeting their house building targets, they must also take seriously the need to ensure that there is a robust planning process that protects our rivers, lakes and seas from further pollution.
I am eager to hear the Minister’s thoughts on those three things: first, Grampian conditions; secondly, private package treatment plants; and, thirdly, compelling water companies to provide full and accurate information. There are three more things that I would also like to hear the Minister’s thoughts on. First, I am concerned about the WINEP—water industry national environment programme—plans, which were published in 2022. They move from calculating the population in an area and the output of a sewage treatment works to a tiered system, which gives an incentive to water companies to pollute up to the level of the next tier. That seems to be a really bad incentive, so I am interested to hear the Minister’s thoughts on it.
Secondly, flow meters are installed everywhere apart from on sewage outlets. Why are the Government so resistant to putting flow meters on sewage outlets? If we had flow meters on sewage outlets, we would have a much more accurate set of data. Thirdly and finally, we would not be talking about sewage if we were not also talking about special administration. I ask the Minister to please work with his colleagues to put Thames Water into special administration.
Order. I remind Members to stick to the topic of the debate, which is planning.
John Milne (Horsham) (LD)
It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mrs Barker. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller), who is also my constituency neighbour, on securing this debate.
In my view, the role of water companies in the planning process is wholly unsatisfactory. In my constituency of Horsham, we have learned that the hard way. For four years, from 2021 onwards, construction in my constituency came to an almost complete halt because of water neutrality, an Environment Agency requirement that was introduced to protect an endangered water environment from over-abstraction. That requirement was introduced overnight and it disappeared overnight, but it left a trail of confusion in its wake. I thank the Minister for his personal involvement in helping us to get past that problem.
Most damagingly of all, that has left us hugely behind on our house building target, even though it was legally impossible for us to do anything to meet it. As a result, we have been punished with numerous inappropriate permissions, most of all the 800 homes at Horsham Golf and Fitness village, which are not in the local plan. Of course, the water requirements and sewerage requirements for that development will now have to be worked out retrospectively; in the first instance, they were not even considered.
Water and sewerage infrastructure is a complex issue, and I am not convinced that we have got to grips with it from a planning point of view. I support those who call for water companies to be made statutory consultees in planning applications. However, that change in itself would not go far enough, because—astonishingly—even if water companies were guaranteed a place at the table, their input would not necessarily have any weight in the planning process. They cannot refuse to support a specific application on the grounds of water supply or sewerage issues, even if they would like to. Indeed, judging from my conversations with Southern Water, it seems that it has never even occurred to the company to refuse an application.
Under the Water Industry Act 1991, developers were given the right to have their houses or commercial buildings connected to the main supply, regardless of how practical that might be—the water companies literally cannot say no. Instead, they have to say what measures they will take to meet the extra demand in the future. In my constituency and in the wider area, including Chichester, that has led to—[Interruption.]
John Milne
Thank you, Mrs Barker. Before we were so rudely interrupted by the other Chamber, I was saying that water companies cannot refuse a planning permission and cannot say no. Instead, they have to explain how they are going to meet the extra demand. In my constituency, and indeed in the wider area, this has led to bizarre schemes, including a plan to ship water from Norway. In practice, it is very hard for anyone to object on capacity grounds alone.
When we lay that alongside an overwhelming Government mission to build as many houses as possible in pursuit of a target—which is already unachievable—it is a recipe for disastrous decision making. I believe that the Government are content to let this absurd situation continue, because they are allergic to doing anything that might possibly stand in the way of any development anywhere. It is a strategy that delivers abundant permissions, but not actual houses that people can live in. That is a growing problem in water-stressed areas such as Horsham. We are at risk of accumulating zombie permissions for estates that cannot be built for decades to come, because local water companies will not be able to meet their over-optimistic supply targets.
To conclude, it is time to give planning authorities the power to make meaningful decisions relating to water and sewerage. Statutory consultee status merely gives a water company a voice. Amending the Water Industry Act 1991 would give that voice force.
I have invited the Minister to come to Horsham to explain to local people and help them to understand his overall housing strategy. That would be a message for Horsham people, but it could also serve the wider community. I hope that Minister will accept that invitation in the future.
Calum Miller (Bicester and Woodstock) (LD)
It is a pleasure to speak with you in the Chair, Mrs Barker. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) for securing this important debate. I also thank my hon. Friends who have spoken already, particularly my hon. Friend the Member for Witney (Charlie Maynard)—noting that the sewage effluent that he referred to as such a plague on his constituency flows straight down and into mine.
The relationship between planning and critical utilities is simply broken. In areas like my constituency, where there is substantial house building and employment growth, it is a huge issue. I want to take hon. Members back to September 2024, when we in Oxfordshire experienced one month’s rain in one day. In Bicester, Kidlington, Woodstock, Bucknell and Cassington, people were suffering incoming foul water that not only polluted but contaminated their homes, requiring them to move out for periods of upwards of six months and leaving them with a terrible legacy. I urge the Government to reconsider how to ensure that key infrastructure is built first before new developments open, because this is essential for existing residents and new homeowners.
Other hon. Members have mentioned this, but let us look at how things work now. In my area, Thames Water will be consulted, but it is not a statutory consultee, so any objections or difficulties it raises do not stop the progress of developments. However, as other hon. Members have said, under the Water Industry Act 1991, Thames Water has a statutory obligation to connect both foul and potable water.
What does that mean? It means that, as a standard condition, the developer must either create new capacity off site or improve or build new capacity on site through a dedicated private facility. That is a real issue in my area because sometimes that is simply not possible. For example, the Oxford sewage treatment works are at full capacity. That has the real possibility of delaying the connection of 4,400 homes that are currently being built near Kidlington, or, in the case of my residents in Woodstock, at the development at Bens Close.
I want to take hon. Members back to almost exactly a year ago. I was shaking a bucket along with the firefighters of Woodstock and their supporter Claire, collecting for Children in Need, and the heavens opened. Claire was one of the residents who had seen her property flooded in September 2024, and she was traumatised, knowing that very heavy rainfall might flood her home again. She stayed and carried on collecting for Children in Need, and I discovered later that evening that her home had flooded yet again, along with her neighbours’, like Genevieve. This is an unsustainable and unacceptable situation because they suffer from the fact that their water connection, which Thames Water has installed, is not adequate to deal with both the surface and foul water drains, so every time it rains very heavily, they have water backing up into their homes as well as surface water flooding directly into their houses.
Finally, where it is proposed by a developer to install a septic tank, as it is for my constituents in Enslow, all too often those septic tanks are poorly installed by developers in a rush; they service a community without adequate supply and through management company failings, residents in Enslow have been left with a noxious smell for a long period because of the poor maintenance of the septic tank. In all three of those examples, we have evidence that the failure to include the objections of the water companies at the time of development is creating real difficulties.
I would like to address the comments made by the hon. Member for Edinburgh East and Musselburgh (Chris Murray), whose area I know well—although I have not picked up sewage from the beach, I have certainly spent time there. He made a powerful case for the need to involve developers early, but the point I would like to make to the Minister is that we are in a broken cycle. When the water companies are not consulted automatically when they are obliged to connect, despite not having the ability to do so, and when, as with the forthcoming challenge in Kidlington, they are therefore unable to allow people to occupy the homes, then the local authority loses its five-year housing land supply and is obligated to allow more speculative development in areas that have no infrastructure whatsoever. Although the aspiration of involving developers early is good, it is not sufficient if the water companies are not involved early in the conversation.
I want to close by making the point that it is not just water. I realise that water is the focus of this debate, but the same thing applies to electricity, as the Minister is well aware. Members will forgive me if this is something of a preoccupation, but the asylum centre proposed in my constituency has neither potable nor foul water nor electricity, and the fact that neither the water authority nor the electricity board was consulted means there will be a real challenge in connecting that facility.
To conclude, I hope the Minister will be able to explain how the Government are seeking to ensure that we have an infrastructure-first approach so that residents like those in my constituency of Bicester and Woodstock can have greater confidence in the quality and sustainability of their homes in the future.
Gideon Amos (Taunton and Wellington) (LD)
It is a pleasure to serve with you in the Chair, Mrs Barker. I pay credit to my hon. Friend the Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) for foregrounding such an important issue in development for communities across the country. She has been a formidable champion on this issue, including when we were debating the Planning and Infrastructure Bill and she tabled, along with me, an amendment to make water companies statutory consultees. It was voted on and was sadly defeated by Labour MPs on that occasion. My hon. Friend the Member for Westmorland and Lonsdale (Tim Farron) also proposed that idea in an amendment to the Water (Special Measures) Act. Again, that was defeated by the other parties. In July, the Government rejected the House of Lords Environment and Climate Change Committee’s recommendation that water companies should become statutory consultees. In doing so, they rejected the Cunliffe recommendations.
A number of Members have made excellent points in this debate, and I congratulate them all. My hon. Friend the Member for Mid Sussex (Alison Bennett) highlighted the challenges of water management failures in her constituency. My hon. Friend the Member for Witney (Charlie Maynard) highlighted the use of Grampian conditions. I heard the Minister suggest from a sedentary position that the problem was solved because of the use of Grampian conditions; but if that is going to be relied on across the country, how can councils properly impose planning conditions or introduce the ideas well used in Witney if they do not have the information from the water companies, which have not been consulted, to tell them what kinds of condition should be imposed?
My hon. Friend the Member for Horsham (John Milne) highlighted the fact that these issues are leading to calls to import water from Norway. Surely there cannot be a more compelling example of the problems we have with water and planning in the development system in this country.
My hon. Friend the Member for Bicester and Woodstock (Calum Miller) highlighted the problem with the accountability of the water industry. The hon. Members for Strangford (Jim Shannon) and for Edinburgh East and Musselburgh (Chris Murray) pointed out that water companies are statutory consultees in both Northern Ireland and Scotland. The hon. Member for Edinburgh East and Musselburgh suggested that it had not made any difference, but I invite both hon. Members to consider how much worse it might be had there not been any consultation with water companies on development in those nations.
The question for the Government and for the Minister is whether it is really better not to consult, and therefore to expose residents and stakeholders to the risks of water supply capacity issues, of sewerage and drainage issues and of homes flooding. Is it right that the Government should expose those groups to those risks? Why take those risks? Surely consulting water companies is the minimum we should do to manage and mitigate them.
My hon. Friend the Member for Chichester explained that homes coming forward outside a local plan is now more or less the norm. With one stroke, the Government rendered most local plans out of date—I believe it is most, but I stand to be corrected. As of March, only 90 councils have up-to-date local plans, because once the Government imposed their new standard method they rendered huge numbers of local plans suddenly out of date. That means that development in all those areas will come forward outside the local plan process, with no strategic environmental assessment of the flooding impacts, water demands or sewerage implications. We are living in an unplanned planning system in most of England at the moment.
Why take that risk? Why not consult water companies so that authorities have the information they need, given that these decisions are so much more important than they were before the standard method was brought in when local plans were in effect? In Taunton and Wellington, we find ourselves at the centre of a perfect storm of all three of the risks I mentioned: the risks of water running out, of homes flooding and of drains and sewerage systems failing. I had to rewrite my speech after a BBC report this morning explained that the French weir, which I campaigned to have designated back in 2023, now has the most sewage-filled bathing water in the whole country. What more graphic example can there be of the failure of water and sewage management and planning alongside development in this country?
It is time for the water companies to step up and take action to invest in the sewage works in Bradford-on-Tone and across the system. Consultee status would highlight the stresses and the need for investment in sewerage and drainage infrastructure. With so many developments outside a local plan, it is vital that we get flood risk information from statutory consultees, in particular water companies, if they were made statutory consultees. Although the Environment Agency is responsible for flood management, water companies bear responsibility for drainage and therefore for reducing flood risk result.
Driven by increasingly unpredictable rainfall and weather patterns, hundreds of thousands of homes are now unable to get insurance and therefore face difficulty in getting mortgages. [Interruption.] I infer from your coughing that time is short, Mrs Barker, so I will do my very best to make a short version of my speech, but the impacts of flooding in my constituency are significant.
Consultee status would highlight the need to invest in drainage to reduce flood risk, in sewage measures and in measures to support water supply. My hon. Friend the Member for Chichester made an excellent case for doing so. I urge the Government to take on board her proposal.
I call the Opposition spokesperson, who has five minutes.
Five minutes? Thank you very much, Mrs Barker; it is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship.
I commend the hon. Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) on securing this important debate. She made the case extremely well. Unfortunately, I will have to skip large chunks of my speech, because so much time has been taken. The argument that has been made has pros and cons. At a time when the country’s population is at record levels and demand for housing is surely at an all-time high, house building in this country is nowhere near the levels it needs to be at. An increasingly convoluted and time-consuming planning process, a multiplicity of increased taxes and regulations, inflation at higher than targeted levels, correspondingly high interest rates and the falling availability of construction workers have all combined to strangle housing development.
Any change we make to the system must support sustainable and affordable house building, not make it less viable. I agree that it is vital for the planning system to lead to homes that have safe and reliable water supplies, firm foundations and decent insulation, and which are crafted with quality and care. But it is also critical that developers can afford to build the homes and sell them at affordable market prices. Unfortunately, we find all too often that neither is viable. At first glance, greater consultation may seem like a solution, but as the quality and quantity of homes continues to decline, can we justify adding more statutory consultees to an already fatigued system?
At present, developers are saddled with excessive cost, times and procedural measures that result in lengthy reports, protracted surveys and drawn-out assessments. These consultations do not just carry financial costs; they also take up an inordinate amount of time. In many cases, they simply set out facts and analysis that we already know, arriving back at square one via a winding route through forests of assessment and oceans of consultation. That is not just unproductive but unviable, especially for small and medium-sized enterprises, of which there is an alarmingly shrinking number.
The statistics prove this to be a stark and sobering reality. For example, according to Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government figures, in the first quarter of 2026, while 91% of applications were decided within the statutory 13-week period—or “an extended period”—closer examination reveals that just 19% of major planning applications were decided within the statutory 13-week period. A major contributing factor to those delays, of course, is extra complexity thrown in to the planning system. I will skip sections of my speech here, because of the time.
Between 2022 and 2025, more than 300 planning applications were escalated to the Secretary of State because of disputes with consultees. While it is not solely to blame, it is clear that consultation fatigue is a core part of the wider problem: a planning process that is obese, fattened up by paperwork and bureaucracy that has reached an unmanageable stage.
Last week, the Centre for Policy Studies noted:
“No decision-maker, consultee or even committee can meaningfully read an application of the length the UK system turns out.”
It found that in Germany, the planning process for a 14-unit development may run to just eight to 10 documents and sets of drawings totalling less than 50 pages. Recently in Walthamstow, an application ran to 1,250 pages, an increase in total pages of around 2,500%. Why is this a good thing?
Importantly, with water companies as a commercial entity, there is a danger that giving them extended statutory consultee powers reverses the incentive to create a better water system. I say that for two reasons. First, a business that has the right to formally object to an application has less pressure to upgrade its service where refusing or delaying is easier than investing. Unlike any other previous statutory consultees, many of which often represent policy rather than business interests, a commercial company may adopt a gatekeeping role that ends up rewarding under-investment. That may be particularly true for companies with strained finances, which we know is the case for many water companies. Secondly, as commercial entities with investment constraints set through price reviews, the objections of water companies may better reflect their funding and capital limitations rather than physical planning constraints.
Those are clear reasons not to list water companies as statutory consultees, but there is an important qualifier; there is another side to this that is equally important. As I mentioned, we have a duty to support homebuyers and to ensure that the homes they work so hard to afford provide access to the most basic of human rights: running water. Unlike other utilities, water is a regulated monopoly. A customer cannot switch water supplier, as they can with broadband, gas or electricity. Reliable and safe water supply is essential, and any company falling short of its statutory duty to provide a secure supply must be held to account.
Plans are all very well, but it is delivery that matters. In 2026—nearly 2027 now—it is to the discredit of Governments past and present that homes both new and old are found without a clean, economical and sustainable water supply. It is an even greater shame that some homes are without a water supply at all.
I have spent some time on the cons—some of the reasons not to include water companies as statutory consultees—but I can see the merits of this move as well. As the hon. Member for Chichester pointed out, at present a local planning authority can approve a site, only for the realisation to come much later that water capacity is completely lacking. A formal consultation could push these problems further up the chain and allow for more solutions and greater proactivity. That would allow for clarity in the system and would work to ground decisions in objective fact rather than in vague reasoning, as well as exposing the decision to scrutiny.
Finally and most importantly, it could support public confidence. Such confidence has hardly been lower, but giving water companies a statutory duty to assess capacity could conceivably help to alleviate concerns. It could also support councils to answer concerns about sewage and water with credible, factual and full datasets, meaning informed answers to pressing questions.
The potential solutions are numerous. We could, for example, see proper analysis of where, who and what needs our vital and diminishing water supplies—a system based on prioritisation rather than a postcode lottery. [Interruption.] I am just coming to my conclusion, Mrs Barker. We could build on this to modify the planning system. There are perhaps merits in bespoke assessments in areas where water scarcity is most problematic. Planning applications in such areas could trigger an automatic statutory requirement to consult water companies, so as to include them only where they are most needed and will add genuine value to an application. We could also decide that water companies should become statutory consultees in every case.
The truth is that the answer is far less clear than the problem is apparent. I am, however, pleased to have been given the opportunity to raise these thoughts and ideas with the Minister, and to highlight the Opposition’s strong concerns about this pressing issue. I will be very interested to hear his thoughts.
Before I call the Minister, it may be helpful for Members to know that in an hour-long debate, the Opposition spokespersons’ speeches should be five minutes, and the Minister’s should be 10 minutes.
It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mrs Barker. I congratulate the hon. Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) on securing this important debate. She is a doughty champion for her constituents, and her opening remarks were a powerful articulation of entirely legitimate concerns about the role of water companies in planning for new residential development. I also thank the other hon. Members who participated in the debate; I welcome the valuable insights that they shared from their constituencies.
I want to make it clear at the outset that I note and appreciate fully the concerns that exist across the House in respect of the delivery of water supply, drainage and waste water infrastructure. I recognise how strongly hon. Members feel about this matter. Water scarcity is a genuine and growing constraint, and not for one second, in anything I say, am I conveying the Government’s view that the status quo is acceptable. There is a real problem here, and it is complex, but in the time available I want to detail the steps that the Government have already taken to address the issue and to reassure hon. Members, if I can, that we are acutely aware of the need to do more, and in particular to ensure—to address the point well made by the hon. Member for Bicester and Woodstock (Calum Miller)—much closer alignment between planning for development and planning for necessary water and waste water infrastructure.
I want to touch briefly on the national planning policy framework, because it is very clear that sustainable development should be pursued, both through the preparation and implementation of local development plans and through the application of policies in the framework in decision making. In short, national policy is unambiguous that new housing must be accompanied by appropriate provision for water supply, drainage, waste water, water management and flood risk infrastructure.
However, I must make it clear that the focus of planning policies and decisions should be whether proposed development is an acceptable use of land, rather than matters that are subject to control under other regulatory regimes. In short, planning decisions should assume that those regimes operate effectively. That reflects a well-established position in law: the courts have consistently held that it is not the role of the planning system to duplicate controls that are the statutory responsibility of other bodies, nor should decision makers substitute their own judgment on matters for which other regulators hold relevant expertise and responsibility.
If the hon. Member will allow me to make a linked point, he can then come back to me if he wants to.
Infrastructure constraints can be a material consideration; I think the hon. Member for Chichester said that they could not be, but they can. Where there is clear evidence that a regulatory regime is not operating effectively in a particular area, decision makers may need to depart from the general assumption. However, such departures must be based on substantive evidence, not a precautionary approach. In other words, the planning system should not become a proxy regulator for the water industry.
If the hon. Member for Witney (Charlie Maynard) still wants to intervene, I am happy to give way.
Charlie Maynard
I thank the Minister. Does he accept that up and down the country, developments are being approved and brought forward despite everybody knowing that no water treatment capacity will be built out and, in many cases, that the capacity is already failing? The carte blanche answer that the law will cover it is not working. We are in a completely failing predicament.
I will come on to some points of detail that I hope will address that. I will say that where appropriate, planning conditions and obligations can play a role. They were dismissed by hon. Members earlier, but they are legally enforceable, provided that the relevant legal and policy tests are satisfied. Let me make a few more points; the hon. Gentleman is more than welcome to intervene again, if there is time.
The hon. Member for Chichester asked me about schedule 3 to the Flood and Water Management Act 2010, which provides a statutory framework for sustainable drainage systems. The Government’s position is that 16 years have passed since the introduction of the Act. We need to consider the most efficient and effective way of securing the objectives of part 3, and our considered view is that they are best achieved through national policy, which we have strengthened. The national planning policy framework now makes clear that for developments of all sizes, sustainable drainage techniques should be used where a development could have drainage impacts, and appropriate long-term management arrangements should be in place. The framework, as now constituted, will mean that sustainable drainage technologies are taken up far more widely in new development, but the Government will continue to monitor whether more needs to be done.
On the central point of the debate, in August, in parallel to the publication of the new NPPF, the Government published our response to the consultation on reforms to the statutory consultee system. We were clear that the system is not operating effectively: we were told as much not only by housebuilders but by local planning authorities across the country. The Government response confirmed that we will maintain the moratorium on new statutory consultees in the planning application process, subject to periodic review.
While the Government considered carefully the case for giving water companies statutory consultee status, we are clear that statutory consultations should be focused where a legal duty is necessary and adds value. In our view, creating blanket additional statutory requirements can introduce duplication, regulatory burden and delay, without necessarily ensuring that the underlying infrastructure is planned or delivered any earlier. Indeed, I would go further, as I did in a debate on 12 March 2025, when I touched on many of the same issues discussed today. I would argue that making water companies statutory consultees not only is not a panacea, as several hon. Members have accepted, but would risk allowing them to argue against the delivery of new homes rather than focus on their responsibility to ensure that the appropriate infrastructure is in place at the outset.
Of course—this is important—water companies not having statutory consultee status does not prevent them from submitting their views on individual applications. There seemed to be some confusion from the Liberal Democrats that being a statutory consultee offers a veto over planning decisions—it does not. Statutory consultees are allowed to input material considerations, which water companies can already do on individual planning applications. Any interested party can make representations. Water companies can work proactively with councils to identify developments of interest, and where particular water issues arise, local planning authorities can consult them directly.
Alison Bennett
Does the Minister accept that in the vast majority of cases, water companies do not participate in the planning process?
I do not accept that, and I will come on to make that point.
Due partly to other hon. Members speaking for slightly longer than they should have, I have run out of time to respond to many of the points made. Let me make a central point: the Government’s view remains that strategic issues such as water capacity, drainage and waste water management are best dealt with at the strategic plan-making stage, when cumulative requirements can be identified across an area and infrastructure needs can be addressed early, rather than through individual planning applications.
As was widely accepted in hon. Members’ contributions this afternoon, we want water companies to be engaged earlier and more strategically through the plan-making system. That is why although water companies are not statutory consultees on individual planning applications, statute requires that they are consulted in the preparation of local plans. Water companies are under a statutory duty to provide new water and sewerage connections, and must plan for future growth through their water resources and waste water management plans. The water resources planning guideline published by the Environment Agency and Ofwat sets out how those companies should forecast demand for water based on existing customers and planned levels of household and non-household growth.
Given the time, Mrs Barker, I will have to finish there. Hon. Members have raised a number of wider points, and I would have loved to touch on local plans in more detail. I am afraid that the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, the hon. Member for Taunton and Wellington (Gideon Amos), is plain wrong to suggest that the changes to the national planning policy framework at a stroke rendered plans across the country out of date—that is simply wrong. If the hon. Gentleman is going to be a Front-Bench spokesperson on these issues, he really needs to do his research. We have strengthened the plan-making system, introducing new measures to subject water and sewage to “requirement to assist” regulations.
I am more than happy to sit down with the Liberal Democrat Members present and other hon. Members to discuss the issue in more detail, and to write to hon. Members with more detailed responses on the many specific points that were raised.
Question put and agreed to.
Resolved,
That this House has considered the impact of water companies not being statutory consultees on planning applications.