Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
(3 weeks, 1 day ago)
Commons ChamberI beg to move, That the Bill be now read a Second time.
Nine years ago, 72 people, 18 of them children, died in the Grenfell Tower tragedy. It was a deadly betrayal and a national tragedy that must never happen again. Let me start by remembering those who lost their lives and paying tribute to the bereaved families, the survivors and members of the Grenfell community.
In the time since, the community has campaigned to fix the building safety crisis exposed by the tragedy. That is why we are all here today—so that no one suffers as they have. A decent, safe and secure home is not too much to ask for, but for many it is still out of reach. Despite nine years passing since the Grenfell tragedy, up to 380,000 residents are still living in buildings with unsafe cladding. Every single one of them tells a story of someone unable to move on with their life, stuck in an unsafe home, unable to sell, and often unable to sleep at night. There are even stories of families evacuated without any guarantee of when they can return home. The mental and financial burden can become unbearable.
We have taken action, and we have accepted our responsibilities, but the truth is that others have not. There are still people and companies out there who are not acting quickly enough to make homes safe. Of the 4,724 buildings where unsafe cladding has been identified, work has been completed on only 1,849. Regulators have so far had to take enforcement action on over 900 buildings where those responsible were not taking their responsibilities seriously. As a Government, we will stand up for every leaseholder who is stuck in an unremediated flat, unable to move on with their lives and facing huge costs in the meantime.
When this Government came to power, the pace of remediation was unacceptably slow. That is why in December 2024 I announced the remediation acceleration plan—our blueprint to identify all buildings with unsafe cladding. We are now delivering on that plan, which means that buildings will be fixed faster and residents will be supported better.
I declare that I am a leaseholder whose home did have cladding, though happily that has now been resolved. I represent one of the largest concentrations of new builds with cladding, and there are serious issues, as the Secretary of State has begun to highlight. Back in 2020, the Public Accounts Committee issued a report about the need to improve skills and make more contractors available, so I appreciate the grip that she took of the situation in 2024 as Secretary of State. Will she flesh out a bit more what work she is doing with other Departments to ensure we get the necessary skilled workforce? That is one of the biggest factors that slows down my constituents’ getting the justice that they deserve.
My hon. Friend is absolutely right; we need to ensure that we have the skilled workforce this situation requires. The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, alongside other Departments, has put more investment into ensuring we have the people in post, and we will continue with that piece of work. We also launched a national identification drive to understand the scale of the problem.
I commend the Secretary of State for the Bill, the work she has done and the statement she just made. In my constituency, the local authority has been very good and effective at dealing with dangerous cladding—it did so immediately, which is to its credit, and that is basically the story across the whole country—but the private sector is less like that. In my constituency, a number of places including Drayton Park and Highbury Gardens among others have now had years with unsafe cladding, with people facing massive insurance costs and, as she rightly said, the inability to move on with their lives. Can the Government take over responsibility, ensure the work is done, charge it to the perpetrators of the problem and, above all, ensure there is compensation for residents for the massive insurance costs they have faced over the last few years?
I thank the right hon. Gentleman for his contribution. He is right to highlight the devastating impact on communities. The Bill will I hope go some way towards doing the things he wants to see for his constituents. Anyone who has deliberately failed to mitigate or remediate buildings that are over 11 metres will face tougher consequences as a result of the Bill, including fines of up to £500,000 and, where needed, criminal prosecution.
Since we launched the national identification drive to understand the scale of the problem, over 200,000 building records have been reviewed. That is significantly improving our understanding of the affected building stock and enabling remediation activity to be targeted more effectively. To drive the pace of remediation work, we also gave social housing providers equal access to Government funding schemes for the first time.
I thank the Secretary of State for the work she has been doing on dangerous cladding remediation. Some constituents of mine have been able to benefit from the remediation work for buildings under 11 metres, but could she say a bit more about when funding will become available? My constituents are still waiting on the release of funding for work that needs to take place.
I thank my hon. Friend for that. Hopefully, as we go through the Bill she will see how we are changing the emphasis in particular to ensure that the buildings most at risk will be remediated first. As I said, we have given social housing providers access to Government funding schemes for the first time, investing over £1 billion to ensure that the most vulnerable residents have safe homes. We have also ended the binary approach to remediation funding based on building height.
I thank the Secretary of State for being so generous with her time. Picking up the point made by my hon. Friend the Member for Lewisham East (Janet Daby), a number of my constituents are stuck in blocks that are not high priority. They do not have as much cladding to be removed, but they are down the list because there are not enough skilled people to do the work—it is not always that the developers are dragging their heels; sometimes that is an issue as well. Therefore, for the sake of a small amount of work, their lives are on hold. They are unable to sell their properties and find it challenging to get a mortgage—all the issues that we know people are still facing, many years on. Could she take that away for the Department to revisit some of the priority issues and get some of those blocks that could be done quickly up the list?
I thank my hon. Friend for that intervention. I hope that in the passage of the Bill she will see we are hoping that we can do that piece of work, because we do understand the devastating impact on people’s lives.
All buildings are now considered based on the risk presented to those living in them. As part of that, we have announced targeted funding for buildings under 11 metres with the highest risk so that the cost of fixing cladding on those buildings does not fall on the leaseholders. We will always ensure that developers pay their fair share towards making buildings safe. We have already agreed stretched targets for developers to accelerate work to assess and remediate buildings and we will hold them to account on their progress.
Jim Dickson (Dartford) (Lab)
Over the weekend, in Ebbsfleet in my constituency we saw the damage that a fire in a residential block can cause. I express my concern for those in Bodycomb Street who were harmed in that fire or have been displaced by it. Another block nearby, Heron Court, has recently had a waking watch imposed on it by FirstPort, with the costs accruing to residents. Do not those two instances underline for everyone in the House how important it is that we get the Bill through Parliament so that we can get some recompense and support for residents who are suffering under the current regime?
I am really sorry to hear about the situation in my hon. Friend’s constituency. Since the Grenfell tragedy, many hon. Members across the House have had similar experiences of fires, including fatalities. As I outlined in terms of the thousands of buildings that need remediation, that is one thing that weighs heavily on my mind every night as Secretary of State. I would not want my family to be in a property that was unsafe. That is why the Bill is so important. He made an important point about waking watches, which I will come to further into my speech.
Shockat Adam (Leicester South) (Ind)
Although only 10% of 394 developer-pledged projects have been completed, I believe that under the Bill resident management companies could face criminal charges while the developers who sign the pledges would not. Can the Secretary of State clarify whether that is the case?
We are trying to ensure that those who are responsible will be part of that. We know that manufacturers and so on have been using routes to try to get out of paying their fair share and doing what they need to do. This remediation Bill is about closing some of the gaps we see. I look forward to working with the hon. Gentleman as the Bill goes through the House.
We have also ensured that social housing providers have ambitious targets for the completion of all remediation work for which they are responsible. The data is clear that the action is working: since we published the remediation acceleration plan, remediation has been reported to be completed on over 470 more buildings. That is about 35,000 more residents who can at least feel safer in their homes.
May I press the Secretary of State a little further? In my constituency, there is a block of flats under 11 metres that has already been recognised as a priority, but the challenge is the release of that funding. Will she arrange to meet me or agree to look at that further?
My officials will have heard that call, and I or the Minister for Homelessness, Democracy, Communities and Faith, who is in her place, will be happy to meet my hon. Friend.
Coming back to the point made by my hon. Friend the Member for Dartford (Jim Dickson) about residents paying for costly waking watch patrols, we have provided an additional £62 million for fire alarms in buildings with defects. That will keep residents safe until remediation work is completed and save leaseholders about £280 a month.
We are also taking action on insurance. We will introduce secondary legislation to do two things: strengthen transparency and bring the insurance commissions ban into force. The ban will stop people—including freeholders and property managing agents—from passing those commissions on to leaseholders. That will end the incentive for unscrupulous landlords and agents to seek out unearned profits and simply pass the cost on to innocent leaseholders.
I thank the Secretary of State for her work on this. Some campaigners have raised concerns about past methods and how the Government have come to the conclusions on which they have legislated. There are concerns that legislation could be gamed by developers, making the situation much worse for residents. I would be grateful for clarification on that.
We are establishing a single, consistent approach to assessing external walls so that buildings are judged on the same basis. Central to that is PAS 9980, which will become the required standard for fire risk appraisals of external walls.
Before the end of the year, we will bring forward the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, which will put power back in the hands of residents and tackle unfair costs and charges. We will cap ground rents at £250 a year before reducing them to a peppercorn after 40 years, and also cap administration fees.
I welcome the Secretary of State back to the Cabinet. It took months of legal wrangling and court time to secure a £1 million refund for leaseholders and £9 million in remediation works on Empire Square in Southwark. Although I fully support the Government’s action to tackle freeholder delays and neglect, as well as some of the charges, will she set out how some of the penalty amounts in the legislation were set? The sum in clause 6 is capped at £14,000, which seems very low, given the overall sums involved. How is the Department working with leaseholders and other stakeholders to set fees that allow us to go at the pace required to deliver on her ambition, and that of the Government?
This is about meeting the challenges that we face, and making sure that those who are not taking responsibility, do. I am happy to continue the conversations with my hon. Friend to make sure that we get that balance right; that is what we want. We want those people to take responsibility and carry out the remediation. The remediation Bill before the House is the next major step in ending the building safety crisis.
Tessa Munt (Wells and Mendip Hills) (LD)
I applaud what the Secretary of State is doing. However, would it not be sensible to stop the business of fire engineers, paid for by the building owners, using PAS 9980 to sign off dangerous cladding as acceptable, so that assessments confirm that buildings meet building regulations?
We are working on that. PAS 9980 is the established approach used across Government remediation programmes. It provides a robust and proportionate way of identifying the risk of fire spreading through a building’s external walls and the action needed to keep residents safe.
This is a rare opportunity to get direct answers from the Secretary of State in the House. That is not a reflection on her, but that is what we are here for. I have a constituent who is an expert on fire safety. We know that the Adam Kiziak forged EWS1 form has been a real issue, and that fire safety is now considered by measures of tolerability, rather than to the set standards. I raised that in a Westminster Hall debate with the Minister for Homelessness, because it is a real concern, and the Bill does not address all of it. Is that in the Secretary of State’s mind? Will she meet interested Members of Parliament—cross-party, because a number of us have this issue—and my very able constituent, Ian Abley, who is an expert on the matter, to discuss how we can future-proof the system? We cannot afford mistakes made as we try to solve the problems of the past.
My hon. Friend’s intervention shows that the remediation Bill is crucial to us meeting our ongoing challenges with the remediation acceleration plan. The relevant Minister will be happy to meet her to go through the specifics relating to fire safety and the regulations on that.
The Bill will help us complete the task of identifying all remaining buildings that require remediation. It will introduce a register of 11 to 18-metre buildings, giving Government a complete record for the first time of all medium-rise buildings in England. It will also mandate how external wall assessments are carried out, to ensure a nationally consistent approach to remediation. Also, for the first time, the Bill makes it indisputable that responsible entities have to remediate building safety defects with urgency through a new legal duty to remediate. They must take action now or risk severe consequences, including criminal charges where appropriate.
It is unacceptable that enforcement is too slow and penalties are too weak to compel those responsible to act. We will give regulators the tools that they need, including the ability to issue escalating financial penalties, and to pursue criminal prosecution in the worst cases. From now on, no building and no resident will be left behind. Our new remediation backstop will allow public bodies to step in and carry out remediation work themselves. That will mean that residents have a route to remediation, even when the responsible entity is determined to ignore its duty to keep residents safe.
James Naish (Rushcliffe) (Lab)
Exactly 12 months ago, I met the then Minister, my hon. Friend the Member for Chester North and Neston (Samantha Dixon), alongside the mum and brother of Amanda Walker. Amanda sadly took her own life as a result of the cladding scandal, which consumed her completely. Before her death, she gave evidence to the other place, seeking five changes, included closure of the loopholes that leave non-qualifying and enfranchised leaseholders exposed, and an industry-funded remediation scheme. I know the Secretary of State is aware of Amanda’s case. Will she consider Amanda’s asks as the Bill continues through this place?
I thank my hon. Friend for highlighting that case and the incredible work that the family have done. Today, I wrote to Amanda’s mother, who has been tremendous in making sure that some of the measures in this Bill were included. It is a devastating case.
Our measures will be backed by tough sanctions, including provisions for cost recovery and the sale of responsible parties’ interests in the building, so that they cannot benefit. We will also bring an end to indefinite decamps, in which residents are evacuated from their home and given no assurances about when they can return. We will empower residents to make sure that their buildings are safe, even when the responsible entity is absent, neglectful or insolvent.
The Bill is not just about getting the work done, but about making sure that the cost of the remediation work is borne by those who are responsible for the building safety crisis. That brings me on to construction product manufacturers who produced unsafe cladding, released it on to the market, and have yet to meaningfully contribute towards the remediation work. As well as being unjust, that puts additional financial pressure on those who are getting on with doing the work. The Bill will fix long-standing gaps in the law: developers, contractors and others who have paid to make buildings safe will be able to properly pursue manufacturers, rather than being blocked by technical legal barriers.
That is not all. I intend to table amendments, as the Bill passes through Parliament, that go further on construction product redress. Through the Bill, for the first time, we will require relevant construction product manufacturers to contribute towards remediation costs that are met by the taxpayer. It is not right that taxpayers should shoulder the burden on their behalf.
At the heart of everything that we do to make buildings safe are the residents and leaseholders who bear absolutely no responsibility for the building safety crisis, but who feel its most acute consequences. The most important thing that we can do for residents is remediate their homes as quickly as possible, to ensure that they are safe. This is not just a safety crisis; for many leaseholders, the presence of unsafe cladding on their home has had a terrible financial toll. Although the Building Safety Act 2022 protects the majority of leaseholders from substantial building safety costs, there are some groups who remain excluded, and who are exposed to remediation bills. Some are forced to pay higher insurance premiums until their buildings are made safe. As a member of this Government, who are committed to lowering the cost of living, I am not prepared to let that continue, so I can announce that the Government will go further than ever to shield leaseholders from the financial burden of this crisis. I am pleased to announce that this Government will commit grant funding towards the remediation of high-risk, high-cost internal fire safety defects in eligible collectively owned and enfranchised buildings. Those buildings do not benefit from existing protections because there is no separate freeholder to carry the cost. The funding will narrow the gap between leaseholders in such buildings and those already protected from remediation costs under the Building Safety Act, giving them greater certainty and support in making their home safe.
I thank the Secretary of State for her drive and determination on this very important matter. Will she give the House a little more detail relating to that group of residents and, in particular, those who face issues with dangerous materials inside their property, such as wood, which have led to a potential fire safety problem?
Again, I thank my hon. Friend for raising this issue. Hopefully, what I have said today goes some way to reassuring those who have raised that issue with us. Since my return to Government, my noble Friend Baroness Blake, who is watching the debate, and I have met End Our Cladding Scandal. We have heard the requests of its members and other leaseholders to expand the leaseholder protections in the Building Safety Act. We have also heard from those who bought their first home, only to find it was a non-qualifying lease. The Government will investigate whether we can extend the protection to any leaseholder who owns a lease on their only or principal home.
We have also heard those who have spoken about the plight of those with small portfolios who were excluded from protection. As the Bill passes through Parliament, I will table amendments to expand the protection from three to six properties. In our manifesto, we committed to reviewing how to better protect leaseholders from costs. These actions show that we are a Government who are committed to keeping our promises.
I very much welcome what my right hon. Friend just announced about those who have found themselves the owner of a flat that they did not know was non-qualifying, because of a previous owner. It is clearly unfair that they should be penalised. Will that measure be retrospective? I have a constituent who unknowingly bought a non-qualifying flat and was gobsmacked—traumatised, actually—to discover what had happened to him. He faces potentially huge costs. Will someone who is already in that position benefit from the measure?
We are hoping to make sure that nobody is left out, or left feeling those pressures. My right hon. Friend makes an important point. I outlined before that many of the groups we have met recently are making the case that we need to push harder on doing everything that we can. As the Bill goes through Parliament, the Building Safety Minister is happy to meet Members to see how far we can go, so that we can make sure that we are doing everything that we said we would do in our manifesto. We committed to accelerating the pace of remediation, better protecting leaseholders, and ensuring that those responsible for the crisis pay towards putting it right.
Our record since 2024 shows that we are getting on with the job, but there is still work to do, which is why, through the Bill, we will go further than ever before. Every building that we make safe helps to give those living in these flats and those looking to buy a home confidence that they are safe. This is about restoring trust in our housing market, protecting our communities and bringing an end to the building safety crisis, once and for all.
I pay tribute, once again, to the Grenfell community—the survivors and the families who were affected—and to all of us who have contributed to getting to this stage, with the Bill in front of us. I commend it to the House.
Katie Lam (Weald of Kent) (Con)
I thank the Secretary of State for her remarks. All of us, across the House, agree on the fundamental need to resolve this issue. As she movingly said, the appalling fire at Grenfell Tower and the resultant loss of life were horrifying. I join her in paying tribute to the victims, survivors and their friends and family.
We all agree that home is the place where people ought to feel safest. It is deeply concerning that so many people across the country still live in a home that has been rendered unsafe, and we welcome the Government’s desire to put that right. The Opposition have concerns about some of the Bill’s provisions, and about whether the proposed measures will definitely ensure that more people end up living in a safer home. I will set out some of those concerns. We look forward to working with the Government to improve the Bill however we can.
Remediation of unsafe cladding is often slow because there are simply not enough qualified people to do the work. This point has been mentioned by the hon. Member for Hackney South and Shoreditch (Dame Meg Hillier), but I will spend a moment on it. Every affected building needs a specialist assessment of its external walls, at a time when fire engineers and assessors are in short supply. Training new specialists takes years, yet the Bill does not lay out any particular plans for training those skilled professionals. Contractors face the same shortage of skilled labour and materials. Too often, owners who want to act cannot find anyone to carry out the work.
Remediation is slow because the work is complicated and unpredictable. When old cladding is removed, contractors regularly find further defects, so the scope, cost and delays grow. On top of those practical difficulties, many of the buildings concerned are part-owned by their leaseholders.
Remediation is also slow because when it comes to the practical implementation of the legal regime, the situation is fragmented. Implementation is managed building by building, and the responsibility is split between owners, managing agents, contractors and three overlapping regulators. Unsurprisingly, that drives up costs and drags out timelines, however willing the owners are. The Bill’s answer is to ask the three regulators to write a statement on how they will co-operate, which is not the same as getting the work done.
We already have evidence that a legal obligation, such as the one proposed in the Bill, does not by itself guarantee timely remediation. Developers on the developer remediation contract, which the last Conservative Government implemented so that developers, not taxpayers, would cover the cost of remediation, are already bound by equivalent requirements, which is why the Bill exempts them. The Government’s figures show that developers have finished work on only a third of their buildings, and fewer than one in four of all their buildings with life-critical defects.
Responding to the Public Accounts Committee, the National Fire Chiefs Council warned that limited workforce capacity was the primary bottleneck to remediation. The then NFCC chair, Mark Hardingham, put it best when he said that
“we cannot enforce our way out of the cladding crisis.”
I do not want to be party political—I think we all know that this was one of the biggest failures of regulation in many generations, and it has affected many people very badly—but this is a disappointment. I wonder if the hon. Lady can reflect, as she is new to her post and new in this Parliament, on how decisions sometimes need to be made early. James Brokenshire, a previous Secretary of State—sadly, he is no longer with us—made some bold decisions in the early days after Grenfell, but then there were delays in things like getting fire safety surveyors trained up, which takes three years. If those decisions had been made earlier, we would be in a better position now. In the spirit of trying to improve things, will she reflect on why those decisions were not made and why we need to back this Government Bill to make sure that we move as fast as we can?
Katie Lam
I think it is fair to say that there are all sorts of ways in which the response to this appalling event and the wider questions that it raised did not happen as quickly and was not as effective as we might have liked—otherwise, we would not still be discussing it today. What is important now is that we make sure that whatever plan we come up with together, as a Parliament, is as effective as it can be to make sure that people are living in the safest possible homes. That is our responsibility now.
It should not come as a surprise that legislating to make something true does not make it so. Passing a law that says that buildings must be fixed will not create a single new fire engineer. Rather than easing those practical bottlenecks, however, the Bill too often assumes that the main blocker to timely remediation is owners deliberately choosing not to act. Our fear is that, as drafted, the Bill may risk making the problem worse.
Under the Bill, every building must be assessed within a year, and every assessment that recommends work must be audited by Homes England, drawing on the same small pool of specialists. There are owners who obstruct, and they should face the full force of the law, but they are the exception, not the rule.
I say once again that I do not doubt that the intentions behind the Bill are noble, but we must always be careful that legislation, even when drafted with the best of intentions, does not produce unintended consequences. Perhaps the clearest risk of unintended consequences comes with the proposed new legal duty. Owners could face two years in prison or penalties of up to half a million pounds for deliberately failing to remediate as soon as reasonably practicable. Those standards—“deliberately” and “as soon as reasonably practicable”—are broad and subjective, particularly given the severity of the punishments prescribed by the Bill. Given that many of the decisions about whether owners have complied with the standards will fall to the regulator, can the Government be sure that due regard will be given to the real practical hurdles to remediation? What guidance will regulators get on what counts as “reasonably practicable”?
Doubtless the Government intend for these measures to be used only in the most extreme cases of deliberate obstruction or delay, but we must be incredibly careful when designing new legal duties and criminal penalties. Like it or not, these standards will hang over owners who are attempting to act in good faith, but who are constrained by the practical difficulty of remediation.
Likewise, opening up directors to personal prosecution on grounds of neglect risks generating unintended consequences. While directors’ liability for building safety is long established, the Bill goes much further. Have the Government assessed how many capable people will simply refuse to be named as directors on remediation compliance plans? What will it do to the cost of directors’ insurance? What impact will it have on the willingness of well-run management firms to get involved in residential property? How many will conclude that it is simply no longer worth the legal risk? Have the Government assessed whether the Bill will have an impact on access to directors’ insurance more broadly, and whether it could create a disincentive to involvement in residential property by well-run management firms?
Another point of concern derives from the Bill’s approach to group accountability for parent companies and firms that are deemed to exercise control. The Bill builds on powers in the 2022 Act, but extends them from recovering costs to imposing penalties for offences. The Government must do more to explain where this stops. In 2022, Parliament let a court or tribunal look through a company’s structure where it was just and equitable to do so. The Bill will allow a regulator to adopt quasi-judicial powers and enforce large penalties in doing so.
Limited liability is an important principle that, in its modern form, has endured in this country for more than a century and a half. It encourages investment and entrepreneurship. The erosion of limited liability that the Bill represents may set a worrying precedent. Until now, Parliament has qualified the principle only through the courts. The Bill qualifies the principle through regulators rather than judges. If that is acceptable in one sector, why not in others? Even if we confine ourselves to this sector, can the Government be sure that the erosion of limited liability will not create a direct deterrent to investment in large residential properties, including build to rent? Housing in this country is far too expensive for far too many people. People must be able to trust that their homes are safe, but they also need homes to buy or rent in the first place.
Another concerning legal precedent emerges from the Bill’s provisions on retrospective liability for product manufacturers. In 2022, the previous Government gave building owners a route to claim against the manufacturers of defective cladding. The Bill goes much further. It loosens the test itself, so that a product need only have contributed “more than trivially” to a building’s being unsafe. The Government must explain why the 2022 test was not enough. Complying with the regulations in force at the time will no longer be a defence; firms that followed the rules can no longer rely on having done so.
Nobody would deny the existence of bad actors—firms that have broken the rules or falsified evidence about their own compliance. Such firms have put people in danger, and some of the consequences have been unimaginably awful. They must be punished. However, there is no reason to believe that those firms would have complied had the legal standard been tougher. The point is that firms that break the rules are going to break the rules, no matter what they are. As is so often the case, the problem is one of enforcement. However, in an effort to tackle this non-compliant minority, the Bill extends retrospective liability well beyond what Parliament agreed in 2022—something that we must always be very cautious about doing. When firms or individuals cannot be sure that complying with the law today will ensure legal safety tomorrow, their behaviour can change. They may be more reluctant to enter the market in the first place, and will certainly be more reluctant to innovate. Insurers will price in that risk, and every new home will cost more to build.
As with so many aspects of the Bill, the Government, in attempting to achieve a noble aim, risk undermining important principles. The presumption against retrospective legislation, the principle of limited liability and the principle of clear legal tests are foundational to the way in which we have designed the law in this country. Of course, we can deviate from them—in our country, Parliament is sovereign and can make whatever law it chooses—but when we do deviate, we ought to ensure that we do so with a full appreciation of the facts and implications. It ought to happen only when we can see no other way to solve the problem at hand, and only when we are sure that new legislation, rather than better enforcement or efforts to ease practical bottlenecks, is the right course of action.
I reiterate my appreciation for the intention behind the Bill. That anybody should feel unsafe in their own home because of structural or material faults is a profoundly depressing state of affairs. However, we are concerned that, in pursuing this noble aim, the Government may not have given due regard to some of the unintended consequences of the solutions they propose. As the Bill progresses, we will probe all those points and more. We look forward to working, with the same noble aim, to improve the Bill however we can.
Joe Powell (Kensington and Bayswater) (Lab)
I wish we did not have to be here debating this Bill today—first and foremost because we are doing so largely due to the Grenfell Tower fire, more than nine years ago. It is right that we again remember the 72 who lost their lives in an entirely avoidable fire, and recognise the suffering that the bereaved, survivors and Grenfell community in my constituency continue to endure.
I place on record my thanks to the Prime Minister for his commitment, at Prime Minister’s questions two weeks ago, to work with me every day for justice for the victims. I also thank the Secretary of State for her determination to find solutions across Government that will implement the Grenfell inquiry recommendations and make necessary changes to how our state functions, including on building safety. Our hope and expectation is that those responsible will face the full force of the law by May next year, when the Crown Prosecution Service makes its charging decisions on the 20 organisations and 54 individuals passed to it by the Metropolitan police. While we wait, almost 10 years on, for justice through criminal accountability, we must also pursue justice through meaningful change in policies, laws and culture. That is how I approach the Bill.
The second reason I wish we were not here is that I believe many of the provisions in the Bill should have been enacted a long time ago and, at very least, should have been part of the Building Safety Act 2022. How is it that, in a similar timeframe since Grenfell, the state of Victoria in Australia has completed works on 99% of the 1,600 buildings that needed remediation, while we have completed only 39% of 4,724 identified buildings? More have not even been assessed, which is something the Bill tries to address. In 2020, Victoria passed a law setting up a group that assessed all buildings over three storeys, identified those at risk using a common state-prescribed standard and then paid for the work via an up-front fund, in part capitalised by developer contributions.
What the hon. Member is saying is excellent. Does he accept that there is a cultural issue here? The dangerous cladding on Grenfell, as in many other places, was dismissed as being unimportant because the people living there were often poor, working-class families, and they were simply not cared about. I hope that the Bill will change that culture, as well as bringing safety to an awful lot of people.
Joe Powell
The right hon. Gentleman is absolutely right. Residents who raised concerns were ignored, and the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea made a decision to cut costs that resulted in the contract that ended up being a major contributory factor in what happened. I have not had the chance to say this on the record, but I am pleased that one of the individuals involved in that is no longer at the Barnet tenant management organisation. That decision was wrong, and it has been corrected. I am glad that that has been done.
In short, in Victoria the government stepped in and put homeowners and residents first. In this country, the previous Government took a market-based approach that has comprehensively failed to deliver remediation in a timely way. Why? It is because, for too long, the British state has been too passive in the face of this problem, relying on private developers to come up with the answers while millions of people suffer the consequences. The British state’s response to the cladding scandal has exposed many of the weaknesses that this Government want to fix: unaccountable power, opaque ownership and a shirking of responsibility; penny-wise cost cutting that stores up massive costs in the future; and a lack of public control over the basics of life, including housing.
I hope that the Bill will contribute to that effort by creating more jeopardy for those delaying remediation and more options to finally fix every building that needs it, but the work to make buildings safe must continue even while we debate the Bill. Existing powers such as remediation orders and remediation contribution orders can be useful tools if Ministers provide a hands-on grip on the crisis by co-ordinating local remediation plans, creating national standards and ensuring that tomorrow’s Budget continues to fund the Department to get the work moving now. We need belatedly to shift to a “fix first and fast” model based on risk, as the Secretary of State said, leveraging all existing avenues to get work started.
I concur with my hon. Friend’s tribute to those who lost their lives in the Grenfell tragedy and to their loved ones. I remember the shock in this place when that tragedy happened.
I have a real concern about tolerability and how fire safety is assessed. This is something that built up over generations, and my hon. Friend gave a summary of it. Decisions on building safety were left to the wrong people; there was no outside inspection. Tolerability is a subjective standard, rather than a safe set of fixed standards. Does my hon. Friend have anything to say about that? We need to be clear as we go forward about fixing that problem and ensuring that it is not down to individuals. Some developers cherry-pick who will assess the building safety of a block, knowing that some people will pass it when others would be more rigorous. That is not an acceptable situation.
Joe Powell
My hon. Friend makes a powerful point. At the very least, there needs to be independent scrutiny of these assessments so that people can feel reassured that someone is checking whether they pass muster. It should be about the whole of the building being made safe—I think the Secretary of State referred to that. Cladding defects are an extremely important component, but there are internal fire defects that also need to be assessed, which have contributed to rising costs.
I welcome the remediation backstop in the Bill that will give Homes England and local authorities the power to step in, but that should not only be a tool of last resort. It should be something that gets the system moving as quickly as possible, because leaseholders in particular have ended up shouldering the burden in recent years. To give one example—others have already spoken about leaseholders they represent—residents at Shaftesbury Place in Earl’s Court approached me in 2024 after receiving huge increases in their service charge, driven by a disputed fire risk assessment which led to a massive spike in insurance premiums for the building from £15,000 a year to £310,000. The following year it went to £375,000. For one leaseholder, their annual bill for the insurance went from £269 to £4,146.
The landlord, Notting Hill Genesis, which is in a shared ownership scheme, told leaseholders that the insurance rise was linked to a fire risk assessment that it had commissioned, but residents disputed it alongside the classification of the building as high-rise. In fact, it had even miscalculated the number of storeys in the building when it did the assessment, which obviously undermined confidence in that assessment. The Building Safety Regulator later agreed and removed the building from the high-rise register. Until recently, several residents were still receiving legal threats about the non-payment of those charges, causing them huge worry and anxiety—let alone their concerns about the value of their investment in the shared ownership scheme.
My hon. Friend is generous in giving way. The insurance issue is a big concern—it is something the Treasury Committee is looking into. Does he not agree that there is a problem with the industry? The premiums have gone up exponentially, and although there is an increased risk, the likelihood of it crystallising has not been proved to be as high as the insurance industry has said. Does my hon. Friend have any further thoughts on that?
Joe Powell
My experience from this case corroborates what my hon. Friend says. I met the Association of British Insurers, and the scheme it introduced subsequently kicked in and has in the last year brought down the buildings insurance, but only by about half—certainly not to anywhere near what it used to be. I hope that Ministers can look at insurance when thinking about protecting leaseholders from higher costs.
The end of the story for the building is that, following pressure from me and my team and from organisers in the building, Notting Hill Genesis has finally agreed to reimburse all the residents. It will repay the difference in the increase for the past several years. I thank Thomas, Hamid, Ian and all the other residents in that building for their work. That is just one example of what is happening in building after building across the country.
I welcome the Bill in the sense that it is an opportunity to fix some of the flaws left by the previous Government and to create a better system, including through the register, a consistent approach to external walls in fire risk assessments, and by listening to campaigners across the country, such as End Our Cladding Scandal, who have helped to give a voice to those most affected. I know that they will have the ear of the Secretary of State and Ministers as the Bill continues its passage.
Clearly, one element at the heart of the Bill is who should pay. I agree that it is high time that the construction product manufacturers who contributed to the cause of this crisis should pay towards resolving it. I really welcome part 5 of the Bill, which strengthens and extends provisions in the Building Safety Act on retrospective liability for cladding products, and the Secretary of State’s announcement today on the Government’s intention to go further. The Grenfell inquiry found that companies including Arconic, Kingspan and Celotex engaged in systematic dishonesty and deliberate manipulation of testing that misled buyers into thinking their products were safe. It is extraordinary that, aside from their payments into a civil settlement, these companies have not paid towards resolving a crisis of their making. In Arconic’s case, its civil settlement was overwhelmingly covered by its insurance and was dwarfed by the payment it made to its own shareholders in compensation.
It is clearly not right that leaseholders, taxpayers and even the developer levy should shoulder the bulk of the costs, while companies such as Arconic do not. That is yet another reason that they should be nowhere near public contracts and supply chains, especially while criminal investigations are ongoing. I know the Secretary of State is committed to working across Government to use every procurement power the Government have to ensure that that is not happening, and I will fully support her in that goal. I also look forward to the new system of construction products regulation being implemented, with consistent safety standards and a single products regulator under the Building Safety Regulator; that will make a big difference.
I am glad that protection from costs for leaseholders has been discussed in the Bill and the debate so far. They are not responsible for this crisis, yet they are the ones picking up the bill in far too many cases. I hope these new powers will give local remediation efforts such as the London Joint Remediation Partnership Board an extra tool to do the building-by-building analysis that cuts through the bureaucracy and delays to find a solution.
I am sure that the communities who have enfranchised their buildings or exercised right to manage will be really pleased to hear the announcement today on ensuring that they are protected. We want more leaseholders to take control of their buildings, appoint their own agents and run their own affairs. We will see more in the leasehold Bill soon, and it is right that the Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill should provide some consistency in protecting them, too.
The building safety crisis has become one of the defining symbols of state failure in the past decade. The entirely avoidable tragedy of Grenfell and the loss of 72 lives should have been a catalyst to making buildings safe as quickly as possible and recovering the costs later. Of course, if we had listened to the coroner after the Lakanal House fire in 2009, not only may it have been possible to prevent the Grenfell fire, but we could have put a halt to new build flats across the country being constructed with cladding that was putting lives at risk. Judge Frances Kirkham said then that approved document B of the building regulations concerning external fire spread, fire-resisting properties and cladding panels should be reviewed. That simply did not happen in the way it should have done, as the public inquiry found.
That missed opportunity is devastating for the Grenfell families but it is also devastating for everyone who bought a flat across the country in a building that could have been built or refurbished differently if that recommendation had been implemented. Think of the billions of pounds wasted that could have been invested in building more homes, including social and affordable homes. That is why I will continue to campaign for a national oversight mechanism to ensure that there is independent scrutiny of recommendations of inquests and inquiries, so that change actually happens. I am delighted that the Prime Minister, the Secretary of State and the Minister are supportive of that effort, and I hope we can now make rapid progress towards setting it up.
The Prime Minister said something at the homelessness summit on Monday that really resonated with me: “names not numbers”. He was talking about how to best support people off the streets. We need a similar approach to this crisis. Behind every statistic is a family who are stuck, who cannot sell their home, who are worried about the value of their main asset and who have had to take on another job of chasing for answers about when the work will be finished, all while they suffer the anxiety of living in an unsafe building.
I hope today marks a shift in approach under a Government who I know are absolutely committed to doing all they can to end this scandal once and for all. The new tools in this Bill will certainly help, and the ones announced at the Dispatch Box today will help even further. With the Prime Minister, the Secretary of State and the ministerial team providing the leadership that this crisis needs, I am sure we can right the wrongs of the previous approach and deliver the solutions that so many people across the country are crying out for.
I call the Liberal Democrat spokesperson.
Gideon Amos (Taunton and Wellington) (LD)
As we remember the 72 victims of Grenfell and the many who are still waiting for justice, I know the Secretary of State and Members from across the whole House share the same commitment to do right by them, to ensure such a calamity never happens again, and to do better for all the leaseholders and residents living with unsafe cladding through no fault of their own.
We need a Bill that will, once and for all, make people’s homes not just safer but as safe as their residents have a right to expect them to be. The Liberal Democrats remain committed to getting the removal of unsafe cladding urgently and by a statutory deadline, to getting remediation to the right safety standard—the one that building regulations were uprated to post-Grenfell—and to residents not having to pay a penny towards fixing a crisis not of their own making. We will look at the amendments that have just been outlined, and we look forward studying them when they come forward. Sadly, as the Bill stands it does none of those things and, because of that, it is substandard and needs radical improvement.
On the plus side, let me be clear about the positive aspects of the Bill that we support. We support the legal duty for responsible entities to remediate, including the important extension of the duty in relation to buildings of 11 to 18 metres in height. We support the stronger intervention powers for housing authorities and the regulator against the blockers, such as through remediation management orders. We support making it easier to bring claims against cladding manufacturers, and we support requirements to have fire risk assessments of external walls and associated registers.
For those reasons, we have not gone as far as tabling a fatal amendment, despite the very serious flaws, as we see them. It would be wrong to deny support to any leaseholders or residents who without this Bill would get less help, but I call on the Government to consider seriously the degree to which the Bill is lacking. While I do not doubt the sincerity of the Secretary of State or the Bill, the Government need to think harder and bring forward amendments that are urgently needed to strengthen the Bill. In the stages that follow Second Reading, we will be suggesting and proposing changes, and working with the Government as constructively as we can to get the improvements that we believe are necessary.
Where does the Bill fall short? First and foremost, it enshrines into law the discredited publicly available specification 9980—PAS 9980—approach. As shown in clause 44, that will allow cladding of “tolerable” risk of combustion to remain on homes after they have been remediated. One may expect “tolerable” risk to be no more than the level of risk allowed in new buildings under the building regulations, as tightened up after Grenfell, but as the hon. Member for Hackney South and Shoreditch (Dame Meg Hillier) has already alluded to, it is not that standard. In this Bill, remediation will be only to a standard that a fire risk assessor decides is “tolerable”. We are talking about fire risk assessors paid by building owners, who are more likely than not to have commercial interests in doing as few works as possible to their building. While I am sure that most assessors are reliable professionals, given that the Grenfell inquiry report chaired by judge Sir Martin Moore-Bick cited “commercial interests” in this area of work as one of the contributory factors to the fire, is retaining commercial interests in the system of fire risk assessment, assessors and building inspectors a risk worth taking?
The hon. Gentleman and I have common cause in this respect, and I rely on the expertise of my constituents in this matter. The PAS 9980 approach was not reassuring for insurers. There was a big problem with insurance anyway, but PAS 9980 does not solve it, because it does not give insurers the certainty they need to do the risk assessment. I am not here as an apologist for the insurance industry—in fact, there are many issues that we will be taking up with that industry—but this approach is not the answer. Given his level of deep expertise in this matter before he came to the place, what would the hon. Gentleman propose instead? Is there an amendment to the Bill that he and the Government could coalesce around and reach agreement on?
Gideon Amos
The hon. Member is very kind—I am sure my experience is as great as many other Members of the House. I am coming to what we believe would be a preferable standard. Our approach is that these issues of “commercial interests” should be expunged from the Bill, and that the tolerability approach should be removed. We believe that existing homes and buildings should be remediated to meet the standard of fire safety required in the building regulations that were uprated in 2018, after Grenfell.
Vikki Slade (Mid Dorset and North Poole) (LD)
Although this Bill is specifically about the remediation of cladding, this issue goes further. Building control is typically undertaken or at least instructed by the local planning authority, and is now instructed and employed by the developers. When my constituents Trisha and Ray moved into their new build in Wimborne, they found that the structural issues in their property had not been independently signed off. They have now found that no one has access to the structural drawings of their building other than the inspector, so when they had problems with their roof, the council had no details, they could not access details and they could not check compliance. Does my hon. Friend agree that, for the protection of residents, an ethical wall needs to be created between developers and inspectors, with proper enforcement and mandatory Housing Ombudsman Service membership for developers?
Gideon Amos
I certainly support my hon. Friend’s plea. I will come to the issue of the independence of building inspectors, which is very important.
Let me return to standards. The building regulations are the standard that the Government have set; they are needed for newly built homes to be safe, so the same standard therefore has to apply to the homes that people already live in. I have visited high-rise apartments in London and elsewhere, and seen them covered in scaffolding and being remediated under the developer scheme, but many of them are being left with so much cladding breaching building regulations and fire safety standards that residents cannot get insurance.
It is the insurance that really gives the game away. If the building really was safe, why would the insurance premiums be so high? We have increases in insurance costs of 56% and higher. For that reason, many owners cannot sell or get a new mortgage, so they sink into negative equity and become mortgage prisoners in their own home.
The hon. Member is making a very important point. Does he agree that the high insurance costs are in no way caused by any action taken by the residents who are forced to pay them? In all honesty, they deserve compensation.
Gideon Amos
Absolutely. The right hon. Gentleman almost read the next line of my speech—I do not know how he did that from his seat over there.
Leaseholders and residents should not have to pay a penny for defects that were not their fault. Thousands of pounds extra in insurance are being paid by completely innocent homeowners to compensate for a safety standard that, while of course is better than nothing, is quite frankly not the standard that it should be—and that is after remediation to the standard has been carried out through this Bill. Meeting the established building regulations standard would perhaps cost more, but why should residents be condemned to live in buildings remediated to a lesser standard than the one that we consider safe for new homes?
The profit motive needs to be expunged from building inspector services generally, and the Bill fails to do that. We need to remove commercial interests from building inspectors and fire risk assessors by placing them all under a publicly controlled, non-profit making authority. There is still no statutory certification requirement for a competent person to become a fire risk assessor. When will those measures be brought forward, as has been promised in previous legislation?
The second big omission is that this Bill provides no more funding for those in buildings under 11 metres in height now that the funding window has closed. While medium-rise buildings come more firmly into scope, which is welcome, why should any residents be forced to pay to put right bad practice that was not their fault? Leaseholders in Taunton and Wellington and across the country are already paying ground rents that are too high to absentee landlords for nothing in return, as abolishing residential leasehold seems to recede further and further into the future.
The Bill fails to give residents the right to see their building’s fire risk assessment and to give local authorities the resources to deliver the new enforcement duties. It also fails to commit the Government to making manufacturers—those that make unsafe products that cause fire—pay. That leaves the onus on others to pursue them through slow and costly court action. It is our position that, in those ways, the Bill fails to fully implement the Grenfell Tower inquiry recommendations. Finally, there is no deadline in the Bill by which all the defects revealed by Grenfell across the tall buildings estate will be put right.
The fire safety of all homes needs to meet the standard that we require for new homes. Existing residents are no less worthy of that than the residents of future homes, who will benefit from the building regulations standard. The commercial interests that ran rife in building safety inspections in the lead-up to Grenfell need to be rooted out once and for all, and residents and leaseholders must not be expected to pay a penny towards repairing a crisis they are completely innocent of causing. We must make homes fully safe under building regulations revised for that purpose; make oversight and inspection independent, not profit-dependent; hold developers and manufacturers to account by pursuing them for the costs; protect leaseholders, including those in buildings under 11 metres; and put residents at the heart of remediation, so that they can see the assessments of their homes and have a real, statutory deadline. That is the Bill that the House needed to see today, and it is the Bill we will work hard to shape through its remaining stages.
Jack Abbott (Ipswich) (Lab/Co-op)
I thank the Secretary of State for the intent she has shown in the Bill that is before us. It is a privilege to be sat next to my hon. Friend the Member for Kensington and Bayswater (Joe Powell)—I know that his mission in this place is to fight for justice for so many of his constituents who have been left alone for so long.
Across the country, far too many lives have been ruined by the building safety crisis. In Ipswich, we have hundreds of residents who have endured years of fear, uncertainty and immense financial hardship. These are people who did everything right—worked hard, saved for a deposit and bought somewhere to call home—only to discover that their home was unsafe. Since the day of the Grenfell Tower tragedy, in which 72 people lost their lives—each entirely avoidable, as my hon. Friend the Member for Kensington and Bayswater said—leaseholders across the country have been left in limbo. What should have been a catalyst for change instead became a straitjacket for so many people who do not know whether they are safe, whether they will lose their home, or whether they will be forced to pay tens of thousands of pounds to put right failures they did nothing to cause.
I have spoken to plenty of residents in my constituency of Ipswich about their experiences. Their stories—like, I am sure, so many we will hear this afternoon—are devastating. They cannot sell their home, cannot move, and cannot move on with their lives. Their entire financial future is at stake, but so too is their mental health and peace of mind. Some have considered bankruptcy just to get out; others have thought about handing back the keys and simply walking away. It is heartbreaking that anyone should reach that point through no fault of their own.
I want to highlight a few of the buildings that we in Ipswich have been facing issues with for many years, beginning with St Francis Tower. Remediation work on that building started in 2018, and residents spent years living under shrink wrap as it dragged on. My right hon. Friend the Minister for Housing visited St Francis Tower in a previous life, when I was a candidate and he was a shadow Minister, and we could not see natural daylight through the shrink wrap. Even when that was replaced, the work dragged on and on, and in July 2023, flooding forced those poor people from their homes after years of misery. Years of disruption were followed by the trauma of evacuation.
My team and I worked with residents and the Government to secure funding for repairs in November 2024. That was an important step forward that replaced the outer cladding, but the internals are still damaged, and three years on, people have not yet been able to return to their homes. Although I am hopeful that there will be good news in the coming weeks, even if remediation work is able to start in the weeks before Christmas, it is unlikely that those people will be able to return to their homes until spring 2028—a decade after work on the building first started. Residents should never have been put in that position. Nobody should have to fight for something as basic as a safe home, but these people cannot even live in their homes.
At Churchmans House, investigations revealed problems extending beyond external cladding—missing fire barriers and inadequate protection around structural steelwork. Leaseholders faced demands for eye-watering payments and the threat that they might have to leave their homes. The original developer was insolvent and people who had done nothing wrong were left facing the consequences, a story that we hear over and over again. The good news is that our Government confirmed funding for the necessary works to make the building safe, but not before months and years of worry. Unfortunately, residents of Cardinal Lofts were not so lucky. I cannot believe that such a building was ever deemed fit for habitation; if a fire broke out there, it would have ripped through the entire building because of a lack of compartmentalisation. People unknowingly slept in their beds every night—some for decades—without knowing how deeply unsafe their building was and how much of a threat to their lives it posed. No one ever never returned to Cardinal Lofts. The building is not fit for use.
These are different buildings with different owners, but the same injustice is shared by so many people, in Ipswich and across the country, and I could name many other buildings in our town that have been subjects of the same stories. People bought those homes in good faith, but were sold something faulty, and they should never have been left with the costs of putting things right. That is why the Bill is so important. For the first time, those responsible will face a clear legal duty to identify and remediate unsafe cladding in residential buildings. Building owners and others with repairing responsibilities must act. That means an end to indefinite delays as residents live with fear and financial uncertainty, trapped in unsafe buildings. Crucially, those who ignore their responsibilities may face substantial financial penalties, criminal prosecution and further enforcement action. Responsibilities can be enforced, and there will be consequences for those who ignore them.
The remediation backstop is particularly important: when building owners fail to act, Homes England and local authorities will be able to step in, arrange repairs, and recover costs from those responsible. That matters enormously to people trapped in the middle of endless arguments over who should do the work. I also welcome measures to secure contributions from manufacturers whose unsafe construction products contributed to this crisis.
We were elected to accelerate remediation and protect leaseholders better, and the Bill is an important step forward in the delivery of that promise. It builds on the remediation acceleration plan, which is already helping thousands of people across the country to live in safer homes. Alongside it are the plans announced by the Government to extend leaseholder protections and support necessary fire safety works in eligible buildings owned collectively by residents.
I would like to take this opportunity to thank the Ipswich Cladiators, and the many, many residents of our town who have campaigned so tirelessly for change—not just for themselves but for their neighbours, their communities and people across the country. They should never have had to fight so hard, and we cannot give them back the years that they have all lost, but we can maintain a relentless focus on making their homes safe, protecting them from unfair costs, and helping them to move forward. That is what they deserve, and that, with this Bill, is what the Government are doing.
Mr Will Forster (Woking) (LD)
Before I speak about the Bill and wider issues in the construction industry, let me say that my thoughts and prayers are with the loved ones of the 72 people who lost their lives in the Grenfell fire. Earlier today the Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee was carrying out a review of fire and rescue services, and, unsurprisingly, building safety and Grenfell were covered., I appreciate that the Bill focuses on building and construction practices—among other issues—and not really on fire services, but I was surprised and disappointed to hear earlier today from the head of His Majesty’s inspectorate of constabulary and fire and rescue services that it had not been consulted about it at all. Firefighters put their lives in danger to cope with and tackle the failures in the construction industry, and I hope that the Minister will agree to consult the inspectorate on the Bill to ensure that any amendments are approved by it. That would also give the inspectorate an opportunity to suggest amendments.
My constituency of Woking has been plagued by three big building safety and construction issues. In 2023, 100 residents of the Eastgate building in Woking were evacuated from their homes after structural defects were found. To this day, Eastgate stands empty—a visual reminder of how our building safety system has failed. Southern Housing, which manages Eastgate, says that it is structurally unsafe, and Barratt, which built it, says that it is safe. After the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government and I became involved last year, independent testing was carried out, and I am grateful to the Government for supporting me in that effort. The new testing on the building was completed many months ago, but the results have still not been released. There is no way that both sides can be right in that situation. I do not know what they are hiding, but this needs to be resolved immediately. Residents deserve to know what is going on. Either residents need to be allowed back in, or the developer needs to rebuild Eastgate and pay compensation. Will the Minister meet me and force the results of the testing to be released?
Sadly, Woking’s building safety issues and construction failures go beyond our homes. The Victoria Square development, which is a new shopping centre with residential towers and a hotel, was built by Sir Robert McAlpine several years ago. It was due to open in October 2020, but following problems with broken cladding fixtures on the Hilton hotel, it finally opened four years after that. The main A road that goes through Woking town centre had to repeatedly close due to the cladding failures, and this caused significant financial losses to local businesses and residents. Thankfully, the road has now reopened, and the cladding panels have been properly secured. Under the common law on negligence, purely economic losses are not recoverable. The formerly Conservative-run borough council could have ensured that this was covered through contract law, but it did not do so. Why is that not standard practice for building projects? Will the Minister amend the Bill, so that any losses consequent on dangerous cladding failures, such as those experienced by businesses and residents in Woking, are paid for by developers like Sir Robert McAlpine?
There is one final building safety issue in Woking that I wish to speak about, and it involves the estate where I grew up. Lakeview in Goldsworth Park is made up of mainly four-storey maisonettes. Woking borough council recently discovered that the cladding is dangerous, and quickly took steps to make it as safe as possible. The council created a plan for a comprehensive refurbishment and a long-term solution to the cladding problems on the estate. I congratulate and thank the council, especially the portfolio holder for housing, Councillor Ian Johnson, and the strategic director for housing, Louise Strongitharm, for their tireless work on this issue.
Although we are getting the right result in Lakeview, what happened on my old estate shows why we as a country need to take building safety much more seriously, and need to agree to legislative changes. Most properties in Lakeview are council homes, but there are almost 100 privately owned leasehold properties in the area. Leaseholders will be charged for the refurbishment but, quite rightly, not for the cladding works. That construction work and refurbishment is planned to start in early January. If it was a private development, leaseholders would slowly pay into a sinking fund, but local authorities are banned from running such a fund. Will the Minister not only lift the ban on local authorities having a sinking fund, but mandate them to have one, so that what happened to leaseholders in Lakeview does not happen again?
Those three examples from Woking show that this Bill does not go far or fast enough, and it is not fit for purpose. As my hon. Friend the Member for Taunton and Wellington (Gideon Amos) said, we will not support it, but we will propose more amendments, to ensure that we genuinely tackle all the building safety issues facing Woking and constituencies across the country.
Darren Paffey (Southampton Itchen) (Lab)
Southampton Itchen is one of the places in Hampshire with the most buildings with unsafe cladding. As hon. Members have said so eloquently, that means people live with the worry that the horrendous tragedy that befell Grenfell all those years ago could well befall them. Even where there has been action, it is hardly ideal. Nearly 200 of my constituents are currently out of their home. They were evacuated in the spring and summer of last year, and they will not be able to return until the summer of 2028 at the earliest. This is the stark reality that drives the urgent need for this Bill, and it is why I very much welcome it.
I thank the Secretary of State and the Minister for bringing forward the Bill. Like other Members, I pay tribute to residents and campaigners, including those from End Our Cladding Scandal who supported one of the very first public meetings that I conducted as a new MP, and who have not let go of this issue over the years. Since I was elected, I have listened to residents who are affected by unsafe cladding on their buildings, pressed Ministers, and submitted evidence to the Public Accounts Committee’s inquiry on remediation. The Bill is the next instalment in resolving these ongoing issues; it will certainly not be the last. I want to acknowledge the real progress that it makes, but also ask for important clarification from the Minister.
Take Oceana Boulevard, a flagship development in the regeneration of brownfield sites in the centre of Southampton. It was built some 20 years ago, and its fire safety problems were first identified nearly 10 years ago. Since then, compartmentation works have been done, but that is all. Today, we have finally got in an application to the Building Safety Regulator, covering cladding, automatic opening vents and balcony remediation works, but—sadly, as we have heard, this is not an isolated story—there is still no agreement between the freeholder and the developer on who will pay for the non-cladding-related remediation, and none of that work is anywhere near starting.
In the meantime, as we all know, residents’ costs have been skyrocketing. Ellie bought her flat in Oceana Boulevard brand new. Her service charge and insurance rose from £1,500 a year to £6,000 a year, and she has not been able to keep up with the payments, so she has handed her home back to the bank. People are losing their homes, even if not to fire, because of these issues, which have taken far too long to resolve. For that reason, alongside this very welcome remediation Bill, we must with all urgency progress the draft Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, and the action that the Prime Minister recently announced on regulating managing agents.
Peter Fortune (Bromley and Biggin Hill) (Con)
The hon. Member is right to point out the stress on residents. Those at Northpoint in Bromley are part of a residents’ management company, but RMCs have no assets, so they lean into the service charges in order to pay some of the company’s liabilities. Would he agree with me that people in RMCs need to be protected as well?
Darren Paffey
We are all fighting for our constituents to be protected from the bills that are landing on them through no fault of their own. They certainly did not choose any of this. They want the simple comfort of having their own home, and they work incredibly hard to achieve that, yet look at where so many of them are.
I welcome the mandatory auditing of fire risk assessments to that all-important single standard. A dispute about what is wrong with a building must never again, as in the case of Oceana Boulevard, outlast a decade; there has been constant back and forth about whether the parties accept what they read in the fire engineer’s report. I certainly agree with the comments made by Members on both sides of the Chamber about people picking and choosing who to commission a report from. In some cases, it seems that they decide whether they like what they read in a report before commissioning a different one. That has to come to an end.
I welcome the message that waking watches are temporary. At Sirocco, a development in nearby Ocean Village, the residents paid for one for years. One of the residents, Ro, tells me that she had to use a freedom of information request just to see the fire risk assessments. Under this Bill, remediation plans have to be published, along with timelines and contacts. No resident should need an FOI request to learn the truth about their home.
I welcome the legal duty to remediate. Ben and his family have told me their story, and again, unfortunately, it is not the only time I have heard such a story. They have put their life on hold and have put off having more children—growing their family—because they cannot sell and move on. Since when should anyone’s life aspirations be subject to the stalling of these companies, many of which have literally not bothered to get their own houses in order? Sadly, being unable to sell and move on is a story I have heard many times, and which other hon. Members have repeated. Remediation work at the Blake building close by began only this summer. It certainly will not finish before next summer, four years after enforcement action was first taken. It is clear that delays cost, and it is far too often still the residents who pay those costs.
Deirdre Costigan (Ealing Southall) (Lab)
Much of what my hon. Friend is saying has echoes in my constituency. Residents in Hanwell Locks have been in a battle with Bellway over remediation works to their building. There has been an acknowledgment that works are needed, but there is no clear programme of works, and no progress at all. Those residents, like those in his constituency, are having trouble re-mortgaging or selling, and they are worried about the continuing fire risk. Does he agree that the remediation compliance plans required in the Bill and the strong financial penalties against builders will make a difference to our constituents?
Darren Paffey
I absolutely agree. As I will come on to say, it is simply unforgivable that too many companies still have no plan whatever for remediation, and people are paying the price, financially, but also with their life ambitions.
Shockat Adam
Does the hon. Gentleman share my concern that although the Government already have remediation orders, remediation contribution orders and the responsible actor scheme, the Property Institute says that it has seen absolutely no evidence that they have been used proactively, and that no developer to date has faced any consequences? The Bill must ensure that is addressed.
Darren Paffey
I certainly agree with the hon. Gentleman’s closing point. The Bill must fix that, which is why I welcome its progress, but like Members from across the Chamber, I will follow its progress very closely to ensure it is not just a Bill that gets a headline, but instead fixes things and gets things right.
The Blake building sits outside the developer contract, so this new duty will finally reach it. That is real progress from the Bill, but there are points on which residents still have questions, and campaigners are not yet convinced that all this goes far enough. I hope that the Minister will address some of those questions today.
First, most Ocean Village buildings are subject to the developer contract, but the Bill excludes them from the new duty because “equivalent requirements” are already in place; however, physical works have still not started on Sirocco, Moresby, Hawkins or Oceana Boulevard. We have heard different statistics, but those I am looking at tell me that nationally, there are over 2,500 buildings in that contract, but for 854 of them, work has not started and there is no plan in place—not a single plan between them. What will the measures mean for those living in buildings with no plan? It must mean progress. Should they not have audited assessments, published timetables and a backstop if a developer stalls? I hope that the Minister will confirm that Ocean Village residents will benefit from all three. The Bill rightly focuses on cladding, but residents live in whole buildings, and internal safety matters, too, so I very much welcome the announcement made at the Dispatch Box today. When it comes to filling that gap, I hope that as the Bill progresses, we will hear more detail about what the grant funding will cover.
Secondly, on enforcement, the Bill provides for prosecution, penalties of up to £500,000, and a backstop that allows Homes England or councils to step in, but as we all know, a power is only as good as the capacity to use it, and the route to the backstop will run through notices, representations and tribunals. How long will it take from first notice to a contractor on site? Will Homes England and councils such as Southampton city council be resourced to use that power?
Finally, and most practically for residents like Ben, is the question of when. The duty is to remediate
“as soon as reasonably practicable”,
but the detail is left to regulations. The Government’s 2029 and 2031 deadlines, already put forward in the remediation acceleration plan, do not appear in the Bill. I ask the Minister to add them; my constituents would find that reassuring. If she will not, can she commit to dated milestones, and a hard stop date in those regulations, so that 2029 is the final, legally enforceable deadline that constituents need, not just an aspiration?
Those who have been waiting years and cannot move on have asked if there is any way for the Government to buy back those homes while they are waiting. Now, I suspect that I know the answer, but I will ask—particularly as the Budget is tomorrow. The previous Chancellor amended some of the rules to ensure that council-owned properties are assets, not liabilities. By releasing people from the stalemate that they are in with their homes and families, could we be looking at assets that this Government, who need to build and own more housing, could very much use?
I will proudly support the Bill on Second Reading. For everyone who needs the Bill to be the strongest it can be, I will be glad to engage with Ministers and others as it progresses through the House. We need to fix all our buildings. We need to ensure that the work is paid for by those who were responsible for this sorry episode, which I believe is an absolute stain on our history. In doing so, we might just be able to give people their futures back—people like Ellie, Ro, Ben, the hundreds of others in Southampton Itchen, and the thousands more across the country whose stories have been told by Members across the House. They have all had enough and want an end to the nightmare. The Bill—if we do it right—gives them that hope.
Carla Denyer (Bristol Central) (Green)
As we approach 10 years since the Grenfell tragedy, I thank the Grenfell community and families for the tireless campaigning that they should not have had to do. I welcome the Bill as far as it goes. It includes important measures that are needed, but there remain serious concerns that it does not do enough for those still trapped by the terrible cladding scandal. The issue of the remediation of unsafe cladding in buildings of less than 11 metres is a big problem in my constituency, but it is not just a Bristol issue.
There are a number of medium-height blocks of flats in Bristol Central with flammable cladding. I am going to tell the story of just one of those flats. It is a mid-rise block that is part of a development of three blocks. The other two blocks are taller—over 11 metres. They have the same developer and were built at the same time. All the buildings have the same dangerous cladding; the taller two are eligible for the building safety fund, but the one that is under 11 metres is not. A leading specialist building surveyor has identified that the shorter building also has severe cladding deficiencies that are in urgent need of remediation.
Until recently, the flat was the home of a 97-year-old woman, who eventually moved into a residential home. Because she owned a flat, she was not eligible for a council-funded care home place, so her children needed to sell the flat to fund her care—except they could not. The Conservative Government’s position was that there is no systemic fire safety issue in buildings under 11 metres. In 2022, the then Government said that they had examined specific buildings under 11 metres and found that
“in the overwhelming majority of cases it has subsequently been confirmed that they do not require remediation.”—[Official Report, 26 March 2024; Vol. 747, c. 1419.]
The Labour Government under Keir Starmer maintained that position, stating in September 2024 that:
“the risk to life is usually lower in buildings under 11 metres, and they are very unlikely to need the same costly remediation.”—[Official Report, 11 September 2024; Vol. 753, c. 929.]
The result is that buildings under 11 metres are not eligible for funding under the building safety fund.
The catch? Try telling all that to the mortgage market. No lender will give a mortgage to a flat in a building with unsafe cladding, regardless of height. Therefore, the children of my 97-year-old constituent cannot sell the flat on the open market. They cannot persuade the company that holds the freehold to pay for the remediations from its own balance sheet—believe me, they have tried. That company has insisted that it will only fulfil its legal obligations and not spend a penny more, and based on the legislation, the company believes it is not liable. The building’s insurance policy will also not cover the cladding work.
Even if the owners of the five flats in this small block wanted to pay for the work themselves—which would be wholly unjust, because it is not their fault—as leaseholders, according to their lease, they are not permitted to contribute more than £15,000 per flat. It is estimated that the work would cost more than £1 million.
What are people meant to do? They are trapped in an intolerable Catch-22 situation. The two adult children of this 97-year-old woman were forced to buy the flat themselves in order to release the equity to fund her care. It is lucky that they could afford to do that, although “lucky” seems like a wild choice of word to describe their situation. They are now stuck in possession of an unsafe flat that they do not live in and never wanted to own, with no recourse to the developers, the insurance, the warrantees or anything else to rectify the cladding faults.
In July 2026, as we have heard, MHCLG launched a separate funding pot to address cladding fire safety risks in buildings under 11 metres, called the cladding safety scheme. The Government said that this delivered on their commitment in the remediation acceleration plan and supported a risk-based approach to remediation. However, the application window for the scheme was open for just three months. It has now closed. The management company of the building in my constituency has applied, but there has been no response, and there is apparently no guarantee of receiving this targeted funding.
The Bill before us proposes sticking with the Conservative and Starmer Governments’ insistence that “relevant buildings” means only buildings of 11 metres or more. Surely the Minister can see that that is not good enough.
I have a few questions for the Minister. First, is she confident that three months was long enough for 100% of those in charge of affected buildings under 11 metres to hear about the fund and apply to it? That includes both for-profit management companies, which, famously, can be pretty sluggish when it comes to repairs in their buildings, and internal management companies made up of owner-occupiers and leaseholders, who are often juggling flat admin alongside a full-time job and being a parent.
Secondly, is the fund large enough to cover all the affected sub-11 metre buildings? Thirdly, if the Government do not make funding available for all the affected sub-11 metre buildings, what will the Minister’s message be to the leaseholders of flats that do not receive the funding?
Finally, will the Minister take steps to end this funding lottery and ensure that the remediation of buildings below 11 metres is incorporated into the main Bill and is fully funded, and that there is a legal requirement on freeholders to do this work?
Mike Reader (Northampton South) (Lab)
Next June will mark 10 years since the Grenfell fire. As many have said, at the end of August this year, more than 2,000 residential buildings still had unsafe building cladding, with remediation not yet started. Behind that figure are tens of thousands of people who cannot sell their homes, get mortgages or get affordable insurance, and many who cannot sleep at night. Those people did nothing wrong; they bought a home in good faith, and they have been left carrying the consequences of the failures of others. That is why I welcome this Bill and will support it throughout its passage. At its heart, the Bill is about responsibility: who must act, who must pay and who must be protected.
I will start with the question of who it is that must act. For too long, the system has relied on expectations and good will. Building owners have been asked, encouraged and cajoled to get on and fix the problem, but many have chosen simply not to act. When we debated remediation in Westminster Hall in September, I argued that we had to move from targets to duties and ensure that any duties we set are enforceable.
The Bill does just that: it puts a clear legal duty on those who are responsible for a building to fix it; it gives regulators real power, backed by real penalties; and, where an owner will not act, it will let the local authority step in and get the job done. For residents who have spent many years being passed from freeholder to managing agent to developer and back again, that clarity will matter enormously.
The Bill also tackles something that has quietly undermined progress for years. We have heard today about buildings that sit in the middle ground and are not quite high rise. We still do not know where all these buildings are or who really owns them. A register of mid-rise buildings and new powers to find out who sits behind a building’s ownership will mean that owners are no longer be able to hide behind complex structures. A problem cannot be fixed if it cannot be seen, and someone cannot be held to account if they cannot be found.
The Bill will protect leaseholders by making sure that when a building owner is penalised for failing to act, the bill for fixing the issue cannot be passed back to residents through their service charges. The people who are failing must pay, and the people who have been failed must be protected.
That brings me to the part of the Bill that I have shown a particular interest in: part 5 on construction product liability. So far, the cost of fixing this crisis has fallen on taxpayers and developers. More than £5 billion of public money has been committed to remediation, but the manufacturers who sold the products that are now being stripped off buildings across the country have contributed next to nothing. That cannot be right.
The last Government recognised those principles in the Building Safety Act, but we have to be honest and admit that under its provisions many manufacturers were not held to account, many of the legal hurdles were too high and the claims were too few. Too many manufacturers were able to sit back, confident that nobody could prove enough to make them pay.
This Bill changes that. It shifts the test away from narrow technicalities about whether a regulation was breached and towards the questions that matter: was the product unsafe in the way that it was actually used, and was it marketed in a misleading way? It gives the courts the power to look inside these companies so that we can see what they knew and when they knew it. It also makes sure that corporate structures cannot be used to put assets beyond reach.
There is a really simple principle here—that the polluter pays. That approach is guided by the adage, “Fix it first and fast”. Residents should not be waiting for companies to argue over the bill. Buildings must be made safe now; the fight over who pays should happen afterwards—maybe in court, between the companies responsible, but not on the doorsteps of the people living with the consequences.
I ask the Minister to keep one point in mind as the Bill goes into Committee. Liability has to flow properly through the supply chain and the interface with other regulations, such as the legislation on defective products. If we extend liability at the top of the supply chain but it does not carry further down to the façade contractor and their supply chain and suppliers, we risk loading main contractors with liability while those who supplied or made the products are able to escape. Getting liability right all the way through the supply chain is critical to whether the Bill delivers real money for remediation or simply moves the risk around.
The Bill is a big step forward but it is not the end of the job. I want to raise two areas where there is more to do. I really welcome the Secretary of State’s announcement today from the Dispatch Box on enfranchised and non-qualifying leaseholders. These are people who were excluded from protections that many other leaseholders enjoy, often for reasons such as the date on which they bought their flat. I look forward to amendments coming forward to help shape those provisions further.
The second area is the people who made hay from this crisis. There are two groups who have done very well from building safety issues: insurers and lawyers. I have heard many people talk about the challenges of getting insurance for a building, but I have also heard from contractors and developers. I have heard of contractors who were encouraged to take out professional indemnity cover for works, only to find insurers using every single technicality to avoid paying. When I worked at Mace, I sat on the silver team on building safety, and we were faced with the complexity of working out where our liability sat and how we dealt with our insurers. Dealing with the complexities of product liability as a main contractor was something that gave a lot of people many nights of headaches, and it is an area that I do not think we are completely finished with.
We risk seeing contractors collapse if we do not fix this. I mentioned lawyers as well, because I have heard stories where the legal fees for trying to fix cladding have vastly exceeded the actual cost of fixing the cladding itself. That cannot be right. It is a scandal within the scandal. The Bill rightly opens up a stronger route to recover costs for manufacturers. It does not yet start to address those who make money out of this crisis, but it does ensure that the Government deliver a route for redress, not another payday. Every pound should be spent on making homes safer, not on lawyers’ fees and insurers’ delaying tactics.
Let me end where I began. The Bill puts responsibility where it belongs and makes sure that we are protecting those who need protection. It builds on and strengthens the work of the previous Government, but it rebalances power so that we can fix this crisis once and for all. I support the Bill and hope that the whole House will work to ensure that it passes quickly through this place—we need to see it become legislation, not be stuck in Committee—so that we can end the crisis of dangerous buildings in our country once and for all, and end this nightmare for all.
I start by adding my voice to the tributes paid by the Secretary of State and the hon. Member for Kensington and Bayswater (Joe Powell) to the victims and survivors of the Grenfell disaster. I will not forget waking up that morning and seeing that appalling tragedy unfolding on our television screens; many people across London will have felt the same. I welcome the Government’s attempts to ensure that such a tragedy does not happen again, but it is almost unbelievable that nine years later we are debating this particular bit of legislation in our collective effort to ensure that buildings can be made safe.
Like the Fire Safety Act 2021 and the Building Safety Act 2022, the Bill is a step in the right direction, but—again—it does not go far enough. As the hon. Member for Hackney South and Shoreditch (Dame Meg Hillier), who is no longer in her place, has raised repeatedly, the PAS 9980 regime, which allows a fire engineer chosen and paid for by the building owner to declare dangerous cladding tolerable and decide that no work is required, will remain in place. Would hon. Members in this House feel reassured if a fire engineer paid for by a building’s owner declared the cladding in their block of flats to be “tolerable”?
The anger that followed the Grenfell disaster was directed towards those in power who repeated the sentiments that officials had known about the dangers posed by unsafe cladding but did not care enough to act. Much of the feeling was that the people in Grenfell and others who lived in council housing did not matter enough for serious action to be taken to prevent such a disaster. That speaks to a wider issue that we in the House all need to work to address: accessibility to safe and secure housing.
New high-rise homes must be built with materials that do not burn. If combustible cladding is considered too dangerous for new high-rise homes, what reassurances does that provide to people living in “tolerable” levels of danger? That should not be our benchmark. All Londoners should be entitled to housing of a standard that is higher than tolerable.
In March 2026, the Government announced a new package of support for house building in London, which provided temporary relief from developer levies. However, BusinessLDN has highlighted that the costs associated with the community infrastructure levy relief included in the package would be offset in effect by the additional costs from the building safety levy in more than a third of cases. I welcome the Government’s intent to remediate building safety defects via the building safety levy, but the two policies seem to contradict each other. Just this morning, a headline in the Financial Times read, “Labour's housebuilding target effectively dead’. We should not be deciding between building houses and building safe housing.
If the Government’s assessment is that housing developments are being stalled in London due to costs, does more need to be done to incentivise developments following the introduction of the building safety levy? I would be grateful if in winding up the Minister could reflect on what the Bill’s measures on manufacturers and developers of construction products providing some of the costs towards remediating cladding mean for the building safety levy and the particular stress that is placing on house building in London.
The Minister and the Secretary of State will both know that Salford has had a large number of buildings affected by the building safety crisis. That has meant years of worry about safety for residents, who have often faced eye-watering bills they cannot afford or been trapped in a home they cannot sell—all for a crisis that they did not cause.
Before I move on with my contribution, I place on record my thanks to two key organisations and individuals. The first is Salford council. In the early days after the horrors of Grenfell, it was one of the first local authorities to act fast and think later in removing dangerous cladding from its council properties. It faced years of legal wranglings trying to recoup the costs from the developers, but it did the right thing and made sure that residents’ safety came first.
Secondly, I place on record my special thanks to two special individuals: Darren Matthews and Mandy Sandhu. They were the first residents to come to me about the building safety crisis and a building called Transport House. They led an amazing campaign when they were faced with eye-watering bills of £97,000 each to pay for building safety remediation in their building. They secured the costs that they needed to carry out the remediations from the developers and the Building Safety Fund, and they acted as an inspiration to many other campaign organisations across Salford—and there were many.
It is welcome to see the Government seeking to fill many of the apparent gaps in the Building Safety Act 2022. However, I will mention a few points that I hope the Minister and the Government will take forward as the Bill progresses through the House. First, on continued delays at the Building Safety Regulator, I know that the Government have introduced a plan to speed up applications, but in many cases it is not yet working. One building in Salford, Quebec Building, has faced significant delays. One resident there told me:
“Our mortgage interest is now 8.9%. Our provider refuses us a new product until remediations are done. We cannot sell as ‘non qualifying leaseholders’ as the status carries on for new owners which might mean liability for payment for some remediations. I am 65 years old and wanting to enjoy retirement and my husband has uncurable cancer and the stress is not helping. We just cannot sustain all this.”
I implore the Minister and the Government to review, as a priority, what the blockages are at the Building Safety Regulator and ensure that it is properly staffed and resourced to tackle the backlog.
Secondly, Salford has had huge issues with non-cladding-related fire safety defects, from non-compliant wooden balconies all the way through to insufficient internal fire doors. Residents have been left wrangling with developers in a David and Goliath-style legal battle, with the cost of temporary fire safety provisions ramping up service charges year on year and huge insurance bills to boot. Many have ultimately been forced to foot the bill for remediation themselves, which is simply unjust. The issue had already been raised in 2025 by the National Fire Chiefs Council, but the Bill still excludes non-cladding fire safety defects, so that must be addressed. I welcome the comments made by the Secretary of State at the Dispatch Box, as they suggest that the issue is on her radar. I look forward to seeing the details on that work going forward, and perhaps the Minister will divulge a little more detail in her summing up.
Thirdly, though the Bill places legal requirements on building owners and responsible entities, developers signed up to the developer remediation contract are exempt. I know why: because the Government assume that being part of the DRC is a sufficient carrot. Yet it is worrying, given that we know that the auditing of assessments at DRC buildings is very thin on the ground in practice, and as End Our Cladding Scandal notes, there is a raft of conclusions
“based on assumption rather than test evidence.”
Worse still, we know that enforcement is weak. Property Week has already stated:
“developer-led remediation continues to progress too slowly, with only 10% of projects complete and nearly 60% still awaiting agreed scopes of work.”
Put simply, ruling out developers from the new remediation duty in the Bill but imposing it on resident-controlled entities sadly highlights just how skewed and unfair the system still is. That is a crucial issue that I hope the Government will look at getting right.
It cannot be right to continue to place significant burdens on the shoulders of volunteer leaseholders, especially in buildings owned by leaseholders, which were ruled out of the leaseholder protections. The Bill makes no mention of protecting them at the moment, nor does it close gaps affecting non-qualifying leaseholders, shared owners and buildings below 11 metres. Those people are left fending for themselves. Again, the Secretary of State highlighted that she seeks to address those things, and I look forward to seeing the detail in due course.
I will briefly make a final point on the wider issue of the capacity of fire authorities to respond to high-rise blazes. In 2025, I wrote to the Government to highlight significant understaffing, often due to poor pay, which was having an impact on the recruitment and retention of firefighters. That has resulted in situations where vehicles are sometimes sent out without a full complement of five firefighters riding, where vehicles are deployed elsewhere to compensate for equipment or staffing gaps, or where vehicles simply cannot be deployed at all due to there not being enough staff to crew or repair them.
Salford’s firefighters and appliances are frequently directed to surrounding boroughs to tackle high-rise blazes because there are not enough fire vehicles available at that time. That results in fewer firefighters on the ground in the early stages of an incident in Salford, which greatly increases the risks for everyone involved. At this time of year, with bonfire night approaching, the situation becomes more acute.
I had three asks of Government in 2025, and I repeat them again today. First, they should co-ordinate with the Chancellor—we have the Budget tomorrow, so they will have to get in quick—to reverse the cuts and invest in the future of fire and rescue services with additional central Government funding. Secondly, they should urgently bring forward the plan to reintroduce national standards to remove the postcode lottery of incident responses and hold fire chiefs accountable. Lastly, they should give firefighters a fair say through a new advisory body that includes trade union representation, and powers and resourcing to investigate fires of special interest.
The Bill is very welcome, and it is definitely a good starting place for identifying the gaps, but there is a long way to go. I hope that we will now have a collective and collegiate conversation about how we can get the final version of the Bill spot on.
I unreservedly welcome the Bill. The story of the cladding crisis arose out of the appalling tragedy at Grenfell on that night over nine years ago, when all those people died in the place they should have felt most safe—their home. They died because of a series of catastrophic failures.
The first and most obvious failure was that cladding was allowed to be put in combinations on the sides of buildings when no one had actually tested what would happen if those combinations caught fire. It is astonishing, when one looks back at it, that architects were able to specify combinations. We now know that when some of those combinations had been put on rigs and set fire to—boom!—they had gone up very quickly.
The second thing—my hon. Friend the Member for Kensington and Bayswater (Joe Powell) spoke so well—is that we are here, over nine years after the event, and we still have not sorted it out. I am much struck by the example that he quoted from Australia; he is right. Many of my constituents have been affected by the cladding scandal. For most of them, it is fair to say, their homes have now been dealt with, but there are still far too many people whose homes have not been. The reaction of the Government at the time was, “Well, it’s not really our responsibility.” They had to be forced by stages, over the years, to do more and more.
There was also a failure to build the blocks in line with the building regulations at the time. It is one thing to look at the cladding—people said, “Oh, I didn’t know that was a problem”—but as it was pulled off buildings, one after another, what did we find? We found that the fire-stopping measures, the firebreaks, were missing—even though that was a requirement of the building regulations at the time. This is a story of a load of jerry-built buildings that people lived in for many years, as one Member said, with no idea that they were living in a fire trap. I make that point because, on occasion, I have heard Members in this Chamber lambast Britain as an over-regulated society. I mean, give us a break! This story is a monumental failure of regulation. People died as a result, and many other people’s lives have been put on hold, as we have heard.
I join others in paying tribute to the End Our Cladding Scandal group, Leeds Cladding Scandal, and the many constituents who have raised cases with me and who have worked so hard to try to change the circumstances in which they find themselves. Time and again, people have said to me, as they have to all other hon. Members, “I thought I’d bought the home of my dreams, and I find I’m living in a nightmare that I don’t seem able to get out of.” Many Members have referred to people’s lives being put on hold. That is absolutely true: they cannot get on with things, whether having a family or moving to another part of the country where they have been offered a good job, because they cannot sell their flat. There appears to be no escape. The bills go up, the waking watches are costly, insurance is expensive and service charges go up. I remember the first constituent who told me, “I’ve had to move out of my flat.” I said, “You’ve moved out of your flat?” He said, “Yes, I couldn’t afford the bills, so I moved out of my flat; I’m now renting it, so I can pay the bills that I can’t afford in the flat that I thought was the home of my dreams.”
Each block, particularly the ones that have not yet been remediated, is a very complex story—changing ownership, developers disappearing or going bust, the legal pass the parcel, which was mentioned in a previous speech, and mortgage lenders refusing to lend. The hard truth is that no legislation is going to require a mortgage lender to lend on a property it does not want to lend on. The mortgage lenders therefore have to have confidence.
Gideon Amos
The right hon. Gentleman is making a typically cogent, sensible speech. Is not the logical conclusion of what he is driving at that buildings should be remediated to a standard such that they can be insured at reasonable levels and will get mortgages, and that that is the building regulation standard we require for new buildings?
I understand the point that the hon. Gentleman is making, but is he arguing that a mortgage lender should be required by law—
No, the hon. Gentleman is not; I did not think that he was. That is a fundamental problem. It is about confidence in the system and in the property. Too many of my constituents still worry that they could be landed with bills they simply cannot afford. Someone said to me, “Thirty thousand quid? It might as well be 30 million quid, because I can’t afford thirty thousand.”
I want to raise three specific issues. First, I very much welcome what the Secretary of State said in her opening speech about those who have bought non-qualifying flats. As I was reflecting on the question I put to her about making the measure retrospective, I realised that that probably is not an issue here. The sole owner of a flat that was deemed to be non-qualifying will be relieved of the requirement to meet the costs themselves and will be eligible for the support that other leaseholders have.
The second issue relates to blocks below 11 metres. I echo the point made by the hon. Member for Bristol Central (Carla Denyer). There is a development in Leeds called the Chandlers; some of the blocks are over 11 metres and some are below 11 metres. Applications have been made to the new fund that was opened—from memory, the closing day was 17 August. There will be lots of applications, and we do not know who will be successful and who will not. I seek clarity from the Minister. As I understand it, under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, a “responsible person” is required to carry out fire risk assessments on all buildings and put in place measures to address fire risks they identify. A House of Commons Library briefing note states:
“Since 2022, this risk assessment duty has included assessing the structure and external walls of the building, including cladding”.
Although the Government generally argue that most buildings under 11 metres do not present a risk, what is the situation in cases where there is a risk in those buildings? For example, a PAS 9980 assessment was done for the Chandlers. The residents were first told that the blocks under 11 metres were a high risk; they were then told that those blocks were a medium risk. But hey—a medium risk is still a risk. Would you want to live in a block that has a medium risk of catching fire, putting your life at risk? I have read the Bill and the explanatory memorandum on this point quite hurriedly, and it appears that these particular powers apply to buildings of over 11 metres. However, since the Government have said, “We are prepared to provide funding for buildings under 11 metres,” can the Minister tell me whether any of the powers in the legislation as it is currently drafted apply to blocks of under 11 metres and the people responsible for them? If not, if such a block has got a PAS 9980 assessment that says, “This is a risk”, then why, logically, would we not extend these powers to ensure the remediation of blocks under 11 metres?
Finally, I join my hon. Friend the Member for Southampton Itchen (Darren Paffey) in making a plea about people who really, really, really need to move. Could the Government think creatively about developers buying back flats or, as was said a moment ago, the local authority purchasing them? We want more social housing, and each one would be one more unit. I wonder whether we could see what might be done to help people who really needed to move—for example, if their mother were extremely ill and they needed to move in order to look after her.
Having said that, our constituents who still live in unsafe flats have waited far too long to have them made safe, and I look forward to the Bill making very speedy passage through both Houses.
Could I pay my own tribute to the whole Grenfell family? I think we all remember quite vividly the moment when we heard on the news about this absolutely and utterly appalling disaster. Our hearts go out to all those who were affected and their families, particularly at this time when so many people must be thinking about the anniversary next year as well. It was quite clear, as other hon. Members have said, that this was a complete and utter failure of regulation, and I am so pleased that the Bill is tackling that.
As other Members have said, cladding is an issue around the whole country, and I will address some matters in my constituency, but first, I thank the Secretary of State and the ministerial team for their drive and ambition on this important matter after some years of what, sadly, can only be described as drift under the last Government. I wholeheartedly welcome the Bill, and in particular some of its key elements and points. It creates greater certainty, which is long overdue. It gives regulators the powers they need. It makes companies that made unsafe products contribute towards remediation—that is such an important point, as other Members have said. Most of all, it ensures that residents have a route to remediation, which is utterly important.
I am conscious of time as some other Member wish to speak, so I would like to turn to Reading. There are serious concerns locally, like those we have heard from Members describing the situations in their own constituencies. Our town has grown and changed dramatically within my lifetime, from being a county town made up of Victorian terraces and many brick buildings to now having a large number of taller buildings, many of which are blocks of flats. Obviously, the recent crisis has a huge implication for our community and for other towns across the county of Berkshire.
At the time of the Grenfell disaster, I remember receiving a briefing from the Royal Berkshire fire and rescue service, and I can only say that it had an utterly chilling effect on those who listened to it—on myself, local councillors and others. The situation they described was one of a service trying to cope with serious concerns and issues across a large English county. For example, as Members have described, they mentioned the problem of cladding on many buildings—a number of them below 11 metres—as well as related issues such as poor compartmentalisation. I remember them talking about blocks in Slough where builders had unwittingly drilled holes through walls that were meant to prevent fire. In Reading, some blocks had very serious problems with compartmentalisation. There were a whole series of issues with dangerous wooden cladding, dangerous wooden fittings in foyers or doors that were not fire-safe at all—and all of this existed in just one county. Fire and rescue service staff and local authority staff were enormously pressed to deal with it.
I remember listening to the accounts of waking watches being set up and thinking how terrifying it must have been to live in one of the blocks that were affected, just after Grenfell, when people were very aware of the disaster and horror that had happened not far away, in London. Those people had to live through a waking watch every single night. They were not able to have a whole range of items, and they could not cook certain types of food because of the fire risks from frying and other common forms of cooking. This was a huge issue for our community, particularly in the town centre and nearby areas. Many building owners were extremely responsible and acted as quickly as they could, despite the supply problems, the lack of skilled tradespeople, problems with putting up scaffolding and the pandemic that followed. I pay tribute to a number of housing associations that acted very quickly.
Luckily, all the council housing in Reading was not affected because it was not built using cladding; the council had taken a very robust approach to that. However, there were a number of problems with private blocks that were either rented or leasehold, and some of those issues have continued right up to the present day; there have been local media reports on ITV and the BBC that have highlighted some of the problems. Like other Members—indeed, my hon. Friend the Member for Southampton Itchen (Darren Paffey) put it very well—I have constituents who bought flats in blocks with cladding and were then trapped in them. They were struggling to sleep, and they lived in complete stress. Sometimes, I think it is fair to say that they had moments of terror living in these flats where they clearly were at great risk. They could not get the work done, and they were facing huge financial costs, which has been a problem across the whole country. I am so pleased that the current Government have gripped this and want to tackle it and to introduce some reassurance and routes to remediation at a much greater pace.
I would like to press the Minister on the point about flats under 11 metres, and I hope she will be able to respond to this when she winds up the debate. It is great to hear about the fund for flats under 11 metres—there will be a number of these in many medium-sized towns—but there are other non-cladding-based fire safety issues in exactly this type of block. That includes the issues I mentioned, such as dangerous wooden items in the foyer of a large block in Reading, and wooden balconies; in one case, a building had wooden balconies next to an underground car park, which was then discovered to be a huge fire risk. Some of these risks are in blocks under 11 metres, which may not be covered by the fund. Could the Minister elaborate on the nature of the fund, to provide further reassurance to residents?
Could the Minister also look into the wider issue of fire safety in buildings under 11 metres? As will be the case in many constituencies, we have a significant number of older blocks that are under 11 metres and might date back to the 1960s, 1970s or 1980s. They may not have dangerous cladding, but there might be issues with fire safety doors, evacuation procedures and a whole series of things. Because of the large number of these flats, residents will be concerned about the capacity of local authorities or the fire service to investigate. If the Minister could provide more information on that point, it would be very reassuring to residents in Reading and other similar towns.
I am conscious of time, so I will conclude by wholeheartedly welcoming the Bill. It is a huge step forward, and I really welcome the drive and thrust of activity from the Department on this matter. I am sure that the whole House will once again want to offer their thoughts to the families of the Grenfell community. I look forward to hearing more from the Minister.
Six weeks ago, residents in Neutron Tower in my constituency woke up in the middle of the night to a fire. They had to rush from flat to flat to warn their neighbours of what was unfolding. Tragically, one of my constituents lost his life, and I am sure that all of us in this House send our condolences to his family and loved ones. Others were hospitalised, and evacuated residents are being told that it may be months before they can return. This was the first fatal fire at a tower block that has unsafe cladding since Grenfell. It happened in a building that had been identified as having combustible insulation in the cladding, combustible balcony floors and defective balcony doors. While investigations are still ongoing, early indications are that the cladding itself did not play a role in this fire. However, the fact that the fire occurred in a building that has been awaiting remediation for so long has terrified residents of Neutron Tower and the adjacent Proton and Elektron Towers, and of Switch House, as well as those in the hundreds of other high-rise residential units in my constituency that need remediation work.
This serious incident is a stark and grave reminder of the potential peril faced by hundreds of thousands of people in this country, who feel that they are at the mercy of unscrupulous developers and managing agents. Repairs and remediation are being delayed again and again, and residents’ safety concerns are going unheard, all while they are tied to unsellable assets and escalating fees. Astonishingly, traumatised residents who have been evacuated from Neutron Tower are still being made to pay rent and service charges in the meantime. The fact that this Bill is being put before the House is welcome, as are the engagements that I have had with the Building Safety Regulator, the Secretary of State and officials in her Department; I know from them that the Neutron Tower fire is being taken extremely seriously.
Many of my constituents who fall into the category of having non-external cladding risks and internal defects in their homes, or of being non-qualified leaseholders, will be looking closely at the Bill as it progresses through the House. They will be pleased to have heard the Secretary of State’s announcement that these areas will be explored as the Bill progresses. I pay tribute to the End Our Cladding Scandal campaign, led by a group who have been campaigning on these fronts for a long time. I have been contacted by unpaid resident directors of local right-to-manage companies, who are worried about the new liabilities that they might face for defects that they did not cause, without any new funding or support for meeting those duties.
Then there is the bigger picture—the behaviours and the dispute practices that have allowed remediation processes to drag on for completely unacceptable lengths of time for so many buildings. I am disappointed that the new powers that will be placed on responsible entities will exclude developers who are part of the developer remediation contract, because developers under the DRC are able to delay remediation, drag their heels and avoid financial responsibilities. I understand that the Government’s position is that there are enough existing mechanisms under the DRC, so the backstop powers in the Bill do not need to be extended any further, but the system is not working in practice. Many residents are alarmed that there is not greater accountability for those ultimately responsible.
Ultimately, this comes down to a question of ambition. There is no denying the complexities at play in this decade-long ordeal. I am glad that some of the glaring gaps in the Bill are already being addressed, so that we can finally, through legislation, fix issues that we have been talking about for so long. The questions for many of my constituents, including the residents of Neutron Tower, are: when will the remaining gaps be addressed and, most importantly, how long before they finally have a safe home? Like many hon. Members, I will follow the Bill very closely as it progresses through the House, and will look for ways in which it can be strengthened even further, because we cannot delay taking action any longer.
Fleur Anderson (Putney) (Lab)
I too pay tribute to the families of those who died in the Grenfell fire, which we will never forget. It scarred not only those in that area of London, but all Londoners. I also pay tribute to my hon. Friend the Member for Kensington and Bayswater (Joe Powell) for his excellent speech, for the campaigning he has done and for standing up for his community, and for his work to ensure that the Bill is as good as it is.
I welcome and support the Bill, although I wish it had been introduced by the previous Government, years ago. Unsafe cladding is a big issue across the country. The UK Government track 4,724 high-rise buildings with unsafe cladding. Some 39% of those are now fully remediated, and 15% have works under way, but 46% are still waiting for works to start. There are more than 1,000 such buildings in London, several of which are in my constituency of Putney.
Let me begin by thanking the Minister and her team, as well as former Ministers, for their constructive engagement throughout the development of the Bill. They have taken the time to listen to me. I have shown case studies of what is happening to my constituents to Ministers and asked, “Would the Bill work for them?” I am so glad to see so many ways in which it will. The Bill goes a great way, in many ways, to address problems, and to hold to account the developers who built the buildings and who, in so many cases, seem to have been able to walk away, delay, obfuscate and make things really difficult, when they should have stepped up and said, “There were these issues. These are our buildings, and we will work to rectify them.”
The Bill represents a significant step, and builds on the remediation acceleration plan in putting safety, accountability and those affected first. For too long, many leaseholders have been trapped in homes that they cannot remortgage and, in some cases, do not even feel safe living in. They bought their homes in good faith and followed the rules, but they have found themselves paying the price for failures elsewhere in a system that they trusted. The human impact of the delays cannot be overestimated, as many Members have said. I have spoken to constituents who are not able to start or increase the size of a family, take up jobs or care for relatives across the country because they are stuck in their home and unable to move on with their life. They have experienced prolonged disruption and financial uncertainty, and huge levels of stress.
I welcome these measures. The Bill gives regulators stronger powers to hold to account those who delay or obstruct remediation, and introduces a statutory duty to remediate. It replaces cosy deals and voluntary commitments, as so many Ministers in the former Government promised to. Time and again, I came to the Chamber, with many other Members who are here, to be told, “We will take action. It will be done. I have got the developers round the table, and they are all going to do it—don’t you worry”, but that did not happen at all. No more of that.
Luke Murphy (Basingstoke) (Lab)
My hon. Friend is making a really strong speech about the need for this Bill. Does she agree that this action is long overdue? Residents in Crown Heights in my constituency have waited for years—far too long. They have been in financial uncertainty, and uncertainty about their safety, and they deserve a clear timeline of when their remediation works will be completed. Residents like those in Crown Heights will be served better in the future by action that will be delivered through this Bill.
Fleur Anderson
I absolutely agree. My hon. Friend’s constituents, my constituents and the constituents of all Members will be watching this debate, half feeling glad that all this is happening, and half hoping that it actually will happen. In that respect, one part of the Bill I really welcome is that a remediation compliance plan has to be published on a website, openly available and proactively shared with residents. The fact that that even has to be said is testament to how frustrating it has been for residents to try to find information. Instead of them asking, “Who has built this building? Who are the responsible parties? What are they going to do? Where is the plan? Will I be moved out? When is it going to happen? When can I get on with my life?”, a plan has to be published, put on a website and proactively shared. I really welcome that.
Dr Al Pinkerton (Surrey Heath) (LD)
The hon. Lady talks about the need and desire to end the culture of cosy deals. I completely agree, but is not PAS 9980 itself a cosy deal done by the former Secretary of State, Michael Gove, as a compromise with building developers, to let them off from so many of the financial obligations that they would have had if they had to remediate buildings to the standard at which they should have been built? Does this Bill not turn that cosy deal into law?
Fleur Anderson
I have been following this issue closely. As well as EWS1 forms and the question of who fills them in, developers marking their own homework to any degree causes problems in the system. Many Members will be looking at the Bill as it progresses through this House and the other place to see how we can strengthen it even further. Measures may be put into the Bill in all good faith, but in practice, there may not be enough people inspecting buildings, so there may be huge delays in the system. We do not want those people to want to minimise the amount of work done and keep the delays going.
I welcome the fact that building owners who fail to act could face fines of £500,000 and even criminal prosecution. Where owners refuse to do the work, Homes England will have the backstop powers to step in and ensure remediation is finally carried out, with the costs falling on those responsible, rather than the leaseholders. The measures in the Bill will help accelerate the resolution of historical safety defects, require manufacturers of unsafe building products to contribute to putting things right, and ensure that those affected have a clearer route to redress.
For many people, the cladding scandal is not a historical issue, but a daily reality. Throughout this scandal, I have found out all the layers of poor regulation in building works. For many homes and developments in Putney, not only has the cladding been unsafe, but many other parts of the building have been unsafe as well. In looking at the cladding, we have also found missing or inadequate fire stopping, inadequate compartmentation, poorly installed cavity barriers, defective balconies and water ingress. In a couple of the developments I have been in, I have watched water flowing down through electrical cupboards. That shoddy building work and the way that developers seem to have been able to get away with it should also be looked at, although not in this Bill. This Bill needs to be specific, and we need to get on with it, but other questions are being asked as a result of this process.
My residents have had to find out a lot more about whole developments and how they work; about their managing agents and how they should be working for them, but in many ways are not; about waking watches; and about non-communication by those who are meant to communicate about other defects in their buildings. They have had to become experts in inspections and how they work. They have had to work with the fire service themselves, because they are the people who are involved with all of these different things. I have been to meeting after meeting that residents have called, or that I have called, to try to get answers. It really should not have been so hard—it should be far easier for residents and leaseholders to know what is going on in their building. That is why I really look forward to the upcoming leasehold and commonhold Bill, because in my constituency of Putney, Roehampton, Southfields and Wandsworth Town, I am still working with people whose lives continue to be disrupted years after these problems first emerged. Many of them are currently decanted and living in other places, and many are unable to rent, sell or remortgage. They struggle to obtain their EWS1 forms or—as has been mentioned by other Members—affordable insurance, and far too often, their service charges are also going up. They describe uncertainty, stress and frustration.
I want to draw the Minister’s attention to continuing delays by the Building Safety Regulator, which I have talked about before in a Westminster Hall debate. I have had three developments really affected by huge delays by the Building Safety Regulator; two of them have now been fixed, so I thank the Ministers very much for that, but I have one left, so I am going to raise it now. That is the heritage-listed stilt blocks on the Alton estate in Roehampton. They are really iconic—people come from all over the world to look at our stilt blocks. We are very proud of them, but living inside them is not so nice. They have mould, and they have really poor windows that let the water and the weather in. Residents have endured winter after winter waiting for replacement windows.
Although Wandsworth council approved and funded new windows and stairwell fire doors in September 2023, the introduction of the new building safety regime transferred responsibility for approving those works to the Building Safety Regulator, because those listed blocks are classified as high-rise residential buildings. The residents narrowly missed the approval window before the new arrangements came in, leaving them in limbo with the Building Safety Regulator and causing further delays for people who have already waited far too long. They have waited through the winters of 2023, 2024 and 2025, and now they are approaching yet another winter with these very cold windows. Residents say that when they put a radiator on, they might as well just be throwing money out of the window. It is an appalling situation, and I really hope that as a result of me raising it in the Chamber today, the Ministers will address it.
None of us wants to return to the failures of the past. Robust regulation is essential, and the whole purpose of reform is to ensure that safety comes first, but a system that leaves people in prolonged uncertainty is also failing them. As implementation of the Bill proceeds, I urge Ministers to continue examining how regulatory processes can be made more efficient without compromising safety, whether that is ensuring they have the right number of staff or that their systems are right—whatever it takes to make the system work. People should not be left waiting months or years for decisions when works are ready to proceed. Safety and speed are not mutually exclusive; we need to have both.
As I have said, I look forward to the commonhold and leasehold reform Bill, which is part of the package of exciting and strong new regulatory powers that are being introduced by the Government in a number of ways. The last Government could have done the same, but did not.
I support this Bill, and I hope that while making these reforms, we will continue to focus relentlessly on turning regulation into results for the people of Putney and people across the country.
Chris Vince (Harlow) (Lab/Co-op)
I thank the Secretary of State for opening the debate and, like many others, I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Kensington and Bayswater (Joe Powell) for his extremely powerful and important speech, and for all the work that he has done to support the Grenfell families who so deserve that support. He is a fantastic champion for them. I also welcome the Bill, and the fact that those responsible for unsafe residential buildings will be held legally accountable. History has shown that these matters cannot be left unmonitored.
As you will know, Madam Deputy Speaker, I am forever honoured to stand in this place as the Member of Parliament for Harlow and the villages. To find myself listening to, for example, my right hon. Friend the Member for Leeds South (Hilary Benn)—of whom I admit to being a bit of a fan—is a “pinch me” moment. I have to say, though, that above all that, the biggest honour I have experienced in this place was when I spoke for the first time in a debate about Grenfell, some two years ago. I mentioned an incredible constituent, Rod Wainwright, who was one of the first responders on the scene at Grenfell. As you may remember, Madam Deputy Speaker, he witnessed at first hand the absolute horror that was caused by the unsafe cladding that had been used. That unavoidable tragedy that took so many lives has had a lasting impact not only on the families whom I have mentioned, but on heroes like Rod. He is an incredible man, both personally and professionally. People like Rod should not be suffering the consequences of others’ failings, and the Bill is just one step towards ensuring that that does not happen again.
I recently spoke to Rod, who, as I have mentioned previously, was medically retired owing to post-traumatic stress disorder. This is not an issue for the Ministers who are present today, but I hope that members of the Department for Work and Pensions team will listen. Every two years, Rod has to prove again that he has PTSD and that he should be medically retired. That has a massive impact on his mental health, and when I spoke to him I observed that impact at first hand. I do not think it right that heroes like Rod should have to go through this. He has to relive that terrible night every two years, again and again. It is very difficult for him, and it can be very difficult for his family.
I welcome the Government’s wider remediation acceleration plan, and the measures to protect leaseholders from unexpected costs and eye-watering bills to fix building safety defects that they themselves did not cause. In Harlow, there have been many cases of leaseholders facing such bills, and for many years this cladding was not seen as a defect. Criminalising those who fail to remediate or mitigate such important elements is a huge step in the right direction. It is clear that that failure costs lives, and I am glad that this Government are recognising the seriousness of it. I am pleased that the Bill provides for financial penalties to ensure that people are legally obliged to provide truthful information—which, as we know, did not happen in the aftermath of Grenfell—and will face penalties if they do not.
I also welcome the statutory duty to remediate multi-occupied residential buildings in England that are over 11 metres high or have at least five storeys. One of my constituents, Claire Miles, has talked about the tragic loss of her mother Daphne in a care home fire in April 2017 when building safety legislation applied only to buildings at least 30 metres high. Some consideration should be given to that during the Bill’s passage. While, as has been recognised, Harlow has great fire safety provision for high-rise buildings, earlier legislation has forgotten buildings such as care homes.
Finally, I thank the Secretary of State, the Minister for Homelessness, Democracy, Communities and Faith and the entire MHCLG team for bringing forward this legislation and for their continued championing of building safety—something that I think we can all agree is incredibly important. Everybody deserves a home, as we discussed yesterday, but more than that, everyone deserves a safe home.
Kevin Bonavia (Stevenage) (Lab)
Time and again today, we have remembered all those who tragically died in the Grenfell fire all those years ago. We look back on that not only because they deserve our tribute, but because we all know in our hearts that it did not need to happen. It could have been avoided, and the warnings were there years before. As has been said a few times today, the fire happened nine years ago, and we still have not got things right.
I cannot speak any more eloquently than my hon. Friend the Member for Kensington and Bayswater (Joe Powell) did. He spoke for only a few minutes, but he has campaigned relentlessly on behalf of his constituents for many hours, days and months—not only to make sure that we get the truth and learn from it, but to keep championing all those people who are still worried. Many feel trapped in homes in which they should be able to live safely and comfortably, but in which they cannot.
I really welcome what the Government are doing today, and I pay tribute to the Secretary of State and her Ministers. In 2024, the Secretary of State began the remediation acceleration plan, because it was taking way too long. Relevant legislation has been passed in this place before, but we see that it is not delivering. There are too many gaps, and I believe that this Bill is a great step forward. I am grateful to the Secretary of State for saying that she will add to it, and I am sure that she has been listening carefully to what has been said today and will continue to listen, not just to us in this place but to the people we represent. I know that she and her Ministers have been meeting people affected by this issue and representatives of End Our Cladding Scandal. One of the big champions in my constituency, Sophie Bichener, has been working in this area for years, and she has acknowledged those meetings.
When we talk about examples in our constituencies, we sometimes think that MPs who represent big cities will have a lot, which might be true. I represent a new town, just like my hon. Friend the Member for Harlow (Chris Vince), who represents another fine new town that is not far from Stevenage. We do not have as many examples as the House might think, but I want to highlight two. It does not matter that we do not have many, because those residents who have been trapped for so long really feel it. In Stevenage we have Monument Court and Vista Tower, and I want to relay a couple of my residents’ expressions of despair.
One resident of Vista Tower said:
“Since the Grenfell disaster we have been imprisoned in a property that we cannot sell, has no apparent value and has continuing yearly safety improvements. But worst of all, the owners of flats have no visibility as to when this nightmare will finish.”
Another said:
“I am living in a home that I know to be unsafe, with no clear timeline for when the necessary remediation work will be completed. The ongoing uncertainty is causing significant stress and anxiety, particularly as I have two young children whose safety and wellbeing are my priority. I am also facing increased insurance costs and am having to deplete my savings to cover the financial burden. I cannot sell my property because of the unresolved cladding issues, leaving me effectively trapped in a home that may be unsafe and unable to move forward with my life.”
Those residents are just two examples of people trapped in their own homes, not knowing if they are safe after all these years.
Residents in Vista Tower are now going through a second round of remedial works. They have been told that they are to be decanted, but for how long? We do not know. When is that going to happen? We do not know. Vista Tower itself has been the subject of many legal actions going on for years, and there seems no end to it. We have to give those residents the hope of an ending, so that they can get on with their lives, feel safe in their homes and, if they want to do so, move on and live elsewhere.
I am pleased that the Bill takes us forward on some of those matters, but it has been very difficult for many Members to hear about some of the issues that have been raised today. We need to ensure that non-qualifying leaseholders, such as those living in Vista Tower and Monument Court, are not left with unaffordable bills to fix historical defects, such as the fire safety defects, so I am pleased to hear movement from the Secretary of State in that regard.
Dr Pinkerton
The hon. Gentleman’s constituents’ stories resonate deeply, and are similar to those I hear from my constituents. Nine different properties in my constituency had EWS1 forms that were signed by a rogue fire safety engineer called Adam Kiziak, which has introduced further uncertainty and anxiety, alongside everything that the hon. Gentleman has spoken about. That is why I feel so passionately that this Bill could go just a little bit further, and call for the independent regulation of fire safety engineers to bring added certainty to those who do have to commission forms that ultimately speak to the quality, but also the safety, of the building. Will he join me in making that case?
Kevin Bonavia
I thank the hon. Member for making a very sensible point. I am pleased that the Bill takes forward the idea of having independent actors to step in, which I would always welcome—the more of that, the better. We cannot have the developers or freeholders of these buildings essentially marking their own homework.
We must ensure that buildings are reviewed holistically and made safe as a whole. As I have said, Vista Tower is facing a second round of intrusive works and the decanting of residents, so we need to ensure that such things can be avoided. That is why it is so important to have compliance plans and, more importantly, to ensure that residents are informed of and are able to influence and shape these plans. I welcome the moves in that regard.
For Vista Tower, there have now been eight years of fighting, with no timeline for ending it. We must therefore make sure that remediation compliance plans guarantee access to assessments, work specifications, delivery timetables and completion evidence, with real and meaningful engagement for leaseholders, while also providing them with accessible routes to challenge decisions and raise concerns about their homes. In that way we can give leaseholders, but also the flats market as a whole, confidence that when work is required, it will be done properly and collaboratively.
Today is a day of real progress—we are filling the gaps one by one—and I am pleased to hear that Ministers are listening. They should carry on listening to make sure that the Bill becomes an Act that finally gives people who are living in fear of the future and uncertain about what is going to happen to their home the release from all of that that they truly deserve.
Jessica Toale (Bournemouth West) (Lab)
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Last, but hopefully not least.
I thank the Secretary of State and the Minister for bringing forward the Bill, and I pay tribute to my hon. Friend the Member for Kensington and Bayswater (Joe Powell) for all his work to honour the victims and families of Grenfell, and to ensure that nobody else suffers the horror of such unavoidable tragedy.
I fully support the Government’s determination to accelerate remediation and better protect leaseholders who have been left carrying the emotional and often financial burden of a crisis they did not create. As we have heard from many hon. Members from across the House today, too many people across the country have been trapped in unsafe homes, facing uncertainty, financial anxiety and delays that have stretched on for years. Everyone deserves to live in a safe home and that is why the Bill is so important. I welcome many of the provisions in the Bill, from the clear legal duty of responsibility for unsafe buildings to the stronger enforcement with clear consequences to ensure that leaseholders are not left paying the price for failures that were not their fault.
I do, however, have to be honest about some of the practical barriers that are impacting my constituents and delaying works on the ground. In my constituency, residents in several high-rise blocks have contacted me repeatedly about remediation delays. In one case, a developer is ready to proceed with the necessary cladding works that would make the building safe, but has been waiting for approval from the Building Safety Regulator since the middle of 2024. The decision on certification has been pushed back six times. I have written to the Minister in the other place, Baroness Blake, regarding the case, but it remains a significant problem and the BSR delayed approval yet again only last month.
Another property in my constituency is similarly impacted. The contractor has bought materials and submitted the relevant applications to the BSR in August 2025, but was rejected several months later. The application was submitted again, but it was rejected in May this year. In the meantime, residents continue to live with significant damp, mould and fire safety issues in the building.
These are not isolated incidents and I could relay others—and I will, because this is significant. One building, a social housing building in my constituency, had some botched internal works, leaving really unacceptable conditions in communal areas and embarrassment for residents. One of them brought me in and showed me a piece of exposed wall with mould all over it where they had affixed a nametag that said, “Jackson Pollock 2024”. That building is on a hill, and when they brought in a contractor to remediate the internal bits of the building, they discovered that the building is smaller at the front than it is at the back. They then had to reclassify the building and submit an application to the Building Safety Regulator. I have very little faith in the fact that those residents, who have already been waiting more than two years for the internal works, will get them done in good time.
This is not about weakening standards or cutting corners; it is about robust scrutiny and effective regulation that is absolutely necessary. The point is that residents, leaseholders and good contractors who are trying to do the right things should not be increasingly frustrated by these delays. My residents need certainty that the plans to make their homes safe can actually take place and be done at pace.
We on the Labour Benches all want stronger regulators, but there appear to be genuine questions about whether the Building Safety Regulator has sufficient capacity and specialist resources to process applications as quickly as everyone would like. Concerns about delays with the regulator have been raised elsewhere, including by the Industry and Regulators Committee in the other place. The provisions in the Bill are necessary and long overdue, but if the ambitions of the Bill are to be realised in practice, the Building Safety Regulator must have the capacity and resources to match those ambitions. I would be grateful if the Minister, in her closing remarks, could address Building Safety Regulator resourcing and capacity. Will she also consider meeting Members from across the House whose constituents are experiencing delays, so that these concerns can be discussed directly? The regulator must have the staff, expertise and support it needs to ensure that vital remediation projects are not delayed unnecessarily.
The people living in these buildings have waited long enough. They deserve safe homes. They deserve certainty and to see progress. I am proud to support the Bill and I hope that the Minister will address my concerns in her closing remarks.
With the leave of the House, I call the shadow Minister.
Katie Lam
I would like to acknowledge some of the Back-Bench contributions to the debate. The sheer volume and range of locations affected by unsafe cladding is remarkable and speaks to the scale of this terrible problem. We have heard from my hon. Friend the Member for Bromley and Biggin Hill (Peter Fortune), the right hon. Member for Leeds South (Hilary Benn), and the hon. Members for Ipswich (Jack Abbott), for Woking (Mr Forster), for Southampton Itchen (Darren Paffey), for Bristol Central (Carla Denyer), for Salford (Rebecca Long Bailey), for Reading Central (Matt Rodda), for Poplar and Limehouse (Apsana Begum), for Putney (Fleur Anderson), for Harlow (Chris Vince), for Stevenage (Kevin Bonavia) and for Bournemouth West (Jessica Toale), who have all spoken of the challenges that their constituents have in dealing with that terrible problem.
We of course heard from the hon. Member for Kensington and Bayswater (Joe Powell). It must be a great responsibility to be the Member of Parliament for so many victims and survivors of Grenfell tower in his constituency—an area that we both know well. I am sure that he feels that acutely. Some of his descriptions of rogue and dangerous activity were shocking.
As outlined in my opening remarks, those of us on the Opposition Benches share the fundamental aims of the Bill. We too believe that every building with unsafe cladding should be fixed—and fixed fast. The questions that the Opposition pose are not about the Bill’s aims, but about whether it will work in practice and whether the full implications of its provisions have been considered by the Government.
The evidence suggests that remediation is slow mainly because there are not enough capable professionals to do the work, because the work is hard and unpredictable, and because delivery is fragmented. Elements of that have been acknowledged by Members on both sides of the House. In our view, there is a risk that a Bill that creates new legal duties, deadlines and penalties, but not a single new assessor or contractor, may add more pressure on the system and risk making the problem worse.
As the Bill progresses, I hope that the Government will be able to answer some of the questions raised in this debate. First, on capacity, every building in scope of the Bill must be assessed within a year of commencement, and every assessment that recommends work must be audited by Homes England. What assessment have the Government made of whether there are enough qualified people to meet that deadline and, if there are not, what happens to owners who miss the deadline through no fault of their own?
Secondly, on the new legal duties and associated offences, owners could face up to two years in prison or a penalty of up to £500,000 for deliberately failing to remediate as soon as reasonably practicable. What guidance will the relevant regulators be given on what that means in cases where qualified professionals are simply not available? Can the Minister be sure that an owner who is trying in good faith to commence remediation, but cannot get the work done, will not be prosecuted?
Thirdly, on group accountability, in 2022 Parliament allowed a court or tribunal to look through a company structure when it was just and equitable to do so. The Bill hands a version of that power to regulators through the power to issue penalty notices. Why was the judicial route not enough? Fourthly, on manufacturer’s liability, the 2022 Act gave building owners a route to claim against those who made defective cladding. The Bill loosens that test, but why was the 2022 test not sufficient? Have the Government made any assessment of what that will do to insurance costs and the cost of building new homes?
There is also a great deal that we have not yet seen. Remediation management orders will be set out in guidance that has not yet been published. Councils are being given new duties, including the remediation backstop, with no clear sense yet of how they will be resourced. Parliament should see the detail before it can approve those powers. The Opposition intend to table amendments in Committee to test each of those points, and we look forward to continuing that discussion with our shared ultimate aim in mind.
I thank Members from across the House for their contributions. As the Secretary of State, the shadow Minister and many hon. and right hon. Members outlined, next June will mark a decade since the Grenfell fire disaster took the lives of 72 people, including 18 children. None of us can imagine the horror that survivors, families and friends suffered that day, and the community will continue to carry that trauma, anguish and suffering throughout their lives.
It is a tragedy that should never have happened, and one that must never happen again, but we must be honest and say that it is unacceptable that far too many people in this country still do not have the safety and security of a safe roof over their heads, nine years after Grenfell. This is not just about building safety; it is about giving everyone the peace of mind that a safe, decent and affordable home brings. We must ask ourselves how we can expect anyone to sleep soundly, and get on in life, if the building they sleep in every night is covered in dangerous and flammable cladding. The building safety crisis must be resolved, homes must be made safe, and residents must be allowed to live their lives.
This Government were elected on a manifesto that made commitments to accelerate remediation, better protect leaseholders and make those responsible for the building safety crisis pay to put it right. Our remediation acceleration plan and this Bill deliver on that pledge. By introducing a register of 11 to 18 metre buildings and a national standard for assessing buildings, the Bill will finally bring certainty on the scale of the problem and the work required to fix it. By creating a new legal duty to remediate, backed up by substantial new penalties for inaction, we will compel those responsible to fix their buildings without delay.
Gideon Amos
I am extremely grateful to the Minister for giving way during a very serious and measured speech. She referred to the standard of remediation. A number of Members, including myself, raised use of the standard of tolerability instead of building regulations. Are the Government willing to review the standard of remediation so that after remediation, buildings are not left, as they are now, with flammable cladding on the outside?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for that intervention. A number of Members have raised the matter of remediation standards. I know that the hon. Member for Surrey Heath (Dr Pinkerton), who is sitting next to him, also raised it in a recent Westminster Hall debate that I responded to.
Many right hon. and hon. Members will be aware that the Bill will make independent auditing of fire risk appraisals of external walls mandatory. We are confident that PAS 9980 has a robust and appropriate methodology for assessing the risk of fire spreading throughout the building. The Bill will also look at the independent auditing and the statutory requirement, ensuring that additional checks on those assessments have been carried out properly. To reassure Members, Homes England will also audit all assessments that recommend mitigation and remediation and will have the power to audit other assessments.
By delivering the remediation backstop, we will ensure that no building and no resident is left behind, even if the person responsible for the building is determined to ignore the risks it presents to residents. By creating stronger avenues for redress against construction product manufacturers, we will ensure that those responsible for the cladding safety crisis pay towards the cost of fixing it.
I thank the Secretary of State and the Building Safety Minister, Baroness Blake, for bringing the Bill forward. I also thank all the Ministers who came before me for the work they did to make this Bill a reality, including the Lord Chancellor, my right hon. Friend the Member for Streatham and Croydon North (Steve Reed) and my hon. Friends the Members for Chester North and Neston (Samantha Dixon) and for Bethnal Green and Stepney (Rushanara Ali).
Sam Carling (North West Cambridgeshire) (Lab)
On the subject of fire safety, residents of Fletton Quays in my constituency were shocked recently to see nearly all internal fire doors fail an inspection; it turns out that they had not been inspected for many years and had been allowed to fall into disrepair, and residents are now on the hook to replace them at high cost, as well as being subjected to dangerous conditions. Does the Minister agree that that is really not on, and would she ask officials to examine whether that might be happening in other blocks of flats around the country, meaning that it might merit Government intervention?
I thank my hon. Friend for that point. This Bill deliberately focuses on unsafe external cladding, because the Grenfell tower inquiry phase 1 report found that cladding on external walls. We will be looking at the area he raises as the Bill progresses, so I give him that assurance.
I now turn to a number of comments made by right hon. and hon. Members today, and apologise that I may not be able to cover all Members’ comments. I start with the shadow Minister and the comments she made on the limited workforce capacity of fire safety technicians. We will continue to review that area. There is additional funding to ensure that those fire assessors are in place.
My hon. Friend the Member for Kensington and Bayswater (Joe Powell) outlined why this is such an important issue. I thank him for tireless campaigning and continued work with the survivors of Grenfell. He highlighted some of the dangers that still exist and mentioned the increasing costs that many of his constituents are facing—examples of some residents who are having to pay eye-watering bills to fix the issues. One of the matters I worked with him on in my former role as Chair of the Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee was the national oversight mechanism. It is not right that we are having to go through those recommendations one by one. I hope I can assure him that the Government accepted all the inquiry’s recommendations and we are making progress.
The hon. Member for Taunton and Wellington (Gideon Amos) outlined the issue with PAS 9980. I hope that he will be assured that we will continue to look at that.
My hon. Friend the Member for Ipswich (Jack Abbott) detailed the real-life nature of this issue and the fact that many leaseholders continue to be left in limbo, and their mental state is being affected. Leaseholders are in limbo, waiting for remediation, sometimes having to spend a decade out of their homes. Residents continue to face this injustice, and I thank him for continuing to work with leaseholders.
My hon. Friend the Member for Southampton Itchen (Darren Paffey) outlined the work that he has been leading around Ocean Village and Oceana Boulevard. That building was built only 20 years ago—yet, 10 years in, fire safety defects were outlined. That shows why we have to continue to work to ensure that all buildings are safe, including some that were deemed to be new builds.
The hon. Member for Bristol Central (Carla Denyer) detailed the tragic case of her 97-year-old constituent, who is having to rely on her children to buy her property to give her some certainty. They are now lumbered with a property that they cannot sell—simply for doing the right thing for their parent. No child should have to go through that process and face those costs. That is why we are making sure that the developers are paying for the work with the developer remediation fund.
My hon. Friend the Member for Northampton South (Mike Reader) outlined points that a number of Members highlighted. We will continue to look at the issues around insurance and non-qualifying leaseholders. I know he has expertise and knowledge on construction product manufacture, and I will continue to engage with him as the Bill progresses.
My hon. Friend the Member for Salford (Rebecca Long Bailey) outlined the work she has been doing with her constituents for many years and praised the decisive action taken by Salford council to act fast and think later, and then seek those costs back. It shows that our local authorities, where possible, are stepping forward to fill the gaps where developers have failed, but councils should not have to be leading on this. The developers of the buildings should be the ones paying, and we hope that the Bill will identify those owners.
My right hon. Friend the Member for Leeds South (Hilary Benn) outlined the fantastic work that he has been doing with the Leeds cladding campaigners. He also highlighted the issues around the delays in building safety regulations. Under the leadership of Lord Roe and Charlie Pugsley, I hope that Members will see that we are making progress in building regulation standards.
My hon. Friend the Member for Poplar and Limehouse (Apsana Begum) highlighted the tragic case of the fire at Neutron Tower, which sadly resulted in a resident losing his life. My hon. Friend knows that the investigation is still ongoing, so it would be inappropriate for me to comment, but we are continuing to work with relevant parties to ensure that the safeguarding and wellbeing of displaced residents is addressed as soon as possible. The London Fire Brigade has stated that the fire is believed to be accidental, but as this investigation is ongoing, we will continue to engage with my hon. Friend and her residents.
My hon. Friend the Member for Harlow (Chris Vince) highlighted the PTSD faced by his constituent. That shows the real-life consequences that many of our firefighters—the first responders to that tragic fire and the many tragic fires we continue to see—have to live with. I hope that Ministers in the DWP will take into account how my hon. Friend’s constituent has to reapply every two years to that Department.
This is a real issue on which all hon. Members need to continue to engage and discuss. I hope that hon. Members will continue to engage constructively with us as the Bill progresses through the Public Bill Committee.
The passion with which hon. Members have spoken is testament to the desire we all share to bring the building safety crisis to an end and protect the residents and leaseholders who desperately need and want to see action. The Government are delivering on that. We are providing more remediation funding than ever before, remediating more buildings than ever before, prioritising higher-risk buildings and putting the safety of residents at the heart of our work.
My hon. Friend the Member for Stevenage (Kevin Bonavia) spoke about the work of his constituent, whom the Secretary of State and I had the pleasure of meeting two weeks ago, along with cladding scandal group members. No one could have been unmoved when listening to their testimony, given the real-life issues and trauma that the ongoing delay is causing to so many. People’s lives are on hold—they cannot plan for their future, and they are in financial ruins. Tragically, some people have died waiting for the issue to be resolved.
Alongside the package of measures we have delivered to accelerate remediation and support leaseholders, the Bill will ensure that no building and no resident is left behind. I hope that hon. Members see that the Bill will bring certainty, clarity and accountability to drive forward remediation and make every building safe. That is what we owe to residents, and that what we owe to the country.
I am grateful to hon. Members from all parties who have given their support to work with us on the Bill. In that spirit, I commend it to the House.
Question put and agreed to.
Bill accordingly read a Second time.
Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill (Programme)
Motion made, and Question put forthwith (Standing Order No. 83A(7)),
That the following provisions shall apply to the Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill:
Committal
(1) The Bill shall be committed to a Public Bill Committee.
Proceedings in Public Bill Committee
(2) Proceedings in the Public Bill Committee shall (so far as not previously concluded) be brought to a conclusion on Tuesday 8 December 2026.
(3) The Public Bill Committee shall have leave to sit twice on the first day on which it meets.
Consideration and Third Reading
(4) Proceedings on Consideration shall (so far as not previously concluded) be brought to a conclusion one hour before the moment of interruption on the day on which those proceedings are commenced.
(5) Proceedings on Third Reading shall (so far as not previously concluded) be brought to a conclusion at the moment of interruption on that day.
(6) Standing Order No. 83B (Programming committees) shall not apply to proceedings on Consideration and Third Reading.
Other proceedings
(7) Any other proceedings on the Bill may be programmed.—(Rachel Hopkins.)
Question agreed to.
Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill (Money)
King’s recommendation signified.
Motion made, and Question put forthwith (Standing Order No. 52(1)(a)),
That, for the purposes of any Act resulting from the Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill, it is expedient to authorise the payment out of money provided by Parliament of:
(a) any expenditure incurred under or by virtue of the Act by the Secretary of State, and
(b) any increase attributable to the Act in the sums payable under any other Act out of money so provided.—(Rachel Hopkins.)
Question agreed to.
Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill (Ways and Means)
Motion made, and Question put forthwith (Standing Order No. 52(1)(a)),
That, for the purposes of any Act resulting from the Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill, it is expedient to authorise the charging of fees and charges under or by virtue of the Act.—(Rachel Hopkins.)
Question agreed to.
(6 days, 4 hours ago)
Public Bill Committees
The Chair
We are now sitting in public and the proceedings are being broadcast. Before we begin, I remind Members please to switch electronic devices to silent, and that tea and coffee are not allowed during sittings. We will consider first the programme motion on the amendment paper, then a motion to enable the reporting of written evidence for publication and a motion to deliberate in private about our questions before the oral evidence sessions. In view of the time available, I hope that those matters can be taken formally, without debate. TABLE Date Time Witness Thursday 12 November Until no later than 12.05pm Building Safety Regulator Homes England Local Government Association Thursday 12 November Until no later than 12.40pm National Fire Chiefs Council London Fire Brigade Thursday 12 November Until no later than 1.00pm Deputy Mayor of Greater Manchester Thursday 12 November Until no later than 2.35pm The Property Institute National Housing Federation Thursday 12 November Until no later than 3.00pm End Our Cladding Scandal Thursday 12 November Until no later than 3.30pm Britain Remade Centre for Policy Studies Thursday 12 November Until no later than 3.50pm Vistry Thursday 12 November Until no later than 4.20pm Ian Abley, Steve Day Thursday 12 November Until no later than 4.40pm Dame Judith Hackitt Thursday 12 November Until no later than 5.00pm DCCH Experts LLP Thursday 12 November Until no later than 5.20pm Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
Ordered,
That—
1. the Committee shall (in addition to its first meeting at 11.30 am on Thursday 12
November) meet—
(a) at 2.00 pm on Thursday 12 November;
(b) at 9.25 am and 2.00 pm on Tuesday 17 November;
(c) at 11.30 am and 2.00 pm on Thursday 19 November;
(d) at 9.25 am and 2.00 pm on Tuesday 24 November;
(e) at 11.30 am and 2.00 pm on Thursday 26 November;
(f) at 9.25 am and 2.00 pm on Tuesday 1 December;
(g) at 11.30 am and 2.00 pm on Thursday 3 December;
(h) at 9.25 am and 2.00 pm on Tuesday 8 December;
2. the Committee shall hear oral evidence in accordance with the following Table:
3. proceedings on consideration of the Bill in Committee shall be taken in the following order: Clauses 1 to 34; Schedule 1; Clauses 35 to 45; Schedule 2; Clauses 46 to 102; Schedule 3; Clauses 103 to 116; New Clauses; New Schedules; remaining proceedings on the Bill;
4. the proceedings shall (so far as not previously concluded) be brought to a conclusion at 5.00 pm on Tuesday 8 December.—(Florence Eshalomi.)
Resolved,
That, subject to the discretion of the Chair, any written evidence received by the Committee shall be reported to the House for publication.—(Florence Eshalomi.)
The Chair
Copies of the written evidence that the Committee receives will be made available in the Committee Room.
Resolved,
That, at this and any subsequent meeting at which oral evidence is to be heard, the Committee shall sit in private until the witnesses are admitted.—(Florence Eshalomi.)
The Chair
We are now sitting in public again and the proceedings are being broadcast. Before we start to hear from witnesses, do any Members wish to make a declaration of interest in connection with the Bill?
James Asser (West Ham and Beckton) (Lab)
As we have London Fire Brigade witnesses, I declare that my partner works for it, in fire safety.
Sagal Abdi-Wali (Holborn and St Pancras) (Lab)
I declare that I am still a councillor in a local authority.
I declare that the headquarters of the London Fire Brigade are in my constituency and that I meet the fire commissioner.
Noah Law (St Austell and Newquay) (Lab)
I declare my interest as a volunteer director of the St Austell community land trust.
The Chair
If any interests are particularly relevant to a Member’s line of questioning or speech, they should declare them again at the appropriate time.
Examination of Witnesses
Lord Roe, Charlie Pugsley, Helen Fisher and Mark Norris gave evidence.
The Chair
We will now hear oral evidence from the Building Safety Regulator, Homes England and the Local Government Association. We must stick to the timings in the programme motion that the Committee has agreed, and for the purposes of the witnesses, that means that this session will end at 12.05 pm. I ask each of the witnesses to introduce themselves for the record.
Charlie Pugsley: Good morning. I am Charlie Pugsley, acting chief exec of the Building Safety Regulator.
Lord Roe: Good morning. I am Andy Roe, chair of the Building Safety Regulator.
Helen Fisher: Good morning. I am Helen Fisher, the director of the cladding safety scheme and interim measures alarm fund at Homes England.
Mark Norris: I am Mark Norris from the Local Government Association.
Q
Lord Roe: It is nice to see you. The Bill gives powers to a series of regulators, which is useful. The first thing I want to say is that we welcome the Bill as another tool in our arsenal. It is not a panacea, but it will certainly be useful with the most recalcitrant actors in this landscape. I think, between us, we are clear how we operate. We are in constant dialogue—multiple meetings a week—with the likes of Homes England, local authorities, the London Fire Brigade and other fire services, and there is very good co-ordination.
There is no single hierarchy that necessarily fits all circumstances. My experience of having been a regulator in this space for a very long time is that you choose the most appropriate regulator set against the circumstances. You need to do that early in any potential enforcement process. It normally comes through a memorandum of understanding in the context of those individual circumstances. To set a sort of hierarchy within this would potentially be a mistake.
Q
Lord Roe: Because remediation itself is a complex issue. Without wanting to go into infinite detail, the reality is that there is normally a number of different routes to enforcement on a dangerous building, and it is not necessarily through this piece of legislation. I want to be clear: this is one tool in the arsenal. If we were presented with a problem building or entity organisation, the first thing we would do is get on to the other regulating and enforcing organisations and decide what the best route of enforcement is. It might not be this Bill. It could be the Housing Act. It could be the fire safety order. The point is that determining a hierarchy for remediation is potentially a mistake. I would rather we operate as we do, which is in clear collaboration and set out in an MOU. I do not know if there is anything you would add to that in terms of practical reality, Charlie.
Charlie Pugsley: Normally, for example, the Building Safety Regulator would be expected to take the lead on high-rise buildings, but we have one case currently that we are working with the London Fire Brigade on, and we are both looking at enforcement. If the fire brigade is six months ahead—you are legally not allowed to duplicate—it is in the public interest and the interest of efficiency for the fire brigade to make that decision. If that is the case, so be it—they should decide, to get the enforcement in the most timely and effective way.
Q
Lord Roe: It gives us more powers to tackle the worst actors in the remediation landscape. It gives us the additional ability to call those people in and force them to make progress. That is the advantage of this legislation.
Q
Lord Roe: I am conscious of time, but it comes in all shapes and forms. It could be reluctance to devote the money required to an expensive specialist contracting model to get the work done, so you can hold things up at contract. It could be putting forward really poor, under-resourced design proposals. There are multiple different ways you can hold this process up. To be fair, lots of things make operating in this landscape complicated and hard. Perhaps I will come back to that as a principal answer: this is a good tool. It will not solve remediation, but that is not what it is intended for. A lot of stuff on the delivery side has to be improved, whether it is inside the regulator or the other agencies or out in industry. That will probably give us the greatest gain, but this is a very useful tool where people are not complying.
With the greatest respect, I hope the witnesses this afternoon bring up-to-date evidence. We have gone from a 30% approval rate and a median determination time on approvals into the gateway 2 system of over a year, which was completely unacceptable. Charlie and I were charged with trying to shift that. We publish data transparently every single month. We are now at a 92% rolling approval rate. We got the median determination time down to something in the region of 20 weeks, and we will reduce it further. I personally am not experiencing huge levels of non-compliance, to be fair to the industry. They have worked hard to improve the standard of applications and move things on, but this is a very difficult space to operate in—and where there are bad actors, this will be a good tool.
Sarah Gibson (Chippenham) (LD)
Q
Mark Norris: Like the building safety regulator, the LGA welcomes the Bill. It is another tool in the toolbox. As MHCLG’s statistics already show, local authorities are out there doing enforcement now and have been for a number of years. Some 940 buildings are being inspected by councils under the Housing Act to take enforcement actions against some of the bad actors that Lord Roe referred to, supported by the Joint Inspection Team, which the Department funds the LGA to support. They have completed over 200 inspections so far.
The issue for us, which Lord Roe touched on, is capacity and resources to do that. Environmental health officers are in short supply—there is not a ready tree on which they grow to recruit them from. In terms of being able to do additional work, we already know that environmental health officers have a range of additional responsibilities. Recent legislation, including the Renters’ Rights Act 2025 and the social housing Act from 2023, includes a range of additional duties on local housing authorities within the housing space. Resourcing capacity in environmental health will be needed going forward to support councils in being able to do that work. We are fully up for the task, but need the resources and capacity to do that alongside everything else we are being asked to do, as you pointed out.
Sarah Gibson
Q
Mark Norris: I think they will notice a material improvement from this legislation. The experience of the Joint Inspection Team is that you might know what is wrong with the building and what needs to be fixed, but progressing things through first-tier tribunals to get the ruling that that is what the building owner or responsible entity needs to do takes time. Giving us something that places a duty on responsible entities to fix the building—that says very categorically, “This is what you have to do”—will help to speed that process up. But you are right: councils will need resources and capacity in addition to that to help them make the most of the legislation and the tools available in it.
Darren Paffey (Southampton Itchen) (Lab)
Q
Lord Roe: Those are two different things. I would not want to confuse necessary operational improvement with legislation to deal with bad actors. What you are talking about there is our responsibility to appropriately take a decision on what is sometimes a very complex situation, with thousands of pages to each application, while also operating in the context of a national lack of suitably skilled people to do facade engineering—also a particular point of risk. All I can do is point to the evidence, which shows that there was an unacceptable situation a year and a half ago when we came in: if you were one of those residents and had an application submitted into our system, you could wait up to a year or more. That was not okay and I have apologised for it repeatedly in other Committees.
We were charged to turn that around. I would argue—I have got to say this in defence of the team responsible—that we have done that, because we are now at 92% approval and with 20-week determination times. That will come down further, although maybe not by a lot—this is not about poor bureaucracy or a lack of emails or care anymore; it is about the engineering complexity of getting a building safe that has been built really badly.
The message to your constituents is first that we are super-available. Charlie and I get hundreds of emails into the inbox every week from people who often have rightful challenge—or sometimes do not. They will get a reply and response and, where necessary, we will unpick individual cases from the top of the BSR hierarchy down.
The point is that we can evidence the operational improvement. It is real and it is there in the figures. It is also there in the experience of both industry and many residents. We meet with all the campaigning groups almost weekly to gather intelligence, try and pick off poor actors and recognise where we are doing wrong and where there needs to be improvement in the system. I know, though, that is not going to be a comfort to people who are still trapped inside those blocks and who are under tremendous pressure. All I can tell them—I am sure many of them will be watching—is that we will be doing everything in our power to improve our system and force recalcitrant actors to do better. However, it is a complex problem that has been three decades-plus in the making.
Charlie Pugsley: One thing in the Bill is a duty to bring forward the assessment; that is something that we found in our remediation enforcement unit and have chased up. We work closely with Homes England and other partners. If that duty helps drive that forward, one part of the bigger puzzle will have been progressed and can help. But as Lord Roe says, there is no silver bullet; this is about a collective endeavour.
Lewis Cocking (Broxbourne) (Con)
Q
Lord Roe: It is not just the duties inherent within the Bill; it is the skilled contractors on the other side of it. The answer is no. This problem was built over decades, across successive Governments of all colours who neglected to invest in construction skills. This is not a political point, but the reality is that there is a very significant national endeavour to correct that, led at Secretary of State level. However, it will take time to reverse. There is a very real problem, and this is part of the complexity.
The Bill is a good tool for enforcement, which we will use, but to be fair to applicants, if you cannot get a specialist scaffolder because none is available in your area, or you cannot find the right facade engineer, we need to be pragmatic about how we chase your application. Otherwise, we will potentially force applicants to engage with poor or unskilled contractors. There are hidden dangers within all of this. If I am honest, all of us are trying to fix the plane on the runway because this mess was created over a number of decades.
The skill shortage is quite profound on both the industry side and for us. We pay very good rates; we are a costs-recovered agency. We employ the same private engineers that the applicants will be trying to employ as well, because there is a small pool of specialists within this field. There is currently a lot of investment to build that capacity, but you do not train these people in one year—it is not like that.
My point is that this Bill is great, genuinely, and we will use it selectively against people where it is appropriate to do so. Before someone else gets to it, I should say that that is unlikely to be resident managed entities, because that would be punching down. That is not okay and we are well aware of that, but there is a much bigger operational problem, which we are all charged with helping to solve, along with the industry, because we will not solve the problem without it.
Lewis Cocking
Q
Lord Roe: I am not saying they should do more. I am well aware of the work being done within the Construction Skills Mission Board. There is a huge endeavour. It is a massive joint industry piece as well. There is really good co-operation from industry and Government together, but they are trying to reverse-engineer a problem that was decades in the—[Interruption.] You might as well say that, Charlie—he is writing me notes. A good example would be the RBIs.
Charlie Pugsley: It is not for us to comment on behalf of the Government, but we are aware that funding has gone into registered building inspectors, for example, from the Government.
Lewis Cocking
Q
Lord Roe: No; I do not think the two things are the same. I think they are doing enough, but sometimes—I mean this with the greatest respect—I sit in front of Committees that want to see reversed in one or two years a problem that was decades in the making. Some of these people can take up to a decade to train. We are talking about very specialist work, particularly in the context of external remediation and façade engineering. These are some of the most experienced and qualified people in the engineering world. You cannot just invent them. It is a bit like growing the number of environmental health inspectors—these are really specialist.
There is £625 million inside the Construction Skills Mission Board, I think. To be fair, the previous Government had started a lot on this as well and I want to recognise that; the previous Administration, through Michael Gove, had started to do a lot of things with this, but it takes a long time to resolve. All the time the housing economy is difficult, by the way, it has an impact on available skills and the people who are going to get employed. So we are trying to get ourselves out of a cycle.
Fleur Anderson (Putney) (Lab)
Q
I have in my constituency a case that I think is a useful test case for the Bill. Barratt Redrow built a building; cladding was an issue but, in looking at that, all sorts of other issues about the whole structure of the building were uncovered. My constituents have been decanted for three years and they are asked to go back next week on the basis of a report by the developers, Barratt Redrow, who in their mind caused all those problems. My constituents want independent scrutiny of that. They want independently to know that, for example, the concrete that it has been made with, which is in question, is the right one. Are they safe to go back? Does the Bill allow for that? Where do residents go when they are being asked to return, or during a process of remediation, for that independent aspect of it? Do you think that is strong enough, or could more be done about the quality and consistency of assessments?
Helen Fisher: I will start with the same message that you heard from the other panel members: Homes England supports the introduction of more tools to ensure that there are things that can be done against those who are not doing what needs to be done.
In response to the question about independent scrutiny, the Bill is introducing tools to ensure that fire risk appraisals of the external wall are put on to a level where they will all have independent peer review. Our experience in Homes England is that when we put the cladding safety scheme together, we listened to residents and leaseholders; we worked extensively with End Our Cladding Scandal and others, and the message—this is the question that you are asking—came out very clearly from them that, over the decade since Grenfell, trust has broken down significantly between developers, building owners and managing agents. We placed the design of that programme significantly in the middle of that to make sure that any independent investigation that had been done by any party was brought into Homes England and put through panel engagement that was independently qualified in order to peer-review, challenge and ensure.
There are policy aspects that are difficult, such as proportionality; PAS 9980 itself has subjectivity to it, and we know, with our engineers and our panels, that there is a degree of growth there over the last two or three years in the programme. Scrutiny exists in the cladding safety scheme. I think we need to bottle that, and this Bill moves towards that—making sure of independent auditing of key investigation documents, such as a fire risk appraisal of an external wall, is having that form of scrutiny.
That is crucial for residents and leaseholders, so that they can have confidence in the documentation that is delivered by individuals and they do not have to concern themselves about who the original instructor of the documents is—whether it is a developer, a freeholder or a right-to-manage company. We have dealt with both ends of that spectrum from betterment and wanting the work to go further than expected, to the other end, where the position is trying to do the least amount of work as is tolerable.
I have a slightly different problem from Andy and Charlie, as we deal with this at every height. The Building Safety Regulator covers buildings of 18 metres-plus, and then there are high-rise buildings. The majority of 11 to 18-metre buildings now coming through are right-to-manage or small entities, so there is a need for us to operationally adapt to that to ensure we are giving support and helping with independent scrutiny, not just to ensure we hold the market to account, but to ensure support for right-to-manage companies so that they can take independent audit as assurance that that work is right for them.
Lord Roe: Could I just add something to provide a bit of assurance, since I imagine that some of your constituents will be watching? Obviously, if an HRB is above the threshold of 18 metres, it will come through our gateway process, which I know is onerous, but is onerous for a reason. We are going to look at the dead load of the façade engineering. We then look at it in the in-build phase as well, so we are going to get eyes on what they are doing—it is like building your extension—and then we sign it off. That is the point of enhanced building control, but it carries some complexity and it takes time.
On the flipside, although it does not solve some of the other problems around the split between internal and external defects, every high-rise building requires a building assessment certificate. That has been in law since 2024. Again, it was not communicated properly when the regulator was set up—we are not going to defend that—but we have done an enormous amount of communication since to educate and put guidance out there. That will mean that it has to come into our system on the basis of an assessment. We will look at the quality of that assessment in determining whether the evidence coming to us is accurate.
The safeguards are there in the legislation. The problem is that if you are living in one of these blocks, it is complex, it is long, it can be costly and there is a shortage of the specialists you need to deal with stuff. It is mind-blowing for professionals in the space who have been doing it for years—you do not have a hope as a resident management company director. I have the utmost sympathy for them.
The challenge to us is less about the Bill. I give credit to Helen; we see each other weekly and meet the campaign groups together. We are trying to get intelligence to improve across our shared systems. It is all about our operational improvement at the other end to bring internal and external defects together. Even if the funding does not match, can we do better inside our organisation to put it in the same team, so that you look at the building at one time? We are not there yet. We are on a pretty radical journey of transformation inside the regulator. A lot of stuff is a lot better, but there is more to do.
Rachel Blake (Cities of London and Westminster) (Lab/Co-op)
Q
Mark Norris: Shall I go first and have a quick stab at that? As you know, there are complex problems with finding out and addressing ownership of buildings. As Lord Roe said, there are bad actors who deliberately try to obfuscate ownership to make it more difficult for people to enforce against them. Certainly, the experience that local authorities have had when using the Housing Act 1988 is that that is a problem.
The provisions in the Bill are at least trying to move us into a position where it is harder for people to hide behind legal entities and not take responsibility for what they should be doing. That is a stronger provision that enables regulators to take action to identify who the right people are. It is really helpful. Will it entirely solve every single problem? No, it probably will not. There will continue to be bad actors who do the best they can to hide behind something, but this is a good step in the right direction and gives us additional tools to take the action that we want to take against the people who really are responsible.
Lord Roe: May I add one thing? It goes back to Gareth Bacon’s question, which is a good question, about the hierarchy of regulation. An extension of that is, “Who do you enforce against?”, in terms of what Mark said. It is important for regulators to talk to each other about hierarchy, who owns it and what you are going to do in the detail across different bits of legislation, but you need to make sure you are not enforcing against people who do not hold power in the system, particularly the resident management companies. There might be some rogue RMCs out there where you might need to do it, but I have not yet come across that situation.
I need people out there to hear that, certainly from our perspective, this measure would be a tool of absolute last resort against those entities, because most often they do not have the power even to resolve their own issues. I want to be really clear about that, because I know there is a heightened level of anxiety about what the Bill might do to those people, as if we are being forced as regulators into doing things to RMCs. We are not. We have choices as regulators. This is a great tool for some of the people you identify. Personally, I do not think it is designed to punch down at RMCs. I think it would be completely inappropriate. We would do everything else in our power to help resolve the situation with them before you got anywhere close to this.
The Chair
We have less than five minutes left, so I am afraid some colleagues will be disappointed.
Sarah Coombes (West Bromwich) (Lab)
Q
Lord Roe: Mark, Charlie and I dealt with this one, so I am going to volunteer Charlie, who is a bit of a victim really, while you think about it.
Charlie Pugsley: If it is the building in Dagenham, we have engaged consistently with residents since then. We are also working closely with London Fire Brigade. I have to be careful, even in Committee, not to talk about things that could prejudice a live investigation. One of the things we have heard loud and clear is about the knock-on impact of the case, where the entity has become dissolved and its estate is in effect taking money from the people who have already suffered the loss of their properties. That is one of the things that we are feeding back to the Department and other regulators. Both we and London Fire Brigade are still working on that. But we are both very much sighted on—this comes back to Lord Roe’s point that you need to approach enforcement with intelligence—in this case, what do we do if the only impact further impacts on residents?
Helen Fisher: May I add to that? Lord Roe made this point earlier. I think we all welcome the Bill. The behavioural point is an important one, and there are a couple of things on that. This is not just about remediation; it is about safety for residents and leaseholders while we get to their buildings, and there are thousands of buildings. We are starting to work with the social sector and the private sector to ensure that transparency is there. One of my goals is making sure that all residents and leaseholders understand when, and understand that they are going to be safe in the interim.
On the behaviour, it is not just about doing everything in your power to step through a design and remediation programme, which is undoubtedly incredibly complex. It is also about how you as a building owner are compliant with resident and leaseholder safety while you wait for key remediation works to go ahead. There is a lot more to do in that space.
Peter Fortune (Bromley and Biggin Hill) (Con)
Q
Lord Roe: The quick answer is that some of it helps, but my message—perhaps this is a good point to summarise from our point of view—is that there is a culture and leadership piece that needs to be understood in industry. We have watched industry really up its game over the past year and a half, so this is not a chance to bash them up, because I think people have worked very hard, but we still see appalling communication at an operational level from operational teams.
Even when the chief exec is leading the strategic entity well—we are talking about some large developers here—something happens at the operational level and they treat residents with disdain. There is no way you can enforce your way out of that, to be honest. We need the industry to take responsibility—even if it is bad news, please can you just communicate with your residents in a way that puts them, as a human, at the centre? Time and time again, that is where it starts to go wrong.
Charlie Pugsley: This is where all of us on the panel will communicate directly with those entities. We will put it in writing, even where it is outside the duty of resident communication, for example, and we will be really clear about what we expect.
Lord Roe: Again, the offer here is that if you have individual examples where the weight of the regulator will help, we are in with chief execs of the big and small developers all the time. We frequently have conversations in which we ask them to up their game, even if we cannot enforce it.
The Chair
Order. That brings us to the end of the time allotted for the Committee to ask questions of this panel. On behalf of the Committee, I thank our witnesses for their evidence. We will now change to the next panel.
Examination of Witnesses
Dan Daly, Penny Pender and Spencer Sutcliff gave evidence.
The Chair
We will now hear oral evidence from the National Fire Chiefs Council and Jonathan Smith, the commissioner of the London Fire Brigade. For this session, we have until 12.40 pm. Will the witnesses please briefly introduce themselves for the record?
Dan Daly: My name is Dan Daly, and I am the director of service delivery improvement at the National Fire Chiefs Council.
Penny Pender: My name is Penny Pender. I am the head of policy at the National Fire Chiefs Council.
Spencer Sutcliff: I am Spencer Sutcliff, the deputy commissioner at the London Fire Brigade, representing Jonathan Smith, the commissioner.
Q
Dan Daly: Currently, the answer would be no. For the work that has been ongoing, there have been some improvements to the monitoring of people who are undertaking risk assessments. Some work ahead—important work—is on the competency and regulating the role of the fire risk assessor. At the moment, more work is being undertaken by fire risk assessors, and that has been monitored. There is probably an overexaggeration of the levels of competency by individuals. Looking at the membership of professional bodies, alongside that competency route, is one of the ways to address the current shortfall. I admire the ambition in the Bill; it is important that we put high expectations on the delivery and remediation of buildings, but a number of aspects—one is the competency of fire risk assessors and access to them—are the Achilles heel of that ambition for the timeframe.
Q
Dan Daly: It is a fair challenge. As I say, personally, I quite like the idea of pushing or challenging timetables. Having said that, a number of the unresolved issues in the Bill we were talking about three years ago probably, and they remain unresolved. There is a pace to delivering the Bill and putting it in place where I think there are some weaknesses, and where those challenges are still present.
One of the aspects where we will be challenged is, to an extent, the pressing timeline to have a Bill in place, because it has been a long time coming. What we are seeing behind some of that is that it then pushes some real pressure on to other regulators, particularly around how we will work together under a collaboration and who takes the lead, which was part of the questions to the last panel. Those pressures are highly challenging, and it might have been better to have resolved them more satisfactorily before the Bill was launched.
James Asser
Q
We cannot answer what is actually wrong with the building, but everything stems from that in terms of whether we need to be clearing people out. In the first instance, everyone phoned the fire brigade, because they thought, “Hey, it’s not safe,” but it sits outside the fire brigade’s powers because it is not a fire issue; it is a structural one. In terms of your powers and where powers lie, where those responsible fail to take building safety seriously or to act when they should, what differences would clearer duties and stronger consequences make? Would additional powers in your remit be helpful in achieving that?
Dan Daly: As the previous panel talked about, the Bill provides a number of tools to a number of different regulators, and that is helpful and should be applauded. In terms of some of the unresolved questions and historical challenges that Lord Roe was talking about, the Bill will struggle to address some of the structural issues, and we will still find ourselves with the issue of who takes the lead in some circumstances. Because the issue falls back to one of public safety, fire and rescue services are often the agency that will stay around, even when we do not necessarily have an ability to affect the outcome, particularly when it comes to structural issues and issues of construction competence down the line. We will be there predominately to support residents and to try to protect their safety.
I am not sure whether it tackles the historical issues. They are some of the unresolved elements of competency throughout the system that we identified and were talking about three or even four years ago, when the Bill was first mooted. I am not sure whether it does enough to tackle those, but it does give some responsibility to regulators elsewhere, which does add value.
Spencer Sutcliff: The example in your constituency is somewhat symbolic of the wider building construction issues over the last few years. I have great sympathy for the impacted residents; it is a terrible situation for them. Dan Daly is correct that the London Fire Brigade has been drawn into this issue despite not having the powers, as it stands, to resolve it—although we naturally have responsibilities around emergency response and other contingency arrangements.
We welcome the Bill, and the work that we will be done to clarify the enforcing responsibilities of each responsible agency will be welcomed—we are a long way through that as it stands anyway, with various protocols and long-standing work and arrangements—but it will not necessarily resolve this particular issue, and I suspect that other unique challenges will show themselves over the years, like this one has more recently.
The Chair
Mr Asser, you want to repeat the declaration you made at the start of proceedings.
James Asser
Yes. I am sorry; I should have done that beforehand. My partner works for the London Fire Brigade in fire safety issues.
Sarah Gibson
Q
Penny Pender: That is a really good question. It depends on what you want to be achieved through the Bill. From the point of view of controlling the risk of fire spread on external walls—that fire safety point of view—we are satisfied that the PAS does what it needs to do. Obviously, it does not deal with how the building should have been constructed to begin with or those wider issues, so if that is something that people are looking for it to resolve, they will remain frustrated. Even though we are happy that it would deal with those critical life-safety issues, you are right to highlight that some of the wider issues, such as insurance, would not be addressed through that means.
Spencer Sutcliff: We think that PAS 9980 is an appropriate assessment, and we would not want, necessarily, to bring in further methodologies that could confuse the arrangement or provide further inconsistencies. It goes back to the root cause, which the previous panel touched on a number of times: the competency of the assessor. When you are using an assessment that always has an element of subjectivity, you are entirely reliant on the competence of the assessor, and we have seen various examples of different assessors coming to different conclusions using that assessment. There is some ongoing concern.
We really welcome and would like to see more of the auditing arrangements for Homes England. Certainly in the initial stages, I would like to see Homes England audit those premises that have been deemed “tolerable” and not just look at the ones that are effectively failing the assessment, because there needs to be confidence that those assessments are done in a consistent manner. We are back, a little bit, to the root cause around who is doing the assessments in the first place.
Penny Pender: If I might build on that, as Spencer says, no matter what methodology you select, if the people using that methodology do not have the right competencies to begin with, you will come across those issues. For the time being, we need that methodology. It is what we have available to us, so changing it at this point might not be helpful. I am aware that the PAS has been updated recently to make it clear that you have to have regard to and think about the wider risks in the building, so it should ultimately lead to those risks being identified. It is just a challenge for people, when they do identify them, how to address them.
Spencer Sutcliff: There is extensive work ongoing around the regulation of those assessors, and we have standards in place. We do not yet have formal regulation of who is permitted to carry out those assessments; that is a work in progress, and we really encourage that the pace of that work is maintained and that it is brought in as soon as possible.
Fleur Anderson
Q
Do you think that the Bill’s co-operation framework will help? The LFB, the borough council, the local management committee and the developer are all involved in conversations, but who can the residents go to for that independent assessment to be assured that the building is safe? Is there anything more that can be done in the Bill to help in that situation?
Spencer Sutcliff: I think the Bill provides a sufficient framework for the work to be done to clarify the exact position around the responsibilities of each of the enforcing entities. It is not unusual at all for the London Fire Brigade to have protocols and memorandums of understanding with different enforcing authorities. For example, we have a long-standing MOU in London with the local authority around houses in multiple occupation, because we both have enforcement powers under the fire safety order and the Housing Act. It is right and proper that we distinguish the type of building, the type of occupancy and who is the lead enforcing authority. To act at the same time is not good practice; it creates inconsistency and would not be correct.
I think the framework proposed in the Bill is sufficient. We have already drafted an enforcement protocol with the Bill in mind, so the timescale proposed in the Bill to set out that framework is suitable and can be met.
Q
In terms of the fire safety of buildings, are you content that the Bill, as currently structured, is sufficiently robust to achieve the safety inspections and sign-off that will be required in the future?
Dan Daly: One thing we have been really clear about ever since the tragedy of the Grenfell Tower fire is that a whole-system approach is required to ensure building safety. Dame Judith quite rightly identified the need for the whole regime to be looked at. There are still elements within that—they have been referenced today—around competency, which is still an issue. There are the general skills requirements both across the construction sector and within fire risk assessors; we talked about fire engineering skills and those with the technical ability to address some of the risks that we now face, particularly when dealing with a historical property.
Q
Dan Daly: It comes down not just to competency; when I talk about competency, I talk about ethical behaviours and how that is controlled through membership bodies and sign-out. I do not think it is an ideal situation. It is certainly a situation that was addressed by some of Dame Judith Hackitt’s comments in that original review.
On the point about a whole-system approach, while the Bill talks about remediation and provides some useful tools, it does not provide the complete answer, because there are historical defects in fire safety that are internal, not just about the external wall of the building. We still find challenges in respect of how those are addressed.
We talked earlier about the suitability of the PAS. The PAS does allow for some weighing up of other features within the building, in terms of how the risk is mitigated. That is a step forward from the combined advice note, which was pretty all-in or all-out and did not allow for some of that balance. But we have issues that are still sitting within the buildings, and there are a number of things we could be doing better and stronger to ensure that buildings are safe overall and to build the confidence of residents, which we talked about earlier.
Q
Dan Daly: To your latter point, it is the role of the Building Safety Regulator to make sure that these things are built correctly from this point on. The last panel talked about the work in that regard.
I think the responsibilities for remediation are clear in the Bill, which assigns responsibility through the “polluter pays” principle, so it is much clearer who is responsible for repairing buildings. Our ability to enforce that would be improved if some of the protocols were agreed around who collaborates and who leads. I note the work in the LFB around writing protocol at the moment, but elsewhere in the country there are some really ambitious and difficult timeframes; if we press ahead as we are now, something in the region of 157 individual partnership protocols will need to be written so that each regulator understands its role in holding the relevant persons to account. That is a challenge.
While the Bill makes it clearer who is responsible, who is going to lead the charge to hold those people to account could be made even clearer through something like a review of the LACORS protocol that we currently have, to make sure that those things are in place and applied consistently across the country. As I said, I commend colleagues in London for being on the front foot in getting that agreement in place. If that agreement was adopted as a national standard, it would bring some consistency of approach across the country and some confidence in how these things are dealt with.
Noah Law
Q
Dan Daly: I will pick up on your last question and then hand over to my colleague on the independent auditing, because we have been talking about that. We already have a duty to collaborate, so that is not new, but providing some clarity around how regulators and agencies will work together in a consistent way that is applied nationally will improve it. I am not sure that it offers us individually anything more than we currently have, but across the wider sector, that duty to collaborate is not unhelpful.
Penny Pender: The point in the Bill about solidifying independent auditing is crucial, and I agree with everything that Helen on the previous panel said. That is a really welcome part of the Bill, and it will hopefully assist in these cases. If I may speak to the concern that Mr Blackman mentioned, just because something has planning permission does not mean that it meets the functional requirements of the building regulations. If those buildings went up with combustible cladding on them, they do not meet the building regulations, full stop. Hopefully there are sufficient powers across the built environment to deal with that, and we would hope to see the Building Safety Regulator and others step in where needed.
There might be room for examining the implementation dates for the Bill, because there are some possible gaps. The Bill will only apply, I think, to buildings that were built before April ’22. There are some periods of time there, such as the possible 15-month gap between when the Building Safety Act came into force and when gateway 2 started, that might bear examination and would be good to look into. There was also an eight-month gap between the Bill coming into force and the review of the combustible cladding ban.
You might recall that there was a combustible cladding ban put in place for buildings over 18 metres; that was reviewed and it was clarified that it would apply from 11 metres, but there was an eight-month gap during which it might have been incorrectly perceived by some in industry—even though we would disagree—that it was acceptable to put combustible material on to those buildings. Even though we would say ultimately that it still does not meet the functional requirements, some may have misunderstood that, so it would be worth examining the timeframes in the Bill to make sure that that is okay.
Rachel Blake
Q
Penny Pender: That is a good question. I would suggest that it is possibly not necessary. There is already a lead regulator’s protocol in existence. It is known as the LACORS guidance, produced by local authority co-ordinators of regulatory services. All authorities would have had local agreements in place aligning to that at some point. The challenge is that it was not kept up to date, particularly following the implementation of the Building Safety Act.
We have been advocating for it to be updated since then. That could be achieved without waiting for primary legislation, and it would be helpful if it was done once and done nationally, and then local regulators were given the option to adopt it or to develop their own ones if they felt that was necessary. As Spencer said, London has done a lot of the heavy lifting already with the pan-London fire safety protocol, so that could easily be lifted and shifted and adopted nationally.
As Dan said, the impact assessment identifies that outside of mayoral arrangements, there could be anywhere up to 157 local partnership agreements that would have to be developed and signed off within only a four-month time period. Our concern is that that could distract from local enforcement on the ground, because in some of the smaller authorities, the staff who are needed for enforcement would have to be diverted towards developing the agreements or writing to the Secretary of State to justify why they have not. We think it should be done nationally and done once.
Rachel Blake
Q
Penny Pender: Yes, absolutely. I am sure they will be. We will be encouraging our members to do exactly that.
Dan Daly: With everyone tuning in independently, though, there is a risk of inconsistency, so some central co-ordination would bring the consistency we are looking for.
Rachel Blake
Q
Penny Pender: One of the benefits of those types of protocols is that they identify the local working arrangements when there is a need for escalation, so it would be dealt with within the scope of those.
Rachel Blake
Q
Dan Daly: We have been saying collectively that what is in here at the minute does not do the work that we would like it to do. We would like that national co-ordination, and within that agreement, for there to be sign-up from partners on who owns the lead in certain circumstances, so it should not require someone to step in and mediate.
Without that agreement, there is more risk of delay as people debate inconsistently through local agreements, or you have a stand-off between agencies because there is no agreement in place. We can tackle that by moving the national agreement forward more quickly to remove the doubt and maybe answer the questions you are asking.
Q
Spencer Sutcliff: Naturally, we are very supportive of RPEEPs and personal evacuation plans. However, our preference would be for the measure to go further and look at fire risk within homes, rather than just being focused on the escape routes.
Dan Daly: I think there are other benefits, one of which is about providing extra assurance on the plans that have been put in place. We know that fires start inside individual dwellings; they rarely start in the common parts of a building. There is also an opportunity to ensure the maintenance of some of the passive fire safety protection that is designed within a building—whether that is where people have access to common service risers, or where they have made adaptions to fire doors and things inside those properties. That is part of the building integrity overall.
Q
Dan Daly: I think the partnership agreement I was talking about would set out very clearly, in certain circumstances, who was leading on what. At the moment, where that is not as clear as it could be, and where there is a reliance on separate entities coming up with these in quick order after the Bill is passed, that leads to the possibility of inconsistency in how they are done. Of course, they do not always come to those agreements quickly, because there will be different viewpoints, so I do not think it would be unhelpful to do that ahead of time.
Sarah Coombes
Q
Penny Pender: I think that the Bill provides a few more tools in the toolbox, as some of our colleagues said earlier. I think the introduction of some of those financial penalties is really interesting and useful to see. The proof will be in the pudding, so it is certainly worth trying them in certain circumstances and seeing how it goes. We hope that they will be helpful. I know that some fire and rescue services have potential interest in those being expanded beyond just the Bill to the application of the whole fire safety order. I think this will be a really useful opportunity to see how it goes, and then to learn from that. Hopefully, it will make a difference.
Peter Fortune
Q
Spencer Sutcliff: That has been a fairly long-standing concern of ours. We have obviously prioritised that and done a lot of work in-house, and our competency levels—as we would determine them—have improved fairly significantly over the last few years. We certainly had a moment in time when we lost quite a high number of highly competent and experienced staff to the private sector, because we simply could not compete financially. We have been well supported by the London Mayor and our GLA colleagues to make arrangements to reduce that impact a little, and that has had some positive effects. Recently, over the last 24 months, we have thankfully had much less of that.
The Chair
That brings us to the end of the time allotted for the Committee to ask questions to this panel. On behalf of the Committee, I thank the witnesses for their evidence.
Examination of Witness
Kate Green gave evidence.
The Chair
We will now hear oral evidence from Kate Green, the deputy Mayor of Greater Manchester. I want to confirm, Kate, that you can hear and see us in the Committee. Under the programme order, we have until 1 pm for this panel. Will you briefly introduce yourself for the record?
Kate Green: Yes, and thank you for the invitation to address the Committee. I am Kate Green. I am the deputy Mayor of Greater Manchester with responsibility for safer and stronger communities.
Q
Kate Green: I think it is true to say, Mr Bacon, that one of the things that residents are looking for is greater certainty, and this is a very complex regulatory and enforcement landscape. We would certainly like to see greater clarity, not necessarily in the Bill, but perhaps in supporting documentation and guidance on how different regulators and enforcers interact with one another, on the escalation processes, and on who is responsible for taking enforcement action in specific circumstances, so that residents can be confident in how the processes work and that they work smoothly and seamlessly.
Q
Kate Green: Capacity is a real concern across the whole system, including for local authorities, as you rightly identify. We have welcomed, and Greater Manchester fire and rescue service, which I oversee on the mayor’s behalf, has welcomed the additional funding that we have received, but it will be important that all new burdens on local authorities are funded adequately and sustainably. The enforcement requirement—that regulatory role—is here to stay; it is not just a one-off, albeit that we clearly have a surge of activity and demand as we remediate a significant number of buildings in Greater Manchester, as part of the legacy of the appalling Grenfell Tower fire nearly 10 years ago.
I think it is important to recognise that particularly across fire safety enforcement and inspection we are struggling to recruit and, more significantly, to retain staff. There are real pressures and competition from private sector employers, who can offer much higher salaries. In Greater Manchester, across all 10 of our local authorities, we are giving high priority to protecting and supporting our residents, but there is no doubt that in times of considerable financial pressure on local government, as you identify, that is a challenge—and it is one that the Government will need to ensure is adequately resourced, so that local authorities and other statutory services can properly fulfil their responsibilities.
Q
Kate Green: The first thing is to provide greater certainty and clarity about what is encompassed in the Government’s remediation commitments. We very much welcome the Bill and the funding already being made available to us to take steps to support our residents. It is useful to have those much more effective funding pathways.
We particularly welcomed the improvements in the funding process through the cladding safety scheme. I pay tribute to Homes England and Helen Fisher, whom I think you have heard from already this morning. That scheme has been a real game changer in enabling funding to begin to move into the system so that buildings can be remediated.
I welcome the provisions in the Bill on mitigations for residents who are exercising the right to manage their buildings or are in resident management companies, although we have concerns that there remains a risk of penalties and sanctions for those residents. We have made progress in Greater Manchester as a result of the attention that the Government have given to remediation of buildings with fire safety defects in recent years. According to MHCLG data, remediation has been completed for 152 buildings in Greater Manchester, but that means that we still have 181, as at quarter 4 last year, for which remediation is deemed outstanding. I would also point to the buildings that require remediation for other defects that will not be covered by the scope of this legislation.
Q
Kate Green: This is a helpful provision; it potentially gives regulators a timelier and more proportionate enforcement option, but we would not want that to arrive at a situation where commercial developers, who often have very deep pockets, considered that a financial penalty was an acceptable cost of delay and that they could afford to hold back, address other priorities that they might have and just pay the price of that. We really do see those penalties as a backstop to other effective enforcement action.
We would also draw attention to the need for the capacity to use that civil route to secure compliance. There will need to be investigation, evidence gathering, decision making and dealing with appeals, and all that will require sustainable long-term funding in to the system. A civil route is certainly welcome. However, our other concern is about buildings subject to the developer contract, where using a contractual route rather than a statutory basis to ensure compliance puts more hurdles, if you like, in the way of residents seeking to have their buildings remediated.
Sarah Gibson
Q
Kate Green: Yes. Unfortunately, I did not hear Ms Fisher’s evidence this morning, but I do share those concerns. There will be an audit process, but that will be a dip sample, in a way; there will not be capacity for Homes England to audit every fire risk assessment that is undertaken. We will need to know that we have a robust audit process and that Homes England has the resources to carry that out.
We also need to be clear that where fire risks are deemed tolerable, there is an appropriate response from the insurance industry, which recognises that they must have full regard to that audit process based on the PAS 9980 framework that you referred to, and that, if fire risks are deemed tolerable, residents should not be penalised by higher insurance premiums, because effectively the insurance now has that assurance that the building can be insured cost-effectively.
Sarah Gibson
Q
Kate Green: I share that concern. The Government will need to ensure that the fire risk assessments and the decisions of fire risk assessors are robust and consistent. Otherwise, there are avenues open for people to game the system or to obtain an assessment that is more favourable to their own interests.
There is a risk there, and I hope that in the course of the passage of the Bill the Government will think about how they can ensure that that fire risk assessment PAS 9980 framework is fully robust and can give full assurance to residents.
Q
Kate Green: I think that the mayoral combined authority has had and can continue to have a role in helping to speed up the process. In Greater Manchester, shortly after the appalling fire in Grenfell Tower in 2017, the then mayor established a high-rise taskforce, chaired by Paul Dennett, the Salford city council mayor. Paul now chairs a high-rise oversight group where we are able to convene local authorities and the Greater Manchester fire and rescue service. Homes England attends, as do the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, housing providers, developers and residents. They can all be convened around one remediation programme.
Of course you will know, as members of the Committee, that we and other mayoral combined authorities published our local remediation acceleration plans in recent months. Those plans are the articulation of the whole-system approach that I think mayors and mayoral combined authorities can help to put in place. We have been able to use our plan to do a number of things, including, obviously, to understand more clearly what buildings are affected in Greater Manchester and what the nature of the risk is in each of those buildings. We have been able to be close to and very fully engaged with our residents, and to ensure that a residents-first focus sits at the heart of the work that we are doing in Greater Manchester and the work that we want to see nationally.
We have been able to bring the social housing partners to the table, which has been exceptionally useful in considering how we get social properties remediated and how we can work with our social housing providers in Greater Manchester to do that as swiftly and as effectively as possible. We can escalate matters when they become stalled. We have also been able to lobby Government; I think it has been helpful that Greater Manchester has been able to present a concerted voice to successive Governments for funding and for action—now resulting in this legislation.
There is a lot more that we hope to do with our local remediation acceleration plan in the coming months and years, and at the heart of that will be resident engagement. Our residents continue to live with a very significant impact on their mental health and their financial position, and in many cases with continuing uncertainty about when their buildings will be fully remediated. I see the work that we are able to do as a mayoral combined authority, maintaining the spotlight on the lived experience of our residents and reflecting that back both into the action that we can take and into the action that we ask national Government to take, as being crucial.
The final thing I will say, given that I have the very specific role of oversight of the fire and rescue service, is that in Greater Manchester we have been able to prioritise having the right capacity in the Greater Manchester fire and rescue service to support the regulatory regime—the inspection and enforcement programmes that are required. That work, and the oversight of the implementation of all the recommendations that came out of the two Grenfell Tower inquiry reports, is being taken forward. We can oversee all that through a series of governance structures that are led by our chief fire officer. One of the things that mayoral combined authorities are in a very useful position to do is to draw all those different players in a geography together.
Peter Fortune
Q
Kate Green: On right to manage and resident management companies—although obviously we are also concerned that all charges are eventually at risk of being passed through to residents—the first thing I would say is that they are already experiencing quite significant financial burdens, because they are unremunerated for what is in many cases a substantial workload. Despite the welcome mitigations in the Bill, they also still ultimately face the risk of criminal sanctions, so we would certainly like attention to be given to that.
In terms of service charges, there are concerns around transparency; residents must be fully informed about the way in which service charges are made up. In my past life as a constituency MP, I think we saw that some professional commercial managing agents were more transparent than others. There needs to be that ability to ensure that the conduct of commercial managing agents is in the interests of residents—obviously they will be acting in the interests of their principal, but we should be very clear about their obligations on behalf of their principal to residents. Frankly, appeals are the last resort, are they not? What we actually want to see is a robust system, which ensures that service charges are fair and proportionate, and that no resident is required to pay, through their service charge or otherwise, for faults and defects in their building that are not of their making.
Peter Fortune
Q
Kate Green: I would certainly want to see more protection for residents who are acting in the right to manage and resident management company space. Prescribing more closely what can and cannot be reflected through service charges may be something that the Government should explore.
Sagal Abdi-Wali
Q
Kate Green: The difference ought to be, from the perspective of the resident, that the work gets done first and that the argument about who pays does not delay the work to make their homes safe. A backstop needs to be exactly what it claims to be: a backstop. What we actually want is a system that ensures, much more swiftly, much earlier and much more effectively, that people fulfil the remediation obligations imposed on them.
As I say, we are probably particularly concerned about those developers whose remediation activity will be overseen through the medium of the developer contracts. We still have quite a complex landscape, I think, of ways in which residents might try to compel remediation. A backstop is necessary, but we would much prefer to see a left shift, ensuring that the obligation to remediate is carried out by responsible actors at the earliest point and is compliant with regulatory requirements from the start of the process.
Q
Kate Green: There are two things: one is that we would like to see the Bill extended to cover defects that are not related to cladding or external walls; the second is workforce capacity. By that I mean capacity both in the regulatory sector—fire authorities, fire services, local authorities and other regulators—and in the construction sector. The tension that the Government are managing between meeting their house building targets, which we support, and getting existing buildings remediated in an industrial sector that is facing significant workforce pressures is a real concern to us.
The Chair
Order. That brings us to the end of the time allotted for the Committee to ask questions this morning. On behalf of the Committee, I thank you, Kate, for your evidence.
Ordered, That further consideration be now adjourned.—(Sarah Coombes.)
(6 days, 4 hours ago)
Public Bill Committees
The Chair
We are now sitting in public and the proceedings are being broadcast. Before we start hearing from the witnesses, do any Members wish to make a declaration of interest in connection with the Bill?
Only that the headquarters for the London Fire Brigade are in my constituency.
Examination of Witnesses
Jaclyn Mangaroo and Kate Henderson gave evidence.
The Chair
We will now hear oral evidence from the Property Institute and the National Housing Federation. We have until 2.35 pm for this panel. May I ask the witnesses to introduce themselves briefly?
Kate Henderson: My name is Kate Henderson. I am chief executive of the National Housing Federation. We represent not-for-profit providers of social and affordable housing in England.
Jaclyn Mangaroo: I am Jaclyn Mangaroo from the Property Institute. We are the professional body for residential property managers. Our members manage about 2.5 million homes across the country and are directly involved in supporting remediation projects and affected residents.
Q
Kate Henderson: First, thank you for inviting the National Housing Federation to give evidence to the Committee. The safety of residents is our No. 1 priority, and we welcome the Bill and its intention. I also acknowledge and pay tribute to the work of Grenfell United; we are here because of the tragic fire at Grenfell Tower, where 72 people lost their lives.
We are absolutely committed to accelerating the pace of remediation in the social housing sector. There was no funding for social housing remediation until the spending review in 2025. Social housing providers were paying for remediation themselves, and that took money away from major refurbishments and new supply. Since the very welcome access was granted to the cladding safety scheme, we have been able to accelerate the pace of remediation, and we expect more properties to come forward.
We can supply the facts and figures on how many properties we have remediated self-funded and how many are being remediated with Government funding to the Committee. I have the details here, but I am not sure that anyone wants me to go through the facts and figures now.
Q
Kate Henderson: Not having funding for remediation has undoubtedly taken huge capacity out of the social housing sector. Since the fire, we have been working very hard to remediate buildings, but the pace of that, without Government funding, was much slower than we would have liked. Last year’s funding has changed this, but it is not just about money; it is also about the system around it. It is about the capacity of the Building Safety Regulator, and not just external walls but internal defects, and the system of assurance and having enough technical competency to support us in that work.
Q
Kate Henderson: The new leadership of the Building Safety Regulator has undoubtedly improved things, but up until the last 18 months, when gateway 2 timeframes have started to improve, it has been very slow. It is really important that the Building Safety Regulator and the forthcoming single construction regulator are adequately resourced by Government to deliver at scale and pace. In the wider construction sector, there is huge upskilling to do to ensure we have the expertise to do fire risk assessments of external walls—FRAEWs—and get consistency of implementation of methodology with PAS 9980,. We are working with lots of people and contractors in the process, but we need many more.
In addition to needing more people with expertise, we need consistency, which I know came up in evidence this morning. At the moment, we are hearing from our members that PAS 9980 is subjective, and different assessors will come up with different decisions. You can have two assessors look at the same property; one will say it requires remediation and one will say it does not. The proposal for a mandatory audit system with Homes England is very welcome. We would like a feedback loop to be built into that system so that any poor practice can be identified and challenged and any patterns of inconsistencies can be flagged. Then, that feedback can be taken back into account in any future updates of PAS 9980.
The Chair
Q
Jaclyn Mangaroo: I agree with a lot of what you said, Kate, particularly around the upskilling and resource elements. What we and our members see is that some of the delays start much earlier in the gateway 2 process. The real problem, which this Bill, with some amendments, will hopefully tackle, is where buildings are completely stalled from the beginning—where scope of works cannot be agreed and, like Kate said, where FRAEWs differ. Standardisation and auditing of FRAEWs will definitely help, as long as that is a speedy process. I understand that we are still waiting on regulation of the fire risk assessor profession.
The Chair
If there is anything that you want the Committee to know, you can write in. Ms Henderson, you suggested that there was some information that should be put before the Committee.
Q
Jaclyn Mangaroo: That is a very good question. I think it goes some of the way by imposing that legal duty, but sometimes that does not fall on the person who will be accountable in terms of having the resources or being able to actually deliver remediation. I am thinking about resident management companies and right to manage companies that would become responsible entities and have that legal duty. They do not necessarily have the resources needed to compel a pledged developer, for example, or a product manufacturer to do that without pursuing them through litigation. RMCs and RTMCs do not really have those resources; they have the service charges, but they cannot always use those to fund litigation or remediation works themselves.
Q
Jaclyn Mangaroo: We welcome the remediation backstop, but that it would be great to see that come further forward so that you do not have to go through enforcement or sanctions to get to that remediation backstop. Particularly where we have evidence that buildings are stalled in the very early stages of project scoping, I think that that would be a reasonable opportunity for the regulators to step in and bring in a remediation manager or bring forward a remediation order or remediation contribution order. I do not think that some of those resources are necessarily being used proactively. I have not seen any transparent data on their use by Homes England and other regulators, and I think that could really help.
Q
Kate Henderson: Equal access to remediation funding, brought in last year at the spending review, is hugely welcome. It has made a big difference to our ability to deliver remediation at pace and to invest in existing homes and development. Previously, our members—housing associations—and councils had to self-fund remediation, which diverted resources away from new homes and refurbishment. Some of our members even had to sell buildings to pay for remediation work. Members are now actively applying to the cladding safety scheme and receiving funding. We are expecting starts and completions of remediation by our members to begin to increase as we get the approvals. Homes England will be able to provide more data on that.
Funding from the cladding safety scheme also funds things such as project management, which is really important to deliver remediation faster. It frees capacity within our member organisations to build new affordable homes and improve existing ones. I should say that the funding only covers external wall defects; members are still facing significant costs for internal walls, including compartmentation and fire doors. We very much welcome the cladding safety scheme funding for high-risk buildings, and new funding has become available for buildings under 11 metres that are also deemed high-risk. That opened earlier this year, and we understand that that fund for buildings under 11 metres is massively oversubscribed. It would be really useful to have the data from those applications to understand the scale of works required in high-risk buildings under 11 metres.
In the sector more broadly, there are lots of other significant changes happening. We absolutely support Awaab’s law and welcome the clarity in the decent homes standard, but recognise that those measures all add cost. Remediation funding that we have access to very much helps to meet those competing demands and makes them more manageable, but the overall financial picture remains complex and has its challenges.
Sarah Gibson (Chippenham) (LD)
Q
Jaclyn Mangaroo: That is a really good question. In some cases, it may be. We have seen it most often with the pledged developers where they are using a contractor that may be part of the organisation, and so are marking their own homework. For a responsible entity where it is an enfranchised building, or where an RMC or an RTMC has the opportunity, they have really no incentive to say that their building is safe when it is not. They have very little incentive to do that. They really want to go much further.
The regulation of the profession will certainly help to improve competency, and hopefully it will speed up the process and reduce delays, as long as that auditing of the fire risk assessments can be done quickly through Homes England. We are all about making sure that there are fewer delays, that stalled buildings can get started and that residents have peace of mind. There is no deadline. There is no set date for when buildings will be finished, so making sure that we get peace of mind, confidence and protection of residents into this Bill will be so important. That is how we have approached our written evidence to the Committee: does it speed things up, does it provide clearer accountability and will it actually give residents peace of mind and create safer buildings?
Sarah Gibson
Q
Jaclyn Mangaroo: I do not know of any particular cases of that. It is more when there is a pledged developer involved. I cannot comment specifically on any other cases.
Kate Henderson: From our members’ perspective, we have already been working really hard to deliver the duties that will become part of the Bill: for example, assessing buildings, mitigating risk, applying for funding and carrying out remediation works. We welcome the introduction of the remediation compliance plans as a way of demonstrating transparency and accountability to enforcing bodies, but also of demonstrating accountability to residents. Having clear plans and timelines will help ensure that expectations are managed, that any delays are addressed quickly, that enforcement action can be taken against bad actors and, in exceptional circumstances, that the backstop can be used to secure a route to remediation.
We welcome standardisation of the fire risk assessments of external walls methodology and the intention that every building be assessed and remediated to the same standard. As I have mentioned, the PAS 9980 methodology has already been used to access funding to the cladding safety scheme. I have also mentioned that we have mixed experience of assessors using PAS 9980 and that it can be subjective. Having a national audit system run by Homes England with a feedback loop will be really welcomed by the sector. I should also say that alongside auditing, as you have mentioned, having regulation of the competence of risk assessors as part of the introduction of a single construction regulator will help to ensure that recommendations are consistent and of good quality. That will provide assurance and transparency to all involved, particularly residents.
Sean Woodcock (Banbury) (Lab)
Q
Kate Henderson: There is nothing more important than residents’ safety, and I can assure you that our members have safety as their utmost priority and responsibility. We are already delivering a huge number of aspects of remediation work that will be covered by and become statutory duties in the Bill, and we welcome that. This legislation is only one piece of the response to the tragedy at Grenfell Tower. There are other pieces of legislation, but in addition to that, a huge part of this work is around culture. It is around learning, accountability and the relationship between residents and their landlords.
As part of that, in a couple of weeks’ time we will be launching a suite of tools for our members—a Grenfell Tower reflection toolkit. This is about learning lessons from the inquiry. It is a suite of resources for board members, executives, operational levels, large organisations and small organisations, making sure that this is not just about physically replacing cladding, but about listening and acting on the information being provided by residents, having appropriate assurances in place, and making it culturally at the heart of who we are as organisations.
On whether we have the capacity to deliver these new requirements, we are already doing a lot of it, but the capacity of the overall system is not us alone. We rely on expertise, fire risk assessors, contractors and the capacity of the Building Safety Regulator. A lot of work is happening on all those fronts, but everybody is going to have to work harder. We are going to need a lot more people and a lot more expertise. We are really pleased to see the leadership of the Building Safety Regulator drive forward the pace of assessments to gateway 2. We are seeing improvements there. That needs to continue, and we are committed to working with all involved, including Government and particularly residents.
Lewis Cocking (Broxbourne) (Con)
Q
Kate Henderson: I am not sure that as the trade body, with our members being the regulated entity, we are best placed to answer that question.
Lewis Cocking
Q
Kate Henderson: We would very much welcome clarity on the regulatory system to ensure that we get clarity on the works that need to happen in a timely way. How that would be worked out is perhaps a question for Government. I do not think I am best placed on that one.
Jaclyn Mangaroo: I agree with that. I think clarity is absolutely key for every provision in the Bill. It is not something that TPI can necessarily comment on, but we need to identify who the final decision maker is.
Andrew Cooper (Mid Cheshire) (Lab)
Q
Jaclyn Mangaroo: Hopefully, issues in those cases will be few and far between, but the backstop and the appointment of a remediation manager is the only way to go. It is important that residents have some certainty and a point of contact in somebody who will be responsible for that. At the moment, yes, I think the Bill does go far enough in those cases.
Andrew Cooper
Q
On the other side, the Government have provided some certainty to the sector through rent convergence, through the 10-year rent settlement, through the social and affordable homes programme and by bringing you in scope of the building safety fund. Do we have the balance right in the resources that are available to the sector from central Government versus what you would expect housing associations to fund directly, either through service charges or through rents paid by tenants?
Kate Henderson: Thank you very much for the question. In the last 18 months, the Government have done a huge amount to rebuild the capacity of the social housing sector—housing associations and councils. Importantly, that has included equal access to building safety funding with an additional £1 billion into the cladding safety scheme. Alongside that, we now have a 10-year rent settlement, rent convergence and the new National Housing Bank. Low-interest loans will hopefully be introduced soon. We also have, of course, the social and affordable homes programme.
The Government have very much listened and engaged and are working constructively with us. We are ambitious, both about ensuring that our existing homes and service provision are of the quality that we would all want and about building many more new homes. All our members are impacted by the building safety crisis, but those less impacted now have more capacity to deliver homes. If grant funding were available, we could deliver tens of thousands more social and affordable homes.
In terms of the balance we have now, we are looking at the overall regulatory landscape. As I say, we support the introduction of the decent homes standard and the implementation of Awaab’s law. We absolutely support and are working very hard on the building safety regulations. But there is a cost to all of this. Our ability to do all those things at once will be down to the individual priorities of organisations. We are meeting quite stringent timelines, which have been set by Government, on things like minimum energy efficiency standards. We support that direction of travel, but there is only so much money in the system.
You mentioned regeneration. We would really welcome more flexibility in the social and affordable homes programme to deliver replacement supply as well as new supply. We are very focused on net additions. I understand that we desperately need more homes, but we do need to invest in places. Similarly, when it comes to investing in building safety measures, I have mentioned the welcome funding that came earlier this year for high-risk buildings under 11 metres. There is not enough money to support those works. If there were more money, based on assessment of the applications that have come into Homes England for the under-11-metre scheme, that would free up the capacity to do more supply. We want to do all those things; our ability to do them at pace is impacted by how much money there is in the system.
Peter Fortune (Bromley and Biggin Hill) (Con)
Q
If I can be cheeky, I have a second question, which should perhaps go to Kate. Do you have sight of your members’ risk registers? If so, how are they flashing up some of the challenges presented in the Bill?
Jaclyn Mangaroo: Much of our written evidence is focused not just on the service charges, but on the unintended consequences. It might fall on residents to fund litigation to pursue the responsible people—the polluter, effectively—to deliver remediation. We want to see greater protection for those.
There is already a lot of law, particularly under the Building Safety Act 2022, around what can be passed through the service charges and what cannot. Building Safety Act costs and service charges have gone up around 50% in the last two years. That is still a very small proportion of those service charge costs, but where residents are not protected at all is for risk mitigation measures, interim measures, fixing internal defects and non-cladding work. There is no funding for that. It is outside the scope of the remediation contract for the developers; it is outside the scope of PAS 9980.
Ultimately, when we speak to our members, mostly residents are picking up the tabs for those interim measures, regardless of whether they are waiting for the cladding to be replaced. Compartmentation, fire stopping and fire doors is a significant issue. We must look at how we fund that and how we protect leaseholders from those rising service charge costs.
The other thing, which came up this morning as well, is higher insurance premiums. We are seeing insurers and lenders price risk not just on cladding, but on those internal defects and on structural defects. We do not just have a cladding crisis; we have a safety and construction quality crisis. That is what we are finding. These buildings are not lasting as long as they should. That is coming home to roost and is landing on leaseholders. They did not cause these problems in the first place, but it is being visited upon them, so one of the things we would like to see is greater protection for those residents.
Part of that solution will be looking at the qualifying and non-qualifying leaseholder protection provisions in the Building Safety Act. We appreciate that the Secretary of State introduced proposals to change some of the rules around that. We would like to see it go altogether. Why, as a leaseholder, should you have to pay for any defect that was not of your making? The process, the regime, is highly complicated. It is very, very difficult for a leaseholder to get involved in the process, and it creates an unstable resource pot to fund the remediation, because even if you have a cap, you only pay 10% of that cap, which means that you could be waiting 10 years until the pot is large enough to undertake those works.
There is a lot that can be done to protect leaseholders from further costs from all this. Good question—thank you.
The Chair
We have five minutes left and one Member to get in, so I will be grateful if you can keep your answer quite brief.
Kate Henderson: Yes, of course. I agree with what has been said. It is important to recognise just how distressing this is for leaseholders and shared owners, who feel trapped, cannot sell their home and are facing rising service charges and insurance bills. People really need a route forward. Accelerating remediation is absolutely the key to this. For us, having access to remediation funding has been a really important step forward, but we want to work with Government to unblock delays and ensure that wider safety defects do not leave residents facing continued uncertainty. There is more I could say there, but I will not. I will just say, on risk registers, that the Regulator of Social Housing will collect this data and will be engaging with all housing associations, but they have to stress-test their business models.
In terms of risk, the Bill itself is part of a tool for addressing the wider building safety crisis. Building safety will be a top risk for all our members, and they will all have mitigation strategies.
James Asser (West Ham and Beckton) (Lab)
Q
Jaclyn Mangaroo: Where there is an RMC or an RTM director or company, they should be given access to a fund to at least fund the litigation up front; they should not have to be scrabbling around in their pockets to try to fund litigation or go after developers. That would be really helpful. It is unfair that they have taken on a role as a volunteer, as you say, are trying to do the right thing and are having this duty visited upon them. I think they will need special consideration when it comes to the enforcement and sanctions in the Bill. They do not have a big pot of money to fund either the remediation work itself or the litigation costs or legal costs to pursue the responsible parties.
The Chair
We have come to the end of our allotted time. On behalf of the Committee, I thank you very much for your evidence.
Examination of Witnesses
Giles Grover and Sophie Bichener gave evidence.
The Chair
We will now hear oral evidence from End Our Cladding Scandal. We have until 3 pm for this panel. Could the witnesses briefly identify themselves?
Giles Grover: Hi, I am Giles Grover. I am the co-lead of End Our Cladding Scandal. I am a resident and leaseholder, and an RMC director and principal accountable person. I have been trapped and involved in this crisis since August 2017, and I still have a home that is not safe.
Sophie Bichener: I am Sophie Bichener, a campaigner for End Our Cladding Scandal and an impacted leaseholder. My building has been through one round of remediation. It was found to be unsafe the month after the Grenfell tragedy, and we are still working through trying to fully remediate it. Giles and I support leaseholders up and down the country who are like us: trapped in buildings that are unremediated and unsafe.
Q
Giles Grover: Essentially, improving a failed system is not the same as introducing one that is capable of fixing this crisis once and for all. We have been dealing with this for nine years, and particularly for the last two years we have been pointing out all these issues—the gaps in protection, the non-cladding defects that keep being mentioned and what needs to be done to actually end this crisis—but we have not really seen any movement.
The Bill is still focused on external walls. It puts a lot of strain on volunteer directors and rules out developers from a legal duty to remediate, and it still focuses on cladding. It does not really deal with all the issues we have seen for the last seven, eight or nine years. As far as we are concerned, it just addresses a lot of the gaps and mistakes from the Building Safety Act—the ineffective protections and the fact that people are just getting pushed from pillar to post. This Bill will make things a heck of a lot more complicated for people, and it will not deliver the certainty we need to actually end this crisis.
Sophie Bichener: We consider a lot of people and a lot of different situations. When we saw the Bill, we were able to stress-test it through lots of different buildings and leaseholders. There is not likely to be a silver bullet that fixes every single scenario, but this Bill leaves too many gaps in our minds, as Giles said, with the non-cladding defects and non-qualifying leaseholders, and it places an unfair burden on RMC buildings and leaves leaseholders with sky-high interim costs. While we wait for these laws to play out and for buildings to be remediated, many leaseholders are still struggling with the interim costs and unaffordable service charges.
Q
Giles Grover: I do not know how far back to go in terms of all the legislation that is already out there, but we can start with the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, and there is the Fire Safety Act 2021, which clarifies that, the Fire Safety (England) Regulations 2022, the Building Safety Act 2022 and the changes to it with leasehold reform—and now we have another Bill. We have all these different laws that have been put in place, a heck of a lot of different interpretations of risk and different funding schemes. That will need regulators all over the place—central regulators, local regulators, MHCLG regulators. You have the developer contract, the building safety regulator, the recovery strategy unit and local remediation acceleration plans as well.
This is just adding a layer of complexity. It is not actually giving us what we need. We have some people in some buildings at some heights being protected from the costs of some defects. Rather than fixing that and addressing those gaps, we are focusing on cladding and not thinking about making a building fully safe. We have a number of buildings where the cladding remediation cannot even start because of structural issues because of non-cladding defects. It is not actually doing anything for the people, residents, leaseholders and shared owners who are the victims of the crisis—the only innocent ones.
Successive Governments have caused this crisis, along with the construction industry and the bad practice it has enabled. We still find this game of everyone blaming everyone else and saying, “They should do the right thing.” Residents and leaseholders are trapped facing attritional battles, and RMCs and RTMs are trying to get answers, and you just go round in circles. Nothing in this Bill is really going to do much to help that, whether it is legislation or delivery. Delivery needs to be key and really focused on. This just feels like more legislation—push it out, and see how it has gone in five years. It will not help people at all.
I am sorry, because that is fascinating and I could talk to you for a long time, but unfortunately other colleagues need to come in.
Q
Giles Grover: Going back to the basics and the framing of the question, cladding was the reason for the fire spreading, but we must also look at the insulation that was part of the cladding, the stay-put policy, the defective smoke vents and the defective fire doors. That is not being fixed in one go immediately. That is the first problem with this.
We have always called for compulsory purchase orders. Bob Blackman was on the Housing Committee in 2020 that called for compulsory purchase orders, if the pace was not quick enough. The Government response was, “Okay, we might consider those.” It is long overdue, and a lot of this is now putting it on a statutory footing, but how long will it take to take effect? If you look at the Bill’s impact assessment, it is about 180 buildings and 12,000 residents, so it is not real material change, the change we were promised by Labour. It is probably good, but it should have been there a while ago. We need a heck of a lot more.
Sarah Gibson
Q
Giles Grover: A lot of this is about control. On that point about building owners, yes, there is obviously going to be a conflict of interest. We have seen that. If you step back, we have had a shifting position from the consolidated advice note. It essentially says, “Remove and replace everything”, which again was probably going to be impossible. We need to get towards a proportionate approach, as they call it. Some people want proportionality, because they want to be able to move on with their lives. Other people are very worried about their permanently high insurance and so on carrying on.
A lot of this is about the operationalisation of the PAS and the tolerability. It is that control. It is about making sure that, if you have a risk assessment that comes to certain conclusions, even the Government’s own advice about understanding quality on the FRU says, “You need to make sure that conclusions are based on evidence”. There are so many assumptions: “Is that continuous? It’s probably not continuous behind the scenes. Let’s not worry about it.”
The Building Safety Act put leaseholders at the back of the queue, but a lot of what it did, unfortunately, opened the way for freeholders, developers and everyone to start gaming the system, blaming each other and saying, “Okay, it is a relevant defect; it is not a life-critical fire safety defect. It might be wear and tear actually”, which means we have to pay for it. There is too much buck-passing and shifting around, so yes, that is an issue, but again, it goes back to the fact that the way that the use of the PAS and the FRUs have been operationalised without the assurance, particularly the developers and contractors. That is a major concern of ours. I could go on, but I probably do not have time.
Sophie Bichener: Building owners over the past 10 years and before have shown that they are not willing to do the right thing and make sure that they appoint the right people to get to a decision on these homes. They have had plenty of time and opportunity to do that, and in many cases they have not. Many buildings are owned by pension funds, for example, which bought them as a sustainable investment, and they have a duty to their pensioners to keep costs low. I think they probably want to make the buildings good and sell them on at a profit if they can, so there is a real financial interest to narrow the scope of the works and get it done as quickly as possible.
Sarah Gibson
Q
Giles Grover: We have been saying this since before it was even introduced: it is all about what “tolerable” means. Again, I understand that we need something about proportionality, but so many different fire engineers will have so many different opinions and views. If something is deemed tolerable, whether it is a building that requires works or does not require works, there must be assurance and proper audits to ensure that the conclusion is based on tests and evidence.
If I am being honest, we have been through 20 or 30 years of just a lot of rubbish being built. Now everyone is saying, “Residents, leaseholders and shared owners are at the heart of this”, but they are still doing all they can to avoid liability, including financial liability. We are the ones trying to battle for answers, and we are sadly just going around and around in circles.
Sarah Coombes (West Bromwich) (Lab)
Q
One of the things that residents often call for is greater certainty about what is happening to their buildings and when, particularly what remediation work will be done and over what timeframe. What value is there in requiring those responsible to set out the steps they will take and, critically, the timetable for remediation? What are your thoughts on that element?
Giles Grover: Every single leaseholder and resident needs to understand what is going on in their building and how long it is going to take, but they also need an independent route to raise concerns. The system has been designed in such a way that, even with the developer contract and the cladding safety scheme—which is doing sterling work, but in a very constrained system—a lot of it still relies upon us having to go to the managing agent or a freeholder for answers.
I have one person in a building who went to the RMC, which said, “Go to the developer”; but the developer said, “Go to the building safety regulator”, and the building safety regulator said, “Go to MHCLG.” They had to fill out a correspondence web forms, but they got a stock answer that said, “Go back to your freeholder.” Yes, people need to be put at the centre of it.
There is the ability to include dates and timescales, but they actually need to be monitored, overseen and enforced, with consequences and penalties at the end of it. That way, it is not just a case of saying, “Oh, it’s the BSR and the regulatory capacities; okay, fair enough. Oh, they’ve had to do more FRUs.” The problem is that the system still allows too much to rely on those self-interested actors making those decisions. They will all tell us that safety is at the heart—but we are actually watching their actions, not their words, and they still are just not good enough.
Sophie Bichener: It is really hard to force people to communicate correctly with leaseholders. A lot of the time, freeholders are saying, “We are communicating”, but for the leaseholders, the communication says, “We’re trying really hard to fix this at pace.” Our members never have a clear picture of whether that means next week or in five years’ time. I have actually never really seen any comms about my building that give me any timeline or confidence that anything is happening.
I think it would be really hard to mandate communication that involves leaseholders, but it absolutely has to happen in order to give leaseholders any confidence that their homes will be safe and that, if they want to try to move on, move out or sell, they can get information on when the timelines for making their building safe will fall into place, and they can then feel a bit more confident not only about where they live being safe, but about, “How and when can I move on with my life?”.
Giles Grover: I should try to be positive again, because I am possibly being a bit too negative. Homes England has built stipulated communication points into its cladding safety scheme, so there are certain points of the process where you have to upload it before you get more funding. That is completely sensible; it actually looks at the quality of it and makes sure that it goes to the right people. Again, the developer contract is the one where it is about ticking a box that just says, “I am communicating 100%, so everything’s fine—see you later.” We need more consistency across the piece.
There are ways to do this, and that is what we have been trying to say for the last two and half years. We can actually simplify things, put people at the centre and save money. Sadly, we have not quite got to that point yet.
Peter Fortune
Q
Giles Grover: Not really, no. Honestly, we have tried so hard to help to show officials the way forward and what they can do to actually improve the situation. I am a residents’ management company director; because of the way that the developer contract has been handled at my building, I have tried to resign, but we cannot resign, because it will then go to the head leaseholder.
At RMCs all over the country, we have volunteers who really want to look after their homes. They are clever, intelligent people and they do the same things that freeholders do, which is to appoint agents, but they are still battling well-resourced developers and well-resourced freeholders and are trying to follow really labyrinthine policies.
There was one building in Sunderland that needed waking watch cost payments and had to put that in place in a few days. MHCLG said to them, “Fill out a building liability order, send that to your freeholder and give them 30 days to respond.” But they needed 20 grand or 30 grand that week—what is going to happen there?
A lot of it is the mentality. We have seen what has happened over the last 20 or 30 years under successive Governments, across industry. We have to put people at the centre of it and forward fund where it is needed, whether for interim measures or non-cladding defects, and then have the Government use their power to recover those funds. That would be the only sensible way forward. Until we get that in place, this crisis is not going to end.
Sophie Bichener: I would add that the Second Reading announcement on the non-qualifying improvement from three to six properties was definitely something that we had been speaking about quite a lot; we felt that had been heard, but it is not protecting all leaseholders, which is what we have said, relentlessly—no leaseholders should be paying for this. Why should one leaseholder be innocent and another have to pay for a building? Although it is welcome, I do not think it went far enough.
I feel that leaseholders are just getting more and more desperate. Giles and I have campaigned on this for 10 years. People are looking for answers and for a way out and, unfortunately, we were not able to go back from the Bill meetings we have had to say, “Yes, this is a little glimmer of hope for everybody.”
There are a few bits in the Bill that will go some way to helping some people; but, as we said at the start, it is not all people. Ten years on from Grenfell, I do not think we should still be wondering, “Will everybody be involved in the help that is coming?”. It should be that everybody has a chance to live in a safe home—if not now, they should know when that will be made safe. At present, there will still be too many people who do not have answers.
Giles Grover: The Government need to understand the number of people who hate their home right now—they are first-time buyers, and they just hate where they live. What is this system that we are living in?
Darren Paffey (Southampton Itchen) (Lab)
Q
Giles Grover: It will probably help but, again, it should have been in the Building Safety Act in the first place. Everything should have been effective from 14 February 2022. We were told at that point that freeholders would not be able to sell and pass on their liabilities, but they could; we saw that happen at a number of buildings. It might help to clarify a little bit, but it should have been there a long time ago—and what does that clarity mean? It will just mean that they carry on with this remediation that will leave us in the homes that we are trapped in, which are not fully safe and sellable, or they will force us to pay huge costs as well. Yes, we need to get to that point, but ultimately it is the gaps and issues that we need to address, so that when we get to that point we are not suffering the costs and effects.
Noah Law (St Austell and Newquay) (Lab)
Q
Sophie Bichener: Do you mean—
Noah Law
What is the economic case for not just narrowing the measures to external wall cladding?
Giles Grover: We have been trying to get that economic case made for quite a long time. We hope that MHCLG officials will make it to the all-powerful Treasury. It is about fixing the first rung of the housing ladder, which would be helpful for making sure that the housing market functions. It is giving people certainty to make sure that they can move on with their lives. It is the opportunity cost as well and the impact on growth. People cannot sell. We are trying to build 1.5 million homes, but what about the number of homes that cannot actually be sold right now, but can still be rented out? You have shared owners, and housing associations, which are meant to be charitable organisations, are refusing buyback from vulnerable shared owners whose homes are not fit for purpose. Quite simply, something that is a financial and moral imperative is not being done.
There are a number of organisations; in Greater Manchester, we have been doing this for so long that we get it, we know what we are doing and we can see all the gaps—I did not see what Kate Green said, but hopefully she raised all those. Andy and Charlie coming into the BSR was a breath of fresh air after three years of awful back and forth between MHCLG and the BSR. On Homes England, ultimately, we need the leadership we have seen there to be in place over all of this. We need proper leadership, and unfortunately that has to be non-civil servants.
Noah Law
Q
Giles Grover: There is so much self-interest throughout the system. That is how it has been built. As Grenfell United said, it
“isn’t broken, it was built this way.”
It allows too many parties to have control when they should have that control taken away from them, at least to a point where we have a consistent approach to a national standard. A lot of this is doable and we should be there by now.
The Chair
If there are no further questions, on behalf of the Committee, I thank the witnesses for their evidence.
Examination of witnesses
Sam Dumitriu and Ben Hopkinson gave evidence.
The Chair
Q
Sam Dumitriu: I am Sam Dumitriu, the head of policy at Britain Remade.
Ben Hopkinson: I am Ben Hopkinson, the head of housing and infrastructure at the Centre for Policy Studies.
Q
Ben Hopkinson: There are a couple of things. There is inherently a capacity issue with the number of skilled fire inspectors. There is also a reasonable lens of professional debate within fire risk assessments. If you have a building owner and a developer, there might be reasonable professional debates over what the tolerable risks are, and that takes time. We also have to remember the sheer scope and scale of the cladding issue. I think there are 4,000 or 5,000 affected buildings across the country, and that obviously takes time. We have seen good progress being made. I suspect that, with the Bill, we will come quite close to ending it as a problem in the next few years.
Sam Dumitriu: One important thing to remember is that a lot of these important building safety projects will often themselves face bottlenecks in terms of getting approval and sign-off from the Building Safety Regulator. One of the issues that we have come across as an organisation is that many things are going through the Building Safety Regulator that probably should not be, which is leading to safety-critical issues being held up in a queue as a result.
I will give one example. We spoke to a gentleman living in Maida Vale who had a window that needed replacing. However, he was told—I think he had pretty good legal advice on this—that, in order to replace that window, he would have to get sign-off from the Building Safety Regulator. In theory, there are meant to be competent person schemes that people can go to, but, in practice, he went to three separate competent person schemes and none were willing to sign off on the works. He suspects that a lot of people are doing that kind of work behind the scenes and not going through the normal routes, but if you try to follow the rules, they seem to imply that that would be something you would need to submit. He can correct me if I am wrong, but Ben wrote about a separate case involving—I think it was a bathroom renovation, was it?
Ben Hopkinson: Yes, it was just a flat refurbishment, and that took at least nine months and several thousand pounds to go through the Building Safety Regulator. That raises questions: should restoring a flat’s kitchen, combined with installing new safety doors within the flat, really be an issue that takes nine months to get sign-off? In the first instance, should it even be something for the BSR to look at when there are a lot of other pressing commitments on its time?
To take that example, why did it end up on the desk of the Building Safety Regulator? Was it because it insisted on that, or because people thought, “Oh crikey, I don’t want to sign this off; I’ll give it to the regulator”?
Sam Dumitriu: There are two potentially different issues between the two cases we have mentioned. In the case that I mentioned, the legislation was designed, in theory, so that competent person schemes could take these issues on, and would be happy to do that. Obviously, if you are a window fitter or whatever, you have an incentive to be quick on these things if you want more windows replaced. I think the issue was that a number of them do not believe the balance of legal risk to be right, so are concerned about liability or insurance.
Getting to the bottom of this issue has been a challenge, but we do know that the competent person schemes are not actually doing the job that they were intended to do. Work is therefore being passed to the Building Safety Regulator, which is in turn creating a backlog where projects that we really care about and are important to get done for safety reasons are being held up, stuck behind them in the queue.
Q
Sam Dumitriu: When I have spoken to developers recently, they have suggested that, although the wait times for the Building Safety Regulator have dropped, part of that is because a bit of backlog is being cleared while not much is coming in. We know there has been a big slowdown in taller buildings, particularly in London, in part because other building safety regulations, such as the second staircase rule, have created new challenges around viability.
The question is: the Building Safety Regulator might be doing better now, but would it still be if it was getting the kind of throughput we would hope for, if the Government are to hit their 1.5 million homes target, for instance?
Q
A question posed by one of my colleagues, who is not here this afternoon, is: in the event that they do not agree over who should be the lead regulator on something, who should hold the ring? Who should be the organisation that actually makes things happen? Who has the coercive power, if I can put it that way? Do you have a view as to who that should be, and do you think the Bill establishes that?
Ben Hopkinson: I am well aware that the Bill contains a duty to co-operate between the three different regulators you described; it is less clear to me whether it has the means to resolve differences between them. A duty to co-operate is one thing, but actually doing so and moving forward is another. I think we have seen that happen where different regulators overlap.
I know the Fingleton review on nuclear was very clear that there are concerns about whose obligation it is to decide, and that there is a culture of excessive caution in which you never want to be the one who actually makes the decision. On who the final regulator ought to be, I do not have a particularly strong view, whether it is local authorities or the BSR. I just think it should be specified whose decision it actually is. You would then build up some level of responsibility there, rather than having a slight fudge of, “Well, why don’t we all co-operate?”
Sam Dumitriu: I agree. In theory, the Building Safety Regulator should have access to the best expertise on this; however, it also has capacity challenges. One thing that I think has been underappreciated in the move from local authorities doing building control to the Building Safety Regulator is that local authorities, with housing targets and legal obligations, have an incentive to process things faster.
It is not just that it is their job; we know that many public bodies, even when they are given statutory targets to meet a certain deadline, do not necessarily decide things in that time. Local authorities at least have some sort of pressure from the top to say, for instance, “Actually, can you decide this a bit quicker? We don’t want to be in a position where we’ve missed our housing target by this much and therefore lose our ability to have a say over this type of development.”
Q
Ben Hopkinson: Clear responsibility, and then having the incentives actually to make the decision, would be quite good. We have to remember that the new buildings we are processing applications for are inherently significantly safer than the ones they are replacing. When it comes to fire risk, the two largest risks are the age of a building and overcrowding, both of which new buildings help alleviate.
Even in the past several years, buildings have become significantly safer, with sprinkler systems, fire evacuation lifts and no flammable materials in cladding. We really ought to figure out all we can do to make it easier for new buildings to be built. If that means assigning a regulator a specific task and trying to avoid the paralysis you get when multiple regulators have some share of the say, that would be an improvement.
Q
Ben Hopkinson: Yes. There is definitely limited capacity within regulators, so we have to figure out where that capacity gets us the biggest safety improvement. Given that existing buildings are less safe than new buildings, they should be the priority for the BSR or a similar regulator.
Sam Dumitriu: I agree with that; I am happy to accept completely what Ben says.
Sarah Gibson
Q
Sam Dumitriu: There is a trade-off between prescriptive and more flexible regulation. Sometimes you might like to have very clear rules, even if they err very far on the side of caution. I think that in the case of building safety, what we have had is a few pieces of Government guidance in the past that have probably been too tick box and restrictive, and that has caused problems. I think that the approach of PAS 9980 is the right one in focusing on proportionality. I also support the position in clause 44 on tolerable risk.
As mentioned, it is very important that we prioritise the types of remediation that happen, because there are very large constraints in terms of who can deliver and assess these projects. As a result, you need some way of making sure something is proportionate and remediation is not necessary in every case. It can be very costly and that work can also potentially push other projects back in the queue.
The area of policy that I have spent the most time focusing on in recent memory is the regulation of nuclear power, and Ben has also raised the Fingleton review. We have some very similar issues here because it is a question of “health and safety principles”, “reasonably practicable” and terms like that. You tend to see regulation that errs on the side of caution—which in safety is understandable—but there can be a tendency to do work that is not 100% necessary.
In the case of building safety, one consideration around external cladding is that you often might have a building owner who has financial interests in the cladding being remediated that are not solely safety related. There might be a different cladding material that requires less maintenance, is more resistant to weather or might make the building nicer. If there is a potential safety case, what you do not want is a situation where that cladding is changed even though we are pretty confident that, in the event of a fire, everyone can be safely evacuated—the building might experience some damage, but ultimately the people inside the building get out okay, which is what we really care about. My instinct is that we do not want to move to a system that requires more work being done over what is proportionate. It is really important when we look at all of these things.
I think that in the Building Safety Act, in many cases, we have erred on the side of regulation beyond what is proportionate, particularly around second staircase rules for buildings above 18 metres. I think that it could very easily be raised to 30 metres without providing any real risk to the public. We need to be very cautious about insisting on things beyond what is proportionate.
Ben Hopkinson: “Tolerable” seems to be the right standard in the Bill. There is a completely understandable drive for caution and safety within these complex issues. However, we have to be careful about proportionality. Already the Bill’s impact assessment shows that the costs of it are 10 times higher than the benefits. If you removed tolerability and mandated complete safety, how expensive would that be? Would we accidentally shut down new construction because we are burdening house builders with incredible asks on development capital?
There are a lot of competing issues here and tolerable seems to strike the right balance. Certainly, you want to make sure that the kind of buildings that are most unsafe are the ones that are remediated first, and removing a tolerable guideline risks buildings with only minor imperfections being treated exactly the same as the ones with the most dangerous cladding. I think that the Bill, as drafted, seems sensible and obviously we will look at the regulations as to how “tolerable” is actually defined.
Sean Woodcock
Q
Ben Hopkinson: The fact is that there has been good progress—although it is not perfect and it is not done yet. I think that the Bill is useful in contributing to the remaining cases that are outstanding. Certainly, having 40% or 45% of homes completely remediated already is, I think, good progress being made. I did not say that it was done.
Sean Woodcock
Q
Ben Hopkinson: These kinds of tasks necessarily take time. It would be brilliant if you could snap your fingers and remediate all of the buildings really quickly. Unfortunately, there are inherent bottlenecks in capacity and skills—on which good progress has been made on resolving. However, it is not resolved completely yet. I suspect that with this Bill and more time, more buildings will be remediated.
Q
On centres, we heard this morning that Manchester, for example, has 129 buildings that have not been touched yet. That demonstrates that this is not just a London issue but a nationwide one. Equally, in London the building of high-rise properties has virtually come to a halt. In your opinion, is that because of the constraints that we are putting on them, to which this Bill will add, or is it because of the lack of skills? Alternatively, is it other costs or something else that we are not aware of? Will this Bill that we are considering end up causing further delays? I know that is a complicated question, but this is where we are coming from.
Sam Dumitriu: Ben, you published a paper on this yesterday.
Ben Hopkinson: Yes, I had a paper out two days ago about this.
It is important to remember that the macroeconomic conditions right now are not that favourable to housing. We have high build-cost inflation and high interest rates. That is a complete reversal of the situation 10 years ago. Yet, while we have a worsening macroeconomic environment, we are also seeing an increased burden on construction. Just in the past four or five years we have seen biodiversity net gain requirements, the residential property developer tax, the building safety levy, the second staircase requirement and the future home standard. All of those are burdens and all have a cost. Individually, they might be justified, but taken together we have seen a complete slowdown in new construction, especially in London, where over the past two years starts have been running at about 10% of the housing target.
These are the worst conditions for housebuilding in London since the second world war. We have to be honest about what new builds can be expected to pay for. It is not like there are infinite amounts that can be taken for Government priorities. In London specifically, my modelling found that 57% of the clearing price of a new build flat is downstream of Government policy. If we are building only 10% of the target, have a desperate housing shortage and new homes are inherently safer than older homes, we have to be realistic about the burdens that we are placing and work on easing them. I think that the Bill will not have that much of an impact on new builds—it is more about existing properties—so I am not really concerned about that.
Q
Sam Dumitriu: There are two real channels through which this could further increase costs. One would be about access to capital. If you are a developer and it turns out that you have to do some remediation works, that comes from your balance sheet, which means you do not have that money to invest in future projects. The extent to which that is a constraint is up in the air: if you are a developer that mainly focuses on London, you probably have capital to spare, and you are returning money to your shareholders anyway because of all the other problems that Ben has just described. The other concern would be about further cost inflation: increasing demand for those skilled workers will have knock-on impacts. However, I do not think they will be particularly large.
There is a broader point about the way we treat development as a cash cow. One of the problems is that politicians of all parties tend to shy away from raising taxes through the most visible means. There is the famous quote, I think from a French economist, that the art of taxation is plucking the goose with the least hissing. We tend to look for places where taxation can be done off the books—where we can fund spending in ways that are not particularly visible. We saw at the Budget—I welcome this—greater scrutiny by the Treasury of what goes into our energy bills, because we have kind of treated energy bills as a source of taxation.
The Chair
May I steer you back to what the Bill is about and to the questions, rather than a much more general view?
Sam Dumitriu: I am just saying that if we want to place cost burdens on developers, we need to be transparent about when there is a strong justification for doing so. At the moment, I think the justifications in this Bill make a lot more sense than those for many of the other burdens we place on developers.
James Asser
Q
One problem that we face on the back of the cladding scandal is that so many of the buildings we are dealing with are very new. As I was telling the Committee earlier, I have five tower blocks evacuated, with hundreds of people homeless. All those blocks are under 10 years old. Naturally, all the neighbouring developments are now questioning whether they are safe, because of their similar age, even though they are different buildings by different developers.
People have to trust that new buildings are safely built, but they are looking over their shoulder when new development comes along—you see a lot of that now. Although I understand your point, to sell and develop, you need trust for those new buildings; people need to be able to say, “I’m going to move into them.” Where do we factor that in? A big part of the cladding scandal is that it has stretched into so many new builds. Logically, you should be right, but there is that problem.
Ben Hopkinson: I am well aware of the somewhat justified concerns about quality in new builds, especially given that new builds are expected to fund all these different priorities, and corners are sometimes cut on certain issues. However, just think about what new builds now have that older buildings do not: no flammable materials on façades; they all go through the Building Safety Regulator; and they all have sprinklers, wet risers for water all the way up, firefighting lifts, smoke ventilation, three fire doors between a flat and an exit, and two means of escape. There have also been certain changes to the way that fire brigades handle large incidents. Taken together, I think you can feel pretty confident that new builds are safer than existing buildings.
Sarah Coombes
Q
Part of the Bill is about holding product manufacturers liable. A lot of Government money has gone to fixing this, and developers have also put in money, but we feel that product manufacturers so far have not played their part in the equation to fix this safety crisis. Do you have any comments on that part of the Bill in terms of getting all this stuff sorted and fixing some issues you have raised?
Sam Dumitriu: One concern when you are trying to work out who is really liable for a problem is that there are often a lot of cooks. Cladding materials that could be used safely in certain contexts have often been used in the wrong context, and in that case you would not want the liability to fall on the manufacturer.
One of the reasons why this has been a slow process is that some of the things we are dealing with are very complicated. Sometimes, you are dealing with people who have left the country and found ways of avoiding things, which is not acceptable, but you are also dealing with cases where there is genuine professional disagreement. In those cases, you do not want people responding to that by coming up with a done decision that is not necessarily correct.
Ben Hopkinson: I echo that. Clearly, manufacturers have not been contributing to the remediation, and there are definitely instances where they should have. I have one broad concern. If a cladding manufacturer has been mis-selling or was not following the rules and regulations in place at the time, they should absolutely pay, and it is good that the Bill is holding them to account. But if the manufacturer followed all the Government guidelines at the time, it is a little bit more complicated, because you do not want to do too much retrospective liability increasing. That will make people unsure: “If I follow all the Government guidelines and regulations right now, but something that neither the Government nor any of the manufacturers or developers foresees then happens, am I on the hook for that?”
There has to be some limit to these retrospective claims, because they destroy investor confidence and any attempts to build new buildings. If you can be held liable even if you followed all the rules in place at a time, why would you want to manufacture building products or build the homes we desperately need? If a cladding manufacturer mis-sold a product or was clearly engaged in corporate malfeasance, they should be punished, and money should be recouped from them. But if they were acting honestly and following the rules at the time, that is a much more difficult circumstance.
When we are changing the standards, this becomes a Government burden and should in turn be funded from general taxation, if we think as a society, “These are changes we should make to buildings.” We do not want retrospective attempts to take back money from people who were following the rules, because that just leads to people not wanting to invest in the first place.
Noah Law (St Austell and Newquay) (Lab)
Q
The Chair
You have less than a minute.
Ben Hopkinson: If they are running the risk of still having excessive liabilities even if they follow all the rules in place at a time, they might not choose to sell to or invest in the UK at all. We do have to be careful there. If they are engaged in malpractice or mis-selling, we should absolutely go after them.
The Chair
If there are no further questions from Members, I thank the witnesses for their evidence. We now move on to the next panel.
Examination of Witness
Alexander Cook gave evidence.
The Chair
Q
Alexander Cook: I am Alexander Cook, the managing director for special projects at Vistry. I oversee the group’s building safety remediation programme.
Q
Alexander Cook: First, on behalf of Vistry, we have been at the forefront since the tragic events of Grenfell in 2017 to make sure we are proactively managing and liaising with building owners. We signed the pledge in 2022 and the developer remediation contract in 2023. To date, 51% of our developer buildings started are completed. It is worth noting that, if 27 buildings had not had delays from blockers this year, we would have been at 70%. I can give some real world examples from our experience of where that has happened.
Q
Alexander Cook: The targets were always a stretch. There are a number of developers that have achieved it, as per the remediation acceleration group data that is issued in the quarterly reports. There are challenges across all of these projects. These are multi-stakeholder projects, so you have fire engineers, responsible entities, RTMs, managing agents, lawyers and project managers. When you try to go back and forth with each of these parties, throw in a scope dispute or an RTM dissolves, and you have to go to a freeholder.
Good progress has been made across the industry, and we are at 51% across the board. The majority of those are sitting in the top right quadrant. To date, good progress has been made, and Vistry has been working proactively with all its buildings to move this forward, but there is still a way to go. We are confident that next year we will be able to get a lot of these things moved forward with some of the support we have had from the MHCLG.
Q
Alexander Cook: Vistry has a dedicated special projects team with funding allocated to remediation, so it is a priority for us that does not take away from the day job. We have, however, had challenges on the new-homes side with Building Safety Regulator applications, which have delayed delivering those homes for up to nine months. We obviously acknowledge that residents need safe buildings, and that is the priority, but some of those statutory approvals are where the blockers have been.
Q
Alexander Cook: We have seen improvements. Of our applications? Not yet. We have had seven remediations applications submitted, all of which had time extensions and three of which are now approved, so we can see the backlog starting to come down. We have not had a fast application or a statutory timeframe application as yet, but we know industry colleagues that have, so we can see the improvements that have been made. Hopefully, going into next year, their recruitment will improve and their capacity and consistency of decisions will help all of us move forward.
Q
Alexander Cook: We support the co-operation of all authorities and the fact that they have to issue their statement. From my reading of the Bill and the proposals, Homes England is going to be the auditing authority of the fire risk appraisal of external walls, which is dictating the scope. The way it works in the developer remediation contract is that MHCLG will be the auditor of the FRAEW. If there is a dispute between the parties, it is the deciding function. It would seem logical that Homes England performs that function if that is the proposal in the Bill.
Q
Alexander Cook: We welcome the changes on manufacturer redress and section 149. That will help make sure that all responsible parties are held to account and share the costs. It will not make any difference in terms of us accelerating our works and delivering what we need to. It just means that the funding at some point will be recovered and will help the future growth of homes, which Vistry is uniquely placed to do as part of the Government’s affordable housing programme.
Q
Alexander Cook: The clarity of the section 149 changes, especially for reliance and the evidence required to hold manufacturers to account.
Sarah Gibson
Q
Alexander Cook: We support the standardisation of the FRAEW methodology and the recent changes to that for the “tolerable” risk changing as well. We will always see subjectivity in fire engineers’ opinions. The auditing by Homes England will hopefully control some of that. There is always more that could be done in terms of charters and control of fire engineers. I think the more the industry has, that will help.
There are a lot of examples where we have had conflicting fire engineers’ opinions in both directions, increasing and decreasing scope, but they are independent of Vistry, so they are not controlled by us. They are appointed, but they follow their own charter’s ethics and morals and set the scope outside of any other interests.
Sarah Gibson
Q
Alexander Cook: Yes. I believe there are chartered fire engineers out there, and that makes sense for them.
Sarah Gibson
Q
Alexander Cook: I think fire engineers should be, as they are now. Improvements could always be made in terms of the fire assessors, and that could be done through the Bill, with guidance on clarifying those roles, especially for FRAEWs.
Darren Paffey
Q
Alexander Cook: There is definitely no “unwilling”. Everyone wants to remediate and they want to get to the same goal. People want to co-operate, but it is not necessarily about co-operating; it is about their response times. When so many parties are involved, maybe changes to the Bill could introduce a stricter turnaround time from responsible entities, and that might introduce acceleration. For us, one of the particular delays and blockers is where you have fire engineers, lawyers and responsible managing agents taking a little bit longer to get through all of those before they actually get a response. When you multiply that by the hundreds of buildings, it soon adds up. The changes to the Bill will help, but I think there is still a way to go.
Darren Paffey
Q
Alexander Cook: It could be. A lot of the things that we come up against with lawyers are in terms of how the remedial works contract is drafted. If you think of construction contracts, it would not be unreasonable for there to be definitions of delay. Rather than just having “a reasonable excuse”, which is a bit broad, you could have specifics, and then there could be timeframes related to some of those, which would help to accelerate buildings where the responsible entities are not performing.
Peter Fortune
Q
Alexander Cook: I cannot comment widely on the market—that is not my speciality area—but I can say that we have seen that safety is a factor in residents’ requirements, which is completely justified. We have also had experiences in London, as I said earlier, where delays to projects have then affected the supplier demand, in terms of where people are available—what flats, what height, and so on—across the UK. Ultimately, the market has slowed in London, particularly due to the regulator’s decisions that have not allowed us to get on site. With our dedicated team on the remediation side, it has not affected the delivery, as such; if we were able to proceed, we would have.
The Chair
If there are no further questions from Members, I thank you very much on behalf of the Committee for your evidence. We will take a short break before the next panel.
The Chair
We now hear oral evidence from Ian Abley and Steve Day. We have until 4.20 pm for this panel. Could I ask you to introduce yourselves briefly for the record?
Steve Day: Thanks very much for your time today. I am Steve Day. I am a building safety campaigner, and have a national campaign called buildingsafetyscheme.org. There are notes applicable to my evidence on the website.
Ian Abley: Good afternoon, Chair. I am Ian Abley. I used to be a site architect, and then, after Grenfell, I started working for the Fire Protection Association. I have spent most of my life trying to work out what “properly build” is in the first place.
Q
Steve Day: I will take that from a leaseholder’s perspective. I am a leaseholder in a block of flats in south-east London, in Woolwich. We have highly combustible Euroclass E on our fire shafts, which is the second most combustible material being retained under PAS 9980; it is banned on new buildings. The Association of British Insurers has confirmed that there will be permanently high insurance if these combustibles are left on.
We have two fire reports. One was commissioned by the building owner and the builder, and it basically said, “Leave the panels in place,” without any fire performance test evidence to show the risk of leaving it on. Then the residents raised £4,300 to do a review of that fire risk assessment and it said, “These panels are dangerous. These must come off.” Both are valid under PAS. The building owner has clearly stated in writing that they will choose the cheaper of the two reports—the one that leaves the dangerous panels on the sole means of escape, using PAS as justification.
PAS has two flaws. First, it ignores building regulations at the time of construction. Building regulations are the baseline for the fire safety order. The fire brigade operates on the assumption that the building regulations at the time of construction are complied with. If you have a remediation standard that does not really look into these building regulation breaches, you can see why the insurers are giving us permanently high insurance—in addition, of course, our insurance doubled with RAAC. We have £6,000 a year service charges, and because of these retained panels on our sole means of escape under PAS, we have no chance of getting the charges back down, so no, the Bill is not helping us.
I do welcome the parts of the Bill that are useful. This is a very difficult subject for me, because I lost one of my best friends, Amanda Walker, who worked on my building safety scheme campaign with the Earl of Lytton and actually presented to Parliament. She was so taken down by the building safety crisis that she took her own life. To be clear, the coroner said it was misadventure, so I am not saying that I know more than the coroner, but I know how badly the building safety crisis affected her and ruined her life. I want to pay tribute to her and to the Government for recognising that part of her campaign as an enfranchised leaseholder was to be protected from cladding costs. They have announced that that is happening, so that is good. The new legal duty to remediate is good, as is the remediation backstop.
The key problem is that the Building Safety Act is identifying building safety risks, but the remediation standard to deal with the problem is watering it down to a tolerable standard that does not recognise as an issue building regulation breaches at the time of construction, which are unlawful breaches. Secondly, it does not require any fire performance test evidence to know the risk of leaving banned material—combustibles are banned on buildings above 11 metres. The insurance is high, as the ABI has confirmed in its evidence to other Committees. Leaseholders are in a terrible position. I will let Ian come in now, but thank you very much for the question.
Ian Abley: I want to stress that leaseholders entered a market where there was a constant, which they expected to have. They may never have read the building regulations, but the constant was always there and sensible. That was requirement B4(1), which said that a building should “adequately” resist the spread of fire up its external walls, which you would expect. My mum would expect that; my sons would expect that. That has been a constant since the Building Act 1984 split the approved document from the requirements.
A difficulty is being replicated in clause 44 of this Bill, however. “Adequate” was never defined except in the approved document, and now “tolerable” is being substituted for the word adequate, which is worse. The failure after Grenfell was not to interrogate what was “adequate”. Since then, we have found out—through great effort, a long period of time and a huge inquiry—that class zero was the problem, because the approved document contained approval for combustible cladding. It did not contain approval for combustible insulation, so it does not explain the defects over 30 years of construction found by people such as Andy Roe, as he described this morning.
The substitution of “tolerable” for “adequate” just leaves that issue free-floating. While the Building Safety Regulator is being given sharper teeth and may be able to bite better, it is being muzzled by the introduction of the concept of tolerability in place of the concept of adequacy.
I would argue that the only Secretary of State post-Grenfell to grapple with the adequacy problem was James Brokenshire. He did a very good job—actually, an extraordinarily clear-headed job—before he sadly died of cancer, which was to introduce modifications to regulation 7, which is about materials and workmanship. He took the problem out of the approved document and stuck it in regulation 7, so that builders could not ignore it.
The difficulty with the approved document arises from section 7 of the Building Act 1984, which means that the approved document is non-mandatory but nevertheless statutory guidance. So you can ignore it, provided you satisfy the requirements.
Let me illustrate the two things that the Bill needs to grapple with and should sort out. There are all of the defects that builders have created by ignoring the approved document and therefore not complying with the requirement, such as putting combustible insulation in high-rise buildings. Since 2006, that has been clearly prevented under paragraph 12.7 of fire safety regulations, and prior to that builders should not have been using combustible insulation on high-rise buildings. That is made difficult because the approved document had a fundamental flaw, which originated in class zero; the wording did not change from 1976 right up to the Grenfell Tower fire.
That test in 1987 was being given a water-cooled frame to test thermoplastics, in other words the kind of cladding that was on Grenfell Tower—aluminium composite material. The problem materialised at the Garnock Court fire in Irvine in 1999. At that time, Nick Raynsford did not remove class zero from the approved document or modify it, and nor did anybody else after that, despite the Government’s own unpublished research on the subject. Not only was class zero known to be wrong at the time, but the policy was sustained all the way through the code for sustainable homes—when insulation was being pushed, including in high-rise buildings—right the way up to the Grenfell Tower fire, when its consequences became obvious.
Class zero served as misguidance. What the Bill needs to do is to define what “adequate” is, and not sell the PAS to the people who would like to open this process up to a subjective view of tolerability.
Q
Steve Day: No. We say that rather than incremental improvement of the protections, we would like all leaseholders to be protected from all costs related to building safety defects. What we say is that if building regulation breaches occurred at the time of its construction, you did not get what you paid for. The builders should not be allowed, under PAS, to get away with that; they should remediate to the standard of the current building regulations. That is not betterment; that is punishment for breaking the law at the time of construction.
Secondly, if the regulations have changed post-Grenfell and the defects are a result of regulations changing regarding things that were lawful at the time of construction, we say that the buildings affected should be remediated to as low a standard as is reasonably practicable, with fire performance test evidence for those combustibles in buildings above 11 metres.
To answer your specific point, what is happening in the Bill is that we have protections that provide no protection at all for buildings below 11 metres. The under 11 metre fund has closed, so there is no protection. There are partial protections for those that have more than six properties, and no protection at all for non-cladding costs. Then we have the risk of multiple remediation. Under PAS, the fire risk assessor is encouraged to deem some remediation tolerable without any evidence to know the risk of leaving it on. Then it says, “But, by the way, if you can, you should bring the risk down from tolerable to low,” so the PAS is encouraging you as a fire risk assessor to undermine “tolerable”. Then, it says in the 2026 version, which is the latest one in force, “When you do a refurbishment, you should potentially do a bit more, because that tolerable standard is a little bit suspect. Do a bit more.” The PAS itself does not trust its own definition of tolerability.
On the other side of that, if it is deemed tolerable, under a highly subjective assessment, these fire risk assessments are done every year and can recommend that the PAS assessment is redone potentially every five years, like EWS1, which is expensive in itself, but we may have to fork out another 40 or 50 grand in five years’ time. Then, with all the defects deemed tolerable—remember it is ignoring building regulation breaches at time of construction and leaving defects on without any evidence to know the risk—there is a good chance that tolerable risk might become medium or high under the PAS for a subsequent remediation.
This comes on to my real worry, which, as a leaseholder, is saleability and insurability. The ABI has condemned PAS. It was excluded from the steering group, which is questionable, because it has been saying for a long time that PAS is not good enough in its current form and needs to take into account the risk post Grenfell of the genie being let out the bottle and people not trusting building regulation compliance. Let me explain why. These are the June 2024 figures of life-endangering building defect rates in four of our top house builders—it was on BBC News, and it is published on the Government website. Barratt Redrow has a 35% life-endangering defect rate as per the developer contracts, Bellway 43%, Taylor Wimpey 77% and Crest Nicholson 69%. These defects have been all over the built environment for the last 30 years.
We should not be having a tolerable assessment that says, “Oh, by the way, if it’s deemed tolerable now, it may either be upgraded to high in the future, or you need to do a little bit more later on when you do a refurbishment and we need to push it down.” All of these are extra costs. If we combine the threat of rolling, unlimited remediations, the cost of all the protections that partially protect and or include no protection whatsoever for buildings under 11 metres, and the 11 metre cladding fund closure, you can see that the simplest solution is to protect all leaseholders. In doing so, we would actually be able to ensure that there would be certainty. I think the definition of permanently complete on a remediation should be that the insurance comes down so the extra building defect premium is removed and the property is sellable.
There is also the risk of the market concerns around this. There is potential for significant financial crisis-type litigation in respect of mortgage-backed securities. I came from an investment banking background and worked in IT in Lehman Brothers and JP Morgan. We look at risk. If you have a load of buildings in which all the defects have been ignored by a watered-down remediation standard and all the defects have been left on without any fire performance test evidence, do you not think that the insurers or the lenders might have picked that up? They are watching today. What I am saying is that if we want to contain this, we really need to recognise that those alarming defect rates I have just quoted to you, which are all available in the public domain, mean that there could be litigation in relation to the UK mortgage-backed securities that are sold to anyone who wants to buy them. Credit, insurance and other derivatives related to UK mortgage-backed securities could blow up.
My buildingsafetyscheme.org team and I have analysed the prospectuses of some of the leading bonds in mortgage-backed securities, and some do not even mention the credit risk of the non-cladding liability; some mention the cladding liability, but do not mention the non-cladding liability; and some do not mention any liability at all. These are all linked to UK residential mortgages, so they are not being honest in the documentation that they sell bonds on. There is a problem here.
I am very conscious that I have taken up half the session.
Steve Day: Yes, I am sorry I went on a bit.
Q
Steve Day: Yes, I did not actually say it, but it was another element that I was happy about. The cladding manufacturers largely have escaped liability. I do not know if you followed our campaign with the Earl of Lytton in the House of Lords. We initially had a remediation scheme, which was trying to make developers pay for breaches at the time of construction with a wide construction industry levy, which did bring in construction manufacturers. That aligns with our approach, but there are some areas where you could extend the levy. The build-to-rent sector, for instance, has largely escaped it. They could contribute, given that they are building. Build to rent would be an area.
Before the Committee, we had a look at the latest status of developers and house builders. The top 10 have £24 billion in net assets, largely due to hoarding land banks and making significant returns to shareholders. We looked at just how much were share buybacks and dividends. For instance, Barratt Redrow has announced an intention to return £400 million to shareholders. With £24 billion plus £400 million, they can afford to pay a little more to cover all these leaseholders. On the buildingsafetyscheme website, you can see a breakdown of all the information that I am giving here, including the items of the mortgage-backed securities—we are going to publish those so that everyone can see the exposure due to bad building in this country.
I really encourage the Committee to look at whether freeholders may evade their responsibilities. There have been certain restructuring events that you might want to consider, which may mean that you have a good bank/bad bank scenario as we had at Lehman Brothers, where some assets may be transferred to the bad bank, and then there is no money to pay the remediation liabilities. I would recommend looking at anti-avoidance measures, potentially as an amendment to the Bill.
Sarah Gibson
Q
My worry is that we have seen poor construction and a race to the bottom over the last 30 years in the UK construction industry, and now the Government are hoping to build large amounts of new housing. How do we make sure that the housing that we are building now will not be the retrofits of 2050, and that we will not be in the same position then? What key things do we need to be doing to make sure that this does not happen again? Is it a question of building control? Is it a question of enforcement? What do we do to make sure that we do not end up here again?
Ian Abley: It is a question of regulation 7. You already have the tools to do it. They are adequate. Building regulation requirement B4(1) said that the external walls should be adequate to resist the spread of fire. That is still the case. The definition of “adequate” is the thing that is missing. But that forces you into a world of very straightforward thresholds of what is and what is not safe.
The problem with tolerability, to my mind, is not so much that it has not collapsed into a low. If the high and medium-risk buildings that already exist are declared as such to the Building Safety Regulator, they have to go through building remediation, which puts them back into the building regulation loop. The structure of PAS actually encourages anybody with a medium or high-risk building who cannot afford to remediate to shop around and find a fire engineer who will give them a “tolerable” report, and they magically get to avoid the building regulation process entirely.
Regardless of David Crowder’s intent for setting up a structure that looks vaguely like something that the Health and Safety Executive would do—with the carrot of risk going from unacceptable through tolerable and down to acceptable—what PAS does is encourage remediation avoidance. Any impecunious building owner is going to find it far cheaper just to employ a fire engineer who will give them a “tolerable”. I have seen that on an epic scale with a signatory to the developer remediation contract.
It is a beautifully connived process where everyone seems to be doing their job, but all that happens is the risk gets accepted by the building owner and then the process stops. The estates of buildings fall off the statistics, and it looks like the remediation problem is not as big as was first thought. If clause 44 mandates the tolerability wheeze into the legislation instead of defining “adequate”, you will see that right the way down to the 11-metre height.
Sarah Gibson
Q
Ian Abley: As Giles Grover said, you need a technical standard that is the legally minimum adequate of what is requirement B4(1). Why would you employ an incompetent fire engineer to give you a rubbish report? The builders who have the money will employ the most competent fire engineers who will use their skill, knowledge and experience, but their behaviour is another thing—they are just acting like mercenaries.
Steve Day: We are seeing that at Royal Artillery Quays. You have one fire engineer saying, “It is safe to leave these panels on,” without caring about justifying it with evidence, which he puts in his report, and another two fire engineers saying, “These are dangerous. The are banned on new buildings for a reason.” The building owner just chooses which report they want. We spent £4,300 of our own money on this—that is how much we cared about getting the right opinion—only to be met with a terse email saying, “Sorry, we don’t have to listen to you because of PAS.” That is the problem we have.
We have to do the two reforms on the buildingsafetyscheme.org website. Please look at those, because they are what the country needs, and they are what the banks, lenders and insurers need. You cannot put this back in the box; the insurers and lenders will not let the Government do it. You need to protect all leaseholders, you need to deal with building regulations breaches at the time of construction, and you need fire performance test evidence to know the risk of leaving things on and, otherwise, to take them off. Only leave them on if you have evidence—that is the rule. If they did that, we would have safer buildings. We are not remediating buildings to a permanent state, either, because of the rolling remediations. These are big issues that we need to resolve.
Ian Abley: Could I make a point about the insurers? Building regulations are not about property protection, and they never have been. PAS 9980 is not about property protection. The insurers have their own standard, which corrected the error of class 0, once they had worked out that it was an error and the inquiry had come to a conclusion, and it adopted James Brokenshire’s standard. The insurers cannot ignore health and life safety, which is all the building regulations have to achieve. The insurers only want Brokenshire’s law for life safety. They do not need anything else for property protection, because there is nothing else. Brokenshire’s law was reasonably practicable and low risk. PAS 9980:2026 itself recognises Brokenshire’s law as low risk. It does not actually name it; it just copies and pastes the text.
The PAS has avoided one of the other aspects of building requirement B4(1): it only deals with the combustibility of the walls and the compartmentation and cavity barriers around windows. It does not deal with the conflagration problem of radiant heat from one building to another, so it cannot claim to be building requirement B4(1). As far as I can see, PAS 9980 was written as a way to undermine James Brokenshire’s law when the calls for proportionality came in, because people were bleating that James Brokenshire’s law was too onerous. It is not. It is the reasonably practicable thing to do for life safety.
Steve Day: The problem—I will not say too much, I promise—
Sarah Gibson
I probably ought to bring it to a halt, because I am conscious of the time.
The Chair
There are no further questions from Members, so I thank you both for your evidence.
Sarah Gibson
If that is the case, Chair, I am quite happy for Steve to finish his statement. I was just conscious that if someone else was trying to come in, we were running out of time. Sorry, Steve. I did not mean to interrupt you.
Steve Day: Thank you. I really appreciate that.
Ian Abley: If not, I had a question for the Minister.
Steve Day: Do you mind if I just do mine?
The Chair
Okay. We will have to move on, because there are no further questions from Members. Thank you both very much for your evidence.
Examination of witness
Dame Judith Hackitt gave evidence.
The Chair
We will now hear oral evidence from Dame Judith Hackitt. We have until 4.40 pm for this panel. Dame Judith, could you briefly introduce yourself for the record?
Dame Judith Hackitt: Yes. I am Dame Judith Hackitt. I authored the independent review of building safety and fire regulations immediately after the Grenfell Tower fire, which led to the series of recommendations that formed the Building Safety Act. Since then, I have been chairing the industry safety steering group, working on driving culture change within the built environment sector.
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: This remediation Bill builds on a number of things that we have learned since the enactment of the Building Safety Act 2022. I am very supportive of many of the measures in it, although there are a few other things that would help enormously. I think it goes a long way towards addressing some of the shortcomings that we have learned of in the last few years, but there are some other things that we could do to make it move even faster.
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: With pleasure. The most important thing that we need to do within this remediation Bill is to give certainty to residents, in particular, who have been waiting a very long time to know whether their buildings need remediation and whether they are safe. Although some of the recommendations move us in the right direction, they do not take away the uncertainty and the room that exists for people to debate in court or through lawyers what needs to be done and by whom. Unless we address that and give residents certainty, we are missing an important opportunity in this Bill.
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: I certainly think it is open to too much interpretation. As I have shared with lots of people, we now have the ability to see what other people have done around the world, so we can see that there is perhaps a better way to do that. I have recently been reviewing the activities in Victoria in Australia, and they have completed all their remediation. Granted, it is on a different scale from ours—they had to remediate in the region of 1,000 buildings—but it is all complete. It has been completed to a standard that was set centrally, about which there is no dispute, and everyone has bought into it.
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: Yes, I do. Defining tolerable risk in statute and getting buy-in from residents and other stakeholders, including investors and insurers, is key to making progress. That would ensure not only that residents feel reassured that we are working to a consistent standard, but that we have a basis on which to rebuild confidence in the markets in our building stock.
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: Yes.
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: Yes. It would need to be a risk framework for all existing buildings that are in scope.
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: I personally do not have a view one way or the other on whether Homes England is the right place to put that. What I do have a view on is that it needs to be an agreed risk framework that everyone has bought into. It needs to be a body that has the technical competence to oversee that and, in cases where there is a dispute, to overrule that and agree the standard to which the buildings are going to be remediated.
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: I think it is impossible to characterise in one word. It is a very mixed picture still. I am going to focus on buildings in occupation, because we have moved a long way when it comes to new build. The new regulatory framework and the way in which that drives certain requirements has moved us a long way in terms of building the right culture for new build.
The big problem that we have to address, and which the Bill is clearly aimed at, is the lack of progress at the right pace when dealing with buildings that are already in occupation. There, I think the culture is very much one of diffuse and unclear responsibilities, even now. That is exacerbated by a lack of competence and a lack of knowledge among the people who are deemed responsible. The sad part is that because of all that, legal disputes take precedence over taking care of residents and reassuring them that their safety is of primary concern.
I will leave it there because I am mindful that other colleagues want to come in.
Sarah Gibson
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: The part about fire engineers’ competence and how we assess that is being addressed separately from the Bill. We already know that there is more work we need to do there, and I am involved in that.
Let us be clear, however, that we are never going to get to a point where fire engineers always agree on a single solution, because the nature of the beast is such that different solutions may be arrived at that give an acceptable level of risk. That is one of the reasons why we have focused on making all the regulation outcome-based so that it gives people the opportunity to look at different routes and so on.
In the cases where disagreements occur, it is really important to have a body that can stop that becoming a long-term delaying process and a dispute through the courts, and focuses on agreeing what is going to be done, getting it done and letting other things play out while speeding up the process whereby residents get to a position where they can both feel safe in their building and, indeed, sell their properties and move on if that is what they want to do.
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: I am not here to suggest for one minute that we should copy everything that has been done by Cladding Safety Victoria in Australia. However, when you look at the series of measures that it has put in place, there is a lot that we can learn. I have already talked about the agreed risk framework that everyone buys into. In addition, to speed up the process, it arrived at a mechanism whereby, when people cannot agree on what needs to be done, progress is not slowed.
Progress still takes place: the Government pay for it, but they take over the right from the building owners to recover costs from the parties who are held to be responsible. The Government are therefore acting in the intermediary space, not as the funder for work that others fail to do. It is a model that we could learn from, of that I am convinced.
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: Yes, I do. As I said, I am very supportive of what the Bill is trying to do, but in a number of areas we are missing an opportunity to go a little further on writing specifics into primary legislation, rather than leaving it to guidance that is open to interpretation and without certainty.
Peter Fortune
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: Yes.
Peter Fortune
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: I cannot answer the second part of that question, I am afraid. We have to get to a landing on what is an acceptable level of risk. I know that will not be easy, but I think it has to be done centrally, rather than allowing these debates and different interpretations to continue. They are holding up progress, of that there is no doubt.
Peter Fortune
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: Personally, I think the language is unfortunate. We need to be talking about life safety here. It must be an acceptable level of risk that does not put people’s lives at risk. Part of the debate is property loss versus life safety—what matters is life safety.
Peter Fortune
I do not understand what the reluctance is.
Dame Judith Hackitt: Neither do I.
Sean Woodcock
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: Is the question whether I think people are less committed to—
Sean Woodcock
My feeling at the time of the Grenfell disaster was that the view from the top down—from industry, Government, local authorities and so on—was that everything would be done, whatever the trade-offs, to ensure that this was sorted, the remediation happened and so on. As we get further away, there is a danger that the consensus and impetus have broken down slightly. Do you have any worries on that? Am I wrong to worry about that? Is it driving some of the issues?
Dame Judith Hackitt: You are absolutely right to worry about it, because we can look at many other industry sectors and see that, with the passage of time, the sense of urgency that follows a disaster tends to decay as you get further and further away from it. What we must never forget in this case is that we have no guarantee that this will not happen again.
The area where we are most at risk is with existing buildings because, as I have said, we have moved a long way. We have a new regime in place for new build, which I am confident sets new standards, and we have new rigour in place to ensure that buildings are built properly. We always knew that going back and addressing existing stock would be the challenge, but it would be unforgivable not to do that. Those are the buildings that affect existing residents the most, and they have been living with this for nearly 10 years.
Noah Law
Q
Dame Judith Hackitt: One of your colleagues spoke a moment ago about the need for trade-offs. I would not advocate prescription and fixed, inflexible definitions in relation to new build, where there is the opportunity to be creative and to innovate in the way we build, and where new things will come along that will enable us to do things in different ways. In the case of existing stock, where speed and the reassurance of residents are of paramount importance, having a very clear, non-disputable standard is really important.
The Chair
If there are no further questions from Members, I thank you for your evidence, Dame Judith. Thank you very much.
Examination of witness
Dr David Crowder gave evidence.
The Chair
Q
Dr David Crowder: Good afternoon. My name is David Crowder, and I am a partner at DCCH Experts. Probably more relevant to this session is that I am the lead technical author for PAS 9980. I will not list my various other credentials as they are in my written evidence.
Q
Dr David Crowder: I will start by saying that my written evidence was not about the Bill; I am here for questions regarding PAS, because I am conscious that there has been a lot of debate about that. My personal view on remediation is that it has taken too long. I investigated Grenfell myself—I spent a year inside the tower, from when it was still burning. I do not want to see that again.
I have worked as fast as I can, and I know many other fire engineers who are, frankly, tired after 10 years of working flat-out on this. There are not enough of us. That is a sad side effect of fire engineering not being a very popular subject pre-Grenfell, and going from being a bit of a sideshow in the industry to suddenly being the thing that everyone demands for a building project. There is now movement to try to increase the number of courses. Given that my qualifications and training took well in excess of 10 years to achieve, I am not particularly optimistic about how much faster things can go unless there is a fundamentally different approach, but I support remediation taking place as quickly as possible.
Q
Dr David Crowder: A different approach. Fire engineers are currently capacity-limited. As I say, everyone I speak to in fire engineering is doing everything they can.
Q
Dr David Crowder: No. That is the short answer. Most of my work is in disputes, legal cases and prosecutions. I am well aware that there is a significant degree of panic about meeting that deadline among the good building owners and developers, because they take it seriously. The practicalities involved make it extremely challenging for those who are willing. For those who are not, I do not hold much, if any, hope of them meeting that deadline.
Q
The Bill concentrates on cladding. To a degree, that is understandable, because we all saw the pictures of Grenfell and the fire going up the outside. One of the reasons why the stay put policy that the fire brigade deployed in the early stages of the fire failed utterly is the breaches inside the building, as opposed to just the cladding going up the outside. Do you think the Bill could have been expanded to cover fire remediation internally as well as externally?
Dr David Crowder: I do. However, I would suggest there is an equally acute problem with internal fire protection as there is with cladding. There is a difference between what was expected of buildings built 10, 20 or 50 years ago versus those built today. I am aware of the criticism, but the PAS has tried to consider buildings of all ages by taking a technology-agnostic view of risk to try to work out what is safe enough—I am sure we will come back to that. We use the term “tolerable”, and again I am sure we will come back to that.
I have been privy to a lot of this, and the difficulty with internal compartmentation is that if you ask a compartmentation specialist or passive fire protection contractor to look at a building, they will insist on current best practice installations because that is part of their professional requirements. There is not currently an equivalent mechanism by which you can look at fire stopping or a fire door that is 20 or 30 years old and reach a conclusion as to whether it still provides adequate performance or needs to be replaced for good reason, as opposed to simply being an old door.
Q
Dr David Crowder: Well, no. Having written it, I am supportive of the standard and what it is trying to achieve. Again, I refer the Committee to my written evidence. The standard is just that, a standard. It is a document. It is not the same as its users. It does not have the power to police its users. As Dame Judith mentioned, a lot of work is going on about the regulation and professionalisation of the fire engineering industry. I can only support that. I am a chartered engineer registered with the Engineering Council, and I have to comply with the ethical behavioural principles of the Engineering Council as part of my work. Those include integrity, honesty and pushing back on anyone who might try to persuade me to behave in a certain way.
Chartered engineers are not the only game in town. There are also incorporated engineers and engineering technicians. They all do different things. Chartered engineers tend to be in leadership, big-picture positions. Incorporated engineers have a greater tendency to be doers—they are more middle-management level. Engineering technicians tend to do very intricate, detailed work. They do the sort of thing that a chartered engineer is not good at. Fire alarm technicians are a good example.
The key point is that they all have to sign up to the Engineering Council’s statement of ethical principles. Having that kind of registration across the board would be extremely helpful in providing confidence in how users are actually applying the PAS. We did a lot of work in how we rewrote the document we published in September to try to address the shortcomings. For example, we have been as strict as we can. Bear in mind, it is a voluntary standard. As it stands, it does not have any power, but we require that any deviation from what is in the standard is recorded in the report so that there is transparency.
Equally, if there is a difference of opinion where a customer, or whoever, commissions multiple FRAEWs—or one simply follows another chronologically—we now require the appraiser to say why they have a difference of opinion with the previous FRAEW. It is no longer a black-box environment where customers, or indeed leaseholders, are simply receiving FRAEWs, seeing that there is a different outcome and not understanding why. We have put a lot of work into trying to improve the transparency of the process.
Equally, we are bordering on hand-holding the appraisers through the process. We have defined the decision-making process that they have to follow at every stage to work through how they deal with uncertainty, to make sure that they are making good, conservative, worst-case assumptions where they do not know things, and only improving upon that once they have evidence that allows them to do so.
Q
Dr David Crowder: “Tolerable” is a word. “Adequate”, “reasonable”, “tolerable” or “good enough” could be used.
Q
Dr David Crowder: I worry about the consequences of doing so. “Tolerable” and, equally, all the other words serve the same purpose, particularly when you think about health and safety law. The intention of the PAS was to support the fire safety order to enable risk assessment. I am sure we will come back to that in a second. “Tolerable” or “adequacy” obviously take into account the level of risk, which we can look at as an absolute level. Is risk high, medium or low?
The question of tolerability, which is similar to proportionality, or “as low as reasonably practicable” as appears in the Health and Safety at Work Act, relates to the ability to pay and what is within the duty holder’s gift to actually do in order to address risk. If Parliament decides to enshrine “tolerable” in law, that would have to be accompanied by some level of resource that puts the duty holders on the same playing field in terms of what they do to meet that bar.
That is because, for example, what a housing association with tens of thousands of properties can afford to do is very different from an individual family who have decided to make their investment pot a block of flats. I have dealt with customers who put all their life savings into building a block of flats, and it ended very tragically. Their ability to pay is not the same as a big housing association with tens of thousands of properties. That is the risk. Again, the PAS is simply trying to address a problem. It is a scientific, engineering-led process, but if we choose to set the bar at a particular level in terms of safety, we have to make sure that people can meet it.
Q
Dr David Crowder: In terms of the original commission that was given to the British Standards Institution by what was then the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, it was written purely as a method for appraising the risk of external wall construction. This is responding to the Fire Safety Act amendment of the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005. A legal duty was created in the wake of Grenfell Tower to ensure that owners of existing buildings had a means by which they could carry out a risk assessment. Under article 50 of the fire safety order, there is a duty for the Secretary of State to provide guidance to enable risk assessments to be carried out.
Once the provision for risk assessing external walls was added, there needed to be guidance to fulfil that role. The PAS is not formally identified in that sense, but my personal view is that that is what it is for. It is not a design document, and it is not there to circumvent building regulations. It supports an entirely different branch of legislation. As has been mentioned by previous witnesses, if an FRAEW recommends building work, that work becomes subject to the building regulations, but that is distinct from what the PAS is doing. The PAS simply looks at the building in its current state and enables a decision to be made on whether or not something should need to be done. It is not an evaluation tool either—I know that RICS refer to it as part of their EWS1s. It is simply doing the job of appraising risk and the life safety impact of buildings.
Q
Dr David Crowder: I do, yes. I take the view, which I know is somewhat different from that of some witnesses you heard from previously, that the ban reflects Government, and indeed the country at large, losing faith in the construction industry, and concluding that the industry cannot be trusted to work with combustible materials. In the building regulations, regulation 7 sits apart from the functional requirements under schedule 1. Those are all couched in terms of safety, whereas regulation 7 simply says, “Do not use combustible materials.” That is fine, and I do not have an issue with it, given the way that trust has fallen away, but I am confident that it is perfectly possible to build a safe external wall façade, despite it containing combustible materials.
I am equally confident, as I have seen examples, that just because an external façade is non-combustible, it does not make it safe. I have seen a nine-storey-high terracotta rainscreen with no cavity barriers and weak enclosure around the windows, which means that smoke is potentially ducted across the nine storeys of that building. It is non-combustible—great, but it is still a life risk to the residents in that building.
Q
Dr David Crowder: Again, I have not focused my interest on the Bill; I am concerned with the PAS. Currently, the Bill simply refers to the PAS, and the PAS gives a definition of whether a building is safe in terms of the risk of external fire. I know it is not for me to ask the questions, but I suppose there is a question to put back to those writing the Bill: are you seeking simply to limit the ability of any square metre of external wall to burn—to reduce its propensity to burn at all—or are you looking in the round at whether the people in the building are safe, in spite of the possibility of some fire spread?
This is where tolerability comes in. A number of public consultations have occurred around what people are content with. Let us start with buildings that comply with the building regulations as written right now, and buildings that have solid masonry wall construction. They are low risk, because the walls simply do not burn, so there is no hazard that anyone needs to concern themselves with in terms of the external walls. That does not mean that external fire spread will never occur, because you can still get window-to-window fire spread, but the walls will not make the problem worse.
If you have combustible material, the follow-on question is: how far does it go? How far up the wall could the fire spread if that combustible material was involved? Does it cross compartment lines, and is there therefore a likelihood of the fire going somewhere else? The final question then concerns the internal arrangements: if that spread should occur and covers a reasonable distance across the building, are there facilities for people to get out of the building?
We have taken a very scientific approach to it, and I am not sure it is conducive to legislation, to return to your question. There is probably a shorter, punchier way of doing it, but my fear, and the driver behind the way the PAS is written, is about giving people options and not assuming that everyone has the resources to do absolutely everything to mitigate risk.
Sarah Gibson
Q
You mentioned that, for fire engineers, control and signing up to ethical standards and so on is in the process of being done. One would therefore expect that fire assessors, who are, of course, more likely to be involved in the remediation we are talking about, would also be included in that regulation. My question is: do you think that the level of control over those applying the assessment and the ethical codes that go with it are sufficient to limit the issues we have seen around discrepancies? Is it more a question of enforcement than legislation for what is causing the discrepancies?
Dr David Crowder: I think that enforcement would help. The answer to your question lies not necessarily within “tolerable” but in the freedom that users have been given to simply reach different conclusions and walk away. That is what we have tried to clamp down on with the redraft.
By way of example, I review FRAEWs on occasion, and I am quite obviously well versed in what PAS 9980 says. We have risk tables in the PAS that give different risk ratings to different features of buildings, and I have seen instances where appraisers will quietly slip in that a feature of a building has a different risk rating from what the PAS says it should have, and that then flows through and changes their outcome. The new PAS—the 2026 edition—says that, for any deviation, including that, you have to declare in your report that you have done something different. With multiple appraisals, people now have to explain why they have reached a different conclusion.
I have seen instances in the past where appraisers are restricted by their professional indemnity insurance and all they can do is condemn combustible cladding. They will not be given professional indemnity insurance unless they condemn everything combustible and give the okay only on stuff that is non-combustible. I argue that it is an ethical problem that they are allowing their work to be influenced by a pressure other than the science and engineering—that needs to be declared. If that is the reason their report says something different from the previous one, they need to say that that is the case.
Equally, it might just be because they do not have the risk appetite. If it is simply risk appetite, they need to say that, so that people can take them to task and we can start getting some clarity. We have done everything we can to try to narrow the field, and I would like to see more appraisers being held to account when they are providing answers that people do not understand.
The additional thing is peer review. We have also prescribed in the 2026 edition that when an appraiser is reviewing somebody else’s FRAEW, they should not simply start again at the beginning, run through the whole process and then reach their own answer, which is likely to be different because different engineers have different views. We now positively say that they are instead expected to go through the other engineer’s work—
The Chair
Order. That brings us to the end of the time allotted for this session. On behalf of the Committee I thank you for your evidence.
Examination of witness
Florence Eshalomi MP gave evidence.
The Chair
We will now hear oral evidence from the Minister. We have until 5.20 pm. Could the witness please briefly introduce herself for the record?
Florence Eshalomi: Good afternoon. I am the Member of Parliament for Vauxhall and Camberwell Green. I am also the Minister of State with responsibility for homelessness, democracy, communities and faith. That includes building remediation.
Q
Florence Eshalomi: One of the things that the Government have been looking at is the fact that PAS 9980—as the Committee may be aware—was designed and developed by the British Standards Institution and went through a rigorous consensus-based public consultation process. On balance, we feel that it provides a robust and proportionate, industry-recognised methodology for assessing the risk. I think it is fair to say that residents will see fire as not discriminating. However, it is a case of making sure that we are looking at the issues around a building’s external walls and the action needed to keep residents safe. That is at the forefront of everything that we are trying to do in this potentially quite long and technical-seeming piece of legislation.
The other thing is around looking at how PAS 9980 will be put into practice and into law to make sure that it is consistent with external wall requirements. There will be secondary legislation at a later stage to require that a fire risk appraisal of external walls be carried out. That will help to give clarity about how external walls should be assessed, and we hope that this will also give regulators a firm benchmark in terms of targeting or challenging any poor assessments.
Q
Florence Eshalomi: One of the key things that we are trying to do is look at some of the other areas contained within the inquiry. We feel that this approach will be better in terms of making sure we are legislating on the key areas around the principle that the developer pays in terms of the levy and the additional measures for non-qualifying leaseholders. All those issues are coming to the forefront first.
Q
Florence Eshalomi: This is an area that we are still keen to look at and are developing with leaseholders and insurance companies. You may be aware that the Financial Conduct Authority is going through a review at the moment on the issue of how remediation and reductions in risk are reflected in the pricing structure. My understanding is that the Treasury Committee is also looking at this. What we are seeking to do with this Bill is strengthen the confidence in the assessments’ decisions through the independent auditing of the FRAEWs, including powers to audit the assessments that conclude that no remediation is required.
With regard to the question of risk maybe being posed and assessed as tolerable, I will go back to some of the comments the Committee heard earlier. Essentially, we need to make sure that residents are safe, but a tolerable risk does not mean that a building is unsafe. Today’s evidence sessions have also highlighted some of the other areas in which leaseholders are rightly pushing us to go further in terms of some of the internal wall defects, which in some cases are causing some of the issues around insurance. I am hoping that during the passage of this Bill, we can look at some additional measures.
However, the building insurance premiums can sometimes reflect a range of areas, not just external wall fire risk: it could be claims for things such as flooding, water or other damage. I think that we need to look at the whole issue of building insurance as a package in the round, not just the external wall risk and the issue of what is and is not tolerable.
Q
Florence Eshalomi: What we need to distinguish is the fact that PAS 9980 as it stands does not remove or replace the need for buildings to comply with building regulations; maybe we need to make that a lot clearer. This is around highlighting that any remediation work that needs to be carried out must also meet building regulations that may apply to that. Again, there is the technical aspect of the Bill, and what we are seeking to do with this legislation is make clearer who owns that risk. PAS 9980 and building regulations serve two entirely different purposes. We are very clear on what building regulations are doing in terms of the regulations for new buildings, whereas PAS 9980 considers the risk and tolerable risk of buildings as they stand now, looking at the critical issue around safety when it comes to life and to external walls.
On the question of whether we should revisit the whole issue of “tolerable”, that goes back to my response to your initial question. Across the sector and industry, we feel that PAS 9980, set by the British Standards Institution, strikes the right balance in trying to find a way forward through something that has been at an impasse for many years—successive Governments have tried to resolve this.
It is about how we get the best approach in terms of moving forward in a really complicated but important area that is affecting so many people up and down the country. They want a resolution and to know that if something goes wrong in their building, which a number of them have invested a lot of money in—sometimes their life savings—they know who they can go to to remediate that. A lot of them bought in good faith and they should not have to turn themselves into building experts just to know that the building they are living in is safe.
Sarah Gibson
Q
We have not had accountable assessors, so we can have an assessment that decides that a building is tolerable but actually that tolerable level, as decided by an assessor, turns out not to meet the standard of building regulations, even at the time of construction. Why are we surprised that people cannot then sell their houses, get mortgages, or get insurance? We should not be. We must recognise that if we are going to put in a new piece of legislation, which will add to the amount of legislation that a leaseholder must look at, it has to be watertight—forgive the expression. The point has been raised today and it still concerns me: there is a lack of clarity about where—with which agency—the buck actually stops. A leaseholder needs to know where to go at the end. Who is really, finally responsible and accountable?
We also must make sure that the assessors who make the decisions can be held accountable, and that they have an ethical code in place to make sure that they cannot be manipulated by their employer. We should make sure that we make those points really clear during scrutiny of the Bill. That will make a difference to our leaseholders, who have waited so long for this legislation. I want to make sure that the Committee irons out those points over the next few weeks.
Florence Eshalomi: I totally hear that and accept it. To be honest, no one Bill can fix this mess. We are trying to make sure that leaseholders who have invested in good faith are not burdened with all the costs, hence the Bill introduces the charge for construction product manufacturers, which is important. To date, construction product manufacturers have not played their part in fixing the mess they created.
We are trying to strike the right balance. We have heard from the National Housing Federation and the LGA. If colleagues from the LGA, and other councillors, were here they would highlight the difficulties that they have in bringing forward new development. I see that acutely in my constituency, where—as the Committee knows—the Government introduced measures to change housing targets, which is having an impact.
A more prescriptive, blanket approach could lead to more extensive remediation, but will it make residents safe? Will it achieve the ultimate goal? How can we have the least disruption to residents? Some residents may have to leave their homes, and some will have additional costs—we must make sure those costs are recouped—and ultimately slower remediation. How do we make sure that we give more power and support to BSR to get the buildings that have been identified remediated?
We must be honest: although the issues in New Zealand are not similar to those here, there are areas where we can definitely learn. I will task officials to look a bit closer at that, and see if there is anything in the Bill that we can tweak during its passage. It is about being open, honest and receptive to those challenges, about making sure that we are being challenged and ultimately about trying to get something right as we progress the Bill.
Andrew Cooper
Q
Thank you for that; it is really important. I am not sure if all colleagues are aware of the new highlights from Minister Pennycook today in terms of charges being passed on to leaseholders. It is allowing leaseholders to interrogate and ask their building freeholders for more information around the insurance costs. It is allowing leaseholders to challenge some of those costs as they come forward. These are all measures we hope will help in some cases where leaseholders have been asked to pay more but in essence get a much poorer service.
Separate to that is the draft Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, which I know you have campaigned on for a very long time, Mr Cooper. We are hoping it will come back to the House before the end of the year. The Prime Minister committed to that in PMQs yesterday. That will help leaseholders in terms of challenging unfair ground rents, where we are seeing many leaseholders pay in excess of £1,000 for nothing.
There are big issues around the service charge. Some leaseholders actually want to get rid of their managing agents, so the right to manage is another area being covered. We are looking at a whole range of packages to help leaseholders who have ultimately made that commitment to a home, because for many of them that dream has turned into a nightmare.
I hope, as the Bill progresses, the packages in it, especially some of the packages for non-qualifying leaseholders and packages for buildings under 11 metres, will help alleviate some of the cost of living pressures that many leaseholders up and down the country are facing.
Andrew Cooper
Thank you, Minister. I was going to ask you about the draft Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill, but you got ahead of me.
Q
Florence Eshalomi: I am happy to take that away, look at it and come back to the Member.
Q
Florence Eshalomi: It is important that we try and get a Bill that can get support across the House. That might mean sitting down with Opposition and Government Members to make sure we are bringing forward amendments that would help strengthen the Bill. We feel that the range of packages, as drafted, are strong enough, but that is something I would be willing to work with Members on.
Q
Florence Eshalomi: I am hoping so. One of the areas that Lord Andy Roe and Charlie Pugsley outlined was capacity across industry. A key issue that has been raised is around the quality and competency of fire assessors; making sure they are in place to carry out the assessments, first and foremost, is quite important. We are working to ensure we are helping and speeding that up.
I know that local government colleagues will raise the extra burdens cost, and we are looking at that. Hopefully, all these different measures should help, ultimately, to speed up that remediation. We have a target; we have not met that target yet, but we are on course and working at pace to make sure we hit it in time.
The Chair
I do not think we have time for a further question. I thank the Minister for giving evidence. We have now come to the end of the session. The Committee will meet again at 9.25 am on Tuesday 17 November to begin line-by-line consideration.
Ordered, That further consideration be now adjourned.—(Sarah Coombes.)