Westminster Hall

Tuesday 17th November 2026

(1 day, 9 hours ago)

Westminster Hall
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text

Westminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.

Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.

This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record

Tuesday 17 November 2026
[Sir John Hayes in the Chair]

Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency

Tuesday 17th November 2026

(1 day, 9 hours ago)

Westminster Hall
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts

Westminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.

Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.

This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record

09:30
Esther McVey Portrait Esther McVey (Tatton) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I beg to move,

That this House has considered the performance of the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency.

It is an honour to serve under your chairmanship, Sir John. I thank the Backbench Business Committee for granting today’s important debate, and the many colleagues from across the House who came together to support the application to the Committee. The Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency is the body responsible for ensuring the safety and efficacy of medicines and medical devices in the UK. That is a huge responsibility with the potential to change countless lives for the better, but also with the potential to cause great suffering and even death.

We last came together to highlight serious and ongoing failures at the agency in a debate chosen by the Backbench Business Committee in January last year. Since then, I am afraid that we have seen little—if any—discernible improvement in its performance. Last time, we flagged worrying inadequacies in the yellow card reporting scheme, yet nothing has happened. We highlighted the lack of transparency in how the agency approves drugs and devices, and then monitors their safety—again, nothing has happened. We called on the Government to fully implement the recommendations in the 2020 Independent Medicines and Medical Devices Safety Review and to acknowledge the harm done to patients—yet again, nothing has happened. Those harmed by Primodos, sodium valproate and surgical mesh—some of whom are in the Public Gallery today—are still awaiting redress after campaigning for years and, in some cases, decades.

Perran Moon Portrait Perran Moon (Camborne and Redruth) (Ind)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I have several constituents affected by the Primodos scandal. Six years on, after the Cumberlege review called for substantial reform of the MHRA, can we honestly say that patients feel more involved in decision making, and is there anything in the MHRA’s strategy 2030 that gives the right hon. Lady confidence that a future Primodos scandal would be handled differently?

Esther McVey Portrait Esther McVey
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The hon. Member raises a very important point: this is a tragedy that has gone on for many years. I have to say that if we look at past performance, I have no confidence going forward. That is why I will ask to meet the Minister. Let us meet the MHRA to get the confidence that the hon. Member and his constituents need and want. I am pleased to see colleagues here today who will talk passionately—as he just did—on behalf of those who have suffered as a result of those medical scandals.

I do not want to repeat the litany of serious concerns I raised in the debate last year. Instead, I want to use my time today to highlight a specific and tragic case that lays out the human cost of the MHRA’s utter incompetence. In spring 2022, an 80-year-old mother with advanced Alzheimer’s, who was living in a care home in my constituency, received the Moderna covid-19 vaccine booster. She became ill the following day with a very high fever, severe and repeated vomiting, and hypoactive delirium, which is very serious for those with dementia. She deteriorated rapidly and subsequently died. There were reports of mass serious adverse reactions in the same care home after the booster was given, and a second related death.

Did the MHRA investigate? No. Did it respond fully to the family’s subsequent complaint? No. Did the MHRA review why the vaccine was approved for frail and elderly people, despite them being absent or under-represented in clinical trials? No. To quote from Moderna’s risk management plan,

“frail subjects with unstable health conditions and co-morbidities”,

including chronic neurological diseases, were identified as “Missing Information”. Why was the MHRA not honest about the woeful lack of safety evidence for using Moderna in the frail and elderly care home cohort?

My constituent’s son and daughter have pulled together the most extraordinary dossier of evidence, not just about their mother’s case but the wider issues it highlights about how drugs are assessed and approved for the elderly, and how safety signals were ignored and dismissed. They have basically done the MHRA’s job for them. Their vaccine damage payment scheme application prompted an investigation that amassed 944 pages of detailed medical evidence. It resulted in a successful claim, but the MHRA has still done nothing. In July this year, the family lodged a formal complaint about the MHRA’s handling of their mother’s case. The all-party parliamentary group on pandemic response and recovery, which I co-chair with the hon. Member for Blackley and Middleton South (Graham Stringer), supported that complaint. To date, the family has still not had a reply to the complaint.

The APPG did receive a reply from the Minister, though I am sorry to say it was inadequate, failing to mention the frail elderly, recognise the family’s vaccine damage payment scheme judgment or any consideration of the individual case. He was keen to reiterate that patient safety is the MHRA’s top priority, but those words mean nothing if they cannot be backed up with meaningful action.

This case is not an isolated one. It exemplifies the problems that I and other Members have raised repeatedly. In February 2024, our APPG, together with more than two dozen cross-party colleagues, wrote to the Health and Social Care Committee urging a thorough, wide-ranging investigation into the MHRA. We described the agency as being at “the heart of…endemic failings” that continue to put patients at serious risk. Those failings include deficiencies in the yellow card scheme, inadequate post-marketing surveillance, conflicts of interest, lack of transparency and a failure to scrutinise and act promptly on data safety concerns.

What happened to my constituent sadly aligns with those long-standing concerns. The MHRA did not properly evaluate or respond to the cluster of adverse events in that care home, where the residents were highly vulnerable. The MHRA seems happily to write off adverse reactions in the elderly as a mere temporal coincidence, yet the events in this case should have triggered rigorous investigation.

Comorbidities, frailty, physiological decline and multiple medications mean that care home residents are more susceptible to adverse effects. The MHRA is supposed to uphold the guidelines in the good pharmacovigilance practices documents, which stress the importance of monitoring the elderly population, due to increased risk factors. We see no evidence of that in relation to this case.

We will hear over the course of this debate how MHRA has failed many more patient groups, which have suffered life-changing injury or death due to other drugs or devices. I hope that will help to focus the Minister’s mind to act and find solutions. The human cost to patients and the financial burden on the healthcare system are substantial. Failure to act will lead only to more harm and further damage to public trust.

Christopher Chope Portrait Sir Christopher Chope (Christchurch) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I congratulate my right hon. Friend on securing this timely debate. Is she going to refer to the report of module 4 of the covid inquiry that identified serious flaws with the yellow card system? Does she share my concern than the MHRA, as an independent regulator, fell down on its responsibilities during the covid pandemic, by refusing to acknowledge that the vaccines were not absolutely safe, as we now know, from the awards made under the compensation scheme? More than 200 cases of death or serious injury arising from covid-19 vaccines have been established, but the MHRA was in denial at the time when people needed the truth.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes (in the Chair)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

We hope we might hear from the hon. Gentleman at even greater length later.

Esther McVey Portrait Esther McVey
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My hon. Friend has put that important point on the record; I know other people will speak to that today. It is yet another finding about the inadequacy of the agency.

Finally, will the Minister for Health Innovation, who jointly launched and endorsed the MHRA strategy 2030 last month, attend the meeting that I have with the Minister for Public Health and Patient Safety, who has agreed to a meeting with me and the family of my former constituent? Or can he commit to a further meeting without delay? The performance of the MHRA in this case fell short of what we should expect. I feel sure the Minister will want to do the right thing and learn from that case to help to protect future patients from such devastating harm.

09:40
Graham Stringer Portrait Graham Stringer (Blackley and Middleton South) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Sir John, and to follow the right hon. Member for Tatton (Esther McVey). We chair the all-party parliamentary group on pandemic response and recovery, which we set up after the pandemic, partly because, as the right hon. Member has just said, of failures during the pandemic. We wanted to investigate what was happening afterwards and make recommendations to improve the process.

We were left confounded by trying to get information regularly from the MHRA, which is a very strange beast indeed. It is an arm’s length regulator, which is sensible, but it is funded by the pharmaceutical industry. That inevitably leads to a belief, and it seems to be the case in practice, that the MHRA is working not on behalf of the public and patients, but on behalf of the pharmaceutical industry. That is further exacerbated by its secretive ways. It has not responded in the past to freedom of information requests and has not responded adequately to our requests for further information about how it is proceeding, assessing and investigating yellow card complaints. So it leads me to ponder whether it should continue to exist. The questions asked by the hon. Member for Camborne and Redruth (Perran Moon) are the right questions: can it be improved? Will it reform itself? Can it be reformed by the Government and improve? From my experience over the last four or five years, it cannot.

We therefore have to ask whether this regulatory quango would be best as an advisory body to the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, because one problem we have had is getting information out of the MHRA. Although parliamentary democracy is imperfect and sometimes we have difficulties in getting information out of Departments, at least we can get the Secretary of State and the Minister on to the Floor of the House, in front of Select Committees and in debates in Westminster Hall to ask questions directly when things go wrong, which is not possible with the MHRA. So, I have come to the conclusion that there should be a serious investigation and assessment of the MHRA by the Government. Obviously, they would have to look at the evidence, but at the moment I think that they should bring it in as an advisory body. My answer to the question is that it is not reformable as it stands.

I would like to take up one further, rather detailed point that the right hon. Member for Tatton made about her constituent, an elderly lady, who died. When the very quick—and, in the final analysis, effective—tests on the vaccines were carried out, as is often the case, elderly people were either not present or under-represented in those tests. That is not unreasonable in itself, but it means that the MHRA should spend more time looking at what has happened when there are adverse events and deaths following injections. Those people were not really tested when the vaccine itself was tested. But the MHRA has done completely the opposite: when there have been adverse events and deaths, it has effectively ignored them and not properly assessed and investigated them.

There are a number of simple points I want to make, although there are people who want to speak. When I looked at the debate we had on 16 January last year, one thing I had forgotten that surprised me was that a number of hon. Members blamed the fact that we had left the European Union for the inadequacies of our regulation. That is the exact opposite of the truth. The fact is that by taking regulation in-house, we should have been able to be more effective. When the European Medicines Agency was in charge, we did not know who was regulating our medicines and devices, because those devices and medicines could be approved anywhere in Europe.

I will finish with a number of questions, but before I get to them there is another case that has not been mentioned before. Voy has put adverts on London buses with the slogan “The Weight is Over”, which is a pun on waiting to get rid of excess weight. The MHRA and the Advertising Standards Agency have found it to be in breach of the regulations. We are not allowed by law in this country to advertise prescription medicines and this is clearly a device to get around that. The MHRA found against it, saying some very strong things in condemnation of those adverts, but what has been the consequence? Zero. It is great to criticise an illegal advert, as found by both regulatory bodies, but what has been the consequence for Voy? Even when the MHRA has assessed things, it has not really pursued it.

I would like to finish with four questions. We do not know how much has been spent on the yellow card system. Will the Minister tell us that, or will he find out? How much is spent on the regulation on devices and medicines? We cannot find that out. How many individual investigations have there been, and how many have led to changes in advice on prescriptions? I would be grateful if the Minister could answer those questions either today or by correspondence.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes (in the Chair)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The co-sponsors of the debate having spoken, I remind Members to bob if they wish to be called to speak. I see Sammy Wilson.

09:50
Sammy Wilson Portrait Sammy Wilson (East Antrim) (DUP)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Thank you, Sir John. The failures of the MHRA have been well documented. The speeches today have focused on the failure of covid vaccinations, but the failures go back a long time. They involve issues such as pelvic mesh—I can remember seeing a constituent whose life was destroyed by the insertion of pelvic mesh—as well as sodium valproate, breast implants, metal hip replacements and puberty blockers. The APPG on pandemic response and recovery, of which I am a member, has been focusing on covid vaccinations. Despite those failures being known, with a report having been made on them six years ago, no lessons appear to have been learned. The problems have been highlighted already this morning.

First, we must question the independence of the MHRA. Is it independent financially? Half of its income comes from the pharmaceutical companies. Is it even independent politically? I sometimes wonder why the early signs of problems with the covid vaccine were not highlighted earlier. Was it because the Government were afraid that highlighting them may have made people wary of taking the vaccine? That is not a good reason. Some European countries had already identified problems with the AstraZeneca vaccine, yet it took six months for the MHRA to accept that there were problems with clotting and so on.

The yellow card reporting mechanism has not worked. Only about 10% of serious cases, and 2% of non-serious cases, are highlighted. It may be that the system is too complicated, that doctors or patients do not know about it, or that there is not enough time to do the research, but if a reporting mechanism leads to only 10% of serious cases being highlighted, there must be something wrong with it.

On transparency, the APPG on pandemic response and recovery has had difficulties in trying to get information. Even when we have asked pointed questions—not vague questions, but questions that there should have been answers to—there has been either no response or a delayed response. Another issue is the composition of the MHRA: patients are not represented properly on it.

What kinds of reforms are required? First, there must be genuinely independent oversight. We cannot have a regulator that almost marks its own homework. Secondly, there should be mandatory reporting. When problems are highlighted, there should be a mechanism whereby doctors have to respond. If a patient comes in and highlights that they have taken a certain drug or vaccine and are having problems, there should be a mandatory reporting requirement.

Gregory Campbell Portrait Mr Gregory Campbell (East Londonderry) (DUP)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My right hon. Friend is outlining a plethora of issues that are at the heart of the MHRA. Does he agree that at the basis of this issue is the wider community’s total lack of confidence and trust in how effectively the MHRA conducts its work?

Sammy Wilson Portrait Sammy Wilson
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My hon. Friend is right; indeed, if the public were aware of the difficulties that there have been even in trying to get the results of investigations, they certainly would not have any confidence in the body to do its job properly.

There should be mandatory reporting and, once problems have been reported, there must be evidence of proper investigation of those issues. Again, as highlighted by the proposer of the motion, sometimes we do not even know if the reports made about the impacts of the covid vaccine were properly investigated and what the outcomes were. There needs to be patient representation on the MHRA.

I would like to ask the Minister three or four questions. First, why has it taken six years for the recommendations in Baroness Cumberlege’s report to be implemented and will he commit to having them implemented now? Secondly, will he introduce a system of mandatory reporting so that when issues are raised, they are not just buried, forgotten or left aside because there has not been sufficient time? Thirdly, what has changed in the MHRA’s handling of serious and fatal yellow card reports, and what investigation have the Government done into that? Lastly, what lessons has the MHRA learned from the original approval and subsequent notifications of its own pathway trial? It is important to have confidence in the work of the MHRA. Radical reforms are needed and those are some of the things I think need to be done.

09:57
Sharon Hodgson Portrait Mrs Sharon Hodgson (Washington and Gateshead South) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir John. I thank the co-chairs of the all-party parliamentary group for calling this important debate and for bringing to light an issue that is vital to every aspect of patient safety.

From mesh to Poly Implant Prothèse breast implants, and from thalidomide to sodium valproate, the MHRA has shown time and again that it needs a complete overhaul of its approval systems, which seem to leave transparency and patient safety at the door. We promised thalidomide victims back in 1973 that nothing like that scandal would every happen again, yet we have seen scandal after sandal since.

After the thalidomide scandal came the sodium valproate scandal. The drug was approved for nationwide prescription just a year after thalidomide was banned. At the same time, the forerunner to the MHRA decided it was best not to mention the adverse effects of sodium valproate on animal foetuses as it would give way to “fruitless anxiety”. That “fruitless anxiety” meant the campaigners for foetal valproate syndrome, who we all know well—Janet Williams and Emma Murphy—were dismissed by the MHRA. The MHRA is at the heart of the epidemic of medical scandals and, quite frankly, like the right hon. Member for Tatton (Esther McVey), I have had enough.

The Government urgently need to launch an inquiry to put an end to the chain of scandals before there is more harm on the MHRA’s hands. The MHRA’s priority needs to be no longer just risk minimisation, but risk prevention. The pharmaceutical company that produced sodium valproate issued warnings about the teratogenic nature of the product. The forerunner to the MHRA shamefully decided to ignore those warnings and not disclose them to patients.

As another example of harm—of which there are so many—as recently as 2017, the director of medical devices at the MHRA explained that using mesh during surgery was perfectly safe based on its evidence. Weeks later, the Food and Drug Administration in the USA banned the use of vaginal prolapse mesh due to the harm it was causing women. The wonderful Baroness Cumberlege, who so many of us worked with on her excellent report, paused sling mesh surgery for incontinence just a year later.

Jim Shannon Portrait Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The hon. Lady has referred clearly to the issue of mesh that was passed as okay here, and told us what the USA did within weeks of that statement from the MHRA. Is there not an onus on the UK health service and those across the world? If they had known in advance what would happen in the USA, the use of mesh would never have been agreed to.

Sharon Hodgson Portrait Mrs Hodgson
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I agree that there are lessons to be learned from across the world. If one country is looking at the harm that some drug or medical device is causing to patients, then the rest of the world should take notice, but there are so many examples where that just does not happen.

In 2018, the MHRA confirmed three deaths associated with mesh incontinence procedures. That is the very same MHRA that in its “Strategy 2030” described itself as having an

“overriding priority of patient safety.”

As recently as last night, at a reception on the Terrace in Parliament, I listened to speeches by the senior people at the MHRA and had conversations with people working there about how patient safety is at the centre of everything that they do. That might indeed be the MHRA’s genuine ambition now, but we cannot forget the failures of the very recent past: there are women and children today living with the consequences of its failures. Where was patient safety as recently as 2017, when it deemed that mesh was safe for use in surgery despite its harms already being public knowledge? It seems to me, and maybe to all of us here today, that patient safety is not always the overriding priority that it should be for the MHRA.

Patient safety also seems to be forgotten when it comes to financial conflicts of interest. During the covid-19 vaccine roll-out, several experts on the advisory committee had undisclosed financial ties to the vaccine companies. There are current reports of hernia mesh surgeons receiving undisclosed financial donations from mesh suppliers. Even since the complications of using plastic mesh were brought to light, it has often been reported that there is a revolving door between those working for the MHRA—the independent regulator—and those working in the industry. What guardrails are in place, such as there are for Government, Ministers and Parliament, to ensure that transparency and patient safety are paramount? MPs have to disclose everything that might give rise to a conflict of interest, but in the medical profession, with medical devices and drugs, that is not the case. In my opinion that is wrong.

I heard last night that the MHRA is launching a new programme to tackle gaps in women’s health—something that I and, I am sure, many of us here today would welcome. However, in the past, the MHRA has failed women, with little remedy and, as far as I am aware, not even an apology. As we heard from the right hon. Member for Tatton, the yellow card reporting system has been known to capture only a fraction of medicinal side effects and medical device complications.

After the Cumberlege review, the medical devices outcomes registry was set up in 2024 as an avenue for medical device performance to be reviewed by healthcare professionals, with the intention of linking the registry to the MHRA’s current data. Two years later, MDOR still has not been associated with the MHRA’s yellow card system, leaving medical devices unbeknown to the scrutiny of the regulator. If the MHRA is failing its audits on existing treatment outcomes, how will the women of tomorrow be reassured by the investment in women’s health that it launched yesterday?

We promised victims of thalidomide decades ago that this would never happen again; we told victims of sodium valproate that we were very sorry that their children had been put through what they were put through; just three weeks ago at Prime Minister’s questions, the Prime Minister said from the Dispatch Box that he would ensure that there is justice for the victims of Primodos—another scandal that Baroness Cumberlege covered in her report—on his watch; and we assured the victims of mesh that they would be listened to and put first in conversations about patient safety. So why does this keep happening? What drug or medicinal device are we prescribing now that has been rushed through regulations without proper checks? When will enough be enough, and when will the MHRA finally be held accountable for its part in these scandals?

10:06
Sorcha Eastwood Portrait Sorcha Eastwood (Lagan Valley) (Alliance)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir John. I thank the right hon. Member for Tatton (Esther McVey) and the hon. Member for Blackley and Middleton South (Graham Stringer) for bringing this matter to the House today.

I want to start today by referring to two incredible people, who became heroes of mine after I watched “Mums v Big Pharma” last week. I sat with my husband and watched it, and we ended it in tears. I know about sodium valproate, because over the years many of my constituents in Lagan Valley have raised it with me as an issue. I also know about pelvic and hernia mesh, for the same reason. But it is not until you see the damage that these products have wrought on families that it is really brought home.

I want to get to the heart of an issue that I feel is critical in all this. Hon. Members from across the House have already said that they feel there is a barrier, and potentially a conflict of interest, and they have questioned the foundation of the MHRA itself and its status as an arm’s length body. I think there is something deeper going on. Whether it is sodium valproate, Primodos, thalidomide, mesh or one of many other things, there is an issue of class. That might be uncomfortable or controversial, but many people in this country trust the medical profession and regulatory authorities without question, to the extent that we have tried to bring in interventions such as the Hillsborough law so that there are barriers and systems to ensure that those bodies are beyond reproach. But if we expect members of the public to be the lone voice against pharmaceutical giants and we disregard them, where is the robustness in that system?

I look at Emma Murphy and Janet Williams. They describe themselves, in our parlance in Northern Ireland, as two wee women. Well, I will tell you what: they are some women. They faced barriers and discrimination for years, and where did it leave us? Hundreds of thousands of families up and down the country have been impacted—damaged—unnecessarily. I look at the guardrails that Members across this House have raised many times, and I question their efficacy and effectiveness. Let me point out, too, that this has damaged everyone in society—men, women and children—but there is a particular issue around women’s health, and I find the issues raised by the hon. Member for Washington and Gateshead South (Mrs Hodgson) particularly concerning.

I say to the House today that we have to stop this reverence. We have to listen to people. People have questioned how robust and effective the yellow card system is, but we do not empower people in this country; we tread on them. We close ranks—professional ranks and medical ranks—and we gaslight them. We tell them they are the problem. We hear about the “fruitless anxiety” that was mentioned in reports. We hear about not wanting to concern people. Meanwhile, we know that people are consuming a drug that we know to have teratogenic impacts. How disgusting, and how wrong.

The final insult is that the redress promised to so many families across the UK is still outstanding. But this is not about the redress; it is about the fact that we have a system that is clearly not fit for purpose. We have to ensure that these regulatory bodies are indeed beyond reproach. It is not enough for links to be based on an old school tie, class references or anything else; we have to ensure that they are robust.

I want to conclude by expressing my heartfelt thanks to the families up and down the country that have been failed by the MHRA and the state. They deserve nothing but our applause and adulation, but the applause is meaningless unless we change this absolutely wrong system, which has damaged people and left many of us in this House without confidence in it. There is nothing more important than health and, frankly, it sits extremely uncomfortably with me that over many decades we have not taken action when we should have done. I again thank the right hon. Member for Tatton and the hon. Member for Blackley and Middleton South for bringing this issue to the House. I urge Members not to give up this fight, and to fight for those families.

10:11
Simon Opher Portrait Dr Simon Opher (Stroud) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Good morning, Sir John. I thank the right hon. Member for Tatton (Esther McVey) for securing the debate.

Although there have been serious allegations about the MHRA and vaccines, I want to commend the enormous number of NHS staff who delivered the covid vaccine programme, which saved hundreds of thousands of lives—particularly those of older people. I do not want them to be denigrated by our debate.

I want to focus on the role of the MHRA with regard to antidepressants. I am the chair of the beyond pills all-party parliamentary group, and I chair our expert working group on antidepressant prescribing strategy. In particular, we want to highlight the problems associated with prescribed dependence-forming drugs such as antidepressants and the relevance of non-drug alternatives, such as social prescribing, talking therapies and access to nature.

Although antidepressants may help some people, overmedicalisation is a key concern. According to the latest figures, about 9.1 million people in England alone are on antidepressants and, shockingly, 187,000 patients under 19 were prescribed antidepressants in the last year. I am a GP with 30 years’ experience, and I specialise in mental health. I know that a significant number of patients are prescribed antidepressants when in fact they are feeling completely normal emotions in response to difficult life situations. They are not suffering from a medical condition and do not, in the main, need drug treatment.

The rising number of antidepressants prescribed brings up the issue of informed consent. Patients must be given clear information about the benefits and risks of antidepressants so that they can make a truly informed decision with their doctor about whether they want to take the drugs. That is where the MHRA comes in. We want to work constructively with the MHRA. I commend it on its recent initiatives recognising the need to strengthen the communication of risk around suicidality and sexual dysfunction with antidepressants. It should support the process of shared decision making between doctors and patients.

We also welcome the MHRA’s patient and public involvement and engagement plan, published on 5 November, which will take into account the lived experience of patients and carers in decision making. However, the MHRA needs to do that in other areas too, and there are still areas where we would like the risks to be communicated better, including akathisia—a distressing condition of such intense mental and physical disorder that people often say they want to take their own lives.

Another key issue is that patients are invariably not informed that they have an average chance of only one in eight that antidepressants will benefit their mental health.

Jim Shannon Portrait Jim Shannon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

One issue I am aware of in my constituency and across the United Kingdom is antidepressant drugs becoming addictive, which has a negative effect on people’s mental health, as the hon. Gentleman mentioned. When the Minister responds, perhaps he could give us some indication of how Government can address the issue of those who become addicted to the prescription medication they take daily.

Simon Opher Portrait Dr Opher
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

That is indeed an enormous problem. They say that about 2.5 million people are trying to get off antidepressants, but patients are not informed of these issues.

Esther McVey Portrait Esther McVey
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The hon. Member is making a significant speech. One of my constituents on a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor antidepressant committed suicide. Does he agree with me about the delays at the MHRA? There was significant evidence over a prolonged period of time that people on antidepressants could commit suicide when they come off, and yet nothing was done.

Simon Opher Portrait Dr Opher
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

That is absolutely true. There are higher risks of suicide when someone starts antidepressants and when they try to come off them, and patients are rarely informed about that. That is why we want more information from the MHRA in the pill packets.

Although we do not really know how antidepressants work, one accepted effect is that they dull emotions, which is called emotional blunting or numbness. That may be welcome for some, but for others it is profoundly distressing. Patient information leaflets might list effects such as apathy, indifference and lack of emotion or attachment, but patients have contacted the APPG to say that those terms do not convey the blunting of positive feelings as well as the negative ones.

One male patient in his 60s recently described the emotional blunting effect of his long-term antidepressants as

“suppressed love, joy, optimism, hope and creativity”.

He therefore decided to stop taking them, but like many others he suffered distressing and protracted withdrawal symptoms, with little support from his GP.

There is now another MHRA review into how well risks associated with withdrawals from antidepressants are communicated. Research suggests that between 34% and 50% of patients who try to come off them, as the right hon. Member for Tatton said, may experience quite severe withdrawal effects. Some 15% of patients who are long-term users—meaning they have used the drugs for more than a year—are likely to have severe withdrawal effects, and yet many of the drug companies do not accept that these drugs are addictive.

Since 2022, the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence has recognised that, for the patients most at risk of experiencing withdrawal, dosages need to be reduced in a slow, stepwise fashion called hyperbolic tapering. We call on the MHRA to urgently consider the need for licensing smaller doses of existing antidepressant drugs to enable that safer deprescribing. Currently, liquid antidepressants can be used, but they are off-label and incredibly expensive, which disincentivises GPs from prescribing them. It is also difficult to dilute them and get the correct dosage. We therefore need the MHRA to force drug companies to make smaller doses of tablets.

This is a tricky situation because antidepressants are licensed to treat indications such as depression, not for deprescribing. That means that very small doses of antidepressants cannot currently be created in tablet form under licence. Compounding pharmacies can make up little tablets, but they are unlicensed and cannot be routinely prescribed. A solution is urgently needed for licensing small doses of these drugs. Drug manufacturers should also be required to provide doses suitable for deprescribing for all new psychotropic drugs that will be licensed in the future. I hope the MHRA will seriously consider and act on those points.

As an addendum, I would be interested in the Minister’s view on the role of the MHRA in the regulation of AI in the NHS. As chair of the all-party parliamentary health group, I am chairing a meeting later to discuss the 44 recommendations that have recently been put forward.

10:19
Jim Shannon Portrait Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Sir John. I thank the right hon. Member for Tatton (Esther McVey) and the hon. Member for Blackley and Middleton South (Graham Stringer) for securing the debate. It is always good to see the Minister in his place; last night he did an Adjournment debate, and this morning he is doing a Westminster Hall debate, so he and I travel similar roads, although he is the man with all the responsibility.

I want to speak about the performance of the MHRA in relation to a slightly different subject—the accessibility of medications—and it is important that I put it on the record. The regulatory agency does important work—I will make this case very clearly—in ensuring that our medical treatments meet the appropriate standards of safety, quality and effectiveness, and we must give it some credit. However, approved medicines cannot be effective if patients cannot access them in the first place. There are currently widespread shortages across the United Kingdom—that is a fact of life. The National Pharmacy Association, which represents about 6,000 independent community pharmacies, states that 96% of pharmacies feel that current shortages pose a serious risk to the safety of patients. I have that very issue of access to medicines in my constituency.

I will give a personal example, and then a couple of examples of others whose health has been detrimentally affected by the shortage of medications. About six weeks ago, I was diagnosed with glaucoma, but the great thing is that people can take drops in their eyes to stop the condition getting any worse. However, access to those drops is difficult to achieve in parts of Northern Ireland, and they have to be ordered in advance and in excess to carry over. That is an example of where things go wrong.

In recent months, there have been record shortages of commonly dispensed medicines such as painkillers and blood pressure and epilepsy medication. I have constituents who have difficulty accessing medicines, and there are serious shortage protocols in place for hormone replacement therapy treatments and Creon—a drug to help those with pancreatic cancer or cystic fibrosis digest food, just so they can have a normal quality of life. It is clear that these shortages are not discriminatory: they affect the mildly ill to the most seriously ill, and any one of us could be affected.

The shortages have come alongside increased reports of pharmacy teams facing abuse or anger from patients whose prescribed medicine is unavailable. That is of course unacceptable on all occasions and under any circumstances, but it makes it clear that frontline pharmacists are also paying a price for medicine shortages and chronic underfunding. The Minister is always very responsive to our questions, and I know that he sets out to try to help us and that he has regular conversations with the relevant Minister back home, so what discussions has he had with them to address the acute shortages in Northern Ireland?

This is a UK-wide issue, but the situation is particularly precarious in Northern Ireland due to its small market and additional logistical costs. There are concerns that, due to Brexit, Northern Ireland has become a lower-priority market for medicine wholesalers, and the worry is that that will have serious implications for patient safety. I understand that the drug companies have to make money—that is their purpose, and if they do not, they cannot be in profit or deliver the medicines—but consideration has to be given to us in Northern Ireland, where the problems are particularly difficult.

Recently, a constituent came to me and made a very moving appeal for these shortages to be urgently addressed. This honourable, lovely, very happy lady has great disablement: she has multiple sclerosis, and has been on the drug Nabilone for 17 years to manage her pain. Just last month, she ran out of that medication and was forced to spend two weeks in bed due to a disruption in supply. That demonstrates the real human cost of medicine shortages: every pill missed is not just a missed dose; it is a lifeline lost. We in this House need to be aware of that.

Chris Murray Portrait Chris Murray (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The hon. Gentleman is speaking very movingly about a discussion with his constituent. I recently visited a constituent who underwent a mesh implant for pelvic floor prolapse in 2011, and I have written to the Minister about it. She was a young woman, and it resulted in her being unable to have children and leaving her job.

Jim Shannon Portrait Jim Shannon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I certainly agree, and I hope the Minister will reply to the hon. Gentleman. The mesh issue is important for women, but I have also seen men in my constituency who have had mesh, and it has affected their lives—sometimes that is lost in these debates. When we address these issues for ladies, it is important that we address them for men as well.

I call on the Government to ensure that medicines remain equally available across the United Kingdom and are regulated with consistency. People in Northern Ireland who are facing the same health problems as people across the water should not be, and cannot afford to be, disadvantaged.

Carla Lockhart Portrait Carla Lockhart (Upper Bann) (Ind)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The hon. Member is making a powerful speech. Does he agree that it is absolutely wrong that there is no independence in the MHRA? The industry is effectively marking its own homework because, ultimately, the MHRA is funded by big pharma. Does he agree that that damages trust? The Patient Safety Commissioner, whose role is to be a voice for patients, is also now hosted within the MHRA. Does he agree that that is just wrong and that we need to see change?

Jim Shannon Portrait Jim Shannon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I certainly do. I thank the hon. Lady for adding to the debate with those details. She is right to outline and underline those points.

I saw a wee story in the paper this morning. Sometimes things happen that are good news, and the good news this morning was for those on medicinal cannabis—I have constituents who are. Medicinal cannabis controls epilepsy and other acute medical conditions, and I read that Boots will prescribe it on a video call. That is a first for pharmacies, and an example of what can be done through good working relationships between chemists and those seeking help with physical problems.

The trend in medicine shortages is worsening, and increasing numbers of people will inevitably be affected. It is often said that health is not valued until sickness comes. Sadly, for many, medicine shortages are now forcing them to confront that grim reality. I look forward to the Minister’s response; he always gives us some encouragement, and I hope today to hear some encouragement for my constituents.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes (in the Chair)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I will start the winding-up speeches at 10.35 am. I call Sir Christopher Chope.

10:27
Christopher Chope Portrait Sir Christopher Chope (Christchurch) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Thank you for encouraging me to participate in the debate, Sir John. I have a few points in addition to those I made in my intervention.

The failure of the MHRA is directly contributing to a decline in vaccine confidence in this country. We know that a large number of families fail to have their young children vaccinated with the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine because they do not trust the authorities. Why not? Largely because, if they look at the literature, they know that there have been too many occasions when the MHRA has failed to be wholly honest and truthful about the impact of vaccines on individuals.

I was looking at the potential cause and how we might rectify it. Regulation 58 of the Human Medicines Regulations 2012 requires that “the positive therapeutic effects” of a vaccine should

“outweigh the risks to the health of patients or of the public”.

I do not think that is enough. What people want is some assurance that there is no risk of death or serious injury as a result of taking those vaccines. That is palpably not what is said at the moment by the MHRA, even in relation to MMR vaccines, although I am not aware of any case where an MMR vaccine has resulted in a death or serious injury. If we had that as the test, it would be a much stronger one. Although a lot of the covid-19 vaccines would have failed that test, people would have been alerted to it and they could then have weighed up in their own minds the merits or demerits of taking those vaccines, in the same way that they weigh up whether all the pressures of a Labour Government should force them to take antidepressants or not. That is a decision that they can make themselves on the basis of the evidence. I must make a declaration, Sir John, that I have not yet been driven to taking anti-depressants, despite this ghastly Government.

Being serious, let us change the rules so that it is much clearer that the MHRA looks primarily at the risk of serious injury or death, rather than these weasel words of positive therapeutic effects outweighing the risks to the health of patients or the public.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes (in the Chair)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I call the Liberal Democrat spokesman.

10:30
Anna Sabine Portrait Anna Sabine (Frome and East Somerset) (LD)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir John. I thank the right hon. Member for Tatton (Esther McVey) for bringing forward this debate; I know she feels very strongly about this issue, as do many of the rest of us here.

One of the first emails I received when I became an MP was from a constituent whose stepson is a victim of the Primodos scandal. Primodos was a hormonal pregnancy test and the scandal around its use is often called the forgotten thalidomide. Taking it in early pregnancy caused limb defects, congenital heart defects, developmental and learning problems, as well as stillbirths and miscarriages. My constituent, and others like her whom I have met since, have told me about the decades of fighting by families and amazing campaigners such as Marie Lyon to receive the justice they deserve for a scandal that has impacted so many lives.

Unfortunately, their story is not unique. Primodos, vaginal mesh and the faulty drugs and devices examined by the Cumberlege review: in each case, patients—women—raised concerns and the system, including the MHRA, has not listened. This should be evidence enough that the MHRA needs substantial reform, yet, as we have heard this morning we are still waiting to see many vital changes.

At the moment, patients are being failed by the MHRA in two ways: failed when the regulator is too slow to deliver promising treatments, and failed when it is too slow to listen when something goes wrong. The Liberal Democrats want a regulator that does both things well. This is why we are calling for reform to make it both effective and trusted.

On the question of speed, there has recently been a welcome turnaround in the MHRA. After years of neglect under the previous Government, nearly all national medicine licence applications in 2025-26 were decided within the statutory 210-day limit. Credit is due here, but that statutory timeline remains too slow. In the UK, it takes an average of 322 days—nearly a year—for a new medicine or medical technology to reach patients, compared with 158 days in Germany. For someone with a rare disease or an aggressive cancer, a promising treatment stuck in a queue uses up time they may not have. Clinical trial targets are also being missed.

What is the Government’s plan to improve that? The Liberal Democrats are clear that we would invest in MHRA capacity with the aim of halving the time it takes for new treatments for illnesses such as cancer to reach patients. We would make timeframes more predictable and offer more informal scientific advice from the outset, so that companies can get their products to patients sooner.

On the second question, trust, the Liberal Democrats would fully implement the Cumberlege recommendations, including providing compensation for those failed by faulty drugs and devices. That should include Primodos.

Finally, I turn to the subject of children with severe drug-resistant epilepsy, such as my constituent Clover, whose case I have raised in this place many times. Families like hers have been fighting for years for medicines that work. Right now, only one cannabis-based medicine is licenced for epilepsy in this country and only for three specific syndromes. Many children whose seizures have finally been brought under control depend on whole-plant medicines that remain unlicensed, so their parents are forced to pay thousands of pounds privately to keep their children alive.

Organisations such as the Medcan Family Foundation have been clear about the way forward. The medicines need to be licensed more widely, and the trials that would build that evidence should sit with the MHRA. Ministers say that a licence cannot come without the evidence, but the evidence cannot come without trials that are properly designed, adaptive and up and running. Families have been caught in that loop for far too long. I should say that the Minister’s predecessor met Clover’s family and was incredibly helpful, but he was the eighth Minister they have met in the time they have been campaigning and they feel that they are being passed from pillar to post.

The danger is now sharper than ever. Since Bedrocan went bankrupt last month, parents have been left wondering whether the medicine keeping their child alive will even be there in six months’ time. Will the MHRA take ownership of this situation, set out a clear route to licensing and ensure that no child is put at risk because the regulatory system has not kept pace?

More generally, will the Government commit to improving MHRA’s capacity, so that it can approve licences quickly, support clinical trials and, more importantly, serve the patients that benefit most from medical innovation? My constituents and thousands of people across the country have waited decades for the MHRA to listen and improve. I hope the Minister will agree to deliver for all the victims of medical scandals.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes (in the Chair)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I call the Conservative spokesman.

10:34
Caroline Johnson Portrait Dr Caroline Johnson (Sleaford and North Hykeham) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir John. I congratulate my right hon. Friend the Member for Tatton (Esther McVey) and the hon. Member for Blackley and Middleton South (Graham Stringer) on securing this important debate. I need to declare some interests: I am an NHS consultant paediatrician and a member of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health and of the British Medical Association, and I worked as a volunteer vaccinator in the covid scheme for much of the pandemic.

The Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Agency is there to ensure that our medicines are safe and effective. It is an important organisation, but it is also an executive agency of the Department of Health and Social Care and, ultimately, Government Ministers are responsible for what goes on. As we have heard, numerous concerns have been raised. I will make a couple of general comments and then review a couple of specific cases.

First, the yellow card scheme is important for safety monitoring. Awareness of the scheme has increased since the pandemic; reports went up 75% between 2020 and 2022. Can the Minister confirm that the MHRA has the resources to manage that increase in reports and is able to look at them effectively to make sure that nothing is missed?

Many hon. Members mentioned the vaccine damage payment. People left severely disabled by an adverse reaction to a vaccine may be able to claim through the scheme. Since 2022, £32 million has been paid out in compensation, with £83 million in administration costs. Is the Minister on top of those costs? Is he happy that the costs are proportional to the administration being provided? The Government have repeatedly said that they are assessing options to improve the scheme. Can the Minister enlighten us on what those options are and when the Government plan to make a decision?

My confidence in the MHRA was eroded further following a debate in May 2025 on what should have been a very straightforward statutory instrument, which set the agency’s fees. When looking at the sums, a civil service pay rise of 2.2% was assumed, which was below inflation; the Minister could not tell us whether it was the intention of the Government to provide a below-inflation pay rise, which in the end they did not. The agency failed to add the Government’s own rise in national insurance, and the Minister could not tell us whether or not it needed to be applied, which it did. That left the agency about 15% out in its sums. Given that it works on a cost recovery basis, the Minister insisted that it could manage—but, if that were the case, why was it asking for more money than it needed? In practice, it did not have enough, because it came back for more money just months later. The Minister needs to ensure that he has a grip not just on what the agency is doing medically, but on whether its sums are right, because ultimately it is important for all of us to get good medication.

Moving on to specific cases, I want to look at the puberty blockers trial. One of the key roles of the MHRA is in regulating and approving clinical trials. The puberty blockers trial will include 226 children—226 physically healthy children, who are developing normally from a pubertal point of view. They are going to be given powerful drugs that could cause them potentially serious damage. The trial has been discussed in detail on the Floor of the House, but I want to look specifically at the MHRA’s role.

After the trial was approved, Professor Jacob George was appointed as the chief medical and scientific officer of the MHRA in January. In February, a redacted letter was produced, talking about concerns related to the wellbeing of participants. At first, the Government appeared not to heed that warning. The following month, Professor George recused himself from further discussion. It was not clear why, but it led to concerns in the press that it was due to his gender-critical views, which are, of course, protected views under the Equality Act 2010. Could the Minister shed further light on what happened?

In June, it was decided that a minimum age would be set of 11 for girls and 12 for boys. Some people asked me, “Why are those different?”. The ages are different because girls go into puberty earlier than boys—an ironic recognition of biology in a trial that otherwise believes that girls may be able to be boys. However, the MHRA recommended a minimum age of 14. Could the Minister explain why there is a difference? The MHRA said that the minimum age was there to strengthen safeguards and ensure the monitoring of safety, bone health and cognition. Why have the Government chosen to have a minimum age of 11 or 12—in some cases, primary school children—rather than 14? I appreciate the Minister has been in the role for only a few months, but is he content to be responsible for the trial? Is he—as the previous Secretary of State said they would—receiving monthly updates on the trial’s progress?

I want to ask about the Hughes Report, published in February 2024. Members are familiar with the details of this scandal. We do not have exact numbers, but we know that around 10,000 women were affected by pelvic mesh and around 20,000 children were born disabled after exposure to sodium valproate in the womb. Earlier this month, a documentary called “Mums v Big Pharma” focused on Janet and Emma, two mums to children affected by intrauterine exposure to sodium valproate. I was fortunate to meet Janet and Emma recently to hear about their campaign. They did not know that these drugs were going to harm their children, but they have evidence that shows the Government knew that it might. They are inspiring women, and I pay tribute to them and their campaign.

It is now approaching three years since this report, and what have the Government done? As far as I can see, nothing. The last Labour Prime Minister failed to act; the latest Labour Prime Minister raised hopes with his words, but has so far dashed them with his lack of action. Last month, the Minister for Patient Safety said

“a decision has not yet been taken to provide financial redress,”—[Official Report, 29 October 2026; Vol. 792, c. 552.]

so when will the Government respond to the Hughes Report and when will that decision be made? That Minister also said that the foetal exposure to medicines pilot service in hospitals in Manchester and Newcastle will be extended. These are run by NHS England, which the Government are abolishing. Will this extension still happen? If so, can the Minister confirm who will be responsible for it?

In summary, there are concerns about the MHRA’s ability to respond to concerns raised, to act quickly, to improve medicines and to manage the financial adding-up. The Minister has only been in post for a few months, but he is a clever man and I know he is concerned to do well; I am sure he has identified the problems, but will he act? This Government have a tendency to kick the can down the road. There is no workforce plan and there are endless delays to plans for maternity. I know you, Sir John, are particularly interested in the acquired brain injury plan; that has also been further delayed, having been promised for last December.

Warm words are cold comfort when they do not come with action. Can the Minister reassure the House that he—as a new Minister, whom I welcome to his position and am glad to see there—will act promptly?

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes (in the Chair)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I now call on James Frith. Minister, please allow a few moments at the end for the right hon. Lady to wind-up. In turn, the right hon. Lady will allow a moment for me to move the motion.

10:43
James Frith Portrait The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Health and Social Care (Mr James Frith)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve with you in the Chair, Sir John. I am very grateful to the right hon. Member for Tatton (Esther McVey) and my hon. Friend the Member for Blackley and Middleton South (Graham Stringer) for securing today’s debate. I am also grateful to all Members who have contributed to, not only today’s debate, but this great history of debates on such incredible issues and related injustices. The exhaustion that some of these families continue to live with is a result of some dark decades of misinformation and withheld or incorrect information. I am happy to stand here as a Government Minister accountable to this House, and responsible for holding feet to the fire with the MHRA. I take that responsibility very seriously.

I am reminded of the very powerful phrase that Bishop James Jones used in his report on the Hillsborough inquiry, the

“patronising disposition of unaccountable power”.

That is something that speaks to my instincts and my political DNA. It is absolutely right that our systems hold Members like me responsible for the threat, the possibility and the prospect of that patronising disposition of unaccountable power. I will come on to speak about how I am assured of significant progress being made, but at no point do I deny, defer or dismiss the serious difficulties those families have been through.

James Frith Portrait Mr Frith
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I will make some progress before I take interventions shortly.

The issues we have discussed matter enormously. Medicines and medical devices affect us all, often when we are at our most vulnerable. The public must be able to trust the system that regulates those medicines and devices. It must be rigorous, independent and transparent and, when concerns are raised, they must be heard.

I acknowledge that the experiences of patients and families that hon. Members have raised remain deeply difficult. Good regulation requires us not simply to explain the system but to listen carefully when people raise concerns and issues. I keep in mind Bev in my constituency of Bury, who lives daily with the effects of pelvic mesh and the complete destruction of her physical relationship, which she wanted me to convey. I think of Janet and Emma, also from Bury, and their incredible sodium valproate campaign, and all the testimony we have heard today.

Regulation needs to occur regularly, not as a one-off event. It needs to be in a permanent state of review, as does the review of the regulator itself. The MHRA has a critical responsibility; its fundamental purpose is to protect the public by ensuring that medicines and devices meet appropriate standards of safety, quality, performance and effectiveness. It must do that independently, based on the best available evidence.

Regarding independence, as referred to by the right hon. Member for East Antrim (Sammy Wilson), fees are payable regardless of the outcome of an application, and are designed to recover the cost of providing the regulatory service, rather than generate a profit. Though subject to scrutiny and the need to be robust, that model is the right one, consistent with global regulators. The hon. Member for Strangford (Jim Shannon) asked about my contact with Northern Ireland. I have two dates in January and February to visit Northern Ireland, in my first few months in this role. I am happy to pre-meet him for a discussion and will be sure to pick up the issue with counterparts in Northern Ireland.

Some hon. Members asked whether reporting by healthcare professionals should be mandatory. Manufacturers already have statutory reporting obligations, while professional guidance provides for healthcare professionals to act on safety concerns. There is currently limited evidence that making it mandatory for healthcare professionals to report would improve the ability to detect signs of possible safety problems. I am conscious that that sounds like a denial or dismissal, but my assessment of the model is that what we actually need is much more access to patients and that patients need access to the system. At the moment, it is effectively a business-to-business or organisation-to-organisation model, and the patient is not in the loop.

One of my responsibilities in health innovation, around the new iterations of the NHS app and the development of NHS Digital, is to ensure verified information, so as to lance the disinformation about the efficacy of vaccines the hon. Member for Christchurch (Sir Christopher Chope) mentioned. Patients need to be able to speak to the system more effectively. The NHS app development I am overseeing is beginning to have that thought; I spoke this morning to the MHRA about leaning more into that.

That should not be interpreted as complacency about under-reporting. The MHRA is improving connections between yellow card and clinical systems, working with healthcare partners to increase reporting, making it easier to use, and developing its capability to use data and analytics to identify emerging risks earlier. I will say more on the yellow card system later.

I note that there has been a significant improvement in the MHRA’s operational performance in the past 18 months, thanks to Government funding and appropriate resource. A question was posed about whether there is enough resource and funding. When 99% of national medicines licence applications were determined on time and 97% of clinical trials and investigations assessed within target, I believe the answer is yes.

Lord O’Shaughnessy agrees: his independent review highlighting the significant challenges facing the clinical trials environment described the MHRA’s progress on performance since then as “remarkable”. On the matter of clinical trials, we have just confirmed the movement from 153 days to 100 days for launching clinical trials, with an appetite to go further and faster. That is an important point in answer to the issues raised about accessing clinical trials, freedom to engage with clinical trials and the pathway to market for the drugs and trial successes in question.

I commit to writing to the Opposition spokesperson, the hon. Member for Sleaford and North Hykeham (Dr Johnson), about the issue of vaccine damage payments. On the matter of puberty blockers that she raised, I recognise her concerns, and hon. Members have rightly highlighted the role of the MHRA in strengthening safeguards. However, I remind hon. Members that a judicial review concluded in July 2026 and the High Court rejected challenges to the regulatory decisions made in the assessment of the pathways trial, stating that:

“The MHRA is responsible for the safety of the clinical trial and the safeguarding of participants. It undertook a rigorous process to assess the trial before giving its initial approval in…2025.”

Crucially, that performance extends to safety monitoring, with the MHRA continuing to exceed its targets for processing serious adverse incident reports within 24 hours. That shows it is a fast and responsive regulator that can collaborate with the wider system and take action to protect patients when potential risks are identified.

Tessa Munt Portrait Tessa Munt
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The Minister is talking about scientific studies and trials, and in relation to Primodos in particular new scientific studies are being conducted. But I do not understand—maybe the Minister can explain it to me—how the MHRA is able to justify withholding vital information requested through freedom of information requests. Those requests have been made, but the Department has either redacted or refused to release data that is required for those studies to go ahead. He speaks about transparency; can he improve transparency in that respect?

James Frith Portrait Mr Frith
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am happy to improve transparency and remain accountable to the House on this issue. The MHRA and the Commission on Human Medicines are committed to considering new and relevant scientific information, including recently published material identified in this debate. I will happily pick that up with the hon. Lady shortly.

Performance cannot be measure by speed alone. Today, hon. Members have rightly asked equally important questions about whether the regulator identifies safety signals robustly enough, acts on them appropriately, is sufficiently transparent abouts its decisions, and listens properly to patients. I want to address those questions directly.

We have to be careful not to talk about innovation as though it cancels out the testimonies that Members have made behalf of their constituents today, because it does not. Behind Primodos, sodium valproate, pelvic mesh and other cases are people whose families believed that the system was supposed to protect them. I am sympathetic to the point of the hon. Member for Lagan Valley (Sorcha Eastwood) about there being both a class and a gender lens to this issue, and I have had conversations about that with regard to the application of the women’s health strategy. Hon. Members will also have heard the Minister for Women and Equalities make that class point passionately. I am happy to pick up on that matter subsequently.

We should acknowledge that those experiences are completely unacceptable. Trust cannot be demanded from those who feel that they have been let down; it has to be earned anew and permanently renewed. I recognise the argument recently made in this House that for affected families, preventing future harm does not resolve the consequences of the harm that they have already experienced. On the redress scheme, the Minister for Public Health and Patient Safety said to the House last month that we are

“committed to making meaningful progress in this Parliament”.—[Official Report, 20 October 2026; Vol. 791, c. 956.]

I will not pre-empt that work today, but the Prime Minister has spoken of his alertness to the issue.

Caroline Johnson Portrait Dr Caroline Johnson
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Will the Minister give way?

James Frith Portrait Mr Frith
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I will make some progress. I am conscious that I need to give the right hon. Member for Tatton time to sum up.

We should not assume that the regulator of today is incapable of learning from the regulator of the past. The test that I would apply is whether it listens when patients raise concerns and whether it shows a readiness to reform or renew. That matters for the future as much for the past. Science does not stand still while institutions catch up. New medicines and devices, and AI—which the good doctor, my hon. Friend the Member for Stroud (Dr Opher), referred to—are being introduced. My view is that innovation moves at the speed of trust. Good regulation should therefore be an enabler, not by lowering the bar, but by making the bar clear, rigorous and responsive to evidence.

My hon. Friend is right that the Government accepted the 44 recommendations and will be responding formally with a plan for delivery. As he helpfully confirmed, the patient and public involvement and engagement plan is about giving patients much more information about the professional dialogue that happens around prescription. It also speaks to the wider point about the NHS app and about the digital verified information that we make available so that people can make informed decisions.

Hon. Members raised concerns about the number of fatal covid vaccine reports that were investigated. The MHRA assesses every yellow card report involving a suspected adverse reaction with a fatal outcome. That includes all fatal covid vaccine reports. The MHRA should be judged on whether it can both learn honestly from where regulation has fallen short and give patients the confidence to benefit from where science takes us next.

The hon. Member for Frome and East Somerset (Anna Sabine) talked about clinical trials, and she also raised Bedrocan. Through the British embassy in The Hague, I am in active discussions about the bankruptcy of the company and about suitable alternatives, but I am conscious that there can be significant consequences if people with epilepsy switch medication, and I am sensitive to that.

A regulator succeeds ultimately because patients, their healthcare providers and the public have confidence in the quality and independence of its decisions. That is the standard that the Government expect from the MHRA, and we will continue to hold it to that standard. I again thank the right hon. Member for Tatton, my hon. Friend the Member for Blackley and Middleton South and all those who have contributed to this important debate.

10:58
Esther McVey Portrait Esther McVey
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank all Members who ensured that this debate happened and who spoke about the performance and failure of the MHRA, prompted by what happened to their constituents.

Time and again—not just today but over a long period—hon. Members have come to the House to raise concerns about the agency’s repeated failures and delays, and about the lack of transparency, independence, trust, teeth, oversight and scrutiny. It is time that action is taken. How many more times do hon. Members have to secure a debate, come to the House and point out the failures? I hope that all hon. Members here today have a further meeting with the Minister to ensure that he really does take the issue seriously. We do not want to be back here again talking about Primodos, surgical mesh, sodium valproate, the covid vaccines, antidepressants, the yellow card scheme, thalidomide and puberty blockers.

James Frith Portrait Mr Frith
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It was remiss of me not to answer the right hon. Lady’s question. I am happy to meet if the diary works for the planned date—otherwise a subsequent one will be found. I am very happy to give that commitment.

Esther McVey Portrait Esther McVey
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the Minister for that commitment.

What the public want is an organisation that can be relied upon to be in charge of the safety and efficacy of medicines and medical devices. As it stands, it cannot be.

Motion lapsed (Standing Order No. 10(6)).

Infrastructure and Housing Development: Faversham and Mid Kent

Tuesday 17th November 2026

(1 day, 9 hours ago)

Westminster Hall
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts

Westminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.

Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.

This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record

11:00
John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes (in the Chair)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I will call Helen Whately to move the motion. I will then call the Minister to respond. There will be no time for Back Bench speeches unless they have been cleared with both the Minister and the mover of the motion.

Helen Whately Portrait Helen Whately (Faversham and Mid Kent) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I beg to move,

That this House has considered infrastructure and proposed housing development in Faversham and Mid Kent constituency.

Kent is officially classified as in drought. In my constituency, we have had a hosepipe ban virtually all year round and multiple major water outages. Even now, as we head towards Christmas, we are still not allowed to wash a car or get out the hose to water the garden should we wish to. Water is being tankered along narrow country lanes round the clock—massive, heavily laden tankers that shake building foundations, damage the roads and keep people awake at night. That is just to keep water flowing through our taps. There is a new reservoir planned for Kent, but it will not be operational for a decade at the earliest. In short, there is not enough water in my constituency for existing residents. Yet there are another 20,000 new houses in the pipeline. To put that into perspective, that is the size of two Favershams.

Jim Shannon Portrait Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I commend the hon. Lady for bringing forward this issue. The issues that the hon. Lady referred to in her constituency of Faversham and Mid Kent are similar to those in Strangford, where chronic underinvestment in wastewater and sewerage infrastructure has left our network at capacity. Does the hon. Lady agree that the Government must make it a priority in their strategy for the future to ensure that water, sewerage and road infrastructure are properly funded and put in place before large-scale housing targets are imposed on local communities?

Helen Whately Portrait Helen Whately
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I completely agree with the hon. Gentleman. I was interested to see how he would bring his constituency into the question of infrastructure in Faversham and Mid Kent. However, he has made a point that I will be making in my speech about the importance of infrastructure not only being delivered but being delivered first and not lagging behind huge developments.

Those 20,000 new houses are parcelled up into five major developments. Nearly half of all those planned new houses—8,400—are part of the proposed new Highsted Park development. That development will extend across acres of farmland from Teynham and Tonge in the north, down to the rural villages and hamlets of Tunstall, Bredgar and Bexon to the south.

The development is currently awaiting the Secretary of State’s decision. That decision was called in two years ago by the Secretary of State at the request of my neighbour, my hon. Friend the Member for Sittingbourne and Sheppey (Kevin McKenna), just hours before the Swale planning committee was about to meet and make its decision. That took the decision away from elected councillors who know and truly care about this area, such as Councillor Julien Speed and Councillor Lloyd Bowen, the borough councillors for Teynham and Lynsted, who have been working hard with local parish councils and the Teynham and Highsted community action group to put the many problems of the Highsted Park development before a public inquiry.

To be clear, those problems are many: the thousands more cars on congested main roads and narrow country lanes, the serious shortages of GPs in local practices and overstretched local hospitals, the inadequate capacity of sewage networks and wastewater treatment works to cope with development on this scale, and the lack of drinking water. Of course, investment is promised as part of the development, but it would be inadequate if it even happens. Too often developers row back on such promises by arguing that their commitments made during the planning process are no longer viable.

In the summer my constituents took some reassurance from a clear statement by the then Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government, the right hon. Member for Streatham and Croydon North (Steve Reed), who told the BBC South East that new homes “will not be built” if the infrastructure to provide them with water is not in place. He was absolutely right. We cannot have a situation where more and more houses are built with less and less water to supply them. Will the Minister assure me that the former Housing Secretary’s statement will not be ignored when the decision is taken on Highsted Park? It is the Government’s opportunity to draw a line in the sand and make clear that water—the most critical element for survival after the air we breathe—must be guaranteed before any more major housing developments are built?

Another major development in my constituency is Heathlands: a proposal to build 5,000 houses in the countryside at Lenham Heath. It is sponsored by Homes England and Maidstone borough council. At a recent information evening, I asked them how an extra 5,000 houses would be supplied with water, given the recent acute shortages and in addition to supplying existing residents, and was told that South East Water had raised no objections at the time the local plan was put together, and that people would have to use less water. That is unrealistic and the equivalent of sticking our heads in the sand. People are not going to start suddenly using less water. I have been told that when new developments are built with lower water pressure to try to save water, people complain and take their own steps to increase water pressure. That so-called solution is not a solution at all; it could simply result in acute water shortages and misery for thousands of people.

Despite not being a statutory planning consultee, South East Water has made it clear that there is not enough water for the planned developments in the neighbouring borough of Tonbridge and Malling. That does not instil confidence that there is enough water for the major developments that have already received planning permission in my constituency, nor for 8,400 houses at Highsted Park or nearly 2,000 houses at Winterbourne Fields that still await a decision.

Unsurprisingly, people have had enough. Nearly 7,000 people signed my “Stop the sprawl” petition, which I took to No. 10 Downing Street. I am now conducting a survey on what people think about mass development and water shortages. Some 96% of those who have taken part say that the Government should stop large-scale developments until our water supply can be guaranteed. Respondents have said:

“It doesn’t really matter on our views…no one listens or takes them into consideration.”

“We are now threatened with a standpipe to supply water unless there is significant rainfall over winter.”

There is a clear argument that water companies should be statutory consultees in the planning process and be required to make a public statement on whether, and how, the water supply will be sufficient for a new development. I ask the Minister, who is kindly listening to my speech, to specifically address that question.

Kent is the garden of England, and we are famous for our fruit. Yet our farmers are being told to ration the amount of water they use. If it is a question of feeding the nation or building more houses in the driest part of the country we must surely prioritise food security. It is not just the acute lack of water, coupled with the more than 20,000 extra houses on the horizon in my constituency, that is a problem. Much of our infrastructure and many of our roads, healthcare and schools are already stretched almost to breaking point. Without major investment, they will simply not be able to manage with a significant population increase.

Another 2,500 houses with planning permission in south-east Faversham are known as the Duchy development. That development was meant to be contingent on a major road upgrade at Brenley Corner. Yet just 16 days after Swale borough council approved the Duchy development the Government abandoned those much-needed Brenley Corner road improvements. With thousands more homes in the pipeline for east Kent, there is no way that junction will cope. Spending hours in traffic jams looks like the inevitable consequence of the Government’s policy of continuing to push major housing developments on my constituency without the infrastructure to manage the population increase.

It gets worse. Maidstone borough council has approved 2,000 houses in Lidsing in my constituency, right next door to another 450 houses approved by Medway council at Gibraltar Farm. That will pile the pressure on local roads, healthcare and schools, as well as lose a much-loved green lung for the local community.

I appreciate that a future Kent and Medway strategic authority could take a more holistic approach to planning, but that is a long way off. In the meantime, we have major planning developments approved by different councils directly impacting each other. Kent county council has raised concerns about the development of 1,815 houses at Winterbourne Fields being too car-dependent, with good reason. It will be next to impossible to live in isolated greenfield developments without a car. Even if there are a couple of bus services, we are talking about rural bus services: do not expect a bus on a Sunday, for instance. Almost every house will have at least one, probably two, cars. Across the 20,000 houses in the pipeline in my constituency, that is 40,000 or so more cars on Kent’s roads.

To be clear, I am not against development; I know we need to build homes. Young people are having to live with parents for longer and longer because of the cost of housing. The problem is the massive scale of building planned on top of the many thousands of houses already built in my constituency in recent years, along with the failure of the planning system to consider the impact of all those developments in combination. Faversham and Mid Kent is situated in the heart of the garden of England. We are historically an agricultural area. We do not have the infrastructure to support this level of housing growth; nor will any of the infrastructure coming with these developments solve the problem.

I thank the Minister for listening this morning. My request to him is to take away what he has heard and have a long, hard look at all the levers the Government are using to push more housing into my constituency, from housing targets to decisions like the forthcoming one on Highsted Park, and pull those levers the other way until and unless the Government can come up with a plan to fix Kent’s gaping infrastructure gap.

11:12
Jim McMahon Portrait The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government (Jim McMahon)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir John. I congratulate the hon. Member for Faversham and Mid Kent (Helen Whately) on securing this debate. She will appreciate that I am unable to comment on her local development plan or individual planning applications in a constituency due to the role of Ministers in the planning system. I will therefore respond in more general terms to the points that she made.

I appreciate the strength of feeling about matters relating to housing in her constituency. The Government needed to act with ambition and urgency to tackle the acute and entrenched housing crisis in England, including by means of a bold overhaul of the planning system. We are delivering the most significant simplification in the planning system in a generation and cutting unnecessary bureaucracy to get Britain building again to deliver the homes and infrastructure that communities so badly need.

The new national planning policy framework, published in August, strengthened support for new and improved community facilities and public service infrastructure, including where they are required to support new development. The NPPF states that development plans should be,

“informed by an understanding of any existing deficits in the availability of community facilities and public service infrastructure, and additional requirements expected over the plan period, arising from proposed development and wider changes in the local population and public service provision”,

are accounted for.

Development plans should also set out facilities and contributions expected from development. The NPPF states,

“Authorities should attach considerable importance to providing for sufficient education facilities (including early years, school and post-16 provision)”—

and—

“all types of health care provision”

through their plan preparation. This should align with the needs of the local population and any wider requirements identified by the Government or public agencies. The NPPF is also clear that individual development proposals, which could give rise to a significant additional number of people in an area, should understand the needs of any associated improvements to community facilities and public service infrastructure, and provide for what is needed to make the scheme acceptable, whether by direct provision or contribution to offsite improvements.

Planning conditions and obligations should be used to secure the timely delivery of community facilities and the public service infrastructure required to support new development. We expect local planning authorities, developers and public service providers to collaborate in a positive and proactive manner to identify and resolve key planning issues before applications for community facilities and community infrastructure are submitted.

Helen Whately Portrait Helen Whately
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the Minister for responding to my speech. He is talking about the importance of infrastructure being taken into account in the planning system. As he will have heard me say earlier, it is quite clear that in my constituency we do not have enough water to meet the needs of the existing population, let alone the needs of potentially 20,000 more houses and all the people that such a development would entail. Can he assure me that, recognising both that shortage of water and the points he himself has made about the importance of infrastructure being provided alongside developments, there will not be this huge amount of new development in my constituency, when there is not enough water for it?

Jim McMahon Portrait Jim McMahon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The hon. Member pre-empts me, because I was just about to talk about water and the need to make sure that in that regard development and infrastructure go hand in hand. New homes cannot be considered in isolation from the infrastructure that makes communities work. That includes a secure water supply, adequate drainage and waste water capacity, protection from flooding and safeguards for the natural environment.

We have introduced a dedicated chapter on securing clean energy and water in the new NPFF to support the development and operation of water infrastructure that meets the needs of existing and future development. Our plan-making policies require early engagement between relevant plan-making authorities, water companies and other relevant partners, so that development plans are informed by a clear understanding of capacity and the future requirements for water infrastructure.

We have also introduced a new decision-making policy to support the delivery of water supply, drainage and waste water infrastructure, giving substantial weight to the benefits of improving capacity for existing users, in order to support growth, and improving water quality and reducing waterborne pollution. The water delivery taskforce has been established by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs to hold water companies to account for delivery, or lack of it, in their planned investments, and to ensure that the additional water supply and waste water capacity needed for growth are delivered hand in hand. To date, the task force has led work across Government, regulators and the water sector to overcome barriers where water scarcity issues have stalled development, such as in Oxford, in Cambridge and in north Sussex, unblocking the construction of tens of thousands of new homes.

The Government have also intervened in the west Kent region by inviting the former chief executive of South East Water to the water delivery taskforce in April this year to answer for the company’s lack of delivery. The Government have scrutinised the company’s performance and asked it to set out how it will support growth going forward, in order to improve resilience and to ensure that local plans and homes can be delivered. A dedicated subgroup containing key partners and officials from across Government meets on a regular basis to unlock constraints across South East Water’s operational area and to report back regularly to the water delivery taskforce.

I think the hon. Lady had a meeting with the Minister for Housing and Planning, my right hon. Friend the Member for Greenwich and Woolwich (Matthew Pennycook) , around 3 June. If there are any particular follow-ups she has after that meeting, I know that my right hon. Friend would be very pleased to meet her again to talk about those.

To conclude, I again congratulate the hon. Member on securing this important debate and thank her for outlining her views on this very important issue. The Government are committed to our target to deliver 1.5 million safe and decent homes during this Parliament. We know that that is a stretching target but it is essential to solve the housing crisis, to boost local economic growth and to support good jobs in every part of the country. I hope that this debate has assured Members that the Government remain committed to ensuring that the planning system delivers genuinely sustainable places in the way that she and other Members care about.

Question put and agreed to.

11:19
Sitting suspended.
[Dr Rosena Allin-Khan in the Chair]

The Economy: Impact of Hostile State Activity

Tuesday 17th November 2026

(1 day, 9 hours ago)

Westminster Hall
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts

Westminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.

Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.

This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record

14:30
Graeme Downie Portrait Graeme Downie (Dunfermline and Dollar) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I beg to move,

That this House has considered the impact of hostile-state activity on the economy.

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Dr Allin-Khan.

There is a tax being levied on this country right now and it is not in a payslip, His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs does not collect it, no Chancellor announced it, and nobody in the House has voted for it, but every business, taxpayer and public service is paying it. It is something I have called the “Putin tax” and the Government do not know how much it is. That is not a guess: I checked. In September, I asked how much Russia’s originating cyber-attacks cost the UK economy. I did get incident numbers, but no cost, and the numbers lumped every hostile state together so I could not even find what Russia’s share might be. I asked the question across Government and not one Department held an estimate of the cost of Russian attacks on the UK.

Working with my team in the office, we tried to do it ourselves and we published “The Putin Tax” report on 7 October. Our estimate is that the Putin tax is costing between £2 and £2.5 billion a year to the UK economy and that is a floor, not a ceiling. Let me be straight about the method we used, because I want the Minister to hear this from me: we took the Government’s figures that cyber-crime costs British business £14.7 billion a year and assumed Russia was behind roughly a tenth of that. We added the incidents that could be identified and verified by independent sources. That included the Leyton warehouse arson ordered by the Wagner Group, with around £1 million of damage; the investigation into drone activity around Lakenheath in 2024, costing more than £600,000 of police time; and we modelled the threats to our sub-sea cables. The estimates used are very rough and also very cautious, but that is not the whole story because it is not just my figure any more. Moody’s has now modelled what state-sponsored cyber activity could cost the UK economy and its finding was stark: in any given year there is a roughly one in 10 chance of a cyber-attack by Russian state-backed hackers costing UK business at least £4 billion.

Will Stone Portrait Will Stone (Swindon North) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My hon. Friend has highlighted perfectly that we are seeing an uptick in foreign interference and attacks on our democracy and civil institutions. Does he agree with me that prevention is part of the cure and we should be investing more resources in 101 information taskforces?

Graeme Downie Portrait Graeme Downie
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My hon. Friend is absolutely right: prevention is key to this, as well as making sure we have the capacity in our civil resilience to respond to the threats we are facing and making sure, and I will come to this later on, that the public are fully aware of the threats we face and what capabilities we need to respond to them.

We estimate that Russia accounts for as much as 80% of all losses from state-sponsored cyber threats—that was one of the other findings from Moody’s report—with ransomware by far the biggest driver. That works out at roughly £100 per taxpayer per attack per year. That is a very conservative number. Moody’s analysis counted only direct costs to business through downtime, recovery, ransoms and legal bills. It left out the hit to British GDP, public services and households, and it did not include physical attacks. It leaves out the criminal gangs operating from Russia that are not directly state-run. These are modelled scenarios, not forecasts, but a one in 10 chance of a £4 billion hit every single year is a risk that no Chancellor would ignore if it were a flood or a pandemic.

Now we have two estimates: one from me and one from a private, credible, modelling firm. Neither comes from Government and I think that should trouble us. The official figure for what hostile states cost Britain should come from the Treasury.

I took this report and its findings to the Prime Minister and asked him in the House to commit the Government to collecting this information and publishing it regularly, so the public would know what Putin’s aggression is costing them. He said:

“I agree with my hon. Friend about the importance of monitoring the data, and I will see what more we can do on that.” —[Official Report, 12 October 2026; Vol. 791, c. 46.]

That is a very good answer and I welcome it, and I feel the argument is beginning to be won. Indeed, last night in his speech to The Guildhall, the Prime Minister named Russia’s “campaign of disruption” and the weaponising of energy and supply chains as a key threat faced by the UK. At the UN in September, the Prime Minister said that the Kremlin spends about £1.3 billion a year manipulating information, and he promised a national resilience public awareness campaign—the fourth recommendation of my “Putin Tax Report”.

The Government know what Russia spends on attacking us and are preparing to tell the public about the threat; the one thing still missing is what those attacks are actually costing our economy. We measure the cost of floods and fraud, because the response costs money and we need to know whether that response is working. For hostile states, there is no equivalent.

Alex Easton Portrait Alex Easton (North Down) (Ind)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Does the hon. Member agree that we need a twin-track approach across the whole of the United Kingdom to strengthen business and economic resilience and protect our critical infrastructure and cyber-security from the damage that an attack can cause, and to use intelligence, diplomacy and sanctions to identify hostile states’ activities and make it more costly for those responsible?

Graeme Downie Portrait Graeme Downie
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I absolutely agree with the hon. Gentleman. A couple of months back, I held an event in Parliament with the ambassadors from Finland, Norway, Denmark and Estonia, all of whom talked about the importance of engaging businesses in conversations about how we defend the UK in cyber-space and elsewhere. Businesses are vital for disseminating information and building capacity with their employees, and will potentially be a target themselves. We must always guard against that.

Royal Mail and Advanced, the software supplier to the NHS, were both hit by ransomware gangs alleged to operate with the Kremlin’s tacit consent. International post was disrupted for weeks, NHS systems were down and thousands of appointments were lost. That must have had a cost, but we do not know what it was.

This is getting worse: MI5 has said that state threats now exceed terrorism, and its work on them has quadrupled. The National Cyber Security Centre dealt with 80 nationally significant incidents in the year to August, and its chief executive says that about three quarters of cyber incidents hitting our critical infrastructure are linked to hostile states. We call this “grey zone” or “sub-threshold”, but tell that to the business that lost a week of trading, the patient whose appointment was cancelled or the taxpayer paying for another police investigation. For them, there is nothing grey about it.

Russia is the most reckless hostile state, but it is not alone—take China, for example. In September, MI5 warned that more than 100 UK academics had worked on projects funded by an institute tied to China’s Ministry of State Security. The strategic intelligence firm Strider has identified more than 8,000 joint publications since 2020 between UK researchers and Chinese military-linked institutions in vital fields such as AI, quantum and aerospace. With Iran, the plots have moved to military sites: seven were arrested over RAF Fairford, and more than 50 arrests have been linked to Iran in a year. Every one of those costs money—in police, protection, and security at our bases. With North Korean IT workers applying for jobs at two major UK banks, a pharmaceutical firm and the civil service and sending more than 90% of their pay to Pyongyang, a British firm that hires one of them is bankrolling a weapons programme without knowing it. Space is the threat that nobody sees: UK Space Command says that Russia is jamming our satellites on a reasonably persistent basis. A Government-commissioned study put the cost of a major satellite navigation outage at about £1 billion a day. Those costs are currently invisible, and we must begin counting the actual cost to the UK economy each year.

Let me be specific about what needs to happen. This is fixable, and the Treasury will be delighted to know that most of it costs next to nothing. First of all, give it an owner. The Treasury sees every bill, so it should lead the method, working with the Cabinet Office, on attribution. Secondly, set a date for an annual assessment published to Parliament, starting with the Budget next year. Thirdly, use some of the information that we already collect and extrapolate into cost. For example, the NCSC sees these incidents; could it be asked to publish cost estimates alongside attribution? Fourthly, count the Defence bill. The Ministry of Defence should cost physical hostile activity, cable patrols and shadow fleet interceptions. Fifthly, make it an official statistic. The ONS should add questions to its business survey, the Home Office should extend its method for costing crime to costing state threats, and insurers should be asked to share claims data, with proper protections in place, of course.

Sixthly, and most importantly, as I mentioned in response to the intervention of the hon. Member for Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross (Jamie Stone), tell the public about this threat and what it is costing them. Finland, Estonia, Denmark and Norway have spoken plainly to their people about the threat and they are more resilient as a result. People will back preparedness when they see what it can do and what the costs are to them.

One of the great strengths of our democracy is that we are able to have open, transparent conversations with the public and build the trust that we will ultimately need if we should come under attack. Without using that strength of democracy, our opponents will exploit it and use it as a weakness to undermine confidence in the Government and other state actors as we try to convince the public of the need to defend themselves. They will only see that threat and give the Government the licence to respond effectively if they know what it is costing them and if we are honest and upfront about the fact that we are under threat from hostile actors every single day. Finally, the Treasury could invite the Office for Budget Responsibility to treat hostile state activity as a fiscal risk. It looked at geopolitical and cyber risk in 2022: it is perhaps time to look again.

I have three direct questions for the Minister: who in the Government will take forward the Prime Minister’s commitment, what is being collected and when can we see some of those first figures? In closing, Lord Sedwill said in Oslo last week that deterrence needs some “jeopardy for our adversaries”. He is right, but we cannot judge whether we are making Putin pay if we do not know what he is making us pay first.

Rosena Allin-Khan Portrait Dr Rosena Allin-Khan (in the Chair)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I remind Members to bob if they wish to be called in the debate.

14:41
Jim Shannon Portrait Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is always an absolute pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Allin-Khan and I thank you for being available for this debate. I congratulate the hon. Member for Dunfermline and Dollar (Graeme Downie) on securing what I believe to be a timely and critical debate.

I want to look at three things and focus on something that has happened in Northern Ireland and, indeed, in the hon. Member’s constituency as well. When we talk about the impact of hostile state activity on our economy, we rightly look at cyber-attacks on industry and the sabotage of undersea cables. I think of the undersea cables off the west of Ireland that go towards the United States. The protection is offered not by the Republic of Ireland because they do not have the ability, but by the United Kingdom’s Navy and security forces. Sometimes we need to have that relationship and we are always aware of the interference in our supply chains as well.

Across Northern Ireland, Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom, we have seen over the last month how digital and hybrid threats hit our communities in the most personal and devastating way imaginable—by targeting our children. Twice within the space of a single month—first on 19 October and again last Wednesday on 11 November—more than 300 schools across Northern Ireland received malicious bomb threat emails originating from outside the United Kingdom. To mention just three, in my Strangford constituency schools such as Victoria primary school and Londonderry primary school in Newtownards, as well as Grey Abbey primary school were caught up in that disgraceful campaign. Parents were worried sick for their children and panicked by the threats.

Every time there is a bomb threat we must take action and clear the schools to make sure our children are safe and not in any way threatened. At Victoria primary school in Newtownards, teachers had no choice but to evacuate young children out of their classrooms into the cold, walking them to a nearby church while police carried out the necessary searches. I think of disabled children in particular. Those with autism, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder or particular educational challenges were disorientated by having their day changed and had to face up to something that was alien to their very nature.

Let us be under no illusion about the human and economic toll of this issue. Think of those—I use this word all the time—wee children standing frightened in the cold. Think of the sheer panic felt by mothers and fathers who had to drop everything, leave their workplaces, race down to the schools and get their children at the gates not knowing if their sons or daughters were safe. The threat of bomb scares is something we became well aware of during the years of conflict in Northern Ireland. Think of the precious hours of education stolen from our young people and the productivity lost across every town and village when businesses, workplaces and emergency services are thrown into chaos. To have two such co-ordinated scares within a month is utterly unacceptable.

I declare an interest, having served in the Ulster Defence Regiment for three years and the Royal Artillery Territorial Army for 11 and a half years. Let me say this clearly: even in the darkest days of the troubles in Northern Ireland, primary school children were never targeted as they have been in the past month. Deliberately weaponising fear against innocent children in their classrooms crosses every line of human decency.

Although the Police Service of Northern Ireland and the education authority have confirmed that those emails were hoaxes, a hoax is not a harmless prank when it terrorises thousands of families, brings schools to a standstill and panics and worries parents. Whether those attacks originated from Russian actors, middle eastern groups, Iranian sources, republican sources or any other hostile state or proxy using artificial intelligence and overseas servers to sow division and disruption, Government must treat them with the utmost seriousness—they have done so on the previous two occasions and will do so again.

Our communities deserve answers. What is happening behind those co-ordinated attacks across the United Kingdom and Europe? Are our security forces and cyber-security agencies treating these threats against our schools as the national security priority that they clearly are? I should have welcomed the Minister to her place; I apologise for not doing so at the beginning, and I look forward to her response to our queries and concerns on behalf of our constituents.

Our economy relies on stability, security and a thriving next generation. Whether that threat comes from Moscow, the middle east or anywhere else on the globe, our children and their education must be protected by all means necessary. Only last Friday, the Microsoft failure highlighted our cyber-reliance. We need greater resilience and a self-contained cyber-system. I am minded of the seriousness of what happened on Friday: my office in Newtownards had no IT contact from about 8.30 in the morning, when the ladies come to the office, through to almost two o’clock. The Minister gave a good response yesterday in the Chamber, and it seems that the Government have a plan of action, but we need to know what that is, perhaps in advance.

Matt Western Portrait Matt Western (Warwick and Leamington) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The hon. Member is making some excellent points. I commend my hon. Friend the Member for Dunfermline and Dollar (Graeme Downie) for securing this debate. On the specific area of cyber-resilience, does the hon. Member think that legislation currently going through Parliament needs to be more ambitious, and to be widened beyond national infrastructure to space infrastructure and food security? Ten days ago across Europe, freezers were rendered useless by a cyber-attack. Does he agree we must have food security, logistics and production covered in that legislation?

Jim Shannon Portrait Jim Shannon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

On that specific incident of freezers across Europe, it is hard for me, as non-practical person who does not understand all of modern life, to grasp how that can happen—yet not only did it happen, it was the second or third time. We need to take action to create the resilience the hon. Gentleman referred to. I hope the Minister will give us some reassurance on that.

In Northern Ireland we have a porous border with the Republic of Ireland. That makes it easy for anti-United Kingdom spies or agents, or those who want to sow mischief and carry out hoaxes, probably financed by Russia, Iran or others. What is being done, Minister, to ensure that the Republic of Ireland border is not as porous as it seems to be at this moment in time? What is the relationship between the PSNI and the Garda Síochána? Is it a working relationship that can stop those involved in terrorism crossing over? Those are the particular circumstances that we have in Northern Ireland.

I will conclude by saying that between these attacks and the Government recommendations to stock the cupboards, Ministers have told us to be prepared. There is nothing wrong with that. It is the right thing to do; whether it is stocking foodstuffs, torches, bottles of water or whatever the case may be, it is good to have the recommendations that the Government have made and to follow them. However, families are frightened, and that is the position that I am speaking from today.

I believe that this House needs to be seen to be acting in the best interests of this United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. I say this with respect: thus far, confidence has not been inspired. I look to the Government and to the Minister in particular to step up to the mark and to reassure me, my constituents and all of us in Northern Ireland that we are prepared and ready for whatever the future may bring.

14:50
Luke Charters Portrait Mr Luke Charters (York Outer) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Allin-Khan.

I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Dunfermline and Dollar (Graeme Downie) for securing this debate. I believe that in the decades ahead, when scholars write about Britain’s readiness for conflict, they will think of the contributions he has made in this place and no doubt of the phrase he has coined, the “Putin tax.”

From the outset, I will be clear that I think we are discussing three types of hostile nation state activity today. First, of course, there is the most egregious form, in which a nation state actor directly targets Britain; the second is where a hostile nation state sponsors a non-state actor; and, thirdly, there is cyber-crime, which I will focus on.

Cyber-crime is an area I know well; my University of Chicago adviser, Professor Bob Pape, has written extensively about it. It is where a non-state actor operates in effectively a laissez-faire environment, whereby a nation state provides sanctuary or tolerates funding of, or recruitment by, international cyber-crime groups, or simply declines to act in the face of such groups. In the academic literature, that is called “passive sponsorship”, and we must focus on that. Therefore, we must also pay close attention to what I term the dandelion effect, whereby hostile nation states train international cyber-criminals, who then operate freely in cell-like structures. Moving on from this definitional pause, that is exactly where I will focus my remarks today.

When I was a member of the Public Accounts Committee, I was one of the lead members on an inquiry into cyber-resilience. A striking case was the chilling ransomware attack on Synnovis, which I believe you will know something about as well, Dr Allin-Khan. Synnovis is the NHS blood testing supplier for Guy’s and St Thomas’, the hospital just over the road from Parliament. Blood and specimen testing was disrupted, and more than 11,000 appointments were missed. That had a knock-on effect on blood cross-matching, leading to an urgent appeal for type O blood donations. In fact, I was struck by the comment by my hon. Friend the Member for Dunfermline and Dollar that there must have been a cost, but we did not know what it was. In the case of Synnovis, the cost may have well been a human life.

A key lesson from the Synnovis case is that hostile state and non-state actors will increasingly target public supply chains. Nothing is off limits, especially the health and safety of our constituents, and those state and non-state actors will always seek the lowest common denominator of vulnerability in the supply chain.

That is the area that I will turn to next. I was a Parliamentary Private Secretary in the Department for Business and Trade when it had the challenging job of working with MPs whose constituents had been impacted by the Jaguar Land Rover cyber-attack, in particular tier 2, tier 3 and tier 4 manufacturers. The Cyber Monitoring Centre said that attack cost the British economy between £1.6 billion and £2.1 billion—it even showed up in Bank of England forecasts—and called it the most expensive in British history “by some distance.”

I note with interest the comments by my hon. Friend the Member for Birmingham Selly Oak (Al Carns), the former Minister for the Armed Forces, who is here in Westminster Hall today. He has said:

“We know the Jaguar Land Rover attack was state-sponsored.”

When someone with such an outstanding record of service says that, we should take heed. Later I will touch on the role of Government in creating an open conversation with the public about the cost of cyber-risk to the British economy.

I also want to mention the recent attacks on Harrods, Co-op and Marks and Spencer. It was a really difficult time for M&S team members in the York Vangarde store in my constituency; there were issues with everything from the café to online ordering. No doubt the cost of those specific attacks amounted to over £1 billion. I mention them because hostile nation states or their proxies are evidently intent on targeting the great British high street itself and the brands that so many of us are familiar with such as Jaguar Land Rover, M&S Co-op.

With a similar modus operandi, criminals in Japan targeted a ransomware attack at Asahi—what an iconic Japanese beer that is. I mention that as an example of cyber-criminals working on behalf of a state-sponsored actor to target deliberately the core brands and institutions that are psychologically fundamental to the average citizen’s conception of the economy itself.

Matt Western Portrait Matt Western
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My hon. Friend is making a very good speech. I want to pick up his point about the businesses affected in 2025. Does he share my concern about the threat posed by the narrowing base of managed service providers to these sorts of companies? Does he agree that it presents a vulnerability in itself?

Luke Charters Portrait Mr Charters
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

When I think back to my time at the Financial Conduct Authority, where we were thinking about a similar concentration risk in the financial sector, I agree that that might well be an issue that the Government want to consider.

Hackers have deliberately and repeatedly targeted British companies that are not just critical pillars of our economy, but institutions and fundamental parts of the British way of life itself. These actors are attacking public services. There is the Synnovis example I mentioned, but there is also the Kido International incident, in which a ransomware gang attack targeted a London nursery company via phishing, and obtained personal data and photographs of more than 8,000 children.

What is next? Well, it is not good, I am afraid. I want to talk about the interlinkages between quantum compute, AI and cyber-crime. We are all now living in the age of AI and grappling with both its costs and its opportunities, but we are fast approaching the dawn of a post-quantum world. What does that mean? Private information could become readable, attackers could impersonate trusted organisations, and information stolen today could be read and decrypted later. Almost no secret may be safe.

The Rivest-Shamir-Adleman cryptosystem and elliptic-curve cryptography are the algorithms that underpin the entire security of the British economy, and quantum computing risks breaking the very security they rely on. Put simply, quantum compute means that traditional security keys can be cracked. Quantum key distribution, quantum cryptography and quantum decryption have been mentioned only in passing—just once in the Commons, according to Hansard.

A few weeks ago, with a visiting delegation of Canadian MPs, I had a briefing on quantum cryptography at the institute for safe autonomy at the University of York. Currently, quantum computers cannot break widely used cryptographic algorithms at scale—but soon, with enough cheap computing, the societal vulnerabilities and the economic risks to the economy will become enormous. Thankfully, the University of York is pioneering work on unbreakable quantum keys, which I am sure will go on to protect some of Britain’s most critical economic systems.

I do not want to turn this debate into a computer science lesson, but I ask the Minister whether the Government agree that we need to accelerate research and innovation funding for quantum cryptography. Thankfully, the NCSC has confirmed that it is pursuing post-quantum cryptography and quantum random number generators, but there is more to do. I will touch on the need to have a national conversation on defence and resilience, but does the Minister agree that we need to fortify the UK economy today, so that it is ready for the risks arising from quantum compute in the future?

Some estimates suggest that a first-generation machine capable of breaking RSA-2048 could cost hundreds of millions of pounds. Initially, such capabilities will be at the behest of only the most capable hostile nation state actors; yet, just as we are experiencing with frontier AI models, advances in mathematics and computing will reduce both the capital cost and number of qubits required. It is doubtful whether Moore’s law has such relevance to the cost per qubit, but over time we would expect that technology around quantum compute could end up in the hands of hostile nation state actors. It is my hope that in these short remarks today we might start a policy conversation in Parliament on how Britain prepares for the transition to a post-quantum world tomorrow—a conversation that foregrounds how we protect the cryptographic foundations of the British economy from hostile state actors who will no doubt be seeking to get their hands on this technology.

I will touch briefly on a related matter: the security of the UK’s internet connection itself. The then Defence Secretary, my right hon. Friend the Member for Rawmarsh and Conisbrough (John Healey), showed leadership typical of his tenure in his previous office when in April he revealed that our armed forces tracked Russian subs whose mission was to survey cables. I commend the Government’s risk review of critical undersea infrastructure security, and I welcome the new criminal penalties regime with broad territorial application. In particular, I praise the Government for being open with the public about the threat to deep sea cables.

As the consultation said, there is a risk of subsea cables being “tapped into” by hostile nation states such as Russia that seek what is known as sensing data that could compromise British national security. There are two main lessons from that. First, as the Government are rightly doing, we need to ensure that legislation keeps up with technological advancements. Secondly, in my view, the Government were right to take the decision in effect to declassify the files relating to the disruption of Russia’s month-long failed covert submarine operation.

Recommendation 26 in the strategic defence review calls for a national Government-led conversation on defence and resilience, so that people and businesses understand the risks, trust official advice, and are ready and not frightened in the event that essential services are disrupted. Ministers are therefore absolutely right that now is the time for openness with the British public about the level of threats we face from nation state actors. I for one welcome examples of that which move the conversation along. While of course balancing the risks around declassification of incidents, we should look for similar opportunities in future.

Let this, too, be a clarion call to the private sector to invest in cyber-security. I am reminded of what JP Morgan CEO, Jamie Dimon, said:

“For every pound JP Morgan saves through AI-driven productivity, much of it is likely to be spent on cyber-security”.

And let me add that I had written my speech before I heard about the outages affecting US banks yesterday.

From our weekly shop to our online clothes order, car service and blood matching, and even our children’s details at pre-school, we are all exposed to the risks of hostile cyber-activity. Those risks are unimaginably greater with the advent of AI, quantum computing and the risks to our critical undersea infrastructure. The hostile cyber-activity of nation states, non-state actors and cyber-criminals operating in permissive environments poses a threat to the British way of life itself. Debates like today’s support the aim of the SDR to have an open conversation with the public about those risks, and I commend hon. Members’ contributions today on this very important topic.

15:02
Al Carns Portrait Al Carns (Birmingham Selly Oak) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Dunfermline and Dollar (Graeme Downie) for bringing forward this really important debate and for his work in highlighting the cost of Russia’s activity to our economy.

It is worth taking a step back and looking at where we are today in the world situation. In the Pacific, there is a build-up of military capability unseen since the second world war—whether they be subsurface, surface, airborne, army or space capabilities, it is moving at a rapid rate. We see conflict right across the middle east: Saudi Arabia into Yemen, the Houthis into Saudi Arabia, and America and Israel into Iran. And here in Europe, right on the edge of the mother of all democracies, we see one of the biggest wars since the second world war, which has now cost 1.5 million casualties—more than America took in the entire second world war.

The implications of force on force and conflicts around the world are resulting in people trying to find weakness in democratic societies and to punish us for our support of the right to self-determination, particularly in Ukraine, as highlighted in the report by my hon. Friend. As they fail to undermine NATO, the Joint Expeditionary Force or democratic nations, they seek asymmetric or grey-zone tactics. Of those tactics, cyber-attacks alone cost £14.7 billion a year. That is 0.5% of our GDP.

If I say that to people in this room, they will absolutely understand it. If we were to say it to everybody across the country, it might get lost in translation. Will the Minister say how we are going to take some of these big, holistic figures and turn them into detail so that they resonate with the rank and file of the population from Scotland to Cornwall, and from London to Wales and Northern Ireland and back again?

Jim Shannon Portrait Jim Shannon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I mentioned this in my speech, but does the hon. and gallant Gentleman share the concern that I and others in the circles that I move in have about the meaning of the big three—President Trump, President Xi and President Putin? I know that there has to be dialogue and understanding, but we sometimes wonder whether the three biggest countries in the world, with perhaps the three biggest dictators—with great respect to the one from the United States of America—are positioning themselves to advance claims upon other parts of the world. Does the hon. Gentleman share that concern?

Al Carns Portrait Al Carns
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I do share that concern. In some cases, we are seeing the alignment of states that, in previous years, would have been far apart in everything from their theoretical view on democracy all the way through to their economies. When it is boiled down to a US or British perspective, we have to focus on what keeps us united: the right to self-determination, freedom of speech and the democratic principles that we have fought for for the last 70 years. Once they go, they are gone and we will not get them back, so we have to focus on what unites us, not on what separates us.

No attack of the sophistication and scale of the JLR attack is likely to have taken place without a state’s awareness. When that is materialised and drawn down, it is half the two-child benefit cap for the year. It is hundreds of thousands of children plunged into poverty because a non-state actor within a state has targeted one of our most treasured institutions.

Then we flip into business. I always say that we make 99% of the best products in the world and outsource 99% of the scaling, but unfortunately we are also the victim of industrial espionage. On average, £7 billion of business secrets are stolen from the country every year. How much does that affect the economy? How does that affect the supply chain? It would be useful to have that type of analysis from the Government to highlight some of the security issues that we face.

Then, of course, we have the hearts and minds of the nation, which is one of the most important things. From open-source information, we can see that during the war between America and Israel and Iran, certain targets were destroyed in Iran, which knocked out 3% of all Scottish independence media—it went black overnight. Now, why is Iran interested in supporting Scottish independence media? Because a nation that is divided along national, societal, religious or community lines is a nation that is weaker. The Government need to push to protect information—what is true and what is not—and look at where that influence is coming from.

Will Stone Portrait Will Stone
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My hon. Friend highlights some crucial points. I agree with him about foreign adversaries entering the grey zone and using asymmetric warfare against us. We absolutely have to have a conversation with the public. Does he agree that, as warfare evolves, we need to change how we respond to it? A deterrent is a deterrent only if our adversaries believe that we will actually do something.

Al Carns Portrait Al Carns
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I completely agree with my hon. Friend. We need to deter more forcefully. The united stance across the House on Ukraine is one of the things that I am proudest of in the last 10 years. We have led the world in supporting Ukraine. We need more of that, but we have to think about asymmetric threats, and particularly about how we impose cost should we be targeted in the future—indeed, we are probably being targeted right now.

Let me delve into a couple of the conflicts that are taking place. We could speak to the nation today and say, “Hey, the Black sea is closed”—one of the major transit routes for grain from Ukraine, the world’s food basket, has been closed for years—but where is the analysis of the impact? Because of the blockage of the Black sea, we have plunged collectively probably millions of people into poverty across sub-Saharan Africa and Asia, and increased food inflation, which was huge at the start of the invasion of Ukraine. Again, explicitly translating military action and crisis into economic impact would be very useful to highlight the issues that we are facing.

Thousands of ships have now been stopped from going in or out of the strait of Hormuz. What does that really mean? It means that a huge supply of ammonia can no longer come out of the strait of Hormuz. So what? Well, ammonia is a key component of fertiliser. That means that the planting season now, and the planting season next year, are going to be really bad. Combine that with the lack of grain through the Black sea and food costs are going to go through the roof—maybe not for the UK, which will be isolated from some of the impact, but it will hit food poverty all over southern elements of the Mediterranean and across the middle east. The same goes for methanol exports—that has a big impact on industry. Again, let us explain that, because we need this national conversation to help us understand why conflict overseas can affect us here in the United Kingdom.

When we talk in this House about conflict and international events and crises, there is an onus on us as politicians, on all sides of the House, to really try to translate what that means for every business, for the cost of living for every citizen in the United Kingdom, for our sanctity as a democracy, and for spending and the allocation of resources across Government.

I have a couple of questions for the Minister. First, the SDR mentioned a national conversation. When will it take place? As part of that conversation, will there be a yearly publication showing the cost to our economy of hybrid grey-zone conflict or other conflicts? It would be very useful to have that as a centrepiece of that national conversation. Secondly, is there any update on the development of the national centre for information defence? That is so important to protecting democracy, given Russia’s meddling in democratic parties here in the UK, with people turning up on Russia Today, all the way through to certain members of Reform in Wales getting 10 years in prison for taking Russian money.

15:11
Sarah Olney Portrait Sarah Olney (Richmond Park) (LD)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairpersonship, Dr Allin-Khan. I congratulate the hon. Member for Dunfermline and Dollar (Graeme Downie) on bringing such an important debate to Westminster Hall.

Threats to the UK from foreign states take many forms: espionage, foreign interference in our political system, sabotage, disinformation, cyber-operations and even assassinations. Just yesterday, the House of Lords National Resilience Committee issued a warning about the UK’s preparedness for escalating threats and emergencies. The UK is increasingly being targeted by state-backed actors, and it is vital that we have strong legislation to deal with those threats.

State-backed cyber threats show the danger of relying on hostile or unpredictable states for our critical national infrastructure. Recent suspected sabotage of undersea cables in the Baltics highlights the hybrid threats that we must prepare for. More directly, businesses feel the impact of the activity most directly through their energy bills. Russia’s illegal war in Ukraine has reinforced the need to significantly reduce the UK’s dependence on fossil fuels and invest in renewables, both to cut energy bills and to deliver energy security.

Last week’s Microsoft outage highlights the extent to which British businesses could be affected by hostile state activity. The outage exposed the severe national vulnerability created by our over-reliance on a single overseas technology provider across the NHS, policing, schools, courts, local councils, businesses and Parliament itself. Although our understanding is that the outage was not caused by a hostile state cyber-attack, it is nevertheless a stark warning of the potential impact of failures at major tech providers that the UK’s services rely on. If a technical failure can bring our frontline services to a standstill, just imagine the harm that a cyber-attack on the handful of overseas providers that the UK relies on could cause.

The Liberal Democrats are calling on the Government to develop a digital sovereignty strategy that puts security at its heart and supports British innovation and businesses. The Liberal Democrats tabled an amendment to the Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill that would have required the Government to publish such a strategy. It is concerning that the Government did not support it. We can no longer ignore the risks of over-reliance on American and Chinese technologies. Given the far-reaching consequences, from hospitals to schools and businesses, will the Government now back our call for a digital sovereignty strategy?

Have the Government undertaken impact assessments in the event of a failure of key software? What are they doing to support UK tech firms to develop domestic alternatives? The Liberal Democrats would ensure that critical national functions are powered by technology that the UK can actually control. It would involve trialling changes to the procurement of digital services. The Government are the UK’s largest buyer of technology, but they almost never buy British. The use of UK technology must be actively championed rather than treated as an afterthought. Currently, US and Chinese companies manage 90% of all global AI computers. By identifying high-risk foreign vendors and pivoting to trusted home-grown alternatives, the UK can gain greater strategic independence, bolster our national security and create high-skilled jobs at home.

The Liberal Democrats would explore tax incentives for small and medium-sized enterprises to adopt stronger cyber-security technology, especially those in strategically important supply chains. We urge the Government to take that action. The UK needs to reduce its economic dependency on China, given the Chinese Communist party’s increasingly arbitrary decisions, coercion tactics and human rights abuses. We would make the UK economy more resilient by reviewing preferential UK market access agreements with China, strengthening foreign direct investment screening and cyber-defences, and by including increased data transparency requirements.

We would also encourage greater diversification of UK trade, investment and supply chains, particularly with other democracies. We would cease research co-operation on technology with China and its companies and researchers if adequate reciprocity and transparency cannot be achieved. On energy, allowing Russian fossil fuels to be imported through third countries means Putin will keep profiting from selling Russia’s crude oil. The Government must implement a full ban on importing oil products derived from Russian crude, as they originally said they would.

The Liberal Democrats are calling for a complete ban on UK companies providing maritime services, such as insurance, for Russia’s fossil fuel exports, and instead investing in home-grown renewable energy to improve our energy security, which can only be a good thing for our businesses and households. Even on the individual level, hostile state actors can pinpoint people living in the UK and target their bank accounts. Victims of transnational repression can have their bank accounts frozen by foreign Governments, imposing incredible financial hardship on them. Over the last few years I have picked up bits of individual casework from my constituents, particularly those who have come here from Iran and Hong Kong, who continue to suffer considerably from transnational state repression. I urge the Government to work closely with our policing services and set up a hotline for transnational repression to ensure the victims can receive the specialist assistance that they often lack when reaching out to neighbourhood policing services, who fail to appreciate the significance of transnational repression.

We live in a more dangerous and less stable world. We must work with our allies to protect our national security and our businesses by building robust frameworks. With our next UK-EU summit just days away, we call on the Government to establish a growth and defence partnership with Europe, including joining the single market, forming a new UK-EU customs union and agreeing a new defence pact.

15:17
John Cooper Portrait John Cooper (Dumfries and Galloway) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I apologise for my throat, Dr Allin-Khan. I think it might have been hacked by foreign actors. I congratulate the hon. Member for Dunfermline and Dollar (Graeme Downie) on securing a debate on such an important issue.

The book “The New Economic Warfare” contains a chapter on economic aggression, which is apposite. Remarkably, it was written in 1941 and appeared in 1942—nothing new under the sun, then. Although the players and methodology might have changed, the perils remain the same.

Such was the consternation of the then Business and Trade Committee when it considered British economic security and how to steel ourselves against foreign interference, it recommended nothing less than the creation of a dedicated economic security Minister armed with an overarching economic security Bill. I was a member of that Committee when those recommendations were issued earlier this year, but they have not been accepted by the Government. Given what we have heard today, perhaps the Economic Secretary might give us a clue as to whether the Government might revisit that Select Committee report. After all, the so-called Putin tax is estimated at around £2.5 billion, as we have heard, which is likely an underestimate. It is money we can ill afford. It would be better spent on myriad other areas. This slow drain is designed to weaken us, to bleed us out and sap our resilience. The Jaguar Land Rover hack put a 0.17% dent in GDP, making it the worst such attack so far. Mystery surrounds the people behind such interference; the euphemism is often “foreign state actors”.

The Business and Trade Committee accepted evidence that the latest iterations of the hacking threat sees hostile state actors—whoever they may be—form an unholy alliance with highly organised criminal gangs. These shadowy state actors order the cyber-bullets and identify their targets, and the criminals make the bullets and fire them. It is also clear that much public risk is in private hands. Commercial companies are out there in a danger zone. Their so-called threat surface is vast. Is sufficient help being given to them?

A recent headline read “GCHQ warns companies after cyber-attack”—“after” being the key word. “After” is the runway behind the aircraft, not in front. It is useless. Firms with tight margins must purchase and update security software and are not even obliged to report to the Government should they fall victim to an attack. Of course, stigma may play a role in firms not wanting to admit a breach, and the Government ought to help ameliorate that.

There is also no coherent approach to the response to attacks. Some firms appear to have paid ransoms, while others have held out. An example of the latter seems to have been the Co-op, which hammered down its own systems and returned to pen and paper in a bid to defeat hackers. I liken their approach to a surgeon removing a patient’s diseased limb: painful, maiming, but necessary. Either way, companies must pay up or pay out to their detriment. Military electrical equipment is often hardened against the electromagnetic pulse emitted by a nuclear weapon. That prevents the equipment being fried by the electrical spectrum from such a weapon.

We have heard today from many hon. Members about some of the problems we face. The hon. Member for Strangford (Jim Shannon) made the relevant point that a hoax alone is sufficient to cause absolute chaos, and an actual bomb is not needed. The hon. Member for York Outer (Mr Charters) referenced quantum and the rising threat that poses. Meanwhile, the hon. and gallant Member for Birmingham Selly Oak (Al Carns) was concerned that what we are talking about may be lost in translation if we talk to the public. I gently say to him that his Aberdeen lilt is not that difficult to understand, but on a serious point, we need to inform the public about the dangers we face.

Does this not indicate that we ought to be hardening our economy against the shock of hostile state activity? What are the Government doing to shield our economy, which is the very lifeblood of Britain? General Sun Tzu advocated “winning without fighting”. Our adversaries know that cyber-attacks offer deniability and the very real chance of victory without firing a shot.

The old adage was that no country is more than three missed meals from revolution; now we may be no more than three failed attempts to pay by chip and pin away from surrender. Why send in tanks when our enemies can cripple our ability to buy food or fuel by attacking banking?

We know in the information war that shaping attacks are well underway. As the hon. and gallant Member for Birmingham Selly Oak said, when American and Israeli bombs shattered Iranian command and control bunkers, a series of social media activists agitating for Scottish independence fell silent on platforms such as X. These are the so-called sock-puppet accounts for Tehran’s monotheocracy, which seek to weaken Britain by amplifying the separatist narrative and using the nationalist threat to weaken Britain from within.

China knows it can outpace and outmuscle us on the economic front. The UK’s weak safeguards against Chinese subsidies for its industries are a risk acknowledged by this Government but—perhaps feeding the Chinese dragon in the hopes it will immolate us last—they do not set out triggers for escalation, defined response options or the consequences that hostile actors should expect.

On this, as with so many other areas of hostile activity, we remain reactive, lacking focus on deterrence before interference occurs. Is the way to protect our economy not to resist external interference and draw together this Government’s unsatisfactory, piecemeal defences under that Minister of economic security, allied to an MOD funded and resourced for the modern era?

Should we be sharing intelligence with companies on the frontline of this new grey-zone war? Should a cross-Government security Minister not lead on everything from the physical security of our underwater infrastructure, such as data cables, to cyber-threats and economic coercion, such as the dumping of artificially subsidised goods and products, including steel?

Only the Conservatives have a fully funded plan to increase spending to 3% of GDP by 2030. All taxes linger and ratchet one way—upwards, ever upwards. This so-called Putin tax will be no different, and we face a Beijing surcharge on top of that. National security must come before social security. A threat to our whole society demands a response from the whole of society. Government must lead. The public are paying up; when will this Government step up?

15:24
Lucy Rigby Portrait The Economic Secretary to the Treasury (Lucy Rigby)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Allin-Khan. I thank hon. Members for their contributions, and my hon. Friend the Member for Dunfermline and Dollar (Graeme Downie) for securing the debate and for highlighting his report. It is fair to say that the issues raised by hon. Members in this debate go right to the heart of our national security for the reasons they covered very well, and which I will also discuss.

Let me be very clear: the report makes an important contribution to our understanding of the economic consequences of hostile state activity. I am glad that my hon. Friend the Member for Dunfermline and Dollar highlighted the Prime Minister’s words both in reply to the report and at the Guildhall last night. If my hon. Friend had not highlighted them, I would have done so.

The central argument of the report is powerful: that Russia’s aggression imposes on this country not simply a security cost but an economic cost that is borne by British taxpayers, British businesses and British public services. It is clear that Russia’s hostile activity, from cyber-attacks on our institutions to sabotage on our streets, imposes significant costs. The report estimates that the Putin tax costs the UK £2 billion to £2.5 billion each year and that confirmed incidents alone have generated £1.6 billion to £2.1 billion of economic losses, and argues that the true cost is even higher than those figures.

I think we all acknowledge that the economic consequences of hostile activity do not step at the immediate cost of repairing the damage caused by an attack. They of course also include the costs of disruption to production and supply chains, of recovery and of spending by businesses and Government on increasing resilience. There are also wider economic consequences when services that people rely on—some of which have been well highlighted in this debate—are disrupted. That demonstrates why economic security and national security can no longer be considered in isolation of each other.

Preparing for the world as it may turn out to be is critically important. The hon. Member for Strangford (Jim Shannon) made that point well, including the importance of stability and certainty to economic growth. That is exactly why we are making the biggest sustained increase in defence spending since the end of the cold war. As hon. Members know, with our NATO allies we have committed to spend 5% of GDP on defence and national security by 2035, including investment in cyber-resilience and infrastructure resilience to protect our economy from exactly the type of threats discussed in this debate.

We are also responding directly and enforcing the toughest ever sanctions on Russia. We are cracking down on those who help the Kremlin to evade those sanctions. Our co-ordinated sanctions action with international allies has deprived Russia of $495 billion to date, and of access to weapons and equipment. The impact of sanctions is clearly seen in Russia’s weakening financial standing: growth has stalled, interest rates remain high, the rouble is significantly depreciated, and the federal budget is expected to remain in deficit throughout this year.

However, sanctions are only part of our response. As multiple members of the Government have made clear, there is absolutely no place for Russian illicit finance in the UK. The hon. Member for North Down (Alex Easton) alluded to that in his valid points around making it more difficult and costly for hostile states to undertake their activity. That is why we are going after the money laundering networks, which have all sorts of complex structures, and the professional enablers that allow sanctioned actors, and others, to hide and move their money. Our new anti-money laundering and asset recovery strategy, which is backed by over £550 million of investment over the next three years, will strengthen the capability of financial intelligence and law enforcement services to target those networks at home.

Part of deterring Russia is of course ensuring that we are at the frontline of European and NATO security. It is important to mention that our support for Ukraine is critical, as has rightly been highlighted during this debate. Russia remains the most acute threat to our national security and the security of our continent. Our economic pressure on Russia and our financial support to Ukraine remain the best policy to support Ukraine and bring Russia to the negotiating table.

It is important to underline that the UK has a broad toolkit to deter, disrupt and respond to hostile state activity, supported by economic security measures including investment screening, export controls and procurement powers. We continue to take action to strengthen our economic security and resilience as all the threats that we are talking about evolve, working closely with regulators, including those in the financial system, as well as businesses and international partners.

Multiple hon. Members have raised the importance of resilience right across our economy and, as they would expect, that is a top priority for the Government. We are continuing to urge all organisations to take action and follow the expert guidance of the National Cyber Security Centre and the National Protective Security Authority. My hon. Friend the Member for York Outer (Mr Charters) made the case very well to follow that guidance and ensure that each business is fully aware of the risks and the importance of resilience.

With regard to the recommendation in the report for the NCSC to publish annual assessments, it publishes an annual assessment of the cyber threat, which includes activity attributed or linked to state and state-aligned actors. The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport and the former Department for Science, Innovation and Technology published the cyber-security breaches survey in April, and that research into UK cyber-resilience includes the cost to the economy, as my hon. Friend the Member for Dunfermline and Dollar is no doubt aware.

The shadow Minister, the hon. Member for Dumfries and Galloway (John Cooper), rightly raised the importance of the resilience of our financial system, which goes right to the heart of my brief as Economic Secretary. Working with the Bank and the Financial Conduct Authority, we are strengthening the cyber-resilience of our financial system so that hostile states cannot undermine the stability on which every single business and household in this country depends. We are taking forward designations under the critical third parties regime. To the point made by the hon. Member for Richmond Park (Sarah Olney), we have recently—not that recently, actually; it was a few months ago now—designated Microsoft, and it is really important that we continue to keep under review the designations that we have under that critical third parties legislation, because it is a very important tool in our armoury.

The issues that we are discussing today obviously go right across the economy and are not isolated to any one sector. The cyber-security and resilience Bill, as has been raised, will increase UK defences against cyber-attacks to protect the services that the public rely on to go about their normal lives. That Bill will deliver a step change in the UK’s national security, making essential and digital services more secure in the face of cyber-criminals and state actors who will use every tool in their armouries to disrupt our way of life.

Jim Shannon Portrait Jim Shannon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the Minister very much for those answers, and I commend her for everything she has said. In my contribution, I mentioned that the border between the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland is porous, so people are able to filter through—for example, actors from enemy states. We need to have a working relationship; we cannot do these things on our own. We are part of NATO, and although the Republic of Ireland is not, of course, there has to be a working relationship. Can the Minister give us some idea of how that relationship can be built and secured to the Republic of Ireland’s benefit as well as ours?

Lucy Rigby Portrait Lucy Rigby
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am grateful to the hon. Member for raising that issue. Clearly, we need to make sure that all the measures we are talking about—indeed, all the measures that are to come—protect every single element of our country, including the border to which he refers. I appreciate that there is a strong economic underpinning to this issue; there is also a strong security underpinning. To the extent that I do not cover his question, I will ensure that the Security Minister or the right person in the Home Office addresses him in writing.

The hon. Member also raised an important point about school hoaxes. I will seek to get him an answer to that as well, as I appreciate just how disruptive that activity can be. Clearly, as a Government, we need to make every effort to protect people from it.

My hon. Friends the Members for Warwick and Leamington (Matt Western) and for York Outer raised a critical issue: specific sectors affected by recent cyber-incidents, some being core services and indeed core brands. It is important to recognise the psychological impact of that as well as the disruptive nature. I am deliberately skipping forward in the interests of time, which I think I may be limited on. If you need to, Dr Allin-Khan, I am sure you will give me an idea.

Lucy Rigby Portrait Lucy Rigby
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Okay, let me talk a bit then about the AI aspects of the issue. At the Budget, the Government provided an additional £150 million to address AI-enabled cyber-risks, alongside a further £120 million for the AI Security Institute to strengthen its testing and research and to develop technical standards.

My hon. Friend the Member for York Outer raised the issue of quantum. I spent yesterday morning at Barclays, discussing the important migration to post-quantum cryptography. As my hon. Friend will know, that needs to start at least by 2028, and then be completed gradually by the target date of 2035. Quantum is a huge—gargantuan, actually—growth opportunity for the UK, particularly for financial services, but as my hon. Friend alluded to, it also poses really significant risks to the sector, especially combined with AI and technologies like tokenisation. From a Government and a regulatory point of view, we need to ensure that, while seeking the benefits of these new technologies, the entirety of our economy is resilient to those risks.

Luke Charters Portrait Mr Charters
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the Minister for that, because it is important that Ministers across His Majesty’s Government follow the recommendations in the SDR and, exactly as she is showing leadership in today, use their ministerial roles across Whitehall to spark a national conversation. I encourage the Minister to keep bringing the financial services sector and regulators around the table to discuss the post-quantum world.

Lucy Rigby Portrait Lucy Rigby
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I hope it is reassuring for my hon. Friend to hear that present at yesterday morning’s roundtable were the Bank, regulators and really senior representation from across the financial services sector. There is a real emphasis on making sure that our economy is sufficiently prepared for quantum technology to maximise the benefits—the UK is a leader in quantum—and take account of the risks.

My hon. Friend the Member for Dunfermline and Dollar asked me about quantification and specific work on other recommendations in the report. Although we are looking carefully at the evidence and analysis in the report, alongside wider evidence available to Government, quantifying the full economic impact of hostile-state activity is, as my hon. Friend will appreciate, inherently complex. I am told we do not currently plan to publish a stand-alone Government estimate for national security reasons, but we will continue to assess those impacts as part of our wider work to understand and respond to the threat.

Graeme Downie Portrait Graeme Downie
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Earlier on, the Minister mentioned that reports are already gathered by the National Cyber Security Centre and DCMS that quantify the number of incidents. Can she work with those Departments to do more to put in a range of costs that they come across in those incidents? I appreciate the difficulty of coming up with a single figure but if, when we are dealing with incidents, we can also come up with a range of costs, that will at least give people an indication of the type of cost we are talking about.

Lucy Rigby Portrait Lucy Rigby
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am more than happy to see what can be done in relation to my hon. Friend’s question, within the remits of what is considered secure. I will certainly take that away because I understand his wider point.

On the report’s recommendation to launch a national public awareness campaign, helping the public prepare for emergencies is, of course, central to building a more resilient country. As hon. Members know, we have launched a Be Ready campaign to raise awareness of the simple steps that households can take to ensure that they are prepared for everyday emergencies, such as severe storms or flooding. Some of the steps highlighted within that campaign relate to other preparedness issues that we are discussing today.

My hon. and gallant Friend the Member for Birmingham Selly Oak (Al Carns) raised a number of specific questions that, as I think he knows, are outside the scope of my brief. I shall not seek to answer them from this position for fear of answering them wrongly, but I will ensure that he receives the written answers that his questions fully deserve. The hon. Member for Richmond Park raised an important question about transnational repression and having a register. In the same vein, that is well outside the scope of my brief, I am afraid, so I cannot give her an answer today that she will consider in any way informative. I promise that I will take her question away and ensure that she receives a substantive answer.

In summing up, I reiterate how grateful I am to my hon. Friend the Member for Dunfermline and Dollar for raising the report and, indeed, to all hon. Members for their contributions on these important issues.

15:42
Graeme Downie Portrait Graeme Downie
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the Minister for her response and all hon. Members for participating in the debate. The hon. Member for Strangford (Jim Shannon) and my hon. Friend the Member for York Outer (Mr Charters) both illustrated well that anything that has an economic cost also has a human cost. Schools in my area were also affected by the hoax that the hon. Member for Strangford referred to. My hon. Friend the Member for Warwick and Leamington (Matt Western) also talked about the relevance of food security. That cyber-attack had an economic cost but will ultimately have affected people as well.

Recently in my constituency, people who work in the defence sector have seen their homes targeted with intimidation. If that has the effect of putting people off working in those industries or of intimidating them, that has not only a human cost but an impact on the UK’s industrial capacity. We are seeing these attacks that look economic, but we also have spill-over attacks, as the Minister acknowledged.

I thank all hon. Members for their participation. This issue will not reduce—in fact, I suspect it will continue to escalate over the years, as we see attacks by Vladimir Putin and others continue to work on our economy, society and information spaces. I am also sure that this will not be the last time I raise these issues in the House.

Question put and agreed to. 

Resolved,

That this House has considered the impact of hostile-state activity on the economy.

15:44
Sitting suspended.

Wales: Prisons and Sentencing

Tuesday 17th November 2026

(1 day, 9 hours ago)

Westminster Hall
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts

Westminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.

Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.

This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record

[Relevant document: Second Report of the Welsh Affairs Committee, Jagged Justice: Prisons, Probation and Rehabilitation in Wales, HC 137]
16:00
Rosena Allin-Khan Portrait Dr Rosena Allin-Khan (in the Chair)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I remind hon. Members that they may make a speech only with the prior permission of the Member in charge of the debate and the Minister. There will not be an opportunity for the Member in charge to wind up, as is the convention for 30-minute debates. I call Liz Saville Roberts to move the motion.

Liz Saville Roberts Portrait Liz Saville Roberts (Dwyfor Meirionnydd) (PC)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I beg to move,

That this House has considered prisons and sentencing in Wales.

Diolch yn fawr iawn. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Dr Allin-Khan.

It is that time of year again when Cardiff University’s Wales Governance Centre publishes its annual fact file on prisons and sentencing in Wales. As Plaid Cymru’s justice spokesperson at Westminster for over a decade now, I recognise the massive gap in knowledge and understanding of the reality of criminal justice in Wales. I firmly believe that we all owe a debt of gratitude to Dr Rob Jones for the work he has done since 2018 both to reveal the scale of our ignorance and to endeavour to remedy it.

The justice system and crime affect all of us, some directly and some indirectly. That is why understanding the failings and successes of rehabilitation in Wales is so crucial. Let us start at the sentencing level in Wales. We all know that court cases are stacking up. While English Crown Court waiting times have been longer than in Wales since 2016, none the less the number of outstanding cases rose by 9% last year, and 16% in magistrates courts.

While the Government tinker around the edges of court reform, taking away long-held rights to jury trial, they have failed to tackle the real issues, like the late delivery of prisoners to court, affecting all six court circuits in England and Wales, according to the Bar Council, with nearly a quarter of those delays lasting over five hours. Barristers on the Wales and Chester circuits tell of murder trials where prisoners arrived on time only once or twice out of 60 days of trial. Why do the Government tolerate that normalisation of delay? Surely work should be done to address that area.

Black defendants are more likely to be remanded in custody than white defendants, with an over nine months longer average custodial length. That is an issue entrenched in the justice system across Wales. Recent south Wales police figures show that 24% of people selected for facial recognition checks last year were ethnic minorities, despite making up only 7% of the area’s population.

The unavoidable fact is that people from black ethnic groups are the most represented ethnic group in prison, with 58 black people from Wales in prison for every 10,000 people in the population, compared with only 15 white people. That cries out for action, especially as the Home Secretary has blocked the Sentencing Council from at least recognising that that is a justice problem.

I am sad to say that Wales has a women problem, too. The number of immediate custodial sentences handed to women in Welsh courts increased by 27% last year, with one in four given sentences of up to one month or less. Shockingly in my patch of north Wales, 63% of women sentenced to immediate custody at magistrates courts received a sentence of a month or less, much higher than in the rest of Wales.

Those women, nearly two in five of whom had committed petty offences of theft from shops, were sent far away from home, across the 12 women’s prisons in England, predominantly to His Majesty’s Prison Eastwood Park in Gloucestershire or HMP Styal in Cheshire. That is despite the plethora of evidence against the use of that type of sentence. We have received such evidence for years.

Next year marks 20 years since the publication of the Corston report into the experience of women in prison. While successive Governments have accepted its recommendations, sadly the data tells us eloquently that so far nothing has changed. Meanwhile, this Labour Government have essentially abandoned plans for a residential women’s centre in Swansea, which was supposed to have been the start of a residential solution for Wales. Now we have been informed that it is not moving ahead, because the funding for it is not there. I ask whether the Minister is in a position to reconsider that decision, because it is clear that a trauma-informed alternative to custody for women in Wales is urgently needed.

Even without a women’s prison, Wales has recorded a higher “in-country” imprisonment rate than England in every year since 2019. Last year, there were 155 Welsh people per 100,000 of the population in prison, compared with 138 in England. When faced with those figures, the Government cannot say that the status quo works for Wales, and while the rate of imprisonment in Wales has been rising, we have lost 100,000 years of cumulative prison officer experience since 2010. In fact, the report by the Welsh Affairs Committee into justice in Wales found that population pressures, coupled with chronic staffing challenges, have

“undermined staff and prisoner safety and the effectiveness of rehabilitation work.”

Those pressures do not come from nowhere; the impact of years of Tory underfunding is evident. But the Labour Government cannot continue to pass the buck indefinitely; responsibility now lies with them.

The UK Government continue to underfund services in the public estate delivered by the Welsh Government, with no changes to the funding for prison health since 2014, which again was highlighted in the report by the Welsh Affairs Committee. That fact needs to be reiterated if we are to improve prisoner health in the public estate in Wales—prison health funding has remained the same for 12 years. That is extraordinary. Given that many of the 1,777 English prisoners held in Wales would likely receive that devolved support, it is even more egregious that the UK Government are cutting these corners.

Forgetting the Welsh context comes easily in Westminster, including the fact that some prisoners actually speak Welsh. We know from Dr Rob Jones and Dr Gregory Davies that Welsh-speaking prisoners in HMP Berwyn have faced significant barriers, to the point that the Welsh Language Commissioner undertook a statutory inquiry into His Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service’s Welsh language scheme. I reiterate the commissioner’s call, and that of the Thomas commission years ago, that all justice bodies should be subject to the Welsh language measures of 2011. This is not a corner that should be cut in Wales.

Sadly, we have come to realise that cutting corners is a common theme in prisons. Over a decade since privatisation, there are billions of pounds worth of maintenance backlogs, and the chief inspector of prisons has warned of

“deteriorating infrastructure and long delays to essential maintenance in prisons.”

The legacy of outsourcing is squalor, but where is Labour’s action to insource those contracts, and tackle the crumbling and vermin-infested prison estate? Sometimes when we talk about prisons, it feels like we are engaging in hyperbole, but it is all true. When I say “vermin-infested”, I mean “vermin-infested.” Surely in the 21st century, that can be remedied.

I declare an interest because I am the chair of the all-party parliamentary group on justice unions, and six justice unions—the Prison Officers Association, Napo, the Public and Commercial Services Union, the University and College Union, the Royal College of Nursing and the Police Federation—have called for a royal commission into prisons and the wider criminal justice system, to work out what has gone wrong, whose fault it was and is, and how to fix it. Having such a royal commission was a promise made by the last Government, but it was never delivered. When we face a problem as serious as the prisons crisis, surely we need a serious commitment to seek a solution, such as would be implicit in a royal commission?

Jim Shannon Portrait Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I commend the right hon. Lady for bringing this matter forward; every time she secures a debate on it, I always come along to support her. I am here again today to support her in her quest.

It has been highlighted that probation staff in Wales are stretched to the limit and that without urgent investment the service will be overwhelmed. By the way, in Northern Ireland we have similar concerns about the retention of social work staff and the loss of experienced staff, which of course can affect the capacity of probation officers to manage their increasingly complex caseload. Does the right hon. Lady agree that the Minister needs to take steps to strengthen the capacity of probation boards across the UK and improve staff retention? The public should be assured that offenders are supervised effectively while also receiving the support they need to rehabilitate successfully.

Liz Saville Roberts Portrait Liz Saville Roberts
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The significance of probation is evident in rehabilitation. I will touch on the details in relation to Wales, but this is a common issue across the nations of the United Kingdom. Of course, Northern Ireland and Scotland have their own justice systems. Wales is part of England’s, but it is unique because many of the services that are integral to rehabilitation are devolved. That is why it is important that we tease out how things are different and how best practice can operate.

When people continue their sentences after leaving prison, the rehabilitative element of criminal justice plays out. I am sad to say that the data for Wales does not make for light reading. Last year, for the fourth consecutive year, the number of people rough sleeping on release increased, this time by 24%. Two in five prisoners from HMP Cardiff alone were released without a fixed address in the year up to March. That worsening trend cannot just be brushed off. Housing is one of the critical first steps, if not the critical step, for rehabilitation, and homelessness is a risk factor for death after release, according to Nacro. Dying in a drug-related incident immediately post release is noted as a particular risk, so it is even more concerning that drug poisoning accounted for 37% of all deaths among prison leavers supervised in the community in Wales in 2024-25, compared with 21% across England and Wales as a whole.

Wales faces distinct challenges, as health and housing policy are devolved. This is another example of where the jagged edge does damage, as the Welsh Government have to contend with whatever criminal justice policy decisions Westminster sends downstream, but they have no control over them. One of the challenges sent downstream is the Sentencing Act 2026. Placing significant added pressure on an already strained probation service without adequate investment is a recipe for disaster, especially without a workload management tool to quantify the extra workload for probation officers.

Sadly, I am sure the Government could not have been shocked when Napo-affiliated probation staff successfully balloted for industrial action last week. Even working to contract will have far-reaching consequences across the whole arc of justice services. I do not want to ask the question, but how prepared is the Minister for the circumstances? As I say, it will play out across the whole of the justice system.

The Justice Secretary said that

“we have to build a new criminal justice system.” —[Official Report, 1 September 2026; Vol. 790, c. 86.]

But to do that we need to pull the right levers and be in possession of the right tools. We need a royal commission to look at the entirety of the criminal justice system, including our prisons. We need full effective funding across the system, its sites and its workforces. As Dr Rob Jones, the author of the Cardiff University report, sets out, the Wales-specific data should make the UK Government assess whether the devolution settlement is adequate, whether it is fit for purpose, and whether the Welsh Government have the powers and policy levers they need to address the underlying causes of these problems.

Before the Minister says this—I suspect it may be in her response—memorandums of understanding are political fig leaves. They cannot conceal the fact that only fully powered devolution, with clarity of funding and clarity of responsibility, can smooth over the jagged edge. We need a better devolution deal for Wales. In a meeting with Welsh Ministers, the Justice Secretary suggested that the “potential is high” on the devolution of justice. Will the Minister assure me that Wales can expect that to be realised in the Prime Minister’s upcoming 10-year devolution plan?

We await news from the independent review of prisons and Lord Hogan-Howe’s review of police force structures, but that is just the first step in the criminal justice journey. This is an opportunity to respond decisively to the data in front of us. As somebody else said, approximately, when the facts demand change, we change our minds. When are we going to change our minds over justice in Wales?

16:14
Catherine McKinnell Portrait The Minister for Prisons, Probation and Reducing Reoffending (Catherine McKinnell)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Diolch, Dr Allin-Khan, and prynhawn da. I thank the right hon. Member for Dwyfor Meirionnydd (Liz Saville Roberts) for the opportunity to discuss the work of His Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service in Wales. Please excuse my Welsh pronunciation; I appreciate that it is far from perfect.

The House will know that the Government inherited a justice system in crisis, but we are meeting the challenge with a wide-ranging programme of transformational reforms. The Government have now responded to the findings of Sir Brian Leveson’s independent review of the criminal courts, and the implementation of his recommendations began earlier this year. We know that it is only by pulling every lever that we have—investment, efficiency, reform—that we can relieve the upstream pressure in the criminal justice system, which the right hon. Lady rightly identified, and begin to deliver faster and fairer justice.

Since taking office, the Government have passed and begun implementing the Sentencing Act 2026, to keep dangerous criminals locked up, stop the cycle of less serious offenders going in and out of custody and stabilise the crisis further downstream in our prisons. The implementation of the Act has been backed up by £700 million of additional investment in the probation service over the next few years.

In addition to those reforms, we are delivering the biggest prison expansion since the Victorian era. We are working to add 14,000 prison places by 2031, and we announced on 1 September that we are bringing forward £110 million from existing budgets to deliver those places within the current estate. We are also looking to acquire additional land to build future prisons. In Wales, we anticipate early works for the 345-place uplift at HMP Parc to begin early in the new year.

The Government have launched the independent review of the prison system, led by the right honourable Amber Rudd, whose recommendations are due shortly. The review is set to identify the reforms we need to build a prison system fit for the future, including in respect of security, safety, decency, capacity and staffing—all issues that the right hon. Member for Dwyfor Meirionnydd has rightly drawn attention to today—and visits to HMP Cardiff and HMP Parc were undertaken as part of its findings.

We have and are taking thoughtful action to address the challenges, and we are making progress, but the Government recognise that there is much more to do. Delivering meaningful improvements for the people of Wales will take time as reforms are implemented across the justice system. The Department has reviewed the recent report published by the Wales Governance Centre, because we are committed to supporting academic research and constructive scrutiny wherever possible. The report makes a valuable contribution to the wider body of evidence, although we are keen to ensure that its findings are considered in the round, in terms of perspectives, rather than being taken in isolation.

Liz Saville Roberts Portrait Liz Saville Roberts
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My office has had to help Rob Jones to gain access to information in the past. The report is critical because it shows the trends year on year, but he has, on occasion, had to make freedom of information requests, and I have had to table written parliamentary questions. Will the Minister commit to working with my office and with Cardiff University to ensure that we have all the detail we need to get the full picture?

Catherine McKinnell Portrait Catherine McKinnell
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I recognise the challenge. For example, the Department is receiving an increasing number of freedom of information requests, which take time to work through. I assure the right hon. Lady that our annual Welsh justice data release, the observations in the Wales Governance Centre’s reports, and findings from other Welsh institutions will continue to form and inform the decisions that we are determined to make and deliver on in Wales. Of course, I will take on board any issues the right hon. Lady raises, and she can certainly contact me if there are challenges in that regard.

The report’s data identifies genuine challenges, which the right hon. Lady set out, but it also shows areas of progress: self-harm incidents fell by 10% across Welsh prisons last year, while a growing proportion of offenders from Wales are serving sentences in Wales. We are acting on the challenges in the justice system, but many of the highlighted outcomes sit at the intersection of justice and devolved responsibilities in Wales. Our response must include not only justice reform but a bolder partnership with the Welsh Government, to ensure that progress can be made where matters are devolved. I am happy to take another intervention if the right hon. Lady so wishes. I am about to turn to other issues in the report.

Liz Saville Roberts Portrait Liz Saville Roberts
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I welcome the Minister’s preparedness to take another intervention, and her comments about working boldly with the Welsh Government; will she explain that a little more, please?

Catherine McKinnell Portrait Catherine McKinnell
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I will come to that later in my speech, if the right hon. Lady will forgive me. I was going to reflect on the meeting she drew attention to, the opportunities to work together and the particular areas where we have. If I do not respond to her question later in my speech, she can by all means intervene.

The right hon. Lady is absolutely right to draw attention to women in our justice system. To ensure that we reduce the number of women in prison, where it is safe and appropriate to do so, and that women get the experience in the prison system that they should, the Government are investing nearly £32 million in women’s community and voluntary organisations over the spending review period, to divert women from the justice system. We are investing £1.9 million in Wales as part of the women’s diversion fund. From January, organisations will be able to start delivering services that will divert women away from the criminal justice system and help to reduce the numbers in prison.

Liz Saville Roberts Portrait Liz Saville Roberts
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Will the Minister say more about the women’s residential centre in Swansea? Sending women so far away to prison is doing so much damage to them and their families.

Catherine McKinnell Portrait Catherine McKinnell
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The right hon. Lady is understandably impatient for justice and a better system for women in Wales, but I am coming to that very point.

Swansea magistrates court is due to become the first intensive supervision court in Wales next year. I have seen at first hand how those courts work and their success in providing a robust, community-based alternative to short custodial sentences, combining judicial oversight with tailored support by multiple agencies to address the root causes of offending, which will ultimately reduce the number of women who need to go into custody and support better outcomes for them.

We will continue to consider the options for the future of the residential women’s centre. I appreciate that it has had a challenging history under the previous Government and during the past spending review period, but we are keen to continue to engage with Welsh partners, including the Welsh Government, as part of that process and will continue to do so.

The right hon. Lady mentioned the challenge around drugs and the conditions in prisons. We know that drugs are a challenge in our communities and in our prison system. We recognise that drug use in prisons is too high and share the concerns about the risks, because it fundamentally undermines our ability to reduce reoffending. We are focused on creating a safer, recovery-focused system that tackles the drugs getting into prison, improves support for prisoners with treatment, keeps people safe and equips staff with the skills and tools they need to achieve that.

HMP Parc has been a particular concern in the Welsh estate, and significant work has been undertaken to address that. The latest quarterly review, from April to June 2026, indicates a significant year-on-year reduction in violence and self-harm, and in the January 2026 report the chief inspector recognised the considerable efforts made to tackle drug ingress and found that drug use had declined. That can be attributed to new security windows, stabilising staffing levels, a consistent regime and the roll-out of a peer mentoring model.

Lessons from the improvements at HMP Parc will be applied right across the Welsh estate. Earlier this month, the Deputy First Minister of Wales and the Welsh Cabinet Minister for Government Effectiveness and the Constitution visited HMP Parc and the Parc young offenders institution. During their visit, they recognised the progress that had been made on safety and wellbeing.

The right hon. Lady rightly mentioned the challenge around homelessness and ensuring that people have accommodation to go to when they leave prison. We recognise that this is a devolved responsibility, but HMPPS in Wales is providing local authorities with weekly data to identify individuals who are due to be released from custody, up to six months in advance. That is helping to improve outcomes.

Where temporary accommodation is needed, HMPPS is providing a range of options based on the circumstances, risks and needs, so that we ensure greater movement into longer-term settled accommodation, and short-term accommodation where it is needed. We welcome the Welsh Government’s wider commitment to a housing-first approach and will continue to work together to ensure that prison leavers can benefit from that ambition, turn their lives around and build a more productive future.

The right hon. Lady mentioned healthcare, the responsibility for which sits with Wales and the Welsh Government. But achieving the best outcomes requires co-operation across our respective responsibilities, which is why we are working with the Welsh Government and local health boards to improve healthcare across prison and probation services in Wales. In September, officials from the Welsh Government and HMPPS in Wales held a positive meeting about enhancing co-operation on health.

Further steps are outstanding, and we will continue to work with partners. We need timely health interventions and evidence-based treatment for drug addictions, and we need to address the factors that contribute to reoffending, so that people can build safer lives and an alternative future.

Liz Saville Roberts Portrait Liz Saville Roberts
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am grateful that the Minister mentioned the devolved areas, in particular housing and health, but I must push her on the question of the devolution of justice which, as I mentioned, has been raised by the Secretary of State for Justice. When does the Minister think justice will be devolved to Wales, the only legislature in the United Kingdom—and possibly the world—without a jurisdiction?

Catherine McKinnell Portrait Catherine McKinnell
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The right hon. Lady raises a point that I am clearly not able to give an answer on today. Conversations are ongoing between her Government and the UK Government here. It is important to recognise—I am sure she will be keen to do so—the areas on which progress can be made today. Let us not wait until tomorrow and what might come then. We are always working to improve things, and we do so together, but there are things that we can work on and collaborate on today to improve outcomes for people in Wales. That is what the Government and I are determined to do.

The right hon. Lady raised imprisonment rates. In the Government’s recent response to the Welsh Affairs Committee report, we committed to engage with criminal justice system partners, the third sector and the Welsh Government to investigate further. I am pleased to inform the House that in December the Criminal Justice Board for Wales will be holding a dedicated discussion on the underlying factors that influence imprisonment rates. It will focus on practical ways to strengthen co-operation across justice and devolved services such as health, housing, education and social services, to address some of the inequalities that can contribute to driving offending or recall rates across Wales. Addressing inequality is a shared commitment that requires a partnership approach. It underpins the work of the criminal justice anti-racism taskforce for Wales and the All-Wales Women and Justice Board, where officials from both Governments work alongside criminal justice agencies and the third sector to identify disparities and drive improvement.

In conclusion, I hope the right hon. Lady is reassured. The Lord Chancellor was in Wales last week to meet the Deputy First Minister of Wales and the Cabinet Minister for Government Effectiveness and the Constitution. They discussed how the UK Government and the Welsh Government can build a better, stronger and bolder partnership to make meaningful progress on shared ambitions to address inequality, support victims, prevent crime and break the cycle of reoffending across Wales. The Deputy First Minister’s social justice and equality portfolio provides a particular opportunity to renew and deepen co-operation across justice and devolved responsibilities, and deliver better outcomes for the people of Wales. I know the right hon. Lady is committed to that. We will continue to work with her, and with colleagues in this place and in Wales, to achieve our collective aims.

Question put and agreed to.

Department for Work and Pensions: Synergy Contract

Tuesday 17th November 2026

(1 day, 9 hours ago)

Westminster Hall
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts

Westminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.

Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.

This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record

[Emma Lewell in the Chair]
16:30
Andy McDonald Portrait Andy McDonald (Middlesbrough and Thornaby East) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I beg to move,

That this House has considered the role of the Department for Work and Pensions in the procurement of the Synergy contract.

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Ms Lewell, and I draw Members’ attention to my entry in the Register of Members’ Financial Interests as a proud trade unionist.

This debate comes at a time when the failures of outsourcing have become increasingly apparent and when this Government have made a welcome commitment to insourcing public sector expertise, strengthening accountability and ensuring public money is spent delivering services rather than financing private profit. The outsourcing of Government payroll and administrative services has its origins in the Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition. In 2013, work previously carried out within government was transferred to Shared Services Connected Ltd, a company that was then 75% privately owned; the Government sold their remaining shareholding in 2023.

The award of the Synergy contract to Capita continues that approach. The question is whether this Government will take the opportunity to reconsider it in keeping with their commitment to insourcing. Synergy is a programme to bring together payroll, human resources, finance and purchasing systems across several Government Departments, led by the Department for Work and Pensions. It covers the Home Office, the Ministry of Justice, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and other public bodies and provides services for more than 250,000 civil servants.

There is a good case for sharing modern technology and reducing duplication, but modernisation does not require outsourcing. I should make it clear that there are ongoing legal proceedings concerning the procurement of the Synergy contract. I will not address the competing bids, the evaluation of the tender or the merits of those proceedings—those are matters for the courts. My concern is with the wider policy of outsourcing essential services, the risks it creates for workers and the public, and whether the Government should reconsider continuing with private provision.

The stakes are considerable. Civil servants must be paid correctly and on time. Payroll failures can mean missed mortgage payments, rent arrears and serious financial hardship. The failures in Capita’s administration of civil service pensions demonstrate what can happen when essential services are outsourced and they go wrong.

Jim Shannon Portrait Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I commend the hon. Gentleman on introducing the debate, which is important to my constituents because I represent many serving and retired UK civil servants, including Home Office staff at our ports and airports who have already endured months of distress and financial hardship due to Capita’s severe backlogs with the civil service pension scheme. Given the record of failure, does the hon. Gentleman agree that DWP showed a troubling lack of due diligence in handing the very same company a £900 million 10-year contract to run frontline payroll and HR systems and that our civil servants, of whom much is expected, should have had a working system put in place instead?

Andy McDonald Portrait Andy McDonald
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The hon. Gentleman makes a really valid point. That is the concern and worry throughout the United Kingdom; it is experienced in every constituency, so he is right to highlight it.

Lara Bird Portrait Lara Bird (Arbroath and Broughty Ferry) (SNP)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I reiterate the thanks to the hon. Member for securing this debate. It is on an issue that many of my constituents have brought to me because they are so concerned about Capita’s ability, given the ongoing scandal. I want to mention several of my constituents whose cases span years because of Capita’s mismanagement, but they are no further forward. My office has been told repeatedly that, despite ongoing conversations with Capita, there is simply no update for them. As a result of a massive delay by Capita, one of my constituents is in a critical situation: they are left to live on less than £100 a month in the escalating cost of living crisis. Does the hon. Member agree that Capita simply cannot be trusted with an operation at this scale?

Andy McDonald Portrait Andy McDonald
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Those are egregious instances of complete and utter failure, and it is right that hon. Members bring those experiences to the House. Our constituents deserve their cases to be raised, and the hon. Lady has done that incredibly well.

On 26 October the Parliamentary Secretary to the Cabinet Office confirmed that Capita had missed its recovery milestones. Figures reported by the Public and Commercial Services Union on 12 November show approximately 156,000 outstanding pension cases, including 1,700 complex cases more than a year old.

Tom Gordon Portrait Tom Gordon (Harrogate and Knaresborough) (LD)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I congratulate the hon. Member on securing this important debate. At first, after this blew up and became a big, high-profile issue—addressed in the statements to which the hon. Member refers—we saw some positive signs of being able to liaise with Capita and get some of the issues fixed. That now seems to be going off the boil and we find it more and more difficult to get Capita’s casework teams to push cases forward. Does the hon. Member agree that the Government need to consistently push to make sure that people do not go without in retirement?

Andy McDonald Portrait Andy McDonald
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The hon. Gentleman makes a valid point. The description of cases as being somehow complex masks the inability of Capita to resolve matters. Behind the figures that I recited are people who spent their working lives in public service only to face uncertainty and hardship in accessing their pensions. PCS reports that some have even been forced to postpone their retirement. There is also a cost to the taxpayer. PCS reports that more than 100 civil servants have been deployed to help to restore the pension service, at a cost of £12.5 billion. Taxpayers are paying a private contractor to deliver a service while public servants and public money are deployed to rescue it. That raises a fundamental question about whether outsourcing delivers value for money.

Ian Lavery Portrait Ian Lavery (Blyth and Ashington) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I congratulate my hon. Friend on securing this important debate. I bet every MP has sackloads of correspondence from individuals with complaints about that pension scheme. Capita cannot pay the pensions. It cannot give predictions on what pension individuals will get on retirement. People are dying without getting their pensions, yet the Government agreed to give Capita the Synergy contract, which is worth £900 million. Does my hon. Friend agree that that is bizarre in many ways?

Andy McDonald Portrait Andy McDonald
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I wholeheartedly agree with my good and hon. Friend. It is a very strange situation. PCS believes that the failures justify removing Capita from pensions administration. I agree that where contractors repeatedly fail to deliver essential services, the Government must be prepared to end those arrangements and bring the work back in-house. Pensions administration and payroll are different services. Problems in one do not mean that the other will fail, but those problems demonstrate why effective oversight, safeguards and contingency arrangements are essential. Those concerns prompted my right hon. Friend the Member for Hayes and Harlington (John McDonnell), as chair of the PCS parliamentary group, to write to Ministers in July to call for the Synergy contract to be paused and reassessed because of the potential consequences for civil servants’ pay.

Staff at the DWP are already under enormous pressure. A recent PCS survey of almost 5,000 members in the DWP found that 73% reported backlogs caused by staff shortages—and these are the people we will depend on to deliver on the Milburn reforms and provide intensive job coaching. Civil servants delivering essential services on which millions depend should not also have to worry about whether their wages will arrive on time. They are entitled to ask, “Am I going to be left waiting for my salary each month?” Ministers must be able to answer that question with confidence.

This is also about the wider financial case for outsourcing. The Public Accounts Committee warned in July that the Government’s wider shared services strategy was at risk of failure. The Government claim the programme will deliver more than £4 billion in benefits, but the Committee found that the Government have failed to establish a clear overall financial case for their shared services strategy.

Crucially, the PAC also questioned the value-for-money case for outsourcing Synergy to Capita, rather than delivering those services in-house, as with the Unity programme. Surely, Ministers must now establish whether outsourcing really offers better value than direct public provision. I acknowledge that Ministers have raised concerns about reversing existing contractual arrangements, and I have no doubt the Minister will warn of the financial, legal and operational risks associated with reversing the reward. Those risks must be taken seriously.

Nobody wants to jeopardise payroll continuity for hundreds of thousands of civil servants, but there is a fundamental distinction between recognising those risks and accepting that outsourcing must continue without serious reconsideration. The Government should review the decision to continue outsourcing Synergy’s essential administrative services and establish whether they can be brought back into direct public provision.

I have sought this debate not simply to catalogue the failures of outsourcing, but because the Government have recognised the need for a different approach. On 26 October, the Parliamentary Secretary to the Cabinet Office told the House that she had instructed officials to examine future delivery options for civil service pensions,

“including insourcing all core business operations.”—[Official Report, 26 October 2026; Vol. 792, c. 31.]

I very much welcome that approach. Given the continuing failures, the assessment must proceed urgently and include the option of ending the existing, outsourced arrangement.

I also welcome the Government’s new central insourcing unit, established to help Departments bring outsourced work back under direct public management. The Government’s updated guidance rightly requires consideration of the full costs over time, service reliability, accountability and the skills needed to deliver services directly.

Where skills have been lost through outsourcing, the Government should consider how to rebuild them. Alternatives already exist within the Government’s own shared services programme. In the Unity contract, which includes His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs and the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, previously outsourced work has been brought back into HMRC with staff transferring into the Department.

In the Matrix contract, including the Department for Education, the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade and other Departments, plans for full outsourcing were halted in favour of public sector provision. If those alternatives are possible elsewhere in the Government, why should the future of Synergy not be examined on the same basis? The Government need not choose between immediately cancelling a contract without adequate preparation and allowing outsourcing to continue indefinitely; they can review the decision, examine the contractual options and develop the staff, skills and systems needed to bring the work back into public provision.

That review must also protect the workforce. PCS has consistently called for guarantees against compulsory involuntary redundancies arising from these programmes, for work transferred overseas to be brought back into the UK civil service and for the protection of employment terms and conditions. I support those demands.

Bringing services back in-house should strengthen the civil service, protect jobs and employment conditions, and rebuild the skills and expertise that have been lost through outsourcing. The objectives should be to rebuild the expertise of the civil service, protect workers, and ensure that essential public services are delivered reliably. Workers must have a meaningful role in shaping that future. I pay tribute to PCS, the PCS parliamentary group and the Insource Now! campaign for keeping this issue on the agenda.

The Synergy programme has recently established meetings to share information with trade unions, but PCS has made it clear that these do not yet amount to meaningful consultation or negotiation. It is insufficient to leave consultation entirely to individual Departments when Synergy is introducing common arrangements across them. Ministers should ensure that recognised unions can negotiate at the level at which decisions are actually being made, as well as within individual Departments. I want to ask the Minister to commit to one central objective: an urgent review of the decision to continue outsourcing Synergy’s essential administrative services with a proper assessment of how and when they could be brought back into public provision.

I have five specific requests. First, will the Government publish the Synergy contract, subject to the necessary redactions, and explain the safeguards for payroll continuity and what happens if the contractor fails to deliver? Secondly, will they urgently review the outsourcing decision and assess the costs and practicalities of bringing the services in-house, including opportunities to review or end existing contractual arrangements?

Thirdly, will the Government respond to the Public Accounts Committee’s recommendations and explain why the public sector approaches used in Unity and Matrix cannot also be considered for Synergy? Fourthly, will the new central insourcing unit examine Synergy as an early test of the Government’s policy, drawing on the lessons of the failures in civil service pensions administration? Fifthly, will Ministers establish meaningful negotiations with recognised unions across the participating Departments, with guarantees on jobs, offshoring and employment conditions?

The Government have made a very welcome commitment to a new wave of insourcing. The challenge now is to turn that commitment into practice. I am not asking Ministers to jeopardise payroll services or prejudge matters before the courts; I am asking them to reconsider whether outsourcing is the right model for these essential functions, and to begin the work necessary to bring them back under direct public management.

For too long, outsourcing has been treated as the default, with public provision required to justify itself as the exception. The Government have an opportunity to reverse that presumption. Modernisation should mean building a more capable state, not simply transferring essential functions to private contractors. Public money should be directed towards delivering excellent public services with public accountability, rather than unnecessarily financing private profit. I hope Ministers will seize that opportunity.

16:48
Sarah Green Portrait Sarah Green (Chesham and Amersham) (LD)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Ms Lewell. I congratulate the hon. Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East (Andy McDonald) on securing this debate.

Every civil servant deserves to be paid correctly and on time. After decades of public service, receiving the pension they have earned should be the very least they can expect from the Government. However, like many hon. Members here today, my team and I have been helping former civil servants who have found themselves unable to access their pensions. This administrative failure has left people facing extreme financial hardship in the middle of a cost of living crisis, through no fault of their own. One constituent from Amersham retired in February this year after 35 years of public service. Almost nine months later, he has still not received a penny of his pension, and he has had no indication of when his payments will begin.

Last October, the Public Accounts Committee, which I sit on, warned that there was a clear risk that Capita would not be ready to take over the civil service pension scheme. When Capita took over on 1 December, the backlog was more than double what the contract assumed. The warning signs were there, but the handover went ahead anyway. At our Committee’s joint hearing with the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee in July this year, 5,700 people were still waiting for a pension quote after their retirement date had passed and more than 3,000 payments were outstanding. The Cabinet Office told us that Capita was in breach of contract and expected to fail 16 of its 21 performance targets that month.

In parallel, in February this year, the DWP named Capita as the preferred bidder for Synergy, which covers pay, HR and finance for more than 250,000 civil servants. The Government were prepared to hand the same company responsibility for another quarter of a million people’s livelihoods. One of my constituents, who is a member of the PCS union, has warned that handing Capita the job of paying a quarter of a million civil servants risks importing that same chaos from the pension scheme directly into their monthly pay packets. Civil servants should not have to worry about whether the company responsible for their salaries is capable of paying it.

At the July hearing of the Public Accounts Committee, the hon. Member for Sheffield South East (Mr Betts) asked for a guarantee: no new contracts for Capita until the pension scheme is fixed. The permanent secretary said that could not be guaranteed, because they have to abide by procurement rules. A company can fail thousands of pensioners, but the Government cannot guarantee that they will stop handing that same company more contracts.

That is at the heart of this issue. A supplier can be in breach of contract, have money withheld every month and miss three quarters of its targets—and still not meet the bar for exclusion. The Procurement Act 2023 was meant to change that, with a debarment list for suppliers that fail. As far as I can tell, not one company is on that list. I ask the Minister: what conversations are taking place across Government to update the procurement guidelines, so that failure on one public contract counts against a supplier when it bids for the next?

The Government have agreed to an independent review of whether shared services delivery remains viable. What assurances can the Minister give that that review will be completed and published before the services transfer to Capita in August 2027? Civil servants cannot endure another round of such failures.

Emma Lewell Portrait Emma Lewell (in the Chair)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Ian Byrne will the last Back-Bench speaker before I call Steve Darling for the Liberal Democrats.

16:52
Ian Byrne Portrait Ian Byrne (Liverpool West Derby) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Ms Lewell. This debate can be summarised in one simple question: why the hell are we handing a £950 million 10-year contract to a company that is failing on the last major public contract it was given, delivering a similar service to civil servants? Because that is precisely what is happening.

That contract is, of course, the civil service pension scheme. I secured a debate on that matter in Westminster Hall only two months ago, with more than 30 Liverpool West Derby constituents facing difficulties in accessing their pensions. MPs from all sides of the House brought forward similar stories. I and my constituents who are affected are extremely grateful to my hon. Friend the Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East (Andy McDonald) for bringing this matter back to the fore.

The most concerning issue with the contract award is that it was confirmed by the Government in March, while Capita’s failure in presiding over the civil service pension scheme was already well under way, with our mailbags full of correspondence from people affected.

Ian Lavery Portrait Ian Lavery
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Only this week, I texted my wonderful caseworker, asking for an update on how many emergency cases we had with the PCS pension scheme. Paul Robertson, a very skilled caseworker, got back to me and asked, “How dare you ask that? Every case—every single case we’ve got—is an emergency.” I have to be honest, I thought he was being really cheeky, but I sat back and thought, “He’s absolutely right.” If individuals cannot get their pension, it is an emergency. If they cannot draw their pension, it is an emergency. If they cannot get a projection on what they should get in a year, it is an emergency. They are all emergencies.

Ian Byrne Portrait Ian Byrne
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank my hon. Friend for that excellent intervention. He is absolutely right.

To give the same firm who created these emergencies the opportunity to administer HR and payroll for more than 250,000 civil servants, while it is has failed to resolve the issues it has caused in running the pension scheme, is simply unacceptable. We are rewarding abject failure. People outside of this place will be scratching their heads, going “How? How is this possible?”

Let us look at the numbers. At the beginning of October, around 150,000 civil service pension cases remained outstanding. Capita receives some 20,000 new cases a week, but even if not one more arrived, the backlog would be nearly two months’ work. How is it asking for another contract?

Of the complex cases, nearly 10,000 are more than six months old and 1,700 are more than a year old. Behind every one of the statistics is, as has been said, a retired public servant waiting for the pension that they rightfully earned. Some are facing real hardship; some of the stories I have heard from constituents in West Derby are absolutely heartbreaking. People have been forced to postpone retirement and are using foodbanks. These are honourable people who have worked really hard and now find themselves in this position through no fault of their own.

The Government have rightly accepted that this is a failure. The Parliamentary Secretary, Cabinet Office, the hon. Member for Doncaster Central (Sally Jameson), told the House that Capita has “comprehensively failed” and called its progress “abysmal”. We all completely agree, so why are we continuing to give it contracts?

We are told that Synergy is different—but Synergy is payroll. It is how people pay their rents and mortgages. If Capita cannot pay a pension on time, why should anybody trust it to pay a salary on time? Those workers must be absolutely terrified about what is coming down the track. Workers whose pay has already been eroded since 2010, during austerity, cannot afford a missed payment. Many will be living month by month.

Andy McDonald Portrait Andy McDonald
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Has it occurred to my hon. Friend that there could be a situation where somebody is still working and is going on to that payroll, and is yet to receive their projection on what their pension may be so is living in some trepidation about that? They may end up with a double whammy of not being paid on time and no pension to look forward to.

Ian Byrne Portrait Ian Byrne
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I ask the Minister to address that issue. It is a vital point.

This comes down to the fundamental issue of outsourcing that bedevils this place. That is responsible for the failure of Capita. We are told that outsourcing delivers efficiency and transfers risk, but after Capita’s failures, we have seen civil servants stepping up and clearing the backlog, employers providing hardship funds, and Government-appointed auditors and MPs becoming an escalation route.

Put simply, outsourcing has proven to be a failed Thatcherite ideology followed by successive Governments, delivering the opposite of the promised aim of efficiency and putting the burden on ordinary people. The number of Government contracts that we have outsourced is terrifying. It feels as though we have been captured by these companies, and we are now in a position where, if one topples, we are absolutely terrified of the consequences. Whether it is Fujitsu in the case of the Post Office Horizon scandal, our failing water industry or the Capita civil service pension scheme, this House must accept that this political experiment has failed completely and Governments must now begin to reverse it.

We look forward to seeing the Government’s proposals on insourcing, because I fully support the call for a wholesale programme of insourcing. That was a manifesto pledge that we stood on but, unfortunately, it is not moving quick enough.

I finish with a couple of questions for the Minister. Will she pause the contract and review it? Will the Government publish contingency plans to guarantee that every civil servant is paid on time, if this contract goes the way of the pensions? Will she open genuine negotiations with the recognised trade unions, including PCS, that have done so much to protect the workers involved and, rightly, are hugely concerned about the workers being paid on time and in full?

16:59
Steve Darling Portrait Steve Darling (Torbay) (LD)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

May I say what a pleasure it is to serve under your chairship, Ms Lewell? I congratulate the hon. Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East (Andy McDonald) on obtaining a really important debate. What has been debated here today—how this juggernaut is allowed to continue—is nothing short of a scandal. We have heard from a number of Members how the most important people in this situation are the civil servants who are being poorly served by Capita; and that should not be a surprise, because it does have form.

For my sins, I am still a councillor, and I have served on Torbay council for more than 30 years. My experience of outsourcing was quite disastrous: our street scene works, our recycling and our parks and gardens were outsourced to a company called TOR2. It was not until we got them back in-house that we turned things around. The staff were so much happier, and genuine investment was possible, whereas up until then it had felt like we were what I fear the Government are at the moment to Capita—a hostage client. It is able to get away with blue murder in the way it is dealing with this, and that is absolutely shameful.

In Torbay, I am desperately worried about the Conservative council repeating the same mistake and outsourcing the heritage asset, Cockington Court. I fear for the future of that asset, because we have seen things go wrong historically elsewhere in Torbay, whether we are talking about Oldway Mansion or the Pavilion.

To come back to the case in hand, there have been some really good questions, and I am looking forward to hearing those answered by the Minister. I also have a key question for the Minister. When outsourcing, it is important to ensure there is a fat enough client to hold the outside bodies to account. Is the Government’s client body too thin, and therefore not able to hold Capita to account?

17:02
Andrew Snowden Portrait Mr Andrew Snowden (Fylde) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under you in the Chair, Ms Lewell. I congratulate the hon. Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East (Andy McDonald) on securing this debate, and Members who have contributed.

Seeking efficiency in the civil service is the right thing to do, and the back office of Government is a logical place to start. Moving four Departments on to one HR and finance system, covering about 250,000 civil servants, is a sensible aim, but this debate is not about the aim; it is about how this contract has been handled and about one question that the Government have so far refused to answer: who is responsible? Frankly, this has been a mess.

Let us take a look at the timeline. In August 2024, the then Chief Secretary to the Treasury approved the first full business case for Synergy. In December 2025, the Government let Capita take over the civil service pension scheme, despite repeated warnings that it was not ready. By February 2026, the backlog stood at about 120,000 cases. In the same month, with that crisis already in the headlines, the Department for Work and Pensions named the very same company as the preferred bidder for Synergy.

What has happened since? By the summer, 100,000 people were still waiting for pension quotes. More than 7,000 of them were already past their retirement date. About 5,000 bereaved families were still waiting for money that they were owed. Last month, the Government had to rush a fix into the Budget, so that families whose death-in-service payments Capita had delayed would not be hit with a tax bill on top.

Those are not abstract numbers. Some 69 of my own constituents have contacted me about this, making it one of the largest single casework issues that we are currently dealing with in the office; other Members have also acknowledged the scale of the casework coming into their inboxes. The individual stories that I have heard in Fylde and from Members who have contributed here today and in other debates demonstrate the urgent need to get solutions for the people we represent.

To go back to the timeline, on 26 October, the Parliamentary Secretary, Cabinet Office, the hon. Member for Doncaster Central (Sally Jameson), came to the House and called Capita’s performance “abysmal”. She said that the company had been “flaky with the truth”. Her own remedial adviser found its recovery planning “wholly insufficient”. One Department tells us that it cannot trust Capita’s figures on pensions, while another hands the same company the pay of a quarter of a million serving civil servants—both cannot be right.

When the right hon. Member for Hayes and Harlington (John McDonnell) asked about Synergy, the Cabinet Office said that that was not within its remit and pointed to the DWP. Ask the DWP, and we are told that the process was robust. The Treasury signed off the business case, the Cabinet Office owns the strategy, DWP ran the procurement and, on pensions, we are told that Capita alone is accountable for the recovery. Everybody had a hand in this, but nobody will take responsibility for it. That is not good enough. If payroll goes wrong, it is prison officers, Border Force staff and jobcentre workers who will not be paid on time. The warning signs are already there: the Public Accounts Committee reported in July that the first moves on to the new service had slipped by five months. The Committee has asked the Government to confirm whether Capita’s bid came in around 40% below the Department’s estimate of what the work should cost. I will not stray into matters before the courts, but that is a question that this House is entitled to have answered at the appropriate juncture.

I have five questions for the Minister. First, which Minister took the decision to award this contract to Capita, and what did they know about the pension scheme when they took it? Secondly, what did the Cabinet Office tell DWP about Capita’s performance before the award, and will the Minister publish that? Thirdly, has the Department assessed what the remedial adviser’s findings on pensions mean for Synergy? If Capita’s planning was “wholly insufficient” there, why will it be any different here? Fourthly, what is the revised timetable for each Department? What have the delays cost so far, and will the Minister commit that no one’s pay will move until clear, published milestones have been met? Finally, if Capita fails, what is the contingency plan, and who pays for it?

The Cabinet Office Minister said that she would return to the House if there was no rapid improvement within a month. That month is almost up. Thousands of retired civil servants are still waiting, and now a quarter of a million serving civil servants are being asked to trust the same company with their pay. They deserve better than a Government that pass the buck from one Department to the next. Somebody signed this off. Somebody must take responsibility.

17:07
Lilian Greenwood Portrait The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Work and Pensions (Lilian Greenwood)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is always a pleasure to serve with you in the Chair, Ms Lewell. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East (Andy McDonald) on securing this debate, and I thank him for doing so.

I understand hon. Members’ concerns about Synergy’s contract with Capita in the light of the civil service pensions debacle. We know that payroll is a must-not-fail service; I am sure we all have civil servants and retired civil servants in our constituencies who have been impacted by the civil service pensions failure. I have listened carefully to the issues and cases raised by the hon. Member for Chesham and Amersham (Sarah Green) and my hon. Friend the Member for Liverpool West Derby (Ian Byrne). I understand their anger and frustration, and I will make sure that those comments are drawn to the attention of the Parliamentary Secretary, Cabinet Office, my hon. Friend the Member for Doncaster Central (Sally Jameson) who has responsibility for the civil service pension issues. It was almost as if the shadow Minister completely forgot that that contract was awarded in November 2023 under the previous Government, but there we go.

I turn to Synergy. It is the largest of the five clusters or groups of Government Departments working together under the Government shared services strategy. As a number of hon. Members have said, it will provide shared human resources, finance and commercial services for the Department for Work and Pensions, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, the Ministry of Justice and the Home Office. It will transform back-office functions for around 250,000 civil and public servants with a shared services model designed by and for Government.

Colleagues have asked a number of questions about other clusters. Each cluster has taken decisions based on its specific context and circumstances. It is important to note that the four Departments within this cluster already use shared services that are outsourced and delivered by Shared Services Connected Ltd, a wholly owned subsidiary of Sopra Steria. For three of the Departments, the current service relies on pre-2013 technology, which reaches the end of extended support in 2031. Synergy will replace that with modern technology and services.

The delivery model gives the civil service greater control; I will explain how. We have a shared services hub, accountable for services, contracts and continuous improvement. There are common HR, finance and commercial processes, reducing complexity and duplication compared with all four Departments operating independently. Oracle software-as-a-service is managed by the hub and enables self-service and automation, with a separate business process services partner for high-volume transactions and day-to-day HR, payroll and invoice processing, and finance administration. It is important that there is that separation. The technology and systems integrator contract was awarded on 30 August 2024 to IBM, Deloitte and Oracle; they are known as the consortium. The business process services contract with Capita was signed on 2 March this year.

Capita’s appointment followed a two-year procurement supported by commercial, legal and programme delivery experts. Functional experts from all four Departments evaluated the final bids. The procurement met regulatory requirements, with advice from His Majesty’s Treasury and the Cabinet Office, and passed their required controls. Because this is a critical service, the programme did not simply choose the cheapest option. Evaluation was weighted 70% on quality and 30% on cost. The programme did consider insourcing the whole service or parts of it. However, its business case and approvals concluded that continuing to outsource business process services was the most efficient and cost-effective option for Departments, Government and taxpayers.

Andy McDonald Portrait Andy McDonald
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am grateful to the Minister for giving way. Given what she said about the insourcing proposal being considered, could she explain how that squares with the commitment to encourage greater insourcing? If that has failed on this occasion, what work has been done to further support the ability to progress those insource bids?

Lilian Greenwood Portrait Lilian Greenwood
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I understand why hon. Members are asking questions about this programme. It is important to say that it began in 2023, under the previous Government. I can assure the hon. Gentleman that this decision was reviewed at appropriate points, including by my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State, but in each case, the alternative threw up significant legal, commercial and delivery risk, along with inevitable delay costing millions of pounds in taxpayers’ money. We have, however, chosen to bring the technology, oversight and co-ordination of the end-to-end service in-house, and those will be managed by the Synergy shared services hub. My hon. Friend the Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East will appreciate that because he asked, given Capita’s failure on pensions and the Government’s commitment to look at insourcing, why we are not reversing the decision to award this contract to Capita and bring it in-house.

Preparation for the Synergy transition is now well underway, and changing course midway would cause significant service disruption, laying a second major transition on top of the existing one, adding high-level risk and significant cost. Given that Capita is, to date, performing against its contractual obligations in respect of this programme, there is no basis on which to terminate the contract, other than voluntarily, which would likely involve paying Capita millions of pounds without requiring it to deliver.

I turn to our approach to assurance and oversight. Accredited contract management professionals, supported by senior commercial and legal advisers, will hold suppliers to account. Contractual levers include the ability to step in and temporarily take over delivery from Capita in the event of serious failings, payment deductions for service failures or delays, and limits on costs and Capita’s profit margin. The current Secretary of State sought and received written assurances from the Capita leadership, including the commitment to a charter on ways of working, which is now in place.

Synergy’s strategic partnership forum meets monthly, bringing together senior leaders from the technology and business process services partners and the current supplier to support a smooth transition. The programme senior responsible officer meets fortnightly with chief executive officers and senior delivery partner leaders for early escalation and oversight.

I understand the concerns raised by hon. Members on behalf of civil servants, and I too have asked those questions. That is why engagement with the recognised trade unions is so important. The Synergy trade union forum has been established, and it met for the first time on 25 September. It plans to meet every two months to share information, listen to concerns and answer questions that representatives rightly ask on behalf of their members.

Finally, I want to explain how and why Synergy is different from the civil service pension transition, as it is important to answer people’s legitimate concerns. Before each Department moves to the new service, payroll assurance will include detailed technical testing, numerical payroll testing, business assurance and operational payroll testing.

There are important differences between the civil service pensions programme that was established under the previous Government and this one. First, Synergy has not outsourced the full service as a package. It has separated the build, testing and delivery of the technology platform from the transactional processing provider. It is using a separate globally-proven technology provider, Oracle.

Secondly, Synergy has acted to avoid the backlogs and data issues seen with pensions, to which a number of Members referred. The Departments work closely with the current supplier to identify and address those in real time. The programme controls data migration, and two successful migration trials have already been completed.

Thirdly, the transition to new services is contractually supported by the existing supplier, with equal emphasis on it to ensure stability at transition. Most importantly, there is no contractual cliff edge. The current SSCL contracts continue until October 2028, which means that Synergy will not go live until all the appropriate testing of payroll and other critical processes is fully assured. We have learned lessons from what happened with civil service pensions. I understand the importance of civil servants getting their pay when they need it. We will not allow this system to go live until we are confident that it can do so.

My hon. Friend the Member for Middlesbrough and Thornaby East asked me a number of questions, and I will try to respond to them. First, the contract was published on 6 March, according to procurement rules. Secondly, the DWP has responded to the PAC recommendations, and we are working with the Cabinet Office on them. The cross-Department engagement with trade unions has started—it is already happening. We cannot pause the contract without substantial losses, but we will continue to look at the issues that people have raised about assurance and contingency, and we will ensure that there are not the problems that we have seen in relation to pensions. Finally, I assure my hon. Friend that there are strong commercial and contract management arrangements in place to hold Capita to account.

The Synergy programme will use established strong commercial controls, contract management arrangements and governance structures to continue to hold suppliers to account throughout mobilisation, transition and live service delivery. Its focus remains on delivering a better service for civil servants and the best overall value for taxpayers. I welcome the opportunity to answer questions today and give that assurance to hon. Members present.

17:20
Andy McDonald Portrait Andy McDonald
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the Minister for her thorough and comprehensive response to the issues that were raised. I am grateful that she has made it abundantly clear that payroll is a must-not-fail function: that is exactly what we are saying on these Benches. That must obtain at all times. She alludes to assurances made by Capita. There is a lingering concern that they may not be wholly reliable, given what has gone on before. Past performance is no guarantee of future results, but it gives us a damn good idea. I suspect that all the things she alluded to in terms of the preparation for the contract may have been said when the pensions contract was first developed with Capita all those years ago. However, I am grateful to her for all that she has said.

I hope that we can get further clarification from the Government as we go forward on how we will embrace the principle of insourcing as a default, because the annals of history are littered with cases such as Capita, Carillion and so on. In finishing, I would like to acknowledge the transformation in the position of the Opposition, who appear to understand that outsourcing has not worked in the way they had hoped. It seems that their love affair with Capita is at an end.

Question put and agreed to.

Resolved,

That this House has considered the role of the Department for Work and Pensions in the procurement of the Synergy contract.

17:21
Sitting adjourned.