Andy Burnham
Main Page: Andy Burnham (Labour (Co-op) - Makerfield)Department Debates - View all Andy Burnham's debates with the Cabinet Office
(1 day, 10 hours ago)
Commons Chamber
The Prime Minister (Andy Burnham)
May I add my condolences to the family, friends and colleagues of Sir David Evennett? He was a kind and generous friend to me when I was in this House before, and to many on all sides, particularly those on the Conservative Benches. He will be much missed.
This morning I had meetings with ministerial colleagues and others, and—according to ChatGPT—I shall have further such meetings later today.
Sir David Evennett was a member of the Education Committee with me when I was first elected. He was a really kind man and I was very fond of him. I send my heartfelt condolences to his family. May I add that we should pay our condolences to the family of John Pardoe, who passed away this week? He served North Cornwall and the Liberal movement so proudly for many years.
Every year, more than 600 people with cancer in south Cumbria have to make debilitating round trips of nearly four hours, every day for weeks on end, to the nearest radiotherapy centre in Preston. We have the worst access to radiotherapy in the whole of England, and therefore tragically many of my constituents die before their time. The answer is obvious: we need to open a satellite radiotherapy unit at the Westmorland general hospital in Kendal. Will the Prime Minister agree to meet me, local cancer patients and clinicians to help us achieve that long overdue investment, so that people who suffer from cancer in south Cumbria can have shorter journeys, but longer lives?
The Prime Minister
I want to see the end of the postcode lottery in cancer care. I am going to agree with the hon. Gentleman—he and I used to talk about this very issue 15 or so years ago, when I was Health Secretary. I would like to see cancer care more in the community and more satellite units, exactly as he says. I will arrange for a Minister to meet him to discuss this issue. We are investing in new cutting-edge radiotherapy machines in hospitals across England. Perhaps there is an opportunity to do more in his area, and we will look into it.
Terry Jermy (South West Norfolk) (Lab)
The Prime Minister
I have an idea of how difficult this year has been for our farmers. I visited a farm myself in Truro at the height of the summer. At the time, we confirmed funding for reservoirs on farms to support them with the changing climate that they face. I will be fighting in Brussels on Friday for a new arrangement to improve the Tory Brexit deal that actually will support our farmers and our food producers, but I recognise that we can do more to support farmers and farming, and I will work with my hon. Friend to that end.
The Prime Minister
I will do everything I can as quickly as possible to get the welfare bill down. We received the landmark report yesterday from Alan Milburn, and I say a huge thank you to him, because he has done a great service to this country and particularly to its young people. Finally—a landmark report that will change the way we think about the coming generation and give them the support that they need to get on in life. I hope that all sides of the House will get behind it. Specifically, I have asked the Cabinet to reprioritise spending plans for ’27-28 to put the beginnings of a fund together to support the youth opportunity service, initially delivering 25,000 quality work placements for 16 and 17-year-olds. We are making progress immediately to get the welfare bill down.
I asked the Prime Minister if he was going to cut the welfare bill in this Parliament; it sounds very clearly like he is not. He talks about a landmark report, but he is not planning any savings for 10 years. Those young people are not going to be young in 10 years’ time. Everything that he wants to do takes 10 years. He wants a 10-year plan—which is still not ready, by the way. The NATO defence plan will take 10 years. Now it is going to take him 10 years to make any welfare savings. We cannot wait 10 years: those young people need those jobs now.
Working-age welfare alone costs £180 billion a year and is set to rise to more than £220 billion a year because of this Government. As the welfare Secretary told us, every Labour MP just wants to know who they can tax to pay for more benefits. Keir Starmer failed to make welfare cuts, because this Chief Whip, the right hon. Member for Knowsley (Anneliese Midgley), and that First Secretary of State, the right hon. Member for Sheffield Heeley (Louise Haigh), led the rebellion on welfare. Now they are in charge of the Labour party. Is that not more proof that the Labour party is just the welfare party?
The Prime Minister
The right hon. Lady reveals time and time again, when she comes to that Dispatch Box, why she does not understand this issue, because she only ever stands at that Dispatch Box asking for cuts. That is all she ever asks for. Her shadow Work and Pensions Secretary confirmed on the television that hundreds of thousands of disabled children would lose funding under her proposals. The Milburn report says that, in order to reduce the welfare bill, we have to improve support. Here is where the Opposition really do not understand it: the report also says that the biggest rise in NEETs came between 2022 and 2024. That is because a report by Sir Kevan Collins, commissioned by the Conservatives, recommended major investment in support for young people coming out of the pandemic to prevent them becoming NEET. Some 250,000 people became NEET because the Conservatives failed to provide that support. We will give hope to young people, and we will oppose the cuts-only approach of the Conservatives.
The Prime Minister says that I do not understand—the only person who does not understand is him. He talks about NEETs, but let me clear his confusion up. When we were in government, between 2011 and 2021, the NEETs rate actually fell by 7%. It then went up because of covid. That 7% is more than all of the savings that the Government are going to find to help young people from the Milburn review. We did more during our time in government than the Prime Minister is proposing now. That is a fact.
The Prime Minister wants to pretend that he actually understands. What he wants is the vibes of welfare reform without actually doing any welfare reform. We need to bring down the welfare bill because we cannot afford it, but he does not understand. On Sky News yesterday, the Prime Minister actually said that no one would lose money as a result of his welfare changes. Also on Sky News yesterday, Alan Milburn said that there will be some young people “who…get less”, so there seems to be some confusion here. Can the Prime Minister clear it up for us? Who is right?
The Prime Minister
We are about helping young people into work. We are about giving young people hope and a better life. That is what this whole reform is about, and I need to hear from the Leader of the Opposition today whether she and her party are going to back the opportunity and support guarantee—a legal guarantee—so that young people in this country can have a better life and can have hope.
There needs to be some humility from the Conservatives. They left government with almost 1 million young people without any hope for their future; we want to give them a better life. Yes, we do want people to accept the support that is on offer. That is clear and it is in the report, but we will not accept the Conservatives coming to this House time and again saying, “We are going to bring down the welfare bill”, but failing to support our young people. They slashed youth services when they were in government, they cut the education maintenance allowance, and they trebled tuition fees. They took hope from a generation; we will give it back to them.
I am going to cut through all this waffle. The Prime Minister says that he wants to give young people a better life; all he is offering them is false hope, because none of the things he is saying are going to work. He keeps talking about all of the schemes that the Government have. The youth guarantee scheme is a complete and total failure—everyone out there knows it. The Government destroy jobs, they kill businesses, and then they offer the businesses a little money to give young people work placements. It makes no sense at all. We are not offering young people false hope; we are the ones who are offering them a better plan.
Yesterday, I spoke to a café owner in Waterloo. He said to me:
“I can’t believe the Government thinks I’m not a working person because I employ people.”
Earlier, I asked the Prime Minister to clear up the confusion about who would lose out, and he could not do so. Let me tell him who is really losing out: it is people like that man, every single hard-working taxpayer out there struggling with the cost of living who is going to have to pay higher taxes because of Labour’s welfare bill. That café owner did not blame the last Government; he blamed this Government. Since Labour came into office, the cost of hiring a young person has gone up by almost £5,000. The best thing the Prime Minister could do to solve this crisis is to cut the jobs tax for young people. Why will he not do it?
The Prime Minister
The Leader of the Opposition comes to the Dispatch Box time and again with her selective facts. Did she see in the news yesterday that unemployment is down? There are hundreds of thousands more people in work in this country, and that includes young people. Did she see last Thursday that growth is up over the last three quarters? Actually, they are the best growth figures for a 10-year period if you exclude the bounce back after the pandemic. The fundamentals of the British economy are strong, and they are getting stronger.
We will consider the Milburn report in the round. We will look at all of its proposals in detail and bring forward our response next month, but if the Leader of the Opposition is arguing for a cuts-only approach, we will stand against that, because we know that that will not help a generation to move on. We will bring forward an approach based on support and opportunity—that will always be the approach of the Labour party. We know that our approach will work, and we also have evidence that the Conservatives’ approach failed comprehensively.
I think the Prime Minister said the quiet part out loud when he said he will consider the report in the round. That will probably take another 10 years as well. The Government want to have reviews, to consult and to create reports, and then they come here and say, “It’s a landmark report.” No—it is yet more kicking things into the long grass. We do not have 10 years; we need to get jobs now. The cheek of him to say that unemployment has gone down! He does not know why. It is because people have stopped looking for work; they cannot get jobs, so they have moved into claiming benefits and are no longer classified as unemployed, and that is because of this Labour Government.
Across Britain, we are watching a lost generation of young people going straight on to welfare because jobs are disappearing. There are nearly 200,000 fewer vacancies under this Labour Government, and the Prime Minister is congratulating himself that unemployment has gone down. Then on Friday, he will, as he said, go to Brussels and sign up to 100,000 more young people coming to our country to compete for those jobs. Where are those jobs supposed to come from?
The Prime Minister
We do need jobs now, and that requires growth in the economy. We know that over the last decade, when the Conservatives were in government, we had a decade of low growth. Those are the facts; they go quiet, because they know that is a fact. The deal that is on the table will bring growth to the British economy; it will reduce red tape for businesses; it will cut the cost of exporting to Europe; and, critically, it will bring food prices down. M&S says that it will ease pressure on the price of the weekly shop. Asda says that it will reduce costs. Morrisons says the same thing. Right now, when families across Britain are struggling with the cost of the weekly shop, what are those families to make of a Conservative party that used to back business in reducing red tape and to back working families with their costs, but that is now so split over this issue that it cannot stand up for this country and support a deal that will bring growth to the British economy?
Again, I am just going to clear up some confusion for the Prime Minister. [Interruption.] Yes, I have to. He said that we do need jobs and that that requires growth. No, the growth is created by the businesses that create the jobs. It is business that creates growth, not Government. Growth comes after the jobs. It does not just happen. After all these years, Labour still does not understand that there is only one way to reduce youth unemployment, and that is to make it easier for firms to hire people. All the Government have done is make it harder and harder for firms to hire people. They are in a mess on welfare, because the same people who led the welfare rebellion against Keir Starmer are now in charge—the same people who think social security is more important than national security. Let us see how they are doing. Today, we learn that energy bills are going up by 26%. Inflation is up, interest rates are up and young people aren’t working. Isn’t the truth that it is the Labour party—and this Labour Government—that isn’t working?
The Prime Minister
As I said, growth is up and unemployment is down. The right hon. Lady can ask all the self-serving questions that she likes, and she can take a patronising tone, if she wants to, at that Dispatch Box, but this Government are leading on the big issues. We will not let a lost generation be the let-down generation. We are acting to deal with these issues and to face them. And we will—yes, we will—lead on Europe and bring growth to the British economy. This side of the House believes in the next generation; that side wants to throw them on the scrapheap again with more cuts. This side of the House has a vision for growth and a positive working relationship with our biggest market; that side is still stuck in the politics of the past and cannot accept that the status quo that they negotiated is not working. They gave us a decade of drift and division; this side of the House is letting Britain believe again and bringing back hope.
Jon Pearce (High Peak) (Lab)
The Prime Minister
I certainly pay tribute to all those organisations, and I look forward to welcoming Andy’s Man Club into 10 Downing Street later today. We know that suicide is the leading cause of death for men under 50, and we know that the sessions that those organisations put on make all the difference, connecting men of all backgrounds so that they can talk openly in a way that they could not do in the family home or at work. We are launching the first ever men’s health strategy, which will put more funding into the kind of projects that my hon. Friend has mentioned. May I also compliment him on his Movember efforts? He has 12 days to go—it might even turn into a moustache at some point. [Laughter.]
May I join others in sending our condolences to the family of Sir David Evennett and to the family of John Pardoe?
Halloween may be over, but the Vote Leave zombies are out in force: Boris Johnson, staggering back, denying the enormous damage to our economy and the cost of living caused by the Conservatives’ Brexit deal; and Dominic Cummings and Lord Gove, trying to scare us with a new made-up number, no doubt coming soon to the side of a bus. But British people now see the true Brexit horror—higher taxes and higher bills—and they want change now, so will the Prime Minister ditch the whole trade and co-operation agreement, and get a new deal that works for the British people?
The Prime Minister
Well, I think we heard from some of those zombies a few moments ago—they were shouting at me. The truth is that they do not like it when we say the truth in this House. The truth is that the Brexit deal that they negotiated was not good enough for Britain. It is just a fact, and the vast majority of the public know that as well. It is really important that we face up to that. They burned bridges with our largest market—old friends and neighbours. They just destroyed all those relationships. Exports are down from their constituencies, and they know that as well.
There will be a deal in front of us on Friday, and I am looking for support across the Floor of this House for what we are trying to negotiate. [Interruption.] Yes, I am, because it can bring growth to the British economy. It can lower the cost of the weekly shop. It can get greater collaboration back on immigration. It is time that they faced up to these facts, and I am hoping that the right hon. Gentleman will back us in our efforts on Friday.
I thank the Prime Minister for his answer, but I hope that he will absolutely ditch the trade and co-operation agreement, because it is bad from start to finish. If the cost of living crisis does not convince him that a totally new deal with Europe is needed, surely the security implications of Trump, Putin and Xi cosying up should. Lurking behind their talks in China is the scandal of Nvidia, the US firm accused of shipping $12 billion of advanced AI chips to China. With Donald Trump investing millions in Nvidia and selling shares before news of Jensen Huang’s affair broke, White House corruption is once more in plain sight. Does the Prime Minister accept that the Nvidia scandal is not just a major US security threat but a threat to the whole world, and given that corrupt President Trump will not, can he tell us what steps he is taking to keep Britain safe?
The Prime Minister
I think we have to have our eyes open to all the threats that are out there, particularly in relation to the issue that the right hon. Gentleman has raised in relation to Nvidia. We have to establish all those facts, and act on them.
Can I say where I will be tomorrow when that meeting is taking place in China? I will be in Berlin for a meeting of the coalition of the willing. The thing that we need to do is continue to stand squarely by Ukraine, and that is what this Government will do. On this issue, I pay tribute to both sides of the House, because that is what we have managed to do in the years since the conflict began, and that is the right thing to do. On this issue, let that clear message go out as that meeting takes place in Beijing: this country is squarely with Ukraine. We know who the aggressor is in this situation, and we will not in any way deflect from continuing that support.
The Prime Minister
My hon. Friend has been a formidable campaigner on this issue, and rightly so. We all remember her sister Margaret with love and affection, and we all support Margaret’s final campaign. My hon. Friend is asking the right questions in this House, and many people are asking the same questions up and down the country. I recently met Archie Goodburn, who is campaigning on these issues, and we all know that Tessa Jowell’s family are campaigning on the same issues as well. As well as understanding how many people are on those trials, we need to galvanise a change here and get a breakthrough, so that more people can access them. The Health Secretary and I, in that meeting with Archie, agreed to appoint a new national brain cancer clinical lead—that is No. 1—and we have said that we will use the G20 next year to see if we can bring a catalyst for change in respect of cutting-edge research on this terrible issue. I look forward to involving my hon. Friend in all of that work.
The Prime Minister has already acknowledged that Brexit has been an unbridled disaster for businesses and communities up and down these islands, but let me contrast the ruthlessness with which he dispatched his predecessor with the queasiness with which he now prevaricates over Keir Starmer’s red lines on the European Union. Rejoining is something that his Back Benchers, in their greater number, would support. It is also something that the more progressive members of his Cabinet, all the Liberal Democrats and even the SNP would support him on. With the parliamentary arithmetic and public opinion behind him, why does he continue to kick this can even further down the road? Why does he not just set out when we are rejoining the EU?
The Prime Minister
Well, I am leading on Europe, as I have said today, but I will also stick by what I said at the recent by-election, where I said that I would honour the red lines in the Labour manifesto. That is the answer to the hon. Gentleman’s question. We made a clear commitment. That is a contract with the people, and I will honour it.
Gill German (Clwyd North) (Lab)
The Prime Minister
I completely agree that north Wales needs better transport; it is so connected to the north-west of England. The Welsh Labour Government, when in power, created Transport for Wales, which I believe is one of the better rail operators under public control, but the infrastructure is not good enough, and that often leads to delays. I can commit to work with my hon. Friend and her colleagues to improve transport infrastructure across Wales, but particularly in north Wales, where it does need to be better.
Charlie Dewhirst (Bridlington and The Wolds) (Con)
The Prime Minister
The hon. Gentleman is raising a live public procurement, and in the circumstances, I think it is best that I do not comment in detail on what he has said, but I heard the important points that he raised.
Sarah Smith (Hyndburn) (Lab)
The Prime Minister
I pay tribute to my hon. Friend, because her youth hub in Hyndburn sounds to me like a forerunner of the Milburn report. I have agreed with the Work and Pensions Secretary that we need to see a much more devolved approach to employment support, and this is exactly the type of facility that we need—a place that people do not fear walking into, as they sometimes do when it comes to Jobcentre Plus, and a place that is going to support them. This is entirely in keeping with what we are trying to do, and I will ensure that she gets support for the youth hub in Hyndburn.
Caroline Voaden (South Devon) (LD)
The Prime Minister
I was talking about farming before, but I am going to make the same commitment to the hon. Lady: I will also support our fishing industry, and I look forward to having that conversation with it. We have taken action on fuel duty; obviously, it was frozen in the Budget. I know that there is probably more that can be done, but again, it is really important that we focus on what we can do in the here and now. The Budget did provide help for businesses up and down the country, but we know we need to do more.
Andrew Ranger (Wrexham) (Lab)
The Prime Minister
Yes, certainly, I will congratulate Wales on a genuinely historic victory. Perhaps, in return, the Welsh parliamentary Labour party will congratulate England on their fantastic victory in Spain.
On the question of powers, I am talking to the First Minister of Wales about pushing power further down in Wales, in a similar way to what we see happening in England. It has to be a model that is right for Wales, but the offer is on the table to work to put power right down into the communities of Wales. I look forward to working with my hon. Friend on that, and with Welsh colleagues across the House.
The Prime Minister
I am very keen to pay tribute to the hon. Gentleman, because I know that he has done a really good job on this issue. I hear that from my Parliamentary Private Secretary, my hon. Friend the Member for Scunthorpe (Sir Nicholas Dakin), who has also worked hard on it. We have common cause here, I believe. The hon. Gentleman mentions the strategic sites accelerator, which is backed by £700 million and is open for applications. We would absolutely encourage an application from his area.
My constituent Keaton Slater was just 12 years old when he was killed by a dangerous driver, who then fled to Latvia. His family spent more than two years seeking an extradition. Does the Prime Minister agree that when offenders flee the country and extradition is required before they can face justice, that should be taken into account in sentencing guidance and sentencing decisions?
The Prime Minister
I understand that this case has been referred to the Attorney General’s Office, and I will ask for an update on it myself. If appropriate, I will raise this with the Latvian Prime Minister when I next see him. I credit my hon. Friend for raising this issue, and if she would like to discuss it further, I would be available for that.
Shivani Raja (Leicester East) (Con)
The Prime Minister
I have said repeatedly that the Government I lead will be relentless in tackling violence against women and girls in every single respect, and the everyday harassment that people are on the receiving end of. I am not aware of the case the hon. Lady raises, but I will look into it.
Sagal Abdi-Wali (Holborn and St Pancras) (Lab)
It was a pleasure to welcome my right hon. Friend to my constituency recently. We sat down with the Single Homeless Project, a wonderful and vital service. We spoke to women with lived experience, and heard about the difficulty identifying women who are rough sleeping, as often their homelessness is out of sight and hidden away. Will the Prime Minister support a dedicated women’s census, so that we can understand the full scale of the issue and ensure that support reaches those who need it most?
The Prime Minister
Credit to my hon. Friend for the work that she does on this issue and on homelessness. I remember well the meeting we had at the Single Homeless Project. It is an amazing organisation that made the point that women’s homelessness can often go missed and does not get the same attention, so I support what she is saying on a local census. We have a drive to end rough sleeping; that is a personal priority for me. I will make sure that there is the right focus in councils across the country on women’s homelessness as well.
Andrew George (St Ives) (LD)
The Prime Minister
I did ask officials to look seriously at the hon. Gentleman’s private Member’s Bill. It was felt that it was not the best way to address the issue, but we do not disagree with what he is trying to do. I will ensure that the Housing Minister meets campaigners, as the hon. Gentleman requests. We will see if we can come back to the issue with a workable solution.
Further to the very important points made by my hon. Friend the Member for High Peak (Jon Pearce), the last few weeks have shown us that there is a critical need to hold powerful men to account when they abuse their position, and to tackle the manosphere, but also to create and support alternative places for our young men and boys, with humour and love. Will the Prime Minister therefore join me in thanking Suggs from Madness, Rowan Williams, Ella Vaday from “Drag Race”, Richard Herring and Sanjeev Bhaskar for being willing to start that conversation on International Men’s Day, this Sunday, at the Soho Theatre Walthamstow? It will show that it must be love, not hate, that leads the relationship between men and women in the future.
The Prime Minister
I am more than happy to send that message to all those people, who are brave for stepping forward. We must address this issue of power imbalances in workplaces; in the media industry, as the Culture Secretary is doing; and in our own workplace. There is an obligation on every single Member of this House, as I said, to be relentless in tackling violence and sexual crime against women and girls.
Ayoub Khan (Birmingham Perry Barr) (Ind)
The Prime Minister
The case the hon. Member raises sounds serious. I do not know all the details. It does sound as though there are issues for the Conservative party, although, again, I do not know the full details, but I will ensure that a Minister meets the hon. Member to discuss this.
Peter Lamb (Crawley) (Lab)
Since the Law Commission reforms introduced by the Conservative party, licensing authorities no longer know who is driving cabs in their area. This puts passengers at risk, as Baroness Casey identified, and distorts local markets. Given the Prime Minister’s past remarks on the issue of cross-border hire, will he now act to ensure that taxis are licensed in the areas in which they operate?
The Prime Minister
Yes, I will. This is a matter of public safety—and, actually, of the safety of women and girls. I do not believe it is acceptable that we can have people with licence plates from 100 or 200 miles away operating in an area where the driver cannot be held to account, so the simple answer is yes. This is an issue that I raised as Mayor of Greater Manchester, and I will correct this in this House.
The Prime Minister
As part of a generation of north-west schoolchildren who went on trips to Jodrell Bank, I feel duty-bound to do everything in my power to save that critical infrastructure, which is also part of the heritage of this country. I am with the hon. Lady on this one. We need to find a solution, and I will ensure one is found.
Will the Prime Minister join me in congratulating the England wheelchair rugby league team, which this week became the first men’s team to win the world cup for the third time? As we are celebrating the achievements of our para-athletes, does he agree with me and the Paralympian Richard Whitehead that the achievements of our sportsmen and women with disabilities should never be weaponised against others?
The Prime Minister
I join my hon. Friend in congratulating the whole of the England wheelchair rugby league team. Back-to-back world championships is a phenomenal achievement. It is a thrilling sport, and I know that Mr Speaker gives it his full approval. I thought the comments by Richard Whitehead deserved a response from the right hon. Lady the Leader of the Opposition. She is not listening, but her remarks were crass and insensitive, and I think she should withdraw them.
The Prime Minister
I know the hon. Lady has worked closely with the First Secretary on these issues, who speaks highly of the very effective work that she has done. NDAs should never be used to silence victims. Powerful and wealthy people able to do that—it should not be possible. I pay tribute to the women who have come forward. We never want to see powerful men using the law to silence accusers. We have taken action in the Employment Rights Act 2025, but the First Secretary has assured me that we will go further. We will look at freelancers and do exactly what the hon. Lady says.
Alice Macdonald (Norwich North) (Lab/Co-op)
Olympian Beth Dobbin recently wrote to the Prime Minister about the devastating impact that ME has had on her. Hundreds of thousands of people across the UK live with the heartbreaking effects of ME. Many are left bedbound, with many more left unable to live any semblance of a normal life. But it is an illness that has been overlooked and under-invested in for far too long. Will the Government back Beth’s call for more research funding and take further action to ensure that those suffering with ME get the treatment and support that they need?
The Prime Minister
The Health Secretary will soon be meeting Beth to discuss her experiences. We will ensure that my hon. Friend is kept updated and thank her for raising Beth’s cause in the House. We are supporting cutting-edge research, including a first-of-its-kind programme to study the genetic factors behind the condition, and we are exploring a clinical trial for potential new treatments. Progress is being made, but my hon. Friend is right—more is needed.