(2 days, 9 hours ago)
Commons ChamberAs is customary, the right hon. Gentleman hits the point exactly. There is always a challenge between what we aspire to do and the reality of the circumstances in which we seek to deliver it. New clause 7 seeks a much more rigorous system for companies to declare what they are doing as well as how they are mitigating modern slavery activities. He will almost certainly be of the opinion, as I am, that there are supply chains coming into the UK that are being underwritten and underpinned by modern slavery activities. We should be doing everything we can to remove that element from the supply chain or to remove ourselves from those supply chains. In some cases, as with the materials that he talks about, that will mean an incredibly difficult set of conversations that we need to have with international partners, but we should not shy away from doing that, because it is the right thing to do.
It is not going to be easy, and neither is it going to happen overnight, but part of the way in which we can drive change is by consumers in the UK having a better understanding of where the products they buy come from and the labour that is being used to construct the products. That would then drive the Government to think, “We are going to have to find a way of making this that does not rely on slave labour, mainly coming out of China.”
Does not the hon. Member think there might be an opportunity in this broad sweep of legislation to put more consequence on businesses using slave-labour goods? He is arguing that we should do more encouragement, while I would argue that we need to take a firm stance and ensure that action is applied.
Ben Goldsborough
No, I am saying that the new clause proposed by the Liberal Democrats is unenforceable. We must be serious about legislation that we try to pass in this House. If we try to pass legislation that finds us in the wrong, while also not being able to do the grown-up politics of international negotiations, we will look ridiculous in the eyes of our constituents.
That brings me to the amendments tabled by His Majesty’s loyal Opposition. My constituents know exactly where the approach of performative politics gets us. We saw it with the Brook hotel, where asylum accommodation was placed just 500 yards down the road from residents, without proper consultation. People were left feeling ignored and taken for granted. That is what happens when politics becomes about headlines rather than delivering workable solutions and engaging with communities. The Bill seeks to take a different approach. It is compassionate but firm, protects our international commitments while restoring common sense, and it puts in place a rules-based system that the public can have confidence in. That is what South Norfolk residents expect Parliament to deliver, and it is time that we got on and passed the Bill.
Another aspect of the Bill that is important to reiterate, and vital for my constituents, is the provision that allows the Secretary of State to require payment from people who have received asylum support. That is welcomed by my constituents, but it is vital to reiterate that there is a carve-out to ensure that minors, under the age of 18, who receive asylum support are not liable for those costs later on, which underlines the fact that the Bill is firm but fair.
As the Bill goes forward for consideration in the other place, I hope we can show that we take these matters seriously. I thank the Bill Committee members from across the House for discussing the issue in a grown-up way. We need to take the heat out of the debate, so that we consider things that benefit our constituents and do not divide our communities.
There is much in the Bill that I agree with and support. However, there is a danger that it presents a missed opportunity to deliver a greater and better good, so most of my comments will address new clauses 4, 5 and 7. I thank the Independent Anti-Slavery Commissioner, Eleanor Lyons, the charities Hope for Justice, Unseen and the Human Trafficking Foundation, and, of course, the brilliant Clerks for the drafting of new clauses 4 and 5—I hope that will get me further assistance in future.
The scope of the Bill is broad and it covers many aspects of the subject. When I was Chief Whip, I would probably have described it as something of a Christmas tree, as it both offers opportunities and presents problems for the Government. It touches on human trafficking, but it does not really seek to do anything. In this country we should be rightly proud of the historical role that this House played in tackling slavery right around the world, including the actions of the West Africa Squadron. We have led the way, not just in words and ideals but, just as importantly, with actions.
Like many Members of the House, I feel proud of my small role—of course your role was much larger than mine, Madam Deputy Speaker—in the Modern Slavery Act, which all Members voted for when it was passed in 2015. In reality, that Act went some way towards making the moral arguments, but it did not go far enough on enforcement—there was no West Africa Squadron as a result of that Act. We talked a good talk, but we did not do enough to follow up, which is what I seek to amend through new clauses 4 and 5. The Bill should be about more than just a good argument and good deeds; it should be about actions flowing from those moral arguments.
As was articulately put by the hon. Member for Stoke-on-Trent Central (Gareth Snell), the Modern Slavery Act went some way but does not have the enforcement element. I would be bolder than him and say that we have to go further than what is proposed in new clause 7. We know that there are certain parts of the world that produce goods under slave labour, so we can designate those areas, which is what new clauses 4 and 5 aim to do. The Minister for Border Security and Asylum is an incredibly thoughtful and passionate woman, who came into politics to make a difference, in common with so many of us in this House. The Bill tackles many issues, but it leaves that question open and it could do more.
The issue of goods produced under slave labour is impacting our businesses in the United Kingdom. The Government say that they want to build more houses, but we do not want those houses to be built from bricks that are produced by slave labour in other countries. This is not a marginal thing—we are talking about almost 50 million people across the globe who are either in slave labour or indentured labour, almost the same number as the population of Spain. I beseech the Minister to work with me, the other organisations I mentioned and the Independent Anti-Slavery Commissioner to do everything we can do to ensure the Bill tackles those issues.
I very much support what the right hon. Gentleman is saying. Does he share my concern that, as these rules are crafted, victims of slavery and trafficking in our communities who might have found safe harbour in this country will be unable to get citizenship because of the good character requirement that we are introducing into law? Will he consider my amendment 75, which would support those victims of trafficking?
I thank the hon. Lady for drawing attention to amendment 75. I am afraid that I cannot read through it all at the moment, but I am very happy to look at it. She makes an important point.
We have a duty to the victims of slavery, but we also have a duty to ensure that the legislation we already have on our statute book has teeth, with the ability to have an effect and an impact. As we go through this process, I urge the Minister to look at how we can improve this legislation and make it something that the whole House is able to support.
Olivia Bailey (Reading West and Mid Berkshire) (Lab)
Today, across our country, hundreds of thousands of children were sitting in classrooms, eager to learn, laughing with their friends and planning for their futures. Those children are not strangers or a threat; they are simply children, and they deserve the opportunity and protection that our great nation offers. I will today speak to my amendments, which are designed to help ensure that is the case.
Let me turn to my new clause 71. This Government have important ambitions to drive down child poverty and give every child in this country the best start in life. My new clause asks them to demonstrate how they will protect those commitments. The Women and Equalities Committee heard compelling evidence earlier this month about the impact of longer routes to settlement on children, and I have written to the Home Secretary from the Committee asking for greater clarity on pathways for children. In addition to commenting on the substance of my amendments, will the Minister provide that clarity and set out how this Government will protect the rights of children with these reforms?
Let me turn to my amendment 76. Clause 41 of the Bill requires well-known indicators of child abuse to be damaging to a child’s credibility when determining whether they are a victim of modern slavery. The independent inquiry into child sexual abuse found that children frequently delay disclosing abuse because of fear, shame, threats and a lack of trust in adults. The Home Office’s own guidance explicitly recognises that conflicting accounts from children can be a common indicator of trafficking. Child victims often do not recognise themselves as victims and cannot consent to their own exploitation. I urge Ministers to amend the clause to ensure that recognised signs of child abuse are not used as reasons to fail to protect a victim of modern slavery. Amendment 77 would also extend protections for vulnerable young people who are at risk of exploitation by extending the child trafficking guardian measures to the age of 25 for looked-after children.
Let me turn to my new clause 70. There is no more important responsibility than looking after children in care, providing those children who have already experienced significant trauma and pain with stability and opportunity, and helping those children to resolve their immigration status, but our current system is not working for children in care. Coram shared with me the story of Aisha, who lived in the UK from the age of six and was taken into care when she had just turned 13 years old. Aisha did not know that she had been brought to the UK on a temporary visa as a child. No one in children’s services knew how to resolve that, and no action was taken. Aisha still had no immigration status when she turned 18, which meant that she could not work, get a student loan or claim benefits, and she was barred in every practical way from leading an independent life. By that time, it was too late for any of the simpler and quicker routes to immigration status or citizenship that had been available to Aisha as a looked-after child.
Coram’s research shows that at the end of 2021 there were 19,000 children and care leavers with an immigration or citizenship issue in England. For all those children, the lack of status or citizenship has a huge impact on their mental health, sense of belonging and ability to plan. As such, I welcome the Government’s commitment in their May 2025 White Paper to solve that problem—to establish a clear pathway to settlement for children in care who reach adulthood without having secured their immigration status, and to ensure that children who turn 18 and discover they do not have status are supported and able quickly to regularise their status and settle. That commitment was repeated in the November 2025 earned settlement consultation, but in the Government’s response to that consultation earlier this month, it seems to have changed. Will the Minister tell the House today whether the Government remain committed to developing a clear pathway to settlement for children in care, and to supporting any care leaver without status to resolve it fast?
(2 weeks, 3 days ago)
Commons ChamberIf my right hon. Friend’s constituent has met the terms of his visa, as I set out in my statement he will be able to apply for indefinite leave to remain at five years. At the point of settlement, people are able to access the benefits system.
Restricting access to public funds to those with settlement rights will most likely require primary legislation. When will such a Bill be brought forward?
The Government are not restricting benefits for those with settlement rights. The right hon. Gentleman is absolutely right that not only does that require primarily legislation, but it would create two-tier settlement rights. The rules on no access to public funds apply before somebody can achieve settlement to make sure that those who have had to fall on the state to seek assistance are still working for a period before they apply for settlement.
(3 weeks, 3 days ago)
Commons Chamber
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for the Home Department (Satvir Kaur)
I thank my hon. Friend for her question. As she will know, there are dedicated teams in every single police force. The Health Secretary has announced the steps to change in our local GP practices, and we are working across Government to halve violence against women and girls.
There is wide consensus across the House on the need to tackle modern slavery. The Modern Slavery Act 2015 went a long way towards doing that, but fails to have any real teeth to stop slave-produced goods being sold in this country. The Immigration and Asylum Bill presents this House with an opportunity to give that Act some real teeth. Will the Secretary of State or the Minister sit down with me to discuss the options to give that Act teeth?
I thank the right hon. Gentleman for raising such an important point. As he will know, our modern slavery arrangements are subject to strengthening in the Immigration and Asylum Bill, which is currently going through this House. I would be happy to ensure that he can speak to either myself or one of my Ministers to discuss whether further changes need to be made.
(4 months ago)
Commons ChamberI am conscious of the short time we have. I will concentrate most of my comments on clauses 44 to 49. This is a Bill about our border, who crosses it and on what terms, but a border policy that scrutinises every person while waving through products of slavery is really only half a border policy. The slavery that we see in the modern world impacts every part of the globe, and greatly impacts this country. One in five cotton garments worldwide is linked to forced labour in China, and Parliament’s Joint Committee on Human Rights warned in July 2025 that the UK risked becoming “a dumping ground” for goods prohibited elsewhere. The International Labour Organisation estimates that forced labour generates roughly £176 billion in illegal profits every year. The Bill does many things, and I welcome many of them, but when it comes to combating modern slavery, which is mentioned in its long title, it does nothing more than offer meek and weak words.
Members on both sides of the House have often worked together to make a difference—we led the world in tackling modern slavery—but we see the United States charging ahead and taking more action than we are. If we look across the channel, which we all talk so much about in this debate, we see that the European Union is doing more than we are doing in this House. What are we proposing to do? We are just asking for a little more reporting. We are not acting to stop goods produced by slavery coming to these shores. In fact, we will act as a magnet for slave-produced goods from not just China, but so many other countries that turn a blind eye to slave labour.
While there is much that I welcome in the Bill, I urge the Government to look at how they can work cross-party, so that they can have an improved Bill that protects some of the most vulnerable people in the poorest parts of the world from being exploited. If they do that, they will have made a much better Bill than the one currently in front of the House.
(7 months, 3 weeks ago)
Commons ChamberI absolutely agree. The Home Office is working closely with other Departments to ensure that, where someone goes missing, there is a joined-up response, through child protection reforms, updating key multi-agency safeguarding guidance and the better use of technology—for instance our investment in the tackling organised exploitation programme.
With the Government’s plans to regionalise police forces and the potential scrapping of Staffordshire constabulary, many involved in the care of vulnerable young people fear that there will be less focus on protecting children as fewer senior police officers will be working with local authorities to ensure that they are cared for. What actions will the Minister take to ensure that that does not happen?
The right hon. Gentleman raises a key point about how safeguarding will be rooted at the heart of the reforms that will be brought forward. I work frequently with the Minister for Children and others to ensure that whatever local multi-agency hubs are set up are fit for now and for the future. I assure the right hon. Gentleman that I will take what he has said in good faith and ensure that that is the case.
(8 months, 1 week ago)
Commons ChamberI will bank the fact that the hon. Gentleman agrees with my instincts on this one—perhaps I am not so authoritarian after all. He raises a more serious point about dissidents. We know the threat posed to dissidents here on UK soil by the Iranian regime. He rightly noted an earlier case. Let me assure him that we work very closely with Counter Terrorism policing and our security services on monitoring the threats posed to all individuals in the UK by foreign states. We are always ready to take any appropriate action. Indeed, the police and the security services take action every day.
I very much welcome the Home Secretary’s decision. Iran has a track record of hostile activity in the United Kingdom. We have so many Iranians who have had to flee their home country for safety here in the UK, yet we still see charities effectively operating as proxies for the terrible regime in Tehran. What further action will the Home Secretary take to clamp down on organisations that masquerade as charities?
The Charity Commission has powers to launch its own inquiries and enforce compliance. It has a full suite of powers to take action if it thinks someone has fallen outside of our rules. There is an ongoing Charity Commission investigation into the overall body relating to the IHRC—the trust, rather than the organisation we are discussing here today. I am sure that once the Charity Commission has completed that work it will take appropriate action, and I know that that will be the subject of further discussion in this House. Let me assure the right hon. Gentleman that we recognise the desire by some to use our charities legislation and to find gaps to pursue ends that are not charitable and for which the law was not intended. We will not hesitate to take further action in that area if we need to do so.
(9 months, 1 week ago)
Commons ChamberUnlike most of Westminster, I am not plagued with “America brain”, and I do not spend any of my time worrying about what is happening over in the States. As the Home Secretary, I focus on my day job, which is protecting people in our country. The hon. Gentleman will know full well that we do not have anything like the sorts of arrangements that we have seen over in America, but we already have record removals without having armed immigration enforcement—just under 60,000 since we have been in government. We will go further, but we will do so in line with the arrangements that we already have in place and our British values.
The murder of Martha Giles in 1959 was particularly horrific, and I can only imagine the pain and suffering that her family have been through, given that the case is still ongoing and there has never been justice. I am advised that decisions about opening or closing the National Archives’ records on the murder of Martha Giles are a matter for the Metropolitan Police Service and not for us, but I am very happy to facilitate the introductions that the right hon. Gentleman might want with the Met police.
I know that the Minister is a deeply compassionate lady. On 12 February 1959, Martha Giles was brutally murdered leaving her work at New Cross hospital in Wolverhampton. She left behind five children. Only one of those children, Mrs Edwards, is still alive today, and she desperately seeks answers. I know that it is not within the Minister’s gift, but if there is any way to convene officials and officers in the Metropolitan police, just to be able to bring some closure to this awful chapter, it would be deeply appreciated.
I thank the right hon. Member, and I again offer my condolences to Martha’s family, who have been looking for justice for many decades. I am happy to do what I can within the bounds of what I am allowed to do, and I will ensure that we make the appropriate introductions for him.
(10 months ago)
Commons ChamberI thank my hon. Friend and fellow Birmingham colleague for her question. That is exactly why I have made the statement I have, because I believe all of us in this country need to be able to trust the police when they come forward and say that they have risk assessed an upcoming event and come to a professional judgment as to whether the event can take place safely. We all need to be able to trust that they have gone about making that risk assessment in a way that is robust, consistent, in line with the law and, frankly, just plain old truthful. That is not what has happened in this case. It is why it has been debilitating to public confidence in policing in our great city and across our region, but also across the country. It is why I set out what I have said about losing confidence in the chief constable and why I believe some powers for oversight of policing need to return to the Home Secretary directly.
The Home Secretary is right to talk about the need for the information to be out there and for openness. In the light of that, can she clarify whether any Government officials talked to Maccabi Tel Aviv as a club or through either of the embassies to discuss the decision by the club to say that away fans would not travel even if the ban were lifted?
I think all the conversations that have happened were set out by one of my officials and by the Policing Minister when they gave evidence to the Home Affairs Committee. I am not aware of any other discussions, certainly not from the Home Office. I can write to the right hon. Member in case there were discussions in other Departments that might also have had an interest.
(11 months, 1 week ago)
Commons ChamberUrgent Questions are proposed each morning by backbench MPs, and up to two may be selected each day by the Speaker. Chosen Urgent Questions are announced 30 minutes before Parliament sits each day.
Each Urgent Question requires a Government Minister to give a response on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
I was not a party to conversations between Aston Villa and UEFA, nor was I a party to the decision- making process. The Government have no political involvement whatsoever in the safety advisory groups—we do not feed into that process at all. That is one of the questions we are looking at, because perhaps that is not the right model for the future.
Right across the political spectrum, I think everyone feels that this was a poor decision and a bad decision, which is why it has unravelled so quickly. Can the Minister reassure the House that there was absolutely no local political interference in making this decision?
The right hon. Gentleman knows that I cannot tell him the motivation for any of the decisions that were made. The Prime Minister’s clear view is that the decision made by the safety advisory group was the wrong decision and that we must ensure that this does not happen again. Safety advisory groups are local groups, with local representatives. The police advise those groups on the safety of events and a licence is then given for that event. Perhaps that structure needs to be looked at, particularly if there are issues of national significance, when there may be a role of national politicians. The operational independence of the police is really important and we have to make sure that we do not ride roughshod over that. That said, we also have to get to the bottom of what happened in this case.
(1 year ago)
Commons ChamberI thank my hon. Friend for welcoming this announcement. The transition to the mayoral model is complex, and people will have different views, opinions and fights locally about what comes next. I believe the mayoral model to be a good one. I think most people see the benefits, and on the whole this Government are in favour of ensuring we have the mayoral model where we can. I certainly think it is the best model for policing.
The last Labour Government forced through the merger of Staffordshire ambulance service with West Midlands ambulance service, and Staffordshire ended up with a poorer service. There will be and is real concern in Staffordshire that these reforms could lead to a merger and the takeover of the Staffordshire police force by the West Midlands police force. Can the Minister assure the House that that will not happen?
The announcement today is on police and crime commissioners, which will not change those boundaries.