Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
Greg Smith
Main Page: Greg Smith (Conservative - Mid Buckinghamshire)Department Debates - View all Greg Smith's debates with the Department for Transport
(1 month ago)
Commons ChamberHow we pay for infrastructure is a matter that the House needs to take extraordinarily seriously. When the Government announced that they would bring forward measures set out in the King’s Speech on using private finance to build new roads, Labour Members should not have been surprised. After all, the Prime Minister was one of the most effective defenders of PFI schemes in the NHS during his previous time in government, and as Mayor of Greater Manchester his effusive praise of the investment from Manchester City shows his willingness to back private finance. It should therefore come as little surprise that the Government are interested in how we can leverage private funding for our roads. The Minister set out in his opening remarks that this is the biggest change in this area since the 18th century. Well, the Bill does indeed once more open the back door to highway robbery.
Having reflected on the debate and listened to the contributions of hon. Members from across the House, I think that most hon. Members recognise the importance of finding innovative methods to build infrastructure. Members from across the House can look at examples of cost overruns on infrastructure—particularly on the lower Thames crossing—that has used private money and incentives to increase road capacity and improve the experience for drivers. As the Government’s own slightly outdated figures in their impact assessment set out, the vast majority of miles travelled across our country are travelled in our cars, and over two thirds of freight is transported on the strategic road network. That point shone through in many of the contributions.
We started with the hon. Member for Northampton South (Mike Reader) and his public service safety announcement. He was followed quickly by the Lib Dem spokesman, the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage (Olly Glover), who, in true third-party style, could not muster up a speech without a European comparison. He was followed quickly by my hon. Friend the Member for Christchurch (Sir Christopher Chope), who brought us his memories of 1991 and Her late Majesty, focused on a case of private enterprise at its very best: the QEII bridge. He then shared ideas with the House, based on his ministerial experience. His points on London’s bridges were particularly well made.
Charlie Dewhirst (Bridlington and The Wolds) (Con)
The issue with London’s bridges is highlighted by Hammersmith bridge, which has been closed since 2019. Is it not time for the Government to get a grip on Labour-run Hammersmith and Fulham council and the Labour Mayor of London, and get that bridge reopened?
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for that intervention. Many moons ago, he and I were Conservative councillors in the London borough of Hammersmith and Fulham. I remember in 2014, when I was leader of the opposition on that council—we had a small electoral mishap, and the Labour party had taken control of the council once more—trying to call out the Labour-run council for failing to take the steps necessary to put a plan in place to fix Hammersmith bridge. Today, it remains closed to traffic. That is a bridge owned by the London borough of Hammersmith and Fulham—it is Labour-run, and it is a Labour failure to get that bridge open again.
Daniel Francis
We were all very interested to hear the view of the hon. Member for Christchurch (Sir Christopher Chope) that charging should be spread across London river crossings. What is the shadow Minister’s analysis of the proposal that the cost of river crossings be spread more widely among taxpayers in London?
I think I am grateful for that intervention. My hon. Friend the Member for Christchurch put some ideas in front of the House that are not necessarily shared by the Conservative Front Benchers. However, his fundamental point—that we have London bridges closed to traffic, and Labour councils such as Hammersmith and Fulham are failing to fix them—desperately needs to be addressed in the interests of motorists in London, and in particular the residents of the London boroughs of Hammersmith and Fulham, and of Richmond.
On the point of charging Londoners for driving, over the past two years, we have seen the Mayor of London introduce the Silvertown tunnel charge, and for the first time, there is a Blackwall tunnel charge. The price for drivers has already risen. The Government have even increased the Dartford crossing charge by around 40%.
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for that point. We will come on to those charges later. One thing that has shone through in this debate is that no one can tell us—unless the Minister pulls a rabbit from a hat in his wind-up and gives us a figure—what the charge will be to use the lower Thames crossing once it is built.
Daniel Francis
I am aware that my neighbour the hon. Member for Old Bexley and Sidcup (Mr French) has not been here for the debate. We have discussed the fact that the charges at Blackwall and Silvertown were introduced, as a result of the 2018 order, under the Conservative Government. The increases were made under that order, introduced by the previous Conservative Government. Can the shadow Minister confirm that all those measures were introduced not by this Government, but his?
The hon. Gentleman wants me to get on to road charging, but I do not think that the Labour party wants me to go through the record of the Labour Mayor of London; he introduced the ULEZ and hiked the congestion charge to unaffordable levels.
To move on to another London Member of Parliament, the Chairman of the Transport Committee, the hon. Member for Brentford and Isleworth (Ruth Cadbury) said that she wanted more powers for the ORR on sustainability, as if banning diesel and HVO in the construction of the lower Thames crossing was not bonkers enough. However, I agree with her about HGV driver facilities. I remember in the last Parliament serving alongside her on the Transport Committee when we did an important report on that and visited Thurrock services. The lorry driver was not what I would classically call delighted when the whole Select Committee was shown the shower facilities that he was using at the time to see that the tiles were falling off and everything was not fully in order.
My right hon. Friend the Member for Rayleigh and Wickford (Mr Francois) injected some common sense into the debate, asking serious questions steeped in the history of the project that affects his constituents. He mentioned their scepticism about the cost and the opening date of the lower Thames crossing. We also heard thoughtful contributions from the hon. Members for Chatham and Aylesford (Tristan Osborne), for Bootle (Peter Dowd), for Bexleyheath and Crayford (Daniel Francis), for Thurrock (Jen Craft) and for Dartford (Jim Dickson).
The shadow Secretary of State for Transport, my right hon. Friend the Member for Basildon and Billericay (Mr Holden), raised a fundamental question during his opening remarks: is this the right type of legislation? Why on earth have the Government drafted the Bill in a way that could feasibly allow charges be to be imposed simply for using roads beyond the tolls? Why is that a concern? Well, to quote clause 3 of the Bill:
“A licensing authority may grant a licence to a person authorising the person to charge tolls in respect of the use or keeping of road vehicles on a highway specified in the licence, in return for the person securing works involving…the maintenance, operation or improvement of a highway specified in the licence which has been…constructed in pursuance of the licence or another licence under this section”.
I fear we risk smuggling in charges on drivers through the back door, and are opening the door to the tolling of the M25 and beyond.
At a time when drivers are getting squeezed at the pump and the Government are cancelling multiple schemes, we must be completely clear that the Bill as it stands is not acceptable. That is why my right hon. Friend the shadow Secretary of State tabled our sensible reasoned amendment. We cannot pass a Bill that could impose costs on drivers without a requirement to deliver significantly increased capacity and new schemes.
The Government say that only new big roads will be included, but they have failed to explain why the Bill allows new infrastructure to fall within the scope of tolling. The use of the term “infrastructure” may paint a picture of an entirely new road scheme, but what is there to stop it being something as small as a new set of smart motorway cameras? The Government may protest that that is unfeasible. If so, why will they not amend the Bill to make that abundantly clear? They should put it on the face of the Bill.
By going well beyond the scope of the lower Thames crossing, the legislation puts in place a scheme that is not fit for purpose. If we do not limit its scope, I fear that the words of the president of the AA will be ringing in the ears of drivers. He has said that drivers already pay for roads through £34 billion in fuel duty and road taxes, so extra charges across the road network would be a “toll too far”. As I said earlier, no one can tell us what the tolls for private motorists and HGV drivers will be.
We want the Government to bear down on the costs of building, which make such projects so expensive. That is why we announced at the Conservative party conference that we would leave the Aarhus convention and tackle the rules that allow costly and protracted legal challenges. If we want to achieve low toll prices for drivers and incentivise private investment to build the project at a lower cost, we must reduce the regulatory burden on those involved, as opposed to imposing burdens such as banning diesel machinery. We should use equipment that is cost-effective to get the best deal for motorists, rather than trying to achieve ideological purity.
It is not merely the costs that we have to consider; there is also the structure of the scheme. As has been noted, the RAB model used by the Government will be dependent on the work of the Office of Rail and Road. At a time when the Government are trying to restrict the powers available to the ORR to uphold competition in rail, the organisation that will regulate the scheme will have to have regard to matters including efficiency and economy, the ability of licence holders to finance their licensed activities, safety, impacts on the wider strategic road network, sustainable development, competition and regulatory best practice. It is one rule for road and another for rail, with no consistency from this Government. That really matters.
As the Government’s own impact assessment sets out, using the RAB model for the strategic road network would be a new application of the model. In the literature about the scheme, one of the central principles is the need for a regulator that can control costs and serve drivers. The ORR may be able to achieve that, but we are going in blind. We need complete clarity from the Government about how the scheme will actually work, in addition to answers to the fair questions that have been raised by Members from across the House about the tolling regime. We cannot treat drivers like a piggy bank.
At the Labour party conference, the Prime Minister told the country that people “need breathing space now”, and that he was “determined to provide it.” If Labour MPs want to follow the Prime Minister’s words, they must send a clear message back: unless this Bill clearly prohibits charging drivers for using existing roads, it cannot be allowed to pass through this House.
Highways (Financing) Bill (First sitting) Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateGreg Smith
Main Page: Greg Smith (Conservative - Mid Buckinghamshire)Department Debates - View all Greg Smith's debates with the Department for Transport
(2 weeks, 4 days ago)
Public Bill CommitteesQ
On one level the Bill, particularly on Second Reading and in other narratives that have come out since it was first published, seems to be presented as answering the question: how do you solve a problem like the lower Thames crossing? But it equally has a lot of other provisions—perhaps it is due to badly drafted clauses or perhaps it is deliberate—that seem to allow tolling and road pricing to extend further than the lower Thames crossing. Is that something your organisations are concerned about, and do you feel enough focus has been given to parts of Bill related to everything other than the lower Thames crossing—to the general motorists in this country?
Edmund King: Obviously if you look at the need for the lower Thames crossing—the congestion and the environmental issues currently at Dartford—it is easy to see that some alternative solution is needed. But, as you rightly say, this Bill is not just about the lower Thames crossing; it could allow that finance model with other schemes. It might have been easier if it was concentrated on the lower Thames crossing because then you could have brought in more restrictions and safeguards on tolls for motorists.
As the Bill stands, on the one hand you have the Office of Rail and Road as the regulator for it, and then you have drivers who are the consumers, whether they are individual motorists or heavy goods vehicle drivers. To some extent, there might be a conflict between those two. The ORR has to ensure that the licensee makes money from it so it can be viable, but at the same time, it regulates tolls for the drivers. You could argue that there might be a conflict in that at times.
When we looked at similar schemes before—I did a paper on road miles with an economist, which looked at the broader issue of road pricing—one thing we called for was an independent body to oversee tolling and ensure it is fair. I certainly think that the responsibility of the ORR when it comes to tolls could be strengthened and given more independence within the Bill.
Steve Gooding: Clearly, the Committee will want to look very closely at clause 3, which I think is the key thing here. Yes, we looked at it and wondered whether this was a way of creating a framework that could then be applied to the existing road network and the existing motorway network. Clearly, the provisions relate to the trunk roads—the National Highways roads.
I think the way clause 3 is drafted tightens that down to where capacity is being added, but we want the Committee to look at how much capacity is being added in order to make that a valid use of the powers in the Bill. Is it simply, for example, playing tunes with the speed limits or maybe adding a lane? What is it? In those circumstances, would we really be contemplating transferring sections of the existing national road network over to a private company? I do not think that is the intention, but the intention is not always the actuality.
Q
“A licence may also provide for the holder of the licence to secure the maintenance, operation or improvement of any other highway”.
Is it the view of your organisation and members that people would expect that to be about an entirely new road or perhaps a dualled road where there is currently a single carriageway, rather than making what many might consider a relatively minor improvement, such as—I do not know whether this is an improvement—adding smart motorway cameras?
Steve Gooding: Our understanding of it, and this is why I think the Committee will want to make sure this is clear, is that the subsections of clause 3 relate back to each other. It is not relatively minor maintenance of itself that would enable the licence to be awarded. In our reading of it, it has to be linked back to enhancement and capacity—but perhaps the Minister will want to make that clearer.
Q
Edmund King: You can say that in relation to the lower Thames crossing, because in that part you know the two elements—one is the current Dartford crossing; one is the new crossing—and you can look in that area. But if you look at the Bill more generally, it is very difficult to say because we do not know where it will be applied. Clause 3(1)(a) does say
“construction of a highway specified in the licence”,
but we obviously do not know where that highway is or what the competing interests are with housing, the economy, routes and so on. In terms of this Bill, it is difficult to say unless a concrete scheme is being considered.
Steve Gooding: It is within the duties that are being placed on the Secretary of State to consider where these powers will be used: there are duties in relation to having regard to users of the network, for example. It could be made more explicit. After all, we are talking about a national asset here, and if faced with a toll and an alternative, people might well choose the alternative, with negative traffic impacts in the round. That would have to be taken into account.
Q
There is a narrative that the Bill is a Trojan horse for widespread road charging. We have made it very clear that the operation of this legislation will be for specific and limited circumstances. Is there something more that we can do or say to reassure you that there is no secret plan to widely use this?
Steve Gooding: I certainly do not think that it is a conscious Trojan horse, if I may say that, but having been involved in similar drafting exercises before, one always wants to destruction test whether something could be used in a way that was not anticipated. When one looks at the proposals for the Dartford crossing and the lower Thames, you are bundling the existing crossing into the package, as it were, that the private sector licensee is going to run. One wonders whether there might be other instances where something will be brought into the ambit of the licence that we will not have been expecting or intending at the point of passing the legislation, for which we might need further tightening of clause 3.
Edmund King: Part of the problem with Governments and tolls is their previous record. If you go back to the original Dartford crossing, the tolls were meant to be removed when the bridge was paid for and certain maintenance was put aside; that occurred in 2003, and subsequent Governments have not removed them. Drivers do remember that Governments have rescinded their promises, so there is that mistrust. Having said that, when we talk to drivers about new infrastructure—and about it being new infrastructure, not existing infrastructure—they are much more open to it being tolled because they can see the benefits in time savings, reducing congestion and so on. Certainly with the lower Thames crossing, they can see the benefits from that.
The Chair
We will now hear oral evidence from Logistics UK, the Road Haulage Association and M6toll. For this session we have until 12.45 pm. Will the witnesses briefly introduce themselves for the record, please?
Ben Garratt: I am Ben Garratt, interim director of policy and communications at Logistics UK.
Michael Whelan: I am Michael Whelan, general manager at M6toll.
Declan Pang: I am Declan Pang, director of policy at the Road Haulage Association.
Q
Ben Garratt: It is a tricky question. What we know is that the current situation and reliance on the Dartford crossing costs the logistics sector, as well as other users of the crossing, a lot in terms of the congestion that comes from that. The cost of sitting in traffic is estimated at £200 million a year. That is based on the time sitting doing nothing, but does not take into account the wider cost to the logistics sector and supply chains of goods not arriving on time. It is just based on the wasted time of the driver. We also know that reliability, or lack of it, is a cost borne by the sector that is then passed on.
When we speak to our members, they tell us that what they want is a reliable transport system so they can factor in how much a job is going to take—how much time, how many drivers and what they should charge for it—and unreliability means it is much harder to do that. As a sector we potentially have more assets than we need to cover the same amount of ground, which is why it is really important for the sector that capacity increases and why we support, therefore, the delivery of the lower Thames crossing.
In terms of a breaking point it is quite tricky because the reason that the sector has a low margin—between 1% and 3%—is because it is a highly competitive sector. It is a feature of the sector rather than something we would say we complain about. It is because there are lots of logistics businesses all competing with each other to deliver the best price. When there are cost pressures on the sector over the medium to long term, it generally keeps that margin where it is, but it results in the overall cost being passed on to the public. Unless it is priced ludicrously, the risk is more about the overall cost being passed on to the public rather than it breaking the operators, as it were.
Q
Ben Garratt: No, we do not. We would say that the inflationary impact is a balance between the direct input costs—paying a toll, fuel duty and taxes—and the indirect costs of congestion. As a sector, we want to keep those two things in balance, but one of the things that we do want is more investment in the transport network—road, rail and beyond—because some real hotspots are causing congestion and therefore passing the cost on. This is one of them, but it is not the only one.
We need to make sure that is in balance. We are not disputing building this particular crossing, but not building things in general has a cost in itself. It is about making sure that this is fair, and therefore about considering the different ways of paying for it. Traditionally, such things have been done under general taxation, which we all pay for, but given the fiscal situation, we as a sector are not against a toll approach, a private finance approach, for this particular crossing.
This crossing is one heavily used by the logistics sector. For us, it is a key part of the trading route between Scotland, the midlands and the north, and Europe; it is not simply an issue for the east of London, Essex and Kent. We want to see it happen and, as a sector, we are prepared to help pay for it. We just want to make sure that the toll takes into account the different vehicles, and that the different toll rates for different vehicles take the sector into account. The toll should not be based just on the weight of vehicle, and wear and tear; we need to take into account the economic value that the logistics sector provides to the rest of the country. Ultimately, we all pay for that in a way that is slightly different from other road users.
Q
Declan Pang: The cost and affordability of toll rates is a significant concern for us. As you all know, the majority of those in the haulage sector are small and medium-sized enterprises. Small businesses, many of them microbusinesses, are the major users of the trunk road network, so their interests need to be front and centre of how toll rates are set. At the moment, we also have quite a fragile situation in the haulage sector—a particular rate of mergers and acquisitions, as well as a high rate of insolvencies—and that difficult climate has certainly been exacerbated by higher input costs and fuel costs. That should certainly be considered when the Bill is looked at.
In the Bill itself, we are particularly concerned about the affordability of tolls and the transparency of how those tolls will be set, as well as the wider impact of the financing model. We would very much like MPs to think about and look at how tolls will be calculated, how they might increase over time, and how the ORR, as the regulator, will assess the affordability of tolls, because we do not feel that that is clearly set out, as the Bill stands. Lots of concern is about whether the Government have plans to use the Bill powers to introduce tolls on roads that are currently free. We certainly seek additional assurances on that point from the Minister.
Q
Declan Pang: Absolutely. The costs of constructing these schemes are essential in terms of reducing the level of tolls. We particularly think that the Bill as drafted is quite open ended in terms of the phrases it uses. As a previous witness said, affordability should be part of it, rather than just “fair and transparent”. We would like to see that included. We are very supportive of Jim Dickson’s amendment on the rates as well. We would like to see more consideration given to affordability for businesses.
Ben Garratt: I agree with everything Declan said. In the assurances space, clause 1 talks about the ORR having regard to economy. That also comes up in other clauses of the Bill. We would like assurances that that includes an understanding that freight and supply chains are a part of “economy”. It is quite a broad term otherwise.
Q
Michael Whelan: Our specific interest in the Bill is part 7, which will enable us to introduce free-flow tolling. At the moment, on the M6 toll, we have barriers where you need to slow down, stop and pay. Part 7 of the Bill is the first step for us to enable free-flow tolling, which will help my freight and logistics friends sitting to either side of me—they will not have to slow down and stop. That has many benefits, including time savings. The M6 toll is a very reliable route compared with the alternatives, so it further increases that reliability through increased time savings. It will also mean reduced carbon dioxide emissions because of less stopping and starting.
Q
Ben Garratt: The current situation lacks resilience. The sector uses the Dartford crossing, which crosses east of London, as a part of what I describe as a core route for the whole country; it connects Scotland and the north, the midlands, the south-east and Europe on that trading route, particularly in trading across the short straits, which handle more than half of all goods traded between Britain and mainland Europe. It is a really important part of the network to get right and it is currently overloaded. As we know, it is causing significant congestion, which adds costs. As you have noted, that is not simply an even matter of a busy road; it is also the crossing being closed to allow hazardous goods to cross, which everyone else has to wait for. That has a significant impact across the whole network. It is not sustainable.
That also takes into account the assumption that the crossing is broadly open all the time, but things will need repairing over their lifetime. Across the rest of the transport network, there is the structures fund and National Highways is focused on other structures that will need repairing at some point. We have a resilience challenge as well as a costs challenge because of that capacity issue.
Declan Pang: We absolutely need to increase the resilience of that particular route as well as the whole road network. Vehicle miles are increasing and congestion is forecast to increase, so this is a problem we have to get ahead of. That means making sure we can increase trunk road capacity.
The Chair
We will now hear oral evidence from Transport Action Network. We have until 1 pm for this session. Will the witness briefly introduce themselves for the record?
Ralph Smyth: My name is Ralph Smyth and I am here on behalf of Transport Action Network. I have about 15 years’ experience, including influencing the Infrastructure Act 2015 and serving on the National Highways strategic design panel and seeing some of the schemes that we are discussing today, as well as working on road freight decarbonisation projects.
Q
Ralph Smyth: It is a very good question. I point first to the second national infrastructure assessment, which was published three years ago. That said that by the end of 2026—so where we are now—the Government should publish an integrated strategy for road and rail. If you can see how you are going to improve the rail links and the road links, that would join up better and give confidence about where there should or should not be, for example, a change to the roads.
The other dimension is the local angle. We have heard recently in the media about how mayors might be given more of a say on water, for example, but the Bill goes in the opposite direction. It actually weakens or removes the mayoral input on transport. Transport has been the totemic issue of devolution and, oddly, the Bill removes that. A special new category of highway is created that is not subject to something called the network management duty, which is about joining things up in long-term planning and in short-term operations, such as where there is disruption. My concern is that for some of the schemes talked about, like the lower Thames crossing, it is going to be difficult to attract the private sector to invest without making it easier—for example, without reducing the risk of mayors getting in the way or trying to promote a railway line that would actually abstract some of the traffic.
Q
Ralph Smyth: I would not want to leave out the rural areas where there are perhaps not mayors.
Absolutely right—do not leave the rural areas out.
Ralph Smyth: Quite. The problem is the bigger context and the discussion about rewiring the state. That is talking about removing consultation, so simply a duty to consult to give your views might not be worth much.
The problem is that it needs to make economic sense for the investors. The M6 toll did not make a profit for 20 years. You are going to have to tilt this, particularly for very big schemes like the LTC, to make it attractive for investors, and that could mean making things less affordable for drivers and there being less involvement for mayors, despite transport being one of their big issues.
Q
Ralph Smyth: The tipping point depends on the sector and the type of journey. For discretionary journeys, like seeing a relative, a sudden increase in toll might have an impact quite quickly. If you are commuting and doing the same journey every day or if a haulage firm is doing the same routes, it might take longer for a response to happen. As we are talking about tipping points, I will also talk about climate change, because some figures from the Environment Agency have shown that by 2050—not long after some of these roads might be built—about half the UK transport network will flood regularly. That obviously means a lot of disruption and a lot of increased costs for the operator or owner of the assets. Those things will also affect, given where we are going, our use of roads, railways and everything else.
Q
Ralph Smyth: That is correct, yes. It is almost like an area that devolution has forgotten. We hear about the importance of roads; we heard about that from the previous witnesses, so it does appear a bit odd that there is not much there. One thing is that currently there is a duty, whether you are a local highway authority—county councils and so on—or the strategic highways authority, which is National Highways at the moment, to co-operate, but this Bill will create a new type of private highway authority and it will not join up. Some of the schemes that have seen funding withdrawn in road investment strategy 3 are very close to urban areas, and if they were funded via this route, that would not be an integrated approach and would be very different from what we are hearing about for the railways, where the Government have talked about the need for a single guiding mind.
Highways (Financing) Bill (Fourth sitting) Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateGreg Smith
Main Page: Greg Smith (Conservative - Mid Buckinghamshire)Department Debates - View all Greg Smith's debates with the Department for Transport
(1 week, 6 days ago)
Public Bill CommitteesIt is a pleasure to serve with you in the Chair this afternoon, Ms Lewell. Let us see if we can rise to the Minister’s challenge of maintaining this morning’s quality of debate.
Amendment 49, tabled in my name and that of my hon. Friend the Member for Bognor Regis and Littlehampton, essentially requires the ORR to review each licence at least every five years and to publish that review. The review would include compliance, user satisfaction, value for money, financial performance and resilience, toll returns and—continuing a theme of some of the amendments we discussed this morning and that flows through the entire Bill—the effects on surrounding roads off the trunk road network and the strategic road network that are the feeders to the new infrastructure: the lower Thames crossing and potentially others that the Bill enables.
I put it to the Committee and particularly to the Minister: why should a long-term licence not be subject to a mandatory review period published at least every five years, although I am open to other suggestions on the period? This is something that will impact motorists from across the whole country, particularly in the case of the lower Thames crossing. The hon. Member for Dartford has already expressed concerns about the impact on local roads. If a licence is granted for much longer than that—and I cannot see how it would not be, in order to bring realistic commercial payback under the tolling arrangements—what if it is a complete disaster? What if things do not pan out as everyone expects them to?
We do not want things to go wrong, but let us face it: sometimes they do. Often they do not go wrong due to any eventuality that has been foreseen. We would not have done it in the first place if there was a plan that saw things going wrong. But when things do go wrong, we need clear answers from those accountable to those paying the tolls on these roads, and indeed to the Government who will have set up the scheme in the first place. That goes in many respects to the conditions that the Minister spoke to in clause 6 around timely notice.
I gently say to the Minister: yes, it is important for an operator to get timely notice of any change, whether that is termination of a licence as it comes up to its expiration or an extension, but what is missing in clause 6 is anything that addresses the point about things going wrong. What if the Government need to step in and salvage a pretty horrendous situation that we might conceive of in future?
Jim Dickson (Dartford) (Lab)
The hon. Member is making a good case; clearly, things need to run well in the interests of road users, the infrastructure provider and local residents. However, clause 11 already provides for the modification of the licence after the grant, which surely includes most of the things he is calling for—that is, an ability to issue a notice and to say that the licence needs to be modified for some reason to do with the operation of the infrastructure.
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman for that intervention. He is right that there are measures in clause 11 that would address that issue, but we are currently discussing clauses 5 and 6, and the Minister’s comments reflected the fact that clause 6 only refers to extensions of a licence as opposed to reviews of a licence.
I cannot imagine that any of us, whatever walk of political life we find ourselves in at any one moment, would not want to have a statutory review period, so that all of us can question whether a contract is working as well as we want it to. Frankly, there are many projects I can think of that I wish we had had review periods for in the past, because we might have been able to pick up things that were going the wrong way.
If the Minister and the Government do not wish to have a five-year review period, I would welcome suggestions about what sort of review period would be acceptable to them. If they do not want a review period at all, there needs to be a pretty good case for that.
Shivani Raja (Leicester East) (Con)
My hon. Friend makes a compelling point. Once a company gets a road licence, it should not just be left to run it indefinitely, without any checks. A review every five years would force the regulator to consider the facts, including whether drivers are getting value for money and whether tolls are pushing extra traffic on to surrounding local streets. Publishing those findings would keep the operators accountable to the public.
My hon. Friend makes the case incredibly well. This discussion is about transparency; it is about openness. It is about saying to those who in the future might receive a licence to run the lower Thames crossing or any other piece of road infrastructure that might be financed through this model that they are still accountable to the public and to the Government, be that the current Government or any future Government.
Such reviews will give us transparency and a clear light on what is going on, so that—to go back to the earlier debate today—any future schemes, which no one can name yet, that might be financed under the scheme created by the Bill could be improved upon by reviews of the operation of the lower Thames crossing in the future. Let us not put a date on when it will actually get built; every state project ends up being built more slowly than originally intended. But five years into the operation of the lower Thames crossing, why would all of us collectively—as parliamentarians or as the general public—not want to know how it was going?
Alison Griffiths (Bognor Regis and Littlehampton) (Con)
I was also reflecting upon the fact that the tolling is almost open-ended. From a competitive perspective, in any regular private sector organisation it would be expected that at the end of a licence or a contract, there would be a competitive tender period. If a road has already been built and, as we now know, the maintenance of that road will then become part of a tolling operation, surely we should consider regularly—my hon. Friend said potentially every five years, but I am open to other suggestions—and on a competitive basis which company should operate it going forward, because once a road is built there is no reason why it should be the original road builder that does so.
My hon. Friend makes some interesting suggestions. I challenge the Government to reflect upon—[Interruption.] One Government Back Bencher is leaving already, it seems.
It’s getting closer! [Laughter.]
Maybe the Government can go back and reflect on that, and before Report, when the Bill returns to the whole House, they will have a sensible suggestion or counter-proposal on the table for how we properly monitor and review the operation of these licences.
I am grateful to the shadow Minister for his contribution. I enjoy when he and the hon. Member for Bognor Regis and Littlehampton riff off of each other—it is like a remake of “Dempsey and Makepeace”; I hope they put themselves forward for the leading roles. To be fair to the shadow Minister, I think that he is coming from the right place on this. It is important that we have assurances that the licences work and deliver the appropriate standard of service, and I agree that we need to hold licence holders to account, but I will explain why I do not believe that amendment 49 is the right vehicle for doing that, if Members will pardon the pun.
First, I do not think that we should fix a five-year review cycle in primary legislation. The appropriate level and frequency of any regulatory scrutiny could change over the life of a licence. A newly established licence may require a different approach from a mature licence, and different projects may present different issues. If this amendment was accepted, we may not actually have the lower Thames crossing operational five years into the licence. When we looked at how best to frame this, because the shadow Minister raised an important matter—
The amendment is very clear in saying, “review each licence”. That is not to say, “treat each licence as if they are identical,” because of course as time passes there might be different regulatory set-ups or safety standards that a new licence is granted under. We are very clear that each licence must be reviewed every five years, as opposed to—as I think the Minister is trying to argue—treating them all the same.
The hon. Gentleman may unwittingly be making my point for me, which is that we want to have regular consideration and an ongoing process from the regulator. We looked at how existing licencing regimes work, including, for example, the Civil Aviation Act 2012. As I am sure he realises, there is no review period specified in that Act, because in practice the Civil Aviation Authority regularly reviews and updates the licences that it has issued. The fact that there is no specified review period has not hindered it in carrying out that role. It is apparent from how the Civil Aviation Authority operates that it takes a proactive approach; that is what we are trying to do here. It does not wait five years to spot a problem and deal with it, but deals with problems as they arise. I am sure that the hon. Gentleman will see that as a preferable approach to waiting five years between reviews.
Secondly, a number of the issues listed in the amendment are already reflected in the ORR’s statutory duties. Clause 1 puts the interests of road users at the heart of the ORR’s role. It also requires the ORR to have particular regard to efficiency and economy, and the ability of the licence holder to finance its activities, as well as to have regard to matters including safety and impacts on the strategic road network. Under clause 1(5), the Secretary of State can provide guidance to the ORR about how they would like it to interpret or carry out its duties, and the Secretary of State can update that if they are not satisfied with that interpretation. Those duties are continuing duties under clause 1; they do not suddenly trigger after five years or at any other arbitrary point.
Compliance with the licence is also already covered by the Bill’s regulatory regime. Part 4 gives the ORR powers for monitoring and information gathering, and provides for enforcement when licence conditions are not met. Clause 7(5) requires the ORR to keep tolling conditions imposed on the licence in clause 7 under review. As my hon. Friend the Member for Dartford said, clause 11 gives powers to amend licences. The shadow Minister talked about the absolute disaster scenario, which we hopefully will not see, but clause 12 gives powers to revoke licences. Therefore, there would be no need to wait five years, and I think it is clear that the flexibility and ongoing review that the Bill sets out is the correct approach.
Olly Glover
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Ms Lewell. Amendment 39 would create a mechanism for compulsory compensation for local councils as a result of additional traffic due to people avoiding tolls.
Local council taxpayers must not be forced to subsidise private toll road profits by picking up the repair bill for local roads damaged by heavy diverted traffic. As Declan Pang of the Road Haulage Association noted in front of the Committee last week, local A and B roads are heavily used by small businesses and hauliers, and severe wear caused by toll evasion can hurt the wider local economy.
Placing compensation in clause 7 would make it a binding legal condition so that private operators cannot bypass or negotiate away the wider impacts. One of the reasons I have tabled the amendment is because of the problem with the current roads funding formula. It is based overwhelmingly on miles rather than use levels. Higher use of existing roads would not necessarily lead to more funding for local authorities as a result, so we need a mechanism to deal with that.
Amendment 40 would, in effect, extend the delay repay concept from the railway to toll roads. It would mean an automatic toll refund scheme that issues partial or full refunds to drivers trapped in severe congestion, roadworks or operator-induced disruptions would come into existence. Motorists paying premium commercial tolls expect a reliable, free-flowing journey and should not be charged full price when the operator fails to maintain traffic flow.
Drawing on European tolling models, the Italian network has a motorway refund system, which creates a direct financial incentive for operators to clear incidents and manage roadworks efficiently. Currently, operators do not always manage to do that here. We are not necessarily saying that that is the right system for the UK context, but it is an illustration of what is possible and an example that the Minister may wish to consider.
As Edmund King told the Committee last week, if drivers pay a higher toll under an independent business model, it must work both ways, giving drivers money back when the road fails to operate properly. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s comments.
I largely wish to comment on amendment 72 in my name and that of my hon. Friend the Member for Bognor Regis and Littlehampton, but before I do so, I will speak briefly to amendments 39 and 40.
The hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage makes a good point about the increased use of local roads that feed vehicles on to new infrastructure, such as the lower Thames crossing, or indeed bring motorists—be they private motorists or haulage operators—off those pieces of new infrastructure. The current modelling that finances local highway authorities—predominantly councils—up and down the land has no mechanism whatsoever for acknowledging the point that the hon. Member makes. When traffic flows are massively increased on an existing road, those surfaces very quickly degrade and start to resemble the surface of the moon. I am sure we all see that in our own constituencies. It something that drives all of our constituents—and me—absolutely potty on a daily basis.
I see that in my own constituency, where we have seen a large amount of big infrastructure being built over recent years, such as East West Rail. That happens where compounds are put in for heavy goods and groundworks vehicles. The traction zones where those vehicles are accelerating to pull out, or braking to come in, as they go to site, move earth away and bring aggregate in, very quickly degrade.
It makes sense to take into account where an existing local road—one that is owned by a local highway authority and is the responsibility of local council tax payers—is suddenly asked, as they will be in the case of the new lower Thames crossing and potentially other schemes in the future, to be used for infrastructure projects. There should be a flow of funding, either from the licensee or from the Government through the Department for Transport, and ultimately the Treasury, that ensures that council tax payers in local areas are not asked to pick up the bill—as my council has been asked to do for roads broken by HS2 construction—for the construction of the lower Thames crossing and other schemes under the Bill. Indeed, they should not be asked to pick up the bill for the ultimate operation of them, either. I have some sympathy for amendment 39 tabled by the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage.
Amendment 40 is a more problematic proposition. I do not disagree with the sentiment. No one can tell us what the toll on the lower Thames crossing would ultimately be, but we can presume it to be commensurate with the M6 toll, where an average vehicle pays £7 or £8. Therefore, it makes eminent common sense, and is surely reasonable, that someone would be entitled to some sort of compensation, or money back, if they paid the toll but then got snarled up in a traffic jam and just sat in a queue that they could have sat in on the original M6 anyway. I have sat in a jam on that road many times over my life.
The problem with the proposition that the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage has put forward is how that would be determined. With trains, delay repay is very straightforward: what time does the train ultimately pull into the destination station? That is very clear: it is either on time or a number of minutes late. Certainly, since Chiltern Railways was nationalised, I have been on late trains from my constituency every single day, but that is beside the point.
However, how is that level of delay really determined in a private vehicle? Everyone’s journey will be slightly different. What is to stop someone from deliberately driving slowly in order to avoid paying the full toll, artificially making their journey seem longer? Is it for the ORR to determine whether someone has had a longer than usual journey? How will they determine that without—and I do not want to sound all conspiracy theorist—some level of state snooping on people’s exact movements in order to determine how long that journey actually took them?
Olly Glover
The shadow Minister gives me an opportunity to say something I omitted from my notes—despite everyone’s obsession with Google, it is incapable of formatting a document properly when it is printed, but that is for another day. The Italian model calculates a base amount for roadworks, plus an extra amount for time lost. One qualifies after any delay on a trip up to 30 km, after a 10-minute delay on trips of 30 to 50 km, or after a 15-minute delay on trips over 50 km. I do not know how they determine that. It may be through some sort of monitoring system, and we already have that in many formats, such as automatic number plate recognition. The Italians are not generally well known for welcoming state surveillance. That is just one mechanism, and I am sure that many options are available using 21st-century technology.
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman for that clarification. I am sure that the Italian model works well to make the number of minutes delayed commensurate to the compensation paid, but he himself acknowledges that he does not know the manner in which it is determined. I would be happy to work with the hon. Gentleman to look at options—
There are no coalitions here. There is only one audition going for the next general election, and it will not be looking toward our side of the House.
If there is a sensible solution that does not involve state snooping on our motorists as they use this new infrastructure, the principle that someone has paid their money and should expect a quick journey time is a fundamentally good one, and it should apply.
Amendment 72 would prevent the Bill from coming into force until after the Secretary of State has published a report that sets out the proposed licence conditions, including—this is the $64,000 question, though I hope not literally—tolling arrangements. Throughout the debates so far, a number of questions have been asked about that. I understand the technical nature of the answers, but bluntly, that does not cut it with our constituents. No one can answer how much it will actually cost motorists to use the lower Thames crossing or how the tolling mechanism will be regulated to give clear, unambiguous rules about how a toll must be set and if there will be any caps on it, so that drivers, motorists, private cars and hauliers alike can have confidence in what is coming.
That is simply what amendment 72 seeks to do. The public should know how tolls will be set and how any increases—an equally important point—will be approved before the regime starts operating. It is not good enough for the road to be built and for people to then find out that they cannot afford to use it. Why should Parliament commence the Act before those conditions are published? If the Minister can come back with some clear guidance and rules around that, we will be much closer to full-throttled support for what he is trying to do. We want the lower Thames crossing, but we do not want it at a rate that nobody can afford to use.
Alison Griffiths
When I spoke earlier to amendment 82 to clause 3, it was with this exact issue in mind. We failed to get that amendment passed, so the improvement and maintenance of these roads will be paid for through tolling. However, we know that the “fair and transparent code” the ORR will decide on will not be put to a vote in Parliament. It therefore becomes even more important that on the tolling for these roads, we require a report from the Secretary of State that sets out the conditions and proposed arrangements for toll levels and the approval of increases. Without that, there is no control or stopgap for these tolls. The tolling does not end when costs have been recovered by the operator, so we could have a very open-ended tolling situation.
Given that it is going to one operator, we do not know how cost-effective maintenance will be. Will they be required to go out to tender on this? If a report is coming to the Secretary of State before we set tolling, that will create a position where we have greater control.
The hon. Gentleman is absolutely correct that the Bill is scheme-agnostic, but as the lower Thames crossing is the only scheme we currently have in mind, it is helpful to draw examples from that for why the amendment is not acceptable.
It is probably also worth pointing out that I am not aware of any other such toll schemes operating in this country at the moment. Is it his position that this compensation measure should be extended to the Mersey tunnels or the Mersey Gateway crossing, for example? My local transport authorities might be interested to hear that, and they might wonder where the funding would come from.
As I have said, the whole purpose of the Bill is to create the regulated asset base model that will fund the crossing. It will be a separate income stream from the general roads budget, and those who benefit directly from the new infrastructure will pay for it. It will improve the reliability of the whole network, which is the correct approach and is far more effective than trying to compensate people for an already overstretched and failing network.
I genuinely do not think the Minister and I are that far apart, because I do not disagree with anything he has just said about getting the new infrastructure to work in the interests of motorists. Where I think he has perhaps missed the point that the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage and I have made is that, in order to get traffic flows on to that new infrastructure, in many cases it is conceivable that local roads will see a much higher level of use than they do today. Therefore does the Minister acknowledge that getting new infrastructure up and running well, in the interests of motorists at a price they can afford, will have an impact on the rest of the road ecosystem, mainly falling on those local authority-owned and financed roads?
I understand the hon. Member’s point, but I cannot say I agree with it because the traffic is already on the local road network. The whole purpose of the Bill is to take that traffic away. It is worth reiterating that we do not intend to do a deal at any cost. We need to do the right deal for road users and make sure this legislation has the necessary protections in place for them. Heaping more costs on to the project by bringing in a wide and broad compensation package would have unintended consequences.
The hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage mentioned the perceived unfairness of the road maintenance formula, which the Department is committed to reviewing, but I cannot accept his amendment and I say the same about amendment 40. That would insert a mandatory licence condition requiring an automated refund system to be provided by a licensee. As I have already stated, the amendment would be contrary to what we are trying to achieve. The shadow Minister talked amusingly about people driving deliberately slowly to try to get a repayment. I am not sure people would be that Machiavellian, but maybe those are the circles he mixes in.
It is fair to say that road users rightly expect well-maintained roads, and they expect operators to minimise disruption in line with their network management duties. However, safe roads require maintenance, and maintenance sometimes requires roadworks. An automatic refund requirement would disincentivise operators from undertaking necessary maintenance and roadworks. It would give them a financial incentive to postpone what might be necessary maintenance. The better approach is to hold operators to account for how they manage expenditure and deliver the service, rather than create an incentive to put off essential work.
Amendment 1 is a small amendment to remove an unnecessary paragraph from clause 8(2). Paragraph (l) currently specifies that a licence may have a condition prohibiting transfer of the licence unless it is done under the provisions set out in clause 14. That is not necessary, as compliance with the provisions is already required by clause 14 itself. This is therefore a minor tidying-up amendment to remove an unnecessary provision, which I hope the shadow Minister will be able to support.
Clause 8 allows a licensing authority to include additional project-specific conditions in a licence, which will sit alongside the conditions that must be included under clause 7. That flexibility is important because each project will be different, and the licence needs to reflect the particular road, works and arrangements involved.
Conditions may set out what the licence holder must, may or must not do. They may also control how the licence holder carries out its activities. For example, conditions may cover the use of land, the licence holder’s financial arrangements, and requirements relating to the design or operation of the highway. A licence may also require the licence holder to follow directions from the Secretary of State or the ORR on matters specified in the licence. Conditions may cover the provision and publication of information, co-operation with highways and planning bodies, and the referral of particular matters to the ORR for a decision. A licence may also require the licence holder to meet costs incurred by the Secretary of State in carrying out functions connected with the licence.
The list in clause 8 is not exhaustive, and it is not designed to be. That ensures that a licence can include any other appropriate conditions needed for the project. I think the overarching principle is pretty clear from the list in subsections (2)(a) to (2)(k), but I will give the Committee a bit more detail.
Paragraph (a) is about making sure the licence holder is financially stable and resilient. It gives the ORR the option to lay out things such as the level of debt the licence holder can have.
Paragraph (b) is about making sure that all the things a licence holder must or may do in respect of the road are spelled out in the licence, such as that it must construct the road, for example.
Paragraph (c) is about how the licence holder does the things that are spelled out in the licence. For example, that might be abiding by the planning conditions laid out in the planning permission for a scheme.
Paragraph (d) is about detailing the consents that the licence holder will or will not need for certain actions.
Paragraph (e) makes it clear that the licence holder must abide by directions from the Secretary of State or the ORR.
Paragraph (f) makes sure the licence holder refers appropriate matters to the ORR.
Paragraph (g) makes sure the licence holder is clear that it has to pay the Secretary of State for any costs incurred by the Secretary of State on its behalf.
Paragraph (h) makes sure the licence holder co-operates with National Highways or a local highway authority, for example, when fulfilling its duties under the Highways Act 1980, to give one example.
Paragraph (i) is about the information that a licence holder may be required to share with the ORR or others.
Paragraph (j) is about making sure that land acquired for the building of any scheme under the RAB model—for example, land acquired for environmental mitigation of the lower Thames crossing—is used for its intended purpose and not for some other purpose. For example, if the land was designated for environmental mitigation but the licence holder tried to build a housing estate on it instead, that would be a breach of the licence.
Lastly, paragraph (k) is probably the easiest to explain, because it is there to ensure that the licence holder abides by the licence, particularly in making sure that the correct standards of road construction and operation are used.
Clause 8 therefore provides the flexibility to tailor each licence, while ensuring that the licence holder’s responsibilities are clear. Because the licence will change over time, depending on the stage of the project, the clause needs to reflect that. For example, the road that the licence holder is required to construct will be complete at some point, so a construction condition will then no longer be needed. As I have said, the clause is not an exhaustive list but is designed to ensure that a licence can include any appropriate conditions needed for an individual project. I commend the clause and amendment 1 to the Committee.
Clause 9 enables the Secretary of State to determine standard conditions for licences granted under the Bill. These conditions will provide a clear, consistent baseline across the new licensing regime to give licence holders, investors, the ORR and road users certainty about the core obligations that apply while avoiding unnecessary repetition in individual licences. These standard conditions must be published and provided to the ORR, and they will then be incorporated into each licence by reference, unless the Bill provides otherwise. Conditions published after a licence is granted will not apply to the licence automatically.
Clause 9 also preserves appropriate flexibility. The licensing authority may exclude or modify standard conditions when granting a licence, where that is justified for the project. Clause 10 requires publication, consultation and protections against undue competitive disadvantage before the licensing authority may do so. Clause 9, therefore, provides a combination of regulatory consistency and proportionate project-specific flexibility.
Clause 10 sets out the safeguards that apply where a licensing authority proposes to exclude or modify a standard condition when granting a licence. Before excluding or modifying the condition, the authority must publish a notice setting out the proposed change, its effect and the reasons for it. The notice must be sent to the other licensing authorities, each relevant strategic highways company and any other appropriate persons, and at least 28 days must be allowed for representations. The licensing authority may proceed only if it considers that the change will not unduly disadvantage either the licence holder concerned or any other licence holder in competing with others. If it proceeds, it must publish the final change, explain its effect and reasons, and state how representations were taken into account. This clause therefore ensures that project-specific flexibility is exercised transparently, proportionately and without distorting competition.
I commend these clauses to the Committee.
I am grateful to the Minister for his explanation of these clauses and Government amendment 1. He will be pleased to know that His Majesty’s loyal Opposition do not object to Government amendment 1. We might ask why such an obvious duplication in the Bill was not picked up before it was published, but we will perhaps leave that for another day.
Speaking more widely to clauses 8 to 10, though probably more in the realm of clause 8, I would be grateful if the Minister could visualise some of the scheme-specific variations that he spoke of. With only the lower Thames crossing really in anyone’s eye under the provisions of this Bill, can he give us some practical, concrete examples of where such scheme-specific variations may come about, to help the House, the Committee and our constituents to fully understand the scope?
Clause 8(2)(a) talks about conditions
“relating to the financial resilience of the holder of the licence or otherwise relating to the holder’s financial arrangements”.
The Minister directly referred to how much debt a licensee might be allowed to have, under the scheme of a licence. I do not object to that as a core principle, but if it is to be the case that something can be laid down as clearly as how much debt-gearing an operator or licensee is permitted to have, surely it can also be written into any licence not necessarily the exact pounds and pence of what any toll can be, but some sort of ruling that says a toll must be proportionate to, for example, the overall build cost over a certain number of years. Maybe, as we are talking about debt-gearing to build infrastructure such as the lower Thames crossing, a licence could say that the toll must not be any more than the total debt divided over how many years the Secretary of State or the ORR deems the licence to cover.
That is the most important question flowing through all the amendments and all the debates on this Bill: how much are the tolls actually going to cost people to use these roads? I fully accept that a pounds and pence figure is very difficult to conjure up, but surely clause 8(2)(a) would give us the ability to set the parameters of a toll. If we can set the debt limit, we can surely set limits for the tolls.
I will start by addressing the clauses in general; if I dive straight into the amendments, it may overcomplicate the debate on what is already a fairly complicated Bill. The clauses set out how a licence can end or be transferred, where the licence holder has requested it. Further to amendments 2 to 4 and 22 to 25, licences can also be transferred under the provisions set out in schedule 1.
For the regulated asset base model to function properly, it is important that transfers of licences can take place and that the process is set out clearly. For some schemes under the RAB model, the same person might hold a licence for a very long time. At some point, however, the licence may well need to change hands. The clauses will allow for that to happen, and set out clearly the conditions that the regulator may deem it appropriate to apply in granting its consent.
Government amendment 2 allows for licences to be transferred under the transfer schemes in schedule 1 as well as under clause 14, and ensures that Government amendments 29 and 35 achieve their objectives. Those amendments allow for the transfer of a licence through a transfer scheme, as well as under clause 14. Amendment 2 makes it clear that provisions relating to modifying licence conditions post grant do not impinge on the ability to make incidental modifications to a licence when it is partially transferred under schedule 1 or schedule 3, once amendments 29 and 35 are made. When only part of a licence is transferred under those schedules, incidental modifications to the terms and conditions of the licence may be necessary to ensure that the licence can be split and continue to operate effectively.
Once it has hopefully been amended, clause 11 will enable a licensing authority to modify licence conditions after a licence has been granted. That power is necessary, because the licences may govern major infrastructure over long periods. The conditions may need to respond to changing operational, financial or regulatory circumstances, and the clause provides a controlled process for doing so. Before making a modification, the authority must publish the proposed change, the effect of it and the reasons for it, and must allow at least 28 days for representations.
If the authority proceeds, it must publish the final decision, explain how representations were considered and give at least 28 days’ notice before the change takes effect. The licence holder may appeal specified modifications to the Competition Appeal Tribunal. During the consultation period, the Secretary of State may also direct the ORR not to make a proposed modification. Clause 11 balances the necessary flexibility with transparency, accountability and effective rights of challenge. I therefore commend amendment 2 and clause 11 to the Committee.
Clause 12 provides a clear process by which the ORR can revoke a licence with the agreement of the licence holder or in accordance with the terms of the licence. That is necessary because a long-term licence may need to end before its stated expiry date, which the clause ensures can happen through an orderly and—importantly—transparent statutory process.
Before revoking a licence, the ORR must publish its proposal, explain its reasons and specify the proposed revocation date. It must allow at least 28 days for representations. If it decides to proceed, it must publish the decision and the date on which the licence will be revoked. The notices must be brought to the attention of those likely to be affected, and copies must be sent to the Secretary of State, each relevant strategic highways company and any other appropriate persons. During the representation period, the Secretary of State may direct the ORR not to revoke the licence. The clause therefore provides necessary flexibility, and contains transparency, oversight and an orderly transition.
Clause 13 provides for the revocation of a licence where necessary in the interests of national security. Strategic road infrastructure may be of national importance; therefore, the statutory framework must contain a clear mechanism to act where continued operation under a particular licence would present a national security concern. The power is deliberately narrow. The Secretary of State may direct the ORR to revoke a licence only if satisfied that revocation is necessary in the interests of national security.
The ORR must then publish a notice of the direction in a manner appropriate to bring it to the attention of any persons likely to be affected, and must send that notice to the licence holder, each relevant strategic highways company and any other appropriate persons. The notice must specify the date on which the licence is revoked. Clause 13 provides a focused national security safeguard, while the wider provisions in the Bill ensure that responsibility for the highway can continue after revocation. I therefore commend clauses 12 and 13 to the Committee.
Government amendment 3 ensures that clause 14 refers to both the conditions and terms of a licence in relation to transfers—[Interruption.] I hope that wasn’t a comment on my amendment.
Amendment 3 makes it clear that licence transfers under clause 14 are subject to the conditions of the licence, as well as its terms. Conditions relating to licence transfers may be imposed on licences under clauses 8 and 9, as the Committee discussed previously. The conditions may affect how and when licence transfers are made, and thus it is important that licence transfers under clause 14 are subject to them.
Government amendment 4 ensures alignment between clause 14 and schedule 1, once the schedule has been amended by Government amendment 29. This amendment is therefore interlinked with amendment 29 and is consequential on it. The Committee will come on to discuss amendment 29 later in its consideration, but by way of brief explanation, it allows for transfer of all or part of a licence through a transfer scheme. Without amendment 4, clause 14(1) would prevent transfer of the licence under schedule 1. The amendment fixes that and ensures that clause 14 aligns with schedule 1, which permits transfer of the licence through a transfer scheme, once the schedule is amended.
Clause 14, alongside the processes set out in schedule 1, establishes the statutory basis for transferring the whole or part of a licence. The licences may operate over long periods. It is therefore sensible to provide for a change of licence holder or a transfer of part of the licensed responsibilities, where appropriate. However, a transfer cannot take place without regulatory control.
The licence holder must obtain the ORR’s consent and comply with the procedure under clause 15, and with any relevant terms or conditions of the licence. The Secretary of State may direct the ORR not to consent where that is necessary in the interests of national security. Subject to that safeguard, the ORR may refuse consent only if it considers that the proposed transferee is not a fit and proper person to hold the licence or the part that is being transferred. The ORR may also impose appropriate conditions, which may ensure that the necessary property, rights and liabilities are transferred or created between the parties. Clause 14 therefore provides commercial and operational flexibility without allowing licence obligations to be transferred free from regulatory scrutiny. I commend it to the Committee.
Finally, clause 15 sets out the procedure that the ORR must follow before consenting to the transfer of a licence or part of a licence under clause 14. Before giving consent, the ORR must publish a notice stating that it proposes to consent and explaining its reasons. The notice must allow at least 28 days for representations about the proposed transfer. If the ORR decides to proceed, it must publish a further notice setting out its decision and the date on which the transfer will take place. Both notices must be published in a manner appropriate to bring them to the attention of persons likely to be affected. The ORR must also send copies to the Secretary of State, each relevant strategic highways company and any other appropriate persons. When sending the proposal to the Secretary of State, the ORR must identify any conditions it proposes to impose on the transfer under clause 14. Clause 15 therefore ensures that transfers are considered openly and on an informed basis, while providing a clear route for an approved transfer to take effect.
I hope that I have been clear for Committee members. Clauses 11 to 15, as amended, will provide the certainty that licence holders need with regard to how their licence may come to an end, or be transferred or revoked. They also provide assurance to the ORR and to the public of the clear processes for how the end of a licence should be managed. I therefore commend the clauses and Government amendments in the group to the Committee.
I have never been considered a Tory wet, Ms Lewell, but my notes now are, after my acrobatics with them. I particularly apologise to the Hansard reporters when my notes eventually make it to the Official Report at the end of the sitting.
The Minister suggests an improvement to my notes—I certainly cannot read them any more.
I do not think that there is particular disagreement between the official Opposition and the Government on this part of the Bill, so I just want to pose a couple of questions to the Minister on clauses 12 and 13 on the revocation of any licences. Clearly, a licence may well need to be revoked if things are going horribly wrong, or indeed—as the Minister highlighted in his remarks—if there is a national security concern. The first duty of any Government is to keep citizens safe, and given a national security concern, it is absolutely right that there should be the power to revoke a licence.
What is missing from clauses 12 and 13 is what happens if a licence is revoked, but there is no one out there willing to take it on so that clauses 14 and 15 would come into effect. Who becomes the licensee by default? Is it the Department for Transport? Is it the ORR? Is it someone else? That is not a disagreement with the clauses—they seem relatively comprehensive, and certainly the power given any national security concerns is absolutely right—but who takes over?
What if no company wishes to take on that liability—that licence—and the cost of operating the lower Thames crossing or anything else that is granted a licence? We need clarity on that. Although the procedure set out in the clauses is unobjectionable, the net result in some circumstances is not. I hope those circumstances never come to pass, but we must plan for the worst. We need an answer on that point.
I have a few questions on this group. We have no problem with clause 16. In respect of clause 17, the Minister referenced the setting of speed limits as an example of where functions should be exercisable by persons other than the licence holder—the state, for lack of a better phrase. I do not disagree with the premise—it would be unusual, to say the least, to allow a private company to set speed limits outside our national scheme—but it prompts a question for the whole Bill.
Let us say that a scheme is built, and its original consent, set by the appropriate body, is for a 40 mph speed limit. If the licence holder then makes a representation to the appropriate body in conjunction with the local police force or local authority, it could be determined that the scheme should be converted to a variable speed limit road—we are seeing a lot of those popping up across the country. That could involve quite considerable expense, putting up gantries and having repeater signs with changing speed limits. Where does that fit in with some of the other provisions we have debated? Would that be a capacity change? In theory, variable speed limits speed up the overall journey time and manage congestion spots before they appear, by slowing the whole road down for a bit so that there is not a pile-up. Can the Minister assure the Committee that there would be no back door for a licence holder to negotiate with the appropriate bodies to charge a higher toll because of a change to a variable speed limit system?
Those were some interesting questions from the shadow Minister. On the first point about the operation of clause 17 and what we have loosely described as “capacity-enhancing improvements”, it is of course the case that the gateway to the licensing regime is through capacity-enhancing improvements in any event. The eligibility for a licence would already have been established under the Act, so I am not sure why additional capacity would create anything different, because the licence would already have been issued by that point. Unless I misunderstood the hon. Gentleman—
I am happy to explain further. My point is that, with speed limits being set, rightly and properly, by other authorities—there is no disagreement on that point—speed limits could then be used to essentially create new conditions on that road, which could then be used as a springboard to a higher toll or a different set of conditions. The ORR and the licensee could find themselves in a vicious doom loop of disagreement on that point. What I am trying to get across to the Minister is how something that is fundamentally and, I double underline, rightly set by a different authority could become a point of disagreement in the set of licence conditions for any licensee.
I am grateful for the hon. Gentleman’s explanation; I think I now understand what he is trying to say. We are entering the realms of speculation at this point—
And the hon. Gentleman is doing it well. He is speculating that any improvements of that nature would probably improve traffic flow and increase the number of vehicles going through the network. I would say that that was probably more of an argument to reduce returns than to increase them, but the prospect is probably rather too remote for us to say anything more concrete at this stage.
Similarly, in response to the hon. Gentleman’s questions about when an emergency under clause 19(2) might be called, it would be rather risky for me to set out every circumstance in which that might happen here. It is important to remember that the clause is about the ORR’s view of the licence holder’s ability to undertake its obligations under the licence. There are obviously already a number of provisions in the legislation about the kind of things that the ORR would be able to consider. Trying to pin us down on the specific instances where an emergency might be called would unnecessarily tie the ORR’s hands.
I understand why the Minister does not want to give an exhaustive list of examples, but if I may slightly confine the question, will he look at the wording in the clause and make it clear, either now or on Report, that when the ORR “must have regard”, the definition of an emergency is specific to that licensee, as opposed to something affecting everyone, such as extreme heat on the road surfaces?
I will take that away. The test under the clause is the license holder’s ability to undertake the licence. It is probably inappropriate for me to speculate om whether that would apply to the rest of the network or specifically to the licence holder. My instinct is to say that that would not be the question. It is about the ability of the licence holder to undertake its functions, and if they are significantly impaired in the ORR’s view, the source of that impairment is probably not relevant. If it is an emergency that has created the impairment, clause 19(2) would come into effect. However, if, having consulted with officials, I have more to say on that, I will of course write to him.
The Chair
Maybe next time.
Question put and agreed to.
Clause 16 accordingly ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clauses 17 to 21 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clause 22
Litter functions
I beg to move amendment 79, in clause 22, page 16, line 23, at end insert—
“(2A) Regulations under this section must ensure that—
(a) a single authority or licence holder is designated as responsible for litter clearance on each highway specified in a licence;
(b) the identity and contact details of that responsible body are published;
(c) members of the public may report litter and make complaints directly to that responsible body; and
(d) that the responsible body remains accountable for litter clearance notwithstanding any arrangements made with another person to carry out the work.”
This amendment would establish clear responsibility and public accountability for litter clearance on licenced highways.
Amendment 79, which stands in my name and that of my hon. Friend the Member for Bognor Regis and Littlehampton, tries, like most of our amendment today, to give more clarity about what happens in the event of the scourge that is littering. I cannot imagine that there is any Member of this House who has not been out litter picking along the roads and highways in their own constituencies—not the motorway, but on certain parts of the strategic road network and A roads. I certainly see groups in my constituency doing that on a regular basis. All our constituents are rightly upset when they see litter on the verges and sides of the roads. It gets me incrediblyangry too.
The point that the amendment makes is that a motorist or local resident should not be left guessing who is responsible for litter on a licensed road. Will the Government accept a named and published accountable body and a direct route for complaints under each licence that is issued? If work is outsourced, who remains legally responsible for ensuring that the highway is kept clear? The public-facing accountable body should, in my opinion, at least be clearly defined in the regulations when they come to pass and provision to ensure that is the case—as amendment 79 would—should be written into the Bill.
It would be a disaster if we get this wrong and an accident happens because of severe fly-tipping or litter on any one of these roads. We have all seen severe fly-tipping in our own constituencies and the impact it has, particularly on safety. During debate on the previous group we discussed the extreme heat. There were significant fires in that extreme heat, and glass dumped on the side of the road only exacerbates that particular problem. While I do not want to labour this point at length, I think it is incumbent upon the Government to properly consider this amendment and to see if we can strengthen the Bill through its inclusion.
I am grateful to the hon. Member for moving this amendment as it gives me an opportunity to promote an upcoming litter pick in my constituency, alongside the father of the Whip, my hon. Friend the Member for Worsley and Eccles, on Saturday morning. We will be doing our bit, as we always do. I pay tribute to all the volunteers up and down the country who do a fantastic job in showing great community spirit. However, I make it clear that the trunk road network is not a place for such activities. Instead, it should be handled by an appropriate body, which is indeed what clause 22 seeks to do.
Regarding amendment 79, the shadow Minister is right to raise the issue of clear lines of responsibility for litter clearance on licensed highways. He is right that there should be a clear responsibility. That is why clause 22 exists. He will not be surprised that existing litter legislation was not drafted to account for privately operated highways under the new licensing framework. Clause 22 therefore allows the Secretary of State to make regulations so that existing litter duties can operate properly for licensed highways. That does not mean that responsibility could be handed out arbitrarily. The purpose of the regulations is to ensure that litter functions sit with the appropriate body for the licensed highway and with a clear responsibility for them to carry them out. My objection is not to providing clear information as the hon. Member wants; it is about prescribing detailed requirements about contact details for complaint handling on the face of primary legislation. Clause 22 already provides a regulation-making power to establish how these functions will operate.
Clause 22 ensures that the existing framework for litter under the Environmental Protection Act 1990 can be applied appropriately to the highways specified in relevant licences. The clause therefore allows the Secretary of State to make regulations so that litter responsibilities can operate effectively on licensed highways. The regulations may apply existing duties to keep land clear of litter and refuse to highways covered by a licence. They may also allow the litter enforcement functions to be exercised by or on behalf of a licence holder. In some cases, those functions may sit alongside another body’s responsibilities, in others they may be exercised instead of them. That flexibility ensures that the responsibility can be allocated appropriately for the licensed highway.
The regulations may also make appropriate changes to how existing litter legislation applies to a private licence holder so that it works effectively with licensing frameworks. This will ultimately help ensure that there are clear lines of accountability and no gaps in the management of licensed highways. I therefore commend clause 22 to the Committee.
I recognise the arguments that the Minister has put forward, but I still think the Bill would be stronger with the exact wording of my amendment. However, I accept his assurances and at this moment, although we might return to it on Report, I am happy to ask leave to withdraw the amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Clause 22 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clause 23
Transfer schemes
Question proposed, That the clause stand part of the Bill.
The Chair
With this it will be convenient to discuss the following:
Government amendments 22 to 31.
Schedule 1.
Property blight would probably be dealt with by development consent orders and the planning process rather than this Bill, which is about the financial and regulatory framework for operating highways. It would probably come before we got to the issuing of licences. I hope that answers the hon. Gentleman’s question.
Government amendment 31 further extends the existing compensation provision in schedule 1 to allow transfer schemes to provide for compensation to be paid to transferors as well as third parties. In some cases, it may be appropriate for compensation to be paid to a transferor—for example, where a licence has been revoked on a non-consensual ground set out in the licence. Under amendment 30, the scheme could provide for the compensation to be paid by the Secretary of State or the transferee, as appropriate. The drafting is not prescriptive. Compensation will not always be needed for either the transferor or a third party, but the provision is drafted to make it possible for all relevant scenarios to be covered.
I will not speak at length; I merely ask some questions of the Minister about the taxation provisions at the end of schedule 1. I think many of our constituents would be surprised to find in the Bill the following provision:
“The Treasury may by regulations make provision for varying the way in which a relevant tax has effect”
in relation to a transfer. The Bill even says that income tax could be varied.
I can conceive of a situation where the ORR finds itself in a sticky spot trying to transfer a licence— perhaps there are not many willing participants—and tries to create an incentive for it to be taken on. Surely, however, to be as explicit as providing for the varying of taxes from income tax to corporation tax and beyond is highly unusual within legislation. Our constituents would normally expect a tax to be a tax. Although there may be, in Budgets from time to time, provisions that allow reliefs, to nakedly change corporation tax or income tax—as my reading of schedule 7(1) suggests—seems an extreme measure. I would be grateful for an explanation from the Minister.
I will have to disappoint the shadow Minister. I will not be able to give him a detailed explanation today. All I would say is that the schedule does require such proposals to be approved in a statutory instrument subject to the affirmative procedure, but I will seek counsel from Treasury colleagues about what possible circumstances this may apply in and write to the shadow Minister.
Question put and agreed to.
Clause 23 accordingly ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Amendments made: 22, in schedule 1, page 68, line 7, after “company” insert
“, a subsidiary of a strategic highways company,”.
This amendment is consequential on amendment 23, which allows for a transfer scheme to provide for transfers from a strategic highways company to a subsidiary of a strategic highways company.
Amendment 23, in schedule 1, page 68, line 9, after first “to” insert “—
(i) a subsidiary of a strategic highways company, or”.
This amendment allows for a transfer scheme to provide for transfers from a strategic highways company to a subsidiary of a strategic highways company.
Amendment 24, in schedule 1, page 68, line 10, at end insert—
“(ba) from a subsidiary of a strategic highways company to a person who holds, or is to hold, a licence;”.
This amendment allows for a transfer scheme to provide for transfers from a subsidiary of a strategic highways company to a licence holder or prospective licence holder.
Amendment 25, in schedule 1, page 68, line 13, after “company” insert
“or a subsidiary of a strategic highways company”.
This amendment is consequential on amendment 26 (which leaves out provision that a reference to a strategic highways company includes a reference to its subsidiary).
Amendment 26, in schedule 1, page 68, line 18, leave out sub-paragraph (2) and insert—
“(2) In sub-paragraph (1) ‘subsidiary’ has the same meaning as in the Companies Act 2006 (see section 1159 of that Act).”
This amendment is consequential on amendments 23 and 24.
Amendment 27, in schedule 1, page 68, line 36, after “date” insert “or dates”.
This amendment clarifies that different parts of a transfer scheme may come into effect at different times.
Amendment 28, in schedule 1, page 69, line 10, at end insert—
1A “(1) The power to make a transfer scheme within paragraph 1(1)(c) is exercisable only if the Secretary of State obtains the consent of—
(a) in the case of a transfer within paragraph 1(1)(c)(i) or (ii), the proposed transferor;
(b) in the case of a transfer within paragraph 1(1)(c)(iii) or (iv), the proposed transferor and the proposed transferee.
(2) The consent of the proposed transferor to the making of a transfer scheme is not required where the scheme is made in connection with or in pursuance of the revocation or expiry of a licence.
(3) In this paragraph ‘proposed transferor’, in relation to a transfer scheme proposed to be made, means the person who is proposed to be the transferor; and ‘proposed transferee’ is to be read accordingly.”
This amendment clarifies the circumstances in which a transfer scheme may be made under paragraph 1(1)(c) of Schedule 1.
Amendment 29, in schedule 1, page 70, line 20, at end insert—
2A “(1) A transfer scheme may include provision for the transfer of a licence held by the transferor to the transferee.
(2) Provision under sub-paragraph (1) may relate to the whole or any part of the licence.
(3) Where a transfer scheme provides for the transfer of a part of a licence, the scheme may include provision—
(a) apportioning rights or liabilities under the licence;
(b) making incidental modifications to the terms and conditions of the licence.”
This amendment provides that a transfer scheme may include provision for the transfer of the whole or part of a licence.
Amendment 30, in schedule 1, page 70, line 23, after “State” insert “or the transferee”.
This amendment provides that a transfer scheme may provide for compensation to be payable by the transferee, in relation to the scheme, as well as by the Secretary of State.
Amendment 31, in schedule 1, page 70, line 23, leave out
“any person, other than the transferor or transferee,”
and insert
“the transferor or any person”.—(Justin Madders.)
This amendment provides that a transfer scheme may provide for compensation to be payable to the transferor as well as any third party whose interests are adversely affected by the scheme.
Schedule 1, as amended, agreed to.
Clause 24
Charging of tolls
I beg to move amendment 50, in clause 24, page 17, line 14, leave out lines 14 and 15.
This amendment would remove the power of the Secretary of State to specify any circumstances in regulations about how tolls must be paid.
The Chair
With this it will be convenient to discuss the following:
Amendment 51, in clause 24, page 17, line 20, leave out lines 20 and 21.
This amendment would remove the power from a licence holder to specify equipment to be carried in or fitted to a road vehicle while it is on the highway.
Amendment 53, in clause 24, page 18, line 6, at end insert—
“(9) Before setting the levels of tolls to be charged, the holder of a licence must consult—
(a) road users likely to be affected,
(b) local businesses,
(c) local residents,
(d) local highway authorities whose areas may be affected.”
This amendment would require consultation before tolls can be charged.
Amendment 54, in clause 24, page 18, line 6, at end insert—
“(9) A tolling scheme made under this section may not come into force unless it has been approved by Parliament.
(10) On any occasion that the licence holder wishes to increase the level of a toll which is already being charged under a licence, this must be approved by Parliament.
(11) To meet the requirement in subsections (9) and (10), the Secretary of State must make regulations setting out the tolling scheme and levels of tolls to be charged under it.
(12) Regulations made under subsection (11) are subject to the affirmative procedure.”
This amendment would require parliamentary approval of road user charging under this Act on each occasion that it was implemented.
Clause stand part.
The amendments in this group stand in my name and that of my hon. Friend the Member for Bognor Regis and Littlehampton. The crux of much of what we have spoken about today, and I am sure will continue to speak about at length on this Bill, is the way in which tolls are charged. Our amendments in this group seek to get the clarity that many of our constituents, I am sure, will want on that very question.
The lead amendment is about removing the power of the Secretary of State to specify circumstances in regulations for how tolls must be paid. Amendment 51 is about removing the power from a licence holder to specify equipment to be carried in or fitted to a road vehicle while it is on the licensed highway. Amendment 53 requires consultation before tolls can be charged. Amendment 54 requires parliamentary approval of road user charging under the Bill—assuming that it becomes an Act—on each occasion on which it is implemented.
The power to determine how a motorist pays should not be an open-ended power to require equipment in vehicles. I simply do not get the necessity or the proportionality of that requirement in the Bill, which is why we seek to remove it. The requirement for equipment in vehicles is almost like taking 10 steps backwards in order to use a tolled road. Certainly, tolls can have those little boxes in a windscreen, which beep as someone goes through a barrier, but as has now been widely proven—over multiple decades—that is just straightforwardly unnecessary.
Here in our capital city, we cannot drive a vehicle without paying the toll that is the congestion charge. That does not involve anyone having to have a little box in their windscreen or any other equipment in their car, because we all have those very straightforward things that have been on our cars for many, many years called number plates. The cameras can very straightforwardly pick any vehicle up as it goes by. By law, we have to have a number plate. If we have not paid a toll, the congestion or ULEZ—ultra low emission zone—charge, the Birmingham clean air toll or whatever against the registration of our vehicle, we get a penalty charge notice in the post. It works. Some of us might not particularly like it, but it works. Why on earth should any toll operator suddenly require any motorist seeking to use the toll roads to stick things in their windscreen or put chips in their car, or whatever it might be?
Richard Quigley (Isle of Wight West) (Lab)
Does the hon. Gentleman agree that there is a problem with ghost number plates and other forms of avoiding ANPR, automatic number plate recognition? What would his solution to that be?
I take the hon. Gentleman’s point—there is certainly a problem with ghost plates, but that is an enforcement problem for the authorities, for police forces, for the Government to crack down on to stop a criminal practice that he is right to say is happening on our streets. I am not convinced, however, that we should legislate for a scheme that will involve the tolling of new infrastructure, such as the lower Thames crossing, and require the expense of technology not only going into cars, but to read that technology in cars in order to pay the tolls, when we have a registration system on all our vehicles in the first place.
On those registration plates, we have agreements with many other countries whose citizens could conceivably drive to the United Kingdom from abroad, to ensure that their plates are recognisable as well. In particular in London, therefore, any visitors driving over from France, Belgium, the Netherlands or wherever will, equally, not need to start strapping devices to their windscreens in order to visit our country, to spend their money here and to enjoy the wonderful things we have to offer in England.
I put it to the Minister that this could be a much simpler Bill if we simply get rid of those provisions. I do not want to relitigate the argument about exactly how much the toll is going to be—we still do not know—but before any toll level is set, affected road users, businesses, residents and local authorities should be consulted. Surely that is a straightforward ask.
We heard a lot of evidence from the haulage sector in our oral evidence sessions. The sector already operates on tiny margins; it is very common for a haulage operator, certainly those that I visit in my own constituency, to be operating on as low as a 1% margin. If haulage operators are to be charged these tolls, it is vital that they should have their say, and for that to be put clearly on the record. We should also bear in mind that ultimately all the costs get added to the cost of the goods being transported, so this is an inflation-fuelling measure.
We all know how consultations go sometimes—we do not always get what we want—but the impact that any tolls could have should be clear and on the record, so that when that toll rate is set, it takes into account, if nothing else, the market conditions that will dictate whether people are willing to use that road or will take any measure conceivable to avoid getting on it in the first place.
Any new tolling scheme or any increase to an existing toll should require Parliament’s approval. Why should that decision be left to operators, Ministers or the ORR alone? We need safeguards to prevent unnecessary equipment requirements, and parliamentary control to apply to the level of any charges.
Amendment 50 would amend the ability of the Secretary of State to reassign responsibility for payment of a toll through regulation. The shadow Minister argues that the amendment would remove the power to specify any circumstances in regulations about how tolls would be paid. The amendment would remove important flexibility from the tolling system and the ability to make someone other than the registered keeper responsible for paying a toll in specified circumstances.
This provision matters, as it is not always possible to trace the registered keeper of a vehicle and there may be situations where it is appropriate for another party to be pursued for payment. That could include hired or leased vehicles, as I am sure the witnesses from last week would attest to. It could also be important where vehicles are registered overseas or following a change of vehicle ownership. Ultimately, it will normally be right for the registered keeper to be held liable for any charges, but that will not always be the case, for the reasons I have set out. It is important that we maintain flexibility.
Clause 24(2)(b) allows regulations to address precisely those circumstances, providing for someone other than the registered keeper to pay the toll where keeper liability would be inappropriate. The question is not whether tolls should be paid, but who should be responsible for them. We would retain the flexibility to make that distinction, rather than impose keeper liability in every case. I therefore ask the hon. Member to withdraw the amendment.
Amendment 51 would amend the ability for a licence holder to require equipment to be carried in or fitted to a vehicle. It is worth pointing out that just because something is in the legislation, that does not mean there is some dastardly, secret plan to implement it. I will give a practical example of why this power is in the Bill. At the Dartford crossing, before the toll barriers were removed, those who wished to do so were able to set up an account and place a smart tag in their vehicle. The smart tag would speak to the toll booth and open the barriers, charging the registered account. It meant that those who had the tag did not need to open their windows to drop a coin into the bucket at the booth, and it sped up their journey. A similar arrangement applied at the Mersey tunnels.
There are, of course, no longer barriers at the Dartford crossing and the charges are based on the number plates of those who cross. We have already heard why that is not necessarily a foolproof process. But—this is the point of having the clause in the Bill—we do not know what might happen in the future in terms of technology in cars. It is possible that we might not even have number plates at all. Perhaps there will be chips attached to vehicles that have all the user’s data on them, which will be important in tracing the registered keeper. The fact that we do not know how vehicles will develop in the future means that it is important to keep the Bill technology-neutral. That is the purpose of this clause.
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. We believe that it would not be in the interests of the licence holder to have a differential scheme, but he is right to raise the importance of that local voice and we believe the legislation as it stands will enable that to happen.
Amendment 54 would, if enacted, see a requirement inserted for Parliament to approve each new tolling scheme. Making pricing dependent on parliamentary approval would introduce uncertainty for investors about the revenues on which a scheme depends. We need a framework that combines effective public controls with the predictability necessary to attract long-term private investment. The Bill seeks to strike that balance through independent regulation. The ORR is a strong independent regulator with a reputation for boosting investor confidence by fostering stable, predictable investment conditions, and it has responsibility for setting tolling requirements and enforcing them. That is the right approach, with robust regulatory oversight within a stable, predictable framework, rather than making prices subject to a separate parliamentary decision.
My concern is therefore not with scrutiny itself, but with the uncertainty the amendment would create for financing schemes under the Bill. It would make those schemes, including the lower Thames crossing, less attractive to investors and harder to finance. I therefore ask the Member not to press the amendment.
I am grateful to the Minister for his response to the amendments. On the equipment in vehicles point, as I said in my earlier remarks, we are in danger of taking several steps backwards, as he himself acknowledged that there were schemes in the past where we used to wind our window down—literally wind it down, rather than press a button—and then throw a few coins into a basket. That has gone—it is over—and so should that be gone and over and moved to an ANPR system, albeit with the challenges we have around ghost plates to enforce against.
I just do not understand why we would have any interest—this is not a party political point; this is just a practical point for all our constituents—in trying to bring about a scheme that involves boxes and chips and all sorts of things being required to be put into heavy goods vehicles and private vehicles, rather than just using the number plate system that by law we are all required to have on our vehicles.
On the point about consultation, the hon. Member for Dartford made the point incredibly well. Preventing the disincentives to use a new scheme if the toll turns out to be higher than the existing Dartford crossing scheme is a sensible point. The hon. Gentleman knows his constituency far better than any of us. If he reports that that is a live concern among his constituents, I would urge the Minister to listen so that the good people of Dartford do not find themselves with that disincentive to use a new scheme because it is priced higher than the existing one.
I am content to withdraw amendments 50 and 53, both of which I suspect we will come back to on Report. I really do invite the Minister to think about how that consultation, in the interests of his colleague the hon. Member for Dartford as much as any future schemes, could be addressed before we get to that stage. On amendments 51 and 54, particularly the point on parliamentary approval—not for Parliament to set tolls—given the Minister declined the rules that we suggested around tolling regimes earlier, if there will not be guidance and upper limits as there are on the debt that any licensee may hold, that only leaves the option for us in Parliament to vote on those tolling arrangements as they come along on each and every occasion.
I beg to ask leave to withdraw the amendment.
Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.
Amendment proposed: 51, in clause 24, page 17, line 20, leave out lines 20 and 21—(Greg Smith.)
This amendment would remove the power from a licence holder to specify equipment to be carried in or fitted to a road vehicle while it is on the highway.
Question put, That the amendment be made.
Highways (Financing) Bill (Fifth sitting) Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateGreg Smith
Main Page: Greg Smith (Conservative - Mid Buckinghamshire)Department Debates - View all Greg Smith's debates with the Department for Transport
(4 days, 20 hours ago)
Public Bill Committees
Olly Glover
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Wishart. Amendment 41 would introduce a requirement for blue badge holder discounts on any toll road. It would close a major loophole in clause 25 by making toll exemptions for blue badge holders mandatory rather than optional.
Clause 25 states that a tolling scheme must specify exemptions, leaving it entirely to operator discretion whether any exemptions are offered at all. Although people in the private sector sometimes do the right thing, they are not always necessarily wholly motivated to do so of their own accord. They may therefore need a little encouragement or requirement.
Disabled drivers rely on private vehicles for essential mobility and must not be subjected to commercial toll charges when accessing healthcare, work or local services. Why does clause 25 leave exemptions for disabled drivers, and indeed emergency services, to corporate discretion rather than enshrining them as mandatory rights in primary legislation?
Amendment 42 would establish a statutory right to discounted toll rates for local residents living in close proximity to a toll highway. Local residents who are near major crossings such as the Dartford crossing or lower Thames crossing bear the daily brunt of construction, disruption, air pollution and localised traffic gridlocks. As Edmund King of the AA pointed out in his public evidence to the Committee, frequent local users who cross toll structures for work or daily life face an unfair tax on jobs without dedicated resident discounts. Michael Whelan, the general manager of M6toll, told us that M6toll had introduced a local resident discount, holding local trips to £4, demonstrating that resident schemes are practical and commercially viable. I look forward to the Minister’s comments.
It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mr Wishart. I have a couple of brief remarks to make on the amendments tabled by the third party.
On the point about blue badge holders receiving a discount in statute, of course we all want to see those in society who find themselves in need of a blue badge, with whatever disability they might have, being treated fairly and supported in getting about and living their life. I am not certain, however, that the blue badge system is the correct mechanism for linking that to any tolling regime, as amendment 41 seeks. His Majesty’s official Opposition are not sold on that point.
With amendment 42, however, we have considerably more sympathy. The hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage pointed out the impact on residents near any toll road—in this case, predominantly the lower Thames crossing—who probably have to use it quite regularly to get to and from their homes, businesses, children’s places of education or whatever it might be. Critically, that phase of construction can be incredibly disruptive to somebody’s life. Believe me, Mr Wishart, I know the pain of that from the many infrastructure projects in my own constituency.
The payback for putting up with years of construction— or with some projects, potentially decades—must surely be some fair recognition in legislation. In this case, that could be a discount on any toll for residents within a set geographic distance from the new road as it is built under the licence given to any operator under this proposed legislation. I am looking briefly to the hon. Member for Dartford, who I am sure would want his residents to receive such a discount for using the lower Thames crossing, as I think any of us would if we saw new infrastructure of that type being built in the vicinity of our constituency. It is surely a matter of fairness that those who live near a new scheme and put up with its construction, and who by definition will probably have to use it for access more than most, should receive that discount.
Jim Dickson (Dartford) (Lab)
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Wishart. I will speak to both amendments.
Currently, Dartford residents who use the Dartford crossing are able to do so at a considerable discount. The definition covers residents within the Dartford borough council area, who either pay £25 a year to use the crossing as many times as they like or pay £12.50 a year for 50 crossings. That represents good value for Dartford residents and gives them some compensation for having to live next to a crossing that takes all the burden of traffic crossing the Thames outside London and that therefore causes huge congestion and significant problems with air quality.
I imagine that when the lower Thames crossing is opened, residents of Gravesham or in the area around and north of the crossing will also want a resident discount, to compensate them for living near a busy crossing. The Dartford crossing and the lower Thames crossing will both still be busy, albeit that traffic will be much better distributed between the two, which will certainly be a blessing for Dartford residents.
I totally understand why the Minister does not want this set out in the Bill; I am sure he will say that such things should be dealt with by the regulator and the licence holder. However, I hope he will give Dartford residents some assurance that that conversation will be had at the right moment, as we expect, so they can have confidence that they will continue to benefit from the current concessions and maybe even see them extended to both crossings, as might be the case for Gravesham residents using the Dartford crossing in future.
I understand the Minister’s argument, but it is predicated on good will. As his words will be taken into account in any future analysis or interpretation of legislation, can he confirm that he believes that it is at least right in principle that residents in an area near any new road get a discount not just for living close to it and using it, but as a form of compensation or recognition for having lived through construction?
I absolutely understand the shadow Minister’s point. The whole point of this work is to make life easier for local residents. There will of course be some disruption during construction but, in the case of the lower Thames crossing, the local road network is quite a long way from the majority of the works. The powers of the regulator, the opportunity for guidance to be given to stakeholder groups and the overriding duties of the ORR are sufficient to give us confidence that the intentions that I have espoused today will be delivered.
My amendment 5 is intended to put beyond doubt that the penalty charge referred to in clause 25 relates to a failure to pay the toll. I hope hon. Members will agree that it is a straightforward amendment made for the purposes of clarity.
Clause 25, as amended, will set out the information that a licence holder must include in its tolling scheme. The scheme must clearly identify the highway where tolls will apply and explain when drivers will have to pay. It must set out which vehicle types will be charged, the amount of the toll and any exemptions or reduced rates. It must explain how and when tolls must be paid and how the licence holder will record and collect payments. It must describe the information that will be used to decide whether a toll is due or has been paid. It must also explain what might happen if a toll is not paid, including the level of any penalty or other charge. Importantly, the scheme must explain how a driver can challenge a toll.
The clause will allow different tolls to apply in different circumstances. For example, charges may vary by time of day, distance travelled, type or use of vehicle or method of payment. The licence holder must publish the scheme in a way that brings it to the attention of people likely to be affected. It must also provide a copy to anyone who asks.
The clause will therefore ensure that drivers can understand when tolls apply, how much they must pay and what rights they have if they wish to challenge a charge. I hope that hon. Members can see the logic of setting that out in the Bill. I commend clause 25, as amended, to the Committee.
I will address clause 26, which requires the ORR to publish a code on how tolls should be charged. The code will set out the principles and standards that tolling arrangements should meet. Its purpose is to ensure that tolls are charged fairly and transparently for road users. The ORR may update or replace the code at any time, and any updated or replacement code must also be published. The ORR may leave out information if publishing it would be likely to harm a person’s commercial interests.
Clause 26 therefore provides clear and independent oversight of how licence holders charge tolls, while protecting genuinely sensitive commercial information, and I commend it to the Committee. I will respond to the Opposition amendment once I have heard what the shadow Minister has to say.
I wish to speak to amendment 69, in my name and that of my hon. Friend the Member for Bognor Regis and Littlehampton. There is a recurring theme in this Bill, and in plenty of other legislation debated in this and the previous Session: we are being asked to trust—throughout all the stages of the Bill, including here in Committee this morning—that something will be produced that is material and intrinsic to the legislation that we are debating and voting on. I could almost describe it as an “It’ll Be Alright on the Night” principle: “It’ll be fine—it’ll be published at some later date. Pass the legislation, then we can judge what the code actually says once the Bill has received Royal Assent and become an Act.” That opens up many questions for this Committee, for the wider House and, most importantly, for all the travelling public across the country.
Amendment 69 is, I would have thought, relatively straightforward. It would prevent any measure in this Act from coming into force until the ORR has published its code relating to the charging of tolls. It cannot possibly be unreasonable that the principles and rules—not the pounds and pence—must be known and clear to all those who may at some point need to pay those tolls, be they a private motorist or members of our incredible logistics sector and road hauliers across the country. It cannot be unreasonable that, when they are making their business plans, they ought to be clear what those rules will be. The regulator’s toll charging code is absolutely central to how motorists will be treated.
I simply put a few questions to the Minister, who I suspect will be resistant to the amendment—I suspect we will hear similar arguments to those he has given on similar amendments to different parts of the Bill previously. If the Government are to resist the amendment, will the Minister answer whether the code will explain the principles of setting tolls, payment transparency and the treatment of road users and toll payers? How far in advance will the code be published in draft and subject to consultation?
What consultation will any such code be subject to? Will that consultation be meaningful, or will it be the sort of consultation that we have become all too familiar with in recent years? Within the confines of that consultation, how will motorists and operators be able to understand with detail and clarity what any such code will actually mean for them? In the real world and in the lived experience of all of us across all sorts of different sectors, we often get these sorts of codes and principles published, and they are not very clear. They are open to a lot of interpretation. If we do not have it set out as clearly as possible now, how will the real users of the roads be able to contribute to the way that code is shaped and get the answers that they deserve—before they find themselves trapped on camera, with a penalty charge notice through the post, trying to understand what on earth went wrong in the first place?
I am grateful to the shadow Minister for reminding us all of Denis Norden and “It’ll be Alright on the Night”. I am not sure I can give him that level of wisdom today, but I will attempt to answer his questions.
The shadow Minister has of course correctly predicted that we will not be accepting the amendment. I hope he is going to give us the lottery numbers for Saturday night as well—his powers of prediction are very strong; he may even anticipate what I am going to say. The amendment would force the ORR to publish a tolling code in the abstract before the Act has commenced and therefore before the licensing authority could actually consult on the licence, which is required under clause 4 of the Bill. That could slow down or delay the delivery of the lower Thames crossing.
The tolling code will set out the principles and constraints that the licence holder must follow when proposing, setting and implementing tolls.
We will come to that issue later in the Bill, so if my hon. Friend bears with me, I will address it then. In summary, clause 27 provides a clear framework for dealing with unpaid tolls, while ensuring that the detailed rules and penalty rates are set through regulations or by the ORR within that regulatory framework.
Amendments 11 and 12 extend the scope of the offences under clause 28(3) to cases where a person seeks to avoid payment of a penalty charge for non-payment of a toll, as well as to those seeking to avoid payment of the toll itself. It is plain to me that those offences, principally for fraudulently seeking to avoid payment, should apply equally in relation to a penalty charge as to a toll.
Amendment 13 creates a new offence within clause 28 for the unlawful removal of a penalty charge. This is standard in relation to the issuance of penalty charges and is principally there to discourage anyone other than the person for whom the charge is intended from removing the notice from the vehicle. That ensures that the intended recipient gets proper notice.
Clause 28, as it will be amended, deals with deliberate attempts to avoid paying tolls, as well as the unauthorised charging of tolls. It makes it an offence to deliberately interfere with tolling equipment or obscure a vehicle registration plate to avoid paying a toll or being identified for non-payment. It is also an offence to deliberately use false information or documents to seek to avoid payment of a toll or a penalty charge. Those offences can result in an unlimited fine, imprisonment or both.
The clause also sets out that it is an offence for anyone not authorised to do so to remove a notification of a penalty charge from a vehicle. That can attract a fine of up to £500. The clause also protects road users by making it an offence to charge or collect tolls without complying with the Bill’s requirements, or without being authorised to do so. That can attract a fine of up to £1,000. A person carrying out tolling functions on behalf of the licence holder under clause 31 is not caught by that restriction. Clause 28 therefore provides sanctions against deliberate toll and penalty charge evasion, while also protecting road users from unauthorised toll collection.
Government new clause 1 gives regulation-making powers to the Secretary of State and the Lord Chancellor to make regulations about the imposition and enforcement of penalty charges related to a specified list of additional matters related to tolling. The list includes matters such as the release of a vehicle from an immobilisation device and, where certain equipment or documentation is required as part of a tolling scheme, a failure to carry them. Those are charges that the holder of a licence could conceivably need to levy, but they would be conferred only as needed. As is the case for penalty charges related to non-payment of tolls, the clause would allow for the rates to be set either by the Secretary of State or by the Office of Rail and Road as the independent regulator.
As with the other penalty charges in the Bill, the new clause includes two offences. First, it is an offence to make false representations, including by using a false document, with intent to avoid paying a penalty charge or being identified as having failed to pay one. On summary conviction, that carries imprisonment up to the maximum term for summary offences, a fine or both. Mere non-payment is not itself the offence; an unpaid charge is recoverable as a civil debt.
Secondly, it is an offence to remove a penalty charge notice fixed to a vehicle unless the person is its registered keeper, is using it with the keeper’s authority, or acts with the authority of either such person or the licence holder. That protects proper notification while allowing authorised removal. On summary conviction, the offence carries a fine not exceeding level 2 on the standard scale. I commend these provisions to the Committee, and will respond to the shadow Minister’s amendments in closing.
This is indeed a mega grouping. Before I come to our amendments, I will speak to the Government amendments, most of which are tidying. We do not have an issue with the majority of them, but Government amendment 13 confuses me. I appreciate that there are provisions later in the Bill that may address some of my issues, but the amendment talks about removing penalty charge notices “fixed” to vehicles. Now, that opens up a very big question. How, on a moving highway, as someone uses a toll road, could a penalty charge notice ever become “fixed” to a vehicle in the first place?
This is not a parking charge ticket of the kind that those workers out there who have a higher social standing than us politicians—traffic wardens—fix to windscreens, although even that is becoming less commonplace as enforcement has moved to automatic number plate recognition systems. I wonder how the Minister thinks that on a moving highway—the lower Thames crossing, the M6 toll or the Mersey tunnel—a ticket would ever find itself fixed with that immovable glue to someone’s windscreen in the first place.
The rest of the Government amendments are tidying. I wonder why the provisions were not thought through when the Bill was first published, but that is a debate we could have time and again.
We will come to this later in the Bill, but I have sympathy with the point made by the hon. Member for Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket about the unfortunate situation we find ourselves in at the moment, where in many parts of the country Royal Mail delays are extreme to the point that people receive things like penalty charge notices or medical appointment letters too late to meet the initial payment window or attend the appointment. That is a fact of life today. We all want to see it improve and get back to a postal system that we can all fully and totally rely on. I ask the Minister to reflect on that practical fact of life right now as he considers the points raised about the issuing of penalty charge notices.
Amendments 52, 59 and 71 are all applicable to clauses 27 and 28. Amendment 52 caps a penalty charge for failure to pay a toll at £100, amendment 59 would ensure that regulations about penalty charges were subject to the affirmative procedure, and amendment 71 would delay commencement until the Secretary of State has published the penalty charge policy.
I put to the Committee that a penalty charge must always be proportionate. When it comes to the use of a toll road, I do not see a good argument for not putting a clear £100 limit on a penalty charge notice on the face of the Bill. It could be increased over time through statutory instruments subject to the affirmative procedure, which we will come to in a moment, but not without the consent of the House. Of course, costs go up and there might be reasons to put it up in the future, but something as fundamental as certainty and proportionality when it comes to any penalty charge notice for the private citizen or business operator using a road should be a decision for Parliament.
I come to this debate with a clear view of the world. Save maybe one or two—a number of people that could be counted on the fingers of one hand—I do not think anybody out there ever deliberately sets out to avoid paying a £5, £6, £7, £8 or £10 toll to use the M6 toll or the Mersey tunnel, or will do in the case of the lower Thames crossing of the future. I just do not think we are in the realms of deliberate avoidance—certainly not with an ANPR enforcement regime where everybody knows there is nowhere to hide and number plates will have been captured.
Therefore, we are not talking about gross dishonesty or grand criminality; we are talking about normal people—any of us in this room—taking a journey and perhaps, for whatever reason, forgetting to pay. There are too many stresses of the day. The kids are screaming in the back, asking to go to every fast food joint they see at every service station advertised in large letters on the motorway. It slips your mind. It can happen to any of us. I therefore suggest a simple cap that gives people the confidence that, if they admit they have made a mistake and forgotten to pay, the penalty will not be an extortionate amount of money, but will instead, as amendment 52 suggests, have a ceiling of £100. This will affect many people on a daily basis, and I believe it should be proportionate.
Olly Glover
I have a question for the Conservatives on their amendment 52. They seem to have been on a rather rapid journey, having had a significant change of mind on the principle of caps since the Civil Aviation (Consumer Protection and Regulatory Reform) Bill Committee. Then, the hon. Member for Bognor Regis and Littlehampton delivered a withering and scathing speech on one of our amendments, which proposed a cap on airport drop-off fees. She argued that it would create a moral hazard and encourage everyone to charge the maximum, yet their amendment 52 tries to set a cap at £100 for failure to pay a toll. Perhaps Conservative Members could address why they feel that is not a moral hazard.
There is a fundamental difference between a fee to do something and a penalty for having forgotten to do something. I therefore think the two positions are entirely compatible. We have a very clear view on airport drop-off charges, but it is nothing to do with this Bill. They are a hindrance to airport users, but there is a fundamental difference between a charge to use a toll road or to drop someone off at an airport and a penalty for failing to do so.
Olly Glover
We could no doubt carry on and have an interesting discussion about economic theory and behavioural incentives, but I gently suggest that the principle is the same. Amendment 52 could encourage every private operator automatically to set their penalty charge at £100 rather than £10, £25 or £50, in the hope of making more money. I feel that the argument made by the hon. Member for Bognor Regis and Littlehampton is relevant to this, but I will leave it there and allow the Conservatives to address that further.
The hon. Gentleman is a generous man.
There are discounts available for early payment in most of these schemes anyway, which I think would speak to the impassioned plea he made about people who innocently contravene the regulations. It is important that such a change is made in regulations and not primary legislation for reasons I will go on to explain.
I do not believe fixing a cap in primary legislation would be the right approach. Penalty charges vary across the country depending on local conditions. For example, the Tyne tunnel has an initial penalty charge of £30 plus the toll, while for the Blackwall and Silvertown tunnels the full charge is £180. The levels of PCNs and the structure of payments need to be appropriate and proportionate to the specific scheme. The Bill already allows penalty charges to be set through regulations, and that responsibility is to be delegated to the Office of Rail and Road acting in accordance with its statutory duties, which we have covered several times already. That of course gives it the flexibility to keep charges under review.
One of the problems with setting a fixed price cap in legislation is that it will erode in real terms with inflation. Hopefully, we will not see rising inflation over the coming years, but of course it is inevitable that, as time goes on, the value of the cap will decrease. For a good example of why fixing these caps in legislation is a bad idea, I refer the shadow Minister to the saga of the Swinford toll bridge, which I am sure he is familiar with: the 10p fee was set in 1760—I believe that is a little time before the hon. Member was actively engaged in politics—and because it was fixed in primary legislation, it has unfortunately not moved on because of the difficulty in changing it. That is a good example of why setting these figures in primary legislation is inappropriate.
My hon. Friend is absolutely correct. The situation under the Bill gives the regulator the power to deal with those kinds of instances. If licence conditions are not being complied with, which is the sort of situation to which he has referred, the Bill gives the regulator the power to intervene. That strengthens the position for people in those instances, although hopefully we will not have too many such instances.
Amendment 59 concerns the use of regulations. It is the case that using the negative procedure for this type of regulation follows an established precedent set in the Transport Act 2000. The Road User Charging Schemes (Penalty Charges, Adjudication and Enforcement) (England) Regulations 2013 were made under the procedure, and they are comparable with the regulations that we would expect to make under the Bill. They implement the detailed machinery needed to enable the charging authorities to impose and enforce civil penalties, including adjudication and, subject to safeguards, vehicle examination or search, immobilisation and removal.
The negative procedure provides an appropriate balance between parliamentary scrutiny and the flexibility required to ensure that the penalty charge regime remains effective, proportionate and capable of adapting to future operational requirements, without the need for further primary legislation. As explained in the delegated powers memorandum, published alongside the Bill, those regulations will set out the detailed enforcement framework to confer powers. As with many things that concern operational matters, this needs to remain flexible, hence why regulations were chosen as the mechanism for setting out the detail. I invite the hon. Member for Mid Buckinghamshire not to press amendment 59 to a vote.
Amendment 71 would prevent the Bill from coming into force until after the publication of a report on the policy regarding penalty charges. Unfortunately, this would also slow and frustrate the progress that we want to make on the lower Thames crossing. Clause 27 allows the Secretary of State to make regulations about the very thing that this amendment asks for: a report before commencement.
It is already the case that Parliament will need to see details of the enforcement regime by way of the regulations made under clause 27 before any enforcement regime would come into effect. Blocking commencement of the rest of the Bill until a report had been issued would mean Parliament being asked to look at the same thing twice—once in a Government publication, and again when it scrutinises regulations. That is the kind of bureaucracy and slowing of progress that we want to avoid. Again, I ask the hon. Member for Mid Buckinghamshire not to press amendment 71 to a vote.
Amendment 6 agreed to.
Amendments made: 7, in clause 27, page 19, line 22, leave out paragraph (a).
This amendment is consequential on amendment 10.
Amendment 8, in clause 27, page 19, line 28, leave out paragraph (e).
This amendment is consequential on amendment 10.
Amendment 9, in clause 27, page 19, line 38, at end insert—
“(6A) Regulations under subsection (1) which make provision for the imposition of a penalty charge must specify whether the charge is payable in addition to the toll in respect of which the charge is payable or instead of it.”
This amendment ensures that a requirement to pay a toll may remain in force (and therefore be recoverable as a civil debt under clause 24) even where a penalty charge is imposed in respect of the toll.
Amendment 10, in clause 27, page 19, line 38, at end insert—
“(6B) The Lord Chancellor may make regulations about the notification and enforcement of penalty charges.”—(Justin Madders.)
This amendment provides that regulations about the notification and enforcement of a penalty charge in respect of a toll are to be made by the Lord Chancellor (instead of by the Secretary of State).
Clause 27, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clause 28
Non-payment of tolls and unauthorised charging of tolls
Amendments made: 11, in clause 28, page 20, line 17, after “toll” insert
“or of a penalty charge imposed in accordance with regulations under section 27(1)”
This amendment and amendment 12 widen the offence under clause 28(3) to cases where a person seeks to avoid payment of a penalty charge for non-payment of a toll.
Amendment 12, in clause 28, page 20, line 18, after “toll” insert
“or a penalty charge mentioned in paragraph (a)”
See the explanatory statement for amendment 11.
Amendment 13, in clause 28, page 20, line 23, at end insert—
“(4A) A person commits an offence if the person removes a notice of a penalty charge imposed in accordance with regulations under section 27(1) which has been fixed to a road vehicle in accordance with regulations under section 27(6B) unless—
(a) the person is the registered keeper of the vehicle or a person using the vehicle with the registered keeper’s authority, or
(b) the person does so under the authority of the registered keeper or such a person or of the holder of a licence.
(4B) A person who commits an offence under subsection (4A) is liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 2 on the standard scale.”—(Justin Madders.)
This amendment creates an offence where a person removes a notice of a penalty charge from a vehicle without lawful authority.
Clause 28, as amended, ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clause 29
Examination, entry, search and seizure
I beg to move amendment 55, in clause 29, page 20, line 34, leave out “holder of a licence” and insert “police.”
This amendment would ensure that powers for examining a road vehicle rested with the police, rather than the licence holder.
The Chair
With this it will be convenient to discuss the following:
Amendment 56, in clause 29, page 21, line 11, leave out “holder of a licence” and insert “police.”
This amendment would ensure that powers for entering a road vehicle rested with the police, rather than the licence holder.
Amendment 88, in clause 29, page 21, line 23, at end insert—
“(2A) Regulations under subsection (2) may not authorise a person to enter or search a road vehicle, or seize items therefrom, except—
(a) under the authority of a warrant issued by a Justice of the Peace; or
(b) in the presence and under the direction of a police constable.”
This amendment aligns enforcement powers with standard civil debt procedure under Schedule 12 to the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 by ensuring that private toll operators or contracted enforcement agents cannot enter or search private vehicles without a judicial warrant issued by a magistrate or police oversight.
Amendment 57, in clause 29, page 21, line 31, leave out “holder of a licence” and insert “police.”
This amendment would ensure that powers for seizing anything from a road vehicle rested with the police, rather than the licence holder.
Clause stand part.
Amendment 60, in clause 100, page 66, line 32, at end insert—
“(f) regulations under section 29(1) (powers to examine a road vehicle).”
This amendment would ensure that regulations about examining a road vehicle were subject to the affirmative procedure.
Amendment 61, in clause 100, page 66, line 32, at end insert—
“(f) regulations under section 29(2) (powers to enter a road vehicle).”
This amendment would ensure that regulations about entering a road vehicle were subject to the affirmative procedure.
Amendment 62, in clause 100, page 66, line 32, at end insert—
“(f) regulations under section 29(5) (powers of seizure).”
This amendment would ensure that regulations about seizing evidence from a road vehicle were subject to the affirmative procedure.
Amendment 74, in clause 103, page 67, line 18, leave out lines 18 to 21 and insert
“after the Secretary of State has published guidance about how the powers in section 29 and section 30 will be exercised by licence holders.”
This amendment would prevent the Act from coming into force until the Secretary of State has published guidance about the exercise of the powers in sections 29 and 30 of this Act.
There are quite a few amendments in the group, but they largely speak to very similar themes. Amendment 55 would ensure that the powers for examining a road vehicle rest with the police, rather than any licence holder, and amendments 56 and 57 would do the same. Amendment 60 is slightly different but also comes back to a debate that we had in the previous group. It would ensure that regulations on examining a vehicle were subject to the affirmative procedure, so I will not repeat those arguments, and the same applies to amendments 61 and 62. Similar again to the previous group, amendment 74 would prevent commencement of the Act, if the Bill receives Royal Assent, until the Secretary of State has published guidance about the exercise of the powers in clauses 29 and 30.
Douglas Lumsden
Does my hon. Friend agree that the Government should remove the threat of equipment being required in vehicles for people to use tolls? We argued previously that ANPR would be the sensible way forward. I have heard today that ANPR will be used for fines, so why can it not be used for tolls? The Government should remove the requirement for equipment to be installed in vehicles, thereby removing the possibility of operators going into vehicles to check that the equipment is working.
My hon. Friend strengthens the argument considerably. It all comes back to this point of proportionality and fairness, and the system that most of us—certainly the vast majority of our constituents—thought we were operating under already, which such intrusive powers would drive a coach and horses through.
Alison Griffiths
To build on the point that my hon. Friend the Member for Aberdeen South just made, by putting such equipment into vehicles, we are exponentially increasing the cyber-threat and the attack surface for state actors to come in and paralyse not just our state but our communities.
My hon. Friend makes a good point. However, given the number of vehicles on our roads that have been so heavily subsidised by the Chinese state, I suspect that horse has already bolted.
If I may briefly speak to amendment 88 in the name of the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage, without stealing his thunder—
The hon. Member seems happy with that, but I do not particularly wish to steal. Amendment 88 potentially offers a useful off-ramp for the Minister—and perhaps a halfway house in ensuring that the rights of the private citizen and the property owner are protected within this—by preventing enforcement officers from entering or searching private vehicles without either a judicial warrant issued by a magistrate or police oversight. That is commonplace for any other search or seizure in our country, with some notable, very extreme exceptions. Therefore, before the hon. Gentleman speaks to his amendment 88, I simply put on the record that the official Opposition has considerable sympathy with that approach and, if he presses it to a Division, we will support it.
I urge the Minister to seriously reflect on the implications from this part of the Bill for accepted norms and precedents within our society, and what enabling a licensee to enter, search and seize—as opposed to the established bodies that we already accept in this country have the legitimate authority, power and trust to do so—would mean for the entire social contract within the country.
Olly Glover
I will say a little about amendment 88, which the shadow Minister has started off, and then make some brief comments about the Conservatives’ amendments as a whole.
Amendment 88 would strengthen the safeguards around vehicle searches in the Bill by restricting private enforcement powers under clause 29 and requiring a judicial warrant issued by a magistrate, or a police presence, before entering or searching a vehicle. Under standard civil enforcement rules in schedule 12 to the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007, court bailiffs recovering civil debts cannot enter or search vehicles without a judicial warrant of control. In that context, clause 29 creates an extraordinary anomaly whereby private toll contractors would enjoy broader, unmonitored powers of search and entry than certificated court bailiffs. The clause, as drafted, looks to give huge, potentially unintended powers to private contractors. Users of these roads should be given more protection to prevent infringement of their civil liberties with little oversight. I therefore hope that the Minister will consider amendment 88.
Most of the Conservatives’ amendments in this group seem sensible, and we are inclined to support them, but I have a—“philosophical” is perhaps overly generous—vaguely political-philosophical question about them. A lot of their amendments tend to take two routes. The first is requiring various things to be published before the Bill comes into force. We understand that route and are inclined to support it; it is a similar argument to what we heard about the ORR code. The other route is requiring the affirmative procedure rather than the negative procedure. The challenge with amendments that would require more use of the affirmative procedure is finding the right balance between holding a Government to account and not making virtually every change subject to a House of Commons vote.
At some point, could the shadow Minister say a little bit about the Conservatives’ thought process and criteria for what should be subject to the affirmative procedure? They are asking for a lot of things to be subject to the affirmative procedure. In principle, that could mean a very large number of things coming to the Commons for a Division after consideration by a Delegated Legislation Committee, but perhaps I have misunderstood and he can clarify.
I will have a bit of banter and answer the Liberal Democrat spokesperson’s question about the Conservative approach to delegated legislation. He need only look at their 14 years in power to see that they were very fond of the negative procedure and delegated legislation.
Well, we can rehearse that argument, but I am delighted that the shadow Minister has found a new interest in championing the need for the role of Parliament, and I assure him that his fears are misplaced.
I will turn to amendments 55 to 57 tabled by the shadow Minister. He has raised the spectre of individuals prodding around in private property and has, rightly, asked what safeguards there will be. It might be helpful if I explain that the broad framework in this Bill follows the approach of the Transport Act 2000, which has detailed safeguards that have been set out in regulations. I believe that those regulations are the right place to specify how these powers may be exercised and the protections that must accompany them.
I need to be clear about what the regulations are and are not. They do not allow for any person to be authorised to pull over vehicles on a highway, and they do not enable any person to interfere with a vehicle on private property. The powers are about enabling the licence holder to determine whether tolling conditions have been complied with or an offence has occurred. They will be conferred only if strictly necessary, and in the case of entry into a vehicle or seizure of evidence, I state quite happily on the record that I envisage a role for a constable in those circumstances.
The question is therefore not whether safeguards are needed, because I think we agree on that, but how best to provide them. We should also make sure that the licence holder has the tools they need to safeguard their significant investment from nefarious characters. The shadow Minister referred to pressures on the police; I wonder whether his shadow Home Office colleagues have considered the impact his amendment would have for resource burden on the police. I recognise his concern, but police should not be enforcing debts owed to private operators.
Enforcement powers should remain with the licence holder, with police oversight to ensure that those powers are not used in an intrusive manner. I can confirm that our intention is to make regulations to require the powers of entry and seizure to be exercised only in the presence of a constable. I favour setting out detailed arrangements in regulations to make sure that the right safeguards are attributed to the right place with the correct detail, rather than prescribing a blunt tool in the Bill. Hopefully that gives the shadow Minister some assurance.
I now turn to amendment 88. I thank the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage (Olly Glover) for his contribution. Again, I think that he and I agree on the need for proper safeguards for the existence of enforcement powers, but I believe that the approach he suggests follows the wrong precedent and would result in an overly burdensome and ineffective enforcement process. The precedent he cites relates to the enforcement of court orders designed for the recovery of charges, but clause 29 is about ascertaining whether an offence has occurred in the first place. Our view is that it would be inappropriate to seek a judicial warrant before it has been determined whether an offence has been committed.
On that basis, it is right that we follow the precedent set out in the Transport Act 2000, but the hon. Member again has my assurance that regulations made under this power will have the significant safeguards he has described. I agree that it would be unacceptable to give unfettered rights to private operators to enter the vehicles without sufficient oversight, so I invite him not to press the amendment.
I think the hon. Member misunderstands the purpose of the clause. This not about requiring equipment to be put into particular vehicles. I will describe what clause 29 will actually do. It will give the Secretary of State powers to make regulations to provide limited enforcement powers in relation to vehicles. Those can be used to check whether required documents are displayed and whether tolling equipment is fitted and working properly—that is to say, that it has not been interfered with in a manner that might trigger the offences outlined in clause 28.
Regulations may also allow entry into a vehicle where there are reasonable grounds to suspect that equipment has been deliberately interfered with or that a false document is being used to avoid paying a toll or being identified. This may allow items to be seized and kept as evidence of an offence under clause 28. These powers will be subject to clear limits. Examination of or entry into a vehicle will be authorised only while a vehicle is on the highway. Intentionally obstructing someone lawfully exercising a power of entry will be an offence, and could be subject to a fine or imprisonment. Clause 29 will therefore provide the tools needed to investigate deliberate toll evasion, with the detail and safeguards set through regulations. I commend it to the Committee.
I turn to amendments 61 and 62, tabled by the shadow Minister. As explained in a delegated powers memorandum published alongside the Bill, these regulations will set out the details of the enforcement framework to confer powers. As with many things that concern operational matters, there is a need to remain flexible, hence why regulations were chosen as the mechanism for setting out the detail. The negative procedure for this type of regulation follows the precedent set in the Transport Act 2000. The negative procedure provides an appropriate balance between parliamentary scrutiny and the flexibility required to ensure that the penalty charge regime remains effective, proportionate and capable of adapting to future operational requirements without the need for further primary legislation. I therefore invite the shadow Minister to withdraw the amendments.
On amendment 74, we have had this debate on a number of occasions already. We believe that it is an unnecessary amendment that would have the effect of frustrating Parliament and slowing down delivery of projects under the regulated asset base model. Clause 29 will already allow the Secretary of State to make regulations about the very thing that this amendment asks for. Before commencement, this amendment would lead to Parliament being asked to look at the same thing twice: once as a Government publication and again when regulations were published. We believe that that is an unnecessary bureaucratic approach, and we cannot support it.
I really do not want a long tit-for-tat session between me and the Liberal Democrat spokesman.
That is for another time. For the representative of a party that literally has the word “Democrats” in its name to make an argument against this House following the affirmative procedure when it comes to setting regulations and for finding a “balance” that just goes with the negative procedure a number of times is really quite hard to stomach. We know that with the demise of the “Orange Book” tribe in that party, they are no longer at least classically liberal; now, it turns out that they are also arguing against democracy. Trading Standards may well be called in when it comes to the titling of the third party.
Olly Glover
How generous of the shadow Minister to give way. He is usually quite a mature, thoughtful fellow—I put it to him that he might be being slightly juvenile in his comments now. He will know full well that my remarks earlier were not criticising his amendments; they were asking for his thoughts on the principles he was using in relation to use of the affirmative procedure. To take his argument to the extreme, we could have literally everything subject to the affirmative procedure. Without doubt, we would then spend our entire life having Divisions in the House of Commons, which we all love, but there is a balance. As for changes to the nature of party names, I suggest to him that abandoning the commitment to climate change and human rights is not very conservative either.
To get back to the amendment and the use of the affirmative procedure, my considered view is that our constituents sent us here to make such decisions. If we are honest about it, the only direct power that any of us actually has as a Member of Parliament is when the Division bell goes or the Chair signals a Division in Committee, and we choose whether to vote aye or no, or not to cast a vote. That is incumbent on us. Whenever we debate something that will affect any of our constituents—in this case, intrusion into their private vehicles—I think that they would expect us not just to talk about it, but to put our vote to the side of the argument that we feel best represents their interests. In direct answer to the question of the hon. Member for Didcot and Wantage, those are my thoughts. Where our constituents are affected, they expect us to have stood up for them, to have argued what we consider to be the best outcome that protects them and enables them to prosper in life, and to put our vote where we think it best serves.
I heard the arguments that the Minister put back. As I have said on other groupings, we do not want to frustrate the core aims and principles of the Bill; we do want to see the lower Thames crossing built and people able to use it, but that does not mean a blank cheque for every provision in the Bill. Something as fundamental to private property rights as the intrusion into a private car does, I think, warrant that additional scrutiny.
I accept that a number of amendments in the grouping fundamentally try to do the same thing, and I can see the numbers in the Committee this afternoon. Therefore, if it helps, Mr Wishart, as we move towards the end of the debate on the grouping, I am happy to confirm that we will test the principle with the lead, amendment 55, but we will be content to withdraw the others on the inclusion of limiting the power to just the police. We will test the core principle once, but I assure the Committee that the Opposition will return to the issue on Report. We will also test the principle in amendment 61 on the affirmative procedure, but I will be content not to press the others in my name.
Question put, That the amendment be made.