(2 days, 3 hours ago)
Commons ChamberAgain, we have been looking at a national framework, but local levies can contain exemptions. That will be for local areas to determine.
Through the Bill, we are also bringing forward provisions on enforcement, appeals and anti-avoidance powers. These include tax-style compliance and inspection powers, civil penalties, rights of appeal to tribunals, and offences for fraudulent evasion or deliberate misstatement. Subject to the passage of the Bill, local leaders will be able to set out plans by March 2028for how levy revenues will be invested, and then introduce a levy before the end of this Parliament.
Further to the point made by my hon. Friend the Member for York Central (Rachael Maskell), the Secretary of State will undoubtedly say that it is for mayors to decide, but surely the Government have an opinion on whether children should be exempt. I cannot imagine that it is the Government’s intention that in places such as Staffordshire, where we are home to the Kibblestone Scout camp, the visitor levy should mean Cubs, Squirrels and Scouts having to pay to stay in the tents they pitch on the Scout camp where they have gone for years.
Again, I gently say that areas will be able to make exemptions. We expect local leaders to factor various needs into the decision-making process, including those of medical visitors, disabled visitors and children, as well as the need for simplicity for business.
The new powers contained in this Bill are just the start. Our plan for good growth in every postcode means that regions will benefit from increased receipts when they grow their tax base. Beginning in 2028, we will replace grants from central Government with a share of local income tax for every mayor. That will sit alongside greater retention of the revenue from business rates for local councils and strategic authorities. We also know that these incentives must be balanced with the need for fairness between places, recognising that there will be different starting points across the country. The fiscal devolution road map sets out how these measures will sit alongside the wider fiscal levers, including the good growth fund.
Throughout this rewiring of the state, we will embed sustainability and transparency, implementing new local accountability arrangements and working with mayoral strategic authorities to ensure fiscal sustainability over time. The Bill embodies those principles by empowering local leaders to benefit from local growth and to deliver investment in a responsible and strategic way. Our plan is for these provisions to benefit the whole of England. We will ensure that every area in England has, or is in the process of establishing, a strategic authority by the end of 2027, with strategic authorities in place everywhere by the end of 2028.
Devolution is about outcomes, not just process. The outcome of this Bill is more investment in local priorities, more new transport infrastructure and more regeneration —more of the things that generate growth and more things that matter to people. We have promised to bring back hope after a decade of decline, and this Bill is part of that. It has been made possible because of the mayors, and I finish by paying tribute to them, including the Mayor of London, Lord Khan, who has campaigned for this measure for so many years; Bev Craig in Greater Manchester, who paved the way through the industry-led city visitor charge; and Steve Rotheram, who has implemented the Liverpool city visitor charge. If we want to build a Britain where all people can live a good life and live it well, where everyone has control to shape their own lives for themselves, we have to give them the means to be able to do it. I commend this Bill to the House.
Let me start by apologising to my colleagues and the rest of Staffordshire, because I will be appropriating a number of their attractions for the purposes of my speech. However, we are one big happy family most of the time.
When you think of places to visit in the UK, Madam Deputy Speaker, you may not think immediately of Stoke-on-Trent or Staffordshire, but that is because most people do not appreciate the depth and wealth of opportunities and experiences that we have. We are home to Alton Towers, which generates about one third of the visitor overnight stays for our entire county. We are home to the World of Wedgwood. The historic roots of our ceramics industry often draw people to explore parts of Staffordshire. We are home to—depending on how we count them—between three and eight different castle settings, because of our rich history that stretches back through the ages. We have Uttoxeter racecourse, the New Vic theatre, the Regent theatre, the Lichfield Garrick theatre and Lichfield cathedral. We have a host of anchor institutions that bring people to Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent.
Currently, what we do not have is a mayor. I am told that we are getting one in 2028, and my fear about some of the Bill’s provisions is that that mayor will have at their disposal a series of opportunities to raise money through the attractions that we have in the county, but the money will ultimately be used to fund their mayoral priorities. I happen to agree with a number of Members from across the House that there needs to be a legislative ringfence to make sure that, if we are to progress with this levy on visitors, it is used solely for the purpose of boosting the tourism offer.
Across my city, we have a host of wonderful things to visit, which are mainly linked to our ceramics industry. People can visit the Spitfire at the Potteries Museum & Art Gallery. They can visit Middleport, Emma Bridgewater and the Gladstone Museum, where “The Great Pottery Throw Down” is filmed, but the strategy that unites all of that does not really exist at the moment. The work being done by the local visitor economic partnership is getting there, but it is not there yet. Any revenue raised from the levy should go towards delivering a strategy, but the Government’s explanatory notes to the Bill state:
“Levy receipts may be used for purposes connected with a strategic authority’s areas of competence. The policy does not impose a legislative national ringfence within those areas, allowing authorities to determine local priorities”.
My fear is that that will mean that newly created mayors who lack revenue income sources from other areas will be encouraged to maximise income from the overnight visitor levy to pay for the other strategic priorities in the county, such as adult education and skills, highways infrastructure and land assembly for urban regeneration—things that do not immediately deliver on the tourism strategy. I ask the Minister to genuinely consider how we can offer at least some statutory guidance, if not legislative protection, to make sure that it is local areas that determine what will be of benefit to tourism, rather than allowing mayors to fund projects that they may wish to claim are tangentially related to tourism.
I also suggest to the Minister that she read a copy of last week’s The Sentinel, in which there is a wonderful article by local author Paul Williams, who has been leading on the heritage, culture and tourism conversations in our city. He points out that if we are to introduce the levy, we have to consider where the money comes from and where it goes. As I have pointed out, a third of the overnight visitor stays in Staffordshire are linked to Alton Towers in Staffordshire Moorlands, yet we have a population of 1.1 million, covering everything from the Wolverhampton border to Chesire. How can we make sure that the money raised goes back into the areas where it is raised, where the immediate effects of tourism, as welcome as it is, can be redressed?
The issue on which I genuinely wish to push the Minister is overnight stays for young people. If it is not resolved, I will table an amendment on Report that exempts scouts from having to pay the levy if they are on scout camps. Staffordshire has Kibblestone scout camp. I have spoken to the Potteries North scout group and those in the five towns of Stoke-on-Trent, and they are concerned that squirrels, cubs and explorer scouts going to a scout camp that is solely for the use of scouting organisations, and where there is no public right of access, will have to pay the overnight visitor charge just to undertake their expeditions.
Are we really saying that 14 and 15-year-olds who are doing bronze and silver Duke of Edinburgh awards, and who pitch their tents as part of their overnight stays, are in scope of this levy? When the Minister sat with her officials and civil servants, did they really think that the people we want to pay the overnight levy are those young people who are going out and doing the things that we are encouraging them to do as part of their citizenship education? Are we saying that we are going to charge squirrels—you look perplexed, Madam Deputy Speaker, but they are the youngest entrants into cub scouts, normally at the age of three or four—a levy for going to a scout camp, even when they will stay in a solid-structure building? That seems like a nonsense.
It seems to me that this is an unintended consequence of the legislation. I say to the Minister that, if the Government cannot resolve this and find a way of exempting scouts from the levy, I will table an amendment on Report and, if necessary, try to force a Division on the matter. I think the House will agree that there are certain examples and anomalies that should simply be outside the Bill’s scope. Staying in Alton Towers overnight for a weekend of fun is very different from taking six, seven or eight-year-olds camping for a weekend as part of a scout expedition. We should recognise and redress that anomaly.
The only other thing I want to raise is a cap on the level. When I intervened on the Secretary of State, she said that these would be matters for mayors. Let us be honest: the Government are in charge—we are notionally in charge—so we should be able to say what we think the cap or limit should be. We do it in other areas: we tell councils that they are capped at 5% for their council tax increases if they do not want to trigger a referendum; we tell police and crime commissioners that they are capped at a 5% increase on their precept; and we say to mayors who raise a precept that the size of what they can raise is capped. We understand that there is a responsibility on us here to be a moderating or restraining factor on some of the levers that are available for local people to pull.
If we are going to progress with this levy, and I support the principle of it, let us make sure that we have a legislative ringfence that says the money raised has to be spent on tourism, that it has to be spent on tourism infrastructure in the locality from which it is raised, and that mayors with these powers are limited to an increase of no more than 5% without having to seek a proper democratic and accountable sign-off either from the local authorities or from the Government. Such small amendments would make this Bill better, and I hope the Minister will address the points I have raised when she sums up.
Sally Jameson
I will not give way again to the hon. Member.
Local authorities will have the opportunity to feed into local consultation and decision-making processes. Local authorities will also see the benefits of revenues being invested locally. I am sure that mayors up and down the country will ensure that voices of MPs and council leaders are heard in the process.
Consultants have been raised by some hon. Members. There is no expectation that consultants will be employed, and the Minister is working closely with strategic authorities on the delivery of the levy. As part of the “Rewiring the State” delivery plan, we are looking at capacity in strategic authorities, and ensuring that they have the people and resource that they need to take on additional devolution. We recognise that visitor economies differ from place to place, so strategic authorities will have flexibility to exempt particular types of accommodation, such as camping pitches or dormitory-style accommodation, where that is right for their area. For example, strategic authorities may exempt lower-cost accommodation that is commonly used for educational trips and groups such as scouts and squirrels—that point was raised by my hon. Friend the Member for Stoke-on-Trent Central (Gareth Snell).
Calm yourselves down. Will the Minister be clear that although that might be the decision of a mayor, the Government do not want Scout camps to be taxed by mayors under this regime? We may not have the power to stop them doing that, but it is not what we want to see.
Sally Jameson
I thank my hon. Friend. I have now taken an intervention from both sides of the Chamber, and will continue with my remarks. It is right that strategic authorities and mayors get to decide what is right for their areas. We specifically included in the Bill the fact that mayors have power to exclude educational trips and groups such as scouts and squirrels, and they will use that as an indication of what is right for their area.
Motorhomes will fall under the same arrangements as campsites, and there is the option for strategic authorities to exempt caravan pitches. My hon. Friend the Member for Chester North and Neston (Samantha Dixon) mentioned package holidays, and it would be just and reasonable to attribute this measure only to the cost of the accommodation element of the stay. Where visitors purchase accommodation as part of a package, the Bill gives providers significant flexibility to apply the cost only to the accommodation. This also applies to festivals, which were mentioned by the hon. Member for Gosport (Dame Caroline Dinenage). As the levy should be based on accommodation costs only, festival operators who are offering accommodation as only part of the ticket price will not need to apply that levy to the full price of the ticket.
While the power to introduce a visitor levy is devolved to strategic authorities, the Bill provides a clear and consistent framework for its administration. The Bill sets out the core requirements on accommodation providers. These include notifying the relevant strategic authorities when they become liable, making returns and payments, and keeping records. We want those requirements to be proportionate and straightforward. We will continue to work closely with strategic authorities and industry on the plans for implementation to minimise administrative burdens, while ensuring that the levy can be administered effectively.
London was mentioned by my hon. Friends the Members for Kensington and Bayswater (Joe Powell), for Cities of London and Westminster (Rachel Blake) and for Brent East (Dawn Butler). The Greater London Authority has its own set of governance arrangements that are different from those for mayoral strategic authorities. The Bill gives London Assembly members a formal scrutiny role and a vote on the Mayor’s proposals at approval stage. While the final decision on whether to proceed with the levy rests with the Mayor, boroughs will be encouraged to work closely with the Mayor of London to advocate for where revenue will be spent. I am sure that the Mayor of London will hear representations from hon. Members, as well as from leaders of the borough councils, and he will work closely with them to ensure their voices are heard and representations are made.
On short-term lets, the Bill provides that each levying authority must publish a notice setting out the information that levy-liable accommodation providers are required to include with their quarterly returns. This is deliberately a local decision, rather than something prescribed nationally, and we are working closely with strategic authorities on the delivery of the visitor levy, and on how the framework can support other functions and priorities. We will keep under review whether and how information collected through the levy returns can support the enforcement of the 90-day short-term let limit.
Local leaders will be empowered to invest levy revenues and improve the visitor experience in their region, including through projects related to economic development, transport and infrastructure. It is for them to decide how that is spent and not Ministers.
In relation to concerns raised by the hon. Member for Harrogate and Knaresborough (Tom Gordon), accommodation providers will not face imprisonment for honest mistakes or minor breaches. Ordinary errors and failures are dealt with through the civil compliance regime and, where necessary, penalties; there are review and appeal rights. Criminal sanctions are reserved for the most serious cases of deliberate fraudulent evasion, reflecting established approaches in tax legislation, but sentencing is ultimately for the courts.
The enthusiasm with which Members of the House have spoken today, whatever their view, is testament to the dedication and commitment Members have to their constituents and areas. We have heard a range of views on the visitor levy, and I hope that the debate has provided some clarity and reassurance on some of the issues raised. As the Bill progresses through the House, I will continue to work collaboratively and constructively—
(2 weeks, 2 days ago)
General CommitteesForgive me, I think I did give an example in my opening remarks, but I do not want to stand here and speculate on the precise programmes that might be funded through those interest payments, if we make a decision to take a portion of them in future. I am being very clear that they would be directed to support private rented sector tenants; they could not be siphoned off for other Government activities. Any payments made to MHCLG would be subject to future agreement via contractual and procurement processes.
I thank the Minister for giving way and for his explanation. Can he at this stage give any indication of the thresholds at which this mechanism would kick in and allow the Department to make those directions? It is perfectly right that a windfall on interest can be put to good public use, but I am interested in where the Department currently considers the threshold for that windfall to start, so that we can know when those schemes might start making a contribution.
(2 months, 1 week ago)
Commons ChamberI welcome the hon. Gentleman to his place and thank him for his constructive comments. It is disappointing that I have had to come to the House to make this statement. I recognise the work that local authorities, Members of the House and others have put into getting us to this point, but when I took over the role recently and the Prime Minister asked me to look again at the reform, and upon receiving legal advice, I wanted to satisfy myself as the Secretary of State that the process was robust and legally sound. That is why I have made this decision today, but I understand why hon. Members will be disappointed.
I was asked about legal costs. Those will be determined in the usual way. Local government reform is often contested in the courts. It is right and part of our democratic system that important issues can be challenged. The Government engage legal advisers to defend decisions whenever challenges are brought; that does bring costs.
The hon. Gentleman asked me about savings. The Government have made savings in the past through local government reorganisation, but for me it has got to be about not savings but the outcomes for people in their local area. That is what has driven reorganisation from my point of view.
In terms of the new mayoral authorities and what will happen, I am really clear that it has to be done correctly and right. As Secretary of State, I have to believe, in good conscience, that I have dotted every i and crossed every t. That is why I have made the decision I have today.
This has been a long process for Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent, where we have ducked and dived as best we can with the announcements that have come over the last two years. The thing that we really care about is devolution, because where the line is drawn on councils is important, but the real powers unleashed by devolution would make a real difference to my constituents. Can the Secretary of State give some indication of the impact on the timetable for moving towards mayoral combined authorities for places like Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent, where currently the opportunity does not meet our aspiration?
My hon. Friend is right to raise the opportunities of devolution. The Prime Minister is really clear that the Government’s ambition is to ensure that every area in England has, or is in the process of establishing, a strategic authority by the end of 2027, with strategic authorities in place everywhere by the end of 2028. The process that I have put in place today is about making sure that we have a rapid review and make the right and correct decisions on reorganisation.
(2 months, 2 weeks ago)
Commons ChamberYes, that is right. Things are changing continually. The Bill goes against the age of adulthood, with lawmakers raising the minimum age for many different things. As a country we collectively agree that the age of 18 is adulthood, and with that come rights and responsibilities, and things we can and cannot do. Once we reach the age of 18, an individual can stand for election to this House, make decisions about their own medical treatment, enter into binding financial agreements, and buy cigarettes and vapes. They can even get a tattoo. Perhaps the greatest right of all is the right to vote and the responsibilities that come with that, yet under the Bill 1.7 million 16 to 17-year-olds will be granted the right to vote.
We could all see that the proposal was about fixing the right to vote. It was about ballot fixing. It was in the hope that the Labour party could win the next general election if it got this generation of young people to vote for it. Now that it has seen the latest polling and that young voters are turning Green, the Government might do what they do on a regular basis: screeching U-turns. That might be done not through common sense but self-interest. They might do another screeching U-turn here.
I thank the right hon. Lady for giving way. The shadow Secretary of State made a defence of the right for overseas electors to vote based simply on their citizenship. Why, when someone who does not live in this country can vote based on their citizenship, does the right hon. Lady argue that a 16-year-old with the same citizenship rights who lives here and contributes should not?
We are talking about two completely different things. We are talking about the age of adulthood, the age at which we think people have the ability to weigh up everything that is going on and come to a decision. The House is saying that those young people cannot go on social media, should not be on certain types of iPhone and should not be able to do other things, yet at the same time they are mature enough to vote—inconsistency. I am saying that we need to be consistent: a bit of common sense and consistency would go a long way in this House.
(4 months ago)
Commons ChamberI have also enjoyed working with the right hon. Gentleman, who is, unfortunately, a very effective shadow Secretary of State. I hope that our relationship can continue in this manner for a long time into the future. Unfortunately, the facts do not support the claims he is making. The majority of proposals I have outlined as decisions have cross-party support. I accept that reasonable people may agree or disagree with the decisions, but the important thing for residents is that we move ahead to realise the savings and to secure economic growth, because those things will benefit local people.
The right hon. Gentleman talks about debt. Of course, when the Conservative party was running Woking council, it racked up billions of pounds. The Government have had to intervene and write that off because of the severity of that debt. In fact, councils across the country will realise savings of up to £1 billion—that is the councils’ own estimate—that they can then invest in frontline services. That is to the benefit of local people.
The right hon. Gentleman will know that I cannot comment on judicial reviews, but I reassure him and the House that this programme will go ahead, on schedule.
I am broadly sympathetic and supportive of the proposals for Staffordshire, as the only MP in Staffordshire already in a single unitary authority, but may I ask the Secretary of State why he did not use the opportunity to make some of the very small consequential changes to the southern boundary of places such as Stoke-on-Trent, where development has spilled into the neighbouring boroughs but has absolutely no connection with the borough and the council it will now be? Did anyone from his Department physically visit those places to see where he is now creating borders? On council tax harmonisation, my constituents pay the lowest council tax in the county. Is it expected that everybody else will be harmonised to their level—a council tax reduction—or will my constituents see a council tax increase in order to give a council tax cut to some of the wealthiest in the county?
I have visited my hon. Friend’s constituency with him on several occasions and I recognise the work he does to champion his local communities, including through the process we are currently engaged in. Council tax will be a matter for the council to set for itself, within the parameters permitted, and it will take those decisions in due course. The particular split in the case of Staffordshire was proposed and selected to minimise service disruption by aligning with delivery, commuting, patient flows and partnership. The proposal we have adopted will be very strong on financial sustainability and resilience. That will benefit the stability of services, but it should also benefit council tax levels further down the line.
(4 months ago)
Commons ChamberUrgent Questions are proposed each morning by backbench MPs, and up to two may be selected each day by the Speaker. Chosen Urgent Questions are announced 30 minutes before Parliament sits each day.
Each Urgent Question requires a Government Minister to give a response on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
I thank the Minister for her answers. She will know that local government reorganisation is one side of the coin, and devolution is the other. In places like Staffordshire and Stoke-on-Trent, access to bus franchising, the adult skills agenda and spatial planning is the real victory that we look for. When the announcement comes this week on the new local authority boundaries, will she be able to give any insight on when decisions about strategic authorities will be made? When might there be the first elections for those, so that we can access the devolved powers that we desperately want?
(4 months, 2 weeks ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Ms Vaz. I congratulate the hon. Gentleman for Bromsgrove (Bradley Thomas) on securing this debate. When he was talking about the enforcement of gaudy signs and the impact they have on communities, I could not help thinking about the old bank in Fenton: it has gone from being a glorious listed building in a conservation zone to being smeared with bright signs advertising all sorts of products—yet trade in there is surprisingly slow for somewhere that opens so often, so I fully endorse what he said about enforcement.
In the brief time I have, I want to press the Minister on three points. One is access to cash. Stoke town is one of the four towns I have the pleasure of representing and it does not have a bank. It has been told that because there is a post office just under a mile away in three locations, the town has sufficient access to cash facilities. It does not. I hope the Minister will work with the Treasury to change the criteria so that it looks at the impact on towns rather than using as-the-crow-flies distances, because that simply does not work.
The second point is travel links. Buses are incredibly important for ensuring that people can get to town centres and use their high streets, and so are trains. I am disappointed that Stoke city council abandoned the plan for the accessibility works at Longton train station; as my hon. Friend the Member for Stoke-on-Trent South (Dr Gardner) knows, that would have made access into that town much easier and allowed us to bring people to the south of the city using public transport.
Finally, I would like to push the Minister on public toilets, which we have not touched on. One of the challenges with town centres and high streets is the closure over many years—predominantly under the Conservative Government, I hasten to add—of public loos. That means there is a “loo leash” for many people who cannot find public conveniences, so they feel that they cannot go out shopping. Will the Minister look at putting a duty on local authorities to provide public loos? That would be a small, but important, step towards making our high streets accessible again.
I agree entirely with my right hon. Friend. That is something that this Labour Government have never got to grips with.
Businesses already operating on tight margins face £40 billion of tax rises, including substantial increases in national insurance contributions, which will place further strain on them. I am delighted that colleagues on the Opposition Benches mentioned the Leader of the Opposition’s pledge to abolish business rates for most high street businesses.
Alongside the economic challenges facing our high streets, we must also confront an uncomfortable truth, which many Members have mentioned: our constituents are increasingly concerned that some high street premises are being used not as genuine businesses but as vehicles for tax evasion, money laundering and organised crime. Those concerns are frequently raised in relation to certain cash-intensive businesses, including some barber shops, nail salons, mini-marts and vape shops. The overwhelming majority of those businesses are of course honest, hard-working enterprises that serve their communities and deserve our support, but the ones that are not undermine legitimate traders, distort competition and damage public confidence in our town centres.
The other point that I want to raise—this is the small part of the hon. Member’s speech that I agree with—is that those places also tend to have people who are in indentured work or modern slavery, so there is a human impact as well as an economic one.
The hon. Member is absolutely right. As I will come to, we welcome the Government’s early actions to tackle those businesses, but we think they could do more, and we offer our support in that.
The Government introduced the economic crime levy, which we support, ensuring that those operating within the regulated financial sector contribute towards tackling money laundering and wider economic crime. It reflected the principle that protecting the integrity of our economy is a shared responsibility. However, there is clearly more to do. Without properly resourced investigations, effective intelligence sharing and robust action by enforcement agencies, there is a risk that the powers will exist only on paper. Trading standards, local authorities, HM Revenue and Customs, the police, immigration enforcement and the National Crime Agency all have a crucial role to play, but they need the resources and capacity to act. Evidence from trading standards professionals is particularly striking: 96% had encountered serious organised crime groups in their work.
My time is fast approaching. I hope there is cross-party agreement on how we can tackle such businesses on our high streets, but there is more work to do. The Conservative party has put forward a platform to enable our high streets to thrive. This Government’s economic policies have damaged them. Maybe that will change when we have our new Prime Minister, but I sincerely doubt it.
Nesil Caliskan
I do not disagree with the right hon. Member. We have seen the impact of online retail, and I think it would be misleading to say that we are about to see its disappearance. Instead, we have an obligation to think about what our high streets might look like in the future. Local communities want to be able to shape their high streets. The partnership between a local authority, businesses and residents can shape future high streets, not least through the commitment to densification—an important point made by a number of Members today.
As part of that densification process, I encourage the Minister to look at living accommodation in town centres and on our high streets. There are examples in Hanley, in Stoke-on-Trent, where new apartment blocks have driven footfall into the town centre while providing accommodation that meets the demands of local people. That model has worked incredibly well, and I hope the Government will consider it as part of the high street strategy.
Nesil Caliskan
Footfall is a key part of keeping our high streets alive. That comes partly through home building, but it also comes from ensuring variety on our high streets. A key part of the Government’s high streets innovation partnership will involve working with selected places to set out new approaches, boost activity and support a shift towards a mixed use of high streets. Alongside that, the Government are investing almost £6 billion into Pride in Place programmes over the next decade to give communities the power and funding to transform their local areas.
(6 months, 3 weeks ago)
Commons Chamber
Miatta Fahnbulleh
The hon. Member is completely right. There is a gap, and we are putting in this provision for a neighbourhood governance structure across the country to address that gap. Many areas that do not have town and parish councils will have other mechanisms in place. I point to my borough of Southwark, where we have area committees that work really well and represent the community. The key principle here, however, is that it must be for the community to determine the right structure that represents their area and can be an effective voice. We cannot and must not dictate from central Government.
As someone who was a parish councillor in a previous life and now represents a seat that has no parish level of governance whatsoever, I wonder whether the Minister sees a role for arbitration over where there is conflict between what that local mechanism might look like—for instance, where a residents association encroaches on another set of streets that might be considered another part of a residents association. Where do the Government see their role in facilitating resolution so that those powerful local bodies can exist in a way that is representative, fair and equal?
Miatta Fahnbulleh
My hon. Friend makes a good point. We as a Government are committed to putting in place a neighbourhood governance framework, and that framework will set in place the key principles. It will be a guide for what effective, strong neighbourhood governance looks like. We will put in place regulation and guidance to support local authorities as they go through the endeavour of working with their communities to put the right structure in place. We have done a huge amount of work with the sector, and have taken evidence, which has informed the principles, but one of the big messages we got from everyone across the sector is: “Whatever you do, do not dictate what this looks like; build on what exists, and ultimately leave it to communities and local areas to come up with the right model for them.” When the sector speaks, we listen.
Miatta Fahnbulleh
My hon. Friend is completely right: we need to build more homes. We are absolutely committed to doing that, but they have to be the right homes for communities. That is why this Government are investing £39 billion to ensure that we have the biggest boost to social and affordable housing in a generation. We must build homes that our communities can afford, and that are appropriate for our communities.
In Stoke-on-Trent, we are outside a mayoral combined authority, but have oodles of old industrial brownfield. We are itching to get our hands on it, but we do not have those compulsory purchase powers that sit with Homes England. Once the strategic combined authorities are up and running, how soon will we be able to use those powers to purchase that land, so that we can build the houses that the Minister talks about?
Miatta Fahnbulleh
We are as impatient as my hon. Friend is to get building on brownfield land, so we are working closely with all our authorities and strategic authorities to ensure that they have the power and tools to do that. We recognise that a big barrier to building on brownfield land is funding. This Government committed a record amount—£5 billion over the spending review—to supporting the remediation of brownfield sites, so that we can unlock the development that we all want.
The Opposition, who are pushing this amendment, accuse us of centralising, yet the amendment would, by its very nature, remove flexibility, whereas the Bill allows our local leaders, be it at regional or local authority level, the flexibility to deploy policy in a way that makes sense for their area. The amendment is fundamentally centralising, and we would be much better off trying to achieve “brownfield first”, an objective that we all agree on, through a policy that gives local leaders the flexibility to apply policy in a way that makes sense for their area.
Miatta Fahnbulleh
I could not agree more with my hon. Friend. That is exactly what happened under the approach adopted by the Conservative party in government. It created random boundaries and involved ad hoc devolution that did not treat our local leaders as equal partners who know their communities and can drive change. That is not our approach.
I ask Members to consider the approach that we are taking by setting up strategic authorities. We have gone to places and asked, “What is the local partnership that works for your place? Which geography means that you can drive the outcomes that your community wants?” We are not dictating from Whitehall; we are leaving this to local areas. That matters, because devolution works well when we have strong institutions, predicated on partnership between local authorities that understand their place and are willing to act collectively for it. We will not use the approach of imposing on places; rather, we will ensure that there is local consent. That is why the amendment works.
I will be brief. I completely understand the principle that the Minister is outlining of not wanting to force areas to have something that they do not want. She talks about consent, but what does that actually look like? In some areas, the board will have one or two intransigent members who will not allow progress—they could hold up a majority view that is in favour of a combined authority. What is the Government’s role, if they are removing their ability to tell parts of the community that they do not have the right to hold up something that a majority of local component units want?
Miatta Fahnbulleh
The role that we will play is to work with our local authorities. Ultimately, the common thread is that we are working in service of and on behalf of communities, and it is for both national Government and local leaders to make decisions on the geography that makes sense for local economies and that works for their community. We will always advocate for the community in those conversations to ensure that we get the right partnership that can deliver for places.
(8 months, 1 week ago)
Commons ChamberI am sorry that the hon. Member has chosen to misrepresent the definition. It is intended to protect Muslims from abuse that we know is shrinking people’s lives and life opportunities. One would hope that everyone in this House would get behind actions intended to give Muslim people the same chances as anyone else in our country.
I welcome the community cohesion strategy, which the Labour group of Hope not Hate, which I chair, has been calling for. The Secretary of State will know that the other side of the coin when building community cohesion is the counter-extremism work to stop people being radicalised in the first place, whether that is people on the far right with anti-Muslim hatred, or people on the far left with anti-Jewish hatred. What action will be taken to address those who perpetrate such myths about people, whether they be Muslim, Sikh, Hindu or Jew, and what resources might come from the Department to achieve that?
The Government are intending to bring into force and fully utilise the powers available in the Online Safety Act 2023. By doing that, we think we can tackle some of the worst online sources of disinformation and hatred that are being spread around to sow division in our communities.
(10 months ago)
Commons ChamberAs I have said in this Chamber a number of times, we can provide substantial increases to councils, as we need to, and it is very important that we do in places like Manchester, but unless we have a more preventive approach—for example, unless we stop children being taken into care, or stop councils facing really big challenges—councils will still face spiking costs. I look forward to working with my hon. Friend and colleagues across Greater Manchester on making that work.
The Government are taking concerted action to boost rates of house building across England, including reforming the planning system and allocating record levels of grant funding support for social and affordable house building over the coming years, to the benefit of Stoke-on-Trent and the rest of the country.
I thank the Minister for that answer. Stoke-on-Trent has benefited from money from the brownfield regeneration fund. However, there are many brownfield sites across the city that could be used for local planning development, but the owners are simply not engaging with the process. Given that we are not in a mayoral combined authority, compulsory purchase powers are limited. Will the Minister consider devolving those powers to authorities like Stoke? If not, will he consider allowing interim development corporations, until such time as we have a mayor in place?
My hon. Friend is a doughty champion for his constituency, and he continues to make a powerful case for the renewal of Hanley city centre as the commercial heart of north Staffordshire. I have had a series of constructive meetings with him and other local leaders about the Hanley masterplan. I know he will welcome the £8 million of investment in Burslem town centre, delivering 800 homes. I am more than happy to continue the conversation with him about the possibility of a new locally led development corporation to take forward the regeneration of the city centre.