Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
Visitor Levy (England) Bill Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateSimon Hoare
Main Page: Simon Hoare (Conservative - North Dorset)Department Debates - View all Simon Hoare's debates with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
(2 days, 2 hours ago)
Commons ChamberMy hon. Friend is absolutely right. This is not something new; it happens around the world. I congratulate those who have come forward with schemes earlier, because this levy will have a profound effect on local areas, enabling them to do the things they want to do.
When making international comparisons, will the Secretary of State also take levels of VAT into account? Some of the countries she has mentioned have a much lower sales tax than we do, and adding a holiday tax to that is going to put holidaymaking in the UK out of the reach of many UK families.
I dispute that—I do not think the levy will make holidaymaking out of reach for many people locally. It is for mayors to decide the percentage rate, and because it is a percentage rate, people will pay a lower amount for lower-cost holidays. As my hon. Friend the Member for Edinburgh South West (Dr Arthur) mentioned, parts of the UK have introduced these levies, including through voluntary schemes. They have been able to invest in their local services, in contrast to the scaremongering about how the levy is going to impact industries locally.
The main provision of the Bill is a new power for every strategic authority to introduce, administer and collect the levy. It is on those strategic authorities to decide whether to use that power; if they choose to do so, the levy can be delivered in line with the nationally consistent levy framework created by the Bill. That framework means that the levy can be charged as a percentage of accommodation costs at a local rate determined by the strategic authority. Using a percentage, rather than a fixed amount, means that low-cost stays will stay low-cost while giving certainty to business, and allowing local leaders to choose their own rate means that they can do what is best for their area. A percentage rate model also accounts for inflation and adjusts according to price changes, such as seasonal peaks.
To protect the smallest providers from disproportionate burdens, the Government will also introduce a minimum threshold. Any provider below that threshold will not be liable for the levy, and strategic authorities will have the power to set a higher threshold, as long as they consult. We are also confirming the scope of the levy, and as part of that we are providing for national exclusions and limited local accommodation-type exemptions. The levy will apply to most visitor accommodation, such as hotels and short-term lets, as well as to hostels, campsites and caravan parks where local leaders do not choose to exempt them. The national framework includes national exclusions, including for shelter and refuge and for temporary accommodation.
We know that devolution cannot just be the transfer of power from one set of leaders to another; communities must get a say directly. The Bill therefore also contains provisions requiring local consultation before a levy can be introduced, including on the percentage chosen and how it will be spent.
Does the shadow Secretary of State agree that when others are praying in aid, “Well, other countries have a holiday tax, so why don’t we?”, they are at a stroke removing a unique selling point for UK tourism? We should be using the idea that we are cheaper as a magnet for people to visit these shores, instead of saying, “Other countries have hiked up their tax rates, so why don’t we follow suit?”
Rebecca Paul
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. If we want to be competitive, we should not be looking to enter into a competition of who can have the highest tax rate. This Labour Government have increased employer national insurance, made it harder and more expensive to hire people, and now they want to increase the cost of their customers even walking through the door.
Nowhere will the pain be felt more acutely than in our coastal communities. I want Members to think about what happens to a seaside town once the summer crowds have gone. The beaches are quieter, the school holidays are over, and the holiday parks are offering discounted breaks to encourage visitors to come back in October or November. Those visitors might not spend as much as families staying in August, but they are vital. They keep the local cafés open, they provide customers for the pubs and restaurants, and they support attractions, independent shops and businesses that depend on tourism to survive. In essence, they help to turn what might have been a five-month season into something approaching a year-round economy. The Government appear not to have considered how fragile those local economies are. Whatever the Government say, customers visiting these areas off season are highly price-sensitive. They will just not go if the price goes up, and that means job losses and businesses going under.
Zöe Franklin
I completely agree that we need to look at the cumulative impact that this levy will add to, at a time when the hospitality industry is experiencing incredible challenges.
As I have said, we as a party have consistently argued that pubs, hotels and tourism businesses should be supported, not treated as an endless source of new taxation. That is why, when the Bill was announced, we approached it with caution.
May I gently suggest to the hon. Lady that her words of support for hospitality, holiday venues and so on would have more force if her party’s Members were not on a one-line Whip tonight? If they are so against this Bill in principle and so concerned about the damage it will do to those sectors, why are they on a one-line Whip?
Zöe Franklin
The hon. Member will understand later why my hon. Friends and I have taken a different approach this evening.
We as a party believe strongly in devolution. We believe that local communities should have greater control over their future, including greater freedom over how they raise and spend money. A well-designed visitor levy would help communities invest in the infrastructure and services that make places attractive to residents and visitors alike. However, whether that succeeds depends entirely on one question: will it work for the people who are expected to pay for and administer it? Hospitality businesses are already facing rising employment costs, the Government’s national insurance rise and a tax burden that is higher than for many of our international competitors. The Liberal Democrats have heard repeatedly from hoteliers and accommodation providers that margins are already tight and costs are mounting.
Before asking those businesses to collect a levy, Ministers must explain what assessment they have made of the impact—the cumulative impact—or are Ministers simply hoping that hospitality businesses will quietly shoulder yet another burden while council finances continue to deteriorate? That is why it is deeply concerning that, as yet, no national impact assessment appears to have been published alongside this legislation. I know that the Secretary of State referred to this point in her opening remarks, but I must disagree with the idea that the need to do impact assessments should land in the laps of our local authorities and mayoral strategic authorities. It should, in part, be down to the Government to publish one alongside this Bill as it progresses through Parliament. Members should not be asked to grant these powers without understanding what it will mean for the businesses that are expected to make it work.
My concern is about not only who pays, but who decides. The Bill is presented as a devolution measure, yet it allows mayors to override constituent councils and proceed with a levy even when those councils object. If Ministers truly trust local communities—and if they truly trust local government—they should trust the elected councils that represent them. Genuine devolution means more power flowing downwards, not simply being transferred from Whitehall to another distant layer of government.
If local people are being asked to support a visitor levy, they should be able to see where that money goes. Communities should see cleaner streets, safer public spaces, better transport links and improvements to the visitor experience as a direct result of any levy. Yet the Bill does not guarantee that the revenue will be spent in the communities where it is raised, nor does it guarantee that the Treasury will not quietly reduce central Government funding in response. Every £1 raised through this levy must be an additional £1 for local communities. Businesses and visitors should not be asked to pay more simply so that central Government can contribute less. A key question for the Secretary of State is: can she guarantee that this will not be the case, and that local government settlements will not be reduced where an authority chooses to introduce a visitor levy?
We should also remember that not every overnight stay is a holiday. Some people travel because a loved one is seriously ill, some travel to receive treatment and some are carers accompanying a disabled relative. This Bill leaves important questions about those groups unanswered. As drafted, there is no clear protection for many of the people who stay away from home not out of choice or leisure, but because difficult circumstances leave them with no alternative.
Finally, there is the question of proportionality. The Government describe this as a modest local levy, yet the Bill introduces extensive enforcement powers and may create offences carrying a maximum sentence of 14 years. Of course, deliberate fraud should be punished, but when introducing a new tax that is expected to be administered by thousands of hotels, guest houses and small accommodation providers, Ministers must demonstrate that the enforcement regime is proportionate and justified.
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Kensington and Bayswater (Joe Powell).
I am tempted to ask: when is a tax not a tax? The answer is: when Ministers of the Crown cannot bear to use the word “tax”, so they call it a levy. A levy somehow sounds rather nice and gentle, doesn’t it? But it’s a tax, it’s a tax, it’s a tax.
It is easy to dismiss this Bill, which I oppose, as the family holiday tax, because that is usually how we define visitors. As others have mentioned, however, this will also be another tax on working people, such as the tradesmen and women who work out of area; the additional costs of their accommodation are going to be passed on to their customers, and they are therefore likely to find fewer jobs. This will be a tax on those with health concerns or caring responsibilities who travel out of area and have to go up the night before for an appointment or stay overnight after having treatment in order to recuperate.
Alison Griffiths
I thank my hon. Friend for making the point about parents staying overnight when their children are in hospital. I just want to remind the Minister that some of those illnesses are serious—we are talking about not just one or two nights, but potentially months. I have direct experience of this from my own meningitis; I am quite sure that many other families will have experienced something similar. These things can take months.
My hon. Friend is right. She makes the point, as others have and as I hope to be able to do, that the Bill raises so many legitimate expectations for exemptions—common-sense, caring, kind, practical exemptions—that by the time they were all encapsulated in the Bill as it progresses through this place, one would have to ask, “What is the point of the Bill?” If fairness and rationality are to be at the heart of all of this, there will—or should be—legions of exemptions.
I am still not convinced as to what particular problem the Government are trying to solve with this Bill. Is it that Britain is too attractive a place for overseas visitors to come, and we think we should knock them back a little bit? Is it that we want to discourage staycations, short breaks and so on? I am not entirely sure—and neither, I would suggest, are those on the Treasury Bench.
North Dorset has many businesses. We do not have a coast—we are entirely rural—although the county of Dorset obviously does. [Interruption.] The Secretary of State is off to choose the hotel she is going to share with my right hon. Friend the Member for Skipton and Ripon (Sir Julian Smith). I am sure there will be some good pre-Christmas deals that she can have a look at with him—
Indeed—my right hon. Friend makes the obvious point, and I am grateful to her for doing so.
North Dorset has a lot of businesses that benefit either directly or indirectly through tourism, which are very often in sectors that are under pressure from the main purpose of their trade. I think of the pubs with rooms in my constituency: the Anvil Inn at Pimperne, the Fox Inn at Ansty, the Crown at Marnhull, the Langton Arms at Tarrant Monkton, the Talbot at Iwerne Minster, and the Swan Inn in Sturminster Newton—all businesses trying to do well and trying to keep their head above water against both myriad switches and changes in customer demand and a burdensome tax and regulatory system. Those pubs often see letting those rooms as a way of helping to break even.
I think also of the farmers in my constituency who have diversified into the tourism sector merely to try to keep their heads above water. It will not, I hope, be lost on the Minister how many of these rural campsites have the word “farm” in the title. As I say, many of these farms have diversified into summer tourism to provide vital income. According to the Tourism Alliance, the visitor economy—a cash cow the Government obviously think can be milked further—is worth £147 billion per annum in the UK, sustains 2.4 million jobs and generates £52 billion in tax revenue.
If the Government are to plough blindly on down the route of introducing this tax, there are, it seems to me, some obvious amendments that I hope my right hon. and hon. Friends will seek to push. There should be a cap on the levy enshrined in legislation, not left to the discretion of a mayor. A clearer and tighter way must surely be found to enforce ringfencing or hypothecation of the tax in order to ensure that the local tourism economy benefits from it.
There should be an exemption from VAT on the levy itself. The Government’s consultation said that there would be, but the Bill is silent, and silent is not good enough. That is particularly true given the point I made in an intervention of the differential in sales taxes between us and the countries the Government have sought to pray in aid. We have Europe’s highest rate of hospitality tax at 20%. Ireland’s is 9%. In France, Italy and Spain, it is 10%, while in Greece it is 13%. If we are going to compare fruits, let us at least compare apples with apples and oranges with oranges. UK tourism and hospitality is already fighting in a dramatically competitive international sector with one hand tied behind its back, and now the Government, through this new tax, would seek to impede their business growth still further.
There are, of course, other exemptions that I hope will be considered, such as establishments where accommodation is ancillary to the main business—I mentioned those rural pubs that have rooms—or having a set number of rooms below which an establishment is exempt from the levy. We should also exempt rooms available and provided by religious institutions providing retreat, accommodation in youth hostels and the YMCA and YWCA.
I want to mention campsites in particular. I have a number of campsites in my constituency, such as Woodfrys Farm in Melbury Abbas and Redlands Breaks in Hazelbury Bryan. We have them in Blandford; we have Home Farm Camping in Tarrant Gunville and others. All of them are trying to attract people to the area to spend their hard-earned money, not just on the campsite but elsewhere, to support the economy.
Every pound in tax that the Government take through this levy will result in either one of two things, or possibly both of them. First, it will reduce the amount of holiday time that hard-working families can actually afford to take. At a time when we are surely supposed to be encouraging family time and everything that goes with it, we should surely be trying to find ways to arrive at the complete opposite landing spot.
Secondly, even if that does not happen, the people who are visiting—people who, as the hon. Member for South Shields (Emma Lewell) said, have looked forward to their summer break and saved for it all year—will just have less to spend in museums, in cafés, in restaurants, at the slot machines, at the ice cream parlour and in the tea rooms, wherever they may happen to be. There will be a diminution in the local tourism economy month on month. For many, it is that high spot in the summer school holiday months—late July through to the end of August—that is their bread and butter and the difference between them sinking or swimming. This levy will just put a further weight on them as they try to swim through the choppy waters of doing business under this Government.
I want to reference a conversation that I had with Jeremy Cooper, who runs Inside Park near Blandford Forum, a beautiful campsite in North Dorset. Most of its business is repeat business. He told me a staggering statistic: 95% of his bookings are from people who live within a radius of just 120 miles of Blandford Forum. This is home-grown tourism—people who want to stay and spend their hard-earned money near to where they live and yet have a holiday.
My hon. Friend is raising a very good point. Does he feel that, in the same way that people tried to avoid the landfill tax by fly-tipping, this tax on camping may mean that we see more fly-camping, where people camp at will in the countryside—in an uncontrolled environment without facilities and where they may leave litter or cause wildfires, and similarly damage the countryside?
I agree with my right hon. Friend—perhaps “Carry On Fly-Camping” could be the next film in the series. He is right; this is going to have significantly negative knock-on effects.
These are negative effects that the Government are authoring with no particular urging from anybody outside of the Government’s mind so to do. I do not particularly want to see competition between the mayoral authority of Devon and Cornwall and the mayoral authority of Wiltshire, Somerset and Dorset, if we are to be given one, where they are trying to differentiate between the two. UK plc should be promoting itself as a tourism destination; it should not a case of, “Come to this bit of England or that bit of England because this bit charges x and this bit charges y.”
I ask the Minister to address this point specifically in summing up. Those who operate campsites or places where people can bring their own motorhome or tourer are not providers of accommodation; they are merely providing a pitch. This is a point that Mr Cooper of Inside Park raised with me.
The hon. Lady is right, but the key word there is “can”! I wonder if the hon. Lady would honestly be able to find me a politician, particularly one who ascribes to her party, who when offered a smorgasbord of tax opportunities suddenly says, “Oh no, no, no—I am on a frightfully strict diet.” Of course not—they will fill their boots. They will tax until the pips squeak, and they will use it for every pet policy that they have. It does not have to be tourism related or local economy related; no, no—we give all the discretion to the mayor.
The point that the Opposition is making is that if the Government wish to run forward pell-mell with this, there must be clear parameters beyond which a mayor, were they to choose to use the powers, could not stray.
If the hon. Lady wishes to point me to a Labour politician who wants to not tax, I will of course give way to her again.
The thing is this: I have confidence in the Mayor of London, and I have confidence that the money will be ringfenced to be used locally, as is written in the legislation. I do not disagree with the right hon. Gentleman with regard to ensuring that there is a cap—mayors have already said that there will be a 5% cap—but we should be honest and talk about where there can and should be exemptions. That is what we will work towards.
It is not for me to give the hon. Lady political advice, but I would just say that “I agree with and support the current Mayor of London” is not her best prospectus to get her party’s nomination for that post—a task I wish her well in.
I am afraid that the hon. Lady is not correct. This is not ringfenced in the Bill; there is no hypothecation there. The Government effectively rest their argument on a benign use of the discretionary powers of the mayor and then a sensible disbursement of the fees—and, as the hon. Member for South Shields rightly said, without any consultation with anyone involved in the tourism sector, Members of Parliament, council leaders, chambers of commerce, residents associations or anybody else. No, no: the mayor, sitting behind this screen of smoke and mirrors, Wizard of Oz-like, pushing the buttons and pulling the levers, is suddenly going to exercise the omnipotent powers of the Wizard of Oz and arrive at this benign visitor levy, which is going to lead to growth.
But growth in what? Youth unemployment figures, one presumes. It is going to lead to growth in the rate of closure of rural hospitality businesses and of rural pubs. That is the only growth that a further tax is going to lead to. Any idea that this is some sort of pump priming or fertile seed bed for tender shoots of economic growth, fostered and encouraged by those on the Treasury Bench, is frankly for the birds. This is a tax that will destroy jobs and family holidays and put pressure on hard-working people, just at a time when they deserve to have a break. If this is the Government’s definition of “Let us give the people of this country hope”, I dread to think what their prospectus of despair would look like.
Let me conclude, Madam Deputy Speaker, before I do myself or the House a mischief. The Bill, as many Members have said already, raises far more questions than it does answers, it generates far more problems than it seeks to solve, and it seeks to answer a question that has not been asked. It seems to rely on an entirely imbalanced argument that some European countries have a visitor tax while entirely neglecting the fact that there is a sharp differential in sales taxes between us and most of Europe. It is a tax that will hit hard UK tourism. It will hit hard entrepreneurs and businesses. It will hit harder still working families. Farms, pubs, SMEs and campsites are already struggling with over-regulation and tax obligations. A holiday tax will be a further burden that is neither wanted nor needed. For the sake of UK tourism, I urge with all my heart that the Government think again.
Peter Lamb
My sincere apologies, Madam Deputy Speaker. I will apologise separately in due course. Regrettably, I forgot the formalities of the Chamber.
The hon. Gentleman may be interested to know that he will enjoy the support of Reform Members. At a recent Local Government Association meeting, Reform councillors voted in favour of the visitor levy, so I have no doubt that he will be making common argument with them.
Peter Lamb
That is an interesting point. With that foreknowledge, I look forward to hearing the remarks of Reform Members.
A levy would not be an imaginary figure; in my area, it would reduce the council tax pressure on my constituents. It would enable the people who use an area’s infrastructure to make a proportional contribution to the community’s infrastructure needs. Overwhelmingly, these are more deprived areas, so the knock-on effect for communities will be positive. That is why I called for a visitor levy for over a decade as a local authority leader.
I understand why people worry about the impact of a levy, as the hospitality sector has suffered, but the Government have done much to support it. Significant business rates reform in the form of higher thresholds, better tapering and a permanent reduction overall have supported the sector. For those with licences, there are changes in beer duty for licensed premises and retail premises. That, again, supports the sector. Regulatory changes that support the sector are continuing to go through: just last week, I was on a Delegated Legislation Committee increasing the number of temporary event notices. The Government are working to support the hospitality sector.
We completely agree that there should be support for families who are struggling and need to spend time with their loved ones. That is the very reason why, in the summer, the Government introduced the summer of savings programme, designed to support people throughout that period. Constituents of hon. Members across the Chamber will have enjoyed that.
As has been discussed, tourist taxes already exist—most people who have visited Europe will know that—so we do not have to guess what the impact will be, and studies have shown repeatedly that in those countries that have implemented those taxes, there has been no impact. We will have paid them, and in most cases, we probably did not notice them. Let us bear in mind that almost two thirds of UK tourists go out of country, so UK tourists are already being charged tourist taxes during their time aboard. Opposition Members are apparently saying that people coming to the UK should not pay to maintain our local infrastructure, in the way that we pay to maintain infrastructure abroad.
The point has been made about VAT. It is true that many countries have a lower VAT rate for hotels, but as a whole, the UK has one of the lowest VAT rates in the continent, so over all, it may well be that costs end up roughly equivalent. There is no evidence of risk. Why are my council tax payers being asked to pay the full cost of the impact of tourists travelling through my community, and staying in it?
We have been warned about various tax increases in the past. Conservative Members told us that the English school system would entirely collapse if we charged the full rate of VAT on private school fees and, of course, that did not happen; that was utterly predictable. This is a storm in a tea cup. This is Second Reading, which is for talking about the concept of whether we could have a visitor levy—a tourist tax—in some areas. We can discuss every provision imaginable in the Public Bill Committee and on Third Reading. My hon. Friend the Member for Blackpool South (Chris Webb) made important remarks about what should be taken into account, and the Liberal Democrats have indicated that they are prepared to work towards additional provisions to improve the Bill—that is welcome—but this debate is about the concept, rather than the final version.
Let us say that there is an impact from the levy. People can say that this is a postcode lottery, but this is democracy, and we have created mayors. People might not like mayors and may have opposed them, but they exist and are voted for by local communities—and if they make bad decisions, they can be voted out by those communities.
Elected members occasionally make mistakes. That is to be accepted; it is part of the democratic process. We do not deny that people in this Chamber have a democratic right to represent people and take actions on the basis of the impact locally. District councils are overwhelmingly the best-supported tier of Government in terms of decision making—the survey evidence backs that up—but where do we draw the line? Should we say that neighbourhood associations should sign off all this? The line needs to be somewhere, and the strategic authority level makes the most sense for dealing with strategic issues, because tourism does not end at the boundary of one constituency; the impact spreads across the sub-region.
In the event that the levy did have an impact, it would create a market, and that market would enable areas to tout their wares by choosing the rate of tourist tax that they charge. That could relocate demand from overheated areas to underheated areas. It is rare to hear Conservative Members criticise a market, but the fact that they are doing so seems to have gone completely gone over their heads in this debate. Even in the worst-case scenario, there are potential benefits to the proposal.
To conclude, this levy will allow local areas to reduce the burden on their existing council tax-paying population and better meet the needs of both residents and tourists. We know from all the available evidence that it is unlikely to have any negative impact on tourism, but even if it did have an impact on tourism, there would be potential benefits in how it distributes tourism within the United Kingdom. I can see no reasonable grounds for rejecting the proposal at this stage, but if aspects of it are giving people cause for concern, we can certainly deal with them at later stages in the Bill’s passage. This is a storm in a teacup.