Cryptocurrency Regulation

Lisa Cameron Excerpts

Tuesday 13th June 2023 Westminster Hall

[Dr Lisa Cameron (East Kilbride, Strathaven and Lesmahagow) (SNP)]

I beg to move,

That this House has considered the regulation of cryptocurrency.

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship for the first time, Mrs Harris, and to see you in your rightful place.

As chair of the crypto and digital assets all-party parliamentary group, I am delighted to be able to talk about the potential of the UK cryptocurrency and digital asset sector, and the need for clear regulation to protect consumers, which should be at the core of everything we do, and to support investment.

Just over a year ago, in April 2022, the UK Government set out their landmark vision to make the United Kingdom the global hub for cryptocurrency investment, committing to creating the right conditions for cryptocurrency and digital asset businesses to set up and scale up in the UK. Shortly afterwards, in August 2022, the APPG launched an inquiry to better understand the opportunities that a regulated industry could bring to the UK, as well as the challenges and potential barriers for Government in making their vision for the UK a reality.

Just last week, we published our report “Realising Government’s vision for the UK to become a global hub for cryptocurrency & fintech innovation”. Our inquiry looked at a number of key areas, including the potential for the UK to be a global hub for investment; the UK’s approach to regulation and the role of UK regulators in consumer protection; the potential offered by central bank digital currencies; and the risks of economic crime. We heard views from operators, regulators, industry experts and the general public—the Advertising Standards Authority, Innovate Finance, the City of London Corporation, the Payment Systems Regulator, the Royal United Services Institute, the Law Commission and many others—on the need for regulation of this ever-growing sector. I put on the record my thanks for their input and help in formulating our recommendations.

The APPG’s report is the first on cryptocurrency and the digital assets industry compiled jointly by MPs and Members of the House of Lords, and I thank colleagues in both Houses for their invaluable contributions. We set out more than 50 recommendations, which we hope will establish a foundation for further discussion. The Minister will be pleased to hear that I will not go through them all today, but I will focus on some of the report’s key findings.

It is clear from our work so far that the growth of cryptocurrency and digital assets presents a number of potential opportunities and that the UK is well placed to realise them, but that will require cross-Government strategic planning.

[Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)]

I commend the hon. Lady for securing the debate—we have become good friends in the House—and I thank her for all she does on this topic. Reports in 2019 indicated that Colu, a tech firm based in Israel, had developed a potential new cryptocurrency for Belfast City Council. There has been much discussion in this place of how cryptocurrency will be regulated across the UK. Does she agree that for the United Kingdom to become a leading force in crypto, regulation must be UK-wide, led centrally from Westminster, and that UK-wide discussion is the only way to achieve safe regulation?

[Dr Cameron]

I thank the hon. Member for his contribution. Yes, much of this will be led by the Treasury, and I imagine that regulation will be streamlined right across the United Kingdom. I am pleased to hear about developments in Northern Ireland; there have been many in Scotland, too. I spoke to Scotcoin not that long ago. This area has enthused and motivated people right across the United Kingdom, and it is important that we collaborate in order to realise its potential.

[Alun Cairns (Vale of Glamorgan) (Con)]

It is a privilege to serve under your chairmanship for the first time, Mrs Harris. I congratulate the hon. Lady on her work with the crypto and digital assets all-party parliamentary group and on its excellent report; it is a privilege to work with her. Some years ago, the UK became the world’s leading fintech centre because the regulatory environment was established with a clear direction from Government, which allowed businesses to invest and regulators to lean positively towards the sector’s development. Does she agree that if the positive record of the Government of that time is replicated with cryptocurrency, the UK will have a similar opportunity to be a leading nation in this sector, as well as in other financial technologies?

[Dr Cameron]

I thank the right hon. Member for his valuable contribution. I totally agree. I saw some research from PitchBook last month that suggested that since the EU produced its regulatory framework on markets in cryptoassets—MiCA—investment in the EU has increased substantially. With a regulatory pathway over the next 12 to 18 months at the maximum, the UK could harness a leadership position in this sector. That will be essential because of the digital revolution that is happening. The next generation is a digital generation already. This is the way that things are moving in the world, and the UK must be at the forefront. I am pleased that the Minister is harnessing his skills and endeavours to ensure that happens.

We heard that without comprehensive regulation there are considerable risks in the industry, particularly regarding consumer protection, economic crime and financial stability, which I will speak about later. While there are clearly legitimate concerns about the potential risk posed by cryptocurrency and digital assets, it is important to acknowledge a number of positive use cases that show the potential benefits of the new technology.

One such example is the use of cryptocurrency at the frontline of the conflict in Ukraine. Many may not know this, but following the Russian invasion, the Ukrainian Government appealed for cryptocurrency donations and received millions of dollars in cryptocurrency to support military and humanitarian efforts on the frontline. Ukraine’s Deputy Minister of Digital Transformation, Alex Bornyakov, has said that cryptocurrency has been “essential” to Ukraine’s response to the Russian invasion. I am delighted to welcome Minister Bornyakov and his team, who are in the Public Gallery. We are delighted to have them here today.

Our inquiry heard that the growth of the sector suggests that cryptocurrency is here to stay. The latest research by the Financial Conduct Authority shows that cryptocurrency ownership has almost doubled in the last year, with almost one in 10 people surveyed owning cryptocurrency in 2022. That highlights the need for proper, clear regulation to protect consumers and support the industry’s growth in a reasonable way. As countries around the world move quickly to develop regulatory frameworks, we feel that the UK must move within the next 12 to 18 months to harness the industry’s potential in order not to lose out to other jurisdictions.

Throughout our inquiry, we heard that there are potential barriers to the UK’s realising its vision, which we set out in the report. We heard that the process for cryptoasset businesses to enter the UK is very lengthy, with limited engagement at times, and that many businesses ultimately choose to invest outside the UK. While the Government have said that they are open for business and for companies in the sector to set up and scale up, we heard that that has not been the experience of many companies seeking to obtain licences to operate in the UK. They have seen very lengthy delays and, in many cases, had their applications rejected. That is fine, because we do not want a race to the bottom, but it often happens without a clear explanation and with limited communication throughout the process.

To date, only 41 firms have been approved to operate in the UK. Will the Minister say what more the Government can do to ensure that legitimate and responsible firms that want to set up and scale up here are able to do so? What steps are the Government taking to ensure that regulators have the resources they need to deliver on their responsibility to process applications?

[Martin Docherty-Hughes (West Dunbartonshire) (SNP)]

It is good to see you in the Chair, Mrs Harris, and I congratulate my hon. Friend on securing the debate. On regulation, my hon. Friend mentioned risks, and does she agree that the Government need first to admit that when it comes to crypto there is a lot of risk? We know there is a lot of risk—it is called fraud, so fraud regulation should be used in the first instance before they introduce other regulation. There needs to be a recognition that fraud is fraud, whether it is related to crypto or anything else.

[Dr Cameron]

I thank my hon. Friend for raising those important issues. There is a section in my report on fraud and scam risks to consumers, so he has pre-empted the latter part of my speech, but I will cover his points in full.

Another area of concern is access to basic financial services. To be a hub of cryptocurrency—of innovation, scale-ups and start-ups—companies need to be able to open a bank account and pay their employees. The inquiry heard that firms were struggling to secure access to UK banking services. A high proportion of banks have refused to provide bank accounts to digital assets firms, even when those firms are regulated and licensed to operate in the UK. In addition, just in recent months, a number of major banks have also announced limits on transactions, making it more difficult rather than less.

Such services are absolutely necessary for companies to operate regulatorily compliant businesses. The inquiry heard that that could be one of the single biggest barriers to growth and innovation for the UK. There are concerns that this could fundamentally undermine the Government’s ambition for the UK to become a global cryptocurrency hub and could be a barrier to growth and innovation in the digital sector.

I recently chaired a roundtable with the industry to hear more about their concerns. What more can the Government do to help find a way forward and to ensure clear pathways for firms to access fundamental banking facilities when they are operating legitimately and robustly within the guidelines? Will the Government consider using their powers to help facilitate meaningful dialogue between the banking and digital assets sectors to find a way forward that works for both?

We also heard strong support for the Government’s current approach of regulating cryptocurrency in line with financial services regulations; when we look at the research and the details, we can see that that offers the best and most robust protections for consumers. In that sense, my report supports the Government’s position on financial services regulation.

There is another issue. I worked in the health service and I am keen that people who make gains in the UK should pay their taxes. A regulatory framework in financial services enables the Exchequer to collect taxes, as opposed to using the gambling regulations, which would not allow for that. It is also important that the UK sets regulations within financial services to position itself in collaboration with other jurisdictions internationally and rather than appear an outlier by using other regulatory frameworks.

Our inquiry heard serious concerns about the risks to consumers from fraud and scams associated with the sector. As with all new and emerging technologies, the sector has the potential to be exploited by criminals. We heard that given the rapid pace of growth and consumer adoption, the risks in this area cannot be ignored, particularly if the UK wants to position itself as the global home of investment. Consumer protection measures must be at the core of everything that the Government do. We must mitigate the risks associated with new developments in the sector.

Research from the FCA in 2021 showed that overall public awareness and ownership of cryptocurrency had increased, but it also showed that

“the level of understanding of cryptocurrencies is declining, suggesting that some users may not fully understand what they are buying”.

Consumer research by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme highlighted the low levels of understanding and the need for much greater financial education. Industry and the Government must partner to help raise awareness. We want a joined-up and co-ordinated approach, including industry, regulators, law enforcement and the Government, to clamp down on scams.

Before I conclude, let me briefly mention that the Government are making great strides with the consultation on a central bank digital currency, and we support the progress being made. I have also heard about improvements throughout industry on the sustainability of bitcoin mining and so on. That is very important because we must realise that we are in a climate crisis, and all innovations and new technological developments should contribute to net zero.

For our report, we heard about the need for a joined-up, co-ordinated approach across all Departments, and we have said that Government might consider the appointment of a crypto tsar, who could help to co-ordinate across Departments and support the Minister to ensure a consistent approach. Will the Minister update the House on the Government’s vision for the UK to become a global hub? I realise that yesterday the Prime Minister made a very important speech that contributes to the debate and I would be delighted to hear what more we can do, as the all-party parliamentary group, to support the Minister in his endeavours. We feel that things have been extremely positive, but there is a need to move at pace within the next 12 to 18 months.