Health Bill

Gideon Amos Excerpts

2nd reading
Monday 1st June 2026 Commons Chamber

[Gideon Amos (Taunton and Wellington) (LD)]

This Bill contains welcome elements, such as creating a single patient record and enabling integrated care boards to become commissioners across a wider area. However, I cannot support the weakening of patient voices, nor removing local authorities from oversight of health trusts. I pay tribute to Gill Keniston-Goble and her team at Somerset Healthwatch for all the fantastic work they have done.

In moving to a single patient record, we need to prioritise privacy and rethink putting the American firm Palantir in charge of our data, with its founders such as Thiel opposing democracy and denigrating our NHS as part of a “Stockholm syndrome”. My constituent, whose family member was brutally murdered, is rightly horrified that victims’ NHS records were shared unlawfully online with NHS workers—she called it “repugnant voyeurism”, and she was right to do so. I hope the Minister will echo the apology of the trust and condemn that kind of behaviour.

However, none of the reforms in the Bill will have a positive impact on patients or staff in Taunton and Wellington who use the maternity and paediatric department until and unless the promised new unit is brought forward. One of my constituents, Jeff, told me of their grandson Ryan, who was admitted to the ward a couple of weeks ago. The lack of air conditioning meant that temperatures there exceeded 30°C over the past week—no wonder medical staff have fainted in the heat while looking after mothers and children who are baking in single-storey flat-roof buildings—buildings that were put up for the United States army as a temporary measure during the second world war and never replaced.

As Jeff put it,

“Walking down the corridor of the old building is an embarrassment. There are literally sheets of plastic attached to the leaking ceilings running into guttering in the corridor”.

I do not need my architectural training to know that guttering should be on the outside of the building, not the inside. It is therefore unsurprising that the previous Secretary of State, the right hon. Member for Ilford North (Wes Streeting), when challenged on BBC Radio Somerset only a month ago, promised that he would speed up the Musgrove Park hospital project if he could. I hope the new Secretary of State will honour his predecessor’s promise to meet me to discuss that.

The Bill is based, at least in part, on the mission to move from treatment to prevention, which is of course the right ambition. Because of its major teaching hospital status, Taunton has a big medical community who know a thing or two about prevention, and I will highlight two areas in which this Bill should be going further on prevention. On prostate cancer, I hope the Government do not decide to hold back from widespread screening, as a recommendation to do so is before them. As a member of a family in my constituency recently hit by that disease told me,

“I am a recently retired doctor and I do not believe the statistics that have been published, with the emphasis being placed on over-investigating patients and the distress this causes. This pales into insignificance compared to a missed diagnosis.”

Finally, more should be done to reform the dental contract. Unless the Bill leads to more NHS dentists, social care reform and better prevention—

[Madam Deputy Speaker (Judith Cummins)]

Order.