Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
Visitor Levy (England) Bill Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateAlison Griffiths
Main Page: Alison Griffiths (Conservative - Bognor Regis and Littlehampton)Department Debates - View all Alison Griffiths's debates with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
(2 days, 3 hours ago)
Commons Chamber
Alison Griffiths (Bognor Regis and Littlehampton) (Con)
I wish my hon. Friend a happy birthday.
I think we know quite a bit about youth employment in coastal towns in my constituency, and what I am hearing from all the businesses in those towns is that this is the straw that breaks the camel’s back. We have already seen layer upon layer upon layer of costs and taxes imposed on these businesses. Does my hon. Friend agree that this is just one more unnecessary tax?
Rebecca Paul
I agree entirely with my hon. Friend. It is also important to recognise the impact of the additional bureaucracy on businesses resulting from the creation of an entirely new tax. It is not cost-free. Many businesses that are currently under the VAT registration threshold will suddenly become tax collectors, with all the compliance requirements and risk that that brings. We need only look north of the border to see some of the consequences of this policy already playing out. I know that the hon. Member for Edinburgh West (Christine Jardine) will be very interested in this part of my speech—
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Kensington and Bayswater (Joe Powell).
I am tempted to ask: when is a tax not a tax? The answer is: when Ministers of the Crown cannot bear to use the word “tax”, so they call it a levy. A levy somehow sounds rather nice and gentle, doesn’t it? But it’s a tax, it’s a tax, it’s a tax.
It is easy to dismiss this Bill, which I oppose, as the family holiday tax, because that is usually how we define visitors. As others have mentioned, however, this will also be another tax on working people, such as the tradesmen and women who work out of area; the additional costs of their accommodation are going to be passed on to their customers, and they are therefore likely to find fewer jobs. This will be a tax on those with health concerns or caring responsibilities who travel out of area and have to go up the night before for an appointment or stay overnight after having treatment in order to recuperate.
Alison Griffiths
I thank my hon. Friend for making the point about parents staying overnight when their children are in hospital. I just want to remind the Minister that some of those illnesses are serious—we are talking about not just one or two nights, but potentially months. I have direct experience of this from my own meningitis; I am quite sure that many other families will have experienced something similar. These things can take months.
My hon. Friend is right. She makes the point, as others have and as I hope to be able to do, that the Bill raises so many legitimate expectations for exemptions—common-sense, caring, kind, practical exemptions—that by the time they were all encapsulated in the Bill as it progresses through this place, one would have to ask, “What is the point of the Bill?” If fairness and rationality are to be at the heart of all of this, there will—or should be—legions of exemptions.
I am still not convinced as to what particular problem the Government are trying to solve with this Bill. Is it that Britain is too attractive a place for overseas visitors to come, and we think we should knock them back a little bit? Is it that we want to discourage staycations, short breaks and so on? I am not entirely sure—and neither, I would suggest, are those on the Treasury Bench.
North Dorset has many businesses. We do not have a coast—we are entirely rural—although the county of Dorset obviously does. [Interruption.] The Secretary of State is off to choose the hotel she is going to share with my right hon. Friend the Member for Skipton and Ripon (Sir Julian Smith). I am sure there will be some good pre-Christmas deals that she can have a look at with him—
Alison Griffiths (Bognor Regis and Littlehampton) (Con)
The British seaside holiday is part of the fabric of Bognor Regis and Littlehampton. Wherever anyone goes in my constituency in the summer, they will find families enjoying the seaside holiday they have spent all year looking forward to. I could give credit to the West Sussex sunshine, but our local businesses would rightly have something to say about that.
An undeniable attraction of the British seaside holiday is that it is fantastic value for money. From the guest houses and hotels that welcome the same families back every year, to the fish and chip shops that stay open late on a summer evening, as well as the seafront attractions that give children so much joy, people choose to holiday in Bognor Regis and Littlehampton not only because it is wonderful, but because it is affordable. Our businesses make that possible. From independents such as the East Beach guest house, the Navigator hotel and Bailiffscourt hotel and spa, to household names such as Butlin’s and Premier Inn, businesses work so hard to ensure that families can enjoy a great British holiday at a price they can afford.
However, this Government have so far spent their time in office making it harder for such businesses to survive. They have hiked employer national insurance, pushed up business rates by an average of more than 30% and piled on red tape. As one local business owner put it to me recently:
“This Government has made it harder to run a business than ever before.”
Not content with adding layer upon layer of cost on businesses, the Government now want to make it more expensive for families to holiday in seaside towns such as Bognor Regis and Littlehampton.
Nationally, Oxford Economics estimates that this 5% levy could result in 12 million fewer overnight stays and £1.7 billion less visitor spending, and put 33,000 jobs at risk. In local terms, for a family of four holidaying for a week in Littlehampton, that could add more than £100 to the bill. For many, that is simply unaffordable; even if they could afford it, that is money that will no longer be spent in other local businesses.
There are no two ways about it: higher accommodation prices will reduce occupancy rates in hotels and B&Bs in our seaside towns. Some families will cut their holiday short; others will look abroad or decide that they cannot afford to go away at all. That is the real fear for Richard and Mark Groome, the proprietors of East Beach guest house in Littlehampton. They know that people cannot afford to spend any more, and they worry that they will choose to stay away instead. What will that force them to do? They have already cut back on costs, and are desperate not to put up prices for their customers, but they are now worried that the Government are making that decision for them. The levy will deter tourists and lead to less custom for the businesses around their lovely hotel. That means less spending on the locally roasted coffee at Edge by the Sea, Mewsbrook Park café or East Beach café in Littlehampton; on the delicious food at Chez Moi in Aldwick, which has been recommended in The Sunday Times, at Fino in Felpham, or at Lemongrass in Rustington; or on a well deserved holiday beverage at the Waverley in Bognor Regis, the Maypole in Yapton or any number of outstanding venues across my constituency.
For businesses that rely on a good summer to get through the winter, the levy will force them to push up prices, cut staff and, in some cases, close their doors for the last time. At a roundtable with local hospitality businesses in July, I heard genuine fear about the impact of this holiday tax. Iain Brown, the director of Sussex Inns, hit the nail on the head when he called it out for what it is: an “absolute killer blow” for our hospitality sector. He is right.
There will be a further damaging knock-on effect of this tax. Tomorrow we expect the Milburn review. It will rightly say that we need to get more young people off welfare and into work. Young people deserve the chance to earn a wage and experience the dignity that comes with that, but many have not had the chance to get the experience that employers ask for and so find themselves in a difficult position.
I am sure that we will hear plenty of warm words from Ministers about their jobs guarantee, but rather than congratulating themselves, they might instead ask themselves why they need to introduce one. They should be thinking about where those young people would have got their first job. In towns such as mine, it is the guest house, the café, the pub, the hotel, the ice cream parlour or the seaside attraction that give young people that first chance. By putting yet another tax on those businesses, we are ensuring that those jobs will no longer exist. The Government have been forced to intervene in a problem of their own making.
The holiday tax shows yet again that this Government have got the wrong priorities and do not understand the consequences of their actions. Whatever the Prime Minister says about breathing space, he is choosing to make it more expensive for British families to go on holiday, choosing to make it harder for young people to get their first job and choosing to make it even harder for businesses to stay afloat. The Government should abandon their plans to put British holidays on the brink. While they are at it, they should join the Conservatives in pledging to scrap the Employment Rights Act 2025, reverse the employer national insurance hike and let businesses give young people the leg up they deserve.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government (Sally Jameson)
I thank hon. Members from across the House for their thoughtful contributions to today’s debate. I am pleased to speak to this Bill, which is something that mayors and local leaders have long called for. I thank the Secretary of State and the Minister for Local Government, Devolution and Regional Growth for introducing the Bill. The Devolution Minister sends his apologies for being unable to attend the debate, but I know that he strongly believes in these measures and would thank Members for their time and contributions this evening. I also thank the Financial Secretary to the Treasury. This Bill has been a joint endeavour between the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government and His Majesty’s Treasury, and I am grateful for his support in bringing it forward.
I turn to points raised by Members. As many have said, many people have paid a levy of this kind on holidays and travels in other countries, and it is right that our cities, seaside towns and areas of natural beauty have the option to introduce such a levy to support their local economy and tourism industry, and to improve the visitor experience in their area. We have heard from my hon. Friend the Member for Edinburgh South West (Dr Arthur), who gave an excellent explanation of how the levy has worked in his city, and I hope that Members have listened to that.
The levy will be a local decision, made by mayors and local leaders, in consultation with local businesses and residents. It is our job in this House to ensure that the levy can be delivered and works for the hospitality industry, which is the backbone of so many local economies, while recognising that local leaders know what is best for their area. That is why this power will be devolved, and why the decision of whether to introduce a levy will be made locally.
Sally Jameson
We made a commitment in the Labour manifesto to having a wide programme of devolution, and this is about devolving power to local areas.
Those who choose to introduce a levy will be able to invest the proceeds in what makes their area special, in improving the visitor experience, and in driving economic growth and local growth. That could mean building new infrastructure, holding and supporting cultural events, security, promoting the area as a destination, or working with local authorities to improve the destination, with cleaner streets and better looked-after parks. Crucially, it will be for local leaders in collaboration with their local authorities to determine how that investment can best support local economies and the visitor economy.
Sally Jameson
I will not give way again to the hon. Member.
Local authorities will have the opportunity to feed into local consultation and decision-making processes. Local authorities will also see the benefits of revenues being invested locally. I am sure that mayors up and down the country will ensure that voices of MPs and council leaders are heard in the process.
Consultants have been raised by some hon. Members. There is no expectation that consultants will be employed, and the Minister is working closely with strategic authorities on the delivery of the levy. As part of the “Rewiring the State” delivery plan, we are looking at capacity in strategic authorities, and ensuring that they have the people and resource that they need to take on additional devolution. We recognise that visitor economies differ from place to place, so strategic authorities will have flexibility to exempt particular types of accommodation, such as camping pitches or dormitory-style accommodation, where that is right for their area. For example, strategic authorities may exempt lower-cost accommodation that is commonly used for educational trips and groups such as scouts and squirrels—that point was raised by my hon. Friend the Member for Stoke-on-Trent Central (Gareth Snell).