Personal Independence Payment and Universal Credit

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Excerpts
Monday 2nd November 2026

(2 weeks ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Baroness Sherlock Portrait Baroness Sherlock (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

The noble Lord raises an important point. We are watching carefully and monitoring benefits-related content and emerging risks online, and we are working to ensure that people have access to appropriate support. In the coming weeks, we will also introduce a new code of practice that will clamp down on activity by claims management companies that are trying to get people to pay them to apply for benefits that they can get perfectly well for free. That simply is not there. If the noble Lord looks, he will see that our new “Don’t pay to claim” marketing campaign has already gone live. It will be out there between now and Christmas encouraging pensioners and those who support them not to pay anything for benefits that they can get for free. I am glad the noble Lord raised this: we are acting in this space and will keep monitoring it.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, the Question is about the trends in claims. I have not heard anything from the Minister about how the Government are looking at the trends and what they are doing to deal with those trends. It is just: “We are doing the same as we have done before”. There are trends, and I do not think they are being looked at carefully enough.

Baroness Sherlock Portrait Baroness Sherlock (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I apologise: clearly, I have not explained myself clearly enough. Let me try again, because we are absolutely not doing what used to happen. We are doing different things, and they are starting to have an effect. For example, when I say that we have rebalanced universal credit, what the previous Government did was to freeze the rates for universal credit but not for disability benefits. What then happened was that people were either driven into poverty or were diverted into sickness and disability benefits. What we have done is to rebalance universal credit. We have invested in right to try, so that people who are disabled can take a risk on work, knowing that if it does not work, they can still get support. Crucially, we are investing in employment support to help people to get out there and into work. If the noble Lord looks at the trends, the number of people who are economically inactive because of long-term sickness has been going up stratospherically; that rise has finally levelled off. That is the difference that we are beginning to make. We will not do this overnight. Nobody has ever fixed this overnight. Oppositions often pretend too; Governments do not. We are going to make a difference.

Pneumoconiosis etc. (Workers’ Compensation) (Payment of Claims) (Amendment) (No. 2) Regulations 2026

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Excerpts
Wednesday 28th October 2026

(2 weeks, 5 days ago)

Grand Committee
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Baroness Sherlock Portrait The Minister of State, Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Sherlock) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, the Committee will also consider the draft Mesothelioma Lump Sum Payments (Conditions and Amounts) (Amendment) (No. 2) Regulations 2026.

The schemes we are debating today provide vital support to people who have developed certain dust-related diseases, often caused by occupational exposure to asbestos and other harmful dusts. This includes diseases such as pneumoconiosis and mesothelioma. We all recognise the devastating impact that these diseases can have on individuals and their families, so I am grateful for the opportunity to debate these schemes and the reforms we are making to ensure that they continue to provide effective support. I will begin by providing a brief overview of these two no-fault compensation schemes and what these regulations seek to amend.

The Pneumoconiosis etc. (Workers’ Compensation) Act 1979 scheme—henceforth “the 1979 Act scheme”—provides a single lump-sum compensation payment to eligible individuals who suffer from one of the diseases covered by the scheme. This includes diffuse mesothelioma, pneumoconiosis and three other dust-related respiratory diseases.

The scheme was designed to compensate people unable to claim damages from former employers that had gone out of business, and who had not brought any civil action against another party for damages. To be entitled to a lump-sum award, claimants must have an industrial injuries disablement benefit award for a disease covered by the 1979 Act scheme—or would have an award but for their percentage disablement.

The mesothelioma lump-sum payments scheme—or the “2008 Act scheme”—was introduced to provide compensation to people who contracted diffuse mesothelioma but were unable to claim compensation through the 1979 Act scheme. For example, they may be self-employed or their exposure to asbestos was not due to their work. The 2008 Act scheme provides support to people with diffuse mesothelioma, quickly, at their time of greatest need.

Although both schemes aim to provide compensation to sufferers within their lifetime, each scheme also allows for claims by dependants, if the person suffering from the disease sadly dies before they are able to make a claim. This is in recognition of the suffering these diseases can bring to whole families.

These regulations make changes to both schemes, the most significant of which relate to awards for dependants and the treatment of claims where a claimant dies before payment can be made. Under the current arrangements, awards payable to dependants are generally lower than those payable to sufferers. These regulations will align the rates payable to dependants with those payable to sufferers under both schemes. That means that dependants will receive compensation calculated using the same rates as eligible sufferers, providing a single payment structure under each scheme.

For families already coping with the loss of a loved one, these changes will provide greater financial support at an already difficult time. This is something the House has raised repeatedly with Ministers over the years. Indeed, when I was in opposition, I recall asking the then Ministers about it myself. I am delighted we are able to address this issue at last.

The regulations also make provision for circumstances where an individual dies after making a valid claim but before payment is made. In those cases, payment may be made to the claimant’s personal representatives. This will help ensure that compensation can still be paid where an individual has done everything required of them to make a claim but sadly dies before their award can be issued.

For the 1979 Act scheme, the regulations also make a number of consequential changes to support these reforms. These include introducing a clear statutory basis for determining the date used to calculate awards and removing payment provisions no longer required following the alignment of award rates.

Together, these changes will ensure that the schemes continue to provide meaningful support to those affected by these devastating diseases and their families. I am sure the Committee will want to join me in recognising the continued importance of the compensation offered by the 1979 and 2008 Act schemes.

Finally, I am required to confirm that these provisions are compatible with the European Convention on Human Rights, and I am happy to do so.

I commend these regulations, which align compensation rates for dependants with those of sufferers and improve the operation of both schemes, to the Grand Committee and ask for its approval to implement them. I beg to move.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- Hansard - -

I thank the Minister for introducing these regulations. Be in no doubt that the Liberal Democrats support both instruments, so I hope to be brief. These regulations, as was said, deal with some of the most grievous consequences of working life in this country. Mesothelioma is incurable and usually fatal within a short time of diagnosis. Pneumoconiosis is a legacy of the coal mines, quarries and foundries that once upon a time powered our economy.

Those who developed these diseases did nothing wrong except go to work. Those who care for them and those left behind deserve a scheme that treats them fairly, which is what the Minister has helpfully outlined. For that reason, the central change in both instruments is right. At present, as we heard, dependants receive lower awards than the person disabled by the disease. The 1979 Act scheme layers on a complex set of top-ups. A widower or widow has no reason to receive less because their spouse died before a claim was made. Moving to a single-rate structure removes an anomaly that was hard to defend, as the Minister said in her opening remarks.

The other welcome change is the provision for payment to personal representatives where a claimant dies after a valid claim but before payment. Given the prognosis for mesothelioma, the scenario is far from hypothetical. It is cruel that a family could lose an award simply because the administrative process was slower than the disease. Even so, I should like to put some questions to the Minister.

First, the Government expect dependants to be “better off overall”. Can the Minister please confirm whether anyone will be worse off? The additional dependant top-up, the minimum payment and the tuberculosis-related top-up are all being removed. Has the department modelled the individual cases most likely to lose out? If so, what is the transitional protection? Secondly, these rules apply only when entitlement first arises on or after 31 October. Families whose entitlement arose just before that date will receive less, for some reason, for the same loss. I understand the legal logic, but what is the Government’s response to those families who no doubt will feel unhappy about that? Thirdly, on the clearer relevant date rules, I welcome the reduction in disputes. Can the Minister say how claimants will be told which date applies to them and whether the department will publish guidance before 31 October?

Fourthly, the instruments replace references to assessment bodies with medical practitioners appointed by the Secretary of State. What assurance can the Minister give us about capacity and waiting times for assessment? Delay is the enemy of anyone with a terminal diagnosis. Fifthly, on probate administration and confirmation documents, how will the department help bereaved families, who may be struggling to obtain them quickly? With those questions, the answers to which I think will add to the debate today, I am pleased from these Benches to support the regulations.

Baroness Stedman-Scott Portrait Baroness Stedman-Scott (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I thank the Minister for introducing these two instruments and setting out their purpose. I confirm at the outset that we on these Benches welcome these changes and are pleased to support both instruments.

Mesothelioma, pneumoconiosis and other dust-related diseases cause immense suffering to workers and their families, often emerging decades after the original exposure to asbestos or other harmful substances. Many of those affected spent their lives working in industries such as mining, shipbuilding and construction, contributing enormously to our country’s prosperity, only to face devastating illness later in life. It is important to remember that the effects of these conditions extend far beyond those diagnosed. Families are often left to contend not only with the emotional toll of serious illness and bereavement but with substantial financial pressures.

The compensation schemes established under the 1979 and 2008 Acts therefore provide an essential safety net, particularly where a former employer has ceased trading or those affected cannot obtain compensation through other means. The central change introduced by these two instruments is welcome. It is right that dependants should receive compensation calculated at the same rates as sufferers themselves. A family’s need for support does not diminish because their loved one died before making a claim. I also welcome the provisions enabling payments to be made through a claimant’s personal representatives, where an individual dies after submitting a valid claim but before receiving compensation.

I want briefly to take this opportunity to recognise the tireless work of charities, campaigners and victims’ organisations that have advocated for these changes over many years, including Mesothelioma UK and the Asbestos Victims Support Group Forum UK. We support the principles underpinning both instruments, but I should be grateful if the Minister can provide further clarification on their practical implementation.

First, on the administration of payments following a claimant’s death, the regulations provide for compensation to be paid to personal representatives once the necessary evidence of probate, letters of administration or confirmation as executor have been supplied. Although those requirements are understandable, obtaining the necessary documentation can be a lengthy process, particularly for families dealing with bereavement. Can the Minister therefore explain what steps the department is taking to ensure that these requirements do not cause unnecessary delays. Will the Government introduce a target processing time for payment once the relevant documentation has been received? What guidance and practical assistance will be provided to bereaved families?

Secondly, I turn to the removal of existing supplementary payments under the pneumoconiosis scheme. The regulations remove a number of existing top-up provisions, including the provision relating to sufferers whose pneumoconiosis is accompanied by tuberculosis. The Government have suggested that the higher basic awards mean that claimants will benefit overall from the new arrangements. Can the Minister nevertheless give a categorical assurance that no individual claimant will receive a lower award as a result of these changes, including anyone who had previously qualified for the tuberculosis-related payment. If that assurance cannot be given, how many claimants does the department estimate could receive less? What is the maximum potential reduction and what transitional protection has been considered?

Thirdly, I turn to the transitional arrangements. Both instruments are intended to come into force on 31 October but they use different tests to determine who benefits from the new provisions. Under the 1979 Act scheme, the amendments apply where a person first fulfils the conditions of entitlement on or after that date. Under the 2008 Act scheme, the increased dependant rate applies where the sufferer dies on or after that date. Can the Minister explain the reason for using these different tests? How will the department treat cases in which a person fulfils the entitlement conditions or dies shortly before 31 October but the claim has not been determined by that date? In particular, what consideration has been given to families who may receive a substantially lower payment solely because the relevant event occurred shortly before the commencement date?

Fourthly, I turn to the speed of payments and awareness of schemes. These schemes are intended, wherever possible, to provide compensation to sufferers during their own lifetimes. Given the often rapid progression of these diseases following diagnosis, it is essential that applications are processed without unnecessary delay. Can the Minister tell the Committee the current average and median processing times under both schemes? How many claimants have died after submitting a valid claim but before receiving payment, in each of the past five years?

Jobcentre Plus and National Careers Service: Merger

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Excerpts
Thursday 10th September 2026

(2 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Baroness Sherlock Portrait Baroness Sherlock (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I can indeed. I am very glad that the noble Baroness has asked this question, because it is really important. The whole point of merging the jobs and careers service is to bring these together in one place to make it easier for individuals who come in to get the help they need. The jobs and careers service will provide more personalised support and help people overcome their barriers, whatever they are. We have launched a jobs and careers service pilot in the north-east which is testing how people with health or disability problems can be helped into work. If they are in the same place, rather than people having to go somewhere else or to a different organisation, this will have to make a difference.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I take what the Minister has said about the trials they are doing, but will the merger result in any closure or consolidation of offices? What assessment has been made of the impact of this on rural and disadvantaged communities?

Baroness Sherlock Portrait Baroness Sherlock (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, one of the great things about making sure that these services come into the jobcentres is that jobcentre services are right across the country. At the moment, the Department for Education contracts this careers service support out to prime contractors, which then contract regionally to community contractors. We are merging them, so they will be working alongside their colleagues in the jobcentre. Alongside jobcentres, we have increased the number of vans that go out into the community. Some of these careers services will be asked to locate themselves in youth hubs or community settings such as libraries. The aim of this is to get the support to where people need it, not just to make them come to us.

Pensions Commission

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Excerpts
Wednesday 22nd July 2026

(3 months, 3 weeks ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Baroness Sherlock Portrait Baroness Sherlock (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I can indeed, and I am grateful to my noble friend for his welcome back. He will forgive me, as I will not be able to give him any specific answers on the future rates of the state pension; if I pre-empt the Budget, I think I may be the shortest-living Minister in history—I would not even make it to 24 hours. But I can tell him how the process will work. The Government are required to do a review of the state pension age. We have set up an independent commission, chaired by Dr Suzy Morrissey, to look at the evidence and make a report, which it has now done and handed it in. The Government will take a wider range of evidence, including from the Pensions Commission, and will then have to make a decision about the future of the state pension age. The commission is looking at the adequacy of the state pension. Obviously, the state pension is there, but the key objective is determining whether people are saving enough for retirement—so it is not just about what the state pension is doing but about whether people are saving enough in private pensions for retirement, and it is clear from the interim report that they are not. We now look forward to the recommendations that are coming. All of us will come together and the Government will make a decision. This is all on the back of the significant work done already by the pensions investment commission and the recent Bill on private pension schemes. It is all coming together.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I welcome the fact that the Minister is still there on the Front Bench; may it continue. My question is on which comes first. We discussed the then Pension Schemes Bill at length—a very complicated Bill—various other pension things have come before the House; and now we have a commission. Surely, it is putting the cart before the horse by us all doing lots of legislation and then having a commission to see what should be in it. Surely, the commission should have come first.

Baroness Sherlock Portrait Baroness Sherlock (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I now realise that I did a terrible job, because repeatedly during the passage of the Pension Schemes Act I tried to explain why that was not right, and I utterly failed—I will have one last go. The Government set out a pensions investment review to look at the state of the landscape of private pension saving. We then recognised that, if we want people to save more for their retirement in private pensions, we need to make sure that they will get the returns they need. The Pension Schemes Act is now laying the ground to make sure that private pension savers are getting the returns, so that if the Pensions Commission looks at it and decides there needs to be more private pension saving, the people who make those savings will get the return on that hard-earned money. It does all come together. I know the noble Lord was not able to be there, but I did a briefing yesterday, open to all Peers, on what is happening in the pensions area, and we set out a road map showing how all these things come together; I would be very happy to send him a copy of that.

Industrial Training Levy (Engineering Construction Industry Training Board) Order 2026

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Excerpts
Tuesday 14th July 2026

(4 months ago)

Grand Committee
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Baroness Coffey Portrait Baroness Coffey (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I do not seek to oppose this order today, but I have a number of questions. I again start by praising the Government, and I strongly support the move to the DWP and the CITB, as well as, more broadly, the changes that the Government have made to the apprenticeship approach. I fully support the merger of the two bodies, which is under consultation, and I hope that that consultation review will be concluded quickly.

One thing that the Minister mentioned was that 85% of the levy payers, who contribute 98% of the levy, are supportive. I was interested in paragraph 33 of the impact assessment, which said that the independent

“customer satisfaction survey in 2024 … found that 65% of employers agreed or strongly agreed that without the levy and grant system the training would not take place”.

As it says elsewhere in the impact assessment, we have a situation where, in order to generate more income, the ECITB has started increasing its training of overseas learners. I do not really understand where this is going.

I am sure the Minister has been diligent more broadly in thinking about what is happening with the amount of people going on to training who do not complete the training or do not continue into work. That is very worrying, given the amounts of money being invested and what is happening with the follow-up. The Government are using powers, as this is an executive non-departmental public body, so is there an element here of thinking about how this could get a bit more refocused, working independently but also in partnership with the department, given that 47% of young people are dropping out? The figures of people who just do the course and, within so many years, drop out of this industry entirely are even higher.

I know that there is work on how to help employers onboard people into apprenticeships, traineeships and the like, but I suggest that some more focus could perhaps help with that. I suggest thinking about how the objectives and key performance indicators for this board could perhaps be published more regularly. On that, 9 July 2025 is when we last saw the annual report and accounts for 2024, so when does the Minister expect the report and accounts to be laid for 2025? As I say, there is a lot of value in this body and its sister body.

I do not expect the Minister to have an answer to this today, but this body is also a charity, and I am unclear about why that is still needed. Is that limiting what can happen in trying to make this more effective? As I say, a good number—65%—of businesses interviewed said that all this training stuff probably would not happen without this board. But, again, on some of the link-up with the other organisations involved in this, including the Government and particularly the Department for Work and Pensions, I think this is a better home for it than where it was, the DfE.

I would be interested in getting some further understanding on the need for this to be a charity. According to the Charity Commission accounts, it is not eligible for gift aid. There is a lot of complexity in why someone is a trustee, when actually they are all appointed by the Secretary of State. The Minister may not have the answer today, but I would be grateful for a follow-up more broadly.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- Hansard - -

My Lords, I thank the Minister for producing this order and giving us such welcome information. It is a key job of any Government to grow the economy, and productivity is central to that. This levy is a proven way to fund skills in the construction sector, because the market alone has not invested enough in training. The 2023 review confirmed that this problem still exists, so the case for keeping the levy is strong. Turning to the detail, the order keeps the current rates in place: 0.35% on directors’ pay and 1.25% on payments to subcontractors. These rates have not changed since the pandemic-era reductions ended.

I welcome the extra help for small firms. The exemption threshold is rising from £135,000 to £150,000, which means that 69% of employers will now pay nothing at all. There is also a 50% reduction for firms with wage bills of between £150,000 and £500,000, helping around 10,000 small businesses, I believe. This strikes a reasonable balance: it protects small firms while larger employers continue to pay their fair share, with no cap on their contributions. The Minister has given lots of statistics. There are so many statistics going around, some of which are contradictory.

As Liberal Democrats, we believe in partnership between employers and educators, and that is exactly how this proposal was developed. As we have been told, the CITB ran a formal consultation last year, called “Consensus”, and over 67% of levy payers backed the plans. Those firms represent almost 72% of the total levy value. This is a genuine mandate from the industry itself, not something imposed from above, and it is the right way to build support for a levy like this.

The sums involved are substantial. I believe the levy is expected to raise around £243 million a year between 2026 and 2028. Last year, the CITB raised £228.1 million and used it to fund £129.8 million in grants and £53.4 million in other schemes. This supported around 30,000 apprentices and, I believe, nearly 20,000 people in gaining a qualification. This is a serious investment in skills, and it costs the taxpayer nothing, since the CITB receives no grant from the Government.

The noble Baroness, Lady Coffey, mentioned charities. I should say that charities are exempt from the levy, but I would welcome hearing anything that the Minister can say in answer to the questions raised about them.

I have one question for the Minister: how will the Government check that this money is working? We need to see real gains in skills and productivity, especially given the scale of the construction skills gap across England, Scotland and Wales. I would welcome the Minister’s thoughts on that. As a nation—or, as the Minister said, nations—we need to up our game in providing training and reduce our reliance on imports to address skills shortages.

On the whole, we on these Benches support this order. It keeps a levy system that the industry itself backs, protects small businesses through a fairer approach and funds real training for a skilled workforce.

Health-related Benefits Assessments

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Excerpts
Monday 8th June 2026

(5 months, 1 week ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Baroness Sherlock Portrait Baroness Sherlock (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I agree with the noble Baroness about the challenge that we face with the number of young people not in employment, education or training. That is why the Government commissioned the Milburn review, and why we welcome that report, and that is why we have action clearly going on in this space. The Government are committed to increasing the number of assessments. There is a range of reasons why it is taking time. The noble Baroness may not be aware that, for example, before Covid, assessments were pretty much all done face to face. They collapsed in Covid and the numbers have barely come back up since. In 2023, about a year before the general election, the previous Government signed long-term contracts, making sure that most assessors could work from home. I understand why that would be attractive—because they can be anywhere in the country—and so it is a bit of a challenge trying to get face-to-face assessments in the right parts of the country. We are working with contractors and driving up face-to-face assessments. We will do the right thing and we are attacking this problem.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, can the department cope with more face-to-face assessments? How long will it take to put that into effect? Has the department come up with any other suggestions of how assessments can be made, particularly for people suffering from health issues which may make face-to-face assessments quite difficult?

Baroness Sherlock Portrait Baroness Sherlock (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

The noble Lord raises an important point and I am grateful to him. There have traditionally been different ways of doing assessments: some are face to face, some are on the telephone and some are video assessments. The starting point is that the health professional must look at and assess all the written evidence—from the GP and the hospital, and evidence provided by the claimant—and then make a decision. There are some cases where, clearly, face to face is right, for reasons of identity verification, wanting to get details they cannot easily get online, where there is a physical examination and so on. There are other cases where people may have a particular reasonable adjustment that they need—it may be difficult for them to get to a centre—and for them a face-to-face assessment is not appropriate. We want to maintain all those things but drive up the proportion of face-to-face assessments to get the right results for individuals and for the taxpayer.

Young People and Work

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Excerpts
Thursday 4th June 2026

(5 months, 1 week ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Baroness Smith of Malvern Portrait Baroness Smith of Malvern (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I do agree with my noble friend. The report rightly identified the systemic issues that have led to one million young people not being able to earn or learn. It is therefore this Government’s responsibility to take action—as we have already started to do—through the education system, through our youth services and through our welfare and health systems to address the wide range of issues that are leading to young people’s failure to start their working and learning lives in a way that will lead to the sorts of futures we all want them to have.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, as we have said, the Milburn review found that one million young people are now classed as NEET—the highest level for 12 years. The report warns that without further action, one in six young people could be in this position within five years. Hospitality vacancies alone have halved in four years. The Government’s own youth jobs grant will reach a miserable 60,000 young people over three years. This is a sticking plaster on a wound the Government helped create. Does the Minister agree that the jobs tax is hammering the very entry-level opportunities on which young people rely? Mention has been made of national insurance contributions. Could the Minister at least confirm that the Government will be consulting on a lower employer NIC band for workers earning between £5,000 and £9,100? The Minister’s comment about workers under 21 does not cover that wide gamut of people. I would like to feel that there is consultation as to how this is affecting the employment of young people.

Pension Schemes Bill

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Excerpts
Viscount Younger of Leckie Portrait Viscount Younger of Leckie (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, in speaking to Motion B1, I welcome that the Government have committed to a review of Regulation 64A of the Local Government Pension Scheme Regulations 2013. That is an important and necessary step, and their further commitments today are most welcome.

However, if the GAD review is to be meaningful, it must first focus on the factors that directly drive employer contribution rates. In particular, it should examine the effectiveness of consultation between fund actuaries, administering authorities and scheme employers.

Secondly, the GAD review must examine outliers in valuations. There is increasing evidence that some funds are applying discount rates that are significantly more prudent than those implied by gilt yields or insurer pricing, despite the Local Government Pension Scheme being an open, funded and asset-backed scheme.

Thirdly, Section 151 officers are rightly expected to scrutinise expenditure rigorously, including pension contributions, just as they would any other area of spending. When budgets are tight and local taxpayers are under strain, those responsible must be able to understand the methodologies being used, weigh the trade-offs and, where necessary, challenge the conclusions reached by fund actuaries.

It was with these concerns in mind that amendments were tabled in Committee, as the Minister is aware. Where such issues arise of the kind that I have outlined there is currently little recourse. Employers may be forced to wait up to three years for the next valuation cycle before any action can be taken. That is a considerable period to carry contribution rates that may be excessive or difficult to justify. The principle in our amendment is simple: the review identifies the problem and the interim review under Regulation 64A provides the remedy.

On these points, I am glad that the Government have broadly recognised the concerns I have raised in my amendment. I shall listen to the remainder of the debate on this group, but I am more reassured now that this is a priority for the Government and that they are aware of the concerns that we have been outlining. I thank the Minister for his movement on this.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I thank the Minister for explaining things in great detail from the Government’s perspective.

I will speak to Motion B1, which the Minister said has already been met. The Local Government Pension Scheme already has mechanisms to review and amend employer pension contributions and funding practices; for instance, under Regulation 64A of the Local Government Pension Scheme Regulations 2013. There is even an existing GAD reporting mechanism under the Public Service Pensions Act 2013, which reports on compliance, consistency, solvency and long-term cost efficiency, with such reports having been carried out in 2018, 2019 and 2024. Therefore, we on these Benches think that the Government’s efforts should be focused—as they are, I think—more on implementing the recommendations of those reports, rather than duplicating efforts. We will probably abstain on Motion B1; we recognise its importance but think it is already being met.

Motion C is a government Motion, so I come to Motion D. Amendment 13 would extend the period before a pension pot is classified as dormant, increasing the threshold from one year to three years. We supported this increase earlier in the passage of the Bill, as it would provide greater flexibility for savers such as mothers, those on sabbatical or mature students. Motion D1, from the noble Baroness, Lady Altmann—

Lord Katz Portrait Lord Katz (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

Motions D and D1 are the opening Motions of the next group.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- Hansard - -

Have they been moved?

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- Hansard - -

It says “D1” on the Order Paper.

Lord Katz Portrait Lord Katz (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is in the second group.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- Hansard - -

I see. I am sorry. Forgive me, I was going on to the next group.

On Motion B1, we will abstain rather than vote against it, because we think that these things are already in process, if dealt with properly.

Lord Katz Portrait Lord Katz (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am glad that, for once, our debate on the LGPS has been short and sweet. I thank both opposition Front Benches for their engagement on this issue. I am glad that the noble Viscount, Lord Younger, recognised that there has been movement. We understand the importance attached to the nature of the reviews. I hope that what I said has met his need for us to demonstrate that we are taking it seriously, which, of course, we are.

In response to the noble Lord, Lord Palmer, I hope that he will be in a position where his abstinence will not be needed because the noble Viscount will not be testing the opinion of the House, but we shall see. I beg to move.

--- Later in debate ---
Lord Davies of Brixton Portrait Lord Davies of Brixton (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I note that my noble friend the Minister went out of her way to mention pre-1997 increases, even though they do not come up in any of these amendments. The House will welcome future increases being paid, but the failure to do anything about lost increases is still a big topic that is not going away.

I share many of the concerns about small pots expressed by the noble Baroness, Lady Altmann, on Motion D1. However, I was reassured by the comments that my noble friend the Minister made in introducing this group about the flexibility inherent in the proposals in the Bill. I hope she will reassure us that the issue will be kept under review and that, if the problems that some of us worry about arise, the necessary action can be taken without the need for primary legislation.

I also support the concerns of the noble Viscount, Lord Thurso. I am glad to hear that the issue is being taken forward—more power to his elbow.

I could speak at great length on the issue of Motion J1, picking up the points raised by the noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe, in her speech introducing it. However, I very much welcome what my noble friend said in introducing this group. I fully agree with all the arguments she made, so I will leave it there.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, prior to this debate we had a Statement showing what can be done in haste, when you should stop and think, in the appointment of Lord Mandelson as the ambassador to the United States of America. I use that analogy here, because one year to move pots is a miniscule amount of time.

The noble Baroness, Lady Altmann, said that two years would also be short but would be more appropriate. I hear that she has decided not to press this Motion. If she had, we on these Benches would have supported it because one year is not enough, just as a flick of the Prime Minister’s eye was not enough to appoint Lord Mandelson as the ambassador to the United States. We need two years. I understand that it is not going to happen here today but, before the Bill is finalised, I ask the Minister and her colleagues in the House of Commons to consider tweaking it to make one year two years. It would please a lot of people and would be a safeguard for people with small pots, who are the least interested in how their pensions work until they find that they are not what they thought they were, they cannot find them or whatever it is. The point about the pensions dashboard was well made.

I welcome the consultations that we have had with Government Ministers. In many ways, we have worked together on this Bill, and we have managed to make some of the points about which we feel strongly. On the pots, I hope that one year could be two years. It does not have to be done now; it could be done quietly, with no fuss at all.

Motion J1, the Conservative Motion, would insist on Amendments 77 and 85. We on these Benches supported these amendments on Report, because we agreed that it would be important for the Government to comment on this issue. However—and I think this shows what I was saying before—we have been convinced by the arguments made by the Government on the content of these amendments overlapping with existing reporting mechanisms. We are happy that that has happened.

I hope that the Government Ministers will take cognisance of the fact that we are not making problems just for the sake of debate in this Chamber. We think that, for small pots, it should be one year, not two. We will be talking in the next lot of amendments on mandation and we hope to convince the Government on that and on the size and range of pension funds.

We will not be voting on the Motion by the noble Baroness, Lady Altmann. If the Conservative Benches call a Division on Motion J1, we will probably quietly abstain.

Viscount Younger of Leckie Portrait Viscount Younger of Leckie (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Altmann, my noble friend Lady Neville-Rolfe and the noble Viscount, Lord Thurso, for their Motions in this group. In the interest of brevity, I shall focus my remarks only on Motion J1.

My noble friend Lady Neville-Rolfe is fundamentally asking the important question of whether we are being sufficiently clear about the long-term sustainability and transparency of the system as it currently stands. The central concern is this: unlike funded schemes, these pensions are not backed by accumulated assets. They are paid out of current taxation, and that means that the cost is not contained within a fund but passed forward, year by year, to future taxpayers. As the number of public sector employees grows, and as people live longer, those obligations grow with them.

There is also a question of incentives. Decisions about expanding the public sector workforce or adjusting pay inevitably carry pension implications that stretch decades into the future, yet those costs are often diffuse, uncertain and ultimately borne by the Exchequer. Without a clear and accessible understanding of the long-term consequences, it is difficult, if not impossible, for decision-makers to weigh those trade-offs properly. A review would allow us to bring together the evidence, to test the assumptions and to ensure that policy is being made on the basis of a clear and realistic understanding of the facts.

For those reasons, including the four key reasons outlined by my noble friend, I believe that there is a strong case for the review proposed, and I am very pleased to support this Motion.

Pension Schemes Bill

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Excerpts
Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, if only we had dealt with all the amendments during the passage of the Bill as quickly as we have today, we would not have been here quite so late on many occasions.

I thank my noble friends Lady Bowles—whose expertise has been amazing—Lord Sharkey and Lord Thurso, and our hard-working political adviser, Ulysse Abbate. I also thank profusely those on the Conservative Front Bench, with whom we have worked very well on things on which we agreed. When we disagreed, we did not come to a bunfight. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Altmann, a former Pensions Minister, whose expertise has been valuable in dealing with the Bill. I also thank the Minister and the noble Lord, Lord Katz, and their team, for their superb work on a very technical Bill with high-stakes issues. I realise that there are pressures from the other end as well as here, but we think we have worked well and come out with something pretty reasonable.

On these Benches we recognise and welcome some of the measures in the Bill, such as the value-for-money framework and the superfunds legislation. We have also noted large gaps in the regulation, including on pension scandals such as the AEAT pension scandal and injustices that no one seems to want to face up to, such as the pre-1997 indexation issues. The Liberal Democrats will continue to challenge the Government on going further.

We have worked hard to expose the flaws in the Government’s plans on mandation. This is probably one of the most important issues. Not only is a reserve power dangerous, in that it gives this and future Governments huge powers, but the clause itself has flaws, which my noble friend Lady Bowles and others across the Chamber have pointed out extensively in our debates.

We have had a very good run with this Bill. I again thank the Minister for engaging with us and, I hope, coming up with something that maybe, as time goes on, we can tweak in some ways, but not necessarily in primary legislation.

Youth Unemployment

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Excerpts
Tuesday 24th March 2026

(7 months, 3 weeks ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Baroness Stedman-Scott Portrait Baroness Stedman-Scott (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I begin by making it very clear that we on these Benches believe it is vital that young people are supported into work. We wholeheartedly support the announcement about the new opportunities for young people, and we want to see them succeed. The evidence is clear that periods of unemployment at the start of a working life can have long-lasting and deeply damaging consequences. That makes early intervention not just desirable but essential. It is therefore welcome that the Department for Work and Pensions recognises the importance of this issue, but recognition alone is not enough.

The latest figures from the Office for National Statistics give us all, across this House, cause for concern. Youth unemployment among those aged 18 to 24 has risen to 14.5%, the highest level in nearly a decade. That represents a generation being denied opportunity: young people unable to take their first step on the ladder, to build skills or to contribute to the economy. It is no surprise that Helen Dickinson, chief executive at the British Retail Consortium, has said that

“the UK faces the prospect of a jobless generation ... this vital step on the career ladder is cracking under the high costs of employment”.

To be helpful to the noble Baroness, who I know shares my obsession with getting people, especially young people, into work, I just ask that when we turn to the past 14 years, she will not say that we had 14 years to sort this, because our record was not all that bad. Look at the facts. In 2010, the NEET rate stood at 16%, and by 2019 it had fallen to 10.7%. In turn, youth unemployment fell from around 20% in 2010 to 10.7% in 2022. We acknowledge that Covid created immense challenges and that the rates went up, but it was not all that bad on our watch. We did a lot of good, but we undoubtedly could and should have done more. However, youth unemployment has risen in each year under this Government, now reaching nearly 15% among 16 to 24 year-olds. It is against this deeply troubling backdrop that the Government bring forward this policy, with which we are pleased.

What we see from the Government here is part of a worrying pattern. When the economy fails to deliver the outcomes we all desire, the Government do not seem to pause, reflect or correct the course; instead they reach instinctively for an intervention to compel the private sector to behave as they wish. I have no doubt that the private sector would love to be creating jobs and getting young people into their workforce. This is the return of an interventionist doctrine that places political direction above market judgment. Many believed that this approach had been left behind, but it is now clearly back at the heart of government thinking. We see it in attempts to direct pension fund investment, allocating other people’s savings in line with political priorities rather than saver outcomes. We see it again here. Having failed to create the conditions for a strong labour market, the Government’s answer is not to enable growth but to intervene, to manage and to control.

We on these Benches are not merely supporters of employment, we are the party of work. Before the pandemic, employment reached a record high of 76.5%, while economic inactivity fell to a record low of 20.5%. That was not by chance; it was the result of a deliberate approach, one that trusted enterprise, rewarded effort and created the conditions for businesses to grow and hire. Opportunity should not be manufactured by the state, it should be generated by growth, and that is the approach we would like to see from the Government, but it is one that, sadly, they seem to have rejected.

I have several questions off the back of this Statement which I hope the Minister will address. If there are too many, I am very happy for her to write to me. How will participants be selected for these roles? There is always a tendency to go for those people who are easy to help. How will the Government ensure that those furthest from the labour market and in the most difficulty get help? Have private sector employers been driving the development of this policy, or has it come from Whitehall? How are the Government ensuring that employers are at the heart of this intervention? How will the Government measure the success of this policy, and over what timeframe? Will the performance be communicated to the whole House?

What will happen to young people at the end of the six-month placement? Are employers expected to absorb the full costs thereafter, and if so, on what basis? Do the Government already intend to extend the timeline? Does the Minister genuinely believe that short-term placements, particularly ones concentrated in sectors such as hospitality, will address the deep-rooted productivity and skills challenges in our economy? Crucially, what does the Minister believe is driving the current rise in youth unemployment? Is not the uncomfortable truth that the Government have taxed jobs and discouraged hiring, and are now asking taxpayers to subsidise the very employment opportunities that their policies have undermined? The British Retail Consortium is unequivocal, saying that in 2025 alone, the cost of employing a full-time entry-level worker has risen by 10%.

If the Minister is seeking the root cause of today’s labour market difficulties, I suggest that the Government need look no further than their own political record and policies. Businesses across the country point to the same pressures: burdensome employment regulation such as the Employment Rights Act, a sharp increase in wage and minimum wage costs, higher and inflexible business rates and ever-growing compliance obligations.

This debate comes down to a fundamental choice: do we continue down the path of higher taxes, heavier regulation and greater state intervention, or return to a model that genuinely creates opportunity, backs enterprise, rewards work and enables business to grow? That is the model that we used to deliver high, record employment. I am sure that the Minister and the Government are serious about tackling youth unemployment, but they must move beyond treating the symptoms and begin to address the causes. They must stop trying to control outcomes and instead create the conditions in which those outcomes can be achieved. That means easing the burden on those who create jobs, restoring confidence and recognising that sustainable employment is built not by government decree but by economic growth. Until they confront that reality, these policies will do little more than mask failure, at great cost to the taxpayer and even greater cost to the prospects of the next generation.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I thank the Minister very much—she did not repeat the Statement, but we have read it—and the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, for raising so many questions the answers to which I look forward to hearing.

We have 739,000 young people aged 16 to 24—nearly 100,000 more than last year—unemployed and sitting on benefits of £338 per month. I make no apologies for repeating this figure, but I give it in numbers and not as a percentage, because percentages are misleading and you cannot really understand what they mean. These unemployed 16 to 24 year-olds are, on average, searching and applying over five months for hundreds of roles, with less than 1% success—so they give up entirely. Yet employers report millions of vacancies remaining unfilled. This is not a shortage of jobs but a failure of matching: the right opportunities for the right candidates remain unsurfaced and undiscovered.

Given that the DWP is already piloting matching technologies at some jobcentres, for which I congratulate it—I know about the one in Leicester—can the Minister set out the department’s timeline for scaling these tools nationally across all jobcentres? Critically, what measurable improvement in time to employment does the department expect from this rollout? Additionally, can the Government explain why they are removing the funding for apprenticeships for management? Will they rethink the impact of the national insurance contribution hike on hospitality, retail and tourism? If we dealt with that, it could substantially help with youth unemployment. This is a big problem and I hope the Minister can answer the few questions I have raised and those raised by the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott.

Baroness Sherlock Portrait The Minister of State, Department for Work and Pensions (Baroness Sherlock) (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I am grateful for the questions from both noble Lords. I will come to them in a moment, but I think it is worth reiterating why we are expanding our support for young people now. While the UK’s overall employment levels are historically high, it has been a tough picture for young people in the labour market for some years. I am sure the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, remembers that, in the three years running up to the election, the number of young people not in education, employment or training rose by 250,000, up to almost 1 million. This has not been helped by the 40% decline in youth apprenticeship starts in the space of a decade. The trends we have seen with young people in the labour market are long-term, deep-rooted and worrying. They did not start on 4 July 2024 and they are not confined to the UK, but we all have to address them.

As the noble Baroness said, and knows very well from her experience, if young people start their adult lives on the wrong foot, it has consequences for decades to come, both for them and for our country as a whole. Sir Charlie Mayfield highlighted in Keep Britain Working that, if a young person goes on to benefits in their 20s, they could lose out on £1 million of lifetime earnings and it could cost the state £1 million to support them. Tackling these trends is in all our interests and there should be good cross-party support for this, especially at the moment. At a time of rapid technological change, young people need our support.

We have already set out our reforms to refocus the apprenticeship system back on young people. I say to the noble Lord, Lord Palmer, that we have made some difficult decisions to focus apprenticeships on the young people who need this start early in their life, so we have focused our priority in that space. We had already announced a youth guarantee to help the young unemployed, including 300,000 work experience and training places and a jobs guarantee of subsidised work for 18 to 21 year-olds who have been long-term unemployed. Last week, my honourable friend the Secretary of State set out how we will go even further.

The noble Lord, Lord Palmer, asked about the timing. From this summer, we will introduce hiring bonuses of £3,000 if a business hires a young person who has been on universal credit for six months and there will be bonuses of £2,000 for small and medium-sized businesses hiring young apprentices. These bonuses can be combined if the young person hired has been out of work for six months. On top of that, we are introducing new foundation apprenticeships in retail and hospitality, as well as new short courses in AI, electrical vehicle charging point installation, electrical fitting and assembly, mechanical fitting and assembly and solar PV installation welding. We are also extending the jobs guarantee to those aged 22 to 24. Altogether, this will create 200,000 job and apprenticeship opportunities over the next three years. This represents £1 billion of new investment on top of the funding announced at the Budget, so our package of support for young people now comes to around £2.5 billion.

I am proud of the efforts we are making to ensure that young people can flourish. The noble Baroness must have got mixed up between this policy and something else, because there is no compulsion here. We are not making employers take on young people, but offering incentives for them to do so. We are offering subsidies for jobs. We are doing all the things to help make sure that the young people who are struggling most have a chance to get those jobs out there. That is not compulsion or controlling outcomes: it is giving young people opportunity, and I am proud that we are doing it.

The noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, pointed to some of the policy choices this Government have made. As I pointed out, youth unemployment has been rising since 2022 and the OBR predicts that overall unemployment will peak this year and fall in every year of the forecast. She mentioned tax rises, I am guessing in reference to national insurance contributions. She will remember that employers are exempt from paying employers’ national insurance contributions for workers under 21 and apprentices under 25, unless they are earning over £50,000 a year. She mentioned the Employment Rights Act and the reaction of employers. The problems young people are facing in the labour market go back rather further than that. They are not new. What is new is this package of support, which has been welcomed by large businesses such as Amazon, PwC and the Kier Group, and the Federation of Small Businesses, which called it a game-changer. In terms of hospitality, the chef and businessperson Tom Kerridge said that

“these incentives will give our industry a great boost”.

The noble Lord, Lord Palmer, made the important point that there are vacancies in the economy. There are 700,000, including 50,000 in manufacturing. There are jobs out there. Our job is to help young people get the support, skills, training and experience to get them and—I completely agree with him—we need to match the young people with them. He made a really important point. That is why we are setting out this package today and why it matters so much.

We have already started to reform the system, but we have to do all the things that will make the difference to help them get those jobs. The noble Lord asked about timing. The £2,000 apprenticeship incentive for small and medium-sized enterprises will take effect for those starting apprenticeships from 1 October, as long as they have joined their employer within the last three months. The £3,000 hiring incentive, the youth jobs grant, will be delivered from June this year. The expansion of the jobs guarantee to include 22 to 24 year-olds will be from this autumn, and the first set of new short apprenticeship units is launching from next month. We are not hanging around; we are getting out there to do the work.

I was really grateful to the noble Lord for acknowledging what jobcentres can do in supporting young people. We all know there are young people out there who want these jobs, but they often need the help. They may not have the skills or the work experience.

In response to the noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, different things are obviously open to different people. What I think she was asking was what would happen after somebody was put specifically into a guaranteed job. If they have been out there looking for work for 18 months and they have not got a job, we will guarantee them six months of a job. We would hope that, by the end of that, the employer would see their potential, with all the support they had getting up to that point, and would want to keep them on. If for any reason they did not keep them on, such as if it is not a good fit, or if they did not feel they had the right skills, then all the support will be there from jobcentres and the range of our youth offer, to make sure that, with their new work experience, we can get them out there and get them a new job. Or maybe they would want an apprenticeship to acquire more skills so they can build a career.

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Portrait Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)
- Hansard - -

I am sorry to interrupt the Minister, but perhaps at this point she could tackle the point I raised, which she touched upon, which is the matching of vacancies with jobs. I gave the example of the Leicester jobcentre, which is doing this. My question, which I hope she answers, is: how are we going to spread that out?

Baroness Sherlock Portrait Baroness Sherlock (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

This is already happening in lots of different places and in lots of different ways. Jobcentres are doing it. For example, we are setting up youth hubs in 360 locations across the country, where we can bring together employers and young people, as well as lots of other services, so they can meet them. We also have jobs fairs, which my colleagues have been visiting, where employers are brought in to meet with potential jobseekers. This is the everyday work of jobcentres, of going out there and matching people together. But I would be very interested to talk to the noble Lord about what he saw in Leicester and what he found particularly helpful about that, because it is really good to learn what is out there.

I have very little time left, but I will just say two other things very quickly. First, even though there are jobs out there, the challenge is always going to be that the young people who are farthest from the labour market are going to find it hard to get them. That is why we have to give particular support to them. I know these are tough times generally, but we have to try to do all we can to give those young people a chance to get those jobs. If they can get the experience at this crucial moment, it could be transformative down the line.

Secondly, we will evaluate this very carefully. We are already evaluating what is out there and we are using the evidence base. The noble Baroness, Lady Stedman-Scott, pushed me on wage subsidies, for example. We have looked at the evidence from Kickstart, introduced by her Government, and from the future jobs fund, introduced by our Government, and the evidence is really quite strong. In trying to shape incentives, we are working on what we know works. The development of the youth guarantee was underpinned by that kind of evaluation and evidence. A DWP evaluation of work experience shows its high impact on employment prospects. For example, we have assessed the sector-based work programmes, which were found to be a really effective intervention.

Finally, we are evaluating the eight youth guarantee trailblazers and will use the learning from the different things happening around the country in different mayoral authorities to work out and inform the design of the youth guarantee as it goes forward. We are using evidence from the past, evidence we are gathering now and all that we are learning to make this the best it can be. This should be a national mission, and I am proud that we are doing something for it.