(1 day, 6 hours ago)
Lords Chamber
Lord Blencathra
To ask His Majesty’s Government what steps they are taking to improve farm profitability.
My Lords, in Farming Roadmap 2050, the Government set out their vision for a profitable farming sector. Since publication, we have already taken targeted action, including strengthening fairness in agricultural supply chains, expanding access to domestic and export markets and removing planning and regulatory barriers to investment. The Government are also investing in productivity, equipment and innovation, supporting farmers to reduce input costs through SFI and working with the sector to unlock investment and growth.
Lord Blencathra (Con)
My Lords. After the family farm tax, the SFI shambles, uncertainty over new agricultural technology like gene editing, which may be sold out to the EU, and a relentless growth in regulatory burdens, farmers have had quite enough government intervention. Farmers do not need another strategy, a road map or a working group. Is not the best way to improve farm profitability to stop overtaxing them, stop overregulating them, stop undercutting them with low-standard imports and stop changing the rules every year? I know the Minister gets it, but will she please try to get the message across to the rest of this Government that farmers are not a problem to be eradicated but the solution to food security, rural prosperity and environmental stewardship?
It is important that we have a long-term plan for farming in order to establish farming profitability. The farming road map sets a direction for agriculture that involves clearer, fairer routes to market and better access to the tools, technology, skills and supply chains that farmers need to run sustainable businesses. It also sets out clear roles for the state and for farmers. It looks at the wider sector to make the vision a reality and gives the sector confidence to grow their businesses. I suggest that, under the previous Government, farmers were not as profitable as they would have liked to have been.
Does the Minister agree that farm profitability cannot be fixed on the farm alone when the groceries code still covers only the 14 retailers with turnover above £1 billion, which misses out the processors and middlemen that most farmers sell to? Now that both adjudicators sit in Defra, will the Government combine them into one regulator and let bodies such as the NFU refer complaints without farmers fearing reprisals?
I am sure the noble Baroness is aware that we in Defra have been doing a lot of work to improve regulation and to make sure that they work more efficiently and better and are able to focus on what makes a difference. However, it is not just about the Groceries Code Adjudicator: we have been looking at the fair dealing rules that have already been introduced for dairy and pigs, and we are now working to bring in the same kind of systems for the egg, combinable crops and fresh produce sectors, which will make a difference.
My Lords, hedge funds profit from speculation on agricultural commodities without ever buying any physical quantities and farmers rarely benefit from it, while this form of gambling increases consumer prices, poverty and hunger. Can the Minister explain how the Government’s farming policy takes account of unrestrained speculation on agricultural commodities?
I suggest to my noble friend that the whole point of the farming road map, and the fact that the Government are pleased to be implementing much of the Batters review on profitability, is that we are looking at the big picture. That big picture will also include some of the issues he is concerned about, because we need to make sure that it works well for farmers and consumers so that we all have a reliable long-term supply of good, healthy, locally produced food.
My Lords, I declare my farming interests. It is clear that confidence remains extremely low and farmers are suffering losses, so the idea of profits is really the wrong word, I am afraid. In the Suffolk Chamber of Commerce survey, the question was, “What improvements would matter to businesses in rural and coastal areas in particular?” Some 88% of respondents said, “Better mobile and digital connectivity”, and that would make a big difference to business. I wonder what Defra and other departments are doing to co-ordinate this vital part of enhancing our infrastructure.
I completely agree with the noble Lord. As someone who lives in a very rural part of Cumbria, I know there are issues around connectivity, whether you are talking about internet speeds or phone signals. Where we are, we now have better broadband but no phone signal whatsoever, so there is still work to be done. It is important that this Government put so much emphasis on cross-departmental working, because another big challenge to rural profitability for businesses is better transport links, which we are also working to improve.
I was pleased to hear the Minister say that in the 10-year farming plan there is going to be an emphasis on rebuilding local. Can she give us examples of what that is going to look like? Will it mean mandatory procurement in schools, prisons and public buildings of local food? Will they be putting back abattoirs? Will there be different kinds of systems for land ownership, horticultural strategies and so on?
We are looking to invest more into horticulture. We see that as an important part of improving food security. It is really important, as well, that we look at how we can best address the loss of abattoirs, which is very complex. We are keen to support small abattoirs but there are skills issues, for example, as well as that of people wanting to work in abattoirs. It is a much bigger problem than just one of supporting abattoirs financially or giving them incentives, but we are looking at that. I know that the Department for Education is also looking at supporting rural schools. There is an awful lot that we need to get in place if rural communities and businesses are to have the right kind of support for the future.
The Lord Bishop of Norwich
My Lords, as a Church Commissioner I recently met Lucy Munns, one of our new entrant farmers on the Ely estate. Lucy is an ambitious young farmer who is caring for nature, but she missed out on the SFI grants. She is out on the land single-handed, with no one to run an office for her. Can the Minister confirm whether the SFI will reopen in 2027 and when the application dates will be announced? Will priority or an early application opportunity be given to farmers such as Lucy, who started applications but were unable to submit them before the previous window closed?
We plan to offer an SFI scheme in 2027. I cannot give the right reverend Prelate the date for when that will be, but we are working as quickly as we can to improve the offer for next year. We have been listening closely to farmers’ experiences since what happened in the last round, because it is really important that we improve the system so that we can make it work better for farmers who want to support SFI.
My Lords, countries such as France and the Netherlands show the power of agricultural co-operatives in helping farmers to pool resources, share risk and boost investment. Can my noble friend the Minister update us on what active steps the Government are taking to improve efficiency for farmers through co-operation?
We are keen to encourage farmers to co-operate, particularly smaller farmers who often find that purchasing equipment, for example, is very expensive. If you can bring people together, it makes it much more likely that we will get investment in the kind of innovation we want to see for the future. Working on co-operation for farmers is an important part of our approach.
My Lords, I declare my interest as a tenant farmer. Tenant farmers do not own their own land. They pay commercial rent to farm and are often unable to enter environmental schemes. Short-term agreements, restrictive tenancy conditions and difficult landlord and tenant relationships are all barriers that prevent tenant farmers investing and building viable businesses. Can the Minister tell me what steps the Government are taking to identify the changes needed to create a resilient, profitable and productive agricultural tenanted sector, including new land-use opportunities?
The noble Baroness puts her finger right on this when she talks about the length of tenancies. Longer-term tenancies are clearly extremely important if tenant farmers are to have security in their investments, because why would you invest if your tenancy is going to come to an end in two years? That is an important part of increasing productivity on tenanted farms. To give her some examples, Defra has been working with the National Estate for Nature group to capture and disseminate best practice models for longer-term tenancies. From that, some of its members, such as the Crown Estate and the Duchy of Cornwall, are already moving to 15-year-plus farm business tenancies. That is the absolute direction of travel we need to go in if we are to get that security and profitability for tenant farmers.