NHS Plan: Consultation

Monday 2nd December 2024 Lords Chamber

Question

14:48

Asked by

[The Lord Bishop of London]

To ask His Majesty’s Government what steps they are taking to ensure the consultation for the NHS 10 Year Plan reaches all communities, including those who have least interaction with the health service.

[The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health and Social Care (Baroness Merron) (Lab)]

My Lords, we want to ensure that the voices and experiences of patients are at the heart of our plans to make the NHS fit for the future, especially those voices that often go unheard. We are working with charities, faith groups, health and care providers, local government and others to ensure that we hear from those that national government often fails to reach. We will monitor this closely and target underrepresented groups before the engagement exercise concludes in spring 2025.

[The Lord Bishop of London]

I thank the Minister for her reply, and I am encouraged by the Government’s consultation on the NHS 10-year plan. However, does she agree with me that, if we are to move from sickness to prevention, any engagement ICBs have with their communities has to be long term and systematic? If so, what are the Government doing to resource ICBs to make sure that their engagement with communities is long term and systematic?

[Baroness Merron (Lab)]

I agree with the right reverend Prelate. Integrated care systems, which are responsible for reflecting the needs of the community and its spending, must follow guidance, and it is important that we identify the seldom-heard groups. We have built into the consultation plans a “workshop in a box”—a toolkit to support discussion in local communities, which ICBs are rolling out. It is a good way of encouraging ICBs to talk directly to local communities.

[Baroness Coussins (CB)]

My Lords, will the consultation be published in languages other than English, with proactive efforts to encourage responses from people whose first language is not English? Secondly, will the department make sure that it consults with public service interpreters working in NHS settings?

[Baroness Merron (Lab)]

I can confirm that both the online portal and the “workshop in a box” to which I just referred will be available in easy read and British Sign Language versions, and in other languages. Attention has been given to those for whom English is not their first language; in-person events can be tailored to their needs—for example, by having smaller groups. The staff to whom the noble Baroness refers are a major group being asked to provide input; indeed, they are taking part in online workshops and can respond online.

[Baroness Pitkeathley (Lab)]

My Lords, does my noble friend the Minister agree that one of the groups that sometimes finds it difficult to interact with health service professionals is unpaid carers? Despite the huge contribution that they make, they often have their needs ignored by those providing services. Does she therefore agree that it is very important that the voice of the unpaid carer is heard in the consultation process?

[Baroness Merron (Lab)]

I agree with my noble friend: we have to hear from unpaid carers, because that will strengthen the exercise. We are constantly monitoring which groups are responding and which are not, and that allows us to tailor our approach to the underrepresented groups who are not coming forward. If that includes unpaid carers, the consultation absolutely will make special, tailored efforts to reach them.

[Lord Scriven (LD)]

My Lords, the life expectancy of people with learning disabilities is, on average, 20 years less than the general population’s. Research has shown that a major contributor to this is a lack of access to appropriate healthcare. What will the Minister do to ensure that this group of people will be not only consulted but listened to, and that the 10-year plan will provide appropriate services tailored to them?

[Baroness Merron (Lab)]

This is indeed one of the groups for whom we need to ensure absolute inclusion. As I mentioned, the work with integrated care systems will be particularly helpful in running the workshop. We train organisations to work with it, and it is designed so that it is easy to use. It can be used in events to reach the seldom-heard voices in communities, including those with learning disabilities. It is vital that we hear from them as we design an NHS fit for everybody for the future.

[Lord Turnberg (Lab)]

My Lords, one of the biggest causes of inequality is where you live in the country. If you live in the north-east or north-west, you live two, three or four years less than if you live in the south-west or south-east. Far fewer resources are available for people in those deprived areas: there are fewer doctors, nurses, physios, dentists and so on. What can the Government do to redress this gross imbalance?

[Baroness Merron (Lab)]

My noble friend allows me to say—and I hope your Lordships’ House will agree with this—that our approach will of course focus on addressing the social determinants of health. The goal will be to halve the gap in healthy life expectancy between the richest and the poorest regions. We are not just going to be moving from sickness to prevention as one of our three pillars, important though that is; we are also seeking, across government, to address the root causes of health inequalities. Again, that is being highlighted as part of the consultation.

[Lord Bailey of Paddington (Con)]

What special efforts will be made to speak to young people, who are often very far away from the health system—those leaving care, those who have just left prison and those from very poor communities? What effort will be made to hear their voices? They are often far away from the NHS because they do not need it yet, but they will in the future.

[Baroness Merron (Lab)]

I thank the noble Lord. Yesterday, I was at an in-person event in Folkestone, and as with all such events up and down the country, it had used systems to find a wide range of people, including young people, who, as he rightly says, are often unlinked with the health service. I emphasise our continued monitoring and our efforts to reach the groups he speaks of. So far, we know that men, those aged under 35, and black Asian and black British people have engaged least with Change NHS. We are now stepping up our efforts.

[Baroness Winterton of Doncaster (Lab)]

My Lords, will my noble friend the Minister look at the role that pharmacists might play in any consultation? While they may not be an obvious source of reaching out, they are embedded in communities and talk to patients and users frequently. If they could be harnessed, it would much improve the consultation.

[Baroness Merron (Lab)]

I am very grateful to all those, including pharmacists, who have used all their networks and contacts to spread the word. That is why we have had over 60,000 responses and more than 1 million visits in what is the largest ever consultation in the history of the NHS. I call on all groups to continue their efforts to ensure that voices across all communities are heard loud and clear.

[Lord Kamall (Con)]

During the vaccine programmes for Covid, the NHS and the last Government put a lot of effort into looking at ways to reach people who are vaccine hesitant—often from some black and Asian communities and other excluded communities. What lessons have been learned by the Government and the NHS to ensure that the consultation on the 10-year plan reaches as many people as possible from these communities, so that their voices are heard?

[Baroness Merron (Lab)]

The lessons that have been learned are that there has to be a whole range of ways of consulting: in person around the country; online, where people can access the website; and through toolkits such as the “workshop in a box”. As I mentioned in an earlier answer, the consultation also needs to be tailored to the needs of those who need to speak up. We are asking the public, staff and organisations what is important, and we want, as the Prime Minister said, their fingerprints all over the 10-year plan.

[Baroness Bull (CB)]

My Lords, people living with homelessness often have chronic and multiple health needs which go untreated, and they are also more vulnerable to substance misuse. Appreciating the difficulty, what are the Government doing to ensure that the needs of people living with homelessness are addressed and heard through this consultation?

[Baroness Merron (Lab)]

We have identified those who are homeless as one of the specific seldom-heard groups, and that is why we are working so closely with integrated care systems: to ensure that we reach them on their territory. The other groups include, for example, sex workers, young people, those with learning disabilities and some ethnic minorities.