Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
Visitor Levy (England) Bill Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateVikki Slade
Main Page: Vikki Slade (Liberal Democrat - Mid Dorset and North Poole)Department Debates - View all Vikki Slade's debates with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
(2 days, 2 hours ago)
Commons ChamberI am sad to say that some of the ways that the Government are framing this tax are completely at odds with the reality of the Bill. We are told that the tax is part of the Government’s fiscal devolution programme, which will put decision making back in the hands of local communities and local people, who know their area best, yet this Bill gives mayors in strategic authorities, like those in the north-east, the power to introduce the tax regardless of the views of local people.
In South Shields, not a single bed and breakfast, caravan park or hotel owner I have spoken to is in favour of this tax. The local councillors are not in favour either, and neither am I as the MP, yet our views can be completely disregarded, and the tax can be imposed on our area whether we like it or not. We will also not have any decision-making powers when it comes to setting the tax, any subsequent increases, where and what it will be spent on, or whether there should be exemptions for carers, armed forces personnel, those visiting relatives in hospital, and so on.
Vikki Slade (Mid Dorset and North Poole) (LD)
A couple of years ago, before I entered this place, I worked with businesses in Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole on an accommodation business improvement district, which was our way of looking at this issue. Unfortunately, the ABID was blocked by the Secretary of State on an administrative technicality. That scheme was led by the business sector. It was only for hotels of a certain size, and it was designed by business to benefit the sector. Would the hon. Lady support amending the Bill to guarantee that the voice of business is heard in decision-making, instead of decisions being in the hands of a mayor?
The hon. Lady pre-empts what I will say later. That is roughly the model in place in Manchester and Liverpool.
This is not devolution; it is the centralisation of decision making in the hands of regional mayors. The hospitality industry, despite already carrying the highest tax burden in the UK, will be responsible for collecting and administering this tax, and the Bill outlines the criminal sanctions that businesses can expect to face if they do not do it properly.
Tourists in South Shields are largely from neighbouring regions and other parts of the UK. Families save all year round to visit our award-winning beaches, our fun fair and the Leas, which is the finish of the Great North Run. They come to learn more about our rich history, Souter lighthouse, our Roman fort and, of course, the inventor of the lifeboat, my great-great-great-grandad. They come for so much more, and what keeps them coming back is our warm hospitality. We are a fun, friendly bunch who are rightly fiercely proud of our little part of the north-east.
The introduction of this tax, even at £2 a person per night, would increase the cost of a week-long stay for a family of four by £56. That is a lot of money. The Government have acknowledged that the tax could push up the price of a holiday for Britons and force them abroad. The knock-on effect, not only for my local accommodation providers but for the wider hospitality industry in South Shields, will be devastating. We are not comparable to Barcelona, Amsterdam, Venice and other European holiday hotspots. In fact, some of those destinations have introduced a similar tax to curb tourism. They also have much lower VAT than we do. If we are going to introduce European taxes, we should introduce European VAT as well.
In Manchester and Liverpool, the tax is operated by the businesses in a defined geographical area, and any revenue spend is agreed by an established board of those businesses. That approach is not as heavy-handed as what the Government are proposing in this Bill, and it puts the industry, which knows its businesses best, at the forefront of decision making. In other areas of the UK where the tax has been introduced, it has been in operation for only a short time. It is at a fixed rate, and there is clear guidance about what the revenue must be spent on. It is also worth noting that so far, the tax has largely been introduced for cities only, but under this Bill, entire regions can have it imposed on them, with no exempt areas.