Rare Retinal Disease

Siobhain McDonagh Excerpts

Thursday 23rd January 2025 Westminster Hall

[Shockat Adam (Leicester South) (Ind)]

What a pleasure it is to serve under your chairmanship, Dame Siobhan. In my time in the House I have written speeches for Westminster Hall that are five, six or seven minutes long, but by time I get here the Chair always tells me that I have a minute, so I only wrote a minute-long speech.

[Dame Siobhain McDonagh (in the Chair)]

The hon. Gentleman can go on for as long as he likes.

[Shockat Adam]

The hon. Member for Strangford (Jim Shannon) said, “Do what I do and expand it.” This subject is extremely important, and I am so grateful for the hon. Gentleman for bringing it to this Chamber.

Imagine a mother-to-be sitting on a consulting room chair. Her excitement at becoming a mother has been overshadowed by the news that she has been diagnosed with Stargardt disease. It is literally a race against time: will the child be born or will the sight be lost? Imagine a young boy who has expressed his ambition to become a rugby player for England, only for a cursory investigation at the back of the eye to detect retinitis pigmentosa. Unfortunately for me, that was my reality as an optometrist. I faced such heartbreaking cases regularly in my profession.

Rare retinal diseases such as retinitis pigmentosa, Stargardt disease and Leber congenital amaurosis, among many others, are individually rare but collectively very significant. They devastate and destroy lives. The hon. Member for Strangford mentioned Chris, the victor of “Strictly Come Dancing”; he shows the potential of the majority of people with sight loss, but unfortunately that is not the reality for most—their lives are destroyed, their independence is taken and opportunities at work are limited.

The UK Government have committed to tackling rare diseases through initiatives such as the UK rare diseases framework, which aims to improve diagnosis, raise awareness and enhance the access to specialist care. Additionally, a new action plan is set to be released in 2025, showing promise for further progress. But commitments need to translate into tangible action.

Furthermore, we need regulatory bodies such as NICE to play a pivotal role. I fully appreciate NICE’s work to ensure that the quality and safety of treatments can never be compromised—those principles are non-negotiable —but to encourage innovation, NICE must proactively engage with pharmaceutical and medical companies to work collaboratively to establish best practices. Such dialogue will signal to companies that their commitment to researching rare diseases, which costs millions, will be met with the potential for reward. This will ensure that patients can benefit from cutting-edge advancements without delay. As the hon. Member for Strangford said, short-term investment in research and treatment for rare retinal diseases will deliver long-term financial benefits, to the tune of £600 million. It will also reduce lifelong healthcare costs and empower patients to live independent, productive lives.

The eyes are indeed the window of the soul, but they are also the window to our health. So many health conditions are detected in the eyes, and rare retinal conditions can lead to the early detection of other health conditions, such as Behçet’s disease and so many others. We are thankfully on the brink of transformative breakthroughs. Gene therapies such as Luxturna, which is a virus vector-based medication, along with AI-driven early detection and advancements in stem cell research, offer real hope. By supporting those innovations with funding and adaptable regulations, we can bring life-changing treatments to those who need them most.

This is about not just heath but equity and humanity. Without action, we will condemn families to live in the shadow of irreversible loss, because if a person has sight loss, it affects the whole family. With action, we can rewrite their stories and give them hope and vision. Let us act now for that mother, that young boy and the thousands like them. Sight is not a privilege: it is a right.

--- Later in debate ---

[The Minister for Secondary Care (Karin Smyth)]

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Dame Siobhan. I start by thanking the hon. Member for Strangford (Jim Shannon) for securing this debate on such an important issue and other Members for their contributions.

Both the shadow Secretary of State and I are covering for other colleagues this afternoon, so hon. Members can imagine my joy when actual experts walked into the Chamber. The hon. Members for Leicester South (Shockat Adam) and for Torbay (Steve Darling), as has been said, bring great personal and professional expertise to this debate, so it was joyful to see them come in. It was good to hear from my hon. Friend the Member for Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme (Lee Pitcher); the experience he brings through his wife is really valuable. My hon. Friend the Member for Battersea (Marsha De Cordova) has been such a champion of this issue both in her personal experience and since she came to the House. I understand that it is her birthday today, so I hope she is having a good time. She has brought great expertise to this place.

I am going to do my best to answer the questions. I have been billed highly by the hon. Member for Strangford, and I am grateful for that. The Under-Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, my hon. Friend the Member for Gorton and Denton (Andrew Gwynne), will write to hon. Members about anything that is outstanding.

I would like to take time to acknowledge the experiences of those living with rare inherited retinal diseases and their families, who I know will be paying attention to this debate. I pay tribute to all those who work tirelessly to raise awareness of rare conditions and bring about change. Although rare diseases are rare individually, their impacts are far-reaching. One in 17 people will be affected by a rare condition over their lifetime; that is around 3.5 million people in the United Kingdom. As the hon. Member for Strangford said, rare inherited retinal diseases affect around 25,000 people in the UK and collectively represent a leading cause of sight loss in working-age adults. We recognise the impact that these conditions have on patients, families and wider society and the need for innovative approaches to tackle these changes.

The Government are committed to improving the lives of people with rare conditions. The hon. Member for Torbay used that quote about providing opportunity, support and determination for people. The UK rare diseases framework outlines four priorities to achieve this aim: helping patients get a final diagnosis faster; increasing awareness of rare diseases among healthcare professionals; better co-ordination of care; and improving access to specialist care treatment and drugs. In England, our annual rare diseases action plan sets out the steps we are taking to meet those priorities. We continue to make progress and are working to finalise our next England action plan for publication this year.

It is vital that NHS patients with rare diseases are able to access innovative new treatments as they become available. That includes those with progressive retinal diseases, where early intervention is crucial to preserve sight. Under England’s action plans, NICE, the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency and NHS England are working to understand and address the barriers to access for rare diseases treatment. The hon. Member for Strangford asked a number of questions about NICE’s approach that I hope I will cover. NICE does a difficult job well, in my view, and we think its approach is appropriate for the evaluation of treatments for rare diseases. NICE recommended 84% of medicines for rare diseases evaluated through its standard technology appraisal programme in 2023-24. That is comparable to its approval rate for medicines for more common conditions. Those treatments are now available for the treatment of NHS patients.

NICE also operates a separate, highly specialised technology programme for the evaluation of a handful of medicines for very rare diseases each year that recognises the challenges of bringing treatments for very rare diseases to market. NICE recommended the gene therapy Luxturna for a type of inherited retinal dystrophy through that route. One of the recipients of that groundbreaking therapy on the NHS has spoken of his gratitude for the positive effects of the treatment on not just his vision, but his confidence and independence.

NICE is also in the process of reviewing the criteria for routing topics to its highly specialised technologies programme, which the hon. Member for Strangford asked about. That review will ensure that future routing decisions are more transparent, consistent, efficient and predictable. As part of that process, NICE has launched a public consultation on its progress. I encourage the rare diseases community and hon. Members interested to continue to engage with that process.

Research offers a way to accelerate access to new and innovative treatments. Through the National Institute for Health and Care Research, the Government support rare diseases research. There are currently eight active research projects on rare retinal disease funded by the NIHR, with a combined value of over £6 million. The NIHR also invests in infrastructure to support and deliver research studies. The NIHR Moorfields Biomedical Research Centre, which is dedicated solely to vision research, has made significant strides in the field of rare retinal diseases. By harnessing genomic data, the BRC has developed effective treatments, including gene-replacement therapies for inherited retinal disorders. The NIHR is also working closely with commercial companies to bring new medicines and technology to patients.

To connect people living with rare diseases to innovative treatments and sources of support, we need to diagnose these conditions as early as possible. The UK is a world leader in genomic diagnosis. Patients in England have access to whole genome sequencing on the NHS. Advances in genomics mean that new causes of rare retinal diseases are being found every year. As part of Genomics England’s generation study, we are harnessing the power of genomic sequencing to screen for over 200 rare genetic conditions that can be treated in the NHS in early childhood to improve outcomes for babies and their families. That includes the rare retinal disease RPE65-associated Leber congenital amaurosis, which can be treated with Luxturna.

A central mission of this Government is to build a health and care system fit for the future. The 10-year health plan will ensure a better health service for everyone, regardless of condition or service area. The plan will focus on our three shifts for a modern NHS: moving from hospital to community, analogue to digital and sickness to prevention. All three offer opportunities to improve time to diagnosis and care for people living with rare retinal conditions. The shift from analogue to digital will enable innovative uses of data to improve diagnosis and measure treatment outcomes, while NHS ocular genetics services’ use of video consultations continues to widen patient access to specialist advice, in keeping with the shift from hospital to community. Although many rare diseases are not preventable, early diagnosis, as we have heard, can lead to timely interventions that improve health outcomes.

I will outline the treatment pathway for rare retinal diseases. I am thankful for the role played by high street optometrists, some of them here today, in helping to identify patients with sight-threatening conditions. There is good availability of NHS sight-testing services, with over 12 million free NHS sight tests provided to eligible groups annually, including children, individuals aged 60 and over, and those on income-related benefits. Optometrists are required to refer any patient showing signs of injury, disease or abnormality and integrated care boards have been asked to ensure that there are direct referral pathways in place between community optometry and secondary care. As the hon. Member for Leicester South said, the eyes are the gateway into other health conditions. Optometry has a very important role.

As one of the busiest outpatient specialties with one of the largest waiting lists, we know that ophthalmology is facing huge challenges and we are working hard on how we can help to build capacity. NHS England is looking at how digital connectivity could improve the triage of patients referred between primary and secondary care. That would allow for images to be shared, and specialist advice and guidance could help to keep patients in the community where possible.

We recognise the importance of access to emotional and practical support, especially where treatment may not be available. A diagnosis of sight loss will have a profound impact on any individual, who will be at increased risk of stress, anxiety and depression. NHS England’s patient support toolkit for eye care commissioners and providers aims to ensure that patients with ophthalmic conditions or sight loss are supported throughout their care journeys. The RNIB patient support pathway aims to strengthen that and ensure that support and guidance are available to patients from their first eye care appointment through to having a confirmed diagnosis, and then right the way through to living well with their condition. I know that the work of the all-party parliamentary group on eye health and visual impairment and of other hon. Members will help in giving those people a powerful voice.

As we work towards building a health care service fit for the future, it is vital that people living with rare diseases are not left behind. With the UK rare diseases framework coming to an end in 2026, we will look to build on the progress made over the past five years, which the shadow Secretary of State mentioned. We will work with colleagues in the devolved Administrations, as highlighted by the hon. Member for Strangford.

We have commissioned an evaluation of England’s rare diseases action plans through NIHR and will also be undertaking engagement this year to inform future policy decisions. The Government are deeply committed to working across the health and social care system and with the rare diseases community to improve the lives of those with rare conditions.

Once again, I thank the hon. Member for Strangford for raising this important matter. It is good to have high interest, expertise and experience in this place. We want to work with colleagues here and we thank the rare disease community for their valuable ongoing engagement with us to bring about meaningful change.

[Dame Siobhain McDonagh (in the Chair)]

Order. I will now put—[Interruption.]

[Jim Shannon]

rose—

[Dame Siobhain McDonagh (in the Chair)]

Oh, I am sorry; I nearly denied the hon. Member for Strangford his right to sum up. I apologise. I would never wish to silence him.

[Jim Shannon]

I know we are all anxious to get away, Dame Siobhain. So am I, by the way—I have a plane to catch.

Can I say a big thank you to everyone who took part in the debate? The hon. Member for Leicester South (Shockat Adam) brought up the personal stories of the mum who was expecting and did not realise that she was going to end up with this disease and of the young boy who wanted to be a rugby star when unfortunately that was not going to happen. Those are reminders of what the disease does and I thank him for that. I note that he is an optometrist; I did not know that he did that before he came here, but now I do and I thank him for it. The Minister was right in saying that the talent and information brought to the Chamber has helped us to move forward. The hon. Member for Leicester South also discussed gene therapy and said that the eyes are the window to health. Again, I thank him for that significant contribution.

The hon. Member for Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme (Lee Pitcher) brought us the personal story of his wife, and what they live with every day. Stories of family members are sometimes forgotten; they are doing something for someone and there is a personal story about how the rest of the family is affected.

The shadow Secretary of State was right that the hon. Member for Torbay (Steve Darling) brings many things to this Chamber outside of health issues. When he speaks there on the front row, we take knowledge; we are always reminded by that wee bell that rings that he is here. We all know. I thank him for that and for his knowledge, which is so important.

The shadow Secretary of State and I have been together in many debates over the years. This subject is important and interesting and he was right to thank the hon. Member for Battersea (Marsha De Cordova). I should have done so; apologies. He is right that she has been a leader and a champion when it comes to eye trauma. By the way, I did not know that the work place most dangerous for the eyes was the garden. That was news to me. I will not talk about my endeavours with a chainsaw; they were scary, although I have survived. The shadow Secretary of State also mentioned regular eye tests, early diagnosis, treatment, research, affordable solutions, the UK rare diseases network and the degree of concern.

I thank the Minister. It may come easy or not so easy, but the hon. Lady always endeavours to give a response on the issues, whether her direct responsibility or not. Today she has done that. She referred to this as a far reaching issue and said that the Government are committed to the rare diseases framework, to faster diagnosis and to the new treatment Luxturna. Right away, she was able to tell us that some people have got that and are feeling the benefit. Those are the pluses that come out of these debates. The Government are committed to research and development and the UK is a leader in genomics. She referred to the treatment pathway and also to ensuring that those with rare retinal disease not being left behind. That is a message we all appreciate. Today the debate has done that, and the Minister has done it well.

[Dame Siobhain McDonagh (in the Chair)]

I apologise again to the hon. Member for Strangford.

Question put and agreed to.

Resolved, 

That this House has considered innovation in the field of rare retinal disease.