Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
Visitor Levy (England) Bill Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateScott Arthur
Main Page: Scott Arthur (Labour - Edinburgh South West)Department Debates - View all Scott Arthur's debates with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
(2 days, 3 hours ago)
Commons ChamberThat is precisely why local areas will be able to decide on the percentage of the levy and how they will reinvest it. We believe that people with skin in the game in their local area will understand the issues that affect their local towns, whether they are in coastal areas or other areas, and they will be able to implement the levy appropriately. We need to shift power so that local leaders can collect and spend tax revenue on what the region wants; mayors such as Oliver Coppard in South Yorkshire can decide whether to implement the levy and spend that tax revenue on what the region wants.
Regional government knows what local priorities are. This is about a partnership in which we as a Government support regional government to deliver what is needed. We are therefore overhauling how regional government is funded, starting with a new power to introduce the overnight visitor levy. That will mean that if local leaders can grow their tourism economy, they will have more to spend on local priorities. It brings us in line with many of the world’s major cities for tourism, including New York and Paris, where evidence shows that the levy works.
Dr Scott Arthur (Edinburgh South West) (Lab)
Along with New York and Paris, my right hon. Friend could have mentioned Edinburgh. Will she join me in congratulating Jane Meagher and Margaret Graham, who are both Labour councillors? They introduced the UK’s first tourist tax—as it is called in Edinburgh—or transit visitor levy. It is going to raise £50 million a year, and through consulting with local people, that money is going to get spent on parks, homes, public toilets and city centre policing.
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. This is not something new; it happens around the world. I congratulate those who have come forward with schemes earlier, because this levy will have a profound effect on local areas, enabling them to do the things they want to do.
Rebecca Paul
We should be looking broadly at the tax burden on businesses and ensuring that we reduce the tax load across the levels.
Within a week of Edinburgh introducing its holiday tax in July, accommodation providers were reporting cancellations, with the Association of Scotland’s Self-Caterers describing the situation as “little short of shambolic”. The Scottish Tourism Alliance has since warned that the administrative costs of correcting incorrectly calculated bills could run into millions of pounds. Perhaps most shocking of all, Scottish Ballet has cancelled planned performances in Edinburgh between Christmas and the new year, as the levy compounds already soaring accommodation costs for cast and crew members. The Edinburgh International Festival says that the tax is costing it an additional £50,000 a year. Imagine that, Madam Deputy Speaker—a tax that is supposedly intended to support the visitor economy is making it more expensive to stage the very cultural events that attract visitors in the first place!
Rebecca Paul
I will make a little progress, otherwise I will be here all night. Obviously, on my birthday, I would love to be here all night, but I am sure that everyone will want me to sit down at some point.
Scotland is providing us with a cautionary tale. Why on earth is Labour so determined to repeat its mistakes? The wider economic evidence that we have is also deeply concerning. Research conducted by Oxford Economics modelled the potential consequences of a 5% visitor levy across England. It estimated that by 2030, such a levy could result in £1.8 billion less tourism spending, a £2.2 billion reduction in GDP, and almost 33,000 fewer jobs than would otherwise be supported. The levy is also expected to wipe out nearly £700 million of existing tax revenues as a result of reduced activity. Of particular interest is separate research commissioned by Haven, examining the potential impact of a visitor levy in East Lothian, a Scottish coastal area that is heavily dependent on domestic tourism. This assessment, by Lichfields, estimates that a 5% levy—6% when VAT is included—could result in about 32,000 fewer visitors every year, £19 million less visitor spending, and 190 fewer direct tourism jobs.
All this involves a significant cost to the public purse: VAT on the lost visitor spend, income tax and national insurance on the lost jobs, and the cost of welfare for those who are now out of work—this adds up to millions of pounds lost. And how much do the Government expect the levy to raise every year if they go ahead? Just £1.2 million. All that effort and cost for so little, and there will likely be similar stories in many parts of England if the Bill is passed. Let me ask the Government this: what is the total cost of this levy to the Treasury when we take into account lost tax revenue, lost jobs, closed businesses and other impacts? I urge the Government to do their sums on this one before proceeding further, so that they can reassure the House about the expected net benefit or, more likely, cost, at both a regional and a national level.
Dr Arthur
The East Lothian example is pertinent, because East Lothian does not have a tourist tax. It can choose not to have one, and perhaps it has done so on the basis of the analysis mentioned by the hon. Lady. Edinburgh chamber of commerce found that 70% of businesses supported a tourist tax. Last week, the council decided to pedestrianise George Street, partly by using tourist tax money. That will help the cafés, restaurants and shops in that street, and guess what? They support it. Are they wrong?
Rebecca Paul
They may well find that there are lost jobs, and that, as a result, they cannot enjoy that spending. However, as the hon. Gentleman has said, the council has a choice, and I hope that it takes the report into account and decides not to go ahead.
Make no mistake: this is not a popular policy. According to a survey of more than 10,000 adults, only 24% support it. Nearly three quarters said that it would cause them to reduce, or spend less on, holidays in England, or stop taking them altogether, and 39% said that it would make them more likely to holiday abroad instead. This is a policy that encourages Brits to go overseas for their holidays, rather than staying at home and supporting British hospitality and business. However, the levy does not just have an impact on tourists; the effects are much broader than that.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker.
“Most people won’t even notice a tiny little bit extra”.
That is what the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government said earlier today. A “couple of quid”, someone said; “don’t shed crocodile tears” said another. Those comments are completely out of touch. We are living through an affordability crisis where people are finding life very, very tough in the real world. Bills are going up—food bills in particular—rents are rising, and mortgages are going to go up next year. The cost of taking a family away on holiday is going up and up and up, and many people are worried and concerned about whether they will be able to afford just a few nights away.
We are not talking about staying in four or five-star hotels, or about international business travellers staying in corporate hotels. We are talking about whether a family from Nottinghamshire can go on a caravan holiday in Cleethorpes. Can they go camping? Can they go to a small B&B in the Peak district or the Derbyshire dales? Can a school party go to a youth hostel? Is that too much to ask? No, of course it isn’t. But at the moment it is hard. Why in these circumstances, why at this time, would anyone consider making it more difficult to take the kids away on holiday? It is not a crime to go on holiday with your family, yet this policy is going to make it just that little bit harder.
On top of that, the change comes at a time when the hospitality sector is being battered by rising energy bills, employer national insurance and changes to the minimum wage, with thousands of jobs being lost, predominantly among the young. Why would anyone make the business of hospitality more difficult at a time like this, when it is facing probably the greatest crisis in modern times? Pubs are closing. Hotels are shutting. This is a tough time—we all know it—so why are we doing this?
There is rising unemployment—next year, unemployment is set to increase. What are we most concerned about with unemployment? It is youth unemployment, and yet which sector of our economy is both most labour intensive and employs the most young people proportionally? It is hospitality. Why are we doing this at this time, of any? It does not make any sense.
This is not just a “tiny little bit extra”, as the Secretary of State said. UKHospitality estimates that this move will add £100 to a typical family break. Well, maybe £100 does not mean that much to us in this place, but it means a hell of a lot to millions of families out there in the real world. Why are we doing this to everyone? If we are going to go down this road, why do we not just do it to those coming from overseas—to foreign visitors to this country—rather than to Brits, who just want to have a holiday in our own country and support the domestic economy? It does not make any sense.
The truth is that the holiday tax has always been a bad idea. It has been knocking around for years. Its two principal proponents were the Conservative former Mayor of the West Midlands, Andy Street, and the now Prime Minister when he was the Labour Mayor of Greater Manchester. It was knocked back time and again by a succession of Chancellors as a bad, out-of-touch idea, but this Prime Minister and this Chancellor have decided to go ahead with it. It will pummel hospitality, it will increase unemployment, it will increase youth unemployment, and it will harm the cost of living, at the worst possible moment.
The holiday tax will be an administrative nightmare. There are 260,000 short-stay hosts, just to give an example of one aspect of the hospitality sector. Each of them, in one form or another, will be responsible for paying the tax. Imagine what that means for someone who owns an Airbnb: most of the bookings are done through website, but perhaps there are a few repeat direct bookings over the telephone or by email. That person will suddenly have to sign up with His Majesty’s Revenue and Customs to pay the tax. And if they forget? Well, maybe they get 14 years in jail—that is not disproportionate, is it? It is completely ridiculous.
The proposal is not comparable with what has happened in Europe. As we have already heard during the debate, most comparable European countries have lower rates of VAT than we have here in the United Kingdom, so we are not comparing apples with apples. Many of the overseas cities, like Venice and Amsterdam, that have implemented such taxes specifically want to reduce the number of tourists. Maybe there are some cities or communities in this country that want fewer tourists, but I challenge hon. Members to name them—I don’t know any! Certainly my constituents want more people to come to their B&Bs, their hotels and their caravan sites. They do not want to limit the number of people, but when something is taxed, demand is reduced and it becomes less attractive.
Dr Arthur
I am sure the hospitality businesses in Newark want the local authority to do more to attract people to that economy—to spend money there and support those businesses. Does the right hon. Gentleman accept that if the proceeds of a well-run tourist tax are invested in the local tourist economy in Newark, it could actually help those businesses? That is the model in Edinburgh. It is about people coming more often, staying longer and spending more money because there is more to do in the city.
No, I just want my businesses to be competitive, and I want working people to be able to afford to go on holiday. Is that too much to ask for? Maybe that is the big divide across this Chamber.
Some of the suggestions that we have heard today are obviously ridiculous. “Let’s employ a ‘visitor economy consultant.’” Just imagine how much that would cost! Sadiq Khan, the Mayor of London, seems to be a specialist in those. Remember Amy Lamé, his night-time economy adviser, who earned hundreds of thousands of pounds and managed to crush the night-time economy, closing nightclubs and bars in central London? We do not need more quangos. We do not need more bureaucrats. We just need to be able to take our kids on holiday.
This money will obviously be spent on mayors’ vanity projects. The former Mayor of the West of England, Dan Norris, spent £10,000 on bus decorations featuring himself and his dog, and he offered people a free bus journey on their birthday. Sadiq Khan spent £200,000 on Pride last year. Boris Johnson spent £43 million on the garden bridge, which was never built. There was the £340,000 that the Greater Manchester combined authority spent on EY3 Media—mysteriously, the same publicity agents who worked for our now Prime Minister’s election campaign in Makerfield.
We all know that this money will be wasted. It will be robbed from the pockets of working people just trying to take their kids away on holiday. We in Reform will oppose this measure every step of the way. We will vote against it tonight. Reform mayors have vowed never to implement it in our areas, so if people want to avoid this tax, they should go on holiday to a Reform area. They should go to Skegness or Cleethorpes: their holidays will be cheaper and better. If we are lucky enough to form the next Government, we will scrap the tax altogether.
Thank you, Madam Deputy Speaker, for allowing me to catch your eye as a late entrant to this debate. As I made a late entrance, I will put only a few brief comments on the record. I will disappoint the Minister by not offering her any free hotel rooms to encourage her to come to my area. The Cotswolds are one of the most important leisure, tourism and hospitality areas in the country. Everybody knows the beautiful countryside, the hospitality and the various attractions of the Cotswolds—they do not need to be reminded of them.
I view this proposal as a tax—it is not a levy; it is a tax—and the sad thing about it is that it is going to tax some of the poorest people in the country. A family of four going to a modest bed and breakfast for seven days are likely to pay £150, which is probably the difference between going on holiday and not, because they are so squeezed on their cost of living. It is a very unfortunate tax, I have to say.
I have heard arguments from Labour Members, one after the other, who say that they need this tourist tax to be able to improve their areas so that more tourists will come. Actually, the local authority should want to improve the area without a tourist tax. It should be devoting sufficient tax to make the area litter-free, make the lights attractive and cut the verges—all the things that attract tourists to the Cotswolds—without a tourist levy.
Dr Arthur
Too often, local authorities do not have the resources to deal with the extra impact of mass tourism. I do not know about the hon. Gentleman’s constituency, but many do not have the resources and do not benefit economically from tourists coming into the area. The tourist tax will help them make their places even better for tourists to come, so that people can be proud to welcome them to litter-free streets—and perhaps pothole-free roads as well.
The logical impact of what the hon. Gentleman suggests is that we clobber poor people and discourage foreign visitors from coming to this country by imposing a tax on them. The reverse should be the case. We should want businesses to thrive and make a profit, but they have been clobbered by this Government: they have been clobbered by extra taxes on jobs, by inheritance taxes on their businesses and by employment regulations. They have been clobbered by all sorts of things by this Government.
The tourism, leisure and hospitality sector is internationally sensitive. Whether people come to an area is very price-sensitive, and if we start making our hospitality more expensive, foreign visitors at the margin will simply not come and our tourist business will go down and down—it is happening already.
I have indeed had similar representations, and I would be amazed if hon. Members on the Government Benches have not had similar ones. Some of them have spoken up on behalf of those constituents, but others have chosen to put their head in the sand and pretend that this is not happening.
Oxford Economics has warned that a 5% levy could cost 33,000 jobs and cut visitor spending by £1.7 billion. Ministers can challenge those figures if they like, but the Government have not published an impact assessment. Why such a lack of candour about the impact on jobs and the economy, I wonder. Did they listen to the representations to their own consultation, which concluded that
“a visitor levy could reduce holiday affordability, deter overnight stays or encourage UK travellers to choose destinations abroad”?
When all tourism areas are trying to extend day trips and encourage more overnight stays and visitors all year round, that is a damning verdict on Labour’s holiday tax.
I think I will return to the point that has been made by the shadow Secretary of State and other hon. Members: we need to look at the other tax rates within those countries, including the higher VAT and business rates.
Importantly, this tax is not just going to hit people going on holiday. Research for Airbnb has found that British patients and families spend over 600,000 nights a year away from home in private accommodation for medical reasons. How can the Government justify this tax being faced by people travelling for medical treatment or to care for their sick child or family member?
Businesses will also face higher costs, through the 5 million business trips a year. Why are Labour Mayors so keen to hit the electricians, the plumbers, the fit-out engineers and the sales reps who typically stay overnight mid-week in budget accommodation? Far from cutting the cost of business, the Chancellor is loading on more costs, just like his predecessor did. He is loading more costs on to hard-working families, just like his predecessor did—and the people working in the hospitality and tourism sector, particularly those young people wanting that first opportunity in rural and coastal areas, will suffer the most.
A repeated theme of the debate has been which types of accommodation will be covered. As it stands, the Bill includes all short-term visitor overnight accommodation: hotels, B&Bs, campsites, campervan pitches and self-catering cottages. It could even include scout camps, despite the Scout Association pointing out these are
“being run for charitable purposes by volunteers, on minimal budgets”.
Even tents at music festivals are covered. So what is actually excluded from the legislation? The Government have selected three national exemptions, one of which is Traveller sites. There is a power to exempt more categories, but that is discretionary, so scout camps and other sites are liable by default. The Secretary of State did not have a view on scout camps, but we do and other Labour Members have a view. Scout camps should be exempt, and we will be bringing forward amendments to that effect. This should not be left to the whims of mayors. This House should set the framework.
Extraordinarily, or perhaps not, the Government want this to be an uncapped power to charge an unlimited amount. Although Labour mayors, who cannot wait to introduce this tax, say that they will limit it to 5%, there is nothing in the Bill to prevent higher rates. The Government are even adding VAT to the levy, pushing it up even further. It will apply to 28 days of a stay, not five days, as in Scotland. Frankly, it does not take much imagination to see those Labour mayors breaking promises on tax, just like their Front Benchers did after the election. The Government have said that whether to have a cap is a finely balanced issue. No, it is not. It is very straightforward: there should be a cap to protect the public. If the Bill passes, we will seek to amend it to limit the tax to 5%.