Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
Visitor Levy (England) Bill Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateRachael Maskell
Main Page: Rachael Maskell (Labour (Co-op) - York Central)Department Debates - View all Rachael Maskell's debates with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
(2 days, 23 hours ago)
Commons ChamberThe penalty systems are broadly similar, with the common features of civil penalties for failures such as late returns and non-payment, escalating for continued non-compliance. It will be for strategic authorities to carry out their impact assessments on the basis of what they decide their levy will be.
In this place, we talk much about the cost of living, and we are particularly conscious of the cost borne by families. Could the Secretary of State therefore say whether children can be exempt when families have to pay the levy, in order to support family finances?
Again, we have been looking at a national framework, but local levies can contain exemptions. That will be for local areas to determine.
Through the Bill, we are also bringing forward provisions on enforcement, appeals and anti-avoidance powers. These include tax-style compliance and inspection powers, civil penalties, rights of appeal to tribunals, and offences for fraudulent evasion or deliberate misstatement. Subject to the passage of the Bill, local leaders will be able to set out plans by March 2028for how levy revenues will be invested, and then introduce a levy before the end of this Parliament.
I will speak in support of the Bill, but I believe that we need to bring some amendment to it. The quality of York’s tourism offer is exceptional. Right now, the streets are buzzing. We have the Christmas market, the nutcracker trail and numerous attractions, such as the railway museum, the castle museum, Clifford’s tower, the art gallery and Yorkshire museum. The retail offer is exceptional because of its independence, but also because the people in tourism, hospitality and retail work exceptionally hard to make it a success. We are on the tentative list to become a world heritage site, and that in itself incurs a cost. If we invest, we will gain the benefit from that and save, but we need the resource in our city.
Occupancy remains high in our city, and yet cuts to our council’s budget have meant that improvements have not been forthcoming at the rate we would want to see. The visitor levy provides an opportunity to invest in that infrastructure and improve the offer we can make to residents and visitors, and therefore see a greater boom in the hospitality sector—not what the naysayers on the Opposition Benches are saying. However, we need to recognise that when people come to our city, they draw on its infrastructure, whether that is street cleaning, bin collections, A&E—especially for those who like to party at night—or the police who ensure that our city is a safe place. We are an incredibly safe city. We have 9.1 million visitors to our small and perfectly formed city and 1.7 million overnight stays, so that has a real bearing on what happens across York. That is why a visitor levy would be a way for people who come to our city to give back, not only through the tourism offer, but to the residents of York to show their gratitude for the enjoyment they have gained.
When I first advocated for a tourism tax, as we called it back in the day, we favoured a flat rate because of its clarity and simplicity. I said it should be pinned to the price of a cup of coffee, which nobody these days bats an eyelid at. I acknowledge that the Government have put in a more progressive model of a percentage levied on the cost of accommodation, and I support that approach, but we need to recognise that it will have a bearing on those providers. I have heard from hospitality providers in my city that are struggling at the moment, and we have to recognise that what they pin that on is not necessarily the visitor levy, but the national insurance contributions, which took their toll. Providers say that VAT is a problem and they want to see the Government take action on that. If we are introducing a visitor levy, there must be some trade-offs for the industry. Perhaps looking at VAT again for the hospitality sector would be an encouraging step forward. In other European countries where VAT is lower and there is a levy, tourism has boomed as a result. I ask the Government to publish an impact assessment of the proposals as we travel into Committee stage, so that we can see the impacts while acknowledging that mayors will have to put together their own impact assessments.
The way the hospitality sector operates is important, and the detail of the legislation needs tightening up in some areas. In York, we believe the revenue should be hypothecated to York, not wider North Yorkshire, because of the hospitality work our city does as a unit. We believe that if money is raised in our city, it should be spent in our city for the benefit of our residents, as well as for the tourists.
James Naish (Rushcliffe) (Lab)
Research from the Labour Rural Research Group emphasises exactly that point. Its latest report on “The Future of the Rural Economy” found that if the levy were introduced, stakeholders would want to see it ringfenced for the area raising that money. That is just as important to rural areas as it is to more urban areas such as my hon. Friend’s, because they want to see the direct benefit that comes from people visiting their area. Does she agree that it would be great for the Minister to look at how that could be mandated?
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for that intervention because, as I have heard from other Members across the House today, it would be an important amendment in Committee to enable hypothecation and resource well spent in the locality. Also, it would mean that there is a direct relationship between the tourism sector and residents. I have heard too many times residents in York say to me, “It all goes to the visitors and tourists.” This is about accountability within the locality, and surely that is the piece that is often missing in our politics.
Spending determination should not be the domain of the mayor alone. That offer should be developed with the hospitality sector—again, that co-production which is so important. Our hospitality sector would welcome that engagement to ensure that its voice on where the money is spent is threaded through. Hospitality businesses have said that if the levy is used for the promotion of tourism, the locality and services, they would absolutely understand the need for it and the benefit of charging that levy. I believe a proportion should be dedicated to local projects, so that residents can get the benefit of that for community spaces, and a proportion should be spent on services such as street cleaning, and the additional demands on health, policing and other services; there is data to show that that demand comes from outside of our area when tourism comes to our city.
It is also right to think about which accommodation is included and which is excluded. As hon. Members know, I have long called for short-term holiday lets to be properly licensed—it is appropriate to ensure that there is a levy on them. However, I would exclude hostel accommodation, like youth hostels and local provision. We have heard about tents; those low-budget options should automatically be removed from the levy. I recognise that new types of accommodation are on the scene. I do not know where these pods fit in, or yurts—maybe the glamping world would not be exempt. It would make for a good debate in Committee, so that we get this right.
Paragraph 2(1)(b) of schedule 1 states that a strategic authority should
“consult such persons as the authority considers appropriate on the initial prospectus and visitor levy proposal”.
I am afraid that is far too vague. The strategic authority must be obliged to consult local authority leaders, MPs, the hospitality sector, and the wider tourism and retail sectors. It should also consult residents and local service providers. Mayors are already far too unaccountable for the decisions they make. I know that is something the Government want to address, but we need to be able to bring in that accountability when introducing a new form of taxation. It is therefore crucial that those stakeholders are listed on the face of the Bill as statutory consultees. The consequential report that the mayor must produce should also reflect the findings of the consultation, not just have “regard” to those responses as set out in paragraph 2(3) of schedule 1. I ask for the Minister to further consider those points.
As I have said, family budgets are tight and we need to consider an exemption for children. That option is not in the Bill, but I ask that such a measure is considered. It would be a popular move, and it would enable families to ensure affordability. We have also heard about carers and people on hospital stays, including for treatment—there should be proper exclusions in those cases too. With inflation currently running at 4%, to introduce a 5% charge could mean a 9% increase in the cost of holidays. I therefore ask the Government to consider introducing a levy with a 1% per year increase, so that there is a phasing-in stage and a more gradual approach.
Finally, will there be consideration for neighbouring authorities? If there are cliff edges, there could be challenges, and that needs to be debated and considered by the Government. Schedule 4 refers to levels of criminality and dependency of the justice system, which I think are extortionate—the hon. Member for Harrogate and Knaresborough (Tom Gordon) also mentioned that. We need to reconsider that issue not least because, as we know, the justice system is under extreme pressure, and we need to ensure a good system of compliance. Finally, we must ensure clear reporting of where the levy is spent, so that we can really understand its impact on tourism and the local community.
Several hon. Members rose—