Whole-life Sentences

Lord Tomlinson Excerpts

Wednesday 17th July 2013 Lords Chamber

[Lord Morgan]

My Lords—

[Lord Tomlinson]

My Lords—

[Lord Morgan]

My Lords, does not this judgment raise the very important legal principle of rehabilitation? It does not say that whole-life prisoners should be released or that the British Government should take any action, but it does suggest that they retain what the court called the right to hope, the possibility of atonement and the possibility of a review, as in many other countries. Is this not a very serious issue of penal philosophy that should be considered as such?

--- Later in debate ---

[Lord McNally]

There are a number of architects; Sir David Maxwell Fife was a notable originator. However, what the noble Lord said is absolutely right. That is precisely why, given the importance of this judgment, we intend to give it a full analysis and will provide our considered response in due course.

[Lord Tomlinson]

Does the Minister agree that we do incredible damage to our international reputation for upholding the rule of law when, every time we get a judgment from the European Court of Human Rights, there is a knee-jerk reaction from Members in another place, calling for us to abrogate our responsibilities under the European convention?

[Lord McNally]

My Lords, that is why my Answer to this House is that we are making a full analysis of the judgment and will provide our considered response in due course.