All 4 Debates between John Hayes and Daisy Cooper

Wed 18th Nov 2026
Wed 12th Feb 2020
Terrorist Offenders (Restriction of Early Release) Bill
Commons Chamber

Committee stage:Committee: 1st sitting & 3rd reading: House of Commons & Committee: 1st sitting: House of Commons & 3rd reading & 3rd reading: House of Commons & Committee: 1st sitting & Committee: 1st sitting: House of Commons & Committee stage & 3rd reading
Wed 12th Feb 2020
Terrorist Offenders (Restriction of Early Release) Bill
Commons Chamber

2nd reading & 2nd reading: House of Commons & 2nd reading & 2nd reading: House of Commons & 2nd reading

UK-EU Relations

Debate between John Hayes and Daisy Cooper
Wednesday 18th November 2026

(1 day, 6 hours ago)

Commons Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

I have no such understanding that it has changed. It is typical of my right hon. Friend, with both perspicacity and foresight, to anticipate the very reason that my hostility to the European Union has its roots back in the 1970s. Those roots were of two forms. The first was because I believe that in nationhood, we nurture the sense of belonging that nourishes a true sense of worth—so I believe in the magic of nationhood. The second was because I believe that political power is best exercised closest to its effect. When it becomes remote from its effect, it risks at first becoming unaccountable and ultimately becoming corrupt.

For those two reasons, I resist the idea of surrendering nationhood to something supranational. I know that that was the ambition of the architects of the European Community. If we look at what Monnet and others said back in the 1950s, before the treaty of Rome, we see that they were under no illusions that this was a common market and a means of perpetuating good trading relationships. They saw it as a political project, and “project” is the word often used to describe it by them and about them.

Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Will the right hon. Gentleman give way?

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

I will. I am always happy to teach liberals a lesson, as the hon. Lady knows. [Laughter.]

Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

We did 10 rounds on this subject last week. The right hon. Gentleman says that he is against supranational institutions. Obviously the subject of this debate is UK-EU relations, but, if we extend his argument, is he also against the United Nations, the World Trade Organisation, the World Health Organisation, NATO and all other supranational organisations in which co-operation happens on a whole range of different issues?

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

The difference there is in the emblems and totems, the reality of governance and the character of polity. The problem is that the European Union has taken on the function of a polity itself. It is a law-making body. In other words, it exercises governance.

Organisations of the kind that the hon. Lady describes—I think particularly of NATO, which I do not think she mentioned—are intergovernmental organisations, in which Governments come together, co-operate and collaborate. Of course, collaboration between nations matters—she and I would agree on a lot of that, actually—but the creation of something that has an anthem, a President, a flag and, more substantially, the ability to make laws that affect this place, irrespective of the will of this Parliament, is of an entirely different nature. I knew that back in the 1970s, and I know it now. That is why, as my right hon. Friend the Member for New Forest East (Sir Julian Lewis) predicted, year by year both my understanding and hostility grew and had their culmination in the magical moment when we voted to leave the European Union in 2016—perhaps the greatest moment of my time in politics.

--- Later in debate ---
John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

It is certainly true that a nation alone can be nimbler and more responsive than a nation that is obliged to agree what it does in concert with many others, where there will be differing opinions about both scale and speed. My right hon. Friend is right—that is a good example of how, freed from those obligations, we were able to deal with a pressing problem.

That is part of a bigger point, which I referenced earlier when I intervened on the Minister, the right hon. Member for Lincoln (Mr Falconer). Much is made of how the world is changing and how, in this dramatically altered world, we need the security blanket of our connection with the European Union. However, the counter-argument is just as powerful. In a more confusing world, a Government’s ability to act quickly and cut across some of the bureaucracy that is associated with supranational bodies—the nimbleness that my right hon. Friend the Member for Chingford and Woodford Green (Sir Iain Duncan Smith) referred to—is all the more important. In a changed world, a free and dynamic country can be a more effective country.

Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I invite the right hon. Member for Chingford and Woodford Green (Sir Iain Duncan Smith) to consider correcting the record, because that claim was fact-checked at the time and found to be untrue. Under European law, the UK was permitted to act independently to approve a vaccine in an emergency, and it was made clear—I was a Member of the House at the time and I remember fact-checking Boris Johnson and Matt Hancock when they made that claim—that it was not the case that we were able to accelerate the vaccine because we were outside the EU. We would have been able to do so anyway, because of the exemption for trialling novel vaccines under a specific medical exemption. I refer the right hon. Gentleman to the Full Fact article on that point.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

Madam Deputy Speaker, you will have noted that that was more of an intervention on the previous intervention from my right hon. Friend the Member for Chingford and Woodford Green than it was an intervention on me, so I will leave my right hon. Friend and the hon. Lady to sort the matter out between themselves.

The bigger point is the one I made about how we perceive our future. I perceive our future as a nation that is outward-looking but sure about the sovereignty of this Parliament, for though the sovereignty of this Parliament may be spoken of blithely, essentially we are talking about the will of the people exercised through this place.

The second point that inspired me to oppose the European Union back in those teenage years was the one about power. Here we are directly accountable to the people who elect us. We are answerable in the most palpable way, are we not, to our voters? Every single Member of this House has regular engagement with all kinds of people in their constituencies, with all kinds of opinions, and that is their constituents’ chance to access and influence power.

I studied politics at university, and I have studied the EU ever since. One requires virtually a PhD to understand how it works. Many of the people elected to the European Parliament have only a sketchy idea of how it works. We know how laws are made there. It begins with discussion among relatively junior bureaucrats, who then listen to a series of interest groups and lobbying organisations. It is then elevated to a diplomat, who discusses it, plans it and sets it out in rather more detail. By the way, that is long before it gets to anybody who has been elected. Finally, it gets to the MEPs, and they discuss it, usually in some smoke-filled room—well, I guess these days the room would not be full of smoke, so that metaphor is perhaps becoming rather dated. National Governments are reached very late in the process, and their chances to influence EU laws are very limited.

The hon. Member for Chelsea and Fulham (Ben Coleman) said he is a fully fledged—he is not shy to admit it—member of the liberal bourgeoisie. In the case of the current arrangements, he also said we will have a chance to shape some of those decisions. The experts— I shudder when that word is used; I never claim expertise in anything, really, and neither should he—will have some influence on this process, but there is a real difference between shaping and deciding.

Budget Resolutions

Debate between John Hayes and Daisy Cooper
Tuesday 3rd November 2026

(2 weeks, 2 days ago)

Commons Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

My right hon. and learned Friend is absolutely right. Young people are being forced to compete with those foreign workers for a scarce number of jobs. The only people who support that policy are dim-witted bourgeoise liberals and hard-hearted plutocrats, because both of them glory in the idea of foreign labour. That foreign labour is edging Britons out of jobs and, by so doing, weakening our economy.

Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

On that point, will the right hon. Gentleman give way?

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

I happily give way.

Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The right hon. Gentleman surely has not missed the evidence that, since his party’s botched Brexit deal, it has become more expensive to do business in the UK, businesses are wrapped up in red tape, and many businesses have moved abroad, taking good, high-quality jobs with them. We have a NEETs crisis in this country, caused by many different factors. One of the reasons that there are graduates who cannot get jobs is because his party’s ridiculous Brexit deal has driven businesses abroad. If we get back into the single market and make doing business cheaper, those businesses will come back here and create jobs for British young people.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

I was going to address the issue of trade later, but the hon. Lady has encouraged me to do so now. The truth is that the balance of payments has been a neglected subject in this Parliament and for successive Governments for decades. We never sold as much to Europe as Europe sold to us, and that balance was out of kilter for the whole time that we were members of the European Union.

Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

On that point, will the right hon. Gentleman give way?

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

No, I will not give way again, because there is only so much you can teach the Liberal Democrats!

The balance of trade figures was once a pivotal announcement in Parliament and for Governments. That has been forgotten as we have chosen to import more and more goods into this country, and to make fewer and fewer. The hon. Lady will recognise that, given that I represent a rural constituency that grows a lot of the food we consume, I am particularly sensitive to the fact that we have made ourselves dependent on foreign food imports. That is preposterous. We need to shorten supply chains and make ourselves more economically resilient. As the Prime Minister said, actually—

Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

On that point, will the right hon. Gentleman give way?

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

I was about to make a point, but I will then give way once more to see whether I can teach the hon. Lady something more. As the Prime Minister said, we must remanufacture—we must build our manufacturing capacity again. Successive Governments have failed to do this. I do not claim any credit for any political party, and I certainly claim no credit for the Liberal Democrats.

Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The right hon. Gentleman is absolutely contradicting himself. He has simultaneously said that we need to shorten supply chains to improve our food security while defending the very trade barriers that prevent British importers and exporters from getting food to each other on a shorter supply chain. It was the right hon. Gentleman’s party that agreed the terrible trade deals with New Zealand and Australia that have put up food prices and undermined British farmers. Would he like to apologise for that? After 10 years, we are still teaching the Conservatives how damaging their trade deals were.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

I mentioned my record on apprenticeships. I was in the coalition Government when I was able to bring about that outcome, with the full support of Liberal Democrat Ministers. It was Vince Cable, actually, as Secretary of State, who understood the need to build skills and train domestic workers so that we were not dependent, in the way that I described, on European goods or goods from anywhere else in the world. We just need to make more of what we consume. It is not hard to work out.

I said that I would deal with one or two other things, and time is pressing. Productivity is a macroeconomic problem that has faced all Governments. Declining productivity over time means that we spend a great deal of money on things from which we do not get a great deal of outcome. Our productivity is worse than some of our key competitors. The Government need to focus on that; the previous Prime Minister and his Ministers said that they would, but there was little about that in the Budget.

To summarise, I think it was Disraeli who said, “Men are not the victim of circumstances; they create circumstances.” It is not enough to blame context for the failure to address the macroeconomic problems of skills, productivity and immigration. More must be done, and done soon.

Terrorist Offenders (Restriction of Early Release) Bill

Debate between John Hayes and Daisy Cooper
Committee stage & 3rd reading: House of Commons & Committee: 1st sitting: House of Commons & 3rd reading & Committee: 1st sitting
Wednesday 12th February 2020

(6 years, 9 months ago)

Commons Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts Amendment Paper: Committee of the whole House Amendments as at 12 February 2020 (revised) - (12 Feb 2020)
Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper (St Albans) (LD)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am not seeking to press new clause 3, but I am seeking reassurances from the Minister relating to the purpose behind it and a commitment to post-legislative scrutiny.

In my earlier remarks, I made the point that fast law can be bad law. In the absence of an opportunity for thorough pre-legislative scrutiny, we absolutely must have post-legislative scrutiny. There are relevant examples of where this has happened: the Immigration Act 2014 was controversial, so it contained the same requirement as exists in new clause 3; and the Data Retention and Investigatory Powers Act 2014, which was rushed in in response to a court ruling, included a sunset clause of 18 months. I am not asking for a sunset clause, but new clause 3 sets out clearly that we would like the opportunity for a statutory review after one year. The person conducting that review should be appointed after consultation with the independent reviewer of terrorism legislation and they should have professional experience relating to imprisonment for offences of terrorism.

New clause 3 does not seek to outline the scope of such a statutory review, but I would like to give the Committee some examples of the kind of matters that could be covered by it. Such a statutory review could ask whether the extra time the terrorists spend in prison is being used to de-radicalise them. Are they actually receiving an effective de-radicalisation programme or, on the contrary, are they potentially becoming more dangerous? It could look at whether the Parole Board has the resources to cope with the extra demands put on it. It could look at whether terrorist prisoners are being failed by the Parole Board and whether they are being released at the end of their sentence without any supervision on licence. It could look at whether the probation service has the staff and resources it needs to ensure effective supervision during the shorter period that offenders spend on licence. It could also perhaps look at whether the change in the release point affects the sentencing decisions made by judges.

As I said earlier, there is a risk that because of the lack of opportunity for pre-legislative scrutiny there is the possibility that this becomes a law of unintended consequences. I know there are proposals for legislation down the line, but we also know that legislation can get delayed. It would be absolutely right for the House to insist on post-legislative scrutiny by virtue of a one-year statutory review. Who knows, the review might even identify things that could be included in future legislation.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes (South Holland and The Deepings) (Con)
- Hansard - -

I speak in sympathy with all the amendments for the reasons I shall give. In respect of the amendment tabled by my hon. Friend the Member for Stone (Sir William Cash), it is important that we anticipate the likely counters to this proposed legislation that will perhaps come from malign forces in the other place and outside it. There are people who will seek to frustrate the Government in their attempt to the right thing.

Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I note that the right hon. Gentleman says there are malign forces. I ask him to recognise that there are those of us who hold public and national security front and centre in our roles in the House, and that some people may be looking not to frustrate but improve the Bill by ensuring it complies with human rights law.

--- Later in debate ---
John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

We have well-established mechanisms, of the kind I have just described, for doing exactly that. Sometimes the Government build a review mechanism into legislation, but much more often the Committees of this House designed for that purpose consider the effectiveness of what the Government do and how legislation is working. Our Select Committee structure is now long established in the House—even longer established than my hon. Friend the Member for Stone—and fulfils that function well. Particularly in respect of legislation relating to terrorism, the Intelligence and Security Committee has, time and again, played an important role in considering these matters, reflecting, reporting, and influencing Government policy, as I know from my time in the Home Office. So I think that there is well-established practice. If it ain’t broke, why fix it?

Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The issue is not just that there should be a review, but who should conduct that review. The right hon. Gentleman has talked about various Select Committees, which, as we know, have a very broad workload. Does he agree that it is important to ensure that there is an independent review, conducted on our behalf by someone who is independent of the House and has experience in relation to the sentencing of terrorists?

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

We do, in fact, have an independent reviewer of terrorism legislation. In that context, I was privileged to work with Lord Carlile—a former Liberal Democrat Member of this House, by the way. So that role exists, but I do not want to underestimate the significance or value of the Committees of this House in doing their job. The ISC in particular is a well-respected Committee of the House, which has a very strong track record of looking at these matters empirically and advising accordingly. My argument is not that we should not have that kind of scrutiny; ideally, it would have been a precursor to this legislation, but we should indeed consider allowing it through the mechanisms that I have described. I invite the Minister to embrace the spirit in which I have advanced my argument.

The third and final amendment that we have heard ably articulated during our considerations this afternoon is the one in the name of my right hon. Friend the Member for New Forest West (Sir Desmond Swayne). Again, I am extremely sympathetic to the purpose of the amendment. Indeed, I might even go further, and say that “nine-tenths” is too modest. However, while my right hon. Friend’s amendment is welcome and adds pressure, if I might put it that way—he said “prodding” rather than “probing”, and I have added a third “p”, “pressure”, because I know that alliteration is dear to his heart—given that the Government have made crystal clear that in forthcoming legislation they will look at three matters, minimum sentences, maximum sentences and mandatory sentences, much of what he desires should form part of that further Government policy and practice. I hope that we can increase minimum sentences, that we can increase maximum sentences, and that we can tie to that—as the Government have said they will, as I note from comments made in the statement by the Secretary of State following the recent terrorist outrage—

Terrorist Offenders (Restriction of Early Release) Bill

Debate between John Hayes and Daisy Cooper
2nd reading & 2nd reading: House of Commons
Wednesday 12th February 2020

(6 years, 9 months ago)

Commons Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts Amendment Paper: Committee of the whole House Amendments as at 12 February 2020 (revised) - (12 Feb 2020)
Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper (St Albans) (LD)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I, too, put on record my thanks to the Under-Secretary of State for Justice, the hon. Member for Croydon South (Chris Philp), who has kept me updated in recent days.

In the wake of the two recent terrorist attacks, it is absolutely right that the Government look at the legal framework to decide whether it is adequate. Like the hon. Member for Eastleigh (Paul Holmes), I was caught up in the 7/7 bombing. I was on one of the tube trains behind the one that was blown up at Russell Square, and I remember the unbearable heat that came from the blast. I was also in this place during the Westminster lockdown. The hon. Gentleman is right that many of us have been affected by acts of terrorism, but with respect, many of us nevertheless come to this debate with slightly different views.

This Bill does three things. First, it brings about an end to automatic release and applies that retrospectively. That is overdue, but very welcome. Liberal Democrats have said before, and we say again, that this part of the law is currently wrong, and it is right that this House seeks to change it. The Government are rushing this Bill through to get to Royal Assent before the end of the month and before the scheduled release of other terrorists. However, this part of the Bill alone, on ending automatic release and applying that retrospectively, would achieve the Government’s goal—and, indeed, the priority of all of us to keep the public safe. This part of the Bill alone would stop the release of terrorists without Parole Board agreement. It would be possible to adopt just that part of the Bill for it to be a change in the administration of a sentence in a way that is compatible with the rule of law.

However, the Bill tries to do two other things that, I think it is fair to say, are problematic. The second thing it tries to do is move the point of release from the halfway point to the two-thirds point for future offences. Of course, it is the natural instinct of all of us to have bad people locked up for longer, but who would want somebody locked up for longer if there was evidence that that could in fact make them more radicalised and more dangerous at the point that they are released?

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

That is not an argument about the length of the sentence; that is an argument about how people are dealt with when they are incarcerated.

Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the right hon. Gentleman for that point. Much of the evidence suggests that what helps the deradicalisation process is not only how people are treated when they are incarcerated, but the amount of time they have on licence in order to find a home, rebuild family connections and do all the activity outside prison. There is evidence to suggest that the time on licence can make more of a difference to reducing reoffending rates and deradicalising people.

--- Later in debate ---
Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The hon. Gentleman will recall that, in my opening remarks, I made the point that this was a very overdue change. In fact, we have had many years where we have seen the effects of increased radicalisation in prison simply because of a lack of resources both for our prisons and for our parole service, so he is right to point to that element.

That leads me very nicely to my next point: because of the speed of the passage of the Bill, there is not sufficient opportunity for pre-legislative scrutiny. I would argue that, in the absence of adequate pre-legislative scrutiny, hon. Members should all sign up to a system of post-legislative scrutiny. Others in this debate have called for a review mechanism. The Government say there is other legislation coming down the line, but we know that legislation can slip, so I will finish by asking the Government to think again about this particular point to make sure that we have sufficient post-legislative scrutiny and that this law—

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

I waited to intervene until a point at which I agreed with the hon. Lady, because I thought that was in the spirit of this debate. She is right about the need to review these provisions, but as she said a moment ago, any number of Committees will be able to do that in the course of time. We can move ahead with rapidity to defend the public, and then look at these matters in the round through the processes she has set out.

Daisy Cooper Portrait Daisy Cooper
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The right hon. Gentleman is right that this legislation will of course be scrutinised in due course, but it is vital and right, because we are moving on with it so quickly, that we write into law a statutory review in one year’s time.

I conclude by saying that there is a danger that Bill will become a law of unintended consequences. In summary, we welcome the end to automatic release and doing so retrospectively—that is a good move—but we have concerns about changing the release point, particularly if that ends up allowing people to be released who are more dangerous than before. There are also questions to answer about the impact on the rule of law in applying retrospectivity to the release point.