All 3 Debates between John Hayes and Ben Coleman

UK-EU Relations

Debate between John Hayes and Ben Coleman
Wednesday 18th November 2026

(1 day, 6 hours ago)

Commons Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

Madam Deputy Speaker, you will have noted that that was more of an intervention on the previous intervention from my right hon. Friend the Member for Chingford and Woodford Green than it was an intervention on me, so I will leave my right hon. Friend and the hon. Lady to sort the matter out between themselves.

The bigger point is the one I made about how we perceive our future. I perceive our future as a nation that is outward-looking but sure about the sovereignty of this Parliament, for though the sovereignty of this Parliament may be spoken of blithely, essentially we are talking about the will of the people exercised through this place.

The second point that inspired me to oppose the European Union back in those teenage years was the one about power. Here we are directly accountable to the people who elect us. We are answerable in the most palpable way, are we not, to our voters? Every single Member of this House has regular engagement with all kinds of people in their constituencies, with all kinds of opinions, and that is their constituents’ chance to access and influence power.

I studied politics at university, and I have studied the EU ever since. One requires virtually a PhD to understand how it works. Many of the people elected to the European Parliament have only a sketchy idea of how it works. We know how laws are made there. It begins with discussion among relatively junior bureaucrats, who then listen to a series of interest groups and lobbying organisations. It is then elevated to a diplomat, who discusses it, plans it and sets it out in rather more detail. By the way, that is long before it gets to anybody who has been elected. Finally, it gets to the MEPs, and they discuss it, usually in some smoke-filled room—well, I guess these days the room would not be full of smoke, so that metaphor is perhaps becoming rather dated. National Governments are reached very late in the process, and their chances to influence EU laws are very limited.

The hon. Member for Chelsea and Fulham (Ben Coleman) said he is a fully fledged—he is not shy to admit it—member of the liberal bourgeoisie. In the case of the current arrangements, he also said we will have a chance to shape some of those decisions. The experts— I shudder when that word is used; I never claim expertise in anything, really, and neither should he—will have some influence on this process, but there is a real difference between shaping and deciding.

Ben Coleman Portrait Ben Coleman
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

This is perhaps not a deeply intellectual point, but what is important about this place is the traditions we have, and those are not just the traditions that have pertained for a long time, but those that develop. May I say how grateful I am to the right hon. Gentleman for inventing a new tradition, which is that every time he speaks, he has a go at me? I look forward to it, and I have not been let down.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

I detect just a touch of paranoia in the hon. Gentleman. He knows that I am a soft-hearted soul, and I think he was pricking at my soft heart in the hope that I will be kinder to him in future.

The key thing is to understand how dynamic alignment works. It is true, as Labour Members have said, that this agreement that the Prime Minister will reach may slash some of the post-Brexit checks imposed thereafter by the European Union, which may make things easier for some of our exporters, of which food producers are a good example. In return, however, the Prime Minister will agree to align permanently—“in perpetuity” was the phrase used earlier—with EU regulations on food and farming. This process means that the UK will have to adopt new EU regulations in areas as soon as they are passed by Brussels, with no vote on them. I will come in a second to the House of Lords Committee that has already been mentioned, but in essence that will mean scores, perhaps hundreds, of new regulations affecting British businesses, about which we will have no say in this place. That House of Lords Committee said that the deal would mean

“significant volumes of EU legislation”,

and heard evidence that complying with farming laws alone

“might generate at least 780 pieces of in-scope EU law a year”.

I am not going to second-guess a distinguished Committee of the House of Lords, but even if that were an overestimate, the principle remains that many additional regulations will be imposed on this country, with Parliament having no say.

Much has been said about mandates and Makerfield. Let us be clear about the polling. A recent survey in Makerfield about who should decide UK economic policy on 10 different issues, ranging from medicine approval to state aid, showed that in every single case a clear majority of people there said that the policy should be determined by the UK Government alone. The British people may have bought some of the liberal elite’s propaganda about Brexit per se, but when it comes to deciding where laws should be made and how those making them should be held to account, they are pretty clear that that should happen in this country, in this sovereign Parliament.

Let me now draw my remarks to a close, as I know you will want me to, Madam Deputy Speaker. The truth—and I think we can speak it in this private place, can we not?—is that a large proportion of the British establishment resented the EU referendum result from the very beginning, and did all in their power, funded by greedy plutocrats, to try and stop it. The greedy plutocrats, of course, benefited from the cheap labour that came across from Europe, and thank God that ended. Now they hope—exactly as the hon. Member for Boston and Skegness described—that this is the beginning of a process that will reverse that. In contrast, I say this: the referendum result was an expression of the will of the people.

I will end with George Orwell, if I may. He said of that very left-wing intelligentsia at the time of the last war that they took their tastes from Paris and their instructions from Moscow. We might substitute that with “instructions from Brussels and Strasbourg.” I take the polar opposite view. I believe that this nation should be governed by Britons chosen by other Britons to do so. I believe in the national interest and the common good—first, foremost, forever.

Backing Business to Create Economic Growth

Debate between John Hayes and Ben Coleman
Monday 18th May 2026

(6 months ago)

Commons Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Ben Coleman Portrait Ben Coleman (Chelsea and Fulham) (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

That was a very powerful and upsetting speech. I am grateful to the hon. Member for Rutland and Stamford (Alicia Kearns) for raising that issue. There is a lot to think about.

In a world of growing uncertainty, our country’s economic security has never mattered more, which is why I have to say I am delighted by the European partnership Bill in the King’s Speech. Right now, our rigid distancing from the EU is simply holding us back. It has piled costs on to business and has done nothing for ordinary people. If Members visit the Italian-Spanish deli on the King’s Road in my constituency, they will see that the shelves are half bare because the white van person who used to make buying runs across northern Europe cannot or does not want to do the paperwork any more. A drinks importer in Fulham is paying £100 to £150 extra per pallet. These are import businesses, but the costs fall on exporters just as hard, and small businesses can least afford the costs they now face.

Large sectors are also paying heavily for our rigid distancing from the European Union. British cars now have to meet a separate set of regulatory requirements just to enter European markets, and it is costing the automotive sector £600 million a year that they did not used to have to pay. In chemicals, leaving the EU REACH registration scheme and creating an entirely separate one has left the UK industry facing a £2 billion bill. In pharmaceuticals, British products are waiting for four to six weeks for batch testing before they can get into European supply chains.

Ten years ago, none of those costs existed. Why not? We all know the answer: because we and our European neighbours were in a single market together. Once outside that market, Britain became subject to all these new trade barriers, just like any non-EU country, which pushed up costs.

Indeed, in the food and drink sector, costs for British exporters have risen by as much as 20%. Since 2023, businesses have had to pay for over a million multi-page export health certificates just to trade with the EU, at a total cost of between £90 million and £210 million. Each certificate costs up to £200 quid. This did not used to be the case. A salmon shipment can then face sampling costs of £1,400 on top. The cost can be £1,200 for a consignment of beef or cheese. If you have got the forms even slightly wrong, valuable produce can be held at the border, or spoiled entirely.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

As you might know, Madam Deputy Speaker, I try to read a lot of fiction—I read two novels a month—but I sometimes think I do not need to, because what we are hearing now is a fiction about the European Union. In every Department in which I served as a Minister, I tried to encourage the procurement of British products and services, including vehicles. Every time I did so I was told that it was impossible because of EU regulations and rules, particularly state aid rules. That disadvantaged British businesses large and small. We have been freed from that now, which is why Ministers on the Treasury Bench can preside over a regime that procures British goods and services, and I know that every day they try to do so.

Ben Coleman Portrait Ben Coleman
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am most grateful for that intervention, but it does not in any way even attempt to address the point I was making about the loss of money to this country through trade and the fact that so many businesses have gone under.

On state aid and product procurement, I will accept that one of the most unpalatable things that civil servants have always said, along with “commercial in confidence”, is, “No, we can’t do that because of EU procurement rules.” After the changes to EU procurement rules there was, even while we were in the European Union, a huge amount that you could do to prefer small and local firms, as I knew when I was deputy leader of my local council and got officials to do that. The civil servants you were dealing with perhaps should have looked again—

UK-EU Summit

Debate between John Hayes and Ben Coleman
Tuesday 13th May 2025

(1 year, 6 months ago)

Commons Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Ben Coleman Portrait Ben Coleman
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Oh, it was sarcasm.

As I was saying, I am very pleased, as many are, with the Government for being cool-headed and having a common-sense approach. We are going to reset our relationship with the European Union and put Britain first. Putting Britain first has to also mean putting our young people first, so I am excited by the opportunity for young people in my constituency and every constituency to take advantage of a time-limited, controlled visa-based youth system, which we already have with a dozen countries.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

The hon. Gentleman will know that thousands of young people—perhaps not in Chelsea but in most of the country—are NEETs, meaning they are not in education, employment or training, and that number is growing. Why should those young people, who are desperately seeking access to education or jobs, have to compete with large numbers of people from abroad? Is that what the people in Chelsea and Fulham really want for the people who live in the rest of Britain?

Ben Coleman Portrait Ben Coleman
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I can tell the right hon. Gentleman what people in Chelsea and Fulham really want. They do not want a Prime Minister like the last one—a business Prime Minister—who said that we would level up to help people across the country but then did nothing about it. What they want is a Prime Minister who will invest in increasing skills and apprenticeships right across the country, as ours said yesterday that he will. That is what we need, and that is what we are getting now.

--- Later in debate ---
John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

It is typical of my hon. Friend’s humility and good humour that he should acknowledge that in the Chamber in such an open and frank way, and I pay tribute to him for it.

The scepticism that I have described and tried to articulate takes the form of real doubts about what realignment will really mean. Let me just deal with three or four specifics. I spoke earlier in an intervention about security and defence. Of course, it is right that we have a continuing relationship with our neighbours in those terms. We do work with the agencies across Europe, but the critical security relationship we enjoy is with the Five Eyes countries—by the way, we also enjoy relations with many other countries in the world outside the Five Eyes and Europe—and it is vital that we reinforce that relationship. That, of course, overlaps with our commitment to NATO and defence.

There may be some virtues in information sharing—indeed, there certainly are virtues in various kinds of co-operation—but anything that undermines the sovereignty of that security and defence alliance seems to be highly questionable and also risky, which is worse.

Let me turn now to free movement. Although the referendum was not all about immigration, immigration was perhaps the most pressing and salient matter during those times. People resented and resisted free movement and they wanted to bring it to an end. For many, the term “take back control” epitomised the need to control our borders—to decide who came here and who did not. Although it may be understandable that people want to wax lyrical about young people being able to travel across the continent, what they say less enthusiastically, or do not say at all, is that young people from the entire continent will want to travel here. Until we know the terms of that, that could easily mean those people competing with Britons for scarce jobs.

We have large numbers of young people not in education, employment or training. No Government have dealt with that satisfactorily. I started speaking about this more than 20 years ago. Previous Labour Governments and, indeed, Conservative Governments did not really grasp that nettle as firmly as they should have done. Disturbingly, the trend is upwards, and so I do not want people in my country to have to compete for education and training places and for other opportunities with possibly tens of thousands of people who have entered the country by those means. There will be suspicions that it is the beginning of a return to free movement.

What did mass immigration do? The Prime Minister was right about this yesterday. He is a very late convert, but the Bible says that we must welcome all converts with enthusiasm. What mass immigration did was to displace investment in recruitment, training and retention of workers and in automation and improving workplaces, making us ever more dependent on low-skilled labour. It had the effect of stultifying the economy. Any suggestion that we may return to that will inhibit—perhaps ruin—the Government’s intention of improving productivity. If we really want to deal with productivity, we have to create a high-tech, high-skilled economy. I am fearful that that broader consideration will not necessarily hold sway when we get into negotiations with the EU on this issue of some relaxation of the bar on free movement, which was brought by the referendum.

Mindful that there are enthusiastic, insightful and bright colleagues on all sides of the House, but mainly on the Conservative side, who want to contribute to the debate, I will draw my remarks to a close. I can hear colleagues saying, “No, go on”, but I am going to resist those overtures and finish with this thought: C.S. Lewis said, “We are what we think we are”. I think we are a proud, independent nation that has made a disproportionate contribution as part of western civilisation to world history. I think that our past is noble and should give us a sense of achievement and pride. I do not buy the self-loathing that seems to have taken hold with too much of the very establishment that I derided earlier.

Ben Coleman Portrait Ben Coleman
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Will the right hon. Member give way?

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

I will happily give way—let us see whether the hon. Member is a self-loathing individual.

Ben Coleman Portrait Ben Coleman
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I trust that I am not. I hope that the right hon. Gentleman appreciated when I said earlier how excited I was for the prospects ahead of us. I want to thank him for identifying me a couple of times and associating me with my constituents, which I am certainly proud of. I also thank the right hon. Gentleman and a number of his colleagues for making me feel like I have been in this place not for 10 months but for 10 years, and for giving me the privilege of seeing the Brexit debate live, writ large again. It is a rare opportunity that I did not know I would get as a Member of this House, and I am most grateful.

John Hayes Portrait Sir John Hayes
- Hansard - -

I invite the hon. Gentleman to look at it through this prism: for all intents and purposes, I am Brexit, I stand for Brexit: I am a patriot, proud of my working-class origins; I am determined to do my best for my constituents and my country; and I am driven by a combination of the national interest and the common good. That was the spirit that inspired Brexit. It inspired those of us who campaigned for it, and those who voted for it, which 75% of my constituents in South Holland and the Deepings did. I am a bit resentful that Boston and Skegness next door had an even higher percentage, but it was only by 1%.

As I said, C.S. Lewis said that we are what we think we are. I think that we are a proud country who can stand in the world, in collaboration with other nations, of course, but free and sovereign. Labour cannot have it both ways. It cannot say that we have done a great deal with India because we did not have to kowtow to the EU and that we have done a great deal with the US because we escaped the clutches of the EU, while at the same time saying that we want to creep back in and for them to have more say in any future deals we might do.

Let me end with the words of one of my political heroes, Joseph Chamberlain, who understood that to protect our economy we need to protect the jobs, industry and enterprise that are part of it and not to give in to the free trade liberals. He said:

“a democratic Government, resting on the confidence and support of the whole nation, and not on the favour of any limited class, would be very strong. It would know how to make itself respected, and how to maintain the obligations and the honour of the country.”

No Member of this House should do less than that.