Finance Bill (Third sitting)

Gregor Poynton Excerpts

Committee stage
Thursday 30th January 2025 Public Bill Committees

[Mr MacDonald]

I do not have a great deal to add. I did miss out, when we declared our interests earlier, the fact that I own a pub, which hon. Members are very welcome to visit when they are next in Fort William—do not all rush at once. It never rains there.

I want to come back, briefly, to the 1p a pint reduction that we were promised. The whole hospitality industry and beer industry have come together to agree that that is a stunt, and that that 1p will not be passed on to the customer. It is just not relative at all, because the reduction in business property relief and the national insurance and minimum wage increases effectively mean that the cost to the hospitality industry is going through the roof. The Minister knows that perfectly well, but he still continues to trot out his line.

On the whisky industry, I am not sure that account has been taken of the potential tariffs. We talk about exports being very strong, but they are not actually very strong at the moment.

Lastly, on tax overall, when I make a submission to Scottish Government Ministers about the tax on hospitality, the whisky industry and so on, they all blame Westminster, but when I speak to Westminster Ministers about it, they all blame Scotland. The net result is that industries such as hospitality in Scotland are suffering from both sides, and that is simply not fair.

[Gregor Poynton (Livingston) (Lab)]

On business rates, they are clearly devolved to the Scottish Government, so it fully sits within their remit to help the hospitality industry. If we are talking about standing behind the whisky industry, one of the first things that the Secretary of State for Business and Trade did was go to Brazil to work out that protected status for the Scotch whisky industry, which will mean millions of pounds extra in exports to Brazil.

We are also discussing clause 64, which deals with the abolition of duty stamps for alcoholic products, and that will also help the whisky industry. The Government are doing a number of things to support the whisky industry and stand behind it, including the provisions on its tax status and the Secretary of State’s efforts to increase exports. The hon. Member should perhaps reflect that in his comments.