(2 days, 6 hours ago)
Public Bill Committees
Sarah Gibson
An important point to make here is that fire engineers tend to be involved in new buildings and fire assessors in remediation. Fire engineers are already well regulated, but fire assessors are not. There is no control over their qualifications and there is no accountability. My hon. Friend is trying to ensure that we have accountability. Auditing after the problem is commendable, but if we can avoid it to start with, that is so much better.
Gideon Amos
I am grateful to my hon. Friend, who has considerable experience in the industry. She is absolutely right in what she says. The important factor here is the independence of building safety assessors. How can someone in the pay of the owners—who have an interest in the outcome—be considered a suitable professional?
The distinction between building safety assessors and building inspectors is an accurate one. That is why we have another amendment that would address—[Interruption.] I hear some interesting off-stage effects.
(2 days, 6 hours ago)
Public Bill Committees
Gideon Amos
If no one else wishes to speak, I am happy to make some final comments on new clause 3.
I am grateful to the Minister for her response, as I am for all her responses to our amendments. She asked whether the eligibility would be too broad, but of course it could be defined in regulations made under the new clause. The new clause is targeted at leaseholders and residents, who are the ones who should not be left out of pocket. Self-evidently, they were not responsible for the building defects caused by the developers and the building owners who were at fault in the first place, so they should not be subject to those costs. Although the eligibility of individual cases can be looked at, we need a scheme that applies comprehensively to buildings under 11 metres. That is what the Bill lacks, and that is why we tabled the new clause.
The Minister says that the Government are open to looking at further measures to tackle buildings under 11 metres. We have done everything we can to help the Government: our new clause provides the measures that the Minister requires.
Sarah Gibson (Chippenham) (LD)
My hon. Friend will note that the general opinion of the witnesses who gave evidence on Thursday was that buildings under 11 metres tend to be resident-owned and therefore more likely to suffer financial pressures. The new clause would help them.
Gideon Amos
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for illustrating exactly the point that I was trying to make, albeit not quite as clearly as she did. Residents and leaseholders should not be left with the burden.
I suspect that it is possible that the Government have not been convinced by my remarks. On that basis, we will press new clause 3 to a vote when the time comes.
Question put and agreed to.
Clause 9 accordingly ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clauses 10 and 11 ordered to stand part of the Bill.
Clause 12
Offence: sections 7 and 8
Sarah Gibson
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Stringer. I rise to speak to Liberal Democrat amendment 14, which would make it clear that delays in applying for or receiving public funding under schemes such as the cladding safety scheme or the building safety scheme are not a reasonable excuse for failing to mitigate or remediate.
The purpose of the Bill is to deal with some of the delays and with the bad actors, as the hon. Member for Orpington mentioned. We have seen time and again—in fact, the BBC has run a series of articles—that waking watch patrols have been taking longer than necessary. It is clear that that is due to the fact that those are paid for by residents, whereas the repairs are paid for by the building owner. It is therefore in the interests of the building owner to delay until they get Government funding.
We need to make sure that building owners address problems in a timely manner and are not waiting. This amendment would send a clear message to those building owners who are attempting to delay that they must make sure that those delays do not adversely affect residents, as we have seen over the last few years, with huge bills for waking watch patrols. I therefore ask the Minister to accept the amendment.
Gideon Amos
I rise to endorse the comments from my hon. Friend the Member for Chippenham and also to briefly respond to the amendment tabled by the hon. Member for Orpington. The amendment would insert the defence of not knowing what the law is, which I find extraordinary. I know that he tables amendments sincerely in order to improve the Bill, so will he clarify whether the Conservatives are really saying that someone can just turn around and say, “Oh, sorry, I didn’t know what the law was when I stole your car”?
Sarah Gibson
Amendment 15 would place a duty on the Secretary of State to provide ringfenced funding to enforcement authorities to cover the full cost of enforcement and step-in remediation. Those of us who have had a long career in the building industry will know that a lack of enforcement, not a lack of legislation, is quite often the issue that causes delays, problems and a lack of clarity. The Minister mentioned earlier that the prospect of fines should be a deterrent, but I beg to mention that the prospect of fines would act as such only if enforcement is enacted and properly funded. Residents left without that option can be left with long legal action, which I want to avoid.
Gideon Amos
I have sympathy with the intent behind amendment 38, tabled by the hon. Member for Orpington, as it addresses one of the compelling points that came out of the witness sessions. I apologise: I was travelling to a funeral that day, so I could not be there. However, on reading Hansard afterwards, it became increasingly clear that the complex jungle of different responsibilities among regulators was a real cause for concern. Several witnesses pointed out the need to have either a single regulatory body, which is what the hon. Member is proposing, or at least a single framework.
I think it was pointed out that the LACORS agreements between local authorities and regulatory services would have to be rewritten some 147 times to cover all parts of the country, and the agreements and memoranda of understanding between local authorities and regulatory services would come on top of the agreement being shaped for the London area. That cannot be the right approach. I hope that the Minister will say something about how the issue can be better addressed. We cannot leave this Bill without addressing what all the witnesses said was necessary: having a single framework or regulator. Otherwise, we face the prospect of months or years of discussion, in each local authority up and down the land, to decide who will be the lead authority.