Debates between Gideon Amos and Gareth Bacon during the 2024 Parliament

Tue 3rd Nov 2026
Thu 29th Oct 2026
Tue 27th Oct 2026
Thu 10th Sep 2026

Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill (Fourth sitting)

Debate between Gideon Amos and Gareth Bacon
Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I am grateful to my hon. Friend for illustrating exactly the point that I was trying to make, albeit not quite as clearly as she did. Residents and leaseholders should not be left with the burden.

I suspect that it is possible that the Government have not been convinced by my remarks. On that basis, we will press new clause 3 to a vote when the time comes.

Question put and agreed to.

Clause 9 accordingly ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Clauses 10 and 11 ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Clause 12

Offence: sections 7 and 8

Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I beg to move amendment 30, in clause 12, page 7, line 3, after “they” insert “deliberately or knowingly”.

This amendment would ensure that the offence of failing to comply with the duties to mitigate and remediate would only be committed if the failure was knowing or deliberate.

--- Later in debate ---
Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I rise to endorse the comments from my hon. Friend the Member for Chippenham and also to briefly respond to the amendment tabled by the hon. Member for Orpington. The amendment would insert the defence of not knowing what the law is, which I find extraordinary. I know that he tables amendments sincerely in order to improve the Bill, so will he clarify whether the Conservatives are really saying that someone can just turn around and say, “Oh, sorry, I didn’t know what the law was when I stole your car”?

Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

No, of course that is not what we are saying. The building owner may not know that there is remediation that needs to take place; that is the point we are trying to make. If there is no dispute and remediation needs to take place, that remediation should take place. If they know that the building is unsafe and that remediation is required, but they are not doing it, that should be a criminal offence. It is not about whether they know what the law is; it is about whether they know that there is stuff that needs to be done to their building.

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I am grateful for that further explanation. I still find it difficult to understand how the abuse of such a provision could be avoided. The remediation orders will surely make it clear where there is a duty to remediate. The fact that anyone could say, “Sorry, I just didn’t know about it,” simply cannot be a defence.

Amendment 31 would provide a non-exclusive definition of what would count as a reasonable excuse. Similarly, I do not think we should be legislating in the Bill for excuses. We need to get remediation done, and it needs to happen in a timely way.

--- Later in debate ---
Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am sure the residents would have been entirely delighted to do so. However, if the fault lies with central Government not providing funding to an adequate timescale, it would be wrong to criminalise people for something outside their control. That is why we simply cannot support the amendment, which may disincentivise responsible entities from working quickly to explore new projects and get them started. That is a delay that we cannot afford, and one that residents do not deserve. For that reason, I am afraid we cannot support amendment 14.

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

Will the hon. Member give way?

Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My apologies, but I have just finished.

Question put, That the amendment be made.

Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill (Third sitting)

Debate between Gideon Amos and Gareth Bacon
Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

Amendment 5 would prohibit responsible entities—building owners and landlords—from appointing or directly paying assessors where a conflict of interest exists. It would require external wall assessments to be conducted by independent assessors registered with the Building Safety Regulator. This would be an important amendment in addressing the potential conflict of interest that I identified in relation to the previous group. We need assessors who are independently appointed and not chosen and paid by the building owners.

The report of the Grenfell Tower statutory inquiry, chaired by Sir Martin Moore-Bick, recommended that the Government consider whether building safety assessors should be part of a national body, a national service, independent of those being appointed by building owners. The subsequent review carried out by the Government concluded that there are ways in which the existing system can continue, but we contend that a different approach is required post Grenfell. The risk was highlighted in the Grenfell Tower report. We need assessors who are not paid by the building owners and are free of potential conflicts of interest. This is a straightforward amendment, and I propose it on that basis.

Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon (Orpington) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Alec. Amendment 21 stands in my name. Building safety work is critical work. It is vital not only that an effort is made to see all dangerous buildings fully remediated, but that such efforts are properly staffed, resourced and supported. Unfortunately, that is not currently the case. Remediation is a slow and complicated task and an undertaking that requires specialist assessments, trained engineers and skilled assessors. Those are in short supply, and the training needed to perform those roles is long and detailed. We must not give people trapped inside unsafe homes the false hope of a swift and straightforward end to their anxieties when we know that the manpower to undertake the task simply is not there. That would be poor legislating and damaging to what little trust remains in a system still reeling from the wider impacts of the tragic Grenfell Tower fire.

That is why I tabled amendment 21, which seeks to amend the deadline for carrying out risk assessments to 10 months after the Secretary of State has published an assessment of assessor capacity that demonstrates evidence that enough suitably qualified assessors exist to allow the deadline to be met. Without the knowledge that there are enough trained professionals to start and complete the work, we cannot offer residents the certainty that vital work can proceed. Without that certainty, it would be remiss of the Government to progress and it would be another failure that the system and residents cannot afford.

--- Later in debate ---
Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

The Minister deserves a break, but the length of her speech emphasises the seriousness of these clauses. I wish to say a few words on amendment 6, which was so ably introduced by my hon. Friend the Member for Chippenham. The Minister’s response was that the wording providing for remediation works to be carried out

“as soon as reasonably practicable”

is stronger than our proposed alternative wording,

“before the end of…24 months”.

That argument can succeed only if we are dealing with a contingent of building owners and developers the majority of whom are champing at the bit to get that work done. Where that is the case, there is nothing in our amendment that would prevent that from happening. Where it is not the case—for the most recalcitrant—our amendment would provide a backstop of 24 months. The Bill does not currently provide such a backstop, so our amendment would make it far stronger.

The other response to our amendment that could be inferred from what the Minister said is that it would give residents the burden of deciding whether work should go ahead or not. That is not the case. The decision on whether work should go ahead would remain with the regulator. The only decision for residents would be whether they are content for the works to take longer than would otherwise be required.

For all those reasons, our amendment would strengthen the Bill. It would provide the backstop that homeowners and leaseholders deserve on when the works will be carried out, and we will press it to a vote.

Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Like the hon. Member for Taunton and Wellington, I congratulate the Minister on her lengthy response—I am sure she is very tired.

Amendment 26 is not intended to be a get-out clause—far from it. The Minister mentioned that there will be statutory guidance on this point. Why not just put it in the Bill and remove any doubt now, rather than waiting until later? As such, we will press amendment 26 to a Division. I listened carefully to what the Minister said on amendment 27, and we are content to withdraw it.

The Minister said that amendment 34, on not creating a personal liability, could be covered by the reasonable excuse defence. The reasonable excuse defence is doing an awful lot of heavy lifting in the Bill, and we are concerned about its vagueness. Amendment 34 is a clarificatory amendment that would put it beyond reasonable doubt that individuals will not be unduly punished for things that are beyond their control, and we will press it to a Division.

I think the Minister knows what I am going to say about amendment 41 because we had a similar conversation yesterday. It is a periodic feature that Oppositions like Parliament to have scrutiny of what the Government are doing and the Government invariably do not want that to happen. This is such a weighty piece of legislation that the guidance should not be made at the whim of the Secretary of State’s pen, but should come to Parliament for approval, which would not hold the process up significantly. We will press amendment 41 to a Division.

I want to make a couple of remarks on amendment 6 tabled by the hon. Member for Chippenham. There is much in its intention that is to be commended, because no one wants to see remediation take any longer than is necessary—

Social Housing Bill (Fifth sitting)

Debate between Gideon Amos and Gareth Bacon
Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I echo the Minister’s sentiments. Obviously, on a subject like this, there will be disagreements across the House, but they have been largely respectful and, at times, quite good-humoured. I thank the Minister, his officials, my hon. Friends from the Opposition, the Liberal Democrats and all hon. Members on the Committee. I look forward to seeing you all on Report.

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I repeat the thanks from the Minister and the Opposition spokesman to officials. I thank my hon. Friends who have supported me, and the Minister for taking on board so many amendments—at least in spirit, if not in reality.

Question put and agreed to.

Bill, as amended, accordingly to be reported.

Social Housing Bill (Third sitting)

Debate between Gideon Amos and Gareth Bacon
Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I welcome the hon. Gentleman’s question, which anticipates the Liberal Democrats being in government and in a position to ensure delivery of housing. I point him to Eastleigh council, which has taken over a development of 2,000 homes not being delivered by its developer. It has made it a local authority development and is now driving it through. I recently went down to visit Liberal Democrat-run Cornwall council. The previous Liberal Democrat administration set up a housing company that is building 180,000 homes a year—sorry, I mean 180; I wish it were 180,000—and is using the profits from that to build social rent homes.

I invite the hon. Gentleman to join me in my constituency, where we are building 400 council homes on the North Taunton estate and have retained our council housing stock. Sadly, because of right to buy, it is not the 30,000 units it used to be—it is now only 6,000 homes—but we are doing what we can. My colleagues in Somerset council are bringing new council houses to parts of Somerset for the first time in a generation. I encourage the hon. Gentleman to look at the activity of Liberal Democrat authorities on the ground.

New clause 1 would set a target of 150,000 social homes a year, which would something for the Government to aspire to. If not that target, what target will the Government set and when? The new clause does not require that many to be built; it is not a money resolution. It would simply require the Government to publish a strategy for what would be required to reach the target. If the Government are serious about the housing crisis, they should have no objection to setting a target of this kind. In our manifesto, we set an allocation of £6 billion a year towards that achievement. I appreciate that it would take a number of years to reach 150,000.

In the interests of time, I will move on to new clause 4, concerning borrowing restrictions on local authorities. I will give some “Hear, hears” to the Government for the Prime Minister’s words about reviving council housing and delivering a lot more of it, though I fear there are more words than pounds in his pronouncement. Shelter has commissioned research from Savills examining the impact of the housing revenue account debt on councils’ ability to build new social homes. The research found that writing off HRA debt could unlock between 190,000 and 284,000 dwellings.

Shelter also recently published research with Pragmatix Advisory that assesses the economic and financial case for cancelling HRA debt and investing in social housing. The central conclusion is that the policy would be compliant with the Government’s fiscal rules, while generating a substantial long-term economic benefit of £140 billion over a 60-year timeframe. My colleagues in Somerset council told me that if were not for the Government’s self-financing debt rules, they could build out another 630 council houses on top of the ones that I outlined to the hon. Member for Rugby.

I appreciate that the costs of writing off that debt would be significant—I am sure that the Minister has made that point—but if the Government will not write off all that debt, will they write off some of it? In our manifesto, the Liberal Democrats put an extra £2 billion a year into this area. Will the Government put in £2 million to write off some HRA debt? It is important to get councils building again. Those that have their housing revenue account maxed out have the political will, and in many cases the experience, to do so, but they lack the necessary financial headroom. If we want to get councils building, we need to look seriously at the HRA debt.

Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon (Orpington) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Sir Roger. I rise to speak to my new clause 34. I regret that my pointing out that the Bill will not create a single new social home appeared to get under the Minister’s skin on Tuesday, but the fact is that the Bill does not create any extra housing. That is not a surprise, as it comes from a Government who have built just 26% of their target in nearly 50% of their time in office. None the less, it is simply not good enough.

Moreover, in the places—few and far between—where the Government have tried to get Britain building, that has nearly always come at the cost of green belt protections, despite the fact that research from the Campaign to Protect Rural England shows that a large proportion of the Government’s lofty housing target could swiftly be met using brownfield land that already has planning permission. The CPRE estimates that up to 1.41 million homes could be built on existing brownfield land in England, based on data from local planning authorities’ brownfield land registers up to 2024.

Social Housing Bill (First sitting)

Debate between Gideon Amos and Gareth Bacon
Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mr Vickers.

I rise to support the clause. For Liberal Democrats, this is the most important and significant clause in the Bill, as it constrains the selling off of council houses. It is concerning that the Conservatives have tabled an amendment that would essentially reverse it. With 1.32 million people on the housing waiting list and 177,000 children in temporary accommodation, the last thing that we need is to continue the gradual loss of social housing. There has been a net loss of 2 million social homes since the introduction of right to buy. If that does not show that we cannot fill the bath with the plug taken out, nothing does. We stand squarely in support of the clause, although we would go further and give local authorities the ability and power to suspend right to buy completely if that is right for their area so that they can rebuild their stock of council housing and social rent homes.

Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon (Orpington) (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I echo the Minister’s welcome: it is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mr Vickers.

This Bill fails the British people. It effectively destroys right to buy for millions of families. It does nothing to free up stock for British nationals. It fails to introduce efficient stock management regulations. Most egregiously, it fails to build a single social home—a point completely missed by the Government and the Liberal Democrats. In scrutinising the Bill line by line, it is critically important that we defend aspiration and refocus the debate on the delivery of new homes.

I will speak to new clauses 55 and 57 and amendments 84 and 85, in my name. On new clause 55, in the past, Conservative Government-backed schemes such as Help to Buy and stamp duty discounts made a real difference to people buying their first home, and helped about 1 million first-time buyers to get on to the housing ladder. That contributed to 800,000 people buying their first home under the previous Government. However, since 2024 the Government have not shown that they have the aspiration to match that. Instead, they have cut a lot of the products that turbocharged first-time buyers getting on to the housing ladder.

Even when the Government try to support young people into property ownership, it emerges that all that glisters is not gold. I am primarily referring to the Your First Home scheme—a policy limited to new homes and expected to be constrained by income caps. Young people, especially young people in social housing, deserve better than that.

--- Later in debate ---
Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

The hon. Member is quite right. Not only that, but local authorities end up paying over the odds for placing families in temporary accommodation, sometimes in homes that were built as council houses to provide for those families in the first place. Now they are being sublet, sometimes multiple times, to provide that housing.

Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The hon. Gentleman is being very generous with his time. He has made a point that has been made by Members today and on Second Reading: right to buy diminishes the social housing stock. I would agree on paper that it does, but that has to be read in the context, as shown by the House of Lords Library, that right to buy applies only to people in long-term tenancies who have been social tenants for a long time. Some 78% of people living in social housing are on lifetime tenancies. Those properties are not available. They could not be given to anybody else because they are lifetime tenancies. Right to buy is actually providing the receipts to build more social homes for people to live in.

--- Later in debate ---
Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Stopping people from getting on the housing ladder does not help one bit, because it does not increase the supply, and that point seems to have been missed completely by the Liberal Democrats and by the Government.

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I am somewhat surprised that the Opposition spokesperson has entered into the realm of social housing supply, given the record of the previous Conservative Government. Of course, we need to increase supply as well as saving the stock that has been built with public funds—taxpayer’s money—for the community, rather than giving over discounts, sometimes to the extent of a £70,000 or £80,000 transfer of cash, from the taxpayer into the hands of individual property owners for no good reason.

We need to increase supply. That is why the Liberal Democrats have a target to build 150,000 social rent homes per year. I do not know the hon. Gentleman’s party’s target for the delivery of social housing—they did not build many when they were in government. We need to give local authorities the power and flexibility to decide for themselves whether it is right to continue with right to buy in their areas. If we believe in local communities and local democracy, we should give them the ability to say that right to buy and the loss of more council housing stock is no longer right for their area. I commend new clause 2 to the Committee and urge all Committee members to vote for it.

Social Housing Bill [Lords]

Debate between Gideon Amos and Gareth Bacon
Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I thank the hon. Member for I forget where—he does not mention it very often, but maybe it is Harlow. He is right and I will come to exactly that point about temporary accommodation.

The Resolution Foundation found that only one home was replaced for every five sold. That is a direct failure of Governments of all persuasions to build enough social housing. The Conservatives reversed their policy of allowing councils to spend 100% of receipts soon after they introduced it. In comparison, in 2004, a Labour Government required three quarters of receipts to be sent straight to the Treasury. Homes were sold at around half their value, and what money there was from receipts went elsewhere, not into building new social homes, and building rates plummeted.

I am glad that the new Prime Minister talks a good game on devolution, but even under the measures in this Bill, councils will remain unable to stop the loss of council homes from right to buy. The Liberal Democrats would give councils that power to end right to buy in their areas, if that is right for them and their communities. The Government should trust councils to understand their communities and their own housing markets.

When it comes to the Conservatives, who seem to be chasing their ideological bedfellows in the Reform party, apparently the priority is not building housing; it is finding a minority to blame for the problem—a group to alienate as “the other” when we should be focusing on building for the whole of the UK and everyone who lives here. Their amendment banning people who are not full British citizens from social housing overlooks the fact that people subject to immigration control are already ineligible for social housing—that is the law—but they want to go further.

The nurse on the ward at Musgrove Park hospital, in my constituency, would not be welcome under this Conservative amendment and would not be allowed to have a social home or a council house. The care worker who looked after people during the pandemic would not be welcome under this Conservative amendment. Under a Conservative Government, they would have nowhere to live when it comes to council and social housing. That is ironic for a party that has produced two Prime Ministers born outside Britain. As the Member of Parliament for Taunton and Wellington, I do not know whether I should inform his grace the Duke of Wellington that the first Duke of Wellington would not fully be a British citizen under the Conservative amendment tabled today because he was born outside Britain.

Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

That is total rubbish!

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I suggest the hon. Gentleman reads the Conservative amendment that refers to reserving social housing for British citizens.

Gareth Bacon Portrait Gareth Bacon
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The Duke of Wellington was British.

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

No, the Duke of Wellington was not born in Britain—the hon. Gentleman needs to have a look at his history books—[Interruption.] Regardless of the history of the Duke of Wellington, attempts to use the Bill to pump up divisive culture-war claptrap does not deserve our attention. Rather than pointing the finger of blame at minorities, we should be talking about how to build more social homes, and that is exactly what I will go on to do.

The failure to replace social homes, among other factors, means that more and more people are in temporary accommodation. There are 132,000 households in temporary accommodation, and councils spent £2.8 billion on it last year. The scourge of poor-quality temporary accommodation exists for far too many children, and that is why we need a big public housing programme to match the scale of the challenge. If for no other reason, we must do that because it is incumbent on all of us in this House, across parties, to end the tragic loss of children’s lives. The Shared Health Foundation has highlighted that temporary accommodation was found by a coroner to be a contributing factor in the deaths of 104 children in the last five years.