All 1 Debates between Gavin Williamson and Ben Goldsborough

Tue 17th Nov 2026

Immigration and Asylum Bill

Debate between Gavin Williamson and Ben Goldsborough
Ben Goldsborough Portrait Ben Goldsborough
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

No, I am saying that the new clause proposed by the Liberal Democrats is unenforceable. We must be serious about legislation that we try to pass in this House. If we try to pass legislation that finds us in the wrong, while also not being able to do the grown-up politics of international negotiations, we will look ridiculous in the eyes of our constituents.

That brings me to the amendments tabled by His Majesty’s loyal Opposition. My constituents know exactly where the approach of performative politics gets us. We saw it with the Brook hotel, where asylum accommodation was placed just 500 yards down the road from residents, without proper consultation. People were left feeling ignored and taken for granted. That is what happens when politics becomes about headlines rather than delivering workable solutions and engaging with communities. The Bill seeks to take a different approach. It is compassionate but firm, protects our international commitments while restoring common sense, and it puts in place a rules-based system that the public can have confidence in. That is what South Norfolk residents expect Parliament to deliver, and it is time that we got on and passed the Bill.

Another aspect of the Bill that is important to reiterate, and vital for my constituents, is the provision that allows the Secretary of State to require payment from people who have received asylum support. That is welcomed by my constituents, but it is vital to reiterate that there is a carve-out to ensure that minors, under the age of 18, who receive asylum support are not liable for those costs later on, which underlines the fact that the Bill is firm but fair.

As the Bill goes forward for consideration in the other place, I hope we can show that we take these matters seriously. I thank the Bill Committee members from across the House for discussing the issue in a grown-up way. We need to take the heat out of the debate, so that we consider things that benefit our constituents and do not divide our communities.

Gavin Williamson Portrait Sir Gavin Williamson
- View Speech - Hansard - -

There is much in the Bill that I agree with and support. However, there is a danger that it presents a missed opportunity to deliver a greater and better good, so most of my comments will address new clauses 4, 5 and 7. I thank the Independent Anti-Slavery Commissioner, Eleanor Lyons, the charities Hope for Justice, Unseen and the Human Trafficking Foundation, and, of course, the brilliant Clerks for the drafting of new clauses 4 and 5—I hope that will get me further assistance in future.

The scope of the Bill is broad and it covers many aspects of the subject. When I was Chief Whip, I would probably have described it as something of a Christmas tree, as it both offers opportunities and presents problems for the Government. It touches on human trafficking, but it does not really seek to do anything. In this country we should be rightly proud of the historical role that this House played in tackling slavery right around the world, including the actions of the West Africa Squadron. We have led the way, not just in words and ideals but, just as importantly, with actions.

Like many Members of the House, I feel proud of my small role—of course your role was much larger than mine, Madam Deputy Speaker—in the Modern Slavery Act, which all Members voted for when it was passed in 2015. In reality, that Act went some way towards making the moral arguments, but it did not go far enough on enforcement—there was no West Africa Squadron as a result of that Act. We talked a good talk, but we did not do enough to follow up, which is what I seek to amend through new clauses 4 and 5. The Bill should be about more than just a good argument and good deeds; it should be about actions flowing from those moral arguments.

As was articulately put by the hon. Member for Stoke-on-Trent Central (Gareth Snell), the Modern Slavery Act went some way but does not have the enforcement element. I would be bolder than him and say that we have to go further than what is proposed in new clause 7. We know that there are certain parts of the world that produce goods under slave labour, so we can designate those areas, which is what new clauses 4 and 5 aim to do. The Minister for Border Security and Asylum is an incredibly thoughtful and passionate woman, who came into politics to make a difference, in common with so many of us in this House. The Bill tackles many issues, but it leaves that question open and it could do more.

The issue of goods produced under slave labour is impacting our businesses in the United Kingdom. The Government say that they want to build more houses, but we do not want those houses to be built from bricks that are produced by slave labour in other countries. This is not a marginal thing—we are talking about almost 50 million people across the globe who are either in slave labour or indentured labour, almost the same number as the population of Spain. I beseech the Minister to work with me, the other organisations I mentioned and the Independent Anti-Slavery Commissioner to do everything we can do to ensure the Bill tackles those issues.