Financial Services and Markets Bill [HL] Debate

Full Debate: Read Full Debate
Department: HM Treasury
Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle Portrait Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, it is a pleasure to briefly follow the noble Baroness, Lady Hayman, and to applaud the work of her and her allies that has got us to this place, as she said, after a great deal of struggle. One day, we will simply have these provisions arriving in the Bills without the need for struggle—we can but hope.

I have one simple question to put to the Minister, which was inspired by attending “The People’s Emergency Briefing” on climate and nature in Gravesend on Saturday night. It was one of some 3,500 events held all around the country after the initial event in Westminster. We have yet to hear from the Conservative Front Bench, but House rumours suggest that the Opposition are going to oppose this amendment. If that is the case, would the Minister agree that they would benefit from seeing that briefing? I therefore ask the Minister—this is the first time I have asked under the new Prime Minister —whether the Government will organise a live national televised emergency briefing on climate and nature, as all these local events are asking.

Baroness Kramer Portrait Baroness Kramer (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, my colleagues and noble friends Lady Sheehan and Lady Northover spoke eloquently on these issues on Report. If this amendment is pressed and the others are moved by the Government, we will support them.

Baroness Neville-Rolfe Portrait Baroness Neville-Rolfe (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, as this is Third Reading, I want to start by extending my warm thanks to the Minister and his team for their work on the Bill. I welcome the movement that the Government have shown on several of the issues that we have raised during the passage of this 137-page Bill, which in general we support.

Chief among them is proportionality, which will continue to apply to the regulators in the exercise of their day-to-day functions. That change reflects concerns on all sides of the House; my hope is that it will help to reduce the burden on SMEs, so I thank the Minister for this. I also welcome the movement we have seen on the important issue of financial education and look forward to engaging on that. It is becoming ever more important, whether you are a pupil, a student applying for a loan, or an adult managing your finances or thinking about retirement.

However, there remain important issues which the Government have not yet addressed sufficiently. Among them are the Henry VIII powers in Clause 3 and Clause 50 and the first use of the extensive new powers in the Bill. I understand the Government intend to reintroduce Clause 3 at a later stage in the Bill’s passage with further detail, and that is welcome, but it does not detract from the fundamental point at issue. One of Parliament’s principal functions is to scrutinise government legislation, and we simply cannot do so properly when Bills confer broad powers without setting out clearly how they are to be used.

A digital asset strategy to support faster action to stop further loss of digital entrepreneurs and less aggressive use of Section 166 are two areas where we believe the Government should go further, because we have heard consistent concerns from industry.

Turning to the amendments, I deeply regret the amendments the Government are introducing today on climate change. This represents a serious U-turn by the Government. Their original proposal was to move these considerations into five-year strategies. The existing requirements they dispensed with are largely superfluous and burdensome. There is little evidence that today’s amendments to restore them make any meaningful contribution, either to reducing climate change or to protecting the environment. At a time when businesses are already facing considerable pressure, and when our wider economic circumstances demand an unrelenting focus on growth, competitiveness and investment, imposing further needless regulatory burdens is the wrong direction of travel.

I would also suggest that, for an economy as dependent as ours on international investment, these amendments send entirely the wrong signal. We should be demonstrating to investors overseas that the UK is a predictable and attractive market. Instead, they reinforce the perception that doing business here means ever more regulation, additional cost and greater complexity for no clear practical benefit. At Second Reading, the then-Minister, the noble Lord, Lord Stockwood, who I am glad to see in his place, said that the purpose of the Bill was to

“modernise how the sector is regulated”

and

“enable it to grow”.—[Official Report, 8/6/26; col. 1146.]

These amendments seem to run directly contrary to that objective. I am deeply disappointed that the Government have abandoned that principle so quickly and with so little resistance. We on these Benches have been consistent in our opposition to this duty, which we have made clear in the House and in discussions with the Minister. I shall seek to divide the House when the amendments are called.

--- Later in debate ---
Lord Pitt-Watson Portrait Lord Pitt-Watson (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, this Bill delivers important reforms to ensure that the UK’s financial services sector remains open, innovative and internationally competitive while maintaining high regulatory standards and protecting consumers. It strengthens the legislative framework for financial services, supports growth and investment, and ensures that our regulators have the appropriate powers and responsibilities to respond to a rapidly changing market.

The Bill has benefited considerably from noble Lords’ detailed scrutiny and expertise throughout its passage. I hope noble Lords feel that the Government have listened carefully to the arguments advanced in Committee and on Report, and that we have brought forward amendments which were appropriate in response. The Bill, of course, is broad. It touches on lots of areas, but it is united by one common theme, shared by the House: we want to create a clear set of rules which allow the financial industry to serve its customers better and to prosper by doing so.

I thank all noble Lords who contributed to our debates, perhaps in particular my noble friend Lord Stockwood, who led the early stages of the Bill. I also thank my officials, who supported the Bill throughout its passage. It was no mean task. I am also particularly grateful to the Opposition and Liberal Democrat Front Benches; to the noble Baroness, Lady Noakes, and other members of the Financial Services Regulation Committee; to members of Peers for the Planet; and to noble Lords across the House, including Cross-Benchers, for their constructive engagement. If I had a special thank you it would be to my Whip, my noble friend Lord Wilson, without whom I would have found this process quite impossible.

The Bill leaves this House strengthened by the scrutiny that we have given it. I beg to move.

Baroness Kramer Portrait Baroness Kramer (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I will be brief, which has been my practice—as people may have noticed —throughout much of this Bill. I open by saying thank you to the Minister and to the Box. They have been very willing to share their time with us, brief us and listen to issues that we raised. We did not always get the response that we wanted, but it was a positive engagement that gives us some hope for making progress.

I think the Minister came to this Bill having been told that it was a minor, technical Bill. That probably could not have been more wrong. I am glad we achieved what we did, working across the Opposition Benches. I give credit to Conservative Peers—the noble Baronesses, Lady Noakes and Lady Neville-Rolfe, and others—as well as, on my side, to my noble friends Lady Bowles and Lord Sharkey in trying to deal with the issues around proportionality.

There is a great deal left in accountability that will have to be tackled in future Bills. As we see the speed-up in AI, crypto and the other rapid changes that are coming, we will have to find a new way, as a Parliament, to engage. I also thank the noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe, for putting in an amendment that began to deal with the digital issue. I really believe that not covering that within this Bill was a miss-out. The Government will have to step up to the plate again very shortly.

I am also very grateful for the fact that we got support on the child trust fund issue, again from the Tory Benches. It is something I feel very personally, as people can probably guess. It benefits 80,000 disabled youngsters who have been unable to access money that is theirs that is sitting in trust fund accounts.

I thank my noble friend Lord Sharkey in particular for fighting the battle for the FOS—that battle is not over either. I also thank my noble friends Lady Northover and Lady Sheehan; we would have gone farther on the climate change, environment and deforestation issues, but we feel that an important step was taken by the Government in the amendments moved today.

This has been a very constructive Bill, but, frankly, it was not the maximum use that could have been made of a financial services Bill and I hope that we will see another one come along shortly. There are problems to be tackled, not least the issues of mortgage prisoners and community development financial institutions, as well as the utterly significant constitutional issue of accountability and how the regulators need to be effectively accountable to Parliament. I thank the whole House for working on a very complex set of issues, particularly as it entered this phase with the understanding that it was only going to be about minor technicalities.