Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
Visitor Levy (England) Bill Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateAshley Fox
Main Page: Ashley Fox (Conservative - Bridgwater)Department Debates - View all Ashley Fox's debates with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
(2 days, 3 hours ago)
Commons Chamber
Alison Hume (Scarborough and Whitby) (Lab)
I would like to draw the attention of Members to my position on the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee and as the chair of the all-party parliamentary group for coastal communities.
“All I Want for Christmas Is You” is once again playing everywhere as we head into the festive season, but if people actually want to see the diva behind the song live in concert, they should head to sunny Scarborough next summer. Along with the Kaiser Chiefs, Alfie Boe, Robert Plant and many more, Mariah Carey will be performing at Scarborough’s own Open Air Theatre, no doubt helping to smash the venue’s 2026 record of 180,000 tickets sold and £18 million generated for the local economy. Most of those music lovers will travel from across the UK, booking out local, family-run hotels, B&Bs and short-term lets for a night or two, and boosting the tourism and hospitality sector.
Despite our successes, the tourism economy on the beautiful part of the coast that I represent is fragile, due to years of under-investment in coastal towns under the Conservatives, as well as seasonality, the high cost of energy, the cost of employing staff and the price sensitivity of domestic tourists. International visitors will not think twice about a 5% charge on a stay in a four or five-star hotel in York, but domestic visitors will definitely look at the cost of a holiday at one caravan park near Filey and compare it with the cost of a stay at another caravan park a few miles away in Bridlington, which might not be charging the levy.
I support the Bill, and I am not against the overnight visitor levy in principle. I believe it works well in cities and will do well in York, but before it is rolled out to coastal towns like Scarborough and Whitby, we need to see the nitty-gritty of an economic impact assessment. I welcome the provisions in the Bill that ensure that local businesses will have to be consulted before any levy is introduced, because at a recent roundtable in Whitby, several operators reported to me that visitor numbers and occupancy rates are already under pressure; some noted that occupancy levels are at their lowest in a decade. The idea of the overnight visitor levy is that the money raised stays in the area, helping to attract more visitors, support local businesses and improve places for the people who live there. I support that idea, but when the area is 3,000 square miles, what does “local” really look like? Will the money raised in Scarborough, Whitby and the villages stay in Scarborough, Whitby and the villages, or will it disappear into a big pot? In 2025, North Yorkshire welcomed 31.2 million visitors, generating an economic impact of £4.3 billion. The stakes are high.
I could come up with a wish list of investments that the mayor could make with the proceeds of an overnight visitor levy, including in the Whitby cliff lift, the Capitol theatre, and toilets in Danby and Hinderwell—indeed, some in Scarborough town centre would be nice. However, before we dream, we must be clear-eyed about the regional and patchwork nature of uptake of the levy. If the mayors either side of us do not impose it, might we push our incredibly price-sensitive small hotels and caravan parks metaphorically over the cliff, as holidaymakers book where there is no levy?
Sir Ashley Fox (Bridgwater) (Con)
The hon. Lady is making a very good speech. Does she agree that a £2.50-per-head tourist tax on a family of four takes £70 away from that family and gives it to the mayor? That is £70 that they otherwise would have spent in Scarborough or Whitby on drinks, a meal, or treats for the children. Is the real danger not that the tourist tax undermines the purchasing power of tourists with modest means who choose to holiday in England?
Alison Hume
On this occasion, I agree with the hon. Gentleman. Under these proposals, a family staying at the Blue Dolphin holiday park for two weeks in the summer could pay an extra £152. At a time when households are already feeling the squeeze, that is a significant extra cost, and one we need to think about carefully.
Scarborough and Whitby will always be destinations in their own right, but what about families seeking the humble bucket-and-spade holiday, for whom the object of the holiday is not necessarily the destination, but the ingredients—sea, sand, fish and chips, ice cream and, if you are lucky, sun? Will holidaymakers navigate to towns that offer all this, but without the extra charge? In polling of around 10,000 adults by Stack Data Strategy for UKHospitality, 18% said that any increase in cost would stop them booking a holiday, and 85% said that they would be deterred by a £100 increase.
What about corporate travel, business, tourism and conference-related visits? Will people book rooms in the Tees Valley and Greater Lincolnshire to avoid the North Yorkshire tourist levy? The impact of lost bookings would be felt not just by accommodation providers, but by pubs, restaurants, cafés, attractions and other businesses that depend on visitors. I welcome the Government’s move to devolve decisions to local leaders who best understand their region, allowing them to tailor investment towards growing the local economy and making their area better for people to visit and enjoy. I very much look forward to working with Mayor Skaith as he consults the communities we both represent. As Mariah Carey might say to Mayor Skaith, “I don’t want a lot for Christmas; there is just one thing I need. Visit Scarborough and Whitby, so we can bring you up to speed.”
Sir Ashley Fox (Bridgwater) (Con)
Tourism and hospitality are vital to the whole of the UK. The sector employs millions of people and sustains communities in every corner of our country. It is particularly important in Somerset, where we welcome thousands of tourists every year.
The sector is having a tough time at the moment. It has at last recovered from the devastating effects of the pandemic, and visitor numbers have returned to pre-covid levels, but it is now weighed down by the many additional burdens that this Government have placed on them. Many hospitality businesses already pay VAT, business rates, corporation tax and national insurance contributions, as well as struggling with rising food and energy costs. Instead of providing help, the Government now propose a new tax on holidays, tourism and business travel. This tourist tax comes on top of Labour’s unemployment rights Act, Labour’s jobs tax and increases to the minimum wage by substantially more than the rate of inflation. It threatens to put people off visiting beautiful seaside areas such as Burnham-on-Sea, Berrow and Brean in my constituency.
The breadth of opposition to this tax is striking. UKHospitality, ABTA, Premier Inn, Choice Hotels and the Country Land and Business Association have all raised concerns. UKHospitality warned that a 5% overnight visitor levy could place 33,000 jobs at risk and deliver a £2 billion hit to the economy. The owner of Premier Inn has described the proposal as hugely damaging. Choice Hotels has said that operators feel that they are being strangled by additional costs.
Yet again, this Government think they know better than businesses. Their guiding policy towards the economy seems to be, “If it moves, tax it. If it continues to move, regulate it.” Only when it stops moving do they wish to nationalise it. This is a lesson in how not to grow a crucial sector in our economy. The Government’s stated ambition is to grow visitor numbers to 50 million by 2030, yet at the very same time they are making visits to England more expensive. Perhaps the Minister could explain how she intends to reconcile those two objectives.
I am particularly concerned about the impact on domestic tourism. Families already face difficult financial decisions. A tourism levy may appear modest in Whitehall, but for a family of four enjoying a week’s holiday, it can quickly become a significant additional expense. In many parts of the country, this may not have a huge impact. We have heard the hon. Member for Bath (Wera Hobhouse) say that she wants a levy on her city, and the hon. Member for Cities of London and Westminster (Rachel Blake) said that she welcomes the levy. Large cities attracting wealthy foreign tourists may be all right, but has the Minister assessed the risk on those people looking to take domestic holidays—families with modest incomes who go to seaside towns like those in my constituency? A tax of £2.50 per person per night will add £70 to the cost of a week’s holiday for a family of four. That is £70 that will not be spent on drinks or a meal or treats for children. It will reduce the spending impact of that tourist family on the whole economy.
I have another serious concern about the concept of this tax. This tourist tax will not be ringfenced to support the areas in which it is collected. The Government claim that the levy will support growth and improve destinations, yet there is no requirement in the Bill for the proceeds to be spent on tourism infrastructure, destination marketing, visitor facilities or local attractions. Businesses will be asked to collect this tax. They will become another army under the control of HMRC, and they will be fined if they get it wrong—or perhaps put in prison for 14 years. Visitors will be asked to pay it, yet the revenue could ultimately be diverted elsewhere entirely.
In Somerset, that means that money raised in Burnham-on-Sea, Berrow and Brean will most probably be spent by the Liberal Democrats on management consultants in Taunton, because that is what they seem to spend most of their money on. It is risking the livelihoods of working people in tourist towns to give additional revenue to a failing council.
I do not want a tourist tax, but if the Government genuinely believe that this is a tourism levy, why will they not guarantee that the money is spent on tourism? Why not ringfence at least a proportion of the proceeds for investment in the visitor economy in the areas where the revenue is raised?
Tom Gordon
Earlier, we heard proposals that a portion of proceeds could be diverted to organisations or groups, such as town or parish councils, that are responsible for putting on events, managing toilets and sorting out flowers and flower beds. Does the hon. Member agree that is sensible and that the Government should bring it forward?
Sir Ashley Fox
I would much rather not have the tax at all, but if it is going to happen and, as the Government say, it is for the benefit of tourism areas, my question is: why not ringfence it? I suspect the honest answer is that the Government intend for it to become a general form of revenue for mayors and councils that will have nothing to do with tourists at all.
Does my hon. Friend share the suspicion of many of us that the Government’s view is that this additional revenue will simply be netted off the grants provided to local authorities? Certainly, the feedback from the consultation undertaken by the Local Government Association was that the levy would likely result in zero additional revenue to those local authorities because, in effect, the money would be then deducted from other sources, so nobody except the Treasury would be better off as a consequence.
Sir Ashley Fox
My hon. Friend makes a wise point. That is precisely what will happen. Over time, the tourism levy will rise and the Government will restrict the amount of money going to those local authorities that have particularly high numbers of tourists. I thought it was naive of the hon. Member for Cities of London and Westminster to welcome the tax because all the money would be spent on her constituents. She is not in her place, but I tell her that that money will be spent on the Mayor of London’s pet projects, and none of those will be in the Cities of London and Westminster. Most worryingly of all, the Bill contains no statutory cap on the levy; perhaps today’s modest charge will become tomorrow’s significant burden.
Tourism is not a problem to be taxed; it is a success to be encouraged. The Bill will undermine growth, make staycations less attractive, increase costs for business and families, and raise revenue that will not be spent on the communities generating it. That is why I shall vote against the Bill tonight.