Mental Health Bill [HL]

Debate between Baroness Hollins and Baroness Barker

Committee stage
Monday 24th February 2025 Lords Chamber

[Baroness Barker (LD)]

My Lords, I will try to draw together some of the strands that we have been discussing in this debate. When the Minister responds, please will she share with the Committee the department’s and the Government’s thoughts on workforce planning and the modelling they use for the prediction of demand?

As I listened to my noble friend Lady Parminter eloquently introduce her amendment, it brought to mind friends of mine. They have been in the position where their child was diagnosed with a very severe eating disorder, but they were told, “You are not sufficiently ill for anything to happen”. From that stage, nothing happened. If it were a physical illness, there would be some kind of process—although maybe not a care pathway. I am sorry, but I am one of those people who is very cynical about the use of the phrase “care pathway”; it is very overused throughout the whole of health, and particularly in mental health. People are diagnosed and then are just left, until they become so ill that they are in crisis and it is impossible to ignore them. We have seen the trends in the number of young people with eating disorders, which my noble friend Lady Parminter mentioned. What is the department doing to forecast the demand for specialists of that nature in future?

I want also to return to some of the conversations and debates that were sparked by the noble Lord, Lord Davies of Brixton. We know that the police are going to withdraw from being the first responders when people are in crisis. What modelling are the Government doing in terms of the community provision that is needed to deal with those people—who will still be in crisis? They are not going to stop having crises; in fact, they are probably more likely to show up in in hospitals than ever before, because that is where people go in the middle of the night when they have a crisis.

This is the sort of argument that the noble Baroness, Lady Tyler of Enfield, was trying to get to in her discussion of having a mental health commissioner. Who will be the person who is in a position to take the Government to task for their planning and preparation for demands on the health service in the future? That is the kind of thing that we are trying to get to, and which all of us, in various different ways, have been trying to get to all afternoon.

[Baroness Hollins (CB)]

Can I just say that I did not talk about a “care pathway”? Perhaps I should have said the “patient journey”, but I was talking about the patient pathway—the actual experience of the person—which is not separated in their life.