Criminal Cases Review Commission

(asked on 9th May 2024) - View Source

Question to the Ministry of Justice:

To ask His Majesty's Government what procedure, if any, exists within the Criminal Cases Review Commission for ensuring priority is given to those cases where an applicant has a limited life expectancy, due to age or infirmity.


Answered by
Lord Bellamy Portrait
Lord Bellamy
This question was answered on 23rd May 2024

Information on the number of cases received and completed, and the average duration of a review, is available on the Criminal Cases Review Commission’s (CCRC) website and in their annual report. The table below provides data for the last five complete business years:

Applications Received

Cases Completed

Average Duration of a Review (from allocation to initial decision)

2019-20

1334

1453

31.7 weeks

2020-21

1142

1109

35.1 weeks

2021-22

1198

1183

34.4 weeks

2022-23

1424

1275

38.7 weeks

2023-24

1629

1441

35.1 weeks

The average number of Case Review Managers over the past five years is as follows:

Year ending 31 March

Case Review Manager Average Headcount

2019 – 2020

30

2020 – 2021

30

2021 – 2022

29

2022 – 2023

29

2023 - 2024

31

Section three of the CCRC’s published Case Review Process policy (CW-POL-04-Case-Review-Process-v3.0.pdf (cloud-platform-e218f50a4812967ba1215eaecede923f.s3.amazonaws.com)) outlines that cases are generally allocated in date order of receipt. However, there are several exceptional factors which determine the degree of priority once a case is under review. These assessments are fluid and relative to the needs of other cases. There are several factors for a case to be given higher priority, these include old age (75 years or older) and/or ill health, supported by medical evidence, where there is concern that the applicant may die before the case is dealt with. In addition, evidence that the applicant’s serious ill health (or that of any close family member of the applicant) is directly and significantly aggravated by any delay will also result in the case being given higher priority. The full list of factors for a case to be given a higher priority can be found in the Case Review Process policy.

Reticulating Splines