Question to the Ministry of Justice:
To ask the Secretary of State for Justice, whether he will bring forward legislation to remove the requirement in new section 8A(1)(b)(i) of the Sexual Offences Act 2003 for the prosecution to prove that a defendant aged 18 or over did not reasonably believe that a child aged 13, 14 or 15 was aged 16 or over.
We are committed to implementing these important measures to strengthen protections for children and tackle grooming. We are working with criminal justice partners to address the practical and operational requirements for implementation, so that the measures can deliver the intended protections as effectively as possible. The commencement is not dependent on the outcome of the consultation on close-in-age relationships.
“Reasonable belief as to age” is a necessary and appropriate element of the existing and new criminal offences, as it ensures that only those who are genuinely culpable are caught by the criminal law. Thousands of abusers have been successfully prosecuted for the existing offences which include this element, demonstrating that convictions are being secured under the existing framework.
We have heard the concerns which have been raised in relation to “reasonable belief as to age” and will conduct a post-implementation review, after the new offences have been commenced, to test the impact they are having. This review will also include examination of how the “reasonable belief as to age” element is operating. However, as this post-implementation review cannot be conducted until the new offences are in force, we will now seek evidence on the operation of “reasonable belief as to age” in the existing offences. Any evidence received will help to shape our future work.