Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill

Baroness Coffey Excerpts

Friday 12th December 2025 Lords Chamber

[Lord Winston (Lab)]

My Lords—

[Baroness Coffey (Con)]

My Lords, should we not hear from the noble Lords who have tabled the amendments before we—

[Noble Lords]

Order!

--- Later in debate ---

[Lord Mackinlay of Richborough (Con)]

I will just come back on that, if I may. I would also say that the wording in the amendments in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Grey-Thompson, is insufficient, because it is a far more complex issue than that. As I said, there is a world of difference between a very early embryo in the first few weeks and a close to full-term pregnancy. I certainly hope that this Committee would agree that point.

[Baroness Coffey (Con)]

My Lords, I really had hoped that we would get to the next group but, as it is clear that we will not, I will raise a couple of points and some questions. The increasing number of older prisoners has already been mentioned. This is largely driven by sexual offences, particularly those of historical sexual abuse. While we of course need to treat people appropriately, I suggest that, wrongly, the majority of the public would not care if sexual abuse offenders or murderers killed themselves. It is, however, our duty as stewards of the Crown to consider these matters carefully.

It so happens that, in the next group, we would have got to a particular situation about halting treatment, or what could happen as a result of halting treatment. There are situations in Australia where prisoners who have been diagnosed with cancer have then declined treatment and have been able to take up assisted dying. One thing that is happening is the rise in prisons of natural deaths. In the 12 months to September 2025, there were 221, and that is with the Ministry of Justice not even knowing and waiting for further information. That is a significant increase from 123 in 2010, which reflects the older age.

It is important that we have compassion, so it is surprising to me that there has been a yearly average of only 9.5 early releases of prisoners on compassionate grounds over the last 15 years. There was just one in 2022, seven in 2023 and no figures yet for 2024. The policy framework is deliberately sparing. Meanwhile, a legal ruling earlier this year allowed an applicant, Mr Khan, out. It is worth considering—it may not be possible at this stage in the response by the Minister or the sponsor—and thinking ahead to Report. Where are we going with this? It should not just be that the ECHR does not allow this.