Debates between Luke Akehurst and Lisa Smart during the 2024 Parliament

Proportional Representation: General Elections

Debate between Luke Akehurst and Lisa Smart
Thursday 30th January 2025

(6 days, 14 hours ago)

Commons Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lisa Smart Portrait Lisa Smart
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am delighted to report that my bar charts have been measured and are accurate to the millimetre.

Luke Akehurst Portrait Luke Akehurst
- Hansard - -

rose

--- Later in debate ---
Lisa Smart Portrait Lisa Smart
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I would be delighted to give way on that subject.

Luke Akehurst Portrait Luke Akehurst
- Hansard - -

Does the hon. Lady accept that one of the great advantages of moving to a proportional voting system would be that there would be no need to put any bar charts on any leaflets—it would be highly misleading to do so—that there would be no “two-horse race” graphics or squeeze messaging, and everyone would be able to vote for the party they really wanted?

Lisa Smart Portrait Lisa Smart
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I could not have been more delighted to welcome the hon. Gentleman’s intervention. I wonder if he has been listening in to the Hazel Grove constituency Liberal Democrat executive meetings. I agree with the him, though. When thinking about how to vote, I would much rather—as, I imagine, would a number of voters—talk about values, principles and policies, instead of a rather grim-looking canvasser pointing earnestly at a bar chart, worried about who might get in if the vote splits. PR would be better for our politics and better for our communities.

There is widespread and growing support for change, both in Parliament and across the country. A national commission for electoral reform would provide the necessary first step towards finally addressing the failures of first past the post—a step that must be taken well before the next general election. To ignore the urgency of this issue would be to further undermine our democracy.

Governments are not always known for doing things that they do not see as being in their best interest; however, like a number of colleagues across the House, I argue that proportional representation is in our whole country’s interest, and that is why I urge the Government to act. The public are watching, and the demand for fair representation cannot be ignored forever—our democracy depends on it.