Housing and Planning Bill (Fourth sitting) Debate

Full Debate: Read Full Debate

Lord Jackson of Peterborough

Main Page: Lord Jackson of Peterborough (Conservative - Life peer)

Housing and Planning Bill (Fourth sitting)

Lord Jackson of Peterborough Excerpts
Thursday 19th November 2015

(9 years ago)

Public Bill Committees
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text
Roberta Blackman-Woods Portrait Dr Blackman-Woods
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The hon. Gentleman does not have to look very hard, because the front page of Inside Housing of either this week or last week has comments from the deputy Mayor about how concerned he is. Perhaps that is contrary to some evidence that was given to the Committee, but there is some concern in the Mayor’s office about how starter homes might negatively affect what I think is the rent-to-buy scheme.

Lord Jackson of Peterborough Portrait Mr Stewart Jackson (Peterborough) (Con)
- Hansard - -

I have a soft spot for the hon. Lady, who is playing a sticky wicket particularly well. We should be basing our scrutiny on facts and demonstrable evidence. Surely she would concede that the expert witnesses we heard, notwithstanding the fact that Build to Rent is quite a new regime, did not come forward with anything other than anecdote. They did not provide any evidence whatever Build to Rent would be “killed off” by starter homes. Surely she would concede that. Perhaps in a year we will find evidence, but at the moment that is not the case.

Roberta Blackman-Woods Portrait Dr Blackman-Woods
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

That is actually a very helpful suggestion. Maybe we should suggest during the Bill’s progress through Committee that monitoring arrangements should extend to reviewing whether the Bill is working in its intent of getting more people into home ownership, particularly people who would not be able to get on the housing ladder in the open market. Perhaps I will take on board the hon. Gentleman’s suggestion and introduce an amendment later in the Bill’s progress.

Lord Jackson of Peterborough Portrait Mr Jackson
- Hansard - -

The hon. Lady can take her own amendment; she does not have to pinch mine.

Roberta Blackman-Woods Portrait Dr Blackman-Woods
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Indeed, but I could be supportive if the hon. Gentleman wanted to introduce one on that basis.

--- Later in debate ---
Roberta Blackman-Woods Portrait Dr Blackman-Woods
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank my hon. Friend for that intervention, not least because over the lunch break I will look out the comments from the Mayor’s office. My hon. Friend highlights clearly the point I was making. He used a good example. I could have given many examples from the evidence to the Committee about people’s concerns about starter homes crowding out other sorts of housing delivery, but I thought in my naivety that Conservative Members might listen to a Conservative Mayor and the comments made by his office, but apparently not. Those comments crystallised for the Committee people’s concern that starter homes could crowd out other forms of low-cost home ownership. We would not particularly welcome that and we would like to hear from the Minister how he will ensure that starter homes will be in addition to other forms of low-cost home ownership and help people to get on the housing ladder, which we all want to see.

Lord Jackson of Peterborough Portrait Mr Jackson
- Hansard - -

I shall be brief because I am getting looks of admonition from my Whip and perhaps also from you, Mr Gray. For the record, was it not the case that, when pressed, every expert witness said cumulatively that the starter homes policy would deliver more homes for people in our country and our constituencies?

Roberta Blackman-Woods Portrait Dr Blackman-Woods
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Well, on the basis of the point made by my hon. Friend, let us wait and see whether that proves to be the case.

In conclusion, I am looking forward to hearing what the Minister says about ensuring that starter homes are an addition to all other types of homes to encourage people into home ownership and across all other tenures, and his answers to our question about why the Bill does not include measures to ensure that that is the case.