Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
Visitor Levy (England) Bill Debate
Full Debate: Read Full DebateLee Anderson
Main Page: Lee Anderson (Reform UK - Ashfield)Department Debates - View all Lee Anderson's debates with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government
(2 days, 5 hours ago)
Commons Chamber
Peter Lamb (Crawley) (Lab)
It is a privilege to follow the hon. Member for North Dorset (Simon Hoare), who is undoubtedly the finest Select Committee Chair on the Opposition Benches, though I am afraid to say that on this matter we most profoundly disagree.
I am the Member of Parliament for Crawley, and prior to that, I was the leader of Crawley council. Crawley is the finest town in England. Unfortunately, most people still do not know where it is, which is why we always follow up a mention of it with the sentence, “It’s where Gatwick airport is.” It is a privilege that much of the country will, in the course of their lifetime, travel into or through my constituency without knowing its name, and they are very welcome to, but that does have an impact.
Before I get to that, I would like to address some of the points made by Opposition Members. During my time as local authority leader, we had to go through Brexit. What many Members ignored at the time, when they were shouting, “No deal is better than any deal,” is the open skies agreement. For those who are not aware, the open skies agreement was the basis on which UK planes flew anywhere in the world. Without it, planes coming to and leaving the UK would need to agree a deal with every single destination. There was a moment, prolonged over three-and-a-half years, when it genuinely looked possible that every plane in this country would be grounded, as the Tories cheered on no deal being better than any deal.
We have open skies agreements in place today by virtue of doing a deal with the EU, which many Conservative Members still appear to disagree with, but the reality is that we are still worse off than we were with the previous deal. They are telling us that we are going to destroy the entire hospitality economy over a couple of quid on a night’s stay in a hotel, when they were ready to destroy the entire aviation industry and the inbound tourism economy because of their ideological bent. I have to say to them that the crocodile tears do not impress.
I was local authority leader in my constituency during covid, when every plane was grounded for a time. We went from being the town with the densest employment in the entire country outside of London to the worst-affected economy in the country. The then Government said that they were prepared to help, but would do absolutely nothing in practice to help. There was no financial support, and no support or attention from Ministers or civil servants. It was down to the local authority to rebuild that place, brick by brick, back up to that status, without the help of the Government. I do not take Opposition Members seriously when they raise concerns, given how they behaved in the past.
Visitors are very welcome to Crawley—it is a privilege to have them, and they are good for our economy—but they do have an impact, including on roads and transportation. We can talk about potholes—apparently it is a concern that the money could be used for potholes. What do Opposition Members think people use to come into and go out of a constituency? A very high proportion use cars, and our roads suffer by virtue of that. I have to say that the argument that more funding for maintaining our roads will be in any way unpopular with local electorates is not very convincing. Just this morning, I was collared by a man in my local Tesco who was boasting about how many roadworks were taking place, and who said how good it was to see the roads being redone, thanks to the Government’s additional funding.
We have to deal with housing and the impact of short-term lets on our local economy. We have to deal with the impact of visitors on waste and environmental issues. I accept that commercial waste is dealt with separately, but it still has to be dealt with at the strategic level by strategic authorities. We also have to deal with water—[Interruption.] It still has to go somewhere, and at the end of the day, that infrastructure will be overseen by the strategic authority. Having a mechanism for taking population into account is sensible, because those pressures exist in my community.
Two weeks ago, I was at a sewage works.
Thank goodness the hon. Member went to a sewage works. He is talking plenty. Is there any chance that during his speech he will mention the visitor levy?
Peter Lamb
I will get on to the visitor levy—but back to the sewage works. If you want to attract the most fun comments you can on your social media feeds, I recommend taking a video at a sewage works; people’s creativity goes through the roof. The impacts of expansion and of tourism on sewage are significant, and the works is having to plan what will happen in the event of Gatwick’s expansion.
I will not completely bore hon. Members again on local authority funding—I went on about it when we debated business rates—but when we look at the history of local authority funding, we see it is grounded in Tudor England. It was brought in to deal with the disbursement of poor relief by parish councils in Tudor times, as back then there was a requirement that everyone earned a minimum wage. The knock-on effect is that everyone in a community who is putting pressure on that infrastructure is expected to pay towards its maintenance. We have council tax. There is a discount for single-person households, to take into account the fact that fewer people live in them. Businesses have gone through various systems, but today they contribute towards their area through business rates. What about communities that see a drastic increase in their size, and on the pressure on their infrastructure, but see no contribution made towards the provision of infrastructure in that area? We could claim that business rates make a difference, but there is the capping and levying on top of business rates. My community collected £120 million of business rates this year and got to keep £4 million to £5 million. If we get more people in, using more local hospitality, that figure will not change.
The reality for those communities is that there is no accounting for the fact—[Interruption.] The hon. Member for Ashfield (Lee Anderson) seems to be having a fine conversation. Are you discussing the impact that you appear to have on my constituency by taking this line? Are you discussing the impact on my community? No, of course you are not.