National Insurance Contributions (Rate Ceilings) Bill (First sitting)

Debate between John McNally and Rebecca Long Bailey

Tuesday 27th October 2015 Public Bill Committees

[Rebecca Long Bailey (Salford and Eccles) (Lab)]

Q 2 The Bill legislates to prevent rises in the current rates of class 1 and secondary class 1 national insurance contributions, but says nothing about the thresholds. In your opinion, are changes to thresholds absolutely ruled out for the duration of the Parliament?

John Whiting: From a simplification point of view, we tend to leave rates and thresholds as a policy matter for Ministers, but naturally, one of the main projects we have on our agenda is looking at closer alignment of income tax and national insurance. As part of that review, we are inevitably considering the impact of thresholds and other factors about the structure of national insurance, and whether bringing them into closer alignment with income tax in some way would bring some simplification. As I read the Bill, it is all about capping rates rather than thresholds, but I stress that how those are treated is really a matter for Ministers.

[John Mc Nally (Falkirk) (SNP)]

Q 3 You will know that there has been a lot of speculation in the past two days regarding the possibility of changing the national insurance contribution because of the tax credit cuts. Have you any comment to make on that as a possibility?

John Whiting: Again, Mr Mc Nally, I have to say that the actual rates of national insurance are something that we at the Office of Tax Simplification steer clear of, other than to consider whether they add complexity or simplification. To give an example away from national insurance, we drew attention to having two rates of corporation tax. Obviously, that was a complexity, as they have now been harmonised on one rate. That is an obvious simplification and easier for business. That is about as far as we tend to go with rates, but in terms of absolute rate setting, I cannot comment, other than to say that, whenever you make a change to the tax system, it adds a measure of complexity and confusion.

National Insurance Contributions (Rate Ceilings) Bill (Second sitting)

Debate between John McNally and Rebecca Long Bailey

Tuesday 27th October 2015 Public Bill Committees

[Rebecca Long Bailey]

Further to that point of order, Mr Bailey. I reiterate the thanks the Minister has expressed. I also thank him for what has, as always, been a lively and engaging debate. It has been a pleasure.

[John Mc Nally (Falkirk) (SNP)]

Further to that point of order, Mr Bailey. This is the first Bill Committee on which I have sat. May I, too, thank the Minister and the Clerks for taking us through the Bill and for the guidance they have given us? I am equally glad that our proceedings have been quite short and relatively simple to follow and that I could associate them with my constituents back home in Falkirk.

Bill to be reported, without amendment.