(2 days, 7 hours ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
I congratulate my right hon. Friend on securing this timely debate. Is she going to refer to the report of module 4 of the covid inquiry that identified serious flaws with the yellow card system? Does she share my concern than the MHRA, as an independent regulator, fell down on its responsibilities during the covid pandemic, by refusing to acknowledge that the vaccines were not absolutely safe, as we now know, from the awards made under the compensation scheme? More than 200 cases of death or serious injury arising from covid-19 vaccines have been established, but the MHRA was in denial at the time when people needed the truth.
We hope we might hear from the hon. Gentleman at even greater length later.
Thank you for encouraging me to participate in the debate, Sir John. I have a few points in addition to those I made in my intervention.
The failure of the MHRA is directly contributing to a decline in vaccine confidence in this country. We know that a large number of families fail to have their young children vaccinated with the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine because they do not trust the authorities. Why not? Largely because, if they look at the literature, they know that there have been too many occasions when the MHRA has failed to be wholly honest and truthful about the impact of vaccines on individuals.
I was looking at the potential cause and how we might rectify it. Regulation 58 of the Human Medicines Regulations 2012 requires that “the positive therapeutic effects” of a vaccine should
“outweigh the risks to the health of patients or of the public”.
I do not think that is enough. What people want is some assurance that there is no risk of death or serious injury as a result of taking those vaccines. That is palpably not what is said at the moment by the MHRA, even in relation to MMR vaccines, although I am not aware of any case where an MMR vaccine has resulted in a death or serious injury. If we had that as the test, it would be a much stronger one. Although a lot of the covid-19 vaccines would have failed that test, people would have been alerted to it and they could then have weighed up in their own minds the merits or demerits of taking those vaccines, in the same way that they weigh up whether all the pressures of a Labour Government should force them to take antidepressants or not. That is a decision that they can make themselves on the basis of the evidence. I must make a declaration, Sir John, that I have not yet been driven to taking anti-depressants, despite this ghastly Government.
Being serious, let us change the rules so that it is much clearer that the MHRA looks primarily at the risk of serious injury or death, rather than these weasel words of positive therapeutic effects outweighing the risks to the health of patients or the public.
(1 year, 11 months ago)
Westminster HallWestminster Hall is an alternative Chamber for MPs to hold debates, named after the adjoining Westminster Hall.
Each debate is chaired by an MP from the Panel of Chairs, rather than the Speaker or Deputy Speaker. A Government Minister will give the final speech, and no votes may be called on the debate topic.
This information is provided by Parallel Parliament and does not comprise part of the offical record
Very briefly, the ESO review of the east of England network demonstrated that there is a higher up-front cost for undergrounding of an extra £1 billion from Norwich to Tilbury, but in the longer term it saves money. It is just not correct to say that undergrounding is automatically much more expensive. That is a departmental mantra that is now discredited—just read the ESO and NESO documents.
Order. Before the right hon. Gentleman responds to that intervention—he is being very generous in giving way—can I just say that we have to move on to the Front-Bench speakers at 10.30 am and there are many people who wish to participate? I have not imposed time limits; all I am saying is that there are 13 minutes left and probably seven people who want to speak.
On that basis, Sir Christopher, I will not give way again, for as you have noted, I have been immensely generous. I will abbreviate my remarks without missing out any of the other four subjects that I promised to speak about. Let me deal with them very rapidly. Efficiency is critically important in delivering energy policy. As I have already said, if we want to get that policy pursued and delivered quickly, we need an approach that avoids the protracted debates and disputes I have described.
Let us speak more strategically about energy policy, on which the hon. Member for East Thanet (Ms Billington) made a powerful point; we need to understand that bringing supply closer to demand is vital at a strategic level. Successive Governments have failed at this. A lot of people have made comments about the previous Government—the previous Government would have done a lot better if they had listened to me more often. I hope this one will; then they will not go wrong. It is important to reconsider the relationship between supply and demand. No Government have done that with sufficient vigour, and I hope this one will.
On economics, putting in the pylons will also have a displacement effect, because Lincolnshire is perhaps the most important county of all in respect of food production. I understand that about 30% of the fresh produce we consume goes through my constituency. South Lincolnshire produces 20% of the vegetables we consume, 20% of the sugar beet, and so on. The displacement effect of energy infrastructure, including pylons and solar, will have a devastating effect on food production and therefore food security. I simply say to the Minister that energy security must not be made the enemy of food security, and vice versa. That is why the economics are more complex than they perhaps first appear.
Finally, on the cognitive ergonomics of Government, it is really important that in winding up, the Minister assures this Chamber that the Departments across Government are working closely together. We have talked about land use studies, and that is a good thing, but given the commitments that the Planning Minister has made to beauty and the commitments that the Environment Secretary has made to food production and security, it is important that we do not simply pursue a policy that is invidious because it contradicts the other priorities of Government. In my long experience as a Minister in a variety of Departments, I have found that lateral thinking in Government is a rare and precious thing; I simply recommend to the Minister a more lateral approach in combining those critical priorities.
Finally, my hon. Friend the Member for Harwich and North Essex is right: we need to approach this in a bolder than partisan way, because we are speaking about fundamental decisions in the interest of our country. This is a matter of national interest, but it does not have to be a matter of national interest that compromises the common good.