Read Bill Ministerial Extracts
John Hayes
Main Page: John Hayes (Conservative - South Holland and The Deepings)Department Debates - View all John Hayes's debates with the Home Office
(2 days, 9 hours ago)
Commons ChamberWith the leave of the House, in the time that remains, I will do my best to respond to the many thoughtful and heartfelt contributions that we have heard this afternoon.
Let me start by turning to new clause 62, which is in the name of my hon. Friend the Member for Poole (Neil Duncan-Jordan). A number of other Members have spoken in support of it, including the hon. Member for Birmingham Perry Barr (Ayoub Khan), my hon. Friend the Member for Poplar and Limehouse (Apsana Begum), my right hon. Friend the Member for Hayes and Harlington (John McDonnell) and my hon. Friend the Member for Alloa and Grangemouth (Brian Leishman). I know that my hon. Friend the Member for Poole is a tireless campaigner for workers, and I appreciate the intent behind his new clause, but I profoundly disagree with it and with the use of the word “retrospective” in this debate, for reasons that I will come on to explain.
As my right hon. Friend the Home Secretary has said in the House and in discussions throughout recent weeks, including in conversations with my hon. Friend the Member for Poole, settlement has always been determined at the point of application, not at entry, and that principle has been upheld in the courts. Being in the United Kingdom does not give someone the right to settle under the rules that happened to exist when they first arrived. Settlement in this country is a great privilege, and it comes with indefinite access to great institutions, such as the NHS, our schools and the welfare state. People should not have a sense of entitlement to that when they come to this country under visas or other short-term rights. We believe that people should have the time to demonstrate contribution in order to receive the status of settlement.
The Minister is making a profound point. This is about citizenship. For citizenship to mean anything, it must confer certain entitlements that non-citizens do not enjoy. That is not a complicated idea; it is a time-honoured principle, and I support any Member of this House who upholds it.
I sincerely appreciate the right hon. Gentleman’s contribution. He is right; the whole purpose of our reforms is to recognise the privilege that comes with settlement in this country—the rights and the responsibilities, and the contribution we expect people to make when they are here. As all Members know, we have created a targeted exemption for care workers and other non-degree-level public sector roles in health and education. This is exceptional and has been done in view of their service during covid and during our recovery since, when we asked them to come to this country and support us in looking after some of our most vulnerable people. Some 300,000 skilled workers expected to settle at 10 years will not fall into that category.
As my right hon. Friend the Home Secretary has said, this policy is about fairness, both to those who are here now and those who have come recently. Where exceptional conditions do not apply as they do for care workers, I do not think it is fair to allow permanent access to our great institutions if a contribution has not been proved; as my right hon. Friend has said, the impact would be billions in welfare costs and a huge number of people becoming eligible for social housing. Many of these workers came to this country when the salary threshold was £25,000, a threshold set by the previous Government, and vast numbers now remain on very low wages, so we know that the likely impact on things like social housing would be profound. We do not think it would be fair—either to those who have contributed more, including in public services, or to the British people—if demands on the welfare state go up.
This is not a question of removing people. No one is being asked to leave. It is about people who do not yet have permanent status and the conditions for accessing it. We expect them to be able to settle after a further period of contribution.