(1 day, 9 hours ago)
Commons ChamberMadam Deputy Speaker, I am grateful to be called. We have a time limit, and I will try to stick to it. The main thing I want to say is that we seem to be debating something that is not really the subject for today. We seem to have reignited this whole idea about whether the UK should go back in to the EU, and most of the arguments are proposed along those lines.
The problem we have is that the Government are was in favour of leaving the EU for reasons to do with our control in setting our own regulations and our ability to make meaningful trade deals with everybody else outside the EU, while retaining a good relationship with the EU. This has never been anti-EU; it is simply the nature of what is good for the UK.
The reality is that a negotiation is going on with the Government. Again, I do not have a problem with the Government asking for negotiations on our trade arrangements with the EU. The question in all of this is: what is the purpose of the negotiations? This is where we have a problem, because the Prime Minister at the moment seems to flit between different statements about his own purpose with regards to the EU. If this is just another narrow attempt to try to make the passage of goods across to the EU happen in the way it did before, I do not have any problem with that.
The key issue is: what is the price of making such an arrangement? It boils down to this very simple question: what is the price of our contribution to the EU? What is the price in what we have to take as rules from the EU thereafter in those specific product areas? What price will follow when we deal with others with which we have done trade deals or will do trade deals when the EU wants to make changes in those areas, as I am sure will be negotiated, if we are unable to change those arrangements because we are bound by this agreement in perpetuity?
That is really what we should be looking at in this debate. We can have these wonderful debates about whether we should rejoin, but we have left the EU, so we are talking only about such arrangements. We can have these wonderful sweeping remarks about how Brexit has been a disaster and that we have done worse than we ever would have done, but we have outgrown the EU ever since we left. That is because British business and British abilities made sure that we upped our game. Germany has real problems right now: 15,000 manufacturing workers a week are being laid off. France has real economic problems, and it is teetering on the edge of recession. Given all that, why would we want to get bound more deeply to Europe, and why now?
I will give way in a moment. I have very little time, and I want to make a couple of points, if the hon. Member does not mind.
The point I am really making is that the cost is the one thing we should be debating today, and the Government should have put the cost on the table. The part I disagree with is keeping that under wraps and not telling us what is going on until after they have done the deal and then not have a debate.
Ben Coleman
Given the way a lot of this debate is going, it may help to suggest that we should talk not just about how Germany and France have done in the last couple of years, but about the extraordinary growth in Poland and Spain. Indeed, since we left the European Union, our growth has been 6.2%, while France’s has been 6.2%, Germany’s only 1.8%, that of the euro area as a whole 7.8%, Italy’s 8.7% and Spain’s about 12.1%. Let us put—