Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill (Fourth sitting)

Debate between Gideon Amos and Florence Eshalomi
Florence Eshalomi Portrait The Minister for Homelessness, Democracy, Communities and Faith (Florence Eshalomi)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship for the first time, Mr Stringer.

Clauses 9, 10 and 11 should stand part of the Bill. Clause 9 will introduce a practical mechanism for remediation recommendations to be revised. This power is to be used where a suitable professional or Homes England determines that implementing the original recommendations would not result in the external walls being properly remediated. The clause recognises that in some cases new risks or issues may become apparent only once remediation works have commenced on site. Where that occurs, the original recommendations may no longer be sufficient to achieve proper remediation and will therefore need to be updated.

Importantly, alternative recommendations cannot simply be devised by the responsible entity; they must come from a suitably qualified professional or from Homes England. This will help to ensure that revised recommendations are supported by appropriate expertise and continue to deliver proper remediation. Clause 9 will enable responsible entities to follow revised recommendations where necessary, without requiring the assessment process to be restarted from scratch, which could cause disproportionate delays.

Since 2018, the Government have provided funding for remediation. Many responsible entities are likely to use Government funding to comply with their duty to remediate. Clause 10 will give the Secretary of State the power to provide financial assistance to a responsible entity where that assistance may help the responsible entity to comply with the clause 8 remediation duty. The assistance can be provided through a grant, a loan or another form of support, and it may be provided directly or indirectly. The clause will not create a right to funding, nor will it remove the responsible entity’s duty to remediate. Instead, clause 10 recognises that Government funding is an established and practical route to remediation. It makes it clear how reliance on established funding routes may be taken into account when assessing what steps are reasonably required and reasonably practicable in the circumstances.

Responsible entities need certainty and clarity on exactly how they are expected to comply with their part 1 duties. That is why clause 11 will allow regulations to be made to support the duties in clauses 7 to 10. The power allows technical and operational details to be set out in regulations. The intent is that this power will be used to provide details on what steps are regarded as reasonably necessary to mitigate or remediate fire safety risks. This will support responsible entities to comply with their duties under part 1. It should also support enforcement, as regulators will have clear guidance on what are considered the reasonably necessary steps.

Regulations will also provide for the detailed requirements to be described and updated as building circumstances, identified risks, technical standards and industry practice change over time. Clauses 9, 10 and 11 should all stand part of the Bill; I commend them to the Committee.

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos (Taunton and Wellington) (LD)
- Hansard - -

It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mr Stringer. I rise to speak to new clause 3, which stands in my name and that of my hon. Friend the Member for Chippenham. The new clause would require the Secretary of State to establish a financial assistance scheme to cover the cost of remediation works for buildings under 11 metres. We believe that no leaseholder, tenant or homeowner who has found that their building was built with fire safety defects should have to pay to put those defects right, no matter the height of the building concerned. Cases of homeowners having to find large sums of money are well known across the country.

I recognise that the Government have established some grants for buildings under 11 metres. However, we believe that a comprehensive scheme is needed so that all buildings under 11 metres are tackled and the necessary remediation is provided. The Bill covers buildings of 11 metres to 18 metres, but omits buildings under 11 metres. The new clause would put that right so that all residents can benefit from support where it is needed and where developers and building owners fail to comply with remediation. I commend the new clause to the Committee.

Florence Eshalomi Portrait Florence Eshalomi
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the hon. Member for Taunton and Wellington for tabling new clause 3. I recognise the concerns that have prompted it. The Government are committed to supporting residents facing serious cladding fire safety risks, including those in buildings under 11 metres. We have therefore made targeted funding available for eligible multi-occupied residential buildings under 11 metres with unsafe cladding, prioritising those that present high life-critical cladding fire safety risks.

We recognise that residents may face other building safety issues. That is why we continue to explore what further support may be appropriate for leaseholders in buildings under 11 metres. Any further intervention will be evidence-led, proportionate and targeted at the risks identified.

New clause 3 would go significantly further. It would require a scheme covering external wall systems, wider fire safety defects and associated interim safety measures, with eligible leaseholders and residents entitled to have those costs fully covered. We do not consider such a broad funding entitlement to be proportionate. Supporting all defects regardless of the risk that they present could be more regressive and would represent poor value for money, directing public funding towards lower-risk defects rather than towards buildings that present some of the greatest life-critical cladding fire safety risks. Placing those requirements in primary legislation would also restrict the Government’s ability to adapt support as risk, evidence and circumstances change. For those reasons, the Government cannot accept the new clause. I ask the hon. Member for Taunton and Wellington not to press it.

--- Later in debate ---
Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I am grateful for that further explanation. I still find it difficult to understand how the abuse of such a provision could be avoided. The remediation orders will surely make it clear where there is a duty to remediate. The fact that anyone could say, “Sorry, I just didn’t know about it,” simply cannot be a defence.

Amendment 31 would provide a non-exclusive definition of what would count as a reasonable excuse. Similarly, I do not think we should be legislating in the Bill for excuses. We need to get remediation done, and it needs to happen in a timely way.

Florence Eshalomi Portrait Florence Eshalomi
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

We know that most reasonable entities have taken their existing legal duties seriously and got on with the remediation of historical fire safety defects at their properties. However, too many are still failing to act quickly enough.

Of the 4,724 residential buildings over 11 metres with unsafe cladding that the Department is monitoring, only 1,849 have had work completed on them. Regulators have taken enforcement action on at least 929 buildings because of confirmed or suspected unsafe cladding. Currently, those responsible will face penalties for inaction only once they have failed to comply with a statutory notice and been prosecuted. That process is slow, costly and inefficient. Current enforcement does not provide a sufficiently strong or immediate deterrent against non-compliance, allowing avoidance and delay to persist. To deliver real change, we need clear legal duties requiring responsible entities to act without waiting for enforcement, as well as stronger and faster enforcement tools to hold those who obstruct to account.

Clause 12 delivers that change. It makes it a criminal offence for a responsible entity to fail to take the required interim measures or required remediation steps as soon as reasonably practicable. When a responsible entity fails to act, it may face serious consequences, including a significant fine, imprisonment or both. The prospect of severe sanctions should drive compliance in the majority of cases. Where it does not, we should make sure there are meaningful consequences for the worst actors in the system.

Prosecution or the payment of a penalty do not remove a responsible entity’s duty to make their building safe. A responsible entity will still be required to take interim measures and remediation steps even if it has been convicted or paid a fine. If the responsible entity continues to offend, clause 12 allows it to be prosecuted again for continued non-compliance over a different period of time. That ensures that prosecution cannot be treated as the only cost for not carrying out the remediation work.

Clause 12 is needed to compel responsible entities to act now to make buildings safe; otherwise, they will face the full force of the law.

--- Later in debate ---
Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I have sympathy with the intent behind amendment 38, tabled by the hon. Member for Orpington, as it addresses one of the compelling points that came out of the witness sessions. I apologise: I was travelling to a funeral that day, so I could not be there. However, on reading Hansard afterwards, it became increasingly clear that the complex jungle of different responsibilities among regulators was a real cause for concern. Several witnesses pointed out the need to have either a single regulatory body, which is what the hon. Member is proposing, or at least a single framework.

I think it was pointed out that the LACORS agreements between local authorities and regulatory services would have to be rewritten some 147 times to cover all parts of the country, and the agreements and memoranda of understanding between local authorities and regulatory services would come on top of the agreement being shaped for the London area. That cannot be the right approach. I hope that the Minister will say something about how the issue can be better addressed. We cannot leave this Bill without addressing what all the witnesses said was necessary: having a single framework or regulator. Otherwise, we face the prospect of months or years of discussion, in each local authority up and down the land, to decide who will be the lead authority.

Florence Eshalomi Portrait Florence Eshalomi
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the hon. Members for Orpington and for Taunton and Wellington for their engagement on clauses 22 and 23. The clauses provide clarity on which public authorities are enforcement authorities for part 1 of the Bill, placing a clear duty on enforcement authorities to exercise those functions. Clause 22 matters because responsible entities for residents, and residents themselves, need certainty about who is responsible for enforcing the regime, if the responsible entity is failing to comply with its duties to assess, mitigate or remediate external fire safety risks.

The clause makes local housing authorities and fire and rescue authorities the enforcement authorities in respect of chapter 1 buildings in their areas. The Building Safety Regulator is made the enforcement authority for chapter 1 buildings that are considered “higher-risk buildings” under section 65 in part 4 of the Building Safety Act 2022. Those authorities already have duties under existing legislation to regulate and enforce fire safety, so the clause builds on and complements existing expertise and regulatory responsibilities. It also includes a regulation-making power so that the list of enforcement authorities can be updated if needed. That is important for ensuring that part 1 duties and offences can continue to be enforced effectively even if the relevant authorities change over time.

On amendment 38, I agree that there must be clarity about which authority is leading investigation or enforcement activity for a particular building, but the amendment is unnecessary because the Bill’s co-operation arrangements already provide for regulators to agree who should lead, when joint action is needed, and how information should be shared. Local housing authorities, fire and rescue authorities and, for higher-risk buildings, the Building Safety Regulator have distinct but overlapping responsibilities and powers. One authority will lead in many cases, but different authorities may need to lead on different issues or at different stages, and in some cases, joint action may be the most effective response. Requiring in primary legislation a single lead enforcement authority for every building could therefore introduce unnecessary rigidity. The Bill instead provides clarity about lead responsibility while retaining the flexibility needed to reflect different buildings, risks and regulatory functions. For that reason, the Government cannot accept the amendment, and I ask the hon. Member for Orpington not to press it to a vote.

The first purpose of clause 23 is to clarify that enforcement authorities should use all the tools available to them to secure remediation. The new powers in the Bill are intended to complement, not replace, existing powers under the Housing Act 2004, the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 and the Building Safety Act. The clause achieves that by requiring enforcing authorities to exercise their existing or new powers to secure compliance with part 1 duties while allowing them to choose the most appropriate enforcement action in each case.

The second purpose is to place it beyond doubt that remediation is an enforcing authority’s responsibility. Clause 23 places a clear duty on enforcement authorities to exercise those functions to secure compliance with the duties to assess, mitigate and remediate, or otherwise secure proper remediation. That provides greater clarity and consistency across enforcing authorities and helps to ensure that all parts of the regulatory system play their role in driving remediation outcomes.

I acknowledge the intention behind amendment 15: relevant authorities must have the capacity and resources they need to carry out their functions under the Bill effectively. However, we do not consider it necessary to impose a statutory requirement to provide ringfenced funding for the full costs incurred by authorities. In accordance with the new burdens doctrine, the Government will undertake a new burdens assessment to assess the additional costs arising from the Bill and determine what additional support, if any, relevant authorities require. Separate Government funding is available to support eligible remediation projects, including those carried out through the remediation backstop. The Bill also allows the Secretary of State to provide financial assistance to remediation authorities carrying out backstop work.

Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill (Third sitting)

Debate between Gideon Amos and Florence Eshalomi
Florence Eshalomi Portrait The Minister for Homelessness, Democracy, Communities and Faith (Florence Eshalomi)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship for the first time, Sir Alec. I thank the witnesses who gave evidence in our sittings last week. I hope that Committee members found the sessions useful. I think it was a positive and engaging discussion of topics raised by all interested parties.

I continue to believe that we agree on the core principles of this Bill: the building safety crisis must be resolved, homes must be made safe, residents must be allowed to move on with their lives, and a tragedy like Grenfell must never be allowed to happen again. The Government’s mission is to ensure that everyone has a safe, decent and affordable home. This Bill is one step towards achieving that. The Bill has four objectives: to identify all buildings requiring remediation, to make it clear who is responsible for remediation, to make those responsible for the crisis pay to put it right and to ensure that no building is left behind.

We will begin by discussing some of the core definitions that establish what the Bill is designed to achieve. Clause 1 is essential in that endeavour, as it makes clear which buildings are included under part 1 remediation duties. Residents and responsible entities need certainty about which buildings are in scope of the regime. The clause provides that by clearly establishing that the chapter 1 regime applies to relevant buildings completed before 28 June 2022. The June 2022 cut-off ensures that the regime remains focused on addressing historical fire safety defects in existing building stock.

Buildings completed after that date are not within the scope of the Government’s remediation programme because they are not associated with the cladding and building safety issues that the programme was established to address. The date also aligns the regime with the leaseholder protections introduced by the Building Safety Act 2022. That ensures that any relevant costs arising from those measures fall within scope of these protections.

Clause 40 defines relevant buildings as multi-occupied residential buildings in England that are at least 11 metres high or have at least five storeys. The clause also makes it clear how connected developments are treated. A whole building is self-contained if it is structurally detached. Clause 41 supports that definition by defining how building height and storeys should be counted. Clear measurement rules are needed to determine whether a building is in scope of part 1. Without them, features such as sloping ground, basements, mezzanines and rooftop plant areas could lead to different conclusions about whether a building is covered. Together, those provisions give responsible entities and regulators a consistent basis for identifying buildings within scope and applying the regime.

Clear duties need clear accountability. Clause 42 provides clarity by identifying who is the responsible entity for the purpose of part 1. Put simply, the responsible entity is the party with the relevant repairing obligation of the external walls, as they are the party with the right to carry out the works at the building. Depending on the building’s ownership and management arrangements, that could be a freeholder, head lessee, sub-lessee, right-to-manage company or resident management company. Responsibility therefore follows the relevant repairing or maintenance obligation, rather than ownership alone. Where responsibility is shared for the same walls, the duty applies jointly and individually, so each responsible entity is responsible for compliance, not just an agreed share. Those provisions sit alongside the duty to co-operate in clause 29, requiring those with shared or divided responsibilities to work together.

Clause 43 provides clarity on what forms part of a building’s external walls for the purpose of part 1. External fire safety risks do not arise from cladding alone; they can arise from different parts of the external wall system and how those parts interact. The definition therefore covers the external wall as a whole, so assessments and remediation are not limited to the primary wall structure or cladding alone. The clause sets out that the external wall system includes doors and windows, cladding systems and their components, balconies and other external attachments, materials within the wall spaces and external finishes. That gives responsible entities and regulators a clear, consistent basis for identifying what must be assessed and remediated and reduces uncertainty or disputes about the scope of their duties.

Clause 44 provides a clear end point for the remediation under part 1 of the Bill. It sets the standards of work and risk reduction required before a building’s external walls can be considered properly remediated. The principle is simple: fire safety risk relating to the external walls must be either eliminated or reduced to a tolerable level on a permanent basis. That is a proportionate, risk-based approach. It will ensure that fire safety risks relating to the external walls have been permanently reduced to a level at which residents can safely leave their homes without relying on temporary measures for their protection. That is consistent with the approach already used in the Government’s remediation programmes.

“Permanent” means permanent. A building cannot be considered properly remediated simply because residents have been moved out or a waking watch is in place. Those measures may keep residents safe while remediation is under way, but they do not address the underlying external wall risk. This clause also allows Government to set out in regulations further detail about when a risk can be considered tolerable. That will provide greater clarity for responsible entities and regulators about when a building has been properly remediated.

This package of clauses sets out the core definitions that underpin the policy within part 1 of the Bill. While this is an area of lively discussion, I believe the Government have struck the right balance to ensure we achieve the objectives set out for this Bill. I therefore commend clauses 1, 40, 41, 42, 43 and 44 to the Committee.

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

It is a pleasure to serve with you in the chair, Sir Alec, and to serve again with colleagues from across the House in this Committee.

This is a very serious Bill and it is important we get it right. Our amendments, and the group as a whole, go to the heart of the Bill and what is meant by an acceptable standard to reach in remediation. Clause 44 suggests that a definition of tolerability will arise from the application of publicly available specification—PAS—9980. We have serious concerns about the application of a standard which, as witnesses said in the oral evidence sessions, includes significant subjectivity in its application. What is needed is a clear and unequivocal standard to which to remediate buildings that are part of this regime. Our amendment 2 would define relevant buildings as

“any building to which Requirement B4(1) of Schedule 1 of the Building Regulations 2010 applies.”

That means that regulations would be applied in the same way that other building regulations are.

For example, if one was to take on a large commercial building and convert it into flats, the 2010 building regulations would apply because one is carrying out material building works, so one must bring the building up to scratch. The same standard should be required under the remediation scheme under this Bill. What is proposed in the Bill would limit the standard’s application. By the way, it is common practice to bring such buildings up to scratch in that way in relation to not just fire safety, but ventilation, heat and sanitary provision. In the case of conversion and material change of use, the building regulations must be met as a whole. The proposed standard is very different and applies by virtue of clause 40 only to buildings over 11 metres. We propose straightforward application of the regulations in the same way that building regulations apply to any building in which builders and owners are engaging in substantive works. That is the appropriate approach.

New clauses 1 and 2 are related to that point. New clause 1 would replace the “tolerable” risk standard in clause 44 with an objective statutory requirement anchored in paragraph B4(1) of schedule 1 to the Building Regulations 2010. In 2018, post-Grenfell, building regulations were tightened to set a standard that all new buildings have since needed to reach, which is logical and reassuring for people living in those new homes. However, that is not the remediation standard at the heart of the Bill; that is a very different standard, so we are entering a two-tier housing market in which buildings built according to the building regulations meet one standard but buildings remediated under the Bill will meet a lower, inferior standard.

The problems of the people living in such buildings are well known: they cannot get insurance even after remediation. I visited a block of apartments where remediation has been carried out but the flammable cladding remains on the exterior of the building. The risk is considered tolerable because—I think the Minister mentioned this—there is enough time to leave the building while it is on fire. That is not the standard that is expected of people building homes: a new and much higher standard is required and that standard should be applied to remediating buildings.

The witnesses raised those issues. The Opposition spokesperson asked Dame Judith Hackitt,

“Do you believe that we are missing a trick by not imposing similar conditions here?”

He meant a standard, objective requirement set in legislation. Dame Judith replied:

“Yes, I do. Defining tolerable risk in statute and getting buy-in from residents and other stakeholders, including investors and insurers, is key to making progress.”––[Official Report, Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Public Bill Committee, 12 November 2026; c. 66-67, Q105.]

Ian Abley, an expert in building inspection, said, referring to the Building Regulations 2010:

“As Giles Grover said, you need a technical standard that is the legally minimum adequate of what is requirement B4(1).”––[Official Report, Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Public Bill Committee, 12 November 2026; c. 64, Q101.]

Fundamentally, we need the same safety standard as we expect builders of new buildings to meet. Our new clause 2 would, by changing the scope of the buildings to which the Building Regulations 2010 apply, ensure that they embrace all buildings on which works are being carried out, in the same way that other buildings engage building regulations. The same definition would be applied.

We need to match the standard for new buildings. The Liberal Democrats are seriously concerned about a standard that has been described as “subjective” and relies on the decisions of building safety assessors who are employed by the building owner and may have an interest in suggesting that as little work as possible is carried out. Although I am sure that most building safety assessors do a very professional job, it is a concern that they are in the pay of the building owners, as is the use of what has been described in the witness evidence sessions as a “subjective” standard. We should replace it with a defined standard, as in the building regulations applied to new homes built today.

Florence Eshalomi Portrait Florence Eshalomi
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Building regulations are important but they are not right for testing decisions that remediation is complete. I hope that the hon. Gentleman accepts that the purpose of the building regulations is to set standards for new building works, rather than to determine whether the fire safety risk that prompted remediation in an existing building has been addressed.

--- Later in debate ---
Florence Eshalomi Portrait Florence Eshalomi
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the hon. Member for that comment and share some of the concerns that she outlined. The issue of capacity is key. This is scalable and has a strong track record. Our analysis indicates that there is currently sufficient assessor capacity to meet expected demand. However, supply and demand are finely balanced, so responsible entities would plan ahead. We will continue to monitor the situation closely and to take action to help mitigate any risks.

To come back to the issue outlined by the hon. Member for Taunton and Wellington, the Bill provides a specific endpoint for remediation. External wall fire safety risks must be eliminated or reduced to a tolerable level on a permanent basis. This keeps the focus on addressing the actual risk to buildings and residents, while ensuring that remediation work continues to comply with building regulations.

Question put and agreed to.

Clause 1 accordingly ordered to stand part of the Bill.

Clause 2

Duty to carry out assessment of risks

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I beg to move amendment 5, in clause 2, page 2, line 9, at end insert—

“(1A) For the purposes of subsection (1)(a) a person is a ‘suitable professional’ only if they are—

(a) a building inspector registered with the Building Safety Regulator; and

(b) not connected with the responsible entity or a body corporate associated with the responsible entity.

(1B) For the purposes of subsection (1A)(b), a person is connected with the responsible entity or a body corporate associated with the responsible entity if—

(a) the person is employed by, receiving direct remuneration from, or contracted to other than for the purposes of carrying out an assessment under subsection (1)(a), the responsible entity or a body corporate associated with the responsible entity, or

(b) there exists any other commercial conflict of interest between the person and the responsible entity or a body corporate associated with the responsible entity.”

This amendment prohibits responsible entities (building owners/landlords) from appointing or directly paying assessors where a conflict of interest exists. It requires external wall assessments to be conducted by independent assessors registered with the Building Safety Regulator.

--- Later in debate ---
Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

The Minister has responded to amendments 5 and 1, both of which I tabled—although I spoke mainly to amendment 5. I do not believe that anyone on the Committee doubts the sincerity with which the Minister brings forward this legislation—we know that she cares deeply about these issues—but, although much of the process in the Bill is acceptable, we have a fundamental issue with the standard of remediation.

Amendment 5 is in two parts. In her response, the Minister dwelt mainly on the part setting out that assessments must be carried out by a building inspector registered with the Building Safety Regulator. She highlighted the distinction between building safety assessors and building inspectors, and she was quite right to do so. It would be possible, of course, to ensure via secondary legislation that building safety assessors were included under the umbrella of “building inspectors” in that part of the amendment, so I do not believe that that is a significant obstacle to passing the amendment.

Florence Eshalomi Portrait Florence Eshalomi
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The Bill goes further by putting independent audits on a statutory footing. Homes England will audit those FRAEWs, recommending any mitigation or remediation, and will have the power to audit assessments that conclude that no work is required. Does the hon. Member agree that that is a positive step forward in addressing some of the concerns that many Members have raised?

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I do accept that, and I very much support the concept of the audits. I think that is a positive part of what the Government are doing. It will strengthen the regime and is a valuable step towards assuring the quality of assessments—although only from a sample of FRAEWs. We need a more robust approach at the beginning of the process, rather than relying on an audit at the end of the process.

As I was saying, the Minister responded mainly to the amendment in relation to what was included under “building inspector”, and I believe that I have dealt with that. The more important part of the amendment sets out that the assessor should not be connected with the responsible entity or a body corporate associated with the responsible entity. An associated person would mean a person employed by, receiving direct remuneration from or contracted to that building owner.

That is the key part of the amendment. It demonstrates the importance of ensuring that fire risk assessors should not be directly employed or remunerated by those who have an interest in the amount of work carried out in that building. We believe that there needs to be an independent national service, fully in line with the conclusions of the Grenfell Tower inquiry report. We will press the amendment to a vote.

Florence Eshalomi Portrait Florence Eshalomi
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I share the hon. Member’s concerns. Another way we are hoping to strengthen this area is by committing to introducing mandatory accreditation to certify the competence of all fire risk assessors, as well as regulating fire engineers. Preventing anyone who is employed or paid by the responsible entity from carrying out the assessment could restrict who can carry out the assessments without necessarily providing the reassurance or capacity that we need. Does he not agree?

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I am grateful to the Minister for her intervention. Of course, any additional safeguards are valuable, and we will not oppose any of those additional measures, but the fundamental point is that our building safety assessors should not be in the pay of building owners, who have an interest in whether those works are carried out.

--- Later in debate ---
Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I am grateful to my hon. Friend, who has considerable experience in the industry. She is absolutely right in what she says. The important factor here is the independence of building safety assessors. How can someone in the pay of the owners—who have an interest in the outcome—be considered a suitable professional?

The distinction between building safety assessors and building inspectors is an accurate one. That is why we have another amendment that would address—[Interruption.] I hear some interesting off-stage effects.

Florence Eshalomi Portrait Florence Eshalomi
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

It’s a fire engineer!

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

Well, if we had had a registered one, we would not have heard that off-stage noise.

We need is a national body. We regard planning decisions outside the building control envelope as so contested, so important and so open to people’s interest that we need a national service of building inspectors. [Interruption.] I will allow the noise effects to—

Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill

Debate between Gideon Amos and Florence Eshalomi
Florence Eshalomi Portrait The Minister for Homelessness, Democracy, Communities and Faith (Florence Eshalomi)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank Members from across the House for their contributions. As the Secretary of State, the shadow Minister and many hon. and right hon. Members outlined, next June will mark a decade since the Grenfell fire disaster took the lives of 72 people, including 18 children. None of us can imagine the horror that survivors, families and friends suffered that day, and the community will continue to carry that trauma, anguish and suffering throughout their lives.

It is a tragedy that should never have happened, and one that must never happen again, but we must be honest and say that it is unacceptable that far too many people in this country still do not have the safety and security of a safe roof over their heads, nine years after Grenfell. This is not just about building safety; it is about giving everyone the peace of mind that a safe, decent and affordable home brings. We must ask ourselves how we can expect anyone to sleep soundly, and get on in life, if the building they sleep in every night is covered in dangerous and flammable cladding. The building safety crisis must be resolved, homes must be made safe, and residents must be allowed to live their lives.

This Government were elected on a manifesto that made commitments to accelerate remediation, better protect leaseholders and make those responsible for the building safety crisis pay to put it right. Our remediation acceleration plan and this Bill deliver on that pledge. By introducing a register of 11 to 18 metre buildings and a national standard for assessing buildings, the Bill will finally bring certainty on the scale of the problem and the work required to fix it. By creating a new legal duty to remediate, backed up by substantial new penalties for inaction, we will compel those responsible to fix their buildings without delay.

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

I am extremely grateful to the Minister for giving way during a very serious and measured speech. She referred to the standard of remediation. A number of Members, including myself, raised use of the standard of tolerability instead of building regulations. Are the Government willing to review the standard of remediation so that after remediation, buildings are not left, as they are now, with flammable cladding on the outside?

Florence Eshalomi Portrait Florence Eshalomi
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the hon. Gentleman for that intervention. A number of Members have raised the matter of remediation standards. I know that the hon. Member for Surrey Heath (Dr Pinkerton), who is sitting next to him, also raised it in a recent Westminster Hall debate that I responded to.

Many right hon. and hon. Members will be aware that the Bill will make independent auditing of fire risk appraisals of external walls mandatory. We are confident that PAS 9980 has a robust and appropriate methodology for assessing the risk of fire spreading throughout the building. The Bill will also look at the independent auditing and the statutory requirement, ensuring that additional checks on those assessments have been carried out properly. To reassure Members, Homes England will also audit all assessments that recommend mitigation and remediation and will have the power to audit other assessments.

By delivering the remediation backstop, we will ensure that no building and no resident is left behind, even if the person responsible for the building is determined to ignore the risks it presents to residents. By creating stronger avenues for redress against construction product manufacturers, we will ensure that those responsible for the cladding safety crisis pay towards the cost of fixing it.

I thank the Secretary of State and the Building Safety Minister, Baroness Blake, for bringing the Bill forward. I also thank all the Ministers who came before me for the work they did to make this Bill a reality, including the Lord Chancellor, my right hon. Friend the Member for Streatham and Croydon North (Steve Reed) and my hon. Friends the Members for Chester North and Neston (Samantha Dixon) and for Bethnal Green and Stepney (Rushanara Ali).

Draft Building Safety Levy (Amendment) (England) Regulations 2026

Debate between Gideon Amos and Florence Eshalomi
Monday 7th September 2026

(2 months, 1 week ago)

General Committees
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Florence Eshalomi Portrait Florence Eshalomi
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the shadow Minister for highlighting that. I should have said that the levy has been designed to minimise potential housing supply impact.

The shadow Minister asked whether the levy could have an impact on our ambitious target—rightly so—of reaching 1.5 million new homes. We continue to work closely with the housing market to look at supply. We are committed to working with the industry to ensure that homes continue to be built at pace. This issue comes up in my inbox, as it does for many hon. Members—it is not isolated to London. It is important that we build good-quality homes.

The shadow Minister also highlighted the impact that the measures could have on innocent homeowners, who should not be burdened with the cost. I thank him for agreeing that the cost should not be placed on them. It is right that developers and house builders be responsible for it, in order to protect innocent homeowners.

The Lib Dem spokesperson, the hon. Member for Taunton and Wellington, highlighted an issue on which many of us have campaigned for many years: ensuring that innocent leaseholders and homeowners are not responsible for paying the levy. Many of them struggle with housing costs and the cost of living crisis on a day-to-day basis. It is important that developers have a way to fund the levy with no additional cost to the taxpayer.

The Lib Dem spokesperson asked about properties that fall out of scope. We will continue to identify those properties and work with the sector to highlight other ways of supporting them, in order to ensure, again, that costs are fairly shared across the market.

Gideon Amos Portrait Gideon Amos
- Hansard - -

On a point of further clarification, I hope that the Minister agrees that one reason for broadening the scope of funding for the safety regime so that it includes cladding manufacturers is that in constituencies such as mine in Somerset, there are no high-rise buildings at all—indeed, most of Somerset has no high-rise buildings—but all the developers in Somerset will none the less pay for remediation in the big cities. None of us begrudges the importance of paying for that remediation, but I hope that that example illustrates the importance of widening the funding of the regime so that cladding manufacturers are required to contribute.

Florence Eshalomi Portrait Florence Eshalomi
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

As I mentioned, we will keep under review the process and, importantly, the rates, and we will report back to the House every three years on those key areas.

The building safety levy is essential to fund the remediation of historic building safety issues without further burdening residents and leaseholders. The draft amending regulations before the Committee are designed to support this work and make the levy work more efficiently, in accordance with our initial intention to support redevelopment of brownfield sites. They are intended to correct drafting and improve clarity and consistency of process for developers and local authorities, rather than alter the underlying policy design of the levy.

The Government are committed to delivering 1.5 million homes in this Parliament to meet the country’s long-term housing needs and unlock growth. That mission must work in parallel with our commitment to remedy the building safety failures of the past. We expect the development industry to contribute to our work making buildings safe for those who live in them. I commend the regulations to the Committee.

Question put and agreed to.