Oral Answers to Questions

Brendan O'Hara Excerpts

Wednesday 22nd October 2025 Commons Chamber

[Jack Rankin (Windsor) (Con)]

5. What his policy is on holding a referendum on Scottish independence.

[Brendan O’Hara (Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber) (SNP)]

11. What his policy is on the holding of a referendum on Scottish independence.

[The Secretary of State for Scotland (Mr Douglas Alexander)]

I was elected on a very clear manifesto, which made clear that this UK Labour Government do not support independence or another referendum. If, after 18 years, the SNP is not prepared to run on its record, that begs the question: what kind of record have they left, after 18 years in power? Behind the smokescreen it has tried to create by talking about independence, we know the reality: one in six of us on waiting lists, rising violence and falling standards in our schools. Frankly, Scotland deserves better.

[Mr Alexander]

As my hon. Friend the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Scotland made clear, we have committed £5.2 billion to the Scottish Government this year—the largest settlement in the 25 years of devolution. There is a very basic question that we Scots are asking: “Where’s the money gone, John?” The reality is that our services are getting worse, not better, and we see industrial-level waste from the SNP. That is why it is time for a new direction.

[Brendan O’Hara]

I, too, welcome the Secretary of State to his place, although it seems that his appointment has not been universally welcomed. Indeed, I hear that the Daily Record, having asked his Labour colleagues for their opinion, feared an asterisk shortage. One particularly caustic comrade said:

“If I had a pound for everyone who liked Douglas, I would have 50p.”

But rest assured, Mr Speaker, his appointment was welcomed with open arms on the SNP Benches, and I have to admit to having a grudging admiration for him as someone who cares not about the opinion of other people. But with Labour tanking in the polls, and independence the majority view in—

[Mr Speaker]

Order. Mr O’Hara, this is meant to be a question, not a statement.