Terrorist Attack in Paris

Lord West of Spithead Excerpts

Wednesday 14th January 2015 Lords Chamber

[Lord Bates]

The noble Baroness, who of course has immense experience in this area, will recall that the Home Secretary said that,

“every day that passes without the proposals in the draft Communications Data Bill, the capabilities of the people who keep us safe diminish; and as those capabilities diminish, more people find themselves in danger and—yes—crimes will go unpunished and innocent lives will be put at risk”.

That is a very sober message for all Members of this House to reflect upon.

[Lord West of Spithead (Lab)]

My Lords, just for complete clarity on the government position, will the Minister agree that the Snowden revelations have made us all much less safe and have enabled terrorists now to use methods of communication that we cannot penetrate, and that there will therefore be deaths as a result of what he has done?

[Lord Bates]

That is absolutely right. I also pay tribute to the interventions and remarks that the noble Lord made last night on people trying to present the communications data Bill as some kind of snoopers’ charter. That is absolutely ridiculous and offensive to people who are trying to do a serious job of trying to keep us safe in this country. They deserve our support and do not deserve to be trivialised in that way.