(5 days, 8 hours ago)
Lords Chamber
Lord Jamieson (Con)
My Lords, I congratulate all those who have made their maiden speeches today and I look forward to the maiden speech of the noble Baroness, Lady Kitching of Penistone, who is a fellow councillor.
If we are to have growth, we need to build more homes and the infrastructure that this country needs, yet the OBR reduced its forecast for housebuilding by 190,000. This Government are on track to deliver fewer than the 1 million homes delivered by the previous Conservative Government, and the latest growth statistics show that private housebuilding is down by 4.7%. It is not only an economic failure but a moral failure. There is a housing crisis in England. Our new Prime Minister has said he wants to end rough sleeping, yet 136,000 households are living in temporary accommodation, including 177,000 children, which is up 5% a year.
The OBR report identifies that the cumulative impact of regulatory and fiscal changes outside the planning system have increased the cost, complexity and timescales associated with residential development. With mortgage rates up, housebuilding is simply unviable at a price that people can afford to pay in many parts of the country, which is why we have seen a decline from 182,000 new homes in England in 2022 to 125,000 last year. In London, it is particularly bad, with planning applications down 96% in the last 10 years, and only 754 homes applying for planning permission in the last two months.
The recent report from the CPS estimates that 57% of the cost of building a two-bedroom apartment in Camden is derived from government and mayoral levies and regulations; that is £442,000 out of £775,000. That is a huge burden, which is ultimately paid for by buyers. While it is better outside of London, with fewer mayoral impositions, it is still £224,000 out of £535,000, to given an example from Chelmsford.
London has affordable housing, stamp duty, CIL, corporation tax, developer tax, mayoral CIL, the building safety levy, Section 106, landfill tax, dual aspect, second staircase, the future homes standard, balconies, carbon offset and planning, and that is before we consider environmental costs, nutrient neutrality, biodiversity net gains, the jobs tax and so on. Does the mayor really need to mandate balconies and dual aspects? Surely a buyer can see these for himself or herself, and make their own decision on whether they represent good value.
The private rental market is also suffering. The OBR notes that the increase in property income tax rates and previous measures collectively risk leading to a steady rise in rents. Then there is the impact of the Renters’ Rights Act. Rightmove recently reported a 9% drop in homes available to rent in London, compared with a 6% increase in demand. Despite the much-vaunted affordable homes programme, which the Minister again highlighted, we are also seeing a decline in the building of affordable homes. As we raised during the passage of the Social Housing Bill, curtailing right to buy will see thousands fewer council homes built as there are no proceeds to reinvest.
With the Government’s housing policy failing, what action will they take to get building in our cities and address the huge government and mayoral-imposed costs? How many new social homes will be completed and occupied in this Parliament as a result of the £40 billion social housing programme? What will the Government do to encourage and stimulate the private rental market so that those who wish to rent have the availability that they need? This is a sorry tale. It needs to see confusing and inconsistent regulation and levies reduced, while safety standards are maintained, and it needs simpler taxes. There is a solution, as proposed by my honourable friend in the other place: a £50,000 reduction in the burden of regulation, combined with a single infrastructure levy.
(1 year, 9 months ago)
Grand Committee
Lord Jamieson (Con)
My Lords, I also support my noble friend Lord Fuller’s amendment. Local government finance is in a parlous state, with more than 70% of funding used for adult and children’s social care, which, due to demographic pressures, is growing substantially above GDP and inflation. In some places, this is exacerbated by housing costs due to the housing shortages across the country.
The latest local government finance settlement has not helped, as the additional government funding is the worst I can recall, after taking account of national insurance, since I became chair of the Local Government Association in 2019. I agree with my noble friends’ comments on this. Yet the financial pressures on local government continue, forcing many councils to put up council tax by the maximum of 5% and, in several cases, to seek additional rises above that. National insurance rises pose a particular burden on local councils. The LGA, as mentioned by my noble friend Lord Fuller, estimates that the cost is around £1.7 billion, of which around £1.2 billion is indirect. The Government have committed to fund the direct costs of the national insurance rise but, as my noble friend Lord Fuller mentioned, that does not even cover the full direct costs.
I emphasise that figure of £1.2 billion. There has been some commentary that it needs to be absorbed by suppliers. Frankly, that is not realistic. For instance, in one of the biggest areas—social care staff and care workers—you have agencies that just are not capable of absorbing that level of cost. They will have two options: get a price rise from the council, or stand away from their contracts. We councils cannot afford that so we will inevitably be forced to pay the extra amounts of money.
For example, in Central Bedfordshire Council—where I am a councillor and therefore declare an interest—the shortfall is around £2 million for the direct costs after the financial settlement. I talked to the finance director yesterday and he estimated indirect costs of around £10 million. To put that in context, that is more than a 5% council tax rise will generate. So, even after such a rise, we will not cover the national insurance rise.
That will inevitably mean that we will have to look at cuts to our essential services, the majority of which are statutory—the classic potholes, parks, libraries, et cetera. They are all up for grabs, so to speak. That is just not fair on our residents, who are paying additional council tax and seeing cuts to their services. I support the amendment, so that the impact of the national insurance rise can be truly worked out on a council basis and then properly funded.
My Lords, I realise that I am very much in danger of becoming repetitive, but this is the last grouping that we will deal with today. If I may, I always feel like cheering on the noble Lord, Lord Porter, every time I hear him speak, which may put him in jeopardy, but it is probably reflected by voices across the Committee.
The issues being raised are crucial. I will not repeat the discussion that we had last Monday and Wednesday, which covered this same area in great detail. However, the amendments put forward then, which would basically exclude adult and child social care, housing associations, charities and others from the changes in the employers’ NICs threshold, would answer very many of the problems that local authorities are going to face. While I understand that this amendment seeks an impact assessment, we go for exclusion of these various necessary services and on that, once again, we stand our ground.
I thought that there might be some mention of town and parish councils in this group, which will get no protection at all from the increases in employers’ national insurance that they will face. We put forward an amendment last week that would exclude them from this. Once again, I ask that town and parish councils not be overlooked in the process of understanding that the public sector will be protected. With the changes that the Government are mooting in going to strategic authorities, town and parish councils will be the only real local government layer left, quite frankly, where somebody within a community knows that community, speaks to the people in it and acts on their behalf. Because they are funded purely through tax rather than through some government grant, the Government have not given them the off-set for the additional costs that they will have to carry. They amount to so little—£10 million a year. The Government would not even notice it. Without that, because they have no other sources of income, they will absolutely be required to increase their taxes by between 1.5% and 3.5%.
These councils should not be overlooked. They might be very small, but they are vital. For many people in this era, they are the connection to politics in a world where there is so much cynicism over politics and people do not feel the reality of it any more. I hope very much that the Conservatives, having made such strong statements on the effect of all these changes, will consider coming into the Lobbies with us on Report.