Debates between Lord Horam and Lord German during the 2019-2024 Parliament

Mon 12th Feb 2024
Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill
Lords Chamber

Committee stage & Committee stage: Minutes of Proceedings & Committee stage: Minutes of Proceedings part one

Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill

Debate between Lord Horam and Lord German
Lord German Portrait Lord German (LD)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I draw attention to my interests, in that I am supported by the Refugee, Asylum and Migration Policy Project. We have strayed very widely across the whole of Clause 1 in this debate. Of course, what we are here to do is to discuss the specific amendments before us. However, I start with the assertion that this Parliament finds Rwanda safe. I looked up in the Companion to see what the role is of resolutions of this House, and it is the resolution of this House that is the determination of this House—and the determination of this House at the moment is that Rwanda is not safe. That is the view on which the Government are trying to make us change our minds, so we need to bear that in mind first of all.

The second, broader point that has been drawn out, largely by the noble Lord, Lord Horam, was the issue of offshoring versus offloading. We had that debate at Second Reading, and I think what the noble Lord, Lord Horam, was talking about was offshoring, when you make the determination about whether people are right to come here, and then they come here. But this is not offshoring; this is offloading, whereby the Government hand over the responsibility to another country to be able to accept them, there is no way back, and it is a permanent situation.

Lord Horam Portrait Lord Horam (Con)
- Hansard - -

I think the noble Lord means “outsourcing”, and it is precisely what the Australians do.

Lord German Portrait Lord German (LD)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

Indeed: what the Australians did was to check whether people were ready to come to Australia.

Lord Horam Portrait Lord Horam (Con)
- Hansard - -

They handed that responsibility over to the Government of Nauru and the Solomon Islands.

Lord German Portrait Lord German (LD)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

No, they did not. I am sorry, but the facts are otherwise. The essential point is that they were doing this work—whatever the noble Lord thinks the situation was, it is not what I think, but we can check the facts—in order that people could be admitted to Australia. That was the point; they were doing it somewhere else in order that they could come to Australia.