Local Government Finance Bill

Debate between Earl Attlee and Lord Smith of Leigh

Monday 16th July 2012 Grand Committee

[Lord Smith of Leigh]

My Lords, I have received an e-mail that tells me that a factory employing 100 people on my patch is going to be closed, so that will give me more problems with the council tax benefit. Local authorities have got into trouble over reductions in expenditure in local authorities through legal challenges. Usually, consultations have not taken account of the equal rights of all groups of people, and that is really important. We need to make sure that we do not fall into this trap and create a minefield. Could the Minister give us a timescale for when the department intends to produce the default scheme? I think that might be helpful.

[Earl Attlee]

We have published the default scheme now.

Local Government Finance Bill

Debate between Earl Attlee and Lord Smith of Leigh

Tuesday 10th July 2012 Grand Committee

[Earl Attlee]

My Lords, I will cover that in my concluding remarks. The noble Baroness, Lady Hollis, suggested that schemes would be determined on the basis of councillors’ prejudices. I refute this, as does my noble friend Lord Shipley. Schemes will have to be constructed by the council, not on the basis of individual councillors’ prejudices. They will not be in a position to take decisions on individuals but will agree to the best system after considering any changes they think they need to make to the current scheme—or they can use the default scheme which, as noble Lords know, is more or less the current scheme.

The noble Lord, Lord Smith of Leigh, made an interesting observation. He said that he supported the localisation of council tax benefits, but not this scheme. If that is so, what scheme would the noble Lord support?

[Lord Smith of Leigh]

One that is fully funded, so we do not have to make local authority cuts.

[Earl Attlee]

My Lords, we would all love to have a fully funded council tax benefit scheme.