All 2 Debates between Baroness Hyde of Bemerton and Lord Kamall

Thu 12th Nov 2026
Wed 11th Nov 2026
Health Bill
Lords Chamber

Committee stage: Part 2

Health: HIV

Debate between Baroness Hyde of Bemerton and Lord Kamall
Thursday 12th November 2026

(4 days, 9 hours ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Baroness Hyde of Bemerton Portrait Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

I do not want to pre-empt the outcome of an ongoing pilot but, as set out in the HIV action plan, the Government are serious about achieving all of UNAIDS’ previous aims of 95-95-95 and UNAIDS’ 2030 plan. This means that we will pull every lever, including that which the noble Lord mentioned, if the evidence suggests that it is how we can finally eliminate HIV and AIDS from the UK.

Lord Kamall Portrait Lord Kamall (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I too pay tribute to both the noble Lord, Lord Cashman, and my noble friend Lord Black for their persistence on this issue—for making sure that it does not go away and that we continue the conversation. We also welcome the Government’s commitment to the 2030 target, originally set in 2019 by our Conservative Government but also by other Governments around the world, which shows that it is not really a political issue at all; it goes across the whole spectrum. Can the Minister tell the House what interim annual milestones have been set between now and 2030 towards meeting that 2030 target?

Baroness Hyde of Bemerton Portrait Baroness Hyde of Bemerton (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

As I am sure the noble Lord is aware, we have provisional figures for 2025 that we expect to be confirmed by the end of this year, probably within the next month. Each year, we will be looking and monitoring, making sure that we track progress, because we cannot expect just to rock up in 2030 with all our work done.

Health Bill

Debate between Baroness Hyde of Bemerton and Lord Kamall
Lord Kamall Portrait Lord Kamall (Con)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, I am grateful to all noble Lords who spoke to their amendments in this group. I will mainly touch on three points. First, on vaccines, I remember that, when I was the Minister who had to answer questions on vaccines during Covid, we were trying to work out how to tackle so-called vaccine hesitancy. One of the things we thought we had cracked was that we worked with local communities and faith organisations, which are trusted far more than whichever Minister happens to be on TV or even the Chief Medical Officer, even though he was a very trusted person. The interesting thing was that we tried to work with local communities, but we found that some churches were saying, “Don’t take the vaccine”. That was a challenge we faced. We thought we had cracked it by working with local organisations.

We have to be careful about distinguishing between misinformation and disinformation. They often have the same outcome. Misinformation, though, is quite often unintentionally spread, whereas disinformation is deliberately spread. We have to be aware of that.

Secondly on vaccines, there was a denial that anyone could come to harm from taking the vaccine, but any pill or therapeutic has risks. I remember when I went to take my first mRNA vaccine. I sat down with the nurses in my local surgery and asked, “How risky do you think this is?” They said, “Don’t worry, it’s safer than the pill”. That is not particularly reassuring for the women out there but, statistically, they were absolutely right. If you tell people that, for example, one in 10,000 might get heart inflammation or whatever then that will scare an awful lot of people but you are actually being honest about the statistics and the risk. There is a real challenge in being completely honest about the risks and the numbers, because everyone will think they might be that one in 10,000 so they will not take it. I really have not worked out how to crack that.

We then seemed to pretend that no one was harmed by the vaccine. It is true that, statistically, very few people—a very small percentage—were harmed or killed by the vaccine, but that gave rise to conspiracy theories about hiding the fact that people could be harmed by the vaccine. In reality, all medicines have a very small risk factor. It is about how we tackle that, because if we are too open about it then people will think they are the one in a million or the one in 10,000. That is a real challenge we all face.

The second thing I want to talk about is public health. Last year, I taught an MBA module on health policy. As part of that, I spoke to a lot of public health academics. One of the things I was astounded to hear from them was that they think that an awful lot of top-down public health does not necessarily work. We spoke about the example of sugar taxes. We feel good about them because there is less sugar in our drinks but, quite often, if people are not actually helped to change their behaviour then all they end up doing is spending more on their fizzy drinks, or they swap from the branded fizzy drinks to Asda or another supermarket’s own brand. We might feel good about it, but we have not actually changed their behaviour.

Far more effective is working with local community organisations. I have often mentioned one that I am very aware of, BRITE Box, which produces 38 meals a year for families. It gives them the ingredients, and it has tested the instructions and the menus. It has done a lot of academic research and found that what is very attractive to children and families are pictures with three or four bullet points. What quite often happens is that these families learn to eat and cook healthier meals together, which they love doing, and now that they have the 38 recipes, they carry on using them. As part of that, they learn to budget as well. That is something that top-down public health cannot do.

Our challenge is how to encourage more of these local community organisations, which understand the people whose behaviour needs to change to eat healthily on more of a budget, rather than always thinking that we should have a tax on something and that will change behaviour. Quite often, all it does is lead to people paying more for unhealthy food, rather than actually changing their behaviour.

I try to be consensual at times—maybe it is my 14 years in the European Parliament—but, for my third point, I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle: we are not paying enough attention to AMR. Let us be honest about this. I remember that in the first Session after the General Election, when we swapped sides and Benches, I was asked to speak for the Opposition on a Question on AMR. The Minister at the time, the noble Lord, Lord Collins, said quite clearly that the Government were going to take a cross-governmental approach to tackling AMR, but we do not seem to have made any progress. I wonder whether the Minister has more information than I have to say what the Government are actually doing on AMR, particularly on a cross-government approach but also on international co-ordination.

All the amendments in this group raise important points. I look forward to the Minister’s response.

Baroness Hyde of Bemerton Portrait Baroness in Waiting/Government Whip (Baroness Hyde of Bemerton) (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I am grateful to noble Lords who have tabled amendments in this group and want to take the opportunity to thank all the directors of public health across the country who are doing excellent work, close to the ground, day in and day out, as mentioned by some noble Lords. I also add my thanks to the noble Baroness, Lady Cass, for sharing her personal experiences on disinformation and misinformation. It is much appreciated.

I turn to Amendment 224 tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Walmsley—with thanks to her colleagues for speaking to it—and to Amendment 267 tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett. We agree that improving health and reducing inequalities requires actions beyond the NHS, across housing, education, employment and environment. Indeed, this was raised in an earlier group, where we discussed the fact that good health cannot be the sole preserve of DHSC. Ministers and officials already work across government to ensure that health evidence informs decisions. That includes some things mentioned by the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, including action on poor-quality housing through the fuel poverty strategy, the decent homes standard and Awaab’s law, on work and health through the Keep Britain Working review—as alluded to in our first group of amendments today—and on air pollution through the environmental improvement plan. On Amendments 267 and 224, we are not persuaded that prescribing internal government structures or introducing a broad duty on Ministers in primary legislation is necessary. The Secretary of State already has a statutory duty concerning public health protection and powers to improve the health of people in England. Ministers also routinely consider the health implications of their decisions and work collectively in the public interest. Furthermore, through the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act, we have introduced a duty for combined authorities, combined county authorities and mayors to have regard to the need to improve health and reduce health inequalities in the exercise of their functions. This duty complements that pre-existing local authority health improvement duty and role.

On the topic of public health, the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, raised a specific question about the small print in the impact assessment. As a statutory arm’s-length body, NHS England’s powers and duties are necessarily set out in statute, and it has a different legal role and responsibilities from the Secretary of State and the Department of Health and Social Care. While it was appropriate for NHS England to be bound by a duty to seek advice to ensure that it effectively discharged its functions, it is not necessary to bind the Secretary of State in that way. However, I can assure the House that the Secretary of State will continue to seek advice as appropriate.

The noble Baroness, Lady Walmsley, tabled Amendments 231 and 223. Although she is not in her place, I want to thank her for her work as chair of this House’s Childhood Vaccinations Committee. As other noble Lords have mentioned, inaccurate information can undermine confidence, but uptake also depends on access, deprivation and awareness. National communication, support for front-line professionals and monitoring of emerging narratives already address misinformation alongside these wider barriers. A statutory strategy focused solely on disinformation risks duplicating activity and reducing flexibility. The Government are acting to improve uptake more broadly, including by making it easier for families to get vaccinated, giving families more information about vaccination, investing in new digital services for vaccination and organising the NHS to promote improvements in uptake. To give an example, we have reformed incentives for general practice to incentivise improved uptake in areas with low uptake, rather than rewarding only those with high uptake. That can then support best practice among general practice and address the inequities in uptake.

On Amendment 223, UKHSA and NHS England already publish extensive, timely data on routine, seasonal and targeted immunisation programmes. Requiring consistent measures in primary legislation could impose artificial standardisation where programmes are not comparable. Instead, our priorities are to improve existing reporting and act on the evidence. This Government take seriously the fact that misinformation and disinformation does and can undermine confidence, but it is one factor among several. We would also include in that the role of social media, which the noble Baroness, Lady Pidgeon, mentioned. That is why we are working across a number of measures, around marketing campaigns, supporting health professionals to have those conversations with people who are vaccine-hesitant, as well as monitoring and responding to emerging narratives and trying to debunk, by “prebunking”, if I may, that kind of misinformation and disinformation.

I turn to Amendment 274 on antimicrobial resistance from the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett. As she said, this is being addressed through the United Kingdom’s 2024 to 2029 AMR national action plan. A stand-alone review of annual AMR-related deaths could duplicate the work already under way in that plan. UKHSA undertakes continuing surveillance and is developing a mortality metric to improve our understanding across different infections and settings. I hope that noble Lords will agree that continuing surveillance, modelling and reporting will provide more durable insight than a one-off statutory review.