Question to the Department of Health and Social Care:

To ask His Majesty's Government, following the Supreme Court's judgment regarding the Cheshire West framework (UKSC/2025/0042), what steps they are taking to ensure that individuals who are reclassified as out-of-scope for Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards continue to have their individual care plans independently scrutinised, specifically regarding the ongoing, proportionate use of restrictive practices.

The Government remains firmly committed to safeguarding and protecting the rights of people lacking capacity. The deprivation of liberty safeguards (DoLS) are only one of several protections in place, and there are a range of other safeguards which are available to individuals who are not subject to DoLS. These include the Mental Capacity Act 2005 provisions, local authority safeguarding duties through the Care Act 2014, oversight by the Care Quality Commission, and common law duties of care. Through these, individuals not subject to DoLS, who are receiving care and support, would be able to access independent advocacy as well as independent scrutiny of their care, including consideration of whether there is proportionate use of restrictive practice where appropriate.

The Department published an update on the GOV.UK website on 15 June in response to the judgement, in an online-only format. The update includes initial steers on what the judgment means, including for valid consent, for practitioners and all those involved in supporting individuals where there is a deprivation of liberty. We are working with a range of stakeholder partners and charities to develop follow-up guidance as quickly as possible.