Autumn Budget 2026

Viscount Stansgate Excerpts
Thursday 12th November 2026

(5 days, 2 hours ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Viscount Stansgate Portrait Viscount Stansgate (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I welcome the Budget. One of the advantages, if I can put it that way, of being so far down the list in today’s debate is that I can say with certainty that I have been able to listen to all the excellent maiden speeches. None of the maiden speakers are in their places at the moment, but I congratulate them all. They will enrich the House in the years to come, and I am sure they all feel much better for having made their speeches.

In the short time available, I want to concentrate on a single question: will this Budget succeed in helping science and technology businesses scale up in the UK? Why is that important? It is because it goes to the very heart of how we can get growth in the UK economy. As the House knows, we have many interesting committees, they produce many interesting reports, and we have many interesting debates. Top of the list of reports that have not yet been debated by this House is the report of the Science and Technology Committee from an entire year ago on the question of scaling up businesses. We entitled it Bleeding to Death because we wanted to make an impact and to make it hard-hitting.

One of the specific examples in our minds as we considered our report was the case of a quantum start-up—I do not know whether anyone remembers the name, Oxford Ionics—that was eventually bought out by an American company for £1 billion because it could not find the scale-up capital necessary to grow in Britain. We cannot allow this type of case to go on, time and again. We have to find better ways to allow businesses to grow and scale up in the UK, ending the endless talk about the valley of death, with which this House has been familiar all too often over the decades.

Today’s debate gives me an opportunity to make the case for the views of the committee, given that there were lots of positive messages about innovation in the Budget speech. I may as well say right at the beginning that I was encouraged to learn that an additional £20 billion is being allocated to the National Wealth Fund and the British Business Bank. My noble friend Lord Eatwell touched on this. However, I am discouraged to learn that it may take several years before this injection becomes a reality.

In addition, I am hoping that the Mansion House Accord will succeed in unlocking around £25 billion of additional investment into UK private markets. I believe I am right that about £2 trillion-worth of assets are managed by UK workplace pensions. Whereas 30 or more years ago pension funds invested 50% or more in UK equities, this figure has slumped to about 2%.

The challenge we face is to accelerate the deployment of capital into innovative S&T, scaling up businesses and supporting the UK’s scale-up ecosystem. On a smaller scale—I know the Minister mentioned it in his opening speech—I hope the planned pilot of a young entrepreneurs’ allowance proceeds as soon as possible.

In our Select Committee inquiry, we had occasion to discuss whether we need what you might call a concierge service that would enable and guide scale-up businesses through the different stages, from start-up to scale-up and beyond. Is this, in effect, the idea behind Scale UK, as mentioned in the Budget Red Book? If so, when will the Scale UK-Connect regional pilot programme, designed to help 200 high-growth firms, begin?

About a month ago, the Prime Minister made a speech at the Innovation Nation Summit in Manchester—where else?—in which he spoke of a

“globally significant cluster in every region”

of the UK. He sees devolution at the heart of a renewed growth strategy. For this to happen we need to nurture the creative sector, the advanced manufacturing sector, fintech, photonics, clean energy, space, automotive engineering, quantum, cyber, compound semiconductors and AI. AI has, after all, established itself as a foundational technology, and the UK’s presidency of the G20 and the G7 gives us a chance to advance the AI for Good agenda.

Can my noble friend confirm that the UK will press for a global code of standards and guardrails to safeguard the global economy and guard against the much-discussed risks of AI, the sheer scale of which we are only beginning to understand? When it comes to international co-operation, a collaboration that is absolutely vital to R&D, what will this mean for future relations with the EU? These questions may go beyond my noble friend’s brief at the Treasury, but they are vital to our future.

I want to briefly highlight one other point about the reallocation of capital budgets across departments, designed in part to pave the way for the defence investment plan. I ask the Minister, as does the Campaign for Science and Engineering, whether there is a risk that R&D budgets might end up being disproportionately targeted. Can the Minister give any reassurance on this point?

I commend the Government for their commitment to ensure that the immigration system supports a dynamic labour market and innovative firms, and, to that end, want to deliver the most pro-business migration system in Europe for high-skilled workers. I put it to the Minister that, when our visa policy is considered, I hope the Home Office will enable this to happen rather than hinder it. I hope that there will be joined-up government, because the visa system was described to us on the Select Committee as “insane”; we took the view that it was an act of national self-harm. I very much hope that the Minister can give us some reassurance that this will be a feature of the years ahead, in support of growth.

Baroness Altmann Portrait Baroness Altmann (Non-Afl)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I will not speak, if that helps.

Viscount Stansgate Portrait The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Viscount Stansgate) (Lab)
- Hansard - -

Allow me to offer my help to the Committee. As I understand it, it is possible for this Sitting to continue until 8 pm.

--- Later in debate ---
Clause 3 agreed.
Viscount Stansgate Portrait The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Viscount Stansgate) (Lab)
- Hansard - -

I thank members of the Committee for the expeditious way they have dealt with this Bill in one sitting. I also extend our thanks to our colleagues from Hansard, who have been able to stay until we concluded. The Committee’s proceedings on the Bill have been completed.

Bill reported without amendment.

Autumn Budget 2025

Viscount Stansgate Excerpts
Thursday 4th December 2025

(11 months, 1 week ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Viscount Stansgate Portrait Viscount Stansgate (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, but I will not be discussing power stations in Essex.

On Budget day, at 2.44 pm and six seconds—I know because I double-checked—the Chancellor spoke the following words:

“Our job is to make Britain the best place in the world to start up, to scale up and to stay”.—[Official Report, Commons, 26/11/25; col. 386.]


That was key message in the Budget and there was action to demonstrate the intent. The £38.6 billion that the Government have announced for UK research and innovation projects over the next four years will be crucial to the achievement of the primary objective of growth. The House should also note that the Budget gives solid backing to British-based AI in four new AI growth zones spread out within the UK—the north-east, Oxfordshire, and north and south Wales. There is also £500 million for a sovereign AI fund to back promising British businesses.

This is all very welcome, but more must be done. We need a step change in the way we fund the growth of science and technology businesses, to ensure that they scale up and stay in the UK. I am advancing today the argument put by your Lordships’ Committee on Science and Technology, chaired by my friend, the noble Lord, Lord Mair, and of which I am a member, in its report last month, Bleeding to Death: the Science and Technology Growth Emergency. This is at heart an economic report, which is why it is so relevant to today’s debate. The argument can be very simply put: this country is brilliant at research and good at start-ups but is failing at scale-ups. As a result, we are losing potentially world-class science and technology businesses, often to the USA.

As a matter of fact, a good example took place while we were conducting our inquiry. In a deal formally completed in September, Oxford Ionics, a quantum tech company based in Oxford, was bought for $1 billion by an American company. Some of the research will continue to go into the UK but the benefits and the finance will go to the USA. If we do not find a way to succeed in scaling up science and technology businesses in the UK so that the benefits and the success are felt here, we will miss out on some of the best prospects for future growth in our economy.

The Select Committee made a number of recommendations. I cannot go through them all, but I will mention a couple. First, it called for leadership at the top, from the Prime Minister and the Chancellor and across government. In our view, we need to exert this through a new national council for science, technology and growth. We have a National Security Council; now we need a growth council. It should include Ministers from all the relevant departments: DSIT, DBT, the Home Office, the MoD, the Department of Health and Social Care, DESNZ, the DWP and the Department for Education, and especially, of course, the Minister of State for Science, together with key public investment bodies and scientific advisers.

Secondly, we need to do more to encourage institutional investors. There has been a shocking decline in the proportion of domestic pension fund investments in UK equities. We need the Mansion House reforms to succeed. If countries such as Canada can amalgamate their pension fund to invest in UK science and technology, so should we.

Thirdly, we need more co-ordination among the public investment bodies that play such a key part in the growth of science and technology companies: Innovate UK, the British Business Bank and the National Wealth Fund. There is a case for amalgamating them, and there is certainly a case for what might be called a concierge service, which guides start-ups through the business of trying to get the additional money needed to scale up.

Fourthly, we must start to exploit the power of public procurement, because it can unlock the growth of innovative science and technology companies. My time is fast running out, but I will say that we should move from grants to contracts because they better enable businesses to grow. We should also have mandatory government targets to invest in UK-based SMEs.

My time is up, so I can only repeat that we need to take this question much more seriously. In the long run, success in this area will be more lasting and important than any of the transient budgetary headlines of the last week.

OBR Forecasts

Viscount Stansgate Excerpts
Monday 1st December 2025

(11 months, 2 weeks ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

The Chancellor was not going to set out the entire Budget in advance. She set out the Budget on Budget Day. As I have said before, what she did before the Budget and at the time of the Budget were entirely consistent. She set out her priorities and then delivered on them. She said that if the productivity review were to lead to a downgrade in productivity, it would mean lower tax receipts, and it did. The Chancellor said that she intended to build more headroom, and she did. She said in the summer that policy choices would need to be paid for, and she paid for them. The Chancellor was also clear that challenging decisions would need to be taken on tax, and she took several challenging decisions on tax, including freezing thresholds for a further three years.

Viscount Stansgate Portrait Viscount Stansgate (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I am grateful to my noble friend for coming to the House and repeating this Statement, which is in two parts. On the first part, some of the comments and exchanges so far have had an element of artificial outrage about them—but we can leave that to the debate on the Budget on Thursday. My question is about the second part of this Statement, which relates to the leak and the information that we have been given about how it seems to have occurred. This is not 1947—for those who understand the reference—but nevertheless it is a very serious matter indeed. If it is not too technical a question, I was wondering whether the IP address that started at 5 am to access this information 32 times has yet been identified, and whether we will be told about what happened, because that is the type of serious breach that we need to avoid in future.

Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am grateful to my noble friend, and I agree with him that this was a very serious breach of highly sensitive information—a fundamental breach of the OBR’s responsibility—and it should never have happened. On the IP address, I do not believe that it has yet been discovered, but ongoing investigations may well yield that information. My noble friend is right: we are absolutely determined to ensure that this never happens again and we have set out next steps to make sure that that is the case.

Primary Stock Exchange Listings

Viscount Stansgate Excerpts
Thursday 10th July 2025

(1 year, 4 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I cannot say what the Chancellor is going to say at her Mansion House speech now, otherwise there would not be much point in her giving her Mansion House speech then. She will publish a 10-year strategy for financial services at that point, and I am sure the noble Lord will enjoy reading it.

Viscount Stansgate Portrait Viscount Stansgate (Lab)
- Hansard - -

My Lords, reference has been made to the Science and Technology Committee of your Lordships’ House, of which I am a member. It is investigating the crucial question of how we can scale up companies in Britain. I ask my noble friend the Minister what he hopes the effect of the Mansion House accords and reforms will be on trying to, for example, get more of our pension funds in this country to invest in British-based science and technology companies, because that will be crucial for the future of growth.

Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank my noble friend for his question, and I pay tribute to his expertise in this area; I know it is something he is deeply passionate about. He speaks about the importance of scale-up in this country. For many years, we have been very good at start-up, but much less good at scale-up. That is something we are seeking to do. As I have already mentioned, the reforms and increased capital for the British Business Bank will be crucial to that. Throughout our work to develop the industrial strategies, we have seen that access to finance has been a central challenge for many companies. He talks about our pension reforms and the Mansion House compact. Those reforms aim to generate up to £50 billion of additional capital to help companies to start to scale up and for crucial funding at that stage of their life.

UK Infrastructure: 10-year Strategy

Viscount Stansgate Excerpts
Tuesday 24th June 2025

(1 year, 4 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I can definitely say yes to one of the noble Lord’s questions, which I am pleased to be able to do. He talked about making sure that this investment is not cut back according to the economic weather, as it were. I completely agree with what he said about how previous Governments did that. That is why the fiscal rules are as they are. That creates the space to ensure that capital investment can continue and is not used to patch up day-to-day spending. That is important for us to appreciate.

The noble Lord is absolutely right that there has been too little investment in transport infrastructure in the past. We have talked before in debates such as this about the importance of connectivity to economic growth and the agglomeration effects that you get from joining up cities with each other, and joining up towns to cities. This ensures that people can live close to where they want to work and can travel to work and, on the skills conversation we have just been having, gets skills into the right place. There are huge growth benefits from transport spending. Some of the money that we are putting in—£15.6 billion into the city regions, £2.3 billion for the local transport grant and £2.2 billion of funding for Transport for London—is vital to what we were just saying. On the percentage of GDP, I do not have that number to hand, but I will write to the noble Lord.

Viscount Stansgate Portrait Viscount Stansgate (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, the Government’s 10-year infrastructure strategy, and the industrial strategy published yesterday, are essential for future growth. If I had to single out one item in the 10-year strategy, it would be to develop our sovereign compute capacity for the future. I am a member of the Science and Technology Committee of your Lordships’ House, which is looking right now at the problems of scaling up science and technology companies. Can my noble friend the Minister assure the House that the National Wealth Fund will be able to provide vital early-stage development support for companies, because we want them to scale up in Britain for the benefit of Britain?

Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am grateful for what my noble friend said. I share his enthusiasm for what we are doing in the innovation landscape, such as putting a record high of £22.6 billion into R&D as part of the spending review. It is exciting that yesterday the industrial strategy talked about allocating £2 billion for AI and £2.8 billion for advanced manufacturing. This is all incredibly important.

What my noble friend said is absolutely part of what the National Wealth Fund is for. My noble friend talked about start-ups and scale-ups. The British Business Bank now has a total financial capacity of £25.6 billion, which will result in a two-thirds increase in support for innovative UK businesses compared with 2025-26, crowding in tens of billions of pounds more in private capital The National Wealth Fund will play that role, but so too will the British Business Bank. That was one of the key announcements in yesterday’s industrial strategy.

UK-US Trade and Tariffs

Viscount Stansgate Excerpts
Thursday 3rd April 2025

(1 year, 7 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Baroness Gustafsson Portrait Baroness Gustafsson (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank the noble Lord for the question. Engagement with business has to be at the forefront of this. Often, we interpret this through our own lens—our own understanding and feelings about being on the receiving end of those tariffs. But for some industries, as the noble Lord rightly points out, there could be an opportunity. It is not for us to reflect our perception of these tariffs on to an industry; it is up to us to operate within industry and hear from them about the impacts on their organisations, their employees and their future strategies.

That is exactly why today’s request for input from industry is so important. There has been an ongoing engagement with industry for weeks and months in the run-up to this. We have been talking about the implications of this for business, but it has been on a hypothetical basis. We are now turning that into a far more tactical conversation. What is the consequence of what is happening? How can we, as your government, support you to navigate through this?

Viscount Stansgate Portrait Viscount Stansgate (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I do not think that any Member in this Chamber envies the position of the British Prime Minister at such a time, with our relationship with the United States coming under such sudden strain on so many fronts in so short a time, whether diplomatically, militarily or indeed now economically. I think yesterday will be long remembered, sadly, as a day that might prove extremely damaging for world trade. I hope that my noble friend the Minister will agree, however difficult it is, that the sheer uncertainty of all this could in itself have an adverse impact on businesses in this country. But, in the face of all this, I support the Government’s measured approach. If I may use the words of the noble Lord speaking from the Opposition Front Bench, we must keep a cool head.

I understand that my noble friend’s colleague, the Secretary of State for Business and Trade in another place, has asked businesses for further information. I take it—perhaps the Minister could confirm—that this will need to be done quite quickly. As I understand it, although there may be no firm date, 1 May is sometimes referred to as a day by which it might be possible for the United States and the UK to reach an agreement. It will be difficult, and I hope very much that we will remember the principle that Parliament and the Government decide what tax is levied on whom and for what.

Finally, I hope my noble friend will use her good offices with the Government to enable this House to have a debate on these matters before things reach a critical juncture. If it ever came to the point where the United Kingdom decided to take firm action, it would be much better for the Government to know that they have the support of the House.

Baroness Gustafsson Portrait Baroness Gustafsson (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I thank my noble friend for that comment, and I agree that the best decisions are often made with cool heads. Sometimes it can be challenging to maintain that cool head, but I think that as a Government we have done well to make sure we navigate that on a calm and pragmatic basis. There is so much uncertainty, and I can feel the desire for clarity in this uncertain world. I feel that the request for input from business is a good way of crystallising some of that clarity, as we understand the impact and possible opportunities for next steps.

But have no fear: although the deadline for that conversation or dialogue is 1 May regarding the request for input, there is continuous and ongoing engagement with our US counterparts about how we draw together an agreement. If such an agreement were to come into place, we have not put any artificial deadline on when that should or should not happen—and nor should we, because it would put the negotiations under undue strain. I am pleased and encouraged that the conversation and dialogue are happening regularly, that they are well received on both sides and that access is able to happen.

So I agree—I hear the need for an informed decision about such responses. A debate on any response, as and when that comes to a position where it is more formed, is absolutely where we can provide some real value, and that would be a worthy place.

Spring Statement

Viscount Stansgate Excerpts
Thursday 27th March 2025

(1 year, 7 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am grateful to the noble Viscount; he has far greater expertise in these matters than I do. The Secretary of State, when she presented the package of reforms to Parliament, said that the costings that she was setting out were subject to final costings by the OBR. The OBR has now set out its final assessment of costings and confirmed that this welfare package will reduce welfare spending by £4.8 billion in 2029-30. Following the OBR’s final assessment of the welfare savings from the package, taking account of the £1.4 billion of investment the Government are putting towards the reforms, including the £1 billion of employment support, the net welfare savings of this investment is around £3.4 billion.

Viscount Stansgate Portrait Viscount Stansgate (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

Can my noble friend confirm that the Statement’s provision for capital spending is crucial if the UK is to sustain and safeguard its research and development budget and infrastructure, such as data centres, that will be vital for future growth? Does he agree that we will need a combination of our world-class universities, entrepreneurs, emerging AI companies and others not only to start up but to scale up businesses in this country? As your Lordships’ House’s Science and Technology Committee is now investigating, it is the scale-up that is the real challenge.

Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

My noble friend is right. The Autumn Budget increased capital investment by £100 billion over the Parliament, including investment to protect record R&D funding, which, as my noble friend said, is vital for growth. The OBR has looked at the growth impact of that investment across a decade and it has been clear that those capital investments—which, incidentally, the party opposite opposed—will lead to a significant 0.4% increase in growth over the longer term. Not cutting capital spending, which the party opposite did time and again, was one of the most significant growth measures that the Chancellor outlined in her Statement.

My noble friend also talked about start-ups and scale-ups. He knows that I agree with him 100% on that. This country is extremely good at start-up; it is much less good at scale-up. Getting the necessary capital to those scale-ups is one of the most important things that we can do.

Growing the UK Economy

Viscount Stansgate Excerpts
Monday 3rd February 2025

(1 year, 9 months ago)

Lords Chamber
Read Full debate Read Hansard Text Watch Debate Read Debate Ministerial Extracts
Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am very grateful to the noble Lord. As he stood up, I was reminded that he contacted me last week on this point and I owe him a response. I apologise to him for not having got back to him quickly enough. What he said dovetails perfectly with what the Chancellor said in her speech. Clearly, the Cambridge Growth Company has been very successful under the leadership of Peter Freeman. We have now set up a growth commission for Oxford to review the barriers to growth that are holding the city back from reaching its full potential. At the moment, that is a specific team within MHCLG, but it has the potential to grow into something similar to what is happening in Cambridge. I do not think we would see any problem in that happening and developing in that way. What the noble Lord, Lord Vallance, is doing is complementary to that in terms of joining it up.

The whole point of the growth corridor is that we do not see it as two separate cities doing their own thing but instead join them up and see the benefits. People talk about it being Europe’s equivalent of Silicon Valley. All the business reaction post the announcement has been incredibly positive in terms of what it can do and the benefits that it can achieve in attracting businesses into the area. The big problem businesses have is a lack of affordable housing and fast transport to move people about within that region. We are looking to address both of those things. I think we will be very supportive of what the noble Lord says about Oxford.

Viscount Stansgate Portrait Viscount Stansgate (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - -

My Lords, I welcome the Chancellor’s speech and the positive statement of intent that it conveys. I put it to my noble friend that one key ingredient is investment in science and technology. I draw the Minister’s attention to one example. We know that we have strengths in the life sciences. A recent report by your Lordships’ Science and Technology Committee, of which I am a member, on engineering biology, indicated an enormous new range of potential growth opportunities. When the Minister and his noble friend Lord Vallance come to consider what to do, I hope that special attention will be paid to reports of that kind, because that is the future.

Lord Livermore Portrait Lord Livermore (Lab)
- View Speech - Hansard - - - Excerpts

I 100% agree with everything that my noble friend said. Innovation is one of the seven pillars of the growth strategy. R&D and innovation are absolutely vital when it comes to growth. He will know that life sciences are one of the eight sectors we have selected as part of the industrial strategy, because of the huge competitive advantage we potentially hold in that area. I held a round table last week with representatives of the life sciences sector. They have some incredibly exciting proposals to bring forward. They will be captured when it comes to the life sciences sector plan that we will bring forward as part of the industrial strategy before the spring.

National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill

Viscount Stansgate Excerpts
Amendment 5 not moved.
Viscount Stansgate Portrait The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Viscount Stansgate) (Lab)
- Hansard - -

We now move on to the next group. I call Amendment 6 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe.

Baroness Noakes Portrait Baroness Noakes (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My Lords, before we start on that amendment, it is 7.28 pm and the Committee is due to finish at 7.45 pm. It always used to be the custom that if we would cover only a very short part of a group, we would normally draw stumps at that stage. That is the way it has always been done in the past. Obviously, we do not absolutely have to finish every group, but we do not normally start a quite significant group with a large number of amendments when there are so few minutes left, so I would like clarification on what will happen in this Committee.

Viscount Stansgate Portrait The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Viscount Stansgate) (Lab)
- Hansard - -

In answer to the noble Baroness, I am in the hands of the usual channels.

Viscount Stansgate Portrait The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Viscount Stansgate) (Lab)
- Hansard - -

They were once described as some of the most polluted waterways in Europe.

Baroness Blake of Leeds Portrait Baroness in Waiting/Government Whip (Baroness Blake of Leeds) (Lab)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I understand that we have the grace of an extra 10 minutes after 7.45 pm. My understanding was that we would like to carry on and that noble Lords would come back if we do not finish the group. However, the Minister says that he is fine to break now, so if that is the will of the Committee then I am happy to do so. We seemed to be making real progress; I apologise for breaking any convention, but I am happy to be reasonable.

--- Later in debate ---
Baroness Noakes Portrait Baroness Noakes (Con)
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am grateful to the noble Baroness for those comments. In the spirit of good will in the Committee, this would be an appropriate time for us to draw stumps.

Viscount Stansgate Portrait The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Viscount Stansgate) (Lab)
- Hansard - -

In the spirit of good will, the Committee is adjourned.

Committee adjourned at 7.30 pm.