Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill (Sixth sitting)

Sojan Joseph Excerpts

Committee stage
Thursday 30th January 2025 Public Bill Committees

[The Chair]

Order. I can only take one answer. I am sorry, Meredith, but we have not got time. It is one answer to one question.

[Sojan Joseph (Ashford) (Lab)]

Q Dr Furst, can I ask a follow-up about anorexia? I know that anorexia is not classified as a terminal illness, but long-term starvation can lead to severe physical health conditions, and patients may end up in palliative care. Do you have any experience of those cases in Australia?

Dr Furst: We have experience of those cases in palliative care, but I would still say that they are not eligible for voluntary assisted dying. None of us would feel comfortable, because the condition has to be irreversible. Capacity-wise, you would have to make sure that they had capacity, and I would question whether someone that is anorexic truly has capacity around their illness.

[Lewis Atkinson (Sunderland Central) (Lab)]

Q Mr Greenwich, we are minded that as well as passing really good legislation we want to get public confidence behind this. We have heard a level of concern from disabled people’s representative bodies about the inadvertent implications of this law for disabled people. Were those concerns shared when you took your legislation through, and how it has gone since the implementation of the legislation?

Alex Greenwich: In New South Wales, and across Australia, having a disability or complex mental health issue like anorexia does not make you eligible at all for voluntary assisted dying. The legislation we are dealing with and you are dealing with is not for people with a disability or anorexia nervosa, and not for people who feel they are a burden. It is for people with a terminal illness who may want the choice of a death that is better than what the illness would otherwise provide.

We worked closely with disability groups in New South Wales. Their main concern was that they would be treated equally in terms of access to the law if a person with a disability had a terminal illness. The key point is that this legislation is a safeguard to those concerns. To the point about people who are starving themselves, that is happening today in the UK because people do not have access to voluntary assisted dying. They are starving themselves to death rather than accessing a regulated scheme where they can discuss all their options and choices.