Debates between Simon Hoare and Kit Malthouse during the 2024 Parliament

Mon 16th Nov 2026
Mon 14th Jul 2025

Visitor Levy (England) Bill

Debate between Simon Hoare and Kit Malthouse
Simon Hoare Portrait Simon Hoare
- Hansard - -

Indeed—my right hon. Friend makes the obvious point, and I am grateful to her for doing so.

North Dorset has a lot of businesses that benefit either directly or indirectly through tourism, which are very often in sectors that are under pressure from the main purpose of their trade. I think of the pubs with rooms in my constituency: the Anvil Inn at Pimperne, the Fox Inn at Ansty, the Crown at Marnhull, the Langton Arms at Tarrant Monkton, the Talbot at Iwerne Minster, and the Swan Inn in Sturminster Newton—all businesses trying to do well and trying to keep their head above water against both myriad switches and changes in customer demand and a burdensome tax and regulatory system. Those pubs often see letting those rooms as a way of helping to break even.

I think also of the farmers in my constituency who have diversified into the tourism sector merely to try to keep their heads above water. It will not, I hope, be lost on the Minister how many of these rural campsites have the word “farm” in the title. As I say, many of these farms have diversified into summer tourism to provide vital income. According to the Tourism Alliance, the visitor economy—a cash cow the Government obviously think can be milked further—is worth £147 billion per annum in the UK, sustains 2.4 million jobs and generates £52 billion in tax revenue.

If the Government are to plough blindly on down the route of introducing this tax, there are, it seems to me, some obvious amendments that I hope my right hon. and hon. Friends will seek to push. There should be a cap on the levy enshrined in legislation, not left to the discretion of a mayor. A clearer and tighter way must surely be found to enforce ringfencing or hypothecation of the tax in order to ensure that the local tourism economy benefits from it.

There should be an exemption from VAT on the levy itself. The Government’s consultation said that there would be, but the Bill is silent, and silent is not good enough. That is particularly true given the point I made in an intervention of the differential in sales taxes between us and the countries the Government have sought to pray in aid. We have Europe’s highest rate of hospitality tax at 20%. Ireland’s is 9%. In France, Italy and Spain, it is 10%, while in Greece it is 13%. If we are going to compare fruits, let us at least compare apples with apples and oranges with oranges. UK tourism and hospitality is already fighting in a dramatically competitive international sector with one hand tied behind its back, and now the Government, through this new tax, would seek to impede their business growth still further.

There are, of course, other exemptions that I hope will be considered, such as establishments where accommodation is ancillary to the main business—I mentioned those rural pubs that have rooms—or having a set number of rooms below which an establishment is exempt from the levy. We should also exempt rooms available and provided by religious institutions providing retreat, accommodation in youth hostels and the YMCA and YWCA.

I want to mention campsites in particular. I have a number of campsites in my constituency, such as Woodfrys Farm in Melbury Abbas and Redlands Breaks in Hazelbury Bryan. We have them in Blandford; we have Home Farm Camping in Tarrant Gunville and others. All of them are trying to attract people to the area to spend their hard-earned money, not just on the campsite but elsewhere, to support the economy.

Every pound in tax that the Government take through this levy will result in either one of two things, or possibly both of them. First, it will reduce the amount of holiday time that hard-working families can actually afford to take. At a time when we are surely supposed to be encouraging family time and everything that goes with it, we should surely be trying to find ways to arrive at the complete opposite landing spot.

Secondly, even if that does not happen, the people who are visiting—people who, as the hon. Member for South Shields (Emma Lewell) said, have looked forward to their summer break and saved for it all year—will just have less to spend in museums, in cafés, in restaurants, at the slot machines, at the ice cream parlour and in the tea rooms, wherever they may happen to be. There will be a diminution in the local tourism economy month on month. For many, it is that high spot in the summer school holiday months—late July through to the end of August—that is their bread and butter and the difference between them sinking or swimming. This levy will just put a further weight on them as they try to swim through the choppy waters of doing business under this Government.

I want to reference a conversation that I had with Jeremy Cooper, who runs Inside Park near Blandford Forum, a beautiful campsite in North Dorset. Most of its business is repeat business. He told me a staggering statistic: 95% of his bookings are from people who live within a radius of just 120 miles of Blandford Forum. This is home-grown tourism—people who want to stay and spend their hard-earned money near to where they live and yet have a holiday.

Kit Malthouse Portrait Kit Malthouse
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

My hon. Friend is raising a very good point. Does he feel that, in the same way that people tried to avoid the landfill tax by fly-tipping, this tax on camping may mean that we see more fly-camping, where people camp at will in the countryside—in an uncontrolled environment without facilities and where they may leave litter or cause wildfires, and similarly damage the countryside?

Simon Hoare Portrait Simon Hoare
- Hansard - -

I agree with my right hon. Friend—perhaps “Carry On Fly-Camping” could be the next film in the series. He is right; this is going to have significantly negative knock-on effects.

These are negative effects that the Government are authoring with no particular urging from anybody outside of the Government’s mind so to do. I do not particularly want to see competition between the mayoral authority of Devon and Cornwall and the mayoral authority of Wiltshire, Somerset and Dorset, if we are to be given one, where they are trying to differentiate between the two. UK plc should be promoting itself as a tourism destination; it should not a case of, “Come to this bit of England or that bit of England because this bit charges x and this bit charges y.”

I ask the Minister to address this point specifically in summing up. Those who operate campsites or places where people can bring their own motorhome or tourer are not providers of accommodation; they are merely providing a pitch. This is a point that Mr Cooper of Inside Park raised with me.

Deprivation of Citizenship Orders (Effect during Appeal) Bill

Debate between Simon Hoare and Kit Malthouse
Kit Malthouse Portrait Kit Malthouse
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

The Minister is a fair man and a fair-minded man. He is quite right, and I am willing to countenance his appeal and give him the benefit of the doubt, and that is exactly what I am asking for the individuals subject to this legislation. He will know that we have certain inalienable constitutional rights as British citizens, which this legislation contravenes. The first is that we have a right to a fair hearing and that any action the Government take must be exercised fairly. That right has been established in the common law again and again, and most recently in 1994, in the case of ex parte Doody, when the court decided that Ministers must exercise their powers fairly.

The second inalienable right, which has been decided in the Supreme Court, is that we all have a right to access to the courts, and that cannot be unfairly restricted. As that has been decided by the Supreme Court, the Government cannot put up artificial barriers to our access, such as raising fees or making sure that we cannot physically get to the court. Indeed, as the Minister will know, I have an absolute right to defend myself in person at every stage of legal action, whether that is at first hearing or at subsequent appeal. All those powers or rights that I have as a citizen are affected by the legislation he is attempting to put through.

My amendment essentially says three things. If the Government failed to win an appeal, but wished to continue to deprive me of my citizenship pending a further appeal, they must, when seeking leave to appeal from the judge, also ask the judge for leave to continue the deprivation of citizenship. The judge basically could say no in three circumstances. First, the judge could say no if there is a real and substantial threat of serious harm to that individual if they were denied access to the United Kingdom. Some of these people will be living or operating from extremely dangerous places. If that person is likely to be killed pending further appeal on the denial of their citizenship, it would seem grossly unfair, their having already won an appeal, to deny them access to the country.

The second ground would be if their exclusion from the UK and the continuing of denial of citizenship would be deeply prejudicial to the conduct of their defence in an appeal that the Government subsequently decided to bring. In such a case, it would be impossible for me to defend myself at appeal in person, which should be my inalienable right as a British citizen. It would be impossible for me to do that remotely in some God-forsaken part of the world where I cannot Zoom in or I do not have the ability to communicate. It would be the same if I am unable to communicate with my legal team. I am sure the Minister can see that it would be unfair to interfere with someone’s ability to mount a proper defence—we should not forget that that person has already won an appeal—through the continuing denial of citizenship.

The third ground, which we covered on Second Reading, is the Government’s taking their time, achieving their objective merely by dragging their heels and playing for time, hoping that something, perhaps something untoward, will turn up. A judge should then make a judgment—the clue is in the name—on whether they are being efficient in their use of the legal system, rather than, as I am afraid happens from time to time, gaming it to their own advantage.

Simon Hoare Portrait Simon Hoare (North Dorset) (Con)
- Hansard - -

As my right hon. Friend knows, I have a huge amount of respect and affection for him, and he is right to refer to the inalienable rights that a British citizen has in terms of access to justice and so forth, but surely he must accept that individuals facing deprivation of citizenship will have crossed a threshold of behaviour, or allegiance, so alien to our traditions, so alien to all the rights and responsibilities accrued over the decades of British citizenship, that in essence, in the court of public opinion, they will put themselves way beyond the pale when it comes to those issues. It would be an extreme hypocrisy for those who most seek to undermine our way of life to demand all the rights and privileges that they have sought to undermine, and possibly destroy, through their actions or foreign allegiances.

Kit Malthouse Portrait Kit Malthouse
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I understand my hon. Friend’s point, but I would have more faith, or confidence, in his view if it applied to me as well, which it does not. What we are saying is that we can have two British citizens who commit the same heinous acts but receive two different kinds of treatment. One can have his or her citizenship removed and be expelled from the country, but another—say I were to do that—cannot. My view is that this is highly discriminatory, and tramples over some of the inalienable rights that my hon. Friend has mentioned. We currently have plenty of British citizens in high-security prisons who have committed acts as heinous as those committed by people whom we have deprived of British citizenship, but we have decided to deprive them of British citizenship purely because of their heritage and background—purely because they may be second-generation immigrants.

As I pointed out on Second Reading, this legislation applies to every single Jewish member of the United Kingdom citizenry. They all have an inalienable right to Israeli citizenship, and as a result, in my view, they all have second-class citizenship. I do not think that that is right. I do not think that it is fair. I think that it drives a wedge into our society, and sows a seed of doubt at the back of everyone’s mind.

This is the point that I was trying to make at the start. Those who perpetrate such heinous acts overseas absolutely should be punished. As my hon. Friend will know, over the past 10 years I have been at the forefront of trying to ensure that as many criminals as possible end up behind bars, whatever the criminality might be, but the fact is that there is a principle in British law—we are all supposed to be equal—and the Bill breaches that principle very significantly. Moreover, what the Government are attempting to do not only reinforces that breach, but aims to twist and skew fundamental tenets of British justice that have been our right for centuries.

Simon Hoare Portrait Simon Hoare
- Hansard - -

Surely the fact that a remedy is not available to all does not mean that it is not a remedy. If we wish to argue for the two-tier approach, we can think of instances in which mental capacity has come into play, particularly in respect of capital offences, when those existed here. In abstract theory, that was a two-tier approach to justice, determined on the grounds of mental capacity or lack thereof. Surely remedies do not have be applicable universally to be applied fairly and within the law.

Kit Malthouse Portrait Kit Malthouse
- Hansard - - - Excerpts

I am not sure that I accept the hon. Gentleman’s logic. The test of mental capacity in the judicial system applies to everyone equally. If I were being prosecuted for an offence, I would be assessed for mental capacity, just as my hon. Friend would. The court would accept that there might be mitigations for his actions, or a requirement for a different disposal if he lacks mental capacity, but that is an external influence on him. It may come about owing to mental illness or some other kind of disability—who knows?

The point is that this comes about through no reason other than birth. My citizenship, or my lack of citizenship, is conferred on me by reason of my birth—my parentage, or my heritage. I cannot do anything about it. I cannot be treated for it, as I can be for mental illness. This is purely because my parents may have come from another country, my skin may be of a different colour, or the country of the origin of my DNA may offer particular rights of citizenship. It is something arbitrary, about which I can do nothing. We might as well have a piece of legislation that says that people with red hair receive different treatment under the law, because there is nothing they can do about that.